The economic and social consequences of the debt crisis on child wellbeing A presentation to the Global Management Team UNICEF October 2024 Our objectives today Become more aware of social data and analytical tools available and needed in SD Reflect together on how Global can support MENA (and sharing some D&A resources – end of the PPT) What are we trying to achieve with social data and analytics? Our analytical work creates a deeper understanding of how social issues affect development and growth in order to: Influence strategic priorities of the Bank (in SCDs, CCDRs, CPFs) Influence national policy dialogue in the countries where we work Inform WB lending – including (but not only) through ESF and operations 1. Our work on social data and analytics How Data & Analytics supports SSI business lines Country and regional team’s analytical work Social opportunities Inclusive Resilient Empowered and risks Societies Communities People • ESF Streamlining and • Country inclusion SSI • Scaling up community • Launch of new GPSA Implementation Support diagnostics platforms in FCV • Portfolio approach CE • Country Systems for Social • Scale up on WEE and • Scaling up locally-led climate • Green Accountability Risk Management Gender (GBV) programs (ER, FLOCCA, • Social Dimensions of • EQOSOGI just transition, etc.) ESG/Sustainable Finance. • Youth • Capacity building to Ips for climate/nature D&A GSG product Country Social Diagnostics Measuring Social Sustainability Customized Analytics lines (plus inclusive data and indicators) D&A GSG Country Team Support Global Public Goods functions Final Input/Influence SCDs, CPFs, CCDRs, DPOs, Projects, Flagships, ASAs Objective EXPANSION INCEPTION Country Diagnostics (sec gen) Global >>Country>>Project BUILDING UP Global • No systematic and Data Toolkit v.2.0 Data Toolkit v.1.0 SS Global Database 2.0 Automatized Data Toolkit consolidated data on SS indicators and vulnerable Guidelines Visualization Dashboard 2.0 Integrated framework and metrics of SS 5-YEAR PLAN populations. SS Global Database 1.0 Open codes in Git-Hub and Poverty piloted in 2 countries • Lack of a conceptual Visualization Dashboard 1.0 Microlevel SS indicators for 150 Country + Project framework on SS. Microlevel SS indicators/index (pilot) countries Mixed-methods country diagnostics • No country diagnostics Country Diagnostics (first gen) Inputs for CCDR’s (10 countries) piloted in 3 countries) Conceptual Framework NOV JUN JUN JUN 2019 2021 2023 2023 2025 2028 UPTAKE OF DIVERSE DATA AND ANALYTICS GP-WIDE CONSULTATION CAPACITY BUILDING TTL Demand Identified products that will Training serve regional PM’s and GL’s Dissemination KM Management PREPARATION & DELIVERY INNOVATION CAPACITY CONSOLIDATION AND EXPANSION PILOTING BUILDING SSI GP acknowledged as an All new social data initiatives are equal partner in social data easily tracked and shared across collection & analytics the Bank SSI GP provides agile analytical Social Sustainability Global solutions for country needs Database and Project level Database are frequently updated and have wide uptake SSI GP addresses effectively emerging corporate needs (project indicators, Social sustainability data is fully scorecard….) integrated in mainstream sources (e.g., WDI) More and better coordination, starting within SSI GP 1. Our work on social data and analytics Never have we had so much social data ADD HERE WORLD BANK PICTURES ON ANUA MEETINGS DATA AND DATA GAPS 1. Our work on social data and analytics Never have we had so much social data World Bank is known for producing poverty data and being a custodian of some SDG 1 Targets but there is so much more we do in terms of social data 1. Our work on social data and analytics Cutting-edge data generation methods are pushing the evidence frontier Big Data & Machine Learning for real-time monitoring High-frequency phone surveys to monitor the impact of and predicting demand and supply service provision COVID-19 across countries gaps among displaced populations in Ukraine FOOD SECURITY In the last 30 days, was anyone unable to eat healthy/nutritious or preferred food due to lack of resources (% of HHs) Source: High-Frequency Phone Survey Period: 2020 Fewer social sustainability indicators Not all the many social indicators capture our components of social sustainability No reason for complacency No reason for complacency 1. Our work on social data and analytics Social analytics vary widely in terms of topics addressed, the complexity of methods used, and resources needed Deep dives Rapid social analyses 1. Our work on social data and analytics Examples of SSI country diagnostics Rapid Social Analysis Deep Dives Thematic Notes Overviews Thematic in-depth SSI Core ESF