OPERATIONALIZING A MULTI-SECTORAL APPROACH FOR THE REDUCTION OF STUNTING IN INDONESIA This is a summary of a longer report with the same title, produced as part of the Cooperation Agreement between a team in the World Bank and the National Institute of Health Research and Development (NIHRD) of the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Indonesia. The Task Team Leader (TTL) was Emmanuel Skoufias, Lead Economist, Poverty and Equity Global Practice. The World Bank team included: Dr. Eko Setyo Pambudi (Health Analyst), Indira Maulani Hapsari (Research Analyst), Ratih Dwi Rahmadanti (Research Analyst) from the Bank’s Jakarta office, Dr. Katja Vinha (International Consultant), and Dr. Atmarita (International Consultant). The NIHRD team consisted of the following: Dr. Ni Ketut Aryastami (chairman of the NIHRD’s Team), Dr. Ingan Ukur Tarigan (member), Nunik Kusumawardani, PhD (member), Siti Isfandari, MA (member), Prisca Petty Arfines, MPH (member), Olwin Nainggolan, MKM (member), Djunaedi, SKM (member). The teams are grateful to Dr. Siswanto (Head of the NIHRD) for his support throughout the process of this report and to the Bank’s Health and Water teams in Jakarta for useful comments. This report was also was funded by the Water Global Practice and the Research Support Budget (RSB) of the Development Economics Vice Presidency of the World Bank. POLICY BRIEF // FEBRUARY 2017 ii Motivation Stunting is a widespread and persistent condition institutions, aim to foster knowledge exchange and in Indonesia with more than one-third of young cross-sectoral collaboration and coordination at the children being stunted. The national stunting rate project level for improving nutrition (World Bank, for under five-year-olds increased slightly from 2013). As of 2016, the “Investing in the Early Years” 36.8 percent in 2007 to 37.2 percent in 2013, based initiative, adopts a stepwise approach to the nature on official stunting rates reported by the Ministry of intervention needed for the healthy physical and of Health of the Government of Indonesia. During cognitive development of children by emphasizing the same time period, the percentage of population the role of reducing stunting and undernutrition in poverty reduced from 16.6 percent to 11.4 for children in their first 1,000 days of their lives percent (World Bank), suggesting that the increased (including 9 months in utero), the role of education and purchasing power did not translate to better stimulation between 1,000 and 2,000 days and the nutritional outcomes for children. role of social protection for the nutrition and health of children greater than 2,000 days. All these initiatives An acceleration of the progress towards reducing are based on the premise that the determinants of stunting in Indonesia, requires enlisting more sectors, malnutrition are multi-sectoral and that the solution to in addition to the health sector, such as agriculture, malnutrition requires multi-sectoral approaches. education, social protection, and water, sanitation, and hygiene in the effort to improve nutrition. Large scale Indonesia’s commitments to reducing stunting is “nutrition sensitive” interventions in these sectors will evidenced by the wide variety of “nutrition-specific” have to be able not only to address the key underlying and “nutrition-sensitive” interventions. Nutrition- determinants of nutrition effectively, but also specific interventions are in place to address intensify the role of “nutrition-specific” interventions nutritional deficiencies at every point in the life-cycle (Black et al., 2013).1 beginning with folate and calcium supplementation, as well as supplemental feeding for malnourished In recent years there has been a significant increase in pregnant mothers, breastfeeding promotion and the number of initiatives at the international as well counseling for lactating mothers, growth monitoring, as at the county level aiming to scale up nutrition- vitamin A supplementation, iodization, supplemental sensitive interventions. One prominent example is feeding, fortification and therapeutic zinc supplements the Scaling-Up Nutrition (SUN) movement, launched for diarrhea management and deworming prevention in April 2010, whose framework is by now endorsed for children zero to five years of age, continuing by 57 developing countries, including Indonesia, and with immunization and school health programs, over a hundred partners and nearly 3000 community supplemental feeding and the promotion of healthy service organizations that are members of SUN. A street food for school aged children. Finally, number of countries are prioritizing nutrition as an additional nutritional services and reproductive investment in economic and social development. health counseling, along