Vietnam Ministry of Industry and Trade World Bank Renewable Energy Development Project Resettlement Plan Ha Tay Hydropower Subproject Chu Pah District Gia Lai Province Prepared by: Song Da - Tay Nguyen Hydropower Joint Stock Company Vietnam Ministry of Industry and Tracle World Bank Renewable Energy Development Project Resettlement Plan Ha Tay Hydropower Subproject Chu Pah District Cia Lai Province Prepared by: Song Da -Tay Nguyen Hydropower Joint Stock Company Pleik.u, Novemher 2008 Table of contents EXECUTIVE SlJMMARY ..................................................................................................... 4 I. INTRODUCTION ................................................................................................................. 5 1.1. Renewable Energy Development Project ......................................................................... 5 . 1.2. Ha Tay Hydropower Project (Chu-Pah District, Gia Lai Province ................................... 6 11. IMPACTS OF THE SUBPROJECT ..................................................................................... 8 2.1. Loss of land..................................................................................................................... 8 2.1 .1. Permanent loss..........................................................................................................8 2.1.2. Temporary loss ...................................................................................................9 2.2. Impacts of trees and crops............................................................................................... 9 2.3. Impacts of houses and other structures............................................................................I0 2.4. Impacts of income and livelihood ................................................................................ I0 2.5. Others............................................................................................................................1 1 111.LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND ENTITLEMENTS OF DISPLACED PERSONS ................13 IV.SOCIO-ECONOMIC CHARACTERISTICS OF DISPLACED COMMUNITIES AND HOUSEHOLDS .................................................................................................................. 17 4.1. Socio-economic characteristics of displaced communities: Dak To Ve commune and Ha Tay commune....................................................................................................................... 17 4.2. Socio-economic characteristics of displaced households ................................................18 V. COMPENSATION, ASSISTANCE AND RESETTLEMENT .............................................20 5.1. Compensation ................................................................................................................ 20 5.2. Assistance ....................................................................................................................22 5.3. Resettlement .................................................................................................................23 5.3.1. Arrangement of the resettlement site.......................................................................23 j.3.2. Resettlement Implementation .................................................................................. 23 VI. INCOME AND LIVELIHOOD REHABILITATION PROGRAM FOR DISPL.ACED PERSONS...........................................................................................................................24 VII. PUBLIC CONSULTATION AND PARTICIPATION OF THE DISPLACED PERSONS 27 7.1. Participation of the displaced persons ............................................................................ 27 7.2. Public consultation ........................................................................................................ 27 7.3. Settlement of complaints and grievances........................................................................ 29 VII1. SUPERVISION. MOhITORING AND EVALUATION ............................................. 31 1X.REPORTING ...................................................................................................................... 33 X . IMPLEMENTATION PLAN .............................................................................................. 34 XI.RESETTLEMENT COST AND BUDGET ......................................................................... 35 List of Acronyms AU Administration Unit PMU Project Management Unit (at district level) DP Development program C&R Compensation & Resettlement PC People's Council HH Household SE Socio-economic Kv Kilovolt M Meter MOF Ministry of Finance MOIT Ministry-of Industry and Trade MW Megawatt PMB Project Management Board RPF Resettlement Policy Framework FFC Fatherland Front Committee PC People's Committee WB World Bank CURRENCY EQUIVALENT (As of 3l October 2008) $ 1.OO = VND 16.465 EXECUTIVE SUlMMAR Y Ha Tay hydropower subproject with the in.rtallrd capacity oJ'9.OMW locates on Dak Po Tang stream, Ha Tay commune fChu-Pah district, Cia Lai province). The subproject is SOkmfarfiom Pleiku city and 30kmfar from Kon Tum town in the North. 1,394,649 m2 of land will be acquired permanently for con.rtruction works in which the agricultural land, garden land, rc.sidentia1 land, area of traffic planning, unused river spring land and natural forest land take 996,733m2 (mainly burnt-over lan4, 23,405 m', 211rn2, 8,700m2,161,700m2and 203,900m2,re.spectively. There are 68 households of Ba-na ethnic in Dak To and Ha Tay communes (Chu Pak district, Cia Lai province) losing ports of rhe land due to acquisition. In which, there are 07 displaced households losing residential land and suffering affection on their structures, so they have to be relocated to a new resettlement area. The acquired productive land area takes a significan! considerable rate in comparison with total existing productive land area of household. The average lost area of Ha Tay commune and Dak To Ye commune is 35.5% and 40.22% of total existing producfive land area, respectively. 19,821rn2 oj'burnt-over land which is. under atlmini.r/rationof I hou.seholdv will be rrcquired temporurily tofacilitate storage yrrrd of rnuterial.c, plant and equipments and worker capps. In addition, 8,725p1ant.v and trees, mosf of which are perennial plants, will be suffrred ajJection. Regarding public assets, 02 stayed bridges, which are used lo connect the population site to the production site and 03 domestic water withdrawal p0int.s of community, will be affected by the subproject. The compensation fund will be released in the end of November, 2008 as schedzcled The resettlement shall be launched in h'ov, 2008 (3 householdv rebuild their house on their remaining residentiul land and I householdr conduct resettlement or1 u villuge range). The income and livelihood rehabilitation program for (he displaced households will be established and implemented in early December, 2009. Total costs associated with compensation, re.rettlemenr are estimafed to be VND 8,368,329,637, equivalent to US$ 50,824.0. I. INTRODUCTION 1.1. Renewable Energy Development Project The objective of the proposed project is to increase the supply of least-cost electricity to the national grid from renewable energy sources on a commercially sustainable basis in an environmentally and socially sustainable manner. The project will have three components: (1) the investment project imple~nentationcomponent:(2) the regulatory development component, and (3) the pipeline development component. The Investment Project Implementation component will provide (i) a re-financing facility to participating commercial banks for loans to eligible renewables-based projects below 30MW developed by private sponsors, and (ii) technical assistance for building the capacity of participating banks and subproject developers to prepare, appraise, finance, and implement renewables-based projects according to international best practices. This component will be implemented by the Project Management Board (PMB) for Rural Energy and Renewable Energy of the Ministry of Industry and Trade (MOIT). The component has two subcomponents as described below. Subcomponent I: Credif foSupporf Renewable Enera lnvesfmenfs Private developers will develop subprojects of below 30MW based on small hydro, wind, and biomass in accordance with REDP criteria including environmental and social safeguards. Developers will commit at least 20% in equity funding and will approach participating banks for lending of up to 80% of each subproject's total project cost. The participating banks, which have been selected on a competitive basis, will appraise eligible renewables-based subprojects proposed by developers and provide loans to projects that meet all the requirements of the participating banks. The banks will lend to subprojects on commercial terms determined by market forces and will bear the full credit risk of the funds. Eligible loans will be re-financed up to 80% of participating banks' lending or 64% of total project cost for each subproject. This means that participating banks will commit at least 16% of total project cost to each subproject as their own lending and project developers will contribute 20% as equity. Upon approval of an application for re-financing a loan, the respective participating bank will receive KEDP (IDA) re-financing through MOF. REDP's contribution will be based on IDA funding lent to the Ministry of Finance (MOF) on IDA terms. It is estimated that some 20 subprojects (90% small hydro and 5% each wind and biomass) will be supported by the re-financing facility, averaging some 10-1I MW and with an average cost of about US$ 12 million. When fully operational, these projects are expected to comprise about 210 MW of installed capacity producing about 880 GWh of electricity annually. Subcomponent 2: ~rchnicul~s.visluncefor Invrs[mrnfProject Implernenfafion The technical assistance part of Component I will support the overall management of REDP, verification of eligibility for re-financing. and capacity building at PBs. developers/investors and others. This technical assistance facility will be managed by MOIT's PMB. The TA facility will support the subproject developers by providing them the necessary skills to identify good projects and to prepare proposals for bankers. navigate the approvals process, and negotiate financing. This would include. inter alia. training for conducting feasibility studies, design optimization. construction management, operation. maintenance, the management of financial risks and takes into consideration environmental and social safeguards. The TA facility will support the PBs by enabling them to understand the risks of investment in renewable energy projects, supervise such projects with respect to safeguards, prepare credit policies for such projects, and ap.praisesubprojects against those policies. The TA facility will also provide resources for project management of REDP by the PMB. If required, the TA facility would also assist the AU to evaluate projects against the eligibility criteria. The Resettlement Plan of Ha Tay hydropower subproject is prepared under the Renewable Energy Development Project (REDP). 1.2. Ha Tay Hydropower Project (Chu-Pah District, Gia Lai Province Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project with the installed capacity of 9.0 MW will be located on Dak Po Tang stream - or otherwise called "la Krom stream" - belonging to Ha Tay Commune (Chu- Pah District, Gia Lai Province), approximately 50 krn far from Pleiku City and 30 krn far from Kon-Turn Town to the North. The major construction works consist of headwork weir, penstock, power house and other facilities will be located in Ha Tay Commune, but the reservoir will be stretched on the stream-area of 03 communes, i.e. Dak To Ver and Ha Tay communes (Chu-Pah District) and Daksomei commune (Dak-Doa District) - Gia Lai Province. Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project is categorized of post-dam work with a daily regulating reservoir. The average annual electricity generation output will be approximately 35.2 x lo6 kwh. The total construction cost (excluding compensation and resettlement cost) is estimated at 198.414 x 1 o9 VND. 'The expected construction period for the whole sub-project is 30 months from construction commencement date. The key technical parameters of Ha Tay Hydropower sub- project are as follows: Map of the Subproject and the area of local ethnic minorities Table 1: Key technical parameters of Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project Construction items Unit Value Reservoir ~ m ' 675 1.2 Normal water level 569 1.3 Dead water level 567 1.4 Storage capacity at normal water level 1 o6 rn3 1.18 --1.5 Storage capacity at dead water level 0.74 1.6 Useful storage capacity 1o6 rnl 0.44 r - 1.7 Surface area with normal water level ~ r n ' 0.783 I 2 I Power house I 1 I 1 ~ L - I 2.1 1Calculated head 1lvl 1 17.6 I I ITJXrn capacity - MW 1 1.8 -1 2.3 Installed capacity M w j 9.0 h e a m right bank Length of the dam's right bank 3.3 Width of the dam's right bank ----+- 3.4 Elevation of the dam's left bank 573 /+I 3.5 Length of the darn's left bank 3.6 Width of the dam's left bank I I 4 Spillway 4.1 Elevation of overflowing threshold (with a valve gate) M 560 4.2 Height of overflo\sing threshold (\\ith a tali c gate) lvl 15 4.3 Elevation of free overflowing threshold M 569 5 Headrace 5.1 Length of the canal's bed M 100 5.2 Width of the canal's bed M 15 6 Penstock 6.1 Length of penstock M 168.8 x 3 pipes - 6.2 Diameter of penstock -t"- 2.5 x 2.5 7 35KV power line 7.1 Length of line IM X km C d 11. IMPACTS OF THE SUBPROJECT 2.1. Loss of land 2.1.1.Permanent loss 1,394,649m2of land (139,46 ha) will be acquired permanently for construction works, including: Table 2: Area of land lost permanently I I 1 1 I Permanenil Affected objects Type Oftand lost land (mr) Agricultural land 52 farming households in Dak Vo Te Commune 16 farming households in Ha Tay Commune 1 / Chu-Pah Rubber Company I I 2 Residential land 07 householder in Dak Vo Te Commune, of which 04 * I 1 households have to relocated (in-~laceresettlement) . L . I 3 Garden land 23405 9 households in Dak Vo Te Commune -- 4 Traffic planned 8700 Dak Vo Te Commune and Ha ~a~ Commune / land F.ir I 5 and spring 161700 Dak Vo Te Commune and Ha Tay Commune 16 1Natural forest land 1 203900 1Dak Vo Te Commune and Ha Tay Commune 1 I ITotal / 1,394,649 1 I Among the acquired agricultural land, 48,500m2 is one-crop rice land, 64,800m2 is land for planting rubber and 883,433m2 is burnt-over land. List of affected households and their details are given in the Annex I and Annex 2. Level of land loss for each construction works is as follows: -Headwork weir:: Total 41,000m2of land shall be acquired for construction of headwork weir, in which 10,050m2is burnt-over land, land for industrial trees of 02 households and Chu-Pah Rubber Company; 17,500m2is river and spring land, unused land and 13,450m2 is natural forest land. The headwork weir shall not affect to rice land. - Reservoir bed: The reservoir bed shall take a considerable area of land. Total 1,206,575m2of land shall be acquired permanently, which is mainly 2 1 I m2of residential land of 07 households (04 households shall have to relocate), 23,405m2 of garden land of 09 households; 38,340m2of one-crop rice land of 47 households, 1 08,450m2of river and spring land, unused land (of which there are 8700m2 of traffic planned land of both Dak To Ve commune and Ha Tay commune), 864,843m2of burnt-over land of 61 households and Rubber Company of Chu Pah District. and 171,326m2of natural forest land. . - Headrace channel: Total 33,462m2of land shall be acquired permanently, which 6,698m2is in one-crop rice land of 14 households, 6,700m2 is river and spring land, unused land, 18,000m2is burnt-over land for planting perennial plants, industrial trees of 08 households. In addition, this works shall also acquire 2,064m2of natural forest land. - Penstock: Total 15,277 m2of land will be acquired permanently including 3,462m2of one-crop rice land belonged to 6 households: ?,500m2of river and spring land. unused land; 6,700m2of burnt-over land belonged to 2 households and 2,61 5m2of forestry land. - Powerhouse: Hydropo~\erplant and au~iliarq~ o r k swill acquire total 9,571 rn2 rice land, including 3,760m2 of river and spring land and unused land. 4.?40m2 of burnt-over land and industrial trees belonged to 0 I household. and 1.571 tn2of natiiral forest land. -Access roads: Existing roads shall be expanded to become access road of 5m width and 15 km length. Among 63,985 m2permanently acquired land. there are 23,190 m2 of river and spring land, unused land; 29,700m2 of burnt-over land for planting perennial plants and industrial trees belonged to 8 households and 1 1,095m2of natural forest land. - 35kV line: The 35kV line with 8km length shall be connected through burnt-over land, river and spring land, unused land and forest land. 24,779m2will be acquired permanently, including 8,300m2 of river and spring land, unused land; 14,700m2of burnt-over land belonged to 05 households. In addition, this works shall also acquire permanently 1,779m2of natural forest land. Table 3: Inventory of acquired land \Construction I Of which items (m2) 1 Residential 1Garden Ian! Ian! (m') land, river land for land (m*) (m') and spring planting (m2) land industrial (m2) . trees . (m2) Headwork weir 1 7500 I0050 13450 - Reservoir bed 1206575 21 1 23405 38340 108450 864843 171J26 - Headrace channel 33462 6698 6700 18.000 2064 - Penstock 15277 3462 2500 6700 2615 Powerhouse 9571 3760 4240 1571 Access road 63985 23 190 29700 11095 35 kV line 24779 8300 14700 1779 Total 1 J94.649 2 1 1 23405 48500 170400 948233 203900 Among total 68 households losing land, there are 52 households losing a permanently a part of agricultural land, 07 households losing both agricultural land, residential land and garden land, remaining 03 households losing permanently a part of agricultural land and garden land. The affected households are mainly in Dak To Ve commune (52 households), Ha Tay commune has only 16 affected households. 