Overview analysis Diagnostics Assessments Disability Inclusion in Romania SCD Institutional GBV India SSI Diagnostic E& S Borrower Jamaica Background note on prevention gaps in GBV 2022, 36 pages Framework Assessment 2022, 12 pages Roma inclusion portfolio review Liberia in Georgia 2018, 15 pages 2019, 91 pages 2022, 59 pages Identifies national entry Provides an overview of Recommends key It identified groups at risk of Described key gaps between points to strengthen the existing data around Roma interventions and risk exclusion in the country and existing environmental and inclusion of persons with exclusion across different management measures to combined it with an analysis social legislation and disabilities in Jamaica. sectors. be integrated in projects to of how relevant to the India practices and ESF address key risks with the portfolio. standards. Recommended potential to contribute how to fill gaps. towards SEA/GBV. Impact Impact Impact Impact Impact Prepared to accompany the It was used to feed into the Provided evidence on It helped identify priority Led to the improvement of operationalization of the SCD and CFP. institutional GBV prevention areas for work under the land registration and regional report Disability gaps and informed the Gender and Inclusion valuation & the inclusion of a Inclusion in Latin America engagement with client and Platform. trigger in the Green and and the Caribbean : A Path CMU on the Liberia Women Resilient Growth DPO to To Sustainable Development Empowerment Project adopt a Law on Biodiversity (2021).  Influence strategic  Influence strategic  Influence strategic  Influence strategic  Inform WB lending priorities priorities priorities priorities  Inform WB lending  Influence national policy  Influence national policy  Influence national policy dialogue dialogue dialogue  Inform WB lending 1. Our work on social data and analytics EXAMPLES Deep Dives | SSI Core Diagnostics First Generation Second Generation SSI Country Profile/Diagnostic Uses of the product SSI Country Profile/Diagnostic Uses of the product • 1 Cameroon CMR CMU SCD/CPF CCDR • 23 Peru Ongoing Pilot/ASA • 2 Ghana GHA CMU CPF CCDR • 24 South Africa ZAF CCDR Pilot/ASA • 3 Nigeria NGA CMU • 25 Madagascar MDG CCDR • 4 Cambodia KHM CCDR • 26 Namibia NAM CCDR • 5 Mongolia MNG CCDR • 27 Bots wana BSW CCDR • 6 Vietnam VNM CCDR • 28 Cameroon CMR CCDR • 7 Bosnia & Herzegovina WBA CMU • 8 Kosovo WBA CMU • 29 Cote d'Ivoire CIV CCDR • 9 Montenegro WBA CMU • 30 Dem Rep Congo DRC CCDR • 10 North Macedonia WBA CMU • 31 Gabon GAB CCDR • 11 Serbia WBA CMU • 32 Senegal SEN CCDR • 12 Türkiye TUR CMU CCDR • 33 Sierra Leone SLE CCDR • 13 Brazil BRA CMU • 14 Mexico MEX CMU ASA • 15 Egypt EGY Pilot • 16 Iraq IRQ CMU Dialog • 17 Tunisia TUN Pilot • 18 Bangladesh BAN CMU • 19 India KERALA Pilot • 20 Nepal NPL CMU • 21 Sri Lanka LKA CMU • 22 Maldives MLD CPF ASA 1. Our work on social data and analytics Applied analytics: country core diagnostics Bangladesh Social Sustainability and Inclusion Profile 2022 Prevalence of IPV & Child Marriage in Bangladesh Vs. South Asian Countries 1. Our work on social data and analytics Applied analytics: country core diagnostics Who are the excluded and why? Quantifying Vulnerable Groups in Bangladesh c. 2020 Drivers of exclusion in Mongolia, selected groups Changes over time Changes of selected social sustainability indicators in Egypt, 2017-2020 Arrows indicate trend since 2013-2016 1. Our work on social data and analytics Deep Dives | Peru 2nd Generation SSI Diagnostics Key findings Share of population with social Gaps in Peru, % 21.9 Million or 67% of the population have multiple social gaps (million of people) (at least in 1/3 of dimensions considered) Equality before the law 28.7 million On average, Peruvians report social gaps in half of the social dimensions Process Government effectiveness 24.8 considered Legitimacy Satisfaction with democracy 19.5 (that is, 7-8 out of 16 considered) Civil participation 19.0 Gender and ethnicity matter: 69% of women and 85% of IPs in Peru have multiple social gaps Confidence on government institutions 14.9 (65% of men and 62% of non-natives) Perception of safety 4.2 Social Cohesion Experience of discrimination 3.8 For every poor in Peru there are 2.5 individuals with social gaps Victim of crime 1.0 (90% of the poor in Peru also have multiple social gaps) National policies focus on access to labor markets, investments in quality Public assistance 15.8 public services, and more flexible social protection based on individuals Resilience Quality of housing 7.8 as mere workers, consumers and taxpayers Possession of assets 7.3 Level playing field in labor markets (shared parental leave, quality childcare), Capacity