with iron supplementation Along parallel lines, initiatives within the World are available for adolescents and elderly persons Bank and other development agencies and research (Trihono et al. 2015). In parallel, Indonesia has a 1 Nutrition-specific interventions and programs address the immediate determinants of fetal and child nutrition and development- adequate food and nutrient intake, feeding, caregiving and parenting practices, and low burden of infectious diseases. Examples include: adolescent, preconception, and maternal health and nutrition; maternal dietary or micronutrient supplementation; promotion of optimum breastfeeding; complementary feeding and responsive feeding practices and stimulation; dietary supplementation; diversification and micronutrient supplementation or fortification for children; treatment of severe acute malnutrition; disease prevention and management; nutrition in emergencies. Nutrition-sensitive interventions and programs address the underlying determinants of fetal and child nutrition and development-food security; adequate caregiving resources at the maternal, household and community levels; and access to health services and a safe and hygienic environment-and incorporate specific nutrition goals and actions. Nutrition-sensitive programs can serve as delivery platforms for nutrition-specific interventions, potentially increasing their scale, coverage, and effectiveness. Examples include: agriculture and food security; social safety nets; early child development; maternal mental health; women’s empowerment; child protection; schooling; water, sanitation, and hygiene; health and family planning services. Operationalizing a Multi-Sectoral Approach for the Reduction of Stunting iii Design & Methods number of nutrition-sensitive programs in different This report lays the groundwork for more effective sectors that are in the process of being scaled-up. multi-sectoral action on reducing stunting in For example, in the social protection sector, the Indonesia, by operationalizing the UNICEF conceptual PNPM Generasi (National Program for Community framework.2 The UNICEF framework, first proposed Empowerment), and the conditional cash transfer in 1990 (UNICEF, 1990), was one of the first attempts program PKH Prestasi, target the most vulnerable at emphasizing food security, environment, children and women. At the same time the National health, and child care practices as the four main Health Insurance program (JKN) aims to extend health underlying determinants of child malnutrition insurance coverage to the poor and the near poor, in developing countries. A fundamental premise the self-employed, as well as those employed in the of this conceptual framework, is that increases informal sector, consequently, allowing for better in access to adequate services in one or all of the access to healthcare. four drivers of malnutrition, say for example, food security alone, cannot substitute for inadequate The effectiveness and ultimate success of such multi- levels of access to the other determinants. While sectoral approaches towards reducing stunting there is widespread acknowledgment of the four key depends on having a more holistic view of the underlying determinants of nutrition there is limited inequities and gaps in access to adequate levels of the quantitative information on the size and direction of underlying determinants of nutrition: Care, Health, the interdependence among adequate (or inadequate) Environment (or WASH), and Food Security (C H E access to food security, environment, health, and child F). The interdependencies among the underlying care in child nutrition. determinants of nutrition are usually beyond the scope or the control of any given sector. The integration of Indicators for care, for health, for environment, and nutritional considerations in the agricultural sector, for food security are constructed using the 2007 and for example, is unlikely to take into account the fact 2013 RISKEDAS surveys. Each indicator is comprised that water, sanitation and hygiene (W ASH) services of various components based on availability in the and facilities may be poor and inadequate in some survey, with the definition of “adequacy” based on communities. As a consequence, the nutritional national and/or accepted international standards. impacts of such nutrition-sensitive interventions on In consideration of the complexity of the linkages key nutrition outcomes could be impeded considerably between the underlying determinants of malnutrition by the absence of adequate W ASH facilities. On and the economic situation of the family, the analysis the other hand, the impacts of the same nutrition- is also carried out separately for urban and rural sensitive agricultural interventions