2.1.2. Temporaty lo.s.5 19,82I m2of agricultural land (burnt-over land) which is under administration of 04 households, Ha Tay commune will be acquired temporarily to facilitate storage yard of materials, plant and equipments and worker camps. The agricultural land will be also acquired temporarily for the construction works during construction phase, including headwork weir (123,000m2), powerhouses (38,000m2)and access road (37.200m2). List of affected households and its details are attached in the Annex 3. 2.2. lmpucts of trees and crops The 68 displaced households will suffer affection totalled to 8,725 trees. Names of displaced households and details of affection are given in Annex 4 and Annex 5. As the commencement date of construction will be disclosed to the inhabitants living in the subproject site at least before G months. Simultaneo~~sl>.the construction shall not be commenced until the people harvesting completely their crops in the acquired land area. Therefore, there is no impact of crops such as cassava, maize, rice and other short-term crop plants. The affected trees and crops are mainly industrial trees, perennial plants, fruit trees and timbers. Number of affected crops and trees are as follows: Table 1: Number of trees and crops affected by Ha Tay hydropower project Total Banana Guava Mango Bamboo ~oi-loi lhistle Jack Logan Coft'ee Timber Papaya (tree) (tree) (tree) (tree) (tree) (wee) (tree) (we) (tree) (trre) (tree) (me) 8,725 4,539 93 105 75 3687 ( 3 48 4 I40 3 28 2.3. Impacts of houses and other structures There are seven (07) households losing seven (07) houses and fences around the houses and cattle-shed. The affected 07 households are living in the Dak To Ve commune and are affected by the construction works of reservoir bed. List of affected households and their details are given in Annex 6. Among the affected houses, there are two affected houses to be constructed by Program 134 in order to support for the poor households. The houses' architectures are similar, including: fibro- cement roofs, wood walls, cement floors. Its area is different due to the different number of family members. These houses were constructed and delivered in 2005 so they are still in good situation. The remaining houses' architectures are different. including: metal sheet roofs;timber pillars, wood walls and soil tloors. The affected cattle-shed is also designed pri~nitively.si~nply.Almost the floors of cattle-shed is covered by cements, the round of cattle-shed is made by timber and the roofs is covered by fibro- cement roofs. The fences of affected households are made from wooden pillars, surrounded bamboo wattles. Among 07 households losing residential land, there are 4 affected households relocating in place. The remaining household shall dismantle their houses and rebuild on their remaining residential land. The 07 households losing residential land are Ba-na ethnic group. 2.4. Impacts of income and livelihood According to the analysis result between the acquired agricultural land and existing agricultural land area, the lost agricultural land area takes a high rate. It means that the households shall meet difficulties in livelihood and incomes, although they can reclaim to extend land area. Because, land area which can reclaim and are allowed to reclaim at locality is still abundant. In Ha Tay commune. the average acquired agricultural land area for each household is 35.5% of total existing agricultural land area. There is onl) 09, ho~~seholds(among 16 households losing land) having lost agricultural land area less than 10% of total existing agricultural land area, remaining households having lost agricultural land area more than 10% (in which there are 3 households having lost agricultural land area from 10% to 20% of total existing agricultural land area, 7 households having lost agricultural land area more than 40% and remaining households having lost agricultural land area from 20% to 30%). In Dak To Ve commune, the average acquired agricultural land area for each household is 40.22% of total existing agricultural land area. There are I8 households (among 62 households) losing agricultural land area more than 50% of total existing agricultural land area. The permanently acquired agricultural land area takes a high rate. So. it will affect to the livelihood and income of households. especially ethnic minority households having main income source from agricultural products. 2.5. Others Apart from the aforementioned impacts, there is no other impact to the inhabitants in the subproject site. There is no impact to the trading, business such as losing business place and material sources of households. 64,800m2land of Chu Pah Rubber Company is acquired permanently. This area has been used to plant rubber trees for I year. According to the public consultation result with the company and employees, the acquired land area doesn't affect to the rubber planting area of company. Because, the company will be delivered additionally land for planting rubber trees by Chu Pah District. In addition, the company is reclaiming to expand the land area for planting rubber trees as permitted by the DPC of Chu Pah. The land acquisition for construction works will be no impact to the company workers' jobs and incomes. The workers' salary are kept by the wage fund of company. 2.6. Impacts ofpublic assets The subproject shall affect to 8,700m2 of public land to be planned to construct road after 2010 in Dak To Ve and Ha Tay Communes (including 3,800m2 of Dak To Ve Commune and 4,900m2 of Ha Tay Commune). According to the land use master plan duration 2010 - 2020, some inter-village roads of two villages will be buit to create favorable conditions for travelling among villages. However, a part of the traffic planning land area will be acquired to construct the access road, penstock and headrace channel of the subproject. The water level of reservoir shall affect to 02 stayed bridges Hde village. Dak To Ve commune. These bridges were made of iron wire, wooden planks, 18m length for each one. These bridges are used to connect inhabitant site with productive places (milpa, forestry) of the people of Hde Village, Dak To'Ve commune. There is impact to three (03) domestic water withdrawal places (in local language called "giot"), where the water is flowed from the upstream. 0I water withdrawal place will satisfy the water use demand for 12 households and 02 remaining places will satisfy the water use demand for 18 households living in Hde Village (Dak To Ve Commune). So, the lost water source will affect adversely to these 30 households. 24 households in Hde village (Dak To Ve commune, Chu-Pah district) and 37 households in Daksomei commune (Dak-Doa District) usually catch tish in the stream for their family life. While these communes are planned to be acquired for reservoir construction.The construction of dam as well as high-rise of the water level in the stream (when it becomes the reservoir bed, the water level against current water level is more than 3m height) will affect to fishing of the households. At present, apart from fishing for living. the people do not use the stream for any other purposes. The water for living activities, bathing, washing is taken from water withdrawal places or well. The water for production shall not be lost but regulated better thank to the subproject. Apart from the aforementioned impacts. there is no impact to p~~blicstructures or physical cultural resources of the community. As per the consultation result. 203,900m2of permanently acquired natural forest land will not affect to benefit of the com~nunitybecause thi.sarea is legal under administration of the afforest program 661. This forestry is categorized as a thin forest, type 3 and has no economic value. The local people do not perform any activities to create income or develop livelihoods (cutting firewood, wood, gathering forest products without wood.etc..) in this forest area. 2.7. Mitigation measuresfor land acquisition The subproject is planned with best effort to minimize area of land permanently acquired, especially agricultural land and residential land. Two mitigation measures that have been carried out are: 1. to reduce the water level of reservoir bed in order to decrease the area of acquired forest land, burnt - over land, residential land and garden land. If it compares scenarios including the lowest water level and the highest water level and it chooses the scenario of the lowest water level, it will be mitigated 604,000m2of acquired land and 6 relocated households. Table 5. Water level of reservoir and their impacts ) Normal water T Number of relocated 1 ~ c ~ u i r e d l a n d r - Note level households 1 area I I 569 04 139,4 ( Scenario selected I I I to strictly supervise expansion of the existing roads serving for the subproject to ensure that the graded and bulldozed area is not larger than design, no falling of earth and rock into fields, milpa in order to avoid the land acquisition out of mandatorily acquired land area in accordance with the technical specifications. The gathering of materials, machines will be also supervised closely to no additional impact to trees, crops, land of the people. 111. LEGAL FRAMEWORK AND ENTITLEMENTS OF DISPLACED PERSONS This Resettlement Plan is prepared under the REDP, so the legal framework for compensation and resettlement shall be based on the Policy Framework for compensation, resettlement and rehabilitation of project affected persons applied for REDP. The applicable policies for compensation and resettlement consist of (i) %I3 policy requirements, (ii) existing regulation on compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement of the Government of Vietnam; and (iii) regulations on compensation, assistance and resettlement of the local authorities (Lam Dong Province). - Regarding the WB policy requirements. the OP 4.12. (lnvolunta~Re.re111ernenr)applies. The main contents of OP 4.12 are shown in the RPF. - l'he existing regulations on compensation, assistance and resettlement promulgated by the Government of Vietnam apply to implement the resettlement plan of Dak Me hydropower subproject No. I , including: 1. The Land Law 2003 issued on November 26,2003. 2. Decree 181/2004/ND-CP issued on October 29, 2004 guiding the implementation of the Land Law revised 2003. 3. Decree 188/2004/ND-CP issued on November 16, 2004 on methods to determine land prices and assorted land price brackets. 4. Circular 1 14/2004/TT-BTC issued by November 26, 2004 guiding the implementation of the Government's decree No 18812004ND-CP 5. Decree 197/2004/ND-CP issued on December 3. 2004 on compensation, assistance and resettlement when land is recovered by the state. 6. Circular I 16/2004/TT-BTC issued on December 7, 2004 guiding the implementation of the Decree 197/2004/ND-CP 7. Decree 17/2006/ND-CP issued on January 27, 2006 revising and cornple~nentingsome articles of Decrees guiding the implementationof Land Law 8. Circular No. 6912006lTT-BTC issued on August 02, 2006 amending and executing Decree No. 1 16120041TT-BTC. 9. Decree No. 123/2007/ND-CP issued on July 27, 2007 amending and executing some articles of Decree No. 188/2004/ND-CP. 10. Decree 84/2007/ND-CP dated May 25'h 2007 on revision of issuing LURC, land acquisition, implementation of land use right, procedure for compensation, resettlement when land acquired by State and grievance redress 11. Circular 1412008/1'TLT/BTC-BTNMT issued on January 3 1, 2008 guiding the implementation of some articles of the Decree 84/2007/ND-CP The existing regulations on compensation, assistance and resettlement of the local authorities (Gia Lai Province) will apply for the Resettlement Plan, including: 1 .Decision No 479lQD-UB. dated Septe~nbcr26. 2007 of Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee regarding regulations on percentage and limits of agricitlti~ralland area, garden land, adjoining ponds with residential land in inhabitant site. 2. Decision No 422lQD-CIBND, dated August 25. 2007 of Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee regarding adjustment of compensation unit prices for trees, crops in scale of Gia Lai Province. 3. Decision No 122/200/QD-UBND, dated December 31, 2007 of Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee, providing regulations on issuance of price list for different kinds of land in Chu-Pah District (Gia Lai Province) in 2008. 4. Decision No I3tQD-UBND, dated January 10, 2008 of Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee, regarding issuance of compensation price list for houses, structures, construction works on land. 5. Decision No 2512008lQD-UBND, dated May 15, 2008 of Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee regarding compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement when the Government acquires land in the scale of Cia Lai Province. Based on the policies of the Government, of WB and the local authorities on compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement, the following are basic principles applied in the Compensation, Resettlement Plan of the subproject. Table 6: Principles applied for the compensation, assistance and resettlement of Hay Tay hydropower subproject - . 1 . The displaced households losing residential land. agriculture land, crops. trees and others in the subproject site will be compeinsated and assisted to improve or at least maintain their pre-project living standards, income earning capacity and production levels. 2. In case, lack o f land use certificates (including residential land. agriculture land and others) and other legal claims associated with assets has no impact to the entitlements o f compensation. assistince and resettlement. 3. The land and asset acquisition plan. compensation, assistance and resettlement plan, income and livelihood rehabilitation plan and ethnic minority development plan should be consulted with all displaced people adequate1y. 4. The compensation for the lost land, crops and trees and others will be provided at replacement cost and no deducting depreciation and conversion values or any others. 5. Resettlemen[ shall be in the village ol'al'l'ected persons ru keep their inherent social relations. House and residential land will be compensated by replacement cost. The relocated households will be supported transponationi shitiing allowance, livelihood rehabilitation and other allowance as per the regulations. 6. The poor households. households having I'ernale householder and ethnic minority households, etc. and vulnerable households will be assisted in accordance with esisting provisions of the local authorities. Simultaneously. other assistances shall be provided by the subprqject developer depending on the results o f consultation with these displaced households. - .- The Entitlement Matrix of REDP is described in the RPF. Accordingly, the entitlement matrix of the subproject is established as follows: Table 7: The Entitlement Matrix o f the subproject Definition o f Application entitled person - Less than 10% All households. I.Cash compensation for acquired land at 100% of o f total land individuals or replacement cost. holding lost organizations losing 2. Participating into the income and livelihood agriculture land rehabilitation program under Ha Tay hydropower due to , subproject. acquisition (There are 05 displaced households) 1 Definition of 8 of loss Application Compensation Policy entitled person Morethan 10% All households, I. As priority, compensation "land fot land" of HH's total individuals or equivalent productive capacity at a location land holding organizations acceptable to the displace persons, or if requested, or lost have over 10% "land for land'' is not available, cash compensation of their for the lost land at 100%of replacement cost. a&ricultural 2. A rehabilitation assistance including training land to be assistance amounting to a minimum of VNDl.5 acquired million per household and to a maximum amount as (There are 63 approved by the provincial authorities to develop displaced alternative sources of income. households) 3, The displace persons will be given priority to participate in other local development programs funded by the government of international organizations. 4. Priority is given to hire the displaced persons working for the subproject in construction and operation phase. . 5. The displaced persons will be given priority to participate in income and livelihood rehabilitation programs under the subproject. . *. e,,',.: ,.-,,<$ households) Of affected trees are removable, the compensation 3 Restoring land quality through so;; ensure that it can be sanie or better than pr7~jau.s - Definition o f Compensation Policy entitled person . 9 " e+. 