The World Bank                                                                                    Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)



Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)


 MIDDLE EAST AND NORTH AFRICA | Egypt, Arab Republic of | Education Global Practice |
 IBRD/IDA | Investment Project Financing | FY 2018 | Seq No: 4 | ARCHIVED on 29-Jan-2020 | ISR40214 |


 Implementing Agencies: Ministry of International Cooperation, Ministry of Education and Technical Education



 Key Dates


  Key Project Dates

   Bank Approval Date: 13-Apr-2018                                           Effectiveness Date: 28-Aug-2018
   Planned Mid Term Review Date: 12-Apr-2021                                 Actual Mid-Term Review Date:
   Original Closing Date: 01-Sep-2023                                        Revised Closing Date: 01-Sep-2023
 pdoTable

 Project Development Objectives

  Project Development Objective (from Project Appraisal Document)
  The project development objective (PDO) is to improve teaching and learning conditions in public schools.

  Has the Project Development Objective been changed since Board Approval of the Project Objective?
  No


 Components Table

 Name
 Component 1: Improved Early Childhood Education:(Cost $100.00 M)
 Component 2: Effective Teachers and Education Leaders:(Cost $100.00 M)
 Component 3: Comprehensive Assessment Reform for Improved Student Learning:(Cost $120.00 M)
 Component 4: Enhancing Education Service Delivery through Connected Systems:(Cost $160.00 M)
 Component 5: Project Management, Communication, and Monitoring and Evaluation:(Cost $20.00 M)

 Overall Ratings

 Name                                                                       Previous Rating                          Current Rating

 Progress towards achievement of PDO                                        Satisfactory                            Satisfactory
 Overall Implementation Progress (IP)                                       Moderately Satisfactory                 Moderately Satisfactory
 Overall Risk Rating                                                        High                                    High


 Implementation Status and Key Decisions

  By December 2019, the Ministry of Education and Technical Education achieved the following: (a) the expansion of teachers trained under the
  teachers professional behavior training by more than 40 percent; (b) developing new computer-based tests