could be enhanced households, for resource-rich (top 60 per cent) and considerably if they were to be accompanied by resource-poor (bottom 40 per cent) households as well simultaneous improvements in the water and as for districts with high stunting rates and those with sanitation facilities in the same communities. Thus, a low stunting rates. A more holistic view is provided more holistic approach to sector-specific “nutrition- to the extent to which adequate levels of the four key sensitive” interventions is likely to be better able to underlying determinants of nutrition— food security; address the key underlying determinants of nutrition adequate caregiving resources at the maternal, effectively, as well as reinforce the impacts of household and community levels; access to health nutrition-specific interventions. services; and a safe and hygienic environment—on their own as well as in combination are associated with better nutrition as measured by height-for-age z-scores (HAZ) and stunting rates. 2 The same conceptual framework also underpins the IPKM index (Indeks Pembangunan Kesehatan Masyarakat) of the Ministry of Health of the Republic of Indonesia. (IPKM, 2014). The IPKM essentially summarizes all the components of the underlying drivers of nutrition into one index using statistical methods. Policy Brief iv Results In spite of the considerable constraints imposed by wealthier households than poorer households. Slightly data comparability issues across survey years, the less than two-thirds of the mothers of children in the analysis of the trends in access to the four drivers poorest households were seen in prenatal visits (64 of malnutrition reveals that access to most of the percent), 63 per cent of the children were delivered by comparable components of care, health, environment a health care professional or had a post-natal checkup and food security has improved between 2007 and (63 percent), whereas among children in the wealthiest 2013 (Figure I). households, 90 percent were seen in prenatal visits, 98 percent were delivered by a health care professional In spite of the improvements over time, substantial and 88 percent had a post-natal checkup (See Figure inequalities in access between rural and urban areas, III). Along similar lines, in 2013 children living in between districts with high and low stunting rates and rural areas were less likely to have access to adequate between poorer and wealthier households continue to environment than children living in urban areas. persist (Figures II through V). For example, in 2013 the The differences were greater for sanitation measures use of health care facilities was in general greater by than for drinking water. In rural areas, 47 percent FIGURE I. CHANGES IN ACCESS TO THE COMPONENTS OF ADEQUATE, CARE, HEALTH, ENVIRONMENT, AND FOOD SECURITY BETWEEN 2007 AND 2013 Care Health Components of Adequacy in Care Components of adequacy in health National, children less than 60 months National, children less than 60 months Percentage of children who meet criteria Percentage of children who meet criteria Immunizations Mother's handwashing 76 Vitamin A* No smoking 67 72 70 55 62 38 27 30 25 2007 2013 2007 2010 2013 Environment Food Components of Adequacy in Environment - Sanitation Components of Adequacy in Food National, children less than 60 months National, children less than 60 months Percentage of children who meet criteria Percentage of children who meet criteria Improved Mom fruit/vegetable intake Improved Exclusive breastfeeding 64 53 60 44 15 12 2007 2013 2007 2013 Source: Authors’ calculations based on the 2007 and 2013 RISKESDAS. Note: *Only for children 7 months or older Operationalizing a Multi-Sectoral Approach for the Reduction of Stunting v of children had access to basic sanitation whereas in (effectively piped water to the premises), with about urban areas 74 percent had such access (see Figure 11 percent of rural children having access to safely IV). Also, urban children as a whole had better managed water and 30 percent of urban children access to basic sanitation with 62 percent of children having such access. Finally, in 2007, the year in which living in communities where at least 75 percent of this information is available, the consumption of the households had access to basic sanitation, versus calories and protein per adult equivalent in the poorest only 27 percent of rural children. Access to improved households less than in households at the fifth quintile and basic water was relatively high in both areas, of the wealth distribution. Also, only six percent of with about 79 percent of rural children having such the mothers in the poorest households consumed both access and 94 percent of urban children having fruits and vegetables