Early Childhood Development in Tajikistan: A Rapid Review of the Regulatory Framework, Governance Environment and Current Programs 1 Table of Contents Acknowledgements ....................................................................................................................... 3 Abbreviations and Acronyms ...................................................................................................... 4 Executive Summary ...................................................................................................................... 6 1. Introduction ............................................................................................................................. 11 2. Regulatory Environment and Governance for ECD ........................................................... 19 Regulatory Framework for ECD provision............................................................................... 19 Laws and Regulations Related to Child Development ......................................................... 21 Laws and regulations related to parents’ ability to support child development ................... 24 Laws and regulations related to social protection ................................................................. 25 Governance ............................................................................................................................... 26 3. ECD Programs and Services .................................................................................................. 32 Comprehensive ECD ................................................................................................................ 32 Family Planning ........................................................................................................................ 32 Pre and Post-Natal Care and Attended Delivery....................................................................... 33 Child Growth and Developmental Monitoring ......................................................................... 33 Parenting Interventions ............................................................................................................. 34 Early Detection of Developmental Delays and Early Intervention .......................................... 35 Immunization ............................................................................................................................ 36 Nutrition Interventions .............................................................................................................. 36 Deworming ............................................................................................................................... 40 Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH) .................................................................................. 40 Social protection interventions ................................................................................................. 41 Community-based Programs ..................................................................................................... 43 Alternative Preschool Programs ............................................................................................... 43 4. Conclusion ............................................................................................................................... 45 References .................................................................................................................................... 47 2 Acknowledgements This report was prepared by Ms. Lucy Bassett (Consultant, Education), Mr. Sabir Kurbanov (Consultant, Health) and Mr. Cameron Haddad (Research Assistant) under the leadership of Ms. Saodat Bazarova (Senior Education Specialist). The team would like to thank Ms. Ayesha Y. Vawda (Lead Education Specialist) for intensive work on the report finalization and the following for their contributions and comments: Mr. Marcelo Bortman (Lead Health Specialist), Ms. Mutriba Latypova (Senior Health Specialist), Ms. Alexandria Valerio (Lead Education Specialist), Ms. Kate Mandeville (Senior Public Health Specialist), Ms. Yoshini Naomi Rupasinghe (Health Specialist) and Ms. Sanobar Khomidova (Consultant, Education). The team would like to thank Mr. Harry Anthony Patrinos (ECA Education Practice Manager), Ms. Tania Dmytraczenko (ECA Health, Nutrition and Population Practice Manager), Mr. Jan-Peter Olters (WB Country Manager for Tajikistan), and Ms. Susanna Hayrapetyan (Program Leader for Central Asia) for their guidance and support. The team also thanks Mr. Marc DeFrancis for the editing work and Ms. Parvina Mahmadziyoeva (Consultant) and Ms. Shahlo Norova (Program Assistant) for logistical support. This review could not have been possible without the support of the management and staff of the Ministry of Health and Social Protection of Population and the Ministry of Education and Science who provided valuable information and advice. The team would like to thank development partners that contributed to the report: UNICEF and Aga Khan Foundation. 3 Abbreviations and Acronyms AKF Aga Khan Foundation BBP Basic Benefits Package CIS Commonwealth of Independent States CRC The Convention on the Rights of the Child DHS Demographic and Health Survey ECA Europe and Central Asia ECD Early Childhood Development ECEC Early Childhood Education and Care eHCI Early Human Capability Index ELDS The Early Child Learning and Development Standards GAIN The Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition GAVI Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization GBAO Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Oblast GDP Gross Domestic Product GoT Government of Tajikistan GPE Global Partnership for Education IGME UN Inter-Agency Group for Child Mortality Estimation IMR Infant Mortality Rate JME Joint child malnutrition estimate based on UNICEF, WHO and WB harmonized dataset MCH Maternal and Child Health Handbook MoES Ministry of Education and Science MoHSP Ministry of Health and Social Protection NGOs Non-governmental Organizations OSI Open Society Institute PHC Primary health care PHCC Primary health care center PMPCs Psychological, Medical and Pedagogical Committees SUN Scaling Up Nutrition TJS Tajikistan Somoni (currency of the Republic of Tajikistan) TSA Targeted Social Assistance UNFPA The United Nations Fund for Population Activities 4 UNICEF United Nations Children's Fund USAID United States Agency for International Development WASH Water, Sanitation and Hygiene WB World Bank WFP World Food Programme WHO World Health Organization WRA Women of Reproductive Age 5 Executive Summary Tajikistan’s unique opportunity—investment in human capital through the development of its youngest and most numerous members of society—that could change the country’s development trajectory and help it attain social and economic well-being, has become a matter of national emergency since the onset of the COVID-19 global pandemic. The growth and development of the youngest children in a country is likely to be highly vulnerable given the onset of a global recession and the resulting financial hardships on governments and families, as well as the overload on the health system as it attempts to tackle the prevention and treatment of the virus, the closure of school systems, and the heavy reliance on social security to meet basic needs. Some estimates indicate that the global nutrition crisis following COVID-19 will be worse than the impact of the virus itself. If Tajikistan is unable to support the early childhood development (ECD) needs of its population currently, it stands to lose its greatest development opportunity. In a child’s first five years, the brain matures the fastest and is more malleable than it will ever be again. These early years are a critical period to get children the care, nutrition, health and stimulation and learning opportunities they need to succeed in school and grow up to be healthy and productive adults. Severe, lifelong impacts can result from deprivations during the early years if children do not have these critical inputs to ensure optimal child development. Therefore, it will be crucial to continue, and expand if possible, the government’s plans to provide appropriate health, stimulation, education, and nutrition to its youngest. Given the multisectoral nature of ECD services, effective ECD service delivery requires an enabling environment created by: (i) an adequate regulatory framework (laws, policies and strategic plans) to enable different actors to provide complementary services; (ii) governance arrangements that facilitate coordination within and across institutions to ensure effective service delivery; and (iii) an adequate supply of services to support the diverse needs of the sector. This paper, which was prepared prior to the global pandemic, provides insights into the governance and management of ECD in Tajikistan and provides a summary of present programs. It was requested as an input to help the Government of Tajikistan (GoT) launch large-scale investments and policy reform to support ECD. 6 Key Findings The context for improving ECD outcomes in Tajikistan is complex. Despite active measures, progress on many ECD outcomes remains limited. Preventable illnesses cause most child and maternal mortality. For example, the infant mortality rate (at 31 per 1,000 births) is among the worst among all Central Asian countries. Maternal and child anemia (over 40%) and iodine deficiency among women of reproductive age and children under 5 are prevalent (over 50 percent), and only one-third of children are exclusively breast fed until 6 months of age. The preschool enrollment rate, at 14 percent, is among the lowest in the region. Cognitive stimulation and positive parenting in the early years is limited, resulting in a negative impact on early literacy and numeracy. Food security is an ongoing challenge in Tajikistan, and one that has a significant impact on the ECD agenda. Access to safe drinking water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) services has a positive impact on children’s health and nutrition, and these facilities are incrementally being provided to people in Tajikistan. Despite recent developments in enhancing social protection and assistance, young children of the poor, and disabled children remain most at risk at attaining adequate ECD outcomes. While Tajikistan has established regulations affecting several aspects of ECD service delivery, a comprehensive regulatory framework for ECD is yet to be developed. As in other countries, the range of laws and regulations forming the ECD legal framework is wide, representing the multiplicity of services and sectors that contribute to ECD outcomes targeting different groups. Many areas of the ECD service delivery model—health, education, social protection, family welfare, nutrition—are covered through distinct laws, codes, policies, and strategies. The paper provides a snapshot of this wide web of regulations. Nevertheless, a fully developed and integrated legal framework covering all target groups and aspects of ECD holistically is not yet developed. Fragmentation in the legal framework appears to be resulting from (i) the lack of a robust collaboration and coordination mechanism for legislative development between the two core line ministries responsible for ECD outcomes, the Ministry of Education and Science (MoES) and the Ministry of Health and Social Protection (MoHSP); and (ii) limited articulation of the process of and support to implementation of key legislation, for example the inadequate treatment of breastfeeding promotion in the Health Code of 2017. 