for saving 6.1 combat GBV effectively, inclusion and social protection of refugees), transparency for legitimate reforms Quality of employment 24.2 Social Medical attention 15.5 While the Bank's current portfolio reflects some consideration for social Inclusion sustainability, there is ample room for improvement and a systematic Level of education 12.8 approach Access to water, sanitation, electricity & internet 6.2 Increase the financial inclusion among women, mainstream the process for 0% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90%100% issuing land rights to Indigenous Peoples, or encourage the consultation with Ballon and Cuesta (2023). Measuring Social Sustainability a Multidimensional Approach women's social organizations in the preparation of community risk management Benchmarking SOCIAL COHESION IN CHILE (%) compared to regional (LAC) & global averages DON´T LIKE DON´T LIKE HOMOSEXUALS HOMOSEXUALS AS NEIGHBORS CHILE AS NEIGHBORS 47% GLOBAL 28% LAC 29% 28% 42% 42% TRUST IN CONFIDENCE TRUST IN CONFIDENCE PEOPLE 20% 57% IN THE POLICE PEOPLE 13% 47% IN THE POLICE 11% 13% 36% 36% 33% 45% CONFIDENCE IN CONFIDENCE IN GOVERNMENT GOVERNMENT 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 10% 20% 30% 40% 50% 60% 70% 80% 90% 100% 100% 0% 0% Source: World Values Survey, Waves 6 & 7 (2014 & 2020) 1. Our work on social data and analytics Making the case for social sustainability Going beyond monetary poverty and inequality in Sub-Saharan Africa 1. Our work on social data and analytics Positioning in global issues (ESG) Social sustainability and ESG are strongly correlated Source: Sovereign ESG Database and Social Sustainability Global Database 1. Our work on social data and analytics Making the case for social sustainability Social sustainability correlated with more equal and more cohesive societies 1. Our work on social data and analytics Applied analytics: CCDRs Climatic risks and social sustainability in Vietnam circa 2020 (included in Vietnam CCDR 2022) 1. Our work on social data and analytics Contributing to country analytical demands Philippines IP report “No Data, No Story�: Land, Conflict, and IP analysis Source: Madrigal, Cuesta and Sommerville, 2023 Supporting operations (RF, M&E): Uganda anti-homosexual bill mitigation enhanced M&E INPUT AND PROCESS IMPLEMENTATION INTERMEDIATE OUTCOMES OUTCOMES INDICATORS (for verification in November) 1) % increase in the 1) Number of projects retrofitted (and share of 1) Percentage of project beneficiaries who are aware of the GRM and understand how to use it intention of GOU officials the portfolio), and mitigation measures in place in each project retrofitted without fear of retaliation to reduce discrimination in 2) Number of grievance cases reported or 2) Percentage of grievance cases resolved within the GRM system their activities referred by project beneficiaries officially handled by the GRM system 3) Percentage of grievance cases reporting to be 2) % increase in the 3) Number of awareness sessions with CSOs treated with confidentiality, safely and respectfully perception of 4) % of contractors and service providers with codes of conduct signed 4) Percentage of counterpart government units confidentiality among that had supported mitigation measures beneficiaries of WB 5) % of contractors and service providers with contracts clauses on inclusion projects? 6) Number of counterpart government officials that participated in capacity building training * Data collected through the GOU officials and project * Data collected through the GRM system, project beneficiaries’ surveys beneficiaries’ surveys, and follow-up tests during Data collected through project implementation and GRM systems the capacitation training. 26 Theory of Change of EISM Counterpart government The timely officials from resolution of multiple line M&E produces grievances in Bank ministries adopt projects and real-time evidence increased interventions on the awareness among aiming at reducing implementation of counterparts on the mitigation evidence-based exclusion measures and benefits of periodic inclusion improve information the government’s actions toward (quarterly) on the adopting inclusion effects of those measures measures Input and process Intermediate outcome Outcome indicators on indicators ensuring the indicators on grievance planned change in M&E is in place, working, resolution, satisfaction, and monitoring the perceptions and behaviors adequate implementation awareness, and acceptance toward inclusion of mitigation measures of inclusion Social Sustainability Global Database and dashboard 2.0 Social Sustainability Global Dashboard 1. Our work on social data and analytics Project level indicators How many project