1 Loss of public Af'fected A ffected 1. All affected assets will be restored as same as the public assets communitie~ lost quantity and its better quality. (bridgc rill be such as traflic (Dak To Ve rebuilt and "giot nuoc" will be replacedby water well. planning land. and Ha Tay 2. For loss o f land to be planned for transportation, it stayed bridge. commune) needs to grade. level and form a other traffic routine water appropriately. withdrawal 3. The aquatic source will be restored in income and sites livelihood rehabilitation program. i Allowances Material Relocating DP A transportation allowance not to exceed transport (7 households) VND3,000,000 per HH. Subsistence Relocating DP A subsistence allowance equivalent to the market allowance (7 households) value of 3Okg of ricelperson/month for 6 months. Severely 1. Subsistence assistance equivalent to market value assistance affected 01'30kg ot'rice/peyson/month for 3 months if the DP farmers who is acquired a land area of 500rn2 (but not exceed have lost less number o f family members). (Clause I, Article 8, than 10% o f Decision No.25/2008/QD-UBND ofthe PPC of Cia their Lai on May IS, 2008). agricultural land (5 ,households) I. Subsistence assisLance equivalent to market value Severely of 30kg o f ricelpersonlmonth for 6 months if the DP affected is acquired a land area of 500m2 (but not exceed farmers who number of family members). (Clause 2, Article 31, have lost more Decision Nu.Z5/2008/QD-UBND of the PPC of Gia than 10% (63 Lai on May IS, 2008). households) 2. A training assistance for 1 labour for each DH in case of losing from 10% to 50% of total acquired area; A training assistance for 2 labour for each household in case of losing more than 50% of total acquired area; and a training assisrance for all labour in case o f losing more rhan 70% of total acquired - Social are entitled to additional assistance who VND 1.000.0000 to VND currently 5.000.000lhousehold as provided by respective local assistance (7 .households) lncentive minimum of 2.0 million VND up to a bonus maximum amount as determined by provincial voluntarily IV. SOCIO-ECONOMIC CHARACTERISTICS OF DISPLACED COMMUNITIES AND HOUSEHOLDS 4.1. Socio-economic characteristics of displaced communities: Dak To Ve commune and Ha Tay commune Ha Tay hydropower project will affect to 02 communes: Dak To Ve and Ha Tay. Dak To Ve commune has 367 households including 1,810 members. There are 03 ethnic groups living in the commune, those are: Gia-rai (200 households, 1016 members), Ba-na (129 households, 627 members) and Kinh (38 households, I22 members). Their main occupation is from cultivation and breeding. For the cultivation, the affected households in the sub-project site are doing other crop plants such as: cassava, rice, maize, boi loi, sugar cane, banana, and some other kinds of industrial plants such as coffee, almond. However, 3 kinds of plants that are grown with largest area are rice, cassava, maize. Livestock of affected households is not developed and the wander habit is still using popularly. Each household only has from I to 5 fowls and from I to 2 pigs mainly serving for consumption but no for commodity. Total cattle and poultry in the commune now is on$ 2,264. The breeding cows is more concerned, especially since the beginning of 2008, where the people are allowed to borrow capital for breeding development. During the first 06 months of 2008, number of cows in the commune increases from 94?0 704. The production and trading activities in the commune have not developed yet. The exchange of goods is made as per the method that small traders coming from other places provide sale of goods to local people and purchase agricultural products made by them. Apart from income source generating from cultivation and breeding, the local people have no other income sources. Average income per head of Dak To Ve commune, according to the commune-level statistics, in 2007 is 2,600,000 VNDipersonIyear. The rate of poor households of the Commune according to the new criteria of ~ i n i s tof r ~Labor, Ward Invalid and Social Affairs in 2007 takes 47.5%. Dak To Ve commune is the beneficiary from the Mountainous Poor Communes Support Programs, especially Program 134 and Program 135. Three ethnic groups in the commune have little mutual relations, each group lives in a separate area and is limited by language. Gia-rai and Ba-na usually use their own languages. More than 50% of displaced persons can not speak, write fluently popular language and 43% don't have enough literacy of popular. Rate of children going to school is high (98% in 2007). however, rate of children leaving out of school is too high, popularly leaving out of school when they complete primary education. Ha Tay Commune has 3.392 persons belonging to 664 households. There are only 02 ethnic groups in the commune including Bana (639 households, 3,298 members) and Kinh (25 households, 94 members). Like ~ a k Ve o ~ commune, their main occupation is from cultivation and breeding. The main agricultural products are rice, maize, cassava, boi loi, fruit trees, pepper, banana and vegetable. The breeding of the affected households has not developed because of shortage of investment capital. their small breeding habit and backward breeding technique. Average income per head in 2007 of Ha Tay commune, according to the new criteria is 2,700,000 VNDipersonlyear. Rate of poor households in 2007 makes up 42%. Ha Tay commune is a poor mountainous commune, so the people in the commune are supported in various aspects by the Program 134 and Program 135 such as building houses. clean water, supporting fertilizers, salt, kerosene... Ba-na ethnic makes up majority in the commune, so Bana traditional cultural values are prominent. In the comlnune, 2.306 people (around 68% of displaced persons) can not speak, write fluently popular language and about 40% don't have enough literacy of popular. Rate of children going to school in 2007 achieves by 95% however, almost children leave out of school when they complete secondary education. 4.2. Socio-economic clraracteristics of displaced Itouseholds The socioeconomic census has been conducted for displaced households. 43 households on total 52 affected households in Dak To Ve commLlne and 13 households on total 16 affected households have been surveyed by questionnaires. Along with the questionnaires, the other data collection methods that were applied consist of in-depth interview. focused group discussion and statistics of the commune. The raw database on socio-economic characteristics of displaced households is available including 56 questionnaires of affected household, 20 in-depth interviews, 08 focused group discussions and indicators of socioeconomic statistics at commune and village level. The in-dept interviewees are leader of commune. heads of Women's Association, Farmers' Association, Fatherland-Front, village patriarchs of 10 affected villages, 10 heads of village, head of social organizations at village level, PMB of afforesting program 661, Chu Pah rubber company and displaced households due to agriculture and residential land acquisition. The 10 focused group discussions are hold at 10 afkcled villages with the participation of heads of villages, village patriarchs, representatives of organizations and all displaced households relating to trees and crops.etc.. and some unaffected households. The list of the participants in the in-depth interviews, focused group discussions is attached in the Annex 7. The questionnaire on the influenced households is attached in the Annex 8. The processing result of the Questionnaire on the households is attached in the Annex 9. The basic socio-economic conditions of the influenced people are as follows: The average of each affected household has 5.2 members and householder's average age is 39.48 years old. Their main occupation is from farming (cultivation and breeding). The percentage of households doing secondary job is few, there are only 3.6% of total households have a sideline (mainly being as hired labour). Averagely, one household has 30,l 57m2 agricultural lands, of which the burnt-over lands are 25,294m2 and one-crop rice-lands are 4,863m2. Three major crop plants cultivated by the affected households are: cassava (which is being cultivated by 100% of households), rice (cultivated by 91.1% of households) and banana (cultivated by 76.8% of households). Besides, the affected households in the sub-project site are also doing other crop plants such as: pineapple, coffee-tree. etc. but the output is no remarkable. Rice and cassava are two crop plants that are bringing about the highest income to displaced persons, especially the cassava. The earnings from milpa are'usually higher than the ones from wet rice field because of a larger size, suitable to cultivate a variety of plants including rice. The breeding of the affected households has not developed because of their small breeding habit and backward breeding technique. Presently, the households are breed~ng pigs, poultry, goats and cattle. The investigation results indicate that there are only 48% of households breeding pig with average quantity fewer than 02 pigs per household; there are 64.3% of households breeding poultry with an average quantity fewer than 05 po~iltriesper household; there are 7.1% of households breeding goat; there are 33.9% of households breeding cattle with an average quantity of 02 goats, 02 heads of cattle per household. 91% of the affected households are ranked as the poor households according to the new criteria of the Ministry of Labor, War Invalids and Social Affairs (5 1168 households). The remaining households are ranked as the medium household. Average income of the affected household in 2007, according to the commune-level statistics, is 166.666 VND/person/month (about 2,000,000 ~ ~ ~ / ~ e r s o n / m - ni.e.h below the threshold of poverty). 73.2% of the affected o t householders are receiving benefits from the Program 134 and 80,4% of the affected householders are receiving benefits from the Program 135 (support metal roofing, support the community to build clean water works, support money to buy salt, kerosene...). The affected households think that the main reasons of hunger and poverty are shortage of investment capital, capital for production (96.4% of the households): lack of information about market (91. I% of the households); lack of knowledge of production, cultivation, breeding (89.3 of the households). In spite of poverty, the utensils of affected households are relatively enough. The result of questionnaires says that 88.2% of households have motorbikes, 76.6% of households have TVs, 7.9% of households have telephone. Bana language is used for daily communication among members of affected households. The result of questionnaires says that 29.3% of displaced persons can not speak fluently and nearly 27.4% don't have enough literacy of popular language (Kinh language). More than 64% of displaced persons have education level below 3rdgrade class. The affected households are mainly using digging well-water (72.7%), the rate of family households utilizing both well-water and rivulet water is 60%, 34.5% of households are utilizing river-water and spring-water and the remaining balance is utilizing rain-water and water in the public tanks. Issues of the environmental sanitation are inadequately paid attention by the affected households; 94.6% of family households haven't a latrine whereas the remaining balance has a very simple latrine which is surrounded by leaves and waste-bags. The working allocation in the affected households is unequal between man and woman, between husband and wife; In general, women have to shoulder more hard works than the men. According to the investigation results through questionnaires, apart from going to make a slash- and-bum cultivation or acting as a hired labour together with their husband, women normally take over the duty of collecting firewood (90.9% of households), carrying water (98.2% of households), washing clothes of their whole family (90.9% of households). Regarding the land acquisition and land compensation, 100% of the households accept and agree with land acquisition for the subproject. For the compensation method for acquired land, no households choose the method "land for land". Because, they still have land for reclamation and expansion of their land area. The result of questionnaires and group discussion say that 100% of the affected households expect to be compensated by cash at the market price. V. COMPENSATION, ASSISTANCE AND RESETTLEMENT 5.1. Compensation Cut offdate: The cut-off date is on July 20, 2008. The cut-off date is the date starting inventory of affected assets. This date shall be announced in public to affected households 1 week earlier to ensure that of (i) householder. members of household and the inventory team of the District Compensation Committee, together conduct inventory of affected assets; (ii) it confirms that the persons living at the subproject site or affected assets (trees. crops.etc..) will not be compensated for things occurred after the aforementioned cut off date. Replacement cost is defined by a group of people comprising representative of the compensation and site clearance committee of Chu Pah district, representative of subproject developer, authorities of 02 communes Dak To Ve and Hay Tay. women's association, farmer's association, 10 leaders of 10 affected villages and 10 householders on behalf of 68 affected households. The determination of replacement cost will be carried out from 26 to 27 July, 2008. The method for determination of replacement cost consists of: (i) meeting the households which transferred their land use right in the past time in the locality (both transferors and transferees) to collect information about land transferring prices; (ii) visiting and observing the transferred land areas to have foundation for comparison; (iii) meeting the households that have newly built their houses to collect information about costs of materials, manpower and other costs (transportation, inauguration and other cost of religious actions when building new houses...); (iv) meeting the brokers of land use right transfer in the locality for more references of actual transfer costs; and (v) comparing collected information on cost and price of compensation for land, crops, assets as specified in the Decision No 422IQD-UBND, dated August 25, 2007 of the Cia Lai Provincial People's Committee regarding adjustment of unit prices of compensation for trees, crops on the scale of Cia Lai' Province, Decision No 172/3007/QD-UBND, December 3 1, 2007 of Cia Lai Provincial People's Committee, providing regulations on issuance of land price list in Chu-Pah District (Gia Lai Province) in 2008, Decision No I3IQD-UBND, January 10, 2008 of Cia Lai Provincial People's Committee, regarding issuance of price list of compensation for houses, structures, construction works on land, and Decision No 25/2008/QD-UBND, May 15, 2008 of Cia Lai Provincial People's Committee, regarding compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement when the State acquires land in Cia Lai Province. The collected replacement cost is higher than the price of compensation defined by Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee and furthermore, the replacement cost reflects exactly actual prices applied in the scale of province. So, all affected assets, trees and crops will be compensated by replacement cwl and this replacement cost will be determined by the replacement cost collection team . Particularly, the compensation price is applied basing on the replacement cost as follows: Table 8: Compensation price basing on the replacement cost Assets Compensation price Replacement cost issued by PPC pplied for compensation - Residential land 15,000VND1m2 20,500 VND1m2 - Garden land 9,500 V N D I ~ ' 1 1.500 V N D I ~ ' - Annual growing land (rice land) 3,750 V N D I ~ ~ 5.500 VND1m2 - Land for planting perennial plants 3,500 V N D I ~ ' (milpa) - Land for planting rubber trees 3,500 V N D / ~ ' I -Traffic land 12,JOU V N L ) ~ ~ ' I h u Jrlined ~ - Naturalforest land 700,000 VNDIha /Not detined 2. Houses - Houses with wooden pillars, wooden planks, metal rooting - Bamboo, wooden Sences 3. Trees,crops Depending on kind of' plant, its value to defrne - Rice 1,200V N D / ~ * price for each kind of plant, in particular: - Perennial Coffee: From 50,000 to 80,000 VNDltree plants 700 V N D / ~ ' - Rubber trees Papaya: From 15.000 to 32.000 VNDltree 3,680 V N D / ~ ~ Mangu: I'l'um 50,000 to 80,000 VND/tree Banana: From 15.000 to 25.000 VND/tree Jack: From 50.000 to 120,000 VNDltree Longan: From 60,000 to 120,000VNDitree Thistle: From 30.000 to 50.000 VNDitree Roi loi: From I000 V N D I ~ ' Bamboo: From 10,000to 150,000VNDItree guava: From 50.000 to 120.000 VNDltree timber: From 100.000ro 150.000 VNDltree The compensation price basing on the replacement cost will be disclosed popularly in the public consultation. The procedure for compensation has 5 steps: 1. Applying value to the lost assets for compensation to each displaced household (with agreement confirmation of the affected households). 2. The summary of impacts and entitlement's summarizing his/her assets lost and their entitlements for compensation and other assistance will be disclosed to all affected persons at gathering places. 3. To submit compensation plan to the DPC of Dam Rong for approval. 4. The approved compensation plan will be disclosed 5. The compensation and assistance will be paid As of the end of November, 2008, the compensation will be paid to the displaced households with total estimated amount of VND5,883,672,4 I6VND. This cost is breakdown as follows: Table 2: Estimation of Resettlement Cost - Types1 Categories Quantity Unit price Cost (VND) (W~irn') 1 Permanent loss of lands 4,841,375,500 1. Residential land 21 1 20,500 4,325,500 2. Garden land 23,405 l 1,500 269,157,500 2. Rice land 48,500 5,500 266,750,000 3. Burnt-over land 948,233 4,500 4,267,048,500 4. Forest land 70 14,273,000 5 Temporary loss of burnt-over land 19,821 1,000 19,821,000 (ro be pard equal to lond renf) 425,003,916 Loss of trees and crops Loss of trees 8.725 trees Dependingon 425,003,916 kind of plant. age or plant 3 Impact of houses and structure 266,413,000 1. Houses 21 1 1,028,000 2 16,908,000 2. Cattle-shed 112.3 250.000 28.1 25.000 3. Fences 213,8 100,000 21,380,000 4. Impact of public assets 350,880,000 2,400 5,883,672,416 5.2. Assistance The assistance amount as per the regulations specified in RPF and issued by the province includes livelihood rehabilitation, house shifting, production and support to poor households and pol icy households. The assistant amount will be paid since the DPs taking over land to the contractor for construction. The assistance to arrangement of new jobs and training for change of their production for displaced households losing more than 10%of their holding land will be carried out after delivering the land around one month because it needs time to assess the training needs and prepare training conditions. The assistance will be performed along with the bonus payment tor the DPs who timely hand the affected land to the project volunrar~ly.The bonus payment will be also informed to the displaced households before one month. The estimated costs for the assistance are as follows: Table 10: The estimated cost for the assistances Type of assistance Quantity Unit price (VND) Cost(VND) 1 Assistance to livelihood rehabilitation 567,900,000 I . Households losing less than 10% of 17 persons 3 months x 30 kg rice 15,300,000 *----I 2. Households losing more than 20% of --- 264 persons 1 6 months x 50 kg riceI 475,200,000 land I 3. Relocated households 43 persons 6 months x 30 kg rice 77,400,000 . 