7 Important legislation remains unenforced due to either the absence of sub-laws and normative acts, and/or inadequate financing and capacity, risking service delivery to achieve ECD outcomes. For example, the 2019 law on providing the population with fortified food products remains inactive due to the absence of sub-laws, leaving a critical gap in regulations around important areas such as salt iodization. Рolitical commitment to ECD is high: the governance of ECD is challenged by absence of an overarching institutional and policy anchor. Political commitment to improve ECD outcomes is high in Tajikistan. For example, current national priorities include a dramatic reduction in stunting among children under five years of age and an increase in preschool coverage of children ages three to six. Several important regulations have been put into effect that demonstrate this commitment. However, to date there is no single overarching national policy or strategy for ECD, and therefore programs and services related to ECD lack integration and coordination. Several agencies define the ECD governance and management system. The MoHSP and the MoES play key roles in defining ECD policy and programs and in the key service delivery arrangements. Local government authorities play a key role in the financing and provision of social services. Other stakeholders involved mainly in the services provision include development partners, international and local NGOs, private donors, and community organizations. In some cases, the external support to essential ECD services exceeds by far the state contribution. Neither public- private partnerships nor the outsourcing of social services has yet been developed. Establishing an overarching coordinating body and institutional anchor for ECD has been challenging in Tajikistan. Efforts to coordinate across the various multisectoral services have been made since 2005-06 with limited results. An ECD Council was established under the Deputy Prime Minister on Social Issues, but it stopped functioning. A National Early Childhood Development Council (NECDC) is expected to be established. It will be chaired by the Deputy Prime Minister for Social Sectors, with the Minister of Finance as deputy chair, and will comprise the ministers of all concerned ministries, including MoES, MoHSP, and others (Labor, Agriculture, Water, etc.) as well as the Executive Office of the President. Once established, it is anticipated that this council will convene various ministries and agencies involved in ECD service delivery. Several programs are providing support to various elements of ECD service provision . These include support to family planning, pre- and post-natal care and attended delivery, growth and 8 development monitoring, parenting support, early detection of development delays and early intervention, immunization, nutrition interventions, interventions to improve feeding practices, micronutrient supplementation and food fortification, management of severe diarrhea, deworming, water, sanitation and hygiene, social protection and social assistance, child protection and school feeding, and alternative and community-based preschool programs. The most comprehensive among these is the recently approved Early Childhood Development for Building Tajikistan’s Human Development Project. Conclusion The country is to be commended for its decision to invest in the health, education, and development of its youngest citizens. Realizing improved ECD outcomes will require more than good will and financial investments, however. Three overarching findings should inform efforts going forward. First, achieving improved outcomes will require a robust regulatory foundation that enables the many diverse actors to work toward a common purpose. It could begin with a national policy framework for ECD. A policy framework typically includes both a policy statement and a description of institutional and administrative structures to implement the policy. The policy statement includes a vision of where the ECD is heading, a set of goals or objectives that the government would like to achieve, and strategies for achieving them. It is important for the ECD policy to be coherent with other related sectoral policies. Government responsibility for the provision or supervision of ECD services is often scattered across ministries, often according to the age of the child. An ECD policy framework can help harmonize the goals and strategies of these institutions horizontally. Good governance of ECD rests upon high-level political commitment, the involvement of stakeholders from a range of sectors – with both policy and implementation expertise – and defined roles and responsibilities, and an institutional anchor to coordinate horizontally across sectors and vertically within the government. A policy framework inter alia identifies the lead agency and the entities that will implement, manage, monitor, and evaluate ECD programs. Second, as the first and primary care givers, the role of parents and communities cannot be underestimated in achieving positive ECD outcomes. Parental education can focus on raising awareness among parents on the importance of ECD, informing them of what services are available and how to access them, setting realistic expectations for child development at different ages and 9 promoting early stimulation. Therefore, behavior change communication is a critical foundation for generating positive ECD outcomes. Third and finally, co-location of ECD services can enable positive ECD outcomes. Co-location means implementing different ECD services in an integrated way and in the same geographic areas so that children reap the greatest benefit. In Tajikistan this would mean coordinating across ministries and other actors to ensure the presence of strengthened health sector support for ECD, a more child-sensitive social assistance program, ongoing parental education, and high-quality preschool services (among other things) that are provided in the same geographic areas. 10 1. Introduction The Government of Tajikistan places a high priority on early child development (ECD) as a tool for social and economic transformation of the nation. According to analyses by the World Bank’s Human Capital Project, a child born in Tajikistan today is expected to be 53 percent as productive as he or she could be with full health and complete education.1 High rates of childhood stunting, low preschool coverage, and low learning outcomes are the major reasons for underperformance. Given the high proportion of the population that is under six years of age, Tajikistan has made it a development priority to invest in high quality ECD. Prior to launching large scale investments and embarking on policy changes, the government requested the World Bank and the Global Partnership for Education (GPE)2 to support a series of reviews that would enable a deeper understanding of the ECD sector. The first review was concluded in June 2019 and focused on a detailed analysis of the status, policies, and outcomes in early childhood education and care (World Bank, 2019a). The current note focuses on the regulatory environment for provision of ECD services, provides a summary of present programs, and makes policy recommendations for enhancing ECD outcomes in Tajikistan. It is based on a desk review of the regulatory documents, available reports, surveys and statistical information, and interviews with key counterparts and development partners. ECD Is Multisectoral ECD interventions include a set of activities to support children’s development in four domains—physical, cognitive, linguistic, and socioemotional—over the course of their early years, from conception (pregnancy) through to the first years of their primary schooling (6-8 years of age). Development across the four ECD domains is cumulative throughout early childhood, yet some interventions are particularly critical during specific periods (or windows of opportunity) and should therefore be prioritized in decisions on appropriate interventions for different ages (Naudeau et al., 2011) (Figure 1). Because of the multidimensional nature of children’s 1 The World Bank Group launched the Human Capital Project (HCP) in 2018 to accelerate more and better investments in people for greater equity and economic growth. A human capital index (HCI) score is generated for each country, indicating the level of human capital opportunity. The HCI defines full health as no stunting and 100 percent adult survival, complete education as 14 years of high-quality school by age 18. 2 Through the Education Sector Plan Development Grant (ESPDG). 11 development, improving development during early childhood additionally requires adequate and complementary legislation in multiple sectors; the main sectors in this regard are health, education, water, sanitation and hygiene (WASH), nutrition, and social protection (Figure 2). ECD in Tajikistan Despite active measures, progress on many ECD outcomes remains limited. The Government undertook substantial efforts to improve ECD outcomes in the country including adopting and implementing several laws on nutrition and social protection, promoting exclusive breastfeeding, and piloting a new health financing mechanism. However, progress on some ECD indicators remains low, and performance on several indicators remains a concern (Table 1). The infant mortality rate (IMR) at 31 deaths per 1,000 live births, although it represents a decrease from 2012, is still the worst among the Commonwealth of Independent States after Turkmenistan (41).3 The rate of immunization of children (24-35-months of age) with the compulsory free basic set of vaccines is 82 percent (DHS, 2017). Preventable illnesses contribute largely to all child and maternal deaths in Tajikistan (UNICEF, 2012; MOHSP, 2018). Both child and maternal anemia rates (both 41.6 percent) are above the threshold for a severe public health problem (DHS, 2017). Prevalence of iodine deficiency among women of reproductive age and children under five was 58.7 and 52.9 percent, respectively. The stunting rate for children under five decreased from 26 percent in 2012 to 17 percent in 2017, with high regional variation (ranging from 15 to 32) (DHS, 2017). Only 36 percent of the infants under six months were exclusively breastfed (DHS, 2017). Programs to address nutrition related issues include salt iodization, food fortification and micronutrient supplementation. The latter is predominantly implemented with donor funding and limited in scope. 3 Author’s compilation from the United Nation Inter-Agency Group for Child Mortality Estimation (IGME) data base for 2017. 12 Figure 1. How ECD Interventions Vary with Child’s Age Timing of intervention In utero Birth to 6 months 7 months to 2 years 3 to 5 years Domains of child development Physical Mother’s health and nutrition Immunizations and regular health check-ups Adequate nutrition Exclusive to prevent stunting Continued investments in breastfeeding and promote adequate nutrition healthy growth Cognitive Early stimulation by caregivers Early stimulation by caregivers and/or and/or ECD teachers (exposure ECD teachers (manipulation of different to simple concepts, shapes, objects and textures, hide-and-seek, self numbers, colors, etc. through and object, etc.) games and daily routines) Language Early stimulation by caregivers and/or ECD teachers (exposure to language through talking, reading, singing, etc.) Socioemotional Interactions with peers (in Positive caring practices by caregivers to structured group settings) to promote healthy emotional development promote positive social development Source: Naudeau et al., 2011. Note: Investing in young children domains represented in the figure are interlinked and provide few examples. 13 Figure 2. ECD beneficiaries and key services across sectors Health (infant, child and Education: maternal) and hygiene: - Preprimary education (3 - Prenatal and postnatal care to 5 years) - Vaccination - Infant care services (0 to - Other preventive care and 2 years): day nurseries and BENEFICIARIES treatment of common child child day-care services illnesses - Parental education Children - The monitoring of child -0 to 2 years growth, development and -3 to 5 years promotion of early child -6 to 8 years stimulation Protection: - Birth registration Mothers - Domestic violence Both pregnant and breastfeeding - Legislation on the early Nutrition: marriage of girls, child - Exclusive breastfeeding Parents/Caregivers labor, female genital - Dietary supplements mutilation, etc. Communication/education on good parental care - Vitamin A supplements - Iron supplements WASH: Water, sanitation and hygiene Source: Adapted from the Global Partnership for Education, 2014. Table 1. Key ECD related indicators Indicator Value Source Comparators Fertility rate (children per Kyrgyzstan, 3.3; Uzbekistan, 2.4; WRA \a) 3.8 2017, DHS Kazakhstan, 2.8; Armenia, 1.8 (2018) \b Share of births of children of 0- Kazakhstan, 100% (2015); 5 YO registered (%) 96% (88%) 2017 (2012), DHS Kyrgyzstan – 98 (2014) \c The worst among the CIS countries Infant mortality rate after Turkmenistan (41) in 2017 \d: (per 1,000 live births) 27 (31) 2017, DHS (IGME). Uzbekistan, 20; Azerbaijan, 18; Armenia, 12; Kazakhstan, 9 Under 5 mortality rate Kazakhstan, 9.9; Armenia, 12; (per 1,000 live births) 33 2017, DHS Kyrgyzstan, 18.9 \e Maternal mortality rate Armenia, 21.9 (2018) \f; (per 100,000 live births) 24.7 2017, MoHSP Kyrgyzstan, 31.3 (2017) \g Malnutrition (0 to 5 years) (%) 2017 (2012), DHS Prevalence of wasting (%) 5.6% 14 Indicator Value Source Comparators The highest in ECA: Kyrgyzstan, Prevalence of stunting (%) 17% (26%) 11.8 (2018); Uzbekistan, 10.8 (2017); Kazakhstan, 8.0 (2015) \h Prevalence of underweight (%) (8%) Prevalence of child overweight 3.3% (1%) (%) Kazakhstan, 29.3 (2016) \i; Child anemia (6-59 months) 41.6% 2017, DHS Armenia, 31.5% (2016) \j; (%) Kyrgyzstan 38.3% (2016) \k Kazakhstan, 30% (2016); Armenia, Maternal anemia (%) 41.6% 2017, DHS 36% (2016); Kyrgyzstan, 40% \l Child under 5 Iodine deficiency 52.9% 2012, MoHSP \m (%) Reproductive age women 58.7% 2012, MoHSP iodine deficiency (%) Child under 5 vitamin A 37% 2016, UNICEF deficiency (%) Immunization rate: coverage of 82% 2017, DHS \o children with DTP3 (%) \n Exclusive breastfeeding for Armenia, 44% (2016; under 5 36% 2017, UNICEF children under 6 months (%) months); Households using 78% 2016, WB improved/basic water (%) Preschool enrollment for Uzbekistan, 29%; Kazakhstan, 14.4% 2019, MoES children ages 3 to 6 (%) 60%; Moldova, Russia, 82% \p Notes and sources: (a) WRA = Women of Reproductive Age. (b) JME - Joint child malnutrition estimate based on UNICEF, WHO and WB harmonized dataset. (c ) UNICEF Data: Monitoring the situation of children and women. (d) UN IGME. (e) UNICEF Data: Monitoring the situation of children and women (2018). (f) Armenia’s Statistical Service. (g) http://en.kabar.kg/news/unfpa-maternal-mortality-rates-in-kyrgyzstan-remain-high/ (h) JME. (i) https://www.indexmundi.com/facts/kazakhstan/prevalence-of-anemia. (j) https://www.indexmundi.com/facts/armenia/prevalence-of-anemia. (k) https://tradingeconomics.com/kyrgyzstan/prevalence-of-anemia-among-children-percent-of-children-under-5- wb-data.html (l) https://data.worldbank.org/indicator/SH.PRG.ANEM (m) MoHSP, Nutrition and Physical Activity Strategy for 2015-2024. (n) Combined diphtheria-tetanus toxoid and pertussis vaccine. (o) Percent represents all children of 24-35-month age. (p) UIS (2018) 15 Beyond health and nutrition services, cognitive simulation and positive parenting in the early years can be improved in Tajikistan. The brain matures fastest during the early years. When adults respond appropriately to a baby’s gestures, neural connections are strengthened, thereby contributing to communication and social skills. Children need stimulation, which has been shown to improve their cognitive functions, language skills, and educational outcomes. Traditional practices of child development abound in the country, which have some positive and some potential negative repercussions for Traditional Child Development Practices in Tajikistan child development. According to the Early Human Capability After birth there is a tradition of chillla—a period of rest for the mother and baby—for 40 Index (eHCI)4 survey of 2019 (World Bank), days. This time not only allows bonding within the previous three days 42.1 percent of between mother and baby, but also minimizes the risk of exposure to infections by limiting children had been read a book, 52.5 percent access to visitors. had been told a story, 69.2 percent had had songs sung to them, including lullabies, 65.6 percent had been taken outside, 71.3 percent had been played with, and 46.3 percent had been engaged through naming, counting, or drawing. Parenting practices were consistent The practice of tightly cradling the baby in a across child gender, age, region and caregiver gavora cradle, up to 10 months keeps children warm, but may be restricting opportunities for education, for both positive and negative cognitive simulation and development. dimensions of parenting. Regarding the home Kolak, or cutting to remove newborn learning environment, 56.2 percent of children’s “dirty� blood, although less commonly practiced, can increase risk of caregivers reported having no books for their infections as it is done without appropriate children. medical supervision. Food security is an ongoing challenge in Save the Children Tajikistan, and one that has a significant impact on the ECD agenda. Food security can be defined as having physical and economic access 4 The survey is nationally representative and provides information on a short set of indicators, including the caregivers’ styl e of interaction with their children (warm, hostile) and whether household members engaged in activities with their 0-59-month-old children that promote child development. These activities include reading books or looking at picture books; telling stories; singing songs; taking children outside the home, compound or yard; playing with children; and spending time with children naming, counting, or drawing things. 16 to sufficient, safe, and nutritious food that meets dietary needs and food preferences (FAO, 2006). On average, food constitutes 50-60 percent of household expenditure (WFP, 2018). Poor households spend about 75 percent of their income on food and, for these families, acquiring sufficient food is often a concern, particularly during the lean season (January to May) (Lavado et al., 2017). According to the Listening-to-Tajikistan survey of well-being, the availability of food (especially for children) plays an important role in determining life satisfaction in Tajikistan (Azevedo and Seitz 2017). Furthermore, having access to “sufficient daily calories� has been found to reduce the relative risk of stunting by about 37 percent (World Bank, 2017). Access to safe drinking water, sanitation, and hygiene (WASH) services has a positive impact on children’s health and nutrition (WHO, 2015) and these facilities are incrementally being provided to people in Tajikistan. While the exact relationship between nutrition and WASH is difficult to measure and remains unclear5, it is well established that the supply and quality of water and access to sanitation facilities have a direct impact on stunting through biological channels like helminths and diarrhea. Access to “adequate water and sanitation� reduces the relative risk of stunting by about 29 percent; access to “adequate care� reduces it by 35 percent, and access to “sufficient daily calories� reduces it by about 37 percent (World Bank, 2017b). Between 2000 and 2016, use of improved/basic water increased from about 55 percent of households to 78 percent of households, and the share of those relying on surface water for their main drinking water source declined from 33 percent to 15 percent (World Bank, 2017a). This advance was driven primarily by improvements among the two lowest income quintiles of households and have varied significantly between rural and urban settlements. Also, the quality of household sanitation facilities varies by region, with approximately 80-90 percent of households in Gorno-Badakhshan Autonomous Oblast (GBAO) and Khatlon still relying on pit latrines, while an estimated 80 percent of households in Dushanbe use flush-to-pipe sewer systems (World Bank, 2017a). Despite recent developments in enhancing social protection and assistance, young children of the poor and disabled children remain most at risk to low ECD outcomes. Ninety-six percent of births of children ages zero to five are registered, up from 88 percent in 2012 (DHS, 2017), and 91 percent of children under five have a birth certificate. However, 15 percent of the 5A meta-analysis of the expected impact of improved sanitation interventions on reducing stunting found mixed results (Cumming and Cairncross, 2016) 17 poorest children who do not have birth certificates are at a high risk of not being able to access public services and social assistance schemes (DHS, 2017). A new Targeted Social Assistance (TSA) was introduced in 2011 and has been gradually extended nationally.6 However, it provides a limited unconditional cash benefit of TJS 464 per year7. Children with disabilities are among the most vulnerable children in Tajikistan. Based on World Health Organization (WHO) estimates of the global prevalence of childhood disability, Tajikistan had about 150,000 children with disabilities—nearly six times the 26,000 who were officially registered as such—in 2015.8 However, the number, quality, and integration of services for these children and support for their parents remain highly restricted in Tajikistan. 6 The Government of the Republic of Tajikistan, Decree № 271 “On the Introduction of Identification and Payment Mechanism for the Targeted Social Assistance in the Republic of Tajikistan�, May 14, 2020 7 The cash benefit value is of May 2020 8 ‘Evaluation of UNICEF Tajikistan’s work in priority districts during the 2010–2015 Country Programme,’ 2016. 18 2. Regulatory Environment and Governance for ECD Given the multisectoral nature of ECD services, effective ECD service delivery requires an enabling environment created by (i) an adequate regulatory framework (laws, policies and strategic plans) to enable different actors to provide complementary services; and (ii) governance arrangements that facilitate coordination within and across institutions to ensure effective service delivery (GPE, 2014). Regulatory Framework for ECD provision While Tajikistan has established regulations affecting several aspects of ECD service delivery, a comprehensive regulatory framework for ECD is yet to be developed. Since several sectors contribute to ECD outcomes targeting different groups (pregnant women, parents/caregivers, children, schools, health facilities, etc.), the range of laws and regulations forming the ECD legal framework is usually wide. According to a 2013 assessment using the SABER-ECD framework (World Bank, 2013), the legal framework for ECD in Tajikistan, as in other countries in the region,9 can be considered “established.�10 This means that there are existing legislative norms and regulations for various aspects of ECD policy (Neuman and Devercelli, 2013). In order to move to an “advanced� level, a country needs to have a fully developed integrated legal framework covering all target groups and aspects of ECD holistically. This would include laws and regulations on healthcare for pregnant and lactating women and children, laws and regulations that promote appropriate dietary consumption by pregnant women and young children, support for women to care for children in the first year of life (e.g. paid parental leave, job protection, etc.), and child protection and social protection policies and services. Not only must these policies exist, but they must also be enforced.11 The regulatory framework is fragmented. The Early Child Learning and Development Standards (ELDS), developed by the MoES in 2010 establish requirements related to preschool education and care for children from birth to seven years, including elements of child development and care. However, they were not jointly developed with, and have not been integrated with, 9 Albania (2015), Armenia (2012), Azerbaijan (2018), and Kyrgyz Republic (2013). 10 This represents the third level in a scale of four: latent, emerging, established, and advanced. 11 SABER framework paper. 19 MoHSP’s own set of protocols12 related to child development and care. Updated laws and framework appear to have left important gaps in the regulatory regime. For example, the National Health Code of 2017 has invalidated the 2006 law on breastfeeding promotion. The 2006 law was consistent with most of the provisions set forth in the International Code of Marketing of Breast Milk Substitutes, an international health policy framework for breastfeeding promotion adopted by the World Health Assembly in 1981. The 2017 code declares the importance of breastfeeding, but leaves gaps in key areas, such as articulating the means of promoting it (for example through health workers or mass media), the role of central and local institutions in enabling it, and ways to create favorable conditions for breastfeeding infants in public institutions and organizations (for mothers). Another example is the Family Code, which contradicts international legal practice and signed treaties regarding child adoption as it prohibits the adoption of Tajik children by non-Tajik citizens. This is in violation of the Child Rights Convention (CRC), Article 21, of which Tajikistan is a signatory, and which includes the obligation to “ensure that the child concerned by intercountry adoption enjoys safeguards and standards equivalent to those existing in the case of national adoption.� The regulatory framework in Tajikistan is not universally activated, due to the absence of sub-laws and normative acts and to inadequate financing and capacity, risking service delivery to achieve ECD outcomes. Although designed to be mandatory, the ELDS remain limited in practice due to capacity constraints and complexity. The 2019 law on providing the population with fortified food products (2019), which aimed to regulate provision of fortified food products to the population and establish the legal framework for prevention of micronutrient deficiency and related diseases, remains inactive due to the absence of sub-laws. So while it replaces the 2019 Law of the Republic of Tajikistan on Salt Iodization (2002), which made salt iodization mandatory in order to reduce the prevalence of iodine deficiency among all citizens (particularly young children), its delay in activation leaves a gap in the regulatory regime around salt iodization. The most relevant codes, laws, strategies and policies are listed next. 12For example, the MoHSP order of 20.09.2018, #873 “Well child care from 0 to 24 months of age� sets the expected child growth outcomes. 20 Laws and Regulations Related to Child Development Tajikistan is a signatory to more than 60 universal ratified declarations and agreements that ensure protection of the rights to health, education, and social services. In 1993, Tajikistan ratified the CRC and the Convention to Eliminate All Forms of Discrimination Against Women (CEDAW). In 2018 it ratified the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. The ratified conventions set the stage for legal and policy development in the related areas. The Family Code of Tajikistan (2017). This code was originally endorsed in 1998 and most recently amended in 2017. It defines a family as “natural and fundamental nucleus of society and it needs to be protected.