level indicators do you think there exist available to a SD TTL? Social sustainability project level indicators database Social Sustainability Project-level Indicators Global Database Version October 2024 Results Indicator Type of project P code Name Region Country Primary Thematic Area Secondary thematic areas Framework Philippines National Community Social Sustainability and % increase in access toroads, education, healthcenters and water (majorKC investments) in KC-NCDDP municipalities(Percentage) PDO CDD P127741 EAP Philippines Driven Development Program Inclusion Philippines National Community Social Sustainability and % of households in NCDDPmunicipalities with at leastone member attendingregular BarangayAssemblies (Percentage) PDO CDD P127741 EAP Philippines Driven Development Program Inclusion Philippines National Community Social Sustainability and % of members frommarginalized groups(women and IP) in KC-NCDDP municipalities whoattend regular BarangayAssemblies (Percentage) PDO CDD P127741 EAP Philippines Driven Development Program Inclusion Philippines National Community Social Sustainability and % of members fromfemale headedhouseholds KC-NCDDPmunicipalities whoattend regular barangayassemblies (Percentage) PDO CDD P127741 EAP Philippines Driven Development Program Inclusion Philippines National Community Social Sustainability and % of members from IPhouseholds in KC-NCDDPmunicipalities whoattend regular barangayassemblies (Percentage) PDO CDD P127741 EAP Philippines Driven Development Program Inclusion Philippines National Community Social Sustainability and Direct project beneficiaries(Number) Intermediate CDD P127741 EAP Philippines Driven Development Program Inclusion 1. Our work on social data and analytics Project level indicators Consensus core indicators Project levelSet An Extended of Core Project level indicators indicator Type Score Card Beneficiaries in project target areas provided with improved access to socio-economic services and infrastructure (broken down by females, youth and [1-3,12] [1] forcibly displaced) (Number) CDD [17] [1-3,12] [1]b Number of beneficiaries with access to social and economic services and infrastructure (Number) CDD [17] Beneficiaries receiving social and health services (disaggregated by psychosocial & life skills counselling, medical & educational services, economic [1-3,12] [1]c support, women, accompanied girls, at-risk boys) (Number) CDD [17] [1-3,12] [1]d Mental health beneficiaries receiving psychosocial services and support (disaggregated by gender) (Number) CDD [17] [2] Number of community-based livelihoods initiatives implemented in target villages CDD [1-3,12] [2]b Vulnerable communities benefiting from the project (Number), of which affected by FCV (%), of which affected by climate-related shocks (%) CDD [1-3,12] [2]c Improved community infrastructures (Number), of which through a community-driven development (CDD) approach (%) CDD [1-3,12] [1-3,12] [3] Percentage of individuals from the project areas that report project investments reflected their needs (Percentage) CDD [17] [1-3,12] Beneficiaries that feel project investments reflected their needs (percentage) (Percentage), of which female refugees (Number) CDD [3]b [17] IPAMs in beneficiary territories that feel project investments reflect development priorities/needs established during planning process (disaggregated [1-3,12] [3]c by P/N and gender) (Percentage) CDD [17] [4] Percentage of beneficiaries (social entrepreneurs and employees) whose earnings have increased as a result of project interventions (Percentage) CDD [19] [5] Number of new or better jobs created (Number) CDD [19] [6] New bank accounts opened or reactivated as result of the project by women (%) CDD [18] [7] Percentage of beneficiares in target communities who report enhanced trust as a result of the project support CDD [20] [7] b Increase in social cohesion among project beneficiaries (Percentage) CDD [20] Percentage of refugees and host community beneficiaries reporting that project activities have improved cooperation between refugees and host [8] communities (Percentage) CDD [20] Percentage of youth beneficiaries reporting greater community cohesion, tolerance at community level and positive relationship with other groups [8]b (e.g. with IDPs and vice versa) CDD [20] [8]c Percentage of beneficiaries taking a more active role in their communities - disabled, female CDD [20] [8]d Policy dialogue on human mobility management supported. Dialog [20] 3. How do we move forward (together)? What has worked best for you in your work doing D&A? I want to hear from you!  What type of assessment do you use most, and why?  