2 Shifting/transportation allowance 18,000,000 1. Shifting/ transportation allowance 03 households 2,000,000/household 6,000,000 within the remaining residential land.' 2. Shifting/ transportation allowance to 04 households ~,000,000/household 12,000,000 the new resettlement site 3 The assistance to arrangement of new 705,000,000 jobs and training for change of their production The affected households lost more than 5,000,000 705,000,000 10% of land (losing from 10% to 50%. training for I labour will be provided; losing from 50% to 70%, training for 2 labour will be provided; and losing more than 70%, training for all member of household. will be orovidedi --F@@q I ~~- - ~ 4 Social allowance I Assist to households under the threshold 57 households 57,000,000 1 of poverty 5 Incentive Bonus 136,000,000 Incentive bonus for DP who timely 68 households 2,000,000 136,000,000 hand the affected land to the project I . . voluntarily ITotal 1,483,900,000 5.3.Resettlement There are three (03) households lost houses and a pan of the residential lands. The remaining area is enough to re-build their houses without relocation. 02 households among 04 households losing whole house and residential land already have other residential land areas in village and they will shift to their existing land. 02 remaining households bought residential land from their relatives in village. Thus, all affected households will relocated within village and it is not necessary to provide a new resettlement site. The affected households will be compensated by cash at replacement cost for lost residential land, affected house, cattle sheds and fences. In addition, they will be supported the shifting allowance and other allowance for self-shifting and self-resettlement. 5.3.2.Resett/ement Implementation According to the schedule. the payment for colnprnsatlon and allowance will be made a1 the end of November 2008. After that. households can relocate in any appropriate time. The subproject developer will disclose the plan of \Later level of rewr~oirfor all affected ho~rsehold\lo know when their land is affected and resettle initiativel~ VI. INCOME AND LIVELIHOOD REHABILITATION PROGRAM FOR DISPLACED PERSONS After consulting with the displaced persons, local government, the local relevant agencies and basing on the assessment of DP's actual condition, PMB of the subproject agrees with the compensation and site clearance committee of the DPC of Chu Pah, Chu Pah Rubber Company that they will co-ordinate with DPs to conduct the income and livelihood rehabilitation program as follows: A. S~ecificactivities 1. The compensation will be paid at the market price and made one time payment with other support cost to ensure that the displaced persons will have a fund to recover their income generation and livelihood. 2. The subproject developer has coordinated with the DPC of Chu-Pah and the Chu-Pah rubber company to develop the program on delivering area for planting rubber to the affected households in order to generate stable income source. The program shall start conducting on January 2009. Accordingly, each affected household will receive.04 ha of land for planting rubber. Chu-Pah Rubber Company shall support seedlings, organize training of rubber planting and caring techniques. The affected households will plant, take care of rubber and will receive 02 basic benefits, consisting of (i) In the first 04 years, when rubber trees are not grown'up, the households shall grow additionally other trees into the rubber planting land area and shall receive full this harvest; (ii) will receive a lumpsum amount for growing and taking care of rubber trees and will be paid monthly. According to the calculation, the income of households in the first 04 years will be 24,000,000VND/household/year. After 04 years, the income of households will decrease due to no grow additionally other trees. However, their income level is still very good (about 16,000,000VNDlhouseholdlyear). 3. The DPC of Chu-Pah and the Program 661 of Northwest Dak Doa agree to convert a part of forest land area, which is favorable for cultivation into production land and delivery to affected households due to agricultural land loss. Accordingly, the forest land area of around 60ha which is very favorable for agricultural production in the small section 206 nearly Hre village will be converted into the production land and delivery to households losing agricultural land. The converted land has high humus degree, so it is suitable to grow rice in first crops, then grow other plants such as maize, cassava. According to the schedule, the allocation of land to households will be made in January 2009. This program shall be documented in writing and circulated to all relevant agencies of district, commune; Program 61 of Northwest Dak Doa and subproject developer by the DPC of Chu Pah for implementation. 4. Apart from the forest land area to.be converted into the production land. an area of 6.0 ha has been planned for the affected households to reclaim and expand their cultivation area. The affected households are encouraged to register reclaimable land area, the subproject developer will support for fertilizers, seedlings and manday for reclaiming in accordance with the unit price specified by Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee. 5. According to the affected persons' opinion, the poverty is caused by shortage of investment capital and cultivation and breeding skills. After receiving the compensation cash, the households have full capital for production, because each household receives the compensation cash with amount of over 50,000.000 VND excluding other allowance. The remaining matter is provided training to improve culrivation and breeding skills for affected households. The subproject developer has coordinated with ('hii-Pah economic office to develop a Program on training cultivation and breeding technology, including topics such as growing and caring technology of rice. maize. cassava (foci~singon rice. maize. cassava with high productivity, hybridized rice, hybridized maize); technology of breeding and disease prevention for cattle, poultry (focusing on breeding pigs for food. sows, fowls, cows for food and reproductive cows). The training program will be held before paying the compensation cash around 15 days and will be held again after paying compensation 2 days. The training materials will be translated into Bana language and delivered to all participated households. 6. Members of affected households will given priority for employment by the subproject for suitablejobs (construction, planting trees, path widening .etc..) in the process of construction preparation, constructing the plants, maintenance and repairs .etc.. This income source is very stable because the works need about 30 local labourers for 24 months. 7. The households loosing from 10% to 50% of the agricultural land will be supported with the vocational training for 01 member of the family, from 50% to 70% will be supported with the vocational training for 02 member of the family and from more than 70% will be supported with the vocational training for all member of the family. The job to be trained will be consulted for selection by the household. Vocational training will be developed after making compensation of 01 month. B. Institutional arrangement and estimated cost The subproject developer will coordinate closely with relevant departments, agencies and local authorities to organize implementation of the income and livelihood rehabilitation program, as follows: - The subproject developer will coordinate with the compensation and site clearance committee of district to pay compensation cash and allowance to the affected households as per the approved schedule and the compensation cash will be paid one time. - The subproject developer will coordinate with Chu-Pah Rubber Company, the CPC of Dak To Ve and Ha Tay and the affected households to implement the program on delivering rubber planting land to the affected households. - The subproject developer will coordinate with the Afforesting Program 661 of Northwest Dak Doa and the CPC of Dak To Ve to convert using purpose of forest land area permitted by the DPC of Chu Pah and delivery to the affected households. - The subproject developer will coordinate with the DPC of Dak To Ve and Ha Tay and the affected households to reclaim the area planned for the purpose of reclamation in the community. - The subproject developer shall coordinate with the economic office of Chu-Pah District, the CPC of Dak To Ve and Ha Taj and the affected households to carry out programs on training to improve cultivalion, breeding technologies for the affected households. - The subproject developer will carry out a employment program to prioritize local labour. Simultaneously. the subproject will coordinate with the vocational training centers to carry out vocational training for members of the affected households. - The heads of villages, public consultation at commune level, social organizationsand the CPC of Dak To Ve and Ha Tay will coordinate with the subproject developer to carry out activities of the income and livelihood rehabilitation program, simultaneously to monitor, supervise the subproject developer in the implementation of program. - The DPC of Chu-Pah will monitor. assess the imple~nentationof income and livelihood rehabilitation program. The estimated cost for he program is VND135,000,000, including cost relating to reclamation (manday, feni lizers, seedlings), cost for training to improve cultivation, breeding technologies and other cost. VII. PUBLIC CONSULTAI'ION AND PARTICIPATION OF THE DISPLACED PERSONS 7.1. Parricipalion of the displaced persons The information relating to the subproject will be disclosed to 10 affected villages of 2 communes Dak To Ve and Ha Tay to ensure that they are fully aware of the impacts of the subproject and participate into various phases of the construction works. The information is summarized briefly and is disclosed to displaced people living at ten villages by the popular language ( King's language) and Ba-na language. The information booklet is provided in the Annex 9 (Vietnamese version) and Annex 10 (Ba-na version). This document consists 07 main parts: (i) Introduction; (ii) Impacts of the subproject; (iii) Entitlements relating to the compensation, assistance and resettlement of displaced persons; (iv) Implementation plans; (v) Relevant documents; (vi) participation of displaced persons; and (vii) grievance procedures. This document is prepared in the form of question and answer to ensure that the community can understand documents easily. The document is printed by colour and prepared by two languages (the 2009 wall calendar having nice pictures) so that the households can keep and hang it at home for reading, monitoring and supervising the implementation later. The inhabitants living in the affected areas are invited to discuss with the subproject developer about the plan of compensation. assistance and resettlement and all other activities. The subproject developer proposes the implementation plan (socio-economic censu.s. inventory of the affected assets, compensation, resettlement and income and livelihood rehabilitation .etc..). Accordingly, the participants have opinions and agree the implementation schedules with the subproject developer. During the implementation phase, the public consultation relating to the compensation, assistance and resettlement will be conducted actively. All affected households, leader of the village, representative of social organizations should conduct inventory of the affected assets. The replacement cost will be detined basing on the participation of head of the village, representative of social organizations and displaced persons. The displaced persons living at ten affected villages also participate into developing the income and livelihood rehabilitation program and monitoring the implementation plan of agreed activities. Basing on the information booklet of the subproject, the inventory of the affected assets, resettlement plan, matrix of entitlements and relevant documents should be disclosed. The community and displaced persons should be participated into the monitoring and supervision of compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement and income and livelihood rehabilitation program. 7.2. Public consulralion On 01'' August 2008, Dak To Ve PPC issued a Decision to establish a Coninlittee of public consultation of the commune and on 04lhAugust, 2008, Ha Tay PPC also issued a Decision to establish a Committee of public consultation of the commune with its objective of carrying out coordination among the subproject developer, site clearance and compensation committee of Chu Pah district, commune authority and residents in order to carry out public consultation effectively. The actual situation shows that due to limited language skills and the habit of being shy in contacting the authority, the ethnic minority do not discuss directly their concerns about the policy. Members of the Committee of the public consultation shall mainly include the village head and representatives from social association/union well trained for .the job, having full information and doculnents in order to carry out the consultation effectively. The.decision of establishing the Committee of the pirblic consultation of the commune is attached in Annex 11 and Annex 12. Table 11: Functions and duties of Comn~itteeof Public Consultation at conlmunal kvel -1 According to the article 2 of ~ e c i s i o n z nestablishin~rnmunalCommittee of pc~blicconsultation of Dak To Ve and Ha Tay, the functions and duties of Comm~tteeot'p~~hliccons~~ltatinnart: as fnllo\r's: 1 1. Coordinating with Committee of Compensation and site clearance of district and the subproject developer to carry out the public consultation at affected billages in the subproject site. 2. Coordinating with the departments, branches and related parties to supervise, evaluate the operations related to the compensation, the resettlement and development of the ethnic minority such as inventory of aflected assets, compensation, resettlement, development of the livelihoods etc . - -. In fact, the Committee of public consultation plays a role of a facilitator for the process of public consultation. The displaced people can ask for information of compensation policy at any time without waiting until the information dissemination campaign to be conducted, access to the project documents. i he Committee of public consultation can support the residents during the process of grievance settlement, exchange information regularly (because members of the Committee include the village head and the head of mass organizatioll at the village' level), coordinate with the compensation and site clearance committee of district and the subproject developer in implementing public consultation, inform to the compensation and site clearance committee of district and the subproject developer all issues associated with the compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement. The public consultation Committee has been trained b!, the subproject developer and the committee of compensation and site clearance of district about all requirements of public consultation, impacts of the project, matrix of entitlements, delivery of the related documents and implementation plan of public consultation. The communal Committee of public consultation, the subproject developer and the Committee of compensation and site clearance of Chu Pah district coordinates to be held meetings at 10 \/illages in order to make consultatiorl of the subproject. The level of impacts, the negative and positive impacts, the mitigation measures and other implementation plan (inventory of affected assets, disclose of inventory results and compensation etc) are consulted with the affected community in these meetings. All residents of the ten villages, representative of the mass organizations and the head of village also participate into these meetings. The meeting of public consultation on impact levels of the subproject, the matrix ofentitlernents, the compensation policies, the reg.t:Iation of compensation, rehabilitatiorr, rescttlemer~tand grievance procedures was held on August. 