� The child protection provisions in this law are strong with respect to the child’s right to life, to grow up in a family with parents, to receive special service if they have a disability, to be eligible for free services and education and to be protected from abuse and use of drugs. The code stipulates the responsibility of both parents for the growth, education, and emotional, social, and material welfare of their children until they reach 18 years of age, and in case of the parents’ divorce. The code guarantees access to social protection for orphaned and disabled children. Labor Code of Tajikistan (2006). Like other countries in the region, Tajikistan guarantees paid maternity leave and allows for prolonging unpaid parental leave. Endorsed in 1998 and amended in 2006, this code guarantees maternity leave, protection from pregnancy-related employment discrimination, and breaks for breastfeeding upon return to work. This code is applicable to women working in the formal sector. At 140 days of paid leave (70 days prior to delivery and 70 days after) and potential to extend further,13 Tajikistan’s maternity leave is comparable to that in Armenia and the Russian Federation, and it is more extensive than that of the Kyrgyz Republic (World Bank, 2013). All children in the country who have birth certificates are eligible to receive social allowances (50 Tajik somoni per month in 2017) up until they are 1.5 years old. Women can also receive leave without pay until the child turns three years. Law on parents’ responsibility on upbringing of children and their education (2011): This law regulates the responsibility of parents for child-rearing and education, including giving the child a decent name, having the child registered in a civil registration office, and supporting child’s health, 13Maternity leave is 140 days (70 days prior to delivery, and 70 days after) and, in the case of complicated labor (birth), 86 days and is paid at 100 percent of wages by the GoT. 21 physical, cognitive and socioemotional development. The Law stresses the responsibility of both parents for creation of favorable conditions for child development. Law on education (2013): This law sets core principles of state policy in the education sector. It provides an overarching framework for education system service delivery and institutional and governance arrangements. Law on preschool education and care (2013): This law establishes the legal, institutional, economic, and social frameworks for preschool education and care in Tajikistan. National Health Code (2017): National laws mandate the provision of healthcare for pregnant women and young children. The introduction of a new National Health Code in 2017 replaced 16 previously existing laws, including those on immunizations and breastfeeding. The new code includes some general clauses on maternal and child health (guarantees the child’s right to healthy physical, cognitive, spiritual, moral, and social development),14 and there is an effort underway to ensure that the code includes more details to address the needs of young children. The Tajikistan Sustainable Development Goal (SDG) strategy for 2016-2030: This strategy includes a focus on improving food security and ensuring access to good quality nutrition; however, it does not explicitly focus on ECD. The strategy aims to promote an effective multisectoral approach to ensure adequate nutrition by means of policy coordination in the fields of agriculture, public health, social protection, and raising awareness about quality of nutrition and effective financing. There is scope to increase the focus on ECD and work with these sectors to improve coordination of services for young children. National Development Strategy 2016-2030: The strategy prioritizes the development of primary healthcare and preschool education that foster ECD, the importance of strengthening public- private partnerships in social sectors, inclusive education, and the development of a targeted assistance system for low-income households. The strategy sets a goal to increase preschool enrollment from 12.4 percent in 2016 to 50 percent in 2030. National Health Strategy for Tajikistan 2020-2030: This strategy is currently being developed and will replace the National Health Strategy of the Republic of Tajikistan for the period 2010- 14 Maternal health protection, underlined in article 45, states that: the State should provide appropriate condition for maternal health, social and material support of motherhood; pregnant women should get the social support within state approved benefits; a child right’s to health under article 46 guarantees child’s right to healthy physical, cognitive, spiritual, moral and social devel opment. 22 2020 (endorsed in 2010). The existing strategy, which remains in effect until the new one is finalized, prioritizes newborn, child, and adolescent health and nutrition as well as reproductive health and safe maternity practices and contributes to achieving the goals of the Tajikistan SDG 2030 strategy. The current draft emphasizes strengthening integrated primary health care (PHC) services, enhancing early identification and interventions. One of the draft strategy’s objectives is to ensure sustainability and high coverage with essential health and nutrition interventions for the improvement of mothers’ and children’s health and nutrition status. The draft stresses the establishment of a multi-tiered and unified system to manage the protection of children’s rights. National Education Development Strategy of Tajikistan 2021-2030: This strategy is currently being finalized and will replace the National Education Development Strategy for the period 2012- 2020. The current draft emphasizes increasing access to quality early learning services for children 1.5 to six years of age and reaching 50 percent preschool enrolment for children age six by 2030 by, among other means, adopting alternative preschool models, improving the quality of preschool personnel, upgrading preschool facilities, reforming preschool financing, and strengthening the monitoring of early child development. State standard for preschool education (2014): The standard establishes single requirements for preschool education and care including academic workload for students, the graduates’ level of competence, organization of educational process, timelines for preschool learning and care etc. Early learning and development standards (from birth to 7(6) years) (2010): The standards promote the understanding of early learning and development, provide a comprehensive and coherent set of early childhood educational expectations for children’s development and learning, and guide the design and implementation of curriculum, assessment and instructional practices with young children. Draft National Social and Behavior Change Strategy to Improve Childhood Nutrition in the First 1,000 Golden Days of Life (pending endorsement): This is the first draft national strategy on behavior change in the country. It targets all levels of stakeholders, from policy decision makers, health workers to families. The draft provides clear, concise, easily adaptable and practical guidance on the approaches to effectively promote and support appropriate maternal nutrition and infant and young child feeding (IYCF). This draft strategy has a comprehensive five-year implementation plan. 23 Law on providing the population with fortified food product (2019): This law aims to regulate provision of fortified food products to the population and establish the legal framework for prevention of micronutrient deficiency and related diseases. The Law obliges food product producers, sellers etc. to enrich their products with micronutrients. The products include wheat flour, baker's yeast, flour products, confectionery, milk and dairy products, including those intended for baby food, juices, drinking water, soft drinks, edible salt, etc. By this law, the production, import and sale of fortified wheat flour and other food products and non-iodized salt are prohibited in the country. While the law is a huge step forward in tackling malnutrition issues in the country at the legal level, it is not yet operationalized due to absence of sub-laws, and therefore a gap is created in critical areas of regulation. For example, the Law of the Republic of Tajikistan on Salt Iodization (adopted in 2002) which made salt iodization mandatory in order to reduce the prevalence of iodine deficiency amongst all citizens, particularly young children, became invalid upon issuance of the 2019 law, but because the 2019 law is not yet operationalized, there are no regulation in effect for salt iodization in the country at the moment. Laws and regulations related to parents’ ability to support child development The State Guaranteed Package of Health Services (Basic Benefits Package): In 2007, the GoT introduced a pilot program on State Guaranteed Package of Health Services (BBP) in 4 districts to improve equitable coverage of medical services. The pilot program is now operational in 19 out of 65 districts nationally. The BBP regulates entitlement for a variety of free / discounted services at primary and secondary levels of the health system. The eligible groups represent large segments of the population. At the PHC level, the BBP covers services for children under one-year-old, delivery in the hospital, antenatal care, immunizations, emergency care, and care for Acute Respiratory Infection and diarrhea according to the Integrated Management of Child Illness guidelines etc. The BBP does not cover support for preventative care, particularly for young children’s nutrition, micronutrient supplementation and child development. An independent evaluation of the earlier stage of BBP in 200936 suggested “erratic implementation of BBP payment guidelines� which led to “excessive charging, including 100% fees for district residents, who are entitled to reduced rates, and payment for nominally free PHC services.�37 The revised design of the BBP of 2017 has expanded the BBP eligibility criteria38. There are no available evaluations of the latest stages of BBP implementation. The BBP was revised and, in May 2020, 24 the GoT approved this program for the period of 2020 to 2022. The scope of services and eligibility criteria of the BBP for the period of 2020-2022 is being finalized now with other ministries and relevant bodies. Government Resolution on payments for children in state preschool institutions (2016): Prior to the resolution, parental contributions in the form of fees were non-transparent and unregulated across the country’s public kindergartens. The 2016 resolution has standardized fees for services provided by state kindergartens by articulating the eligibility regulations guiding payment, an acceptable range of fees and payment methods. In 2018, the fee varied from TJS 50 to TJS 100 per child per month depending on the district (poor, not poor). Laws and regulations related to social protection There are several policies which promote social protection. However, those policies do not focus specifically on providing access for children or meeting children’s nutritional or developmental needs. Law of the Republic of Tajikistan on Social Services (2008): This law specifies that vulnerable children and young people, pregnant women, elderly persons and disabled persons should have priority in the provision of social welfare services. Concept of Social Protection of the Population of the Republic of Tajikistan (2006) : This Concept states that the basic social rights of the citizens should be preserved and supported, such as the right to a state pension in case of disability, reaching retirement age, loss of breadwinner and other cases, as determined by law. Law on the Child Rights Protection (2015): This law stipulates the rights and freedoms of the child, including, inter alia, right to life, freedom, inviolability, personality, health care, dwelling, education, rest, protection of rights of the child in special educational institutions; protection of orphaned children and children without parental care; protection of rights of the disabled children. Regulation for Guardianship and Trusteeship Authorities (2017): This regulation protects children’s interests and ensures care in the case of a parent’s death or inability to care for the child. Law on Social Protection of People with Disabilities (2010): This law includes a plan of action on implementation of the Convention on the Rights of Persons with Disabilities. According to this 25 law the state should provide the disabled with free pre-school, general and primary vocational education. National Concept Note on Inclusive Education for 2011-2015 and for 2016-2020: This concept note mandates cross-sectoral services and support for children with special needs. It has contributed to the creation of favorable conditions for children with disabilities in kindergartens and schools. For example, school infrastructure has begun to incorporate design that is more conducive for children with physical disabilities, teachers have been trained in inclusive pedagogy, and specialized kindergartens have been established for children with disabilities. National Programme on Rehabilitation of Disabled People 2017-2020 (2016): This program stipulates the provision of free medical and rehabilitation services to all people with disabilities, including children. However, the program does not provide for early identification of disabilities and early intervention among infants. There is a growing recognition that long-term institutional care for children is not an effective and efficient approach in response to the specific social and economic vulnerabilities of children and their caregivers. MoHSP is working on a new regulation on transforming institutional care for children, which will involve incremental transformation of the existing residential institutions for children under four (known as baby homes). Under the regulation, among other things the families at risk of placing