Considering costs and budgets, what is the most likely type of data and analytical cost you will work on this FY?  What do you think we (SD GD) need to do more of:  A: More country diagnostics  B. More customized analytics  C. Only support to operations  D. Other Resources Resources SSI GSG Webpage: Data Analytics and Digital - Home (sharepoint.com) Social Sustainability Global Database: https://public.tableau.com/app/profile/social.sustainability.and.inclusion.world.bank/viz/SSGDv2_0/TableofContents?p ublish=yes Social Sustainability in Development: Social Sustainability in Development: Meeting the Challenges of the 21st Century (worldbank.org) Social sustainability country diagnostics: see links in presentation Key Bibliography: o Social sustainability indices: https://openknowledge.worldbank.org/server/api/core/bitstreams/7fa68bc0-777f-5a9a- 898f-9985292075f9/content o Global estimates of people at risk of exclusion: Social Exclusion: Concepts, Measurement, and a Global Estimate (worldbank.org) o Social and environmental sustainability’s linkages: sustainability-15-03260-v2 (1).pdf o Machine learning in social analysis: Citizen Participation and Political Trust in Latin America and the Caribbean: A Machine Learning Approach (worldbank.org) 3. How do we move forward (together)? Examples of SSI country diagnostics Rapid Social Analysis Deep Dives Thematic Notes Overviews Thematic in-depth SSI Core ESF Overview analysis Diagnostics Assessments Disability Inclusion in Romania SCD Institutional GBV India SSI Diagnostic E& S Borrower Jamaica Background note on prevention gaps in GBV 2022, 36 pages Framework Assessment 2022, 12 pages Roma inclusion portfolio review Liberia in Georgia 2018, 15 pages 2019, 91 pages 2022, 59 pages Identifies national entry Provides an overview of Recommends key It identified groups at risk of Described key gaps between points to strengthen the existing data around Roma interventions and risk exclusion in the country and existing environmental and inclusion of persons with exclusion across different management measures to combined it with an analysis social legislation and disabilities in Jamaica. sectors. be integrated in projects to of how relevant to the India practices and ESF address key risks with the portfolio. standards. Recommended potential to contribute how to fill gaps. towards SEA/GBV. Impact Impact Impact Impact Impact Prepared to accompany the It was used to feed into the Provided evidence on It helped identify priority Led to the improvement of operationalization of the SCD and CFP. institutional GBV prevention areas for work under the land registration and regional report Disability gaps and informed the Gender and Inclusion valuation & the inclusion of a Inclusion in Latin America engagement with client and Platform. trigger in the Green and and the Caribbean : A Path CMU on the Liberia Women Resilient Growth DPO to To Sustainable Development Empowerment Project adopt a Law on Biodiversity (2021).  Influence strategic  Influence strategic  Influence strategic  Influence strategic  Inform WB lending priorities priorities priorities priorities  Inform WB lending  Influence national policy  Influence national policy  Influence national policy dialogue dialogue dialogue  Inform WB lending 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics Social analytics vary widely in terms of topics addressed, the complexity of methods used, and resources needed Rapid Social Analysis • Overviews: short, 8-10 pages, qualitative assessments of key social gaps in a specific context (e.g., during COVID) Thematic In-depth Analysis • Thematic Notes: short, 10-15 pages, providing basic information on a particular topic, e.g., gender, Gender-Based Violence, land acquisition stats, or disability, SOGI, IPEMs Deep Dives SSI Core Diagnostics • SSI Core Diagnostics: medium-size reports, 20-30 pages quantifying vulnerable populations and profiling, ESF Overview Assessments benchmarking, and discussing drivers around key social Resources (time, $, staff) issues (e.g., Bangladesh) short, 10-page notes, quantifying, profiling, analyzing the intersection of social gaps with closer links to Bank portfolio (Peru) • Thematic In-depth Analysis: long (~50-100 pages), dedicated reports on specific themes with original data Thematic Notes and/or analytics such as for example, IPs, Land Titling, and Conflict in the Philippines; Exclusion report in Nepal and Vietnam; Resettlement or Labor Profiles, Gender Overviews Assessments in AFR and SAR. LCR Afro-Descendants report • ESF Overview Assessments: Country-level analysis that Complexity compares national legislation, systems, and practices with (objectives, coverage, methods, data) ESF standards as a benchmark for best practice.