2008. All affected households participated into these meetings. The minute of the meeting is attached at Annex 13.The matrix of entitlements and the policy of conipenbation. assistance and resel~lcrnrntare dibtrib~ltcdto the I i o ~ ~ ~ c l ~and d ~ t i lpasted at head office of the CPC of Dak To Ve and lia Tay. at home of the village heads and at the gathering place of villages. The inventory of affected assets is conducted with the participation of public consultation Committee at the commirnal level. village heads. and representatices of the mass organizations and householders. The summary on inventor) of affected is prepared for each ho~~seholdand distributed to each household to check within 05 days. This summary is also pasted at the ofice of CPC, at home of the village head and at the gathering place of villages. The inventory group stays at the village within 07 days to rebolve all complaints, check damages again if required. The cost of compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement (basing on the matrix of entitlements and the result of inventory of affected assets) is calculated for each household and distributed to the households. This result is pasted at the office of CP.C, at home of the village head and the gathering place of taking water of villages. The other meeting of public consultation with participation of all affected households was held to consult all issues associated with inventory of affected assets, compensation pricing, mitigation measures of adverse impacts, income and livelihood rehabilitation program and operations of compensation, assistance and resettlement. The meeting agreed the implementation plans for next activities associated with compensation, assistance and resettlement. All relevant documents like information booklet, policy of compensation, resettlement, results of inventory of affected assets, compensation pricing, income and livelihood rehabilitation program and implementation plan for next activities etc have been distributed to the households and 01 set for the Committee of public consultation at commune level. Basically, the Committee can explain, provide full information to the affected households. After the approved compensation, assistance and resettlement plan. the subpro-jectdeveloper will coordinate with the compensation and resettlement committee of Chu Pah district and the Committee of public consultation at commune level to conduct consultation for this plan. 7.3. Settlement of complaintsand grievances The senlement of complaint and grievances has been discussed in detail to the affected households the community. All displaced persons will have the right to lodge complaints as the following legal basis: 1. The displaced persons disagree with the policy of compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement and other relevants, they would submit the complaints in writing to the CPC of Dak To Ve and Ha Tay or inform in the verbal manner (verbal) to a member of community consultation committee of the CPC. So that, the committee will take responsibility to work closely with the CPC to resolve a complaint. The CPC will resolve a complaint within a time limil of I 5 days. 2. In case, the agreement and conciliation are not obtained or the displaced persons don't receive any response within a time limit of I5 days as from the date of receipt of the complaint, the displaced persons will have the right to lodge a further complaint with the District Resettlement Committee/ Land Clearance Committee of the DPC of Chu Pah. Where the complaints will be resolved within 15 days from the date of receipt of such grievance. 3. Where a complainant disagrees with the decision on resolution by the DPC or the Representative of Committee, or the CPC doesn't reply within 15 days, it shall have the right to lodge the further complaints with the Provincial People Committee. The Representative of PPC will resolve within 30 days from the date of receipt of such the complant. 4. Where a complainant disagrees with the decision on resoliltion of thc complaint issued by the PPC or Provincial Resettlement committee, ir shall have the right to complaint to the People's Court in accordance with the regulations of the law. Detailed procedures for grievance redress and specific steps are described in the information booklet of the subproject and has been distributed to the displaced persons. The information booklet also provides fully name, address and telephone of persons in charge of resolving the complaints. The displaced persons will be exempted from administrative and legal fees. 'The fee for lodging the complaint with the People's Court will be even exempted. All grievance dossiers will be kept at the CPC of Dak To Ve and Ha Tay, Consultation Committee at commune level and subproject developer. VIII. SUPERVISION, M0NITORIN.G AND EVALUATION I n t e r n a l rnornitoring The subproject implementing agencies are responsible for conducting the internal rnornitoring of Resettlement Plan one time per motnth. The subproject developer will coordinate with the CPC of Dak To Ve and Ha Tay, Consultation Committee at communal level to supervise, momitor and evaluate the implementation of compensation, assistance and resefflement basing on the followingmornitoring indicators. Table 12: Basic indicators for supervision, mornitoring and evaluation Issues 1 Basic indicators 1.lmplementation plan 1- The plan has been discussed with the - The plan is suitable to the actual condition and is coordinated with the affected persons. - The plan is suitablelproper to the schedule of the other operations. - The manpower of carrying out the plan fully I - The *--I cost for carrying out the plan significantly 2. Compensation for land and crops 1 - Checking. counting the damages exactly. - Schedule of the land acquisition, compensation, the land delibery . -The simple procedure of the compensation. - The measures to mitigate the compensation of the land and crops is carried out well or not (acquiring the land after planning t work, the compensation for one time etc) 3. Assistance - Ensuring the performed supports as specified in the matrix of entitlements. - Schedule ofcarrying out the compensation - l'he s~mpleprocedure of' compensation and making payment - The stabilizationlintegration of the resettlement person at the new living place (administration, procedure etc). -The land area assigned in accordance to the regulation. - The conditions ot the infrastructure (Finished), the quallty of the infrastructure, the maintenance, the repair etc.) 5. Income and livelihood rehabilitation - The activities of the livelihoods are carried out as approved plan. - The attected people together make participation. 6. Public Information Dissemination - The affected householdslthe communitylthe communal authority ithe mass organization are fully disclosed information on the policy of compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement, implementation plan and grievance settlement procedures. - The affected peoplelthe community1 the local authority /women's association participale into the related activities, I I especially the supervision of implementing the compensation, 1 1 ( - -- assistance and resettlement. 7. Grievance and complaint procedures I - The affected households and the colnrnunity clearly I I understand the grievance procedures. I ( - Committee of public consultation ar communal le~elfthc ( com~nun~~lpcoplr's comlnltter clearly underhtand the grlekance / proczdu~rs and can support the affectcd people to lodge I I complaints. -- __J The internal monitoring report will be submitted quarterly to DPC of Chu Pah, DOIT of Cia Lai province and will be submitted to the PB on the regular basis. The local authorities, especially the DPC of Cia Lai will participate in supervision, monitoring of compensation, assistance and resettlement to ensure that the land acquisition and entitlement of displaced persons will be implemented in compliance with the approved resettlement and compensation plan, the information dissemination will be conducted by subproject developer and district resettlement committee and the displaced persons will be participated into the income and livelihood rehabilitation program, the grievance redress procedures will be complied and the consultation with displaced persons will be carried out adequately by subproject developer and district resettlement committee. The PBs are responsible for conducting the internal supervision, monitoring and evaluation of subproject to ensure that the subproject meets all requirements under REDP. External monitoring and evaluation The independent monitoring agency will be invited to carry out the external monitoring, supervision and evaluation. The objective of external monitoring is to provide evaluation, supervision of resettlement plan, changes on living standard and job, income rehabilitation. The external monitoring will be conducted on an annual basis, except for the case that the initial phase will be required to conduct a twice yearly supervision. The external monitoring and evaluation will concentrate on reviewing pfogress indicators and sustainable indicators, providing some lessons and recommending measures to improve the performance of the compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement and livelihoods rehabilitation plan. IX. REPORTING The subproject developer will submit the Resettlement Plan to the DOlT of Cia Lai province and World Bank for reviewing and approval. After obtaining the approval, the subproject developer will submit the quarterly progress report on implementation of Resettlement Plan to the DOlT of Cia Lai and PB. The submission of the quarterly report will be finalized when completing the activities of the compensation, rehabilitation, resettlement and livelihoods development. X. IMPLEMENTATlON PLAN 'The resettlement plan will be carried out as follows: X1.RESETTLEMENT COST AND BUDGET The resettlement cost is estimated by V N D 8,368,329,657, equiva.lent to US$ 50,824.0. The breakdown is presented in the following table: Table 13: Estimation of Resettlement Cost - Description Cost (VND) I Compensation 5,883,672,41 6 2 Assistance and bonus 1,483,900,000 b Z e 5 n d livelihood rehabilitation program 1 35,000,000 1 4 1 lnstitutional arrangement 1 7~.00cl.000I 1 1 External monitoring and evaluation 1 Contingency (1 I I 0%) 7 6 0 , 7 5 7 4 I Total 8,368,329,657 All resettlement cost will be covered by s~~bprojectdeveloper. ANNEXES Annex 1 List of permanently acquired land for each household Ha Tay Commune (Chu Pah District, Gia Lai Proviuce) -Chu Pah Rubber Company : 64800 m2 Annex 2 List of permanently acquired land for each household Dak To Ve Commune (Chu Pah District, Gia Lai Province) Annex 3 The temporarily acquired land area for each household (Ha Tay commune, Chu Pah district,Cia Lai province) Lost burnt-over land (m2) Annex 4 The affected trees and crops for each household (Ha Tay commune, Chu Pah district, Gia Lai province) I Name of Address 1 I the affected 1 Log of 1 household Ethnic Banana Guava Mango Bamboo Boiloi Thistle Jacqkfrui Longan Coffe wood Papaya Total - t e tree ---- ppp 1 Mik Kon Komo Ba-na 8 [ 20 28 2 Khhn Kon Komo Ba-na 5 15 20 I3 Khyin Konsulal Ba-na 65 1 100 1 166 4 Khuit Konsc~lal Ba-na 5 1 I 20 1 72 5 Hyuih 1Konsolhng Ba-na 15 50 1 65 6 Juh Konsalang Ba-na , 55 7 62 - 7 Than Konsalang Ba-na 33 8 226 11 267 8 Kruih Konsulsng Ba-na 40 I 41, 9 Khoeh Konsulang Ba-na 15 4 1 40 1 59 1 Djdoh Konsolang Ba-na 0 2 1 I 42 63 I Hyung Konsolilng Ba-na I ___c_ 34 6 1 6 101 5 152 P 1 Dr61 Kon nghel Ba-na 2 35 73 1 Kyer Kon nghel Ba-na 3 7 4 11 A 1 llyiu Konsolal Ba-na 4 125 4 3 170 1 1 fhup Konsolal Ba-na 5 20 18 1 Lui Konsalal Ba-na 6 16 13 28 57 Annex 5 The affected trees and crops for each household (Ha Tay commune, Chu Pah district, Gia Lai province) I Name of Address I Bamboo Boiloi Thistle Iacqkfrui Longan Coffe Log of Papaya Total t r wood househol l tree d --- I TUY Hde Ba-na 50 10 2 100 162 - 2 OEN Hde Ba-na 200 1 250 I 45 1 yHdepp 400 -Ba-na 10 41 1 - -- - --- - -- -- 1 - Ba-na . 250- 10 7 25 292 1 Ba-na 2 2 128 3 160 - 25 Ba-na 114 1 3 2 1 120 -- 240 H V l l Ba-na 154 25 1 180 , Ba-na l 7 _ 2 2 2-I Hde Ba-na 54 I 18 r---,ppT-- 73 Hde Ba-na I 1 '0 HIT 16 10 26 1 1 Hde Ba-na I YUNG 37 15 52 , 1 1 Hde Ba-na , 1 I 2 1TU'ONG 10 2 18 30 1 Hde Ba-na 3 THAN 25 I 2 18 46 1 H de Ba-na 4 I-INIU 47 2 24 73 1 Hde Ba-na 5 PHANH 100 ---- 5 100 4 209 pp 1 Hde Ba-na 6 KRANH 340 3 5 4 352 1 Hde Ba-na 7 AJLflI 125 3 1og 2 230 1 Hde Ba-na .. I 8 ' HNIU t 150 3 4 a 20 180 2 ' , : 2-a dk + I AYAIH . I' w Hde 1 Ba-na 130 + 5 . - 136 Annex 6 List of households suffering affection on houses and structures (Dak To Ve commune, Chu Pah district, Gia Lai province) Annex 7 Socioeconomic Status of Subproject Affected Households -Subproject Impacts and Compensation, Rehabilitation Measures - - - - Characteristics of Affected HH Subproject Impacts Compensation and Reh. I I ( Total Total of Numbers - Land ':?:; Land for land Nilnli ol'tlradr ill' of Occvpationi PuorNulnerable Area o f land Compensation Life Rehabilitation llouseholds compensatio Persons of HHs t4l-l~ u;plF to be acquired in cash year lost Movemen1 Occupati in llHs n (m2) (30 kg (VND) (nl2) rice* 10.000vndc3 assistance (2.000.00 rnonthslperson) Mik 1.323 6 I-armins 8000000 Poor 22.323 5.93% 3969000 854 5.400000 I?h5n rarm~ng Poor 3.234 - I I --- 7000000 13.234 24.44% 8.085000 2OR7 19.800.000 Z 0011000 -- --- Khyin 1;armtng 1000000 Poor 8143 6 0 28.143 28.93% 20357500 5254 10800000 2 (N Khu.it 1arrnlng 10OM)00 Poor 6.557 6 0 36.557 17.94% 16392500 4.231 10.800000 -- 2 000000 Hyu.ih Farrnlng 10O(W.OO Poor 19688 !I 0 39.688 49.61% 49.2201100 12.704 I6200000 2 000000 J L U ~ Farming 10OOO00 Poor 19.091 7 0 59.091 32.31% 47727500 12.318 I 2600000 2000000 Than Farm~ne Poor 16022 8 Kh6ngXD 36.022 44.48% 40055IKX, 10.338 14.400.000 2 000000 Kruih rarming 1301X)OO Poor 12.815 5 0 37.815 33.89% 32037500 8.269 9.000.000 2000000 Khoeh Farming 17566 2 4.000000 32.566 53.94% 43915 000 1 1.334 3.600.000 4000000 D-jaoh Farrn~ng Poor 13 7000000 -- 50,57% 51 152500 4000000 Hyung Farming IOW0.00 Poor 24503 i~- 12 0 49.503 49.50% 61257i00 15.810 21.600.000 20 0 0 9 DrBi Farm~ng Pa>r 1 317 7 R MOOOrJ 31.317 4.21% 3.292.SU0 850 6.300.000 Kyer Farming Ponr 16.788 12 -8000000 46.788 35.88% 41.970000 10.832 21.600.000 2.000000 H~ T u Farming Poor 29725 3 6.000000 59.725 49.77% 74.312500 19 180 5.400.000 2.000000 Thup Farming 1 1.000.00 Poor 25.635 14 0 65.635 39.06% 64087500 16.541 25.200.000 20 0 0 ~ Lki Farming Poor 23.937 3 9000000 53.937 44,38% 15.445 5.400.000 2oOO.000 AN Fannlng 4 3000000 20 370 3 370 16.54% 8 425 000 2 174 7 200 000 2 X l O U Farm~ng 10 00000 Poor THUY 5 0 30513 12513 41,01% 31282500 8 074 9000000 2000 (9 Farm~ng 1400000 Poor VII'ONG --- 3 -- 0 23 029 12029 52.23% 30 072 500 7 762 5 400 000 - 4 000 000 Farm~ng Poor HYU'K 3 8 000 000 26 101 4 601 17,63% 1 1 502 500 2 969 5 400 000 2 000 COO Farming Poor GLAl 6 Khdng XD 14937 3 937 26.36% 9 842 500 2 540 I 0 800 000 2 0 0 0 ( ! Farming Poor -- M IN 6 6 000 000 22 867 1 867 8,16% 4 667 50P 1 205 5 400 000 Farmlng --- AYU'IH 5 KhBng XD 28 078 1 1 078 39,45% 27 695 000 7 148 9 000 000 2 000 000 Farmma Poor Y LI'P , 8 8 000 000 19978 7 978 39.93% 19945 000 5 148 14 400 000 2 000 000 Farm~ng Poor DJlP 3 8 000 000 29 942 18942 63,26% 47 355 000 I2 222 5 400 000 4 OW 0 0 ~ Farmlng ' Poor BYAU - - - --- 6 7000000 - 33 823 6 823 20.17% 17057500 4 402 10 800 000 -- - -- 2 000 000 Fdrmlng Poor - JIUH 2 Khbng XD 26 252 11 252 42.86% 28 130000 7 260 3 600 000 --? 000 00 I Farming Poor P H ~--U 8 >6 679 17 138 47.51% 55 430 OW 1 1 252 28 800 000 3 000 000 ? 000 OUO -- HLOI 3 10 863 23 692 57,98% ---- 64 442 500 15 287 10 800000 3 000 000 4 000 000 Farn~ng Poor I -- R U - A Y I E N G 5 -- DJU'I 3 DJUIH 5 DAN 4 TOAN ? will - 2 I--/- -- 1 Farming RUNG - 6 0 20.98 I 3.481 16.59a/o 8.702 500 2.246 I0.800 000 2000 000 Fanning Poor I KER 3000.030 16.391 4.391 26.79% 10.977.500 2 833 12.600.000 2.000000 Farmlng Poor I LA[ 8 000 000 15185 1.185 7.80% 2.962 500 765 2.700.000 Farm~ng Poor YHANH 5 000 000 26.408 13.408 50,77%' 33.520 000 8 651 7.200000 4.000 000 Farm~ng Poor 3 0 ~ 5000.000 13 840 2.140 15.46% 5.350 000 1.381 7.200.000 2 000 000 1 Farming ADLlCll 1 I 2.000.000 30.872 15.000 Farming Poor ADU'K 4 6.0000~) 14.716 3 216 Farm~ng Poor MfN 5 8.000000 31.421 11.421 Farm~ng BIU 3 9 000 000 40 520. 13520 Famlng 10000 00 Poor BAI 4 o 18568 I 568 Fanlng Poor GIU 4 3 ow 000 22 363 1 363 Famlng IHNHA 1 3 1 / 600oooo 1 I Farm~ng 4 7 000 000 Poor 32 029 5 029 Farming . 8 000000 23215 4 215 I dnds w ~ t hno1 Annex 8 List of participants of the in-depth interview and the focused group discussion (Socioeconomic census) Name Position 1 BiCn V~cePresident of the People Committee ot' Ha Tay Commune --- - 2 Khak Cadastral stalt'of Ha ray Commune -- 3 Hneih Chairman of Committee for Fatherlands Front of Hatay Commune 4 Ytn Chairman of Women's Union Ha Tay Commune - -5 Uu Chairman of Farmers' Union Ha Tay Commune 6 Khoan Head of Kon So Lang hamlet - 7 YBn Head of Kon Bah hamlel 8 Dyat Head of Konhngleh hamlet . - ---- p- 9 Hyunh Head of Kon So Lai hamlet ------ 10 AMach t lead ol' Kon Lo mu hamlet --- --- 1 I Ru a YiCng V~cepresident of the People's Committee Dak To Ver Commune -- 12 ~ r A nVan Phong Land survey officer Dak To Ver commune 13 Uch tiead of Tueh hamiel Thuch Head of Om hamlet Yung Head of Hde hamlet 18 A Yiri Chairman of Commitlee of Fatherland Front of Commune 19 Pluk Chairman ofthe Elderly's Union of commune 2 0 Hich Chairman of Women's Union of commune -- --- 21 Va Thanh Minh Director of Chu Pah rubber company -- 22 V3 Thao Head ofeconomic department. Chu Pah rubber company - 23 Dual Inhabitant of Hre village -. - 24 Hniu Inhabitant of I Ire illage \ - 25 Hlot Inhabitant of Goech village -- 26 Vhit lnhahilant of' Mor village -- - 27 Biang Inhabitant of Kon So Lai village 28 Ngui Inhabitant c ~ lKon so Lai village ' -- 29 HuyCn Inhabitant 01' Kon Bah village 30 Phirt Inhabitant of Kon Bah village -31 DrBi Inhabitant oVKon Nghel village 32 Kyer Inhabitant of Kon Nghel village Annex 9 Questionnaire to the affecteded households Ha f a y Small Hydropower sub-project Hamlet: ............................................ Commune: ....................................... I. Information about the householder 1. - Householder's full name: ................................................................................................. 2. Age: ........................................................................................................................... 3.Sex: Male 0 Female U 4.- Ethnic group: ................................................................................................................................ 5.- Education (which grade at school): ...................................... 6.-Can you read and write well the Kinh language? Ycs O No 1 7.-Can you communicatewell in Kinh language(understand all contentsof communication)?Yes O No O 8. Major occupation of the householder (the one taking the most of time): ................................ 9.How often does the householder go out of the commune: + Go out ofthe commune everyday 0 + Go out of the commune once a week 0 + Go out of the commune once a month 0 + Go out ofthe commune once a year 0 +Other than aforesaid (specib): .................................................................. 10.Reasonsof going out of the commune +7'0 carry out business 0 + To visit relatives. friends 0 +Tobuyfoodforthefamily 0 + Cultural activities, entertainment 0 + Other than the aforesaid (specify): ................................................................ 