their children in baby homes will be supported to keep children at home and will receive daycare services free of charge. Governance Good governance of ECD rests upon high-level political commitment, the involvement of stakeholders from a range of sectors (with both policy and implementation expertise) and defined roles and responsibilities (Naudeau et. al, 2011), and an institutional anchor to coordinate horizontally across sectors and vertically within the government. Political commitment for ECD is high in Tajikistan. Current national priorities include a dramatic reduction in stunting among children under age five and an increase in preschool coverage of children ages three to six. Several important regulations have been put into effect, as mentioned in the previous section, which demonstrate this commitment. However, to date there is 26 no single overarching national policy or strategy for ECD, and therefore programs and services related to ECD lack integration and coordination. To support the government’s priorities in ECD, the Donor Coordination Council in Tajikistan identified ECD as one of its priority areas under the Human Development cluster. Several agencies define the ECD governance and management system. The MoHSP and the MoES play key roles in defining ECD policy and programs and in key service delivery arrangements. The MoHSP defines and supports the provision of health, nutrition, and social protection services during pregnancy, childbirth, postpartum, and in early childhood, and the MoES supports the provision of education and care services for children 1.5 to six(seven) years old. Through their subordinates, the two ministries develop and implement state policies and strategies, set priorities for child development, protection, and care, and approve standards for service provision (process, content, and monitoring). Local government authorities play a key role in financing and provision of social services. They appoint heads of public institutions under their subordination (e.g., education district/city department, district/city PHC manager, hospital head, social protection and education departments heads, heads of PHC centers (PHCCs) and preschool institutions, etc.) with concurrence from the relevant line ministry. Other stakeholders involved mainly in the services provision include development partners, international and local nongovernmental organizations (NGOs), private donors, and community organizations. In some cases, the external support to essential ECD services exceeds by far the state contribution (e.g., in immunization, vitamins and micronutrients supplementation). Public-private partnerships as well as outsourcing of social services are not yet developed. In the health sector, the private sector is not active in the ECD space except in the provision of laboratory services. There are private healthcare institutions that provide outpatient and inpatient services for all age groups, but their focus on specific ECD-related issues (like prenatal and postnatal care, child growth and development monitoring) is limited. In education, the private-sector provides ECD-related services by opening private preschool institutions (kindergartens, early learning centers, family care) and offering private child development programs. However, its coverage is low: less than 4 percent of all preschool institutions are private. At the policy level, the government works with development partners in the areas of data analysis, program evaluation and 27 development of strategic documents. However, there are no broad public consultations on the strategies, initiatives, and programs, and no feedback mechanisms have yet been developed. Establishing an overarching coordinating body and institutional anchor for ECD has been challenging in Tajikistan. Efforts to coordinate across the various multisectoral services have been made since 2005-06 with the support of UNICEF and the Open Society Institute (OSI). The National Child Rights Commission was established in 2008 to facilitate implementation of the provisions of the Convention on the Rights of the Child ratified by Tajikistan in 1993. A national ECD Forum was held in 2009 to create an intersectoral ECD framework.15 The forum created awareness about ECD in the country but could not succeed in establishing an institutional anchor for ECD (World Bank, 2013). An ECD Council was established under the Deputy Prime Minister on Social Issues but it stopped functioning shortly after establishment due to limited funding. There are two high- level councils—the National Council on Health and Social Protection of the Population under the Government of the Republic of Tajikistan and the National Council on Education under the MoES—but neither are coordinating ECD in the country. In 2013, Tajikistan joined the Scaling Up Nutrition (SUN) initiative, an umbrella to gather all stakeholders working on nutrition to adopt a coordinated approach. With this came the development of a multisectoral platform, the Multi-Sectoral Coordination Council, chaired by the SUN focal person, the First Deputy Minister of MoHSP. Joining SUN has provided an opportunity to enhance multisectoral cooperation in nutrition. Despite the challenges, Tajikistan is moving closer to establishing a high-level coordination mechanism for ECD. The National Committee on Population and Human Development was established in 2014 with support from the United Nations Fund for Population Activities (UNFPA). It is a platform for assessing development concerns, recommending and monitoring the implementation of solutions for a wide range of issues related to the population and human development. It includes representatives from the Parliament, government agencies (ministries, committees and agencies), civil society, and mass media. For the past two years, development partners and relevant government agencies have been engaged in an active dialogue on establishing a similar high-level coordination mechanism for ECD. There is a clear need for such a 15Participants in the ECD Forum, including the Ministry of Health and Social Protection, Ministry of Labor and Social Protection, Ministry of Education, Ministry of Finance, the Executive Office of the President, regional and district authorities, and national and international partners, agreed on a ten-point plan of action for ECD to increase political commitment, integrate ECD services into regional and district development plans along with budget support, and encourage donor investment in ECD. 28 multisectoral mechanism, one that would include the Deputy Prime Minister for Social Affairs, Minister of Finance, and other ministers of all concerned ministries, including MoES, MoHSP, and others (Labor, Agriculture, Water, etc.). The government is moving toward establishing a National Early Childhood Development Council (NECDC). The NECDC would potentially be a venue to convene various ministries and agencies involved in ECD service delivery. Inter alia, it would (a) guide the development of ECD policies; and (b) provide strategic orientation of medium- and long-term ECD plans aligned with the country’s development objectives. Key Agencies Under Ministry of Health and Social Protection The following are among the key health and social protection agencies responsible for supporting ECD in the country. • State Supervision Service for Medical Activities and Social Protection of Population, which carries out state supervision of all medical activities (including pharmaceutical and sanitary- epidemiological activities) and social protection of the population; • State Sanitary and Epidemiological Supervision Service, which is authorized to conduct state supervision in the field of ensuring the sanitary and epidemiological safety of the population; • State Agency for Social Protection, which is responsible for implementation of state policy in the social protection of retirees, people with disabilities, and other vulnerable groups in the population, and provides methodological guidance to and supervision of activities of the bodies and institutions under the social protection system (including local social protection departments); • Republican Center for Immuno-Prophylaxis and its local branches (in each district), which are responsible for all immunization activities in the country such as vaccination planning, vaccines delivery, storage and distribution; monitoring of immunization services, which are mainly provided by the PHC institutions/centers; and training to staff involved in immunization; 29 • Republican Nutrition Center, which in collaboration with the Scientific Research Institute “Ghizo� (under the Ministry of Industry and New Technologies) is to develop general nutrition policy and norms; • Republican Training and Clinical Center on Family Medicine, which develops and provides training programs for family medicine staff on family medicine services delivery (e.g. immunization, counselling, growth monitoring, nutrition, early screening and identification, and referrals); and • Republican Center of Medical Statistics and Information, which is responsible for medical data gathering and the preparation of annual medical statistical books and thematic statistical notes (e.g., on maternal and child health and nutrition). Key Agencies Under the Ministry of Education and Science The following are among the key education and science agencies responsible for supporting ECD in the country. • State Agency for Supervision in the Sphere of Education (SASSE), which conducts licensing, attestation, and accreditation for all preschool institutions (the agency is transitioning to direct government subordination); • Academy of Education, which determines the directions of scientific and research work in pedagogy, conducts such work and coordinates it at pedagogical institutions,16 conducts an expertise of pedagogical materials, and jointly with other academic institutions develops methodological guides for teachers and educators; • Center for development, publishing and distribution of textbooks and scientific books, which defines the needed content in textbooks, develops the textbook publication procedures, arranges for the development of textbooks and scientific books (including review of manuscripts and feedback collection), and publishes and distributes textbooks; and 16Institute for Education Development (IED), Republican Training and Methodological Center (RTMC), Republican Institute for In-Service Teacher Training (RIITT), Pedagogical Higher Education Institutions. 30 • Republican Centre for Information Technologies and Communications, which develops and introduces new technologies in education, develops e-materials for education, including for distance learning (lessons, teachers’ guides on the use of ICT in education, teaching and learning materials), and supports the establishment and maintenance of computer networks at the MoES and for regional educational departments. Other Agencies The following agencies and authorities, external to the MoHSP and the MoES, are involved in health, social protection and education aspects of ECD. • State Women’s and Family Affairs Committee, Government of Tajikistan, which is mandated to conduct state policy to protect and ensure the rights and interests of women and families, create equal opportunities for the implementation of their rights and interests, and help achieve gender equality, expanding women’s participation in socioeconomic spheres. This committee is also tasked with monitoring the implementation of the state programs and laws related to women and families; • Agency on Construction and Architecture, which is responsible for establishing construction standards for social infrastructure, including health facilities and preschools; • Regional health, social protection, and education departments, which are responsible for implementing state policy in their related sectors in the region and monitoring the provision of social services in the districts; and • Local government authorities, such as district/city governments and municipalities, are responsible for implementing state policies at local level, including those in health, social protection, and education, and for ensuring provision of social services, following the centrally adopted state norms and regulations. Local authorities play a key role in decisions about the local network of social service provision, and they cover much of the cost of public health, social protection, and education services. They appoint heads of the social entities under their subordination (e.g. district/city PHC manager, hospital head, social protection and education departments heads etc.) with concurrence from a line ministry. 