` 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics A typology of SSI country diagnostics Rapid Social Analysis often based on secondary data/ desk-based analysis e.g. Rapid Social notes produced across SOGI country briefs LAC & in SAR during Covid Disability Inclusion Country Notes in LAC IP country briefs Input notes to SCDs, CCDRs FCV security assessments Broad Focused on a specific group overview identifying or SSI thematic multiple groups areas across different Gender in-depth studies Inclusion deep dives dimensions (markets, services, SDCC background notes/ ESF-Overview spaces) LLCA studies Assessments Country Gender Assessments (CGA) CESA Enabling Conditions Analysis FCV deep dives SSI core diagnostics Forced Displacement and (available for 30+ countries to date) Social Cohesion Studies Deep Dives - In-depth analysis & larger ASAs often including primary (qualitative or mixed) data collection 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics Examples of SSI country diagnostics Rapid Social Analysis Deep Dives Thematic Notes Overviews Thematic in-depth SSI Core ESF Overview analysis Diagnostics Assessments Disability Inclusion in Romania SCD Institutional GBV India SSI Diagnostic E& S Borrower Jamaica Background note on prevention gaps in GBV 2022, 36 pages Framework Assessment 2022, 12 pages Roma inclusion portfolio review Liberia in Georgia 2018, 15 pages 2019, 91 pages 2022, 59 pages Identifies national entry Provides an overview of Recommends key It identified groups at risk of Described key gaps between points to strengthen the existing data around Roma interventions and risk exclusion in the country and existing environmental and inclusion of persons with exclusion across different management measures to combined it with an analysis social legislation and disabilities in Jamaica. sectors. be integrated in projects to of how relevant to the India practices and ESF address key risks with the portfolio. standards. Recommended potential to contribute how to fill gaps. towards SEA/GBV. Impact Impact Impact Impact Impact Prepared to accompany the It was used to feed into the Provided evidence on It helped identify priority Led to the improvement of operationalization of the SCD and CFP. institutional GBV prevention areas for work under the land registration and regional report Disability gaps and informed the Gender and Inclusion valuation & the inclusion of a Inclusion in Latin America engagement with client and Platform. trigger in the Green and and the Caribbean : A Path CMU on the Liberia Women Resilient Growth DPO to To Sustainable Development Empowerment Project adopt a Law on Biodiversity (2021).  Influence strategic  Influence strategic  Influence strategic  Influence strategic  Inform WB lending priorities priorities priorities priorities  Inform WB lending  Influence national policy  Influence national policy  Influence national policy dialogue dialogue dialogue  Inform WB lending 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics EXAMPLES Rapid Social Analysis | Overviews FCV Security Assessments Rapid Social notes Rapid Social Myanmar MIPSnotes Security Rapid Social Romania SCD notes Background Honduras Update to Rapid Assessment Brotherhood note on Roma inclusion Social Assessment Alliance assaults Shan (2018, 15 pages) (2021, 9 pages) North (2023, 19 pages) Provides an overview of Presents a 2021 update existing data around of the current context Roma exclusion across and outlines any different sectors. available data and existing government's Impact programs and policies to It was used to feed into tackle the impacts of the the SCD and CFP. pandemic, esp. with a view to whether specific measures have been taken to mitigate the impacts of the pandemic on persons in vulnerable situations; and (iii) lay out SSI's priorities for FY22. 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics EXAMPLES Rapid Social Analysis | Thematic Notes Short thematic notes Disability Inclusion in Nigeria: Disability Inclusion in Female Labor Force Why Measuring Energy A Rapid Assessment Jamaica Participation in India: What Access for Women Makes (2020) (2022, 12 pages) Does the Research Tell Us? Smart Business - Lao PDR (2020, 20 pages) (2017, 6 pages). Rapid assessment of Identifies national entry Summarizes existing Summarizes lessons socio-economic points to strengthen the literature on the reasons learned from the EAP exclusion of persons inclusion of persons with for the low FLFP rate Gender and Energy with disability in Nigeria, disabilities in Jamaica. and provides Facility. drivers of exclusion and disaggregated data by the policy environment. Impact region and demographic Produced through the Prepared to characteristics to identify SSI Social inclusion accompany the regional dynamics that platform. operationalization of might be at play. the regional report Impact Disability Inclusion in This was used to Latin America and the inform a number of WB Caribbean : A Path To projects, e.g. Nigeria Sustainable Digital Identification Development (2021). for Development. 