11. General information about the household: 1I. Total number of persons in the family: ................................................................ 12. Information about the tamily members (not including the householder) Member I: Male 0 Female 0 Age: .............. Education (which grade)....................................... Member 2: Male 0 Female Age: .............. Education (which grade)....................................... Member 3: Male 0 Female 0 Age: ..............Education (which grade)...................................... Member 4: Male 0 Female 0 Age: ..............Education (which grade)..................................... Member 5: Male 0 Female 1 Age: ..............Education (which grade)...................... ............ .. Member 6: Male 0 Female [I Age: ..............Education (which grade)....................................... Member 7: Male 0 Female 0 Age: .............. Education (which grade)....................................... Member 8: Male 0 Ibemille I1 Age: ..............IZducation (\\hich grade)...................................... Member 9: Male O Female fl Age: ..............Education (which grade)..................................... Member 10: Male 0 Female 0 Age: .............. Education (which grade)..................................... 13. How many t'amily members cannotconimunicate well in Kinh language? ............................................ 14. How many hmily members cannot rcad and write in Kinh languagec?.......................... .. ................ 15. Which language is used among the famil) members: ............................................... I l l . Economic activities of the household 16. Major job ot' the household (job being done by the most of the family members, taking the most of time): 17. Apart from the major job. what is the second,job ol' the family: ............................ .. ....................... 18. Which o f the followings, the household is categorised: + Poor household 0 + Middle household 0 + Better off household I1 + Rich household 0 19. Is the family supported by any Government's Support Programs? Program 133 N o 0 Yes 0 I f yes, what are the supports: ..................... Program 134 N o 0 Yes 0 Ifyes, what are the supports: ...................... Program 135 No 0 Yes 0 Ifyes, what are the supports: ...................... 20. What activity tiom which is the main income source ol'the liimily? ...................................................... 21. How much is the estimated income in 2007 o f the lamily (VND) ................................................. (Merhod o/calclclationr To add up all /he prodrrc/s /hefami!v gained sYch ns rice, callle, poullty converled inlo money,lhen deducling !he im~estrnen/s.sirch a.7 ferlili-er. pe.rricide, collie-feed hrr~not ded~rctingwork's p q Then add 10 other earned amounts of money gany 10 form /he income of /he u~holeyear). 22. How much is the expected expenditure in 2007 o f the family (To add up all estimated expenses such as for food, medical treatment, school fee, travel, purchase o f t'urniture in 2007)? ....................... 23. What kind o f plants is the family growing: -Coffee 0 Mango 0 Pepper 0 Banana 0 Rice 0 - Cashew 0 Tea 0 Casava O Maize 0 Melon O - Other plants (specify) ........................................................................................................ +Among the above plants, which one brings the highest income to the family? 24. Which brings higher income to the family, growing on the mountain slopes or growing in the water fields? - Growing in the water fields brings higher income 0 - Growing on the mountain slopes brings higher income 0 25. What animals is the household breeding? - Pig II H0\4 many heads: ........................................................ -Poultry 0 How many heads: ........................................................ - Goat 0 How many heads: ........................................................ - Cattle I1 Hou man! heads: ...................................................... - Others (specify) ............................ :...How many heads: ....................................................... 26. In agricultural production, does the family encounter any difliculties'? (Stick the box ifthe household doens lack or meet difficulties, do not stick the box if the household does not lack or meet difficulties) - Lack o f production land 0 - Lack o f irrigation water 0 - l.ack o f labour 0 - I.ack o f money for investment 0 - Lack o f market information 0 - I.ack scientitic and lrchnicul kno\vledgr ol'culti\atiori. breeding 0 - Other difticulties (specify) ............................................................................................. - No difticulties 0 27. In the following year (2009) does the family intend to develop any more production activities? -Not develop any more activities, uphold the existing ones 0 - Intend to develop more production activities (specify) .......................................................... IV. Living conditions of the household 28. In the family, who does the following work: - Work Women Men -Working in the fields, milpas 0 [I - Going ~. I to collect firewood 0 0 ----- - Going to take water 0 0 -- - Cooking for the family 0 0 - -Going to work as hired labor 0 0 - Washing clothes 0 0 29. What water source is the family using tbr their domestic use: - Rain-water - Water from public tank - Water from river, spring 0 - Water from creeks, water points adjacent to house 0 - Water from drilled well 0 - Others (specify) ........................................................................................................ 30. What is the latrjne ofthe family like -There is no latrine, they relieve themselves in the forest, river, stream U -The temporarily covered latrine (with leaves, cloths, sacks......) 0 - Septic toilet 0 - Others (specify) ................................................................................................................ 3 1. What energy sources does the Family use for lighting'? - Grid connected electrici~ 0 - Small generator placed in the streamiriver ad.iacenr to the house ' 0 - Kerosene U - Firewood burnt all night 0 - No energy sources are used 0 - Others (specify) .................................................................................................................. .. 32. Which of the following things do you have in the family'? - Bicycle: Yes 0; No 0; I F yes, how many: ...................... - Motorcycle: Yes 0: No 0; It' yes, how many: ...................... - TV: Yes 0; No 0; If yes, how many: ...................... - Video, digital recorder: Yes 0; h o 0; I I'yes, how many: ...................... - Radio: Yes 0: No 0: I I'yes. ho\r man) : ...................... - Desk telephone: Ycs U: No O: If yes. how many: ...................... - Mobile telephone: Yes 0: No U: I ryes. h o \ ~many: ...................... - Electric fan: Yes 0: No O: I f \cs. ho\r man) : ...................... - Ox cart: Yes 0: No 0; Il'yes, how many: ...................... - Water pump: Yes 0: No U: ISyes. how many: ...................... - Electriccooker: Yes 0: No 0: If yes. how many: ...................... V. Awareness of Ha Tsy Small Hydropower sub-project 33. Do you know that Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project will be built in the locality or not? - Know 0 -Do not know 0 If you know, then by what means of communication? - Know through the family members U - Know through the friends, neighbors 0 - Know through the commune's leaders 0 - Knows through the District's compensation and land acquisition council 0 - Know through the developer, developer's staff 0 - Other sources (specify) ..........................................................................................:..................... 34. Do you know that your land, plants will be affected'? - Know 0 - Do not know 0 35. Do you accept for your affected land to be acquired for the hydropower sub-project? - Accept 0 Why do you accept ............................................................... - Do no1 accept 0 Why do you not accept ............................................................ 36. Ifa part of your agricultural land is lost, how do you want it to be compensated? - Land for land 0 - Cash for land at the agreed price 0 - Other methods (specify) ............................................................................................. 37. In general, according to you, how will HaTay Hydropower sub-project impact on the family life? - Do not impact 0 - Impact but insignificantly 0 - Impact negatively on the family life (specify) ................................................................................... Annex 10 Analysis result of questionnaires to the affected households Valid Cumulative Commune Frequency Percent Percent Percent DakToVe 43 76.8 76,s 76,s Ha Tay 13 23,2 23,2. 100,O Total 56 100,O l00,O I. Information about households. 1. Name of families Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent A Duc I 1,s 1,8 1,s A Duoi Ajuih Ayaih Ayuih Biang Bleh Bqih Byou Dan Djaoh PiiP Djuih En Giu Glai Hit Hlot Hniu Huyen Hvit Hyuih Hyuk Hyung Jiuh Ker Kheoh Kranh Kruit Lai Long Lui Ming Ngoi Nhanh Oen 1 1,8 1,s 64,3 Phanh I 1,s 1,s 66,l Phar 1 1,s 1,s 67,9 Phau 1 1,s 1,s 69,6 Phut 1 1,s 1,8 71,4 1,s Que I 1,s 73,2 Rong 1 1,8 1,s 75,O Ru A Yieng 1 1,s 1,s 76,s Tai 1 1,8 1 3 78,6 Than 2 3,6 3,6 82,1 Thup 1 1,8 1,s 83,9 Thuy I 1,s 1,8 85,7 Toan I 1.8 1.8 87,5 Tuh I 1,s 1,s 89,3 Tuong 1 1,8 1,s 9 1,l TUY I 1,s 1,8 92,9 Vui 1 1,8 . 1,s 94,6 Yil I 1,8 1,s 96,4 Yung 1 1,s 1,s 98,2 1,s YUP 1 1,8 1Oq,O Total 100,O 100,O -- 56 A 2. Age N Valid 56 Missing 0 Mean 39,48 Minimum 18 Maximum 78 3. - Gender Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Male 52 92,9 92,9 92,9 Female 4 7,l 7,1 100,O Total 56 100,O 100,O 4. Nationality Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Bana 56 100,O 100,O 100,O Total 56 100,O 100,O 100,O - 5. Education Statistics - - -- N Valid 56 Missing 0 Mean 2,52 Minimum 0 Maximum 9 Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent 1 1 1 3 1.8 35,7 2 I I 19,6 19,6 55,4 3 1 1 19,6 19,6 75,O 4 2 3,6 3.6 78,6 5 4 7,1 7.1 85,7 6 3 5,4 . 5,4 91,l 7 2 3,6 3,6 94,6 8 2 3,6 3,6 98,2 9 I 1,8 1,8 100,O Total 56 100.0 1 00,0 - - 6. Ability to read and write King language fluently. --- - Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Yes 27 48,2 48,2 48,2 No 29 51,8 51,8 100,O Total 56 100,O 100,O 7. Ability to communicate in King language fluently ( Understand conversation) Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Yes 28 50,O 50.0 50,O No 28 50,O 50,O 100,O Total 56 100,O 100,O 8. Major occupation of head of household. (Occupation which takes most of time) - Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Agriculture 56 100,O 100,O 100,O 9. How often head of household goes out of commune? - P Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Weekly 10 17,9 17,9 17,9 Monthly 13 23,2 23,2 41,l Yearly 33 58,9 58,9 100,O Total - 56 100,O 100.0 - 10. Reason of going out: Cases Col Response % For buying foods 2 3.6% For visiting relatives 55 --- 98,2% 11. General information about households 11. Number of persons in family: N Valid 56 Missing 0 Mean 5,27 Minimum 1 Maximum 12 Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent 2 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 12 Total 12.Information about family members (Not include head of household) Men Women Total Member 1 Count 7 49 56 Yo Member 2 Count Yo Member 3 Count Yo Member 4 Count Yo Member 5 Count 14 9 23 Yo 60,9% 39, 1% 1OO,O% Member 6 Count 13 4 17 Yo 76,5% 23,5% 1OO,O% Member 7 Count 10 3 13 Yo 76,9% 23,1% 1OO,O% Member 8 Count 4 4 8 Yo . 50,0% 50,094 1OO,O% Member 9 Count I 1 2 Yo 50,0% 50,0% 1 OO,O% Member 10 Count Yo Age of members Average age Member 1 37,88 Member 2 15,66 Member 3 10.88 Member 4 9,68 Member 5 8,05 Member 6 7,OO Member 7 . 4,69 Member 8 Member 9 Member 10 Education of members (which grage) Average education Member 1 3.09 Member 2 5,38 Member 3 Member 4 Member 5 3,78 Member 6 Member 7 Member 8 6,0000 Member 9 Member 10 13. How many family members cannot well communicate in King language ? N Valid 29 Missing 27 Mean 1,83 Minimum 0 Maximum 8 Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent 0 12 2 1,4 4 1,4 4 1,4 1 I 1,s 3,4 44,8 2 8 14,3 27,6 72,4 3 2 396 699 79,3 4 3 5,4 10,3 89,7 5 2 3,6 6,9 96,6 8 1 178 374 100,o Total 29 5 1.8 100.0 Missing 27 48,2 Total 56 100.0 14.How many family members cannot read and write King language ? N Valid 32 Missing 24 Mean 1,63 Minimum 0 Maximum 8 Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent 0 14 25,O 43,s 43,8 I 2 3 4 5 8 Total Missing Total 56 100,O 15. What is the language used daily by family members? Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Bana 56 100,O 100,O 100,O Total 56 100,O 100,O 111. Economic activities of house holds 16. Major occupation of family ( thejob that most of family members do and take most of the time) Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Agriculture 56 100,O 100,O 100,O 17. Beside major occupation, what is the secondjob of the family? ' Valid Cumulative Freauencv Percent Percent Percent. Commune's officer in charge of women. Employer 2 3,6 3,6 100,O Total 56 100,O 100,O 18. Which of the followings the family is classified ? Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Poor 5 1 91,l 91,l 91,l Average 5 8,9 8,9 100,O Total 56 100,O 100,O 19. Does the family receive supports from the Support Programs of Government? Benefits from 134 Benefits from 135 Benefits from 1 33 Program Program Program Count . YO Count YO Count % Yes 6 10,7% 41 73,2% 45 80,4% No 50 89,3% 15 26,8% 1 1 19,6% Total 56 1 OO,O% 56 100,0% 56 100,0% Benefits from 133 Program Frequency Percent Loans 6 100.0 Total 100,O 100,O Benefits from 134 Program Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent 32 57,l 57,l 57,l Electricity, road, water supply Electricity, road, water supply, school House House, water supply Total Benefits from 135 Program Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent 43 76,s 76,s 76,s Variety 2 3,6 3,6 80,4 Road, electricity, school Metal roof covering 4 7,1 7,1 98,2 Construction of road 1 1,s 1,s 100,O Total -- 56 100,O 100,O 20. From which activies does the family's main income get? Valid Cumulative Freauencv Percent Percent Percent - - Farming 56 100,O 100,O 100,O 21. Estimate income of the family in 2007 (dong): N Val id 50 Missing 6 Mean 7.540.000,OO Minimum 2.000.000 Maximum 25.000.000 Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent 2.000.000 2 3,6 4,O 4,0 3.000.000 4 7.1 8,O 12,O 4.000.000 3 5,4 6,O 18,O 5.000.000 1 1 19,6 22.0 40,O 6.000.000 3 5,4 6.0 46,O 7.000.000 3 5.4 6,O 52,O 8.000.000 9 16,l 18,O 70,O 9.000.000 2 3,6 4,o 74,O 10.000.000 7 12,5 14,O 88,O 11.000.000 2 3,6 4,O 92,O 13.000.000 1 13 2,O 94,O 15.000.000 1 1,8 2,o 96,O 20.000.000 1 1-8 2,o 98,O 25.000.000 1 1,8 2,o 100,O Total 50 89.3 100,O Missing 6 10,7 Total 56 100,O 22. Estimate expenses of the family in 2007 ( including expenses in foods, medical care, tutor fee, travelling, furniture that the family paid in 2007)?: N Valid 46 Missing 10 Mean 7.445.652,17 Minimum 500.000 Maximum 20.000.000 Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent 500.000 I 1,8 2 2 2,2 1.000:000 3 5,4 6 3 8,7 2.000.000 5 8,9 10,9 19,6 4.000.000 I 1 3 2,2 21,7 5.000.000 2 3-6 4,3 26,l 6.000.000 4 7,1 8,7 34,8 7.000.000 5 8,9 10,9 45,7 8.000.000 7 12,5 15,2 60,9 9.000.000 3 5,4 6,5 67,4 10.000.000 8 14,3 17,4 84,8 1 1.OOO.OOO 2 3,6 4-3 89,l 12.000.000 3 5,4 6 5 95,7 15.000.000 I 1.8 2 2 97,8 20.000.000 1 1.8 2.2 100,O Total 46 82,l 100.0 Missing 10 17,9 Total 56 100,O 23. What kinds of tree the family is cultivating ? Cases Col Response % Coffee 2 3,6% Almond Mango Tea Pepper Manioc Banana Maize Rice Pine apple + Among those above, which tree brings higher income for the family: Cases Col Response % Rice 14 93,3% Manioc Maize 24. Which one brings higher income for the house hold: Working in rice field or in milpa? Valid Cumulatiye Freauencv Percent Percent Percent Working in rice field Working in milpa 4 1 73,2 73.2 100,O Total 56 100,O 100,O 25.Which animqls the household is breeding? Pig Poultry Goat Cattle N Valid 27 36 4 19 Missing 29 20 52 37 Mean 1,37 4,94 2,2500 2,47 Minimum I 1 1 ,00 1 Maximum 4 10 3,OO 8 Pig Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Valid 1 19 33,9 70,4 70,4 2 4 Total Missing System Total Poultry Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Valid I 2 3.6 5,6 5,6 3 4 5 6 7 10 Total Missing System Total Goat Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Valid 1,OO 1 I ,8 25,O 25,O 2,oo 3,OO Total Missing System Total Cattle Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Valid I 9 16,l 47,4 47,4 2 I 1 3 5,3 52,6 3 6 10,7 31,6 84,2 4 I 1,8 5,3 89,5 6 I I ,8 5,3 94,7 8 1 13 5,3 100,O Total 19 33,9 100,O Missing System 37 66,l Total 56 100,O 26. In agricultural production. does the family faceany difficulties in (Note: Don't cross the box if you don't lack; to cross the box you lack or got difficulties) Cases Col Response % Lack of production 22 39.3% land Lack of water for irrigation Lack of labour Lack of moneyfor investment Lack of information Lack of knowledge No difficulies 27. In the following year (2008) does the family has plan to develope any more production activities? Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Not develope any activities Has plan to develope more production 3 5,4 5,4 100,O activities Total 56 100,O 100,O Plan to develope Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent 53 94,6 94,6 94,6 Grow more maniac 3 5,4 5,4 100,O Total 56 100,O 100,O IV. Life conditions of the house holds 28. In the family who does the following works? Cases Col Response % Working in fields, milpas Women 45 81,8% Men Children Going to cut firework Women Men Children Going to take water Women Men Children Going to work as hired labour Women Men Children Cooking for family Women Men Children Washing clothes Women Men 20 36,4% Children 9 16,4% 29. What kind of water is the family using for their living activities: Cases Col Response % Well-water 40 72,7% Water from public tank Water from river, spring Water from creeks, water points brought 33 60,0% near the house Water from drilled well 30. What is the toilet of the family like? . 