at least five days of the week, access to improved and basic water. However, far whereas 23 percent of the mothers in the highest fewer children had access to safely managed water wealth quintile did so (Figure V). FIGURE II. DIFFERENCES IN ACCESS TO THE COMPONENTS OF ADEQUATE, CARE BETWEEN RURAL AND URBAN AREAS AND ACROSS WEALTH QUINTILES IN 2013 Care by Rural vs. Urban Care by Wealth Quintile Components of Adequacy in Care, 2013 Components of Adequacy in Care, 2013 By urban/rural, children less than 36 months By wealth quantile, children less than 36 months Percentage of children who meet criteria Percentage of children who meet criteria 72 74 73 66 71 66 62 53 53 54 49 49 5050 45 46 44 45 40 38 39 38 37 38 38 36 33 35 36 32 32 26 24 27 23 Rural Urban 1 2 3 4 5 Early breastfeeding* Appropriate breastfeeding* Complementary** Handwashing Smoke-free Source: Authors’ calculations based on the 2007 and 2013 RISKESDAS. Notes: Wealth quintiles calculated by the NIHRD using polychoric prinipal components analysis (pp. 61-62 of 2013 report). FIGURE III. DIFFERENCES IN ACCESS TO THE COMPONENTS OF ADEQUATE HEALTH BETWEEN RURAL AND URBAN AREAS AND ACROSS WEALTH QUINTILES IN 2013 Health by Rural vs. Urban Health by Wealth Quintile Components of Adequacy in Health, 2013 Components of Adequacy in Health, 2013 By urban/rural, children less than 36 months By wealth quantile, children less than 36 months 95 98 94 92 Percentage of children who meet criteria Percentage of children who meet criteria 89 87 89 87 90 88 86 84 81 78 79 81 78 79 80 77 77 76 77 77 67 67 68 70 64 63 63 66 56 57 40 Rural Urban 1 2 3 4 5 Prenatals Assisted Growth Immunizations Vitamin A* Source: Authors’ calculations based on the 2007 and 2013 RISKESDAS. Notes: Wealth quintiles calculated by the NIHRD using polychoric prinipal components analysis (pp. 61-62 of 2013 report) Policy Brief vi A move away from an analysis of the individual the UNICEF conceptual framework that assumes components of the four drivers of malnutrition that increases in access to adequate levels in one towards a more aggregate analysis of differences of the four determinants alone cannot substitute in access to adequate levels in the four drivers for inadequacies in the other three underlying of malnutrition, care, health, environment and determinants. Nevertheless, it is important to bear food security involves a variety of options. In in mind that alternative criteria could be employed. this report, adequate access to care or health or For example, adequate access to care or health or environment or food security is defined as a child environment or food security could be defined as a having adequate access to all of the components of child having adequate access to at least one or at least each of the four drivers of nutrition. Although this two of the components of each of the four drivers of is admittedly a very strict criterion, it is in line with nutrition. Alternatively, different weights could be FIGURE IV. DIFFERENCES IN ACCESS TO THE COMPONENTS OF ADEQUATE ENVIRONMENT BETWEEN RURAL AND URBAN AREAS AND ACROSS WEALTH QUINTILES IN 2013 Environment by Rural vs. Urban Environment by Wealth Quintile Components of Adequacy in Environment, 2013 Components of Adequacy in Environment By urban/rural, children less than 36 months By wealth quantile, in 2013 Percentage of children who meet criteria 94 94 95 97 96 Percentage of children who meet criteria 94 93 9090 79 78 86 74 81 80 74 62 68 64 62 63 47 46 30 35 27 26 26 19 18 11 13 7 2 4 Rural Urban 1 2 3 4 5 Sanitation Basic Community Drinking water Improved Basic Safely managed Source: Authors’ calculations based on the 2007 and 2013 RISKESDAS. Notes: Wealth quintiles calculated by the NIHRD using polychoric prinipal components analysis (pp. 61-62 of 2013 report). FIGURE V. DIFFERENCES IN ACCESS TO THE COMPONENTS OF ADEQUATE FOOD SECURITY BETWEEN RURAL AND URBAN AREAS AND ACROSS WEALTH QUINTILES IN 2013 Food Security by Rural vs. Urban Food Security by Wealth Quintile Components of Adequacy in Food Components of Adequacy in Food By Urban/Rural, children less than 60 months, in 2007 By wealth quintile, children less than 60 months, in 2007 Percentage of children who meet criteria Percentage of children who meet criteria 75 67 69 62 62 65 58 46 47 45 40 41 40 42 43 37 36 37 37 39 33 23 19 16 9 12 7 6 Rural Urban 1 2 3 4 5 Household calories Household protein Exclusively breastfed* Mom fruit/vegetable intake Source: Authors’ calculations based on the 2007 RISKESDAS. Operationalizing a Multi-Sectoral Approach for the Reduction of Stunting vii applied to the distinct components of each nutrition the children had access to adequate care (Figure VI)3. driver, reflecting the preferences, values and/or Similarly, very few children had