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics EXAMPLES Rapid Social Analysis | Thematic Notes Short thematic notes Sexual Harassment in Public Roma country profiles for Tanzania IP scoping profile COVID-19 just in time notes in Spaces: Analysis of New Albania, Bulgaria, Croatia, (2023, 8 pages) Ghana, Liberia, Sierra Leone Survey Data from Peshawar, North Macedonia, Romania (2020, ~10-12 pages) Pakistan and Serbia (2020, 20 pages). (2022/2023, 6-10 pages) This defined This rapid assistance to which groups should be CMU, helped to ensure This Note analyses Providing basic covered under ESS7, social inclusion focus in sexual harassment in information about Roma providing an overview Bank operations during public spaces as in the different countries, of governance and COVID. reported by women in including available data representation, self- Peshawar city in the and country policy governance systems Khyber Pakhtunkhwa commitments. and key organizations province of Pakistan and that represent IPEM in is part of the World the country. Bank's multimethod Women in the Workforce study. 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics EXAMPLES Deep Dives | Thematic In-depth Analysis Thematic Deep Dives Social cohesion in the Gulf of Guinea Conflict sensitivity in Myanmar Institutional GBV prevention gaps in GBV portfolio review Liberia Data from the Afrobarometer was A suite of analytic methods is being (2019, 91 pages) used to generate localized information used in Myanmar to track conflict about different dimensions of social dynamics & feed into country strategy, Recommends key interventions capital and social cohesion in the Gulf program designs & implementation. and risk management measures or of Guinea. The analysis covered (These are largely for internal use provisions to be integrated in Benin, Togo, and Côte d’Ivoire. This only). A violence monitoring system has pipeline or active projects to analysis suggests that when the been developed with the Myanmar address key risks with the project expands to other areas, it may Institute for Peace and Security potential to contribute towards need to prioritize other types of (MIPS). Data on incidents and impacts SEA/GBV. interventions, and in particular of conflict are tracked in real time with interventions supporting trust in local monthly restricted distribution analyses councils. produced (see attached). Impact Provided evidence on Impact Impact institutional GBV prevention It Informed the Gulf of Guinea Data has fed into Bank research gaps and informed the Social Cohesion project which products such as the Myanmar engagement with client and currently plans to launch activities Economic Monitor and the CMU on the Liberia Women to address prejudice between Systematic Country Diagnostic. Empowerment Project communities. 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics EXAMPLES Deep Dives | Thematic In-depth Analysis Thematic Deep Dives Country Gender Assessments (CGA) Social exclusion and inclusion in Georgia – Afro-descendants in Latin America : Country Gender Assessments a country social analysis (2017) Toward a Framework of (CGA) in: (all accessible here) Inclusion (2018) • Lesotho 2022, • Malawi 2022, It analyzes who is socially excluded and in Offers a first assessment of the • Maldives 2016, what areas. The report draws on a desk data available and a synthesis of • Tanzania 2022, review, quantitative and qualitative data (incl. literature relevant to inclusion of • Bangladesh 2021, perceptions), and two roundtable Afro-descendants in LAC. • Indonesia 2020, discussions in Tbilisi. • South Africa 2022, Impact Impact Impact Influenced Georgia SCD 2018, Georgia Highlighted the prominence of The CGA typically serve to CPF 2019-2022. race issues in LCR, and inform the CPF, SCD, and in Led to multiple operations: Georgia I2Q: provided an entry point for some a cases the CEM (e.g. Innovation, Inclusion, and Quality Project dialogue with Governments latest Tanzania and PNG). (Education),Log-In Georgia Project and Bank teams on how to (Digital Development), Georgia Human better target afro-descendants Capital Program (P4R). through WB financing. 