1 Valid Cumul Frequency Percent Percent Perc There is not a toilet, they relieve themselves in the forest, river, stream 53 94,6 94,6 There is not a toilet, they relieve themselves in the forest, river, stream 3 5,4 5,4 Total 56 100,O 100,O 31. What energy sources does the family use for lighting? Col Response Cases % Grid electricity 54 96,4% Small generator placed in the river near the house Kerosene Candle Firewood burnt all night 3 5,4% No energy sources are used 32. Which of the following things do you have in the family? No I 2 3 4 Total Bicycle Count 34 19 2 1 56 Yo 60,7% 33,9% 3,6% 1,8% 100,0% Motobicycle Count 6 43 1 I 51 Yo 11,8% 84,3% 2,0% 2,0% 1 OO,O% TV Count 1 1 36 47 Yo 23.4% 76,6% 1 OO,O% Video, digital Count recorder % Radio Count Yo Desk telephone Count Yo Mobile telephone Count Yo Electric fan Count Yo Ox cart Count Yo Water pump Count Yo Elecltric cooker Count V. Awareness of Ha Tay Hydro-electrical Work 33. Do you know,that Ha Tay Hydro-electrical Work will be built in the locality or not? Valid Cumulative Freauencv Percent Percent Percent Know 56 100,O 100,O 100,O If you know, then by what means of communication? Col Response Cases % Know through the family members - Know through the friends, neighbors 47 85.5% Know through the commune leaders 5 1 92,7% Knows through the District Committee for 40 72,7% compensation, land acquisition Know through the investor, investor's staff 37 67,3% 34. Do you know that its land, plants shall be influenced? Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Know 56 100,O 100,O 100,O 35. Do you accept for its influence land to be withdrawn for the hydro-electrical work? Valid Cumulative Freauencv Percent Percent Percent Accept 56 100,O 100,O 100,O Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Follow policy of the I 1,8 1,8 1,8 government Product electricity for the country Benefits for community Total 56 100,O 100,O - - - - - - - - - - - - - - 36. If a part of your agricultural land is lost, how do you want to be compensated? Col Response Cases YO Land to land change Land to be paid for in cash at the negotiable price 37. In general, according to you, how will Ha Tay Hydro-electrical Work impact on the family life? Valid Cumulative Frequency Percent Percent Percent Do not impact 56 100,O 100,O 100,O Annex 11 Information about Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project (In the popular language) Song Da Tay Nguyen Hydropower JSC Chu Pah District People's Committee Chu Pah District's Compensationand Land Acquisition Council 1. Where will Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project be built? Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project will be built on Dak Po Tang River or also called Ia Krom River, Ha Tay Commune, Chu Pah District, Gia Lai Province. Hydropower dam, penstock, power-house and other auxiliary works will be placed in Ha Tay Commune, the hydropower reservoir stretches on the stream belonging to three communes Dak To Ver and Ha Tay, Chu Pah District; Daksomei, DakDoa, Gia Lai Province. 2. What will be the impacts of Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project? Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project will impact on the area of total 158.94ha. In which, the reservoir's bed will impact on 1.77ha of residential land of 04 households in Hde Hamlet, Dak To Ver Commune, 9.1 ha of single crop rice field, 3.3 I ha of rubber growing land, 58.38ha perennial tree growing land of both Dak To Ver and Ha Tay, and Daksomei. The construction area of the work items such as dam, power house need to acquire 18.84ha, mainly rubber growing land and perennial tree growing land of Ha Tay Commune. Besides, the project will impact on 0.66ha of cemetery, 0.87ha of land planned for transportation, 02 stayed bridges of Dak To Ver Commune and a certain forest area under the State's management in both Dak To Ver and Ha Tay Communes. 3. What will be the objectives of the policy on compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement for the people affected by Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project? The overall objective of the policy on compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement for the affected people is that: the affected people will be supported so that their socio-economic conditions will be recovered at least as equal as those before the constr~ictionof Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project. The poor households, households in difficult conditions will be supported to improve their socio-economic conditions better than before the construction of the sub-project. 4. Who will be entitled to the policy on compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement of Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project? All individuals, households, business enterprises, organizations that are impacted by the construction process of the sub-project and by water rising in the hydropower reservoir shall be compensated and supported. The impacts may be under the form of loss of land, water sources, fixed or non-fixed assets, influence on fishing on the stream or collecting aquatic products on the stream, influence on business, jobs, place of work, place of residence or living environment... shall be compensated and supported. 5. How shall the lost agricultural land be compensated? The loss of the allocated or reclaimed agricultural land shall be compensated in cash for the land area to be acquired at the replacement cost at the time of compensation. The temporarily influenced agricultural land shall also be compensated at the market price according to land lease level. Besides, the affected households shall be supported to reclaim and enlarge their land area for farm produces and for water rice upon the discussions with the affected people in the community consultative meetings. 6. How shall the individuals and households who lose their residential land be compensated? The residential land shall be compensated in cash at the replacement cost at the time of compensation. 7. How is "market price" defined? It is the amount sufficient to replace lost assets without deduction of taxes and transaction costs. In particular for the aforesaid agricultural land and residential land, the market price is calculated as follows: Production land (fields, ponds, gardens, forests...): basing on the market price to reflect the actual land transfer, sale and purchase in the locality. If in the locality there exists no actual prices of land sale and purchase, exchange, it shall be based on the production value. Residential land basing on the market price to reflect the actual residential land sale and purchase in the locality. If in the locality there exist no actual prices of land sale and purchase, it shall based on the price of residential land at the similar places. 8. Do the affected households need legal documents to be compensated, supported for their loss of land and assets on land? All affected individuals, households shall be entitled to the equal rights of being compensated and supported regardless the status of ownership, socio-economic position or any elements that contradict the objectives of compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement. Lack of legal documents related to land and assets does not bar the affected people from entitlement to the policy on compensation, rehabilitation. In short, the affected individuals, households do not need legal documents to get compensation, rehabilitation for their affected land and assets. However, the identification of ownership and use status depend on the determination made by the Commune People's Committee, individuals whose lands are adjacent to the affected area, publicly disclosed at the Commune People's Committee to avoid any claims on ownership. 9. How shall the compensation for houses, works on land be implemented? The people whose houses are affected shall choose one of 02 alternatives: (i) the affected household is compensated in cash as equal as the amount that they can build a house o f the similar size, better materials and nicer than the existing one. The residential land to be granted is at least of equal size or more than the lost residential land area and the affected people will build their house or (ii) the affected people shall be granted land area o f at least equal size or more than the lost residential area, his house will be built by the Compensation and land acquisition council and handed over to the affected people with the area o f equal size to the lost house area, made of better materials and nicer. According to this alternative, the house design will depend on the affected people's intention. The affected people can choose one of the two aforesaid methods (alternatives) in the community consultative meetings. Other affected works such as rice store-houses. cattle-shed, fences, etc. shall be compensated for replacementof the similar size and materials but with the new ones. The affected people+all be compensated in cash according to the market price of new materials and labour cost to build these works. 10. How shall compensation for community's assets on land be implemented? The works o f the community that are affected consist o f 02 stayed bridges, water sources and cemetery. New stayed bridges shall be built with better quality. Wells shall be dug where the water sources are impacted, each for every 3 households. Pay for leveling and bulldozing for the burial-ground shall be compensatedto the commune. 11. How shall compensation for perennials, fruit trees, plants in garden and plants on milpa be implemented? Compensation shall be made for different kinds of plants basing on actual value o f the plants at the market price. Besides, the households shall also receive support for new fruit seedlings, timber seedlings to grow in their remaining areas based on community consultative meetings with the people. 12. How shall other supports to the influenced people be implemented? The households whose residential land, i f receive compensation in cash to build houses by themselves shall be supported for costs of transporting salvable materials removed from their old houses and transporting other furniture. Unit price o f transport support is in accordance with the Regulations on resettled house support issued by Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee at the support time. Besides, each household whose residential land is impacted shall be supported 3,000,000 VNDihousehold. The households, individuals whose over 1000m2 of land for agricultural production are acquired shall receive a cash allowance equal to 30 kg of rice per month in uninterrupted 03 months to stabilize their lives. Price of rice is calculated at the average price in the locality at the support time. The households, individuals classified as sedentarized ones who had desired to change jobs and registered with the Commune People's Committee during the detailed inventory for losses shall be supported the costs for vocational training. Support amount is in accordance with the regulations on levels of vocational training support issued by Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee at the support time. 13. Shall the households whose agricultural land is impacted be supported for agricultural development? Yes, households whose agricultural land is impacted shall be supported. Forms of supports consist of support for reclamation to enlarge their land area at the support level defined by Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee at the support time. The affected households shall also be supported with new fruit seedlings, forest seedlings and fertilizers within 01 year. Besides, the affected households shall be trained on 03 topics including (i) method of cultivation on sloppy land, (ii) method of breeding development, and (iii) method of intensive multi-cropping cultivation and crop calendar and effective utilization of land. The affected people shall also be supported with domestic animals according to the community consultative results in terms of quantity and categories of animals. 14. Shall the sub-project provide the people who frequently catch fish for their meals in the stream any supports to fishery development? The hydropower sub-project wi.11 not influence on the people's fishing in the stream. However, all affected people shall be provided support for training on pond and reservoir fish culturing technology. Apart from the training support, the affected households shall receive cash for materials to make fish culturing cages in the reservoir. 15. How shall compensation for the forest area and industrial trees implemented under management of the State's Programs and organizations be made? The forest area and industrial trees implemented under management of the State's Programs and organizations shall be compensated according to the unit price detined by Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee at the time of compensation. 16, How is the Program of compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement expected to implement? Community consultative activities and people's participation: From March 2008 to December 2009. Detailed inventory for losses and disclosure the results: From May 16,2008 to December 31,2008. Setting up the Program of lncome recovery: From January 01,2009 to June 30,2009. Making compensation: From January 01, 2009 to March 31, 2009. Implementation of Program of income recovery: From July 01, 2009 to December 12,2009. Resettlement of the affected people: From December 31,2008 Construction activities: October 01,2008. 17. How shall the affected people participate in the activities of compensation, rehabilitation? All affected people shall be consulted and participate in the activities of compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement such as socio-economic survey, detailed inventory for. losses, disclosure of loss inventory results, discussion on compensation price, implementation of activities of income recovery, monitoring, supervision, etc. The affected individuals, communities' recommendations, proposals shall be considered in the stage of design and implementation of activities of compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement, and development of livelihoods. The District's compensation and land acquisition council shall set up a mechanism to receive the people's opinions and resolve claims during the process of preparation and implementation of the Program of compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement, and ethnic minority development. All affected individuals and their families shall participate in the community consultative meetings and other related activities to ensure that the impacted individuals and their families are fully informed and consulted. 18. What documents need be available in the hamlets and villages for reference? - Information about Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project. - Summary of rights and benefits to compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement for the people affected by the sub-project. - Regulations on compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement issued by Gia Lai Provincial People's Committee in 2008, 2009. - Inventory list of losses by each household ofthe hamlet - List of compensation amount by each household of the hamlet - Plan of compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement -Complaint settlement procedure. 19. How could the affected people claim their problems? For all complaints related to compensation, rehabilitation and resettlement, the affected people can lodge their oral or written complaint to the head of the hamlet or the commune's community consultative committee. The head of the hamlet or the commune's community consultative committee shall be responsible for working with the Commune People's Committee to resolve the complaints of the affected people. If the affected people are not satisfied with the resolution of the Commune People's Committee, they can contact the Compensation and land acquisition board of Ha Tay Hydropower sub- project, directly meet Mr. (Ms.) Ro Lan Chung, Chairman of the Dictrict's Compensation and Land Acquisition Council, Vice-chairman of Chupah District at the following address: Chu Pah District People's Committee, Phu Hoa Township, Chu Pah, Gia Lai Province, Telephone number: 059 842 377 or Directing Board of Ha Tay Hydropower sub-project, the contact person: Mr. Pham Tu Mau at the address of Song Da Tay Nguyen Hydropower Joint Stock Company, No.20 Pham Van Dong, Pleiku City, Gia Lai Province.Telephone number: 059 720 098. ' Annex 12 Information about Ha Tay Hydro-electrical Work (In the Bana language) C6ng ty CP dak UY BAN NHAN DAN TORING CHU'PAH SONG DA TAY N G U Y ~ N tcnvul chawiiwg tu gum pang n2ng hnih oei anho Filla boar ta b6h gah c6ng trinh dien dak Ha Tiy 1. Anih pcrjing cdng trinh di@ndak Ha Tiy? C6ng trinh dien dak Ha Tiy gah pa jing ah dak kroang pa ting, pcmah de krao kroong krom, gahteh xZ Ha Tiy ta ring Chupah char Gia Lai. D6u jal c6ng trinh: anih bat dak, anih moong dak troong ding dak jrot, hnamku mai, anih woei lang pang d6m c8ng trinh tu gum anai m8u ah xi3 Ha Tiy, mat dicn dak kujung truh anih dak haboong tro gah teh 3 to xb DBktover, x5 Ha Tiy ta ring Chlrpah, x2 Daksomei ta ring E)ak Doa char Gia Lai. 2.Ddm tcrdirong pcrm tro gah cdng trinh di@ndak Ha Thy? CBng trinh ditn dak Ha Tiy duh to rou trd dT d3ng 158,94 ha teh, 1Bm noh anih moopg dak tmou trd 1,77 ha teh oei 04 td hnam pliy Hde x2 Daktcrver, teh patam ba 01 dqt to rom 9,l ha teh patam cao su 3,3 1 ha teh polam along lo so naln 125,92 ha di pEng td xi7 Daktaver, xB Ha Tiy pang xb D8ksmei. Anih xZ pojing c6ng trinh, anih bM, hnam woei lang kal ayok 18,84 ha lagah teh patiim cao su pang along lasu nam, xb Ha Tiy.P2h aug oaih du an duh tu ram truh the pusat 0,66ha; 0,87 ha amau teh putroong, barto kotoa toh ah x i Diiktcrver pang minh s6 teh britrd teh d5k woei lang tr6 2 td x2 Daktwer pang xB Ha Tby. 3.Kyb adrin gah chinh sael Bn towih, t q u m oei nao 5n bcrngai trd tcr rom b&t cdng trinh di@ndiik Ha Tiy. KyB adrin dl dang gah chinh sael an towih, tagum oei nao 2n bcmgai trd tma: Bagai trd t m m g&h an tagum dam tadrong KTXH an kan hap axoong tb xet d8h ta xcmg at6 adeoh bM pujing c6ng trinh dien d5k Hi T2y. D6m hnam ta neih, hnam dei ta nap t8pkan h8p goh tagum la by&d6m ta drong KTXH he kan hap at6 ku so gB dei c6ng trinh. 