access to adequate food, information of the policy making authority. with only 14 percent having such access nationally.4 About 56 percent of the children had access to adequate Application of the above mentioned definition for environment or basic drinking water and improved adequate access leads to more stark differences in access sanitation simultaneously. The access to adequate health to adequate access to the four drivers of nutrition. At was also relatively high, at 46 percent.5 In 2013 children the national level, access to adequate care was the living in rural areas were less likely to have access to driver with the lowest prevalence rate and access to all of the four drivers of nutrition than urban children. adequate environment was the driver with the highest The largest discrepancy was in the access to adequate prevalence rate. Nationally only seven percent of environment with only around 40 percent of those FIGURE VI. ACCESS TO ADEQUATE, CARE, HEALTH, ENVIRONMENT AND FOOD SECURITY IN 2013 National Adequacy status in 2013, by National Percentage of children who meet criteria 0 to 36 month olds 56 46 Food Care Environment 14 7 Health Rural vs. Urban Wealth Quintile Adequacy status in 2013, by Urban/Rural Adequacy met in 2013, by Wealth Quantile 0 to 36 month olds 0 to 36 month olds 92 Percentage of children who meet criteria Percentage of children who meet criteria 81 71 62 51 53 53 49 41 41 39 26 27 18 21 17 10 8 8 6 11 8 10 6 5 4 7 1 Rural Urban 1 2 3 4 5 Source: Authors’ calculations based on the 2013 RISKESDAS. Notes: Wealth quintiles calculated by the NIHRD using polychoric prinipal components analysis (pp. 61-62 of 2013 report). 3 Adequate care is defined as mother’s hand washing practices, and whether household is smoke free. For children zero to 23 months of age it also includes immediate breastfeeding after birth, and age appropriate breastfeeding at the time of survey. For children six to eight month of age the additional component of the child receiving complementary feedings is also included 4 Adequate food is based on mother’s fruit and vegetable consumption. For children zero to five months of age it also includes exclusive breast feeding. 5 Access to adequate health is defined by mother having had at least four prenatal checkups, the birth was assisted by a skilled professional, the child was seen at a post-natal checkup, and the child’s immunizations are up to date. For children 7 to 35 months of age the additional condition of having received vitamin A supplementation is added. Policy Brief viii in rural areas having access and around 70 percent of The low proportions of children with simultaneous those in urban areas having access (Figure VI). Adequate access to more than one of the drivers of nutrition access to environment is also the nutrition driver with suggests that the integration of nutritional the largest differences by wealth quintiles. Only one considerations in any given sector may have percent of the children in the lowest wealth quintile had nutritional impacts that are limited primarily by access to adequate environment whereas in the highest inadequate access to the underlying drivers of quintile 92 percent of the children had access to an nutrition. The recent emphasis on sector-specific adequate environment (Figure VI). nutrition sensitive interventions (World Bank, 2013) rightly emphasizes the synergies that can be A more austere picture emerges through an analysis of exploited within specific sectors such agriculture, the extent to which children have simultaneous access water and sanitation, or social protection. These to two or more of the four underlying determinants findings suggest that the success of uncoordinated or of nutrition. In 2013, 23 per cent of the children isolated sector-specific nutrition-sensitive initiatives between 0 and 3 years of age did not have access to may be constrained by inadequate access to the adequate level in any of the four determinants of four underlying determinants of malnutrition: food nutrition. In 2007, this fraction was 39 per cent. On security, child care, environment, and health. the other end, less than 1 per cent of children had access simultaneously to all four key underlying The preceding argument is reinforced by the result determinants of nutrition (see Figure VII). These that simultaneous access to two or more of the four key differences in simultaneous access to two or more determinants of nutrition is associated with a decrease drivers become larger between rural and urban areas in the likelihood of a child being stunted (see Figures and by quantile of wealth. VIII and IX). The likelihood that children between FIGURE VII. SIMULTANEOUS ACCESS TO ADEQUATE LEVELS OF TWO OR MORE OF THE FOUR DRIVES OF MALNUTRITION