31 3. ECD Programs and Services While many programs and services are offered for improving ECD outcomes across the country, the following is a list of the key interventions by theme. Comprehensive ECD In April 2020, the International Development Association and the Global Financing Facility for Women, Children and Adolescents approved a $73 million17 grant for the Early Childhood Development to Build Tajikistan’s Human Capital Project. The project objective is to increase utilization of a basic package of health and preschool education services for children ages zero to six. The primary beneficiaries of the project are all children in that age range in Tajikistan (an estimated 1.5 million children), with enhanced support provided to children in this age group and their families in 14 targeted districts (an estimated 70,000 children). To achieve its objectives, the project will develop and support a Basic Package of integrated services to tackle the most pressing needs affecting child development outcomes while building sustainable foundations for cross- sectoral service delivery for improved ECD outcomes for all children. The Basic Package is designed to: (i) ensure that each child’s growth and development is monitored systematically across the country; and (ii) ensure that children in targeted districts enjoy quality health and early education services that promote improved ECD outcomes at an essential level. The proposed project will help establish the foundations for holistic and integrated services promoting improved ECD outcomes at the national and local levels, while testing the delivery of integrated services where the needs are most urgent. Family Planning MoHSP partners with UNFPA, WHO, and regional and district health authorities to increase family planning initiatives among women of reproductive age (15 to 49 years). According to the 2017 Demographic and Health Survey, some women of reproductive age use at least one method of contraception. National contraception-use rates are estimated to be about 29.3 percent among currently married women ages 15 to 49. Regional variations exist; for example, 40.0 percent of 17 Here and throughout this report, all dollars amounts are in US dollars. 32 women from the Sugd province and 36.4 percent of women from the GBAO province use contraception. Pre and Post-Natal Care and Attended Delivery MoHSP, in coordination with regional and district health authorities, is partnering with the World Bank, UNFPA, UNICEF, WHO, GIZ (the German development agency), and the US Agency for International Development (USAID) to implement antenatal visits (or antenatal care). Based on the Soviet system, antenatal care in Tajikistan is expected to include at least seven visits, during which health practitioners provide advice to families on health, nutrition, parenting, and prevention and testing for sexually transmitted diseases, including the Human Immunodeficiency Virus. According to the 2017 DHS, the program has achieved a coverage rate of 91.8 percent for women nationwide. In 2017, approximately 94.8 percent of all births were attended by trained health staff with some provincial disparities. For example, the Sugd province has a coverage rate of 99.5 percent, whereas Khatlon reported 91.9 percent coverage. There has also been an increase in births occurring in a health facility, with an increase from 77 percent in 2012 to 88 percent in 2017. Postnatal visits for mothers at home are supposed to occur, but coverage and quality are uncertain. Following the birth of the child, MoHSP and donor organizations collaborate to increase maternal education through postnatal care visits. Postpartum care is supposed to include an educational component covering the importance of proper nutrition, newborn care, and breastfeeding practices. However, there are no data on quality of the visits and on addressing postpartum depression. Child Growth and Developmental Monitoring Back in Soviet times, growth monitoring was practiced in the healthcare system, focusing mainly on the physical development of the child. However, due to a weakening of the health system and an outflow of health specialists, almost all services have worsened, including the monitoring of child growth and development. MoHSP received significant support from development partners to improve monitoring of child growth and development protocols and guidelines, training, and required equipment. According to existing protocols, home visits (patronage) and growth developmental monitoring and promotion are an integral part of services provided by family medicine staff at health institutions and during home visits. These should be conducted once a 33 month in the first year of life, once per quarter in the second year, every six months in the third year, and once a year during the fourth and fifth year of life. In practice, however, such monitoring is not conducted according to the guidelines (WHO, 2014; World Bank, 2017c). According to a 2016 UNICEF nutrition survey, 87 percent of caregivers with children under age two had contact with health workers to assess child health and development within the previous six months (UNICEF, 2016). Health systems need a more robust monitoring program for child growth and development that will include all aspects of development (social, cognitive, language, and motor skills) and will be based on the recent new learning about child brain development. In 2016, the Maternal and Child Health Handbook (MCH) (also known as “Rohnamo�) was introduced on a pilot basis with technical and financial support from the projects funded by UNICEF, GIZ, the World Bank, and USAID. The MCH handbook is a home-based record for pregnant women and mothers, which contains not only information about maternal and child health but also comprehensive records of pregnancy, childbirth, postpartum care, and children's vaccinations and nutrition. According to the Family Medicine Center Report (2019) there is a need to revise some components of this book. Currently, implementation is limited to around 30 districts in the country. There are no resources (either state budget or external) to expand the coverage to the rest of the country and to make the book available to all pregnant women. Parenting Interventions There are examples of small-scale parenting interventions in Tajikistan, mostly supported by donors and NGOs. UNICEF has been supporting small-scale implementation of Care for Child Development, an approach in which health workers encourage play and communication activities for families to stimulate the learning of their children (Figure 3). Care for Child Development has been integrated into the Integrated Management of Childhood Illnesses training curriculum since 2005 in 12 priority districts out of the 65 districts in the country. There is no clear information or data on the latest status of Care for Child Development training, including the number of trained health workers or the number of children reached. With support from the Open Society Institute Tajikistan, the parents’ organization for children with disabilities provides training for parents and early child identification services for children with developmental delays and disabilities. Other examples include the Aga Khan Foundation’s (AKF’s) training program for community volunteers and health workers, which covers early stimulation as well as health and nutrition in seven districts 34 of the GBAO region, and the Open Society Foundation’s Learning through Play program that educates parents in three districts of the country about how to promote children’s holistic and healthy development up to age six. Figure 3. Care for Child Development: Sample Materials Early Detection of Developmental Delays and Early Intervention Early screening programs require significant health resources, infrastructure, and functional health systems to be effective. As indicated in the previous paragraph, in Tajikistan early identification of developmental delays is assigned to the PHC level, whose capacity is not adequate for standard Child Growth and Development Monitoring procedures. Current activities on early intervention mostly focus on services for children with disabilities. According to MoHSP, there were 26,000 children with disabilities registered in 2015. In 2017, about 1,800 children in Tajikistan were enrolled in baby homes for orphans and for children with disabilities ages 0–4 years old, in residential and half-day institutions for children with disabilities, and in specialized and regular kindergartens (World Bank, 2019a). 35 Currently, in Tajikistan there are several international and local NGOs working on early identification and intervention by engaging in capacity building for PHC workers and in opening the early child identification rooms in PHC facilities to support families in pilot districts of Sugd, GBAO, Dushanbe, and Khatlon. Their target groups include children with autism, children with Down Syndrome, children with physical and mental disabilities, and caregivers of children with disabilities with limited geographical coverage. UNICEF supported the establishment of Psychological, Medical and Pedagogical Committees (PMPCs) in the PHCCs to support the system’s activities in identifying children with disabilities and early intervention, rehabilitation, and parent education. Currently there are 10 PMPCs operating in different parts of the country under the supervision of local PHCCs and funded from local budgets. The PMPCs are staffed by neuropathologists, speech therapists, and psychologists. Among other services, they also provide legal advice and consultation to parents of children with disabilities and supervise children with disabilities living in specialized institutions. Some PMPCs in selected districts provide early intervention services for children with developmental delays and disabilities, working in cooperation with organizations of parents of children with disabilities. Immunization MoHSP, with support from WHO, UNICEF, the Global Alliance for Vaccines and Immunization (GAVI), and USAID, implements an extensive immunization program throughout the country for children between the ages of 24 and 35 months. The compulsory basic set of vaccinations, which is free, includes a single dose of Bacille Calmette-Guerin vaccine, three doses of the DPT-HepB- Hib, three doses of the polio vaccine, and one dose of the measles vaccine. According to the 2017 DHS, 82 percent of all children in the 24-35-month age category have received all these basic vaccinations. Nutrition Interventions A 2012 report indicated that the burden of undernutrition in Tajikistan is substantial, and that deaths in the labor force from undernutrition cost the country nearly $12.3 million a year, while productivity lost due to low birth weight, stunting, iodine deficiency, and anemia costs an estimated $28.6 million to the economy. At least $15 million of the country’s economic losses from undernutrition can be prevented by improving nutrition through a combination of behavioral changes and strengthening and scaling up of existing programs (World Bank, UNICEF, 2012). 36 The country has many programs to target malnutrition and under nutrition across the lifecycle. Key programs among them are listed next. Interventions to Improve Feeding Practices Breastfeeding. MoHSP works with UNICEF, WHO, various NGOs, and local health institutions to promote exclusive breastfeeding practices for children from 0-6 months. Over 245,000 pregnant and postpartum women and 232,000 children under six months of age are targeted through clinics and home-based visits. Family doctors, neonatologists, pediatricians and medical nurses provide counseling at various stages during pregnancy and after an institutional birth. However, despite these initiatives only 35.8 percent of children under six months of age are exclusively breastfed; 5.4 percent of children in this age category were not breastfed at all, and the remaining 58.8 percent of children received breastfeeding and some form of complementary feeding (e.g., water, milk). Complementary feeding. The MoHSP advocates complementary feeding programs to children between the ages of six and 24 months through clinic and home-based visits by PHC staff with support from UNICEF, WHO, and USAID. Nutrition counseling. Nutrition counseling is an integral component of PHC services, which are carried out through antenatal care, home visits, and well-child visits. According to the antenatal care visit standards, women should receive nutrition counseling (concerning the importance of micronutrient supplementation, nutrition during pregnancy, breastfeeding, complementary food, etc.) during each visit to a PHCC. Nutrition counseling for all family members, including the feeding of young children, is covered by the protocols for home visiting by nurses. The government recently endorsed a “draft national social and behavior change strategy to improve childhood nutrition in the first 1,000 golden days of life,� which integrates key counseling messages for health workers to reinforce activities related to nutrition counselling. Nutrition counseling is supported and monitored by different development partner projects: performance-based financing (World Bank), Feed the Future (USAID), and others. Micronutrient Supplementation and Fortification Vitamin A. With support from development partners like UNICEF, MoHSP implements a vitamin A campaign twice a year, targeting children between the ages of six and 59 months. The 2017 Demographic and Health Survey found that about 46 percent of children ages six to 23 months 37 had consumed vitamin-A-rich food in the previous 24 hours, but a much higher percentage (77.9 percent) had received vitamin A supplements in the past six months: 79.4 percent in rural areas vs. 72.5 percent in urban areas. This is above a coverage threshold of 70 percent, which represents the minimal coverage of vitamin A supplementation at which countries can expect to observe reductions in child mortality (UNICEF, 2007). A