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics EXAMPLES Deep Dives | Thematic In-depth Analysis CESA Enabling Conditions Analysis Gender In–depth Studies These have been called different things, Country: • Perceptions of Gender Disparities from social accountability profiles to CE • Morocco Social Accountability Profile in Vietnam's Labor Market (2020) profiles, and can be done at the country, Provides a synopsis of key institutional, portfolio, or regional level: social, economic issues as they are • Vietnam's Future Jobs – The relevant to the CESA agenda, and a Gender Dimension (2019) deep dive on the status of key social Regional: accountability issues and entry points • How to Design The Vietnam Labor • LCR for engagement. Code to Improve Gender When Engagement Works: Quality (2019) Stocktaking of Good Citizen • Burundi: Mainstreaming Citizen Engagement Practices in the World Engagement Impact Bank-funded portfolio in LCR It identified key ministries, task teams Directly informed the 2019 and PIUs jointly developed a roadmap Vietnam Labor Code; served as on how to build on current innovations analysis for prior action in two and strengthen CESA approaches in National DPLs; generated client the future which was followed by a request for input to design of State and Peace-building Fund (SPF) implementation decree for Labor grant to implement a follow-up Code; design of national policy for Strengthening Implementation of the childcare service (underserved Roadmap for CE in the Burundi groups near industrial parks; Portfolio ASA review of labor policy reforms. 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics EXAMPLES Deep Dives | Thematic In-depth Analysis Forced Displacement and Social Cohesion Studies In partnership with UNHCR and the Indonesia SDCC FCV group, SSI led the Forced The report identified critical areas for Displacement and Social engagement in the context of the social Cohesion research program. The dimensions of climate change. program produced 26 background papers and a global report covering Impact countries across Africa, Asia, Central Led to request for LLCA operation even and South America, and Europe. before report formally launched Impact The findings have been used to inform operations in Uganda and policy dialogue in Tajikistan and across Europe, especially regarding refugees from Ukraine and Afghanistan. The full report is available here. Links to the 26 background papers and to recordings of dissemination events are available on the webpage 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics EXAMPLES Deep Dives | SSI Overview Diagnostics ECA AFW SAR Western Balkans Social Social Sustainability and Ghana Social Sustainability India SSI Diagnostic Sustainability and Inclusion Inclusion Diagnostic and Inclusion profile Profile (2021, 90 pages) Cameroon (2022, 113 pages) (2022, 35 pages) It identified groups at risk of exclusion in the country and Comprises over 200 It employs a Regional data combined it with an analysis of indicators capturing the multidimensional variations helped to how relevant to the India current state and trends framework to present inform discussions with portfolio. of three pillars: Social trends about exclusion the CMU on need to Inclusion, Resilience and fragility. Moreover, it invest in local economic Impact and Social Cohesion, discusses how structural development in the It helped identify priority areas and Empowerment, challenges related to rural northern lagging region for work under the Gender and disaggregated by underdevelopment, of Ghana. Inclusion Platform. vulnerable population conflict, and migration groups and location. intersect with gender and Bangladesh SSI Diagnostic demographic identities to compound It identified groups at risk of marginalization. It is exclusion in the country and accompanied by an formulated a range of appendix on climate recommendations for priority change and social areas for policy reform and inclusion. possible project engagement. 1. A typology of SSI country diagnostics EXAMPLES Deep Dives | ESF Overview Assessments ESF Overview Assessments Environmental and Social Borrower E&S Borrower Framework Enhancing Social Risk Management Framework Assessment in Georgia Assessment in Practices in Uganda (P171666) Argentina/Paraguay/Uruguay (P164325) (P173500) Described key gaps between This is a good example of using existing environmental and social Impact analysis to launch policy legislation and practices and ESF The assessment helped discussions with various standards. Recommended how to Argentina to ratify the government agencies together for fill gaps. International Labor clarification of responsibilities Organization’s convention on around social risk management. Impact violence and harassment in Led to the improvement of land the workplace (ILO 190). registration and valuation & the inclusion of a trigger in the Green and Resilient Growth DPO to adopt a Law on Biodiversity.