IN 2013 National Percentage of children who meet criteria Adequacies status in 2013, National Adequate in none 0 to 36 month olds Adequate in 1 of 4 Adequate in 2 of 4 Adequate in 3 of 4 38 Adequate in all 4 30 23 8 1 Rural vs. Urban Wealth Quintile Number of adequacies met in 2013, By urban/rural Number of adequacies met in 2013, By wealth quantile Percentage of children who meet criteria Percentage of children who meet criteria 0 to 36 month olds 0 to 36 month olds 68 42 42 44 39 42 43 37 38 36 34 33 33 29 23 16 18 13 12 14 8 11 5 4 2 0 6 3 0 1 00 1 1 2 Rural Urban 1 2 3 4 5 Source: Authors’ calculations based on the 2013 RISKESDAS. Notes: Wealth quintiles calculated by the NIHRD using polychoric prinipal components analysis (pp. 61-62 of 2013 report). Operationalizing a Multi-Sectoral Approach for the Reduction of Stunting ix 0 and 36 months of age are stunted is lower when top 60 percent of the wealth distribution (Figure IX). children have simultaneous access to adequate levels Yet, for children in households at the B40 percent of to two of the four drivers of nutrition and even lower the distribution of the asset index, the relationship among children with simultaneous access to adequate between access to the four drivers of nutrition and levels to three of the four drivers of nutrition (Figure stunting rates appears to break down. Simultaneous VIII). Specifically, access to adequate level in only one access to one or two or three or all four of the drivers nutrition driver is associated with a reduction in the of nutrition does not appear to be associated with any stunting rate by 5.2 percentage points relative to the significant decline in the stunting rates of children, stunting rate of 41.4 percent in the reference group also evidenced by the fact that the confidence interval of children without access to adequate level in any of lines cross the vertical red line at the zero percent the four drivers of nutrition. Simultaneous access to point difference in the stunting rate. This result could adequate level in any two of the drivers of nutrition be due to the relatively lower quality of services that is associated with a reduction in the stunting rate by could be accessible by households with lower income. 8.9 percentage points, whereas simultaneous access to adequate level in any three of the drivers of nutrition All in all, these results validate the importance of is associated with a reduction in the stunting rate coordinated multi-sectoral policies and suggest that by 13.4 percentage points, both in comparison to the the success of “sector-specific nutrition-sensitive” stunting rate of 41.4 percent in the reference group initiatives can be enhanced by better coordination (Figure VIII).6 More importantly, the same overall and integration of multi-sectoral interventions pattern appears to hold separately in rural and urban that address effectively the four underlying areas as well as for children in households at the determinants of nutrition. FIGURE VIII. SIMULTANEOUS ACCESS TO DRIVERS OF NUTIRITION AND THE PROBABILITY OF BEING STUNTED: 2013 Difference in Probability of Being Stunted, 2013 National, Relative to the Reference Group -0.052 One Nutrition Drivers -0.089 Two -0.134 Three -0.109 Four -0.200 -0.150 -0.100 -0.050 0.000 Percentage point difference in stunting rate Source: Authors’ calculations based on the 2013 RISKESDAS. Note: Showing point estimates and 95% CI. Reference group: Children with access to none, p=.414 6 Simultaneous access to adequate level in all four drivers of nutrition is associated with a reduction in the stunting rate by 10.9 percentage points which is between the reduction in the stunting rate observed for simultaneous access to two and three of the drivers of nutrition. This low point estimate may be mainly due to the very small number of children in this category (less than 1%), also associated with the large confidence interval around this point estimate. Policy Brief x FIGURE IX. SIMULTANEOUS ACCESS TO DRIVERS OF NUTIRITION AND THE PROBABILITY OF BEING STUNTED: 2013 Rural, Relative to the Reference Group Urban, Relative to the Reference Group -0.052 -0.015 One One Nutrition Drivers Nutrition Drivers -0.073 -0.056 Two Two -0.104 -0.096 Three Three -0.070 -0.071 Four Four -0.200 -0.100 0.000 0.100 -0.200 -0.150 -0.100 -0.050 0.000 0.050 Percentage point difference in stunting rate Percentage point difference in stunting rate Children in B40, Relative to the Reference Group Children in T60, Relative to the Reference Group -0.029 -0.012 One One Nutrition Drivers Nutrition Drivers -0.017 -0.041 Two Two -0.047 -0.081 Three Three -0.083 -0.051 Four Four -0.400 -0.200 0.000 0.200 0.400 -0.150 -0.100 -0.050 0.000 0.050 Percentage point difference in stunting rate Percentage