UNICEF report further evidences this rural-urban divide and finds that coverage of vitamin A capsules varied more significantly between provinces: 91.6 percent (the highest) in Sugd vs. 59.7 percent in Khatlon (the lowest). Iron. Iron deficiency, or anemia, can be prevented through the provision of iron supplements or through fortifying food with iron, but coverage of iron supplements is low nationally. According to DHS 2017, only 25.5 percent of children ages six to 59 months surveyed were reporting to have taken iron supplements in the previous seven days, and just 45 percent of women took iron supplements during pregnancy. Iron-folate supplementation efforts for women have been unsuccessful for two reasons. First, there has been a limited supply of the supplements, and second, only a small proportion of women receive these for free, so many do not take the complete course of treatment (DHS, 2017). Iodine. The consumption of iodized salt is critical to ensure adequate consumption of iodine in Tajikistan which, as a land-locked country, does not naturally have iodine in the soil or food supply. A lack of iodine can cause cognitive impairment as well as goiter and cretinism. The MoHSP implements salt iodization programs in collaboration with the MoES, the Committee on TV and Radio under the Government of the Republic of Tajikistan, and the Agency for Standardization, Metrology, Certification and Trade Inspection. These government agencies partner with UNICEF, WHO, and the World Food Programme (WFP) with the goal of achieving universal salt iodization for all ages. In 2013, the Global Alliance for Improved Nutrition (GAIN) and UNICEF, with support from USAID, began a pilot project on strengthening capacity in salt iodization and supporting a universal salt iodization program in the Khatlon province. From 2015, MoHSP, with support from UNICEF, started national implementation of social mobilization and awareness raising among the salt producers and consumers about the benefits of iodized salt and began work to advocate for universal salt iodization. While there is some discrepancy in data on 38 the utilization of iodized salt,18 Tajikistan should aim to achieve a household coverage of 90 percent to eliminate iodine deficiency, according to WHO guidelines. 19 Zinc. The MoHSP partners with UNICEF and the WHO to work with PHCCs to administer zinc treatments for children under five who are being treated for acute diarrhea. The medication is supplied by the Government of Japan. On average, 19.2 percent of children under five who visit PHCCs for acute diarrhea receive zinc treatments (as opposed to 100 percent), with unequal coverage in urban and rural areas (25.6 percent versus 18.2 percent, respectively) (SA, 2018). Multiple Micronutrients. Although there have been several pilots (some very successful) to provide micronutrient powders or “Sprinkles� for home-based fortification of complementary food for children between the ages of six and 24 months, there is no such program in the country at present. In the past, the initiative has received support from donor agencies, such as the World Bank, USAID, UNICEF, the AKF, and the Russian Federation. One initiative, supported by the World Bank and UNICEF, delivered 280,000 boxes of Sprinkles to 140,000 children through PHCCs, resulting in a 5 percentage-point reduction in anemia (World Bank, 2018). Currently, coverage of micronutrient powders is quite variable and dependent on the province and external funding. The DHS found that nationally only 17.2 percent of children between six and 24 months were reported to have received the micronutrient powders within the past week. However, 29.2 percent of the targeted children in the Khatlon province had received the Micronutrient Powders . Uptake in the Sughd province was significantly lower at a reported 6.4 percent. Management of Moderate and Severe Malnutrition MoHSP and various international donors and NGOs oversee the management of acute malnutrition in children under the age of five through a variety of interventions. UNICEF-supported therapeutic feeding centers have been scaled up nationwide, and responsible health staff from each district have been trained in the management of severe acute malnutrition. In cases of severe acute malnutrition, trained health practitioners provide specialized nutrition product (F75 and F100 formulas, deworming, amoxicillin, etc.) for inpatient facilities and oral rehydration salts at PHC facilities. However, there is limited monitoring of these services at the local level. The 2017 18 According to the UNICEF Micronutrient Status Survey (MNSS) 2016, salt iodization declined between 2009 and 2016, while the 2017 DHS indicates that salt utilization increased notably from 84 percent in 2012 to 92 percent in 2017. 19 Assessment of iodine deficiency disorders and monitoring their elimination, WHO. 39 Demographic and Health Survey did report that among children under the age of five who visited a facility for diarrhea within the past two weeks, around 62 percent had received oral rehydration salt packets for treatment. But generally, information is limited. In order to address moderate malnutrition, WFP provides treatment for moderate acute malnourished children. The project has been piloted in five districts and provides a specialized nutritious food – Super Cereal Plus – for such children. Currently, over 6,000 children are enrolled in this supplementary feeding program. Deworming Parasitic worms cause diseases in humans and deworming medication is a low-cost way to treat infected individuals and reduce illness in children and allow them to better absorb nutrients, which is critical during early childhood to prevent malnutrition (Andrews, Bogoch and Utzinger, 2017). In 2012-2013, the Rostropovich-Vishnevskaya Foundation supported national deworming campaign covering more than 4.3 million children and adults who received deworming tablets and hygiene promotion messages. The campaign was followed by the development of national guidelines on epidemiology, diagnosis, clinic, treatment and prevention of helminth infections, and capacity building activities for laboratory staff and parasitologists in modern methods for diagnosing parasitic diseases. According to the 2017 Demographic and Health Survey, 14.8 percent of children of six to 59 months of age received deworming medication in the six months preceding the survey. Water, Sanitation and Hygiene (WASH) The Tajikistan Water Supply and Sanitation Network (TajWSS Network) is a collaborative effort among 17 different ministries, international agencies, and stakeholders with the goal of improving WASH-related interventions throughout the country. The government has adopted the 2016–2025 Water Sector Reform Program, which aims to ensure the use of integrated water resource management, among other things. The sector relies heavily on international funding to fill the existing financing gap, with most of the funding being allocated to irrigation and the integrated water resource management agenda. The rural water supply commitments of $47 million are spread over small 21 projects. These rural projects have covered half of the country’s districts, with most of the projects concerned with rehabilitation, reconstruction, water governance, and social accountability (World Bank, 2019b). The new World Bank Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Project, at $59 million, aims to improve access to basic water supply and sanitation 40 services in selected districts and to strengthen the capacity of institutions in the water supply and sanitation sector. Social protection interventions Social protection interventions can provide resources and a safety net to families who have young children, thus buffering them from risks that can affect ECD. The coverage of social protection programs in Tajikistan remains limited, and these programs do not necessarily target the most vulnerable population groups, including families with young children and those in the informal sector. Social Assistance According to the World Bank’s 2018 report on the State of Social Safety Nets, Tajikistan lags behind most other Europe and Central Asia (ECA) countries with respect to total spending on its social protection programs. Thus, mean spending in the ECA region is about 2.2 percent of gross domestic product (GDP), four times higher than Tajikistan’s 2014 spending level. In addition to low fiscal support, social assistance programs in Tajikistan had poor targeting. In 2014, the government started piloting and is gradually introducing a new Targeted Social Assistance (TSA) program to replace its previous energy subsidy and school allowance programs. The purpose of the TSA is to target scarce budget resources to the neediest population through an unconditional transfer to selected households on a quarterly basis. It provides each registered household with an unconditional cash benefit of TJS 464 per year. Eligibility criteria are based on proxy means and include—among others— the composition and age of all family members, presence of elderly parents, children under 15 years of age, presence of disabled people or children with disabilities, housing conditions, and information on the property of all family members in the household. The annual cash benefit of TJS 464 may seem small, but eligible households receive additional benefits (burial allowance, fee discount on some public health facility services apart from the BBP, higher education tuition discounts, etc.). Outside these benefits set centrally for the entire country, local authorities can add more benefits for registered TSA households, such as a public transport fee exemption and utility cost subsidy. After the TSA’s national scale-up in May 2020, it is expected to cover around 200,000 households (close to 15 percent of all households in the country). 41 Child Protection Services Child protection policies and services are in the process of being established in Tajikistan. The dominant approach is to provide orphans and vulnerable children, including children with disabilities, with services in institutions, such as orphanages and residential care institutions, including boarding schools. Overall, services for children with disabilities have limited outreach, and community-based services are at their early stages in Tajikistan (also, see above under the early intervention section in this chapter). The Mellow Parenting Program has worked with parents since 2010 to keep babies and children out of institutional care. It uses trained facilitators to work with parents who might need additional support to prevent children being placed in institutional care by strengthening parent-child relationships. Results have shown that participating families have predominantly kept their children out of institutional homes.20 Currently, with support from UNICEF and Healthprom, MoHSP’s Hayot dar oila is transforming exiting four Baby Homes to Family and Child Support Centers. The Centers are to provide community-based support services for vulnerable families and children under seven years old. The Centers work in strong collaboration with the Commission on Child Rights and the Child Rights Units as well as with community agencies and public organizations to promote child welfare and strengthen protection systems and services. School Feeding The WFP began piloting a school feeding program in Tajikistan in 1999. Over the past two decades, the WFP has rapidly scaled up the school feeding program to 60 percent of all rural schools in the country, and the program now reaches 370,000 school children with major financial support from the Russian Federation. The state budget has not taken over financing of this program. There is no similar program for children below school age. The WFP also recently began its Food Assistance for Assets program in Tajikistan. This program provides food, vouchers, or cash transfers to vulnerable populations in order to increase food security. In return, communities work on improving assets and infrastructure within their community to increase protections from shocks, while subsequently improving their food security and nutrition status. Additionally, the WFP works with the government’s Committee for 20Mellow Parenting poster at https://www.mellowparenting.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Tajik-Poster-for-WAIMH-May- 16.pdf 42 Emergency Situations and Civil Defense to maintain a contingency stock that can be distributed in the event of a natural disaster. In 2016 and 2017 the WFP provided food assistance worth up to $90,000 to people affected by natural disasters in Tajikistan. Community-based Programs In December 2014, the MoHSP and WHO organized the first national conference on community- based interventions, called "Reaching the Unreached.