4.Lu guh yuu ding chinh sael padreo towih, togum, anih oei hnam cdng trinh.di@ndik Ha Tiy: DT dsng d6m tangla, dBm unl hnam, doanh nghiep, pagar trb ta r a n yua c6ng trinh pujing, cBng trinh pang bat dak moong ditn dik duh dei padreo tawih, tagum. To ram pu hlom hxoong teh chdh, h l i u dak, t m a m dram ha n2ng dak uh ha ning, t a r m rap ca Ism kopal dak d8nh aydk hla nhet hla nhdt 1bm kapal dik, taram truh pam jang, pudro p m jang, anih oei pom jang anih oei dah jum jak erih...duh padreo towih pang tagum. 5.Padreo towih choh jang: Teh choh jang gah axoong dBh choong pa oaih trd axoong hlong hloi g&hpadreo tawih 19ng jen ?in ra yah teh trd ayou towih teh Bh Quy&td]nh s6 122/2007/QD-UBND nar 31/12/2007 ka UBND char Gia Lai sa kat todrong tadra d6rn teh Iirn tming Chupah, char Gia Lai sa nam 2008.Teh choh jang trd ta ram aman g6 dei tagum kia sakd hniu. 6.Podreo teh oei: k-. Teh oei trd ta rau gih padreo hang jCn kia sak& a h ~ u ~ djnhts6 122/2007/QD-UBND nar & 31/12/2007 ka UBND char Gia Lai tadrong saktrt todra d6m khul teh Ihm tming Chuptih char Gia Lai nam 2008. 7.Kiu sukdt podreo towih: D6m hlak j&n kad patal, rdt aydk d6m ta nam dn9m trd hyong uh axoong ka thu&duh hloi d6m xech xoch anai. Teh jang (teh na, salung ka, pagarg brak6ng...) k'ia Iim saktrt ah ~ u ~ djnh s6 & t 122/2007/QD-UBND nar 31/12/2007 ka UBND char Gia Lai tadrong saktrt khul teh Ibm taring Chu pah char Gia Lai narn 2008. 8,Kiu iin d6m unh hnam tr8 to rum goh padreo, togum gi3h teh piing toman dram ka pal teh: D6m tangla, unh ta nuh trd tmom g&haxoong tagum la I%i trd gah yua anih KTXH ta dah ki kio anai yak tarong tadrong, tagum, anih oei nao uh dei Hlabaar t6m tech gah teh pang ta man dram uh g&hpa gat an pangai trd tmau uh dei yua padreo towih tagurn. Akom 13tagla, unhdarn trd tmam ting uh dei d6m hlabaar t6rn teh gah tadreo, tagum an teh choh; ta man dram trd tman ka ban, gih dzi Uy ban nhin din x i ta bat anih yua ayok gah teh pang to man dam g8h tu ugla, unh hnam Iim xi5 dei ka p9h ta ran pang gih patruh di d2ng uh Ujl ban nh2n din xi3 hji tudrong pa rnabom gah yua yok trd pa jah. 9.Podreo towih gah hnam oei, cdng trinh kopah teh: Pcmgai trd t a r m hnarn gah raih bar phuong an: Gah minh, unh hnam trd taram gah padreo tawih pang jen kla ta ying d2l kia gih pajing hnam plong dei yah dang dil kia sak6t 5h ~ u y &djnh s6 122/2007/QD-UBND nar t 31/12/2007 gah Uy ban nhdn dbn char Gia Lai n9m 2008. Gah bar, bongai tr6 tmom gah ra yah teh ta sit dCI dang ail jah uh lahloi ro yah teh oei trd hyong, hnam gah khul ch8 nang, tagurn pang anih oei nao du an dicn dak HB T6y pom pang pa jao an bangai trd taram d6rn ra yah to galatd ra yah hnam trd hyong pang taman hlong loi aliing hlo kia phu.ong an hniu, thi&tk6 hnarn gah chi3 aping mdng lang g8h pmgai trd toram. D6m c6ng trinh anai thor xum ba, ku drong, pa gar...tr6 tmum gih pudreo tuwih putal trd k u ha ndng ping tuman del chdng toman pling. Pcmgai trd tu rum gih pudreo pangjen kiu tuman anai Idm de podro pang pujang aman gih porn ku dih c6ng trinh andu. 10. Padreo towih t m i m dram b61 bal tr8 anit: Gah or kutoa to1 pang la ling dak trd tmum: K u toa to1 gih pum plcmg pang tuman pling aling hloh. Ah anih ma hldu dak trd tmom gah xer pdng pum sueng dak pa aling t6m uah hnam trd tmum. Gah teh pa sat tmum pungai pum jang tu b6-p Ujl ban nhin din x i tmom d6m hundng dag dCI ru yah trd tmum. 11. Padreo towih gn tam along dunh sa nim, along xa plig, al6ng IAm pa gar ping along Iim mir: Hud6m pldy along-tu man pa tam duh gdh pudreo tuwih kiu suk6t tai Quy&t djnh s6 422lQD-UBND nar 25/08/2007 ku Uy ban nhin din char Cia Lai gah tu drong ming sa kut pudreo tuwih pliy al6ng tu man putam Idm char Cia Lai. 12. D6m tagurn i n bmgai trB tarom: Lu unh hnam la yio ayou tuwih oei tu nai gih axoongjen broh nam cho toman pum hnam xo pang cho hnam tuman hnam anai tugum chu borh nlim kiu C)uy&t djnh an tugum anih oei anao ku UBND char Cia Lai k6 anicl tugum, d6m unh hnam trd tmum teh oei gih tu gum 3.000.000 d6ng/ha. D8m unhnam, minh dtr6 yak trd tuwih la k u pal 1.000 m2teh chuh jang gah tugum wa axoong anih pang axoang chdhjang gih tugum pangjen kiu su kut l i m Quy&t djnh k u s6 25lQD-UBND nar 08/05/2008 ku Ujl ban nhin din char Cia Lai. Unhnam minh dtr8 Iim ch6h jang dei adrin aplih pornjang gih chih mat pling UBND x i Ibm anar chi lang tr6 tunap t6m tal gdh axoong jCn po hnam jang anao gih tugum kiu su kut tugum kiu su kut tugum jCn pa hnamjang kiu UBlUD char Cia Lai su kut Idm pa yau tugum. 13. D6m tagum ha nuh choh jang i n bangai tr8 taram teh choh jang: D6m unhnam trd tmum teh choh jang gih tugum ha nuh choh jang la yiu pudreo tuwih tudrong tugurn ha d6m tugum anai jang teh, hlong putam, plin anam gih tugum kTu Quy&t djnh ku UBND char Gia Lai kiu pa yau tugum. Cah angoaih d6m hnam trd tmom gih pa hnam gah k u kachjang teh kbng, ku kachjoh roong pang ku kach putam tu mam dram pang pom jang teh guh yiu. 14. D6m hnam tagum ayong jang ha nuh ta marn rong dik: Cdng trinh dien dak gdh uh trd torom truh tadrong ch2 ka ko bungai pliy. Dong rong du an pujang khaih anih mong dak gdh an ka knuh hhul ka gdh yuo la hloh. D61nbongai trd turom gih tu gum pa hram gah tudrong chi ka ka pal dak mong. 15. Pcrdreo towih rcr yah ping along putim yicr gah chumg trinh pcr gcrr teh dak: Pa yah bri, along potam yia gah chumg trinh pa gm teh dak gah tagum kTa sa kot ka uhun char Gia Lai Ibrn pa yan tagum. 16. Pcr hlom b 6 jang chucrng trinh pcrdreo towih, tcrgum, anih oei nao: D6m khul woei lang pang kow pa Iby: dong khei 0312008 truh khai 1212009. ~ hj82anat anot pang khan rodah ch2j8: d2ng khei 0512008 truh khai 0312009. Pajang an tagum: khei 0112009 truh khai 1212009. Pajang chumg trinh ha nuh pa yia: khei 0412008 truh khai 0812009. P m jang chumg trinh ha nuh pa yia: khei 0912008 truh khai 1212009. B&jang enih oei nao bmgai trb ta r m : Ibrn khei 11; 12 so nam 2009. DBng go1 ha d6m p m jang: khei O 112009. 17. Tcr drong akom kcr bmgai tr6 tcrrcrm Ilm ha d i n pcrdreo towih, tcrgum: Di dang lu bmgai trd t m m gbh aping pang gbh akom Ibrn tadrong padreo twih, tagum, anih oei nao kum tr6 ch2 lang anih jang, ch2 lang anih t6m teh, khan ra dah ch8 lang anat anot, p m a akom gah so kot padreo t w i h p m jang d6m tadrong p m yiea, kTa lang woei lang.... Ha d6m aping, apai k6 minh dr8 pang b6l bal trd t m m gbh lang ka leng Ibrn dZrk ta b8h pang p m jang d6m tadrong padreo t w i h tagum, anih oei nao, ha nuh d6m pa jang dei yuo, khul chB lang, tagum pang anih oei nao ha nuh mong lang apai ka koa pa lei pang axoong d6m khan p6 g& lbm pom anam pang jang chuang trinh padreo twih, tagum. Anih oei nao pang'anuh pmgai kot oei. Di d5ng minh dh8 pang unhnam ha d6m bmgai trd t m m gbh akom pa ma bBI pang p m jang trd anai gbh potil lang minh trd pang unhnam bangai trd t m m gbh pa tbng pang p m a t6m teh. 18. Hcr dam hlarcrar khom dei ah pcrlei kcrleng nsng: + Hlabaar to p6h gah hnam ka mai dicn dak Ha Tby. + Roi ta b6h ha d6m gbh yua gah padreo twih, anih oei nao an bmgai trd t a r m ka hnam, ka m2i. + Sa kot podreo t w i h , anih.oei nao ka UBND char Gia Lai so nan~2008; 2009. + Pa hlom pajang padreo twih, tagum, anih oei nao. + Hlaar tum grum j8 lang anat anot kTa unhnam k6 palei. + Hlaar tum grum ga sa k6-t padreo t w i h kTa unhnam ka palei la yia dei trd yua ch2 lang pa ti1 ka khul woai lang tagum, anih oei nao taring Chupah axoong tadrong p m a pag6-t uh lap. 19. Tcrm r6h puma had6m pug&, vh lap kcr kcrn polei: X6h bmgai trd tarom dei todrong 3 h ka lap dah pug& gah tadrong trd gah padreo twih, tagum, anih oei nao, xu. gbh tabap woei polby dah khul ta b6h kon palei Ibm x. gbh p m a khan pang nor dah hlaar. Woei palby dah khul ta boh kon palei Iim x5 dei pam jang pang UBND x5 p m a ta nuh uh ka lip, pagat ka bangai trd tararn. Yah uh ka lap ding tadrong puma tmuh ka UBND x5, bungai trd t m m g$h tabCrp gbh khul pa oaih hnam ka m2i dien dak Ha Tby, tobop potil boh Ra Lan Chung - Chtj t/ch khul woei Iang, Phb chu tjch taring Chupah, anih oei; UBND taring Chupah thj trin Phu Hba, taring Ch~rpiihchar Cia Lai; ka s6 rajeo 059842377, y5h uh tab@p Ban Giam d6c cbng trinh dien dak HaTiy, tab6-p pail boh Pham Tu M$u anih oei Cbng ty c8 phin thuy dien Sbng Da Tiy NguyCn -20 Pham Van Ding - Pleiku - Gia Lai, ~6dien thoai: 059.720098. Annex 13 Dicision to set up the Commune - Level Community Advisory Board (DakToVe Commune) , 1 1 1 I I I 6 ; Y : ( I3Vll - 01) r~y(i)08 lhdng 01 r~dnl2007 clin < I l r ban !hiu d i n rinll (;ii~L3i V$ vitc plii' duy;~cho phkp c0riC'lv si)n@dil 4 tl~lri,c I dng c011g~y SAng d i J i u ILI citng rrirth 1IiL;ydicn I lb 'lay. l~u!. n g ~ ~ g k n : Can cu Quyi.t djnh s6: 232illl~NL)- (20ngiy 03 ~hdng4 n5in 7-008cila iiy ban nh2n d311 Iiuyen Chti PBh ~ivi@c~phCduyet phdcing i n t6ng 1116bhi thiri~llg.hd Lr? tni djnh ct,cdnf: trinll nhi lniy tht'~ydien 1 l i I'By phan dia bill huyen (:h~i P?ih; Y6r de rig111c i ~ ai i n hA Vnl, phbng - 'l'hfing L? ~i. ~ i 1. hfhanh lap H;u1 Ihaln \;in tong ddng tr5.11dja hin xii y6~nciic rhbnh viitn saki: 0I . Ong: K u A Yii-ng 1'C7K,LJBND xS. L.hm [rirdrlg bull 02. 0 1 1 ~I'i.Brl VBn I'holig : CII. D/nchin11 XI) I hi1111\*is11 07. 01lg: I!ch I'hdn rnidng ling 'l'uitk I'hinh vien 04 onS: ill '1IiA11 1 r ~ 6 lang Rlor n ~ 'I'll;i~~hvi?n 05. (:)li,g: I lr5ng 1'11611lrlrbn~ling KRkh 'l'11Bnh vi&l 00. finl?. 'Thtlch 'rh61111i1cir1~1:11igOIII SI1:inh \:1211 117. l')ng: Yung I'l~filiiru(h1g ling I LDc l'hii11hv ~ C I I Mt;'i : UX. fing: A Yiii CT.L:I~LI'I"~~5O I.kn ~ l i ~ nIbC V I ~ 00. ong: Plilk . C:T IlNC' I' x i rtiilih viC1.1 10. I ~ II .I1ct1 (:r, I I P N ~5 'l'l~i~lhvi.21; ~)i6\12. \)an t1i.m) ~ ; i l i C + I I ~L I ~ I xi~ l ~ ~ I IiL )6~ > ~VUI Ililn den h11 siii pt~tir~: I ri1:lr billg 1iuyi.n v i nl~hnidy [llily diC.11 tien lvinh ciic l ~ o ; !d6ri~.rh;uu \:in ~ ~ C n g dhllLi lai cAc lliir~iling \rang kliu VI!C ~6112 ~1.1lil1 lhilV dien nli; IIB '1'3~.I'h6i hair \ll (.i;>Li>i 1.i VICC ph? tluy:$:I :l!Nl) ..()I?II);-:I~ '25 III;II.I~.: I;:II)) :l~i!S<.I ,AI': hi1111111i11iliill ~ i n l(iii~l.ili~6 vie= thny dni cdns ty tllliy dien I-h'l'iytir cc\l~gt~.inl~ l . . ~ I I Ldill1 :;i,~~g, .I ~ > I,I? c:i~ i ~ l ~IIILI:3 ~ ,clic:!~ !LI~I; ~ ,;:,,II~ !'II~.:I>04 I!;I;I:; SO' 4 II:~I!~ iLl;l 'IiOS !:.? h:!.~!lii';;a:t <.L V? \ i \.,IIL~~>I,;;;.cs :;I,, l~? livi i>Oill~t,~;:.~~. 110 1:rt:r \'i1;11(1!.1 IIII~<,I i l i I ~ C:h1rp8h; X6t '1: ngl~iciu C ~ I I 176 \:~II ~>I!~,II~;, 'I'II;)I-I~.;ItC hi. .r i)i;u I.'l'lAr111liiyi I ~ I[IILUIII ~ VAII ~<)IISdi'i~i~,~ I'I!:! t)i11 xi g & c~i III~IIII L ~ I ~~ ~ viP1.1sau: I.Ung : ISICII I'llL)('I.~.;15hI.> .xi I~ L I U It)a11;I ~ 2.bng: Kllolc. Dia ~.hinh- xay d!rni: I'hh hiill: !.t.li: 1I~lcih C I.lJRM'f'['Q hi -1l1ir1k1~JIGII ; 4.Ri: YSi.1 (."l'.Hl..l~ll'~ <3 'l'lli~r~lls.vi211; .i.(.)ilg; L 11.r C l I l N I ) l'l~:trll~viC11, L'livi 0.1 tr~rungIh6t1: 6. 6rrg Khoarl 'I'~~1ri7igthd~lI<.oi~ l;irl!:Sa 'I'II<~IIII<;?[I; 7, (.)I):+: Y ~ ~ I I I ' I ~ I I ~ ~I ~~ III\;OIIbat: L ~I I 'I Il:111ll k161) : 8. p g : l)y I'hi~r~t~viC11; i)i& 2. U;rn illan1 v i n c(!r~ydhns x5 ph&i h q viri Llan derl hi1 giai pl~i,ll~~ 111ti1Lvin;~, IICI~~I;III/I~ tlli~ydie[\ti211II~II~I(I; ~II:.LIII v i NO5 C:IC IIO:!~ V;~II c(j11: ct&rig1:3i c8c rhi,n \;Ins In,n%l,t~u vyc c0ni; \ ~ . i nthuy ~ l ~ $~r ,i l \\:i \'hO! hv[? \ ~ l ~,l:iy. vhi cAc l',i~~i. r i K ~ ~ l l l cilc hCr1 cii l i ? ~CILI:III ~ I I ~ I I Igii111sit, L I ~ I I I Igii ~ I I><);# , . [,&I Ct(lcng tu ng11y$11vi quy611 lc~ici13inpri~ibj . , A1111111rhngv i 19 c i l ~nhi g i h r ~ g u bbj~Bnl-i Ilirtmg viri xb, 13an d2n hb #iAi phbn:: rn$t biPg hl~ycnv i N h i nay tl~uydie11l l i 'I'Cy. Hall tlla~rlv:^;l~c*n;j d<)ngx,i tkr giii th6 sau khi hoin tlibnh nl1ii:rn tu. l)i;t13. (;ic O I . I ~L>,~IV513l ~ l ~ O-~LIIC$II~,I,? x.5 i g V;I ~ric.OII;; t,:~c0 14i ;iiiLl 1 c I I ! ~IV<~I.IIr l t ~ i < ~ llii 11?1r1li l i q t ~ ~C ~i~lI I I rli~h I (:)u):?i di11l1lihy cti hii:l~Iqc. b: lir n:!Ay I\$.:. Annex 15 Minute of the meeting on community advisory of compensation, support and resetlement policies (DakToVe commune) / /-. . cfip,c;H(>;+ Y.\ 161(:I-IC I ~ ( i ~ i VIK'I : \ NAY! DOCl i ~ p- 'I'L~ - llanh p l ~ ~ i c do i I , I rhirlg n8rn ?00d Bien b i n cuec hop cerl: drjnp ling flBQ lhltllG 1: Thinh phan thnm gin: I . HIji dd17~ bdi thrrirnx, lro' fro, I C ;dink crr 1r11.vPnC'/~l~pciI~: ~ - Nguyen Duy Narri ChG t ~ c hxL. ulj vikn hqi tldn;; oris. Din11Vie1 Luu [.'j 4:1I ~ il61.1~. I I 2. f)ui dien nhri ~nny1huj dien HIJTuv: {jn:: S ~ I I ~ &TI!~1,11111 & I K e rv:in ~ru;mg c)llg:l't,:,l~l l')Ll) I{l&l\ 'L'ru(n~pphhr~?1'6 clliic hinil chinh . Ban [hum vth cdrlg dtjrr(~~rip xd: ) J . ;JII lliz thin11 ~il~.lr~rhml g1.1cilr\c. Ii~>p J ~ q cnghc.d ~diqn C ~ Lddu tif Nhh c!S i I niiy (hi\$:ti211 ''I'$y I~I!II!IXI~I,,')I \c ~III~; I~~IITI\fir1 cC111gC~ ~ > I I ~ <$c v h 52 5i1i1: - Quy Irlo cDr1.s tiif111 cilo r!lu- c1ii.n Lln Tiy. - DII Li@'r~cic [ic Jcing ticll iU< v i tii'i! SUC C~ILIc6ng ki-~nh~ht!$Jicn I f l S i y . - Cic :inh tlt1<.~11; CLI [ h i V? (If11d:11. L,:!!, c[>i. Iho:~1nz11:cb;~ng~!:li d5!1 [t#:~$c5 k H.)1.31; - PIIL:UII: i l l L?~!-I1'11.c'ic G{LI:d&l v i ci1(:Ilk i kliif!~~ nai. thic rnic. - Sau klir rr;lo tl61.rIiar11vin v:! ngllc (I~I tllcn Yhh m;iy lhuy diCrl HA 7'ay tri It71cic thir: :rlhc cirn 11gtr;rl c!3n i.6 c:li \.ilr: rl? nE11rren h~>irighi d.i rhhri: nhir cic n6i dung sau: a'~klc?iII~UCJL J i 1hiii1 v t qu? 1\10c i ~ a11t1inlrjy L ~ L I $ Jicn Hn 'lay v$ lOOC/I ngt~biili~rlcldntl_ vtii " %I r l i s;ly cl;ip. \! lri d;!l nlii rniy, l l ~ y 6 1ilirinl@dAv uh vi rri F cun cic c;iu ph5n khac cii;~~ l h hrn!ly. ": D b) 100% n p i r i dan d5 nh$n thlic duqc c i c tic dQng IA khbng Idn v3. Idlong Bnh h u h g d&nslrlh kc clia hq. c) Tohn be nguui d3n c6 dl1 113 tili s611 men dht hobo tohn thbrlg nhdt vC I phlrong 911din b i vh niirc d6n bil cua FlGi cl6ng b&i rhuin~g,h3 ~ @ 11.uv i 1Ji d/nh cu huycn CbupUi (16 ra. d) IOOYCr~guuid>lnd6ng y v6 c i c I+n phrip 119trr? p h ~ hdic Ihu nh3p duac d6 ~ t$ ~, xui1. .@ Thi)ng ~ I J < I c u ~ cIhop I I ~ L ~ J#!:ill I tli nl1a11rlit'rc duqcV ! ~ Clhilni g : \.go ~nllu. rh6i h~rpcirr~gi101J6ns Jill bb kignl b i LKI, k~crnd!ilti, do d i m vB kiini rra vice dp durlg ntuc d?i1 hu clia Li$i ~ldrigdi:i bL c.6 i n h h~rirrr! rrlrc tie'p den ,qiiy$rl lgr sua zhinh 110 r o i ~bfi n;u??i i dB11hi irih huiniz tlic1.1cvc:, t15o hlm; rl1;111i5::' c0ng tic c1Cri l)i~ cii:~t11jiJOng dtln hi^. f'!Suu kh1 dune nghe \i :r;io diir vE co cIiC kll~eunai, rhdc mdc [hi mc>inguc'li (la hi& dur~ckhi s6 cic :;.kien chus ~ h od6ng s2 Il'lnh h3y i vh b l ~ yr3 9 kign O c!:ju v i r~htrtllr nio. g) Neirljl d311clZ hi&i ~LICTC. c;ic hirile rl~t!c hien deli t ~ ituy nhiln cimg cci rr19L l sb $ kii.11 !lgll<~Idtiri rr~uOnhie'[ su 1118li~s1.6l rhhi gran khi nil,) rhuc llier~3Cn hi1 L:hi ~ nil,, nliil ~rldy.;u dunp JE chi^ tihng trlelr kllai can1116c r1.i.n tlii-n r:cIi cl5r (I;!111~1hAi. Me1 SOy k~$iitilac n19c phtrmig ph:ip 110 Ira s? rlirqc h h 11qn bang ticn hay bang .li~cllvat. Mt)i$ ki2'n ~ h i crnic dii d ~ r ~dai dien Kli:~miy tIi~19t114~1 'FA:,1,; c : FIL liri v3 dlqc .;u rihS~i1.i cua lo211 II~II.;~Itlrln bi ;in11hi1611g. H~enbin nhy thdng nl151sau CLIOC bpp v i nhong nguhi [ham gia dbog 9 kg tell du6i JAY. Annex 16 Minute of the meeting on community advisory of compensation, support and resetlement policies (HaTay commune) 'rhinh phan tham gia: I . H4i ddng b8i tlrtrimg, h j tru,tai e n h cuhrcyen Cllrrp&: - - 611~: Day MLI Chi1 r ~ c hAS,11);viC11hci drjn:, - On;: tlinh ViCr L1n.1 Ui, \'it11hni dijt~g. 2. Dai dien nlrrj nzay tlruj diL;~tH a Tug: 4. Cdc doan thdxh hei gti'rn: Dal Jien UBMT td qudc: Dai Jicn D o h 1 thanh nitn; D+i dieo H(>iphi! r~ir:Dqi (11Cntl(:)indng Jii11~5 I'ii TJy. Uoi dung cuoc hop tharn ban cOng dhllp: - Kk 1io;icll rh~!c hiqn CI:>II~I;;( itii~:I din I~IJ~ L , - C i i hi) irq LJOI v o ~:ipii>~ t~ir(:l~g. b~null - Sir rlizirn giiiGU;I ~I$IIUI &III \a(.;tic LI(.Y+Id1j11g(!ti1 l)u - Trao ,jdi c6i: 1161I!II~I;! vlj 'l"/li I I ~ Lrlilili:_'rill cilil dv .ill. trili~(jdi I :.t! en clit?' kii~@'u11;u rhdc ~ n i c - Sau klii tr3o ddi. than1 v i r ~v i rlplic dat t11CnUhYl riiiy rtu; die11 Hi Tby trd lili c6c rhdc rnic ci1a 11gir;r1 diin re !I:!( k51i(I$ nPu LrCn Ihoi nfhj dl rhdn: nliit t i c i i c ) ~ dung sau: a ) L l n ~ngirhi d i hi& v2 cluy m a cha nlii 171:iy1hu9 tl~$nH:I ' m y v:i 100% ngulri d3n dbng ); vdi v/ rri xfiy dAp. vi rri da~nlii~rn:iy. t~iy&ntluirns dny v i v/ rri ifin cic cdu phin khSc ci1.1n1161r1.i~ b) 100% npiriit i!:ln (1% rlliau thirc il~rqccic rjc dbng la khalrg ltin v i khdng Bnli h~rhlgd&n sinh kCclja h9. 2 ; loan I) IIIIA~Jduwc d& xudr. - 2) TIIOI.I~ qua C U C ~Iiop ilgut~idB11d3 nhln hirc dvqc vlec rhilrn giii v3o cdc Iloat dong din hh nhu: ph6i help cbiig hoi dong din bu kiim trs, kim d/~ih.do dKrn v3 kidm ir;t viec ip dvng IIII?~ dCrl 1 6 cita HQi d611gddn bG c6 Bnh hurhg trqc I.I+ d61 quv611l(~1 cu:~chinti hi?v;l roiti~Iho rugui~id i n hi iunli hurhig iich circ, hito tiimg rha~li513~CIiig15cdin hi1CU~IIl<)i LIL~IL~ ~ C I I 1li1. f j 5111 kt11dut?c nghc v i ~11;totil61 vc) ctr cliS k111Cu11;11.1113~rnac rhi nip! oglrui dS liifu duuc klir c6 cdc 5 k i ? ' ~ ~ [I106 1l5ngsZ trinli biy vh h&y ri) $ klbn 6 d6i1 cl1u.a vh nllur rht n&u. 21Nsirtrl d;!n dii h16ud[rc:lc.~,i,. t1111c. lbul:r(. h ~ udi f r ~hi! 111) r l l l i i : ~ ~~ L ? I I c~ h 1113t $69 kihi rig~rir~dan niucin h ~ fcu t 111; l~,(rnv? t h t ~Elan klii n:lo thud hier~den hi^, L ~ I ~ nho 11hBnuiy >uh6i. .Met sd 9 kien thic n16c v t ~,hlrcmgphrip lid rru.SF duqc 116 11.c bing ti& 11i1vb;inp hi&nvJi. Mpi 9 kit'ri tlidc n t ~ cd i dirgc dai difn N h i mriy rhui drcn 1Ii 1-ntri 1Si vr\ duryc slr nh5r lri clia tuSn bd iiplrhl