point difference in stunting rate Source: Authors’ calculations based on the 2013 RISKESDAS. Note: Showing point estimates and 95% CI. Reference group: Children with access to none, p=.414 Operationalizing a Multi-Sectoral Approach for the Reduction of Stunting xi Policy Considerations The operationalization of the UNICEF conceptual Targeting and tailoring: The above also suggests that framework in this report offers the opportunity of “one size fits all” multi-sectoral programs are not likely serving as a basis for a more systematic monitoring of to be as effective as multi-sectoral programs that are the progress in access to the four main drivers of child tailored and targeted to specific age groups, specific malnutrition. It also serves as a practical diagnostic locations and/or low wealth groups. Investments in framework for identifying potential “binding nutrition-specific and nutrition-sensitive interventions constraints” in the Indonesian context towards the should focus on areas where access to adequate effort to reduce child stunting and malnutrition. levels in the four drivers of nutrition is relatively less prevalent. Measurement drives diagnosis and response: The analysis carried out highlights numerous critical Better coordination and integration: Progress towards data gaps in key components of the four underlying reducing stunting in Indonesia can be enhanced by determinants of child malnutrition. For example, coordinated multi-sectoral interventions that address the 2013 RISKESDAS survey, the one and only effectively the four key underlying determinants of survey containing anthropometric measures for nutrition. The poor performance of multi-sectoral children and adults at the national as well as at the projects in nutrition and health across the world district level does not include variables useful for provides the opportunity to learn a lot from the quantifying key components of food security, such as failures of the past, especially when it comes to setting dietary diversity and consumption or availability of the clarity of objectives and the role and responsibility calories and proteins. On the other hand, the annual of each sector involved in the renewed effort to reduce SUSENAS survey which collects these important stunting Indonesia. Clarity and prior agreement on variables but only at the household level, contains no the common yardstick to be used among the different information on child anthropometric measures and is sectors involved can lead to significant improvements relatively weaker in measures of child care. A more in the efficiency and efficacy of policies against child coordinated approach to data collection that closes undernutrition. the gaps in information collected by nutrition-related and other socio-economic surveys in Indonesia can have substantial benefits for efforts aimed at reducing child stunting through a more informed and better coordinated multi-sectoral approach. Context matters: The probability of being stunted with simultaneous access to two or more of the four underlying determinants of nutrition, varies by the wealth status of the household, and rural and urban areas. xii References Black, R.E., C.G. Victora, S.P. Walker, Z.A. Bhutta, P. Christian, M. de Onis, M. Ezzati, S. Grantham- McGegor, J. Katz, R. Martorell, R. Uauy, and the Maternal and Child Nutrition Study Group, (2013) “Maternal and Child Undernutrition and Overweight in Low-Income and Middle-Income Countries, The Lancet, 382 (Issue 9890): 427-51. http://dx.doi. org/10.1016/S0140-6736(13)60937-X IPKM (2014) Indeks Pembangunan Kesehatan Masyarakat 2013. –Jakarta : Badan Penelitian dan Pengembangan Kesehatan. 2014 Trihono et al. (2015) “Pendek (Stunting) di Indonesia, Masalah dan Solusinya,” Jakarta: Badan Penelitian dan Pengembangan Kesehatan. UNICEF (1990). “Strategy for Improved Nutrition of Children and Women in Developing Countries.” WHO (2007). “Standards for Maternal and Neonatal Care.” Department of Making Pregnancy Safer. Accessed March 2016 from http://apps.who.int/iris/ bitstream/10665/69735/1/a91272.pdf. WHO (2008). “Indicators for assessing infant and young child feeding practices – part I: definition.” Accessed March 2016 from http://www.who.int/maternal_ child_adolescent/documents/9789241596664/en/. WHO/UNICEF Joint Monitoring Program for Water Supply and Sanitation (2015). “JMP Green Paper: Global monitoring of water, sanitation and hygiene post-2025,” Draft, Updated October 2015. Accessed on March 24, 2016 from http://www.wssinfo.org/ fileadmin/user_upload/resources/JMP-Green-Paper- 15-Oct-2015.pdf. World Bank (2013). “Improving Nutrition Through Multisectoral Approaches.” Washington, DC, The World Bank. Operationalizing a Multi-Sectoral Approach for the Reduction of Stunting