� The conference provided guiding principles to implement community-based programs and laid the foundation for initiating government- managed community-based programs in Tajikistan. Starting in 2015, the international NGO Caritas supported a community-based program in three districts of the country (Vahdat, Konibodom and Devashtich), reaching 31,631 children under age three with early screening for developmental delays and with interventions to address them. The screening tool was adapted and endorsed by the MoHSP, and a pool of national trainers has been trained in ECD. Alternative Preschool Programs In 2010-2011, a new alternative model of preschool education – Early Learning Centers (ELCs) – was piloted with support from UNICEF and AKF. From 2012, following the government’s instructions, local government authorities started establishing ELCs in a national scale. As a result, the Early Child Education and Care (ECEC) services provision increased almost fivefold from 2010 to 2017. The increase was mainly driven by the ELCs: from 23 in 2010 to 1,671 in 2017. Tajikistan’s ELCs reflect the country’s first efforts toward its strategic goal of investing in alternative preschool types. An ELC provides half-day services at a location and a price that make it more accessible than a traditional full-day kindergarten. By 2017, ELCs accommodated almost one-third of children enrolled in preschool. Yet ELCs still lack secure public funding and a regulatory framework, limiting their quality and sustainability. ELCs are being established by the government, private sector, and local communities. The latter are supported by development partners (AKF, UNICEF, OSI). Thus, AKF facilitates establishment of ECD support groups, which in turn support community based ELCs. In remote areas, AKF also supports community play groups – a model that promotes caregiver and child interaction in an educational and stimulating play-based environment. 43 The new World Bank-funded ECD Project envisages supporting around 500 ELCs and 1,500 play groups through upgrades in small physical premises, teacher training and mentoring support, and TLMs provision. 44 4. Conclusion Tajikistan faces a unique opportunity today. Investing in human capital can change the country’s development trajectory. Given the large proportion of the population under six years of age, there is no doubt that investing in improving ECD outcomes is the best national investment that Tajikistan can make. The country is to be commended for its decision to invest in the health, education, and development of its youngest citizens. Realizing improved ECD outcomes will require more than good will and financial investments, however. It will need a robust regulatory foundation that enables the many diverse actors to work toward a common purpose. It could begin with a national policy framework for ECD. Such a framework would raise the visibility of ECD for young children and their families and identify strategies to address their needs. A policy framework typically includes both a policy statement and a description of institutional and administrative structures to implement the policy. The policy statement includes a vision of where the ECD is heading, a set of goals or objectives that the government would like to achieve, and strategies for achieving them. It is important for the ECD policy to harmonize with other, related sectoral policies. As was discussed in this policy note, several elements of this framework exist in Tajikistan. It will be crucial to bring them under one umbrella. Government responsibility for the provision or supervision of ECD services is often scattered across ministries, often according to the age of the child. An ECD policy framework can help harmonize the goals and strategies of these institutions horizontally. The policy framework identifies the lead agency and the entities that will implement, manage, monitor, and evaluate ECD programs. A policy can engage new ministries that have not traditionally been engaged in ECD, such as Agriculture and Finance. Furthermore, responsibility may also be distributed vertically among multiple levels of government, such as the national/central, provincial, district, and community levels. Once the policy framework is in place, it is possible to streamline legislation, removing duplications and adding regulations that are crucial yet missing. As discussed in this policy note, the lead agency coordinating ECD needs to be designated and empowered to play that role in Tajikistan, and legislation needs to be enforced through creation of adequate sub- laws, financing, and capacity strengthening. Currently, legislative gaps exist concerning support for pregnant and lactating women, for children under age seven, and for children with disabilities. 45 As the first and primary caregivers, the role of parents and communities cannot be underestimated in achieving positive ECD outcomes. Parental education can focus on raising awareness among parents on the importance of ECD, informing them of what services are available and how to access them, setting realistic expectations for child development at different ages and promoting early stimulation. Early stimulation consists of doing simple, everyday activities with a child— talking, singing, reading, and playing—in a way that is attentive and responsive. Parenting education can be integrated into existing service delivery mechanisms—civil registration offices (ZAGS), health center waiting rooms, home visits by PHC staff, community health workers, and specialized trainings—to cover the full scope of the ECD life course. Awareness raising, and especially behavior change communication, can be very powerful using mass media and simple communication technologies, such as regular text messages to parents. Parental capacity strengthening can and should proceed while the regulatory framework is being upgraded. Finally, co-location of ECD services can enable positive ECD outcomes. Co-location means implementing different ECD services an integrated way and in in the same geographic areas so that children reap the greatest benefit. In Tajikistan this would mean coordinating across ministries and other actors to ensure the provision of strengthened health sector support for ECD, a more child-sensitive TSA, ongoing parental education, and high-quality preschool services (among other things) in the same geographic areas. 46 References Andrews, J., I. Bogoch, and J. Utzinger. 2017. “The Benefits of Mass Deworming on Health Outcomes: New Evidence Synthesis--The Debate Continues.� The Lancet 5(1): PE4-E5. Azevedo, J.P., and W. Seitz, 2017. “How Subjective is Subjective Wellbeing?� Unpublished manuscript based on the Listening to Tajikistan Survey Rounds. World Bank. Washington, DC. Cumming, O., and S. Cairncross. 2016. “Can Water, Sanitation and Hygiene Help Eliminate Stunting? Current Evidence and Policy Implications.� Maternal & Child Nutrition 12 (Suppl Suppl 1): 91–105. https://doi.org/10.1111/mcn.12258 Denboba, A., R. Sayre, Q. Wodon, L. Elder, L. Rawlings, and J. Lombardi. 2014. “Stepping Up Early Childhood Development: Investing in Young Children for High Returns.� Washington, D.C.: World Bank. Economist Group. 2018. Global Food Security Index: Tajikistan. Intelligence Unit. Retrieved from: https://foodsecurityindex.eiu.com/Country/Details#Tajikistan European Observatory on Health Systems and Policies Health System Review. 2016. Tajikistan Health System Review. Food and Agriculture Organization (FAO). 2006. Policy Brief. Food Security. Retrieved from: http://www.fao.org/fileadmin/templates/faoitaly/documents/pdf/pdf_Food_Security_Cocept_ Note.pdf Global Partnership for Education (GPE). 2014. “Education Sector Analysis Methodological Guidelines: Sub-sector Specific Analyses, Volume 2.� Khodjamurodov G., D. Sodiqova, B. Akkazieva, and B. Rechel. 2016. “Tajikistan: Health System Review.� Health Systems in Transition 18(1):1-114. Lavado, R.F., W. Seitz, and A. Thiebaud. 2017. “Childhood stunting in Tajikistan: quantifying the association with wash food security health and care practices.� HNP Discussion Paper. Washington, D.C.: World Bank Group. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/177891521471973553/Childhood-stunting-in- Tajikistan-quantifying-the-association-with-wash-food-security-health-and-care-practices 47 Lynch, 2005. “The Impact of Iron Fortification on Nutritional Anemia.� 2005. Best Practice & Research Clinical Hematology 18(2): 333-346. Mellow Parenting poster: https://www.mellowparenting.org/wp-content/uploads/2016/06/Tajik- Poster-for-WAIMH-May-16.pdf Ministry of Health and Social Protection [Tajikistan] (MOHSP). 2018. “Annual Statistical Book� Naudeu et al. 2011. “Investing in young children. An early childhood development guide for policy dialogue and project preparation�. World Bank, Washington, DC. Neuman, M., and A. Devercelli. 2013. “What Matters Most for Early Childhood Development: A Framework Paper.� Systems Approach for Better Education Results (SABER) Working Paper No. 5. Washington, DC: World Bank. https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/handle/10986/20174 Save the Children. 2011. “Harmful Traditional Practices in Tajikistan.� Statistical Agency under the President of the Republic of Tajikistan (SA), Ministry of Health [Tajikistan], and ICF International. 2013. “Tajikistan Demographic and Health Survey [DHS] 2012.� Dushanbe, Tajikistan, and Calverton, Maryland, USA: Statistical Agency under the President of the Republic of Tajikistan (SA), Ministry of Health and Social Protection of Population of the Republic of Tajikistan (MOHSP), and ICF International. Statistical Agency under the President of the Republic of Tajikistan, Ministry of Health and Social Protection of Population [Tajikistan], and ICF. 2018. “Tajikistan Demographic and Health Survey 2017: Key Findings.� Rockville, Maryland, USA: Statistical Agency under the President of the Republic of Tajikistan (SA), Ministry of Health and Social Protection of Population of the Republic of Tajikistan (MOHSP), and ICF International. Statistical Agency under the President of the Republic of Tajikistan (SA). “Annual Demographic Yearbook 2017.� Table 22. Life expectancy at specified ages for each sex. https://unstats.un.org/unsd/demographicsocial/products/dyb/documents/dyb2017/table22.pdf UNICEF. 2007. “Vitamin A Supplementation: A Decade of Progress.� https://www.unicef.org/publications/files/Vitamin_A_Supplementation.pdf 48 UNICEF. 2009. “Tracking Progress on Child and Maternal Nutrition: A Survival and Development Priority.� https://www.unicef.org/publications/files/Tracking_Progress_on_Child_and_Maternal_Nutrit ion_EN_110309.pdf UNICEF. 2012. “Causal Analysis of Infant Deaths in Tajikistan.� https://www.unicef.org/tajikistan/Policy_brief__eng_final.pdf UNICEF. 2014. “Causal Analysis of Infant Deaths in Tajikistan in 2012.� https://www.unicef.org/tajikistan/Policy_brief__eng_final.pdf UNICEF. 2016. “National Micronutrient Status Survey in Tajikistan.� Retrieved from: https://www.unicef.org/tajikistan/TNNS_National_Nutrition_Eng-Results_web.pdf UNICEF, 2018a. A National 1000 Golden Days Communication Strategy and Plan 2019-2025. Draft report. UNICEF. 2018b. Marketing of Breast-Milk Substitutes: National Implementation of the International Code Status Report 2018. https://apps.who.int/iris/bitstream/handle/10665/272649/9789241565592-eng.pdf?ua=1 UNDP. 2018. Human Development Indices and Indicators: 2018 Statistical Update Briefing note for countries on the 2018 Statistical Update: Tajikistan. http://hdr.undp.org/sites/all/themes/hdr_theme/country-notes/TJK.pdf World Bank. n.d. International Comparison Program (ICP). Database retrieved from: https://databank.worldbank.org/data/reports.aspx?source=international-comparison-program- (icp)-2011 World Bank. 2011. Tajikistan -- Quality of Child Health Services (English). Washington, DC: World Bank. http://documents.worldbank.org/curated/en/757831468312649552/Tajikistan- Quality-of-child-health-services World Bank. 2013. “Tajikistan Early Childhood Development SABER Country Report.� http://saber.worldbank.org/index.cfm?indx=2&ctrn=TJ World Bank. 2017a. “Poverty Diagnostic of Drinking Water, Sanitation and Hygiene Conditions in Tajikistan.� Washington, D.C. 49 World Bank. 2017b. “Glass Half Full: Poverty Diagnostic of Water Supply, Sanitation, and Hygiene Conditions in Tajikistan.� Washington, D.C. World Bank. 2017c. “Baseline Study for the Impact Evaluation of a Performance Based Financing (PBF) pilot in Tajikistan.� Washington, D.C. World Bank. 2018. Final report: Project for the improvement of nutrition in severely food insecurity districts in Khatlon region. World Bank. 2019a. “Early Childhood Education and Care Analysis: A Focused Review of Preschool Education in Tajikistan.� Washington, DC. World Bank. 2019b. Project Appraisal Document for Rural Water Supply and Sanitation Project. 2019. World Bank, UNICEF. 2012. “Situational Analysis. Improving economic outcomes by expanding nutrition programming in Tajikistan.� World Bank, UNICEF, & AOS. 2018. “Child Poverty in Tajikistan.� Draft as of: 14/5/2018. Retrieved from: http://stat.ww.tj/pages/Child_Poverty_Tajikistan_final.pdf World Food Programme (WFP). 2018. Fill the Nutrient Gap. Tajikistan. Summary Report. Retrieved from: https://docs.wfp.org/api/documents/WFP- 0000099222/download/?_ga=2.73742619.827313761.1554694305-886072713.1549121643 World Health Organization (WHO), 2014. “Evaluation of the structure and provision of Primary care in Tajikistan.� World Health Organization. 2015. “Improving Nutrition Outcomes with Better Water, Sanitation And Hygiene: Practical Solutions for Policy and Programmes.� https://www.who.int/water_sanitation_health/publications/washandnutrition/en/ World Health Organization. 2018. “Infant and Young Child Feeding.� Fact Sheet. https://www.who.int/news-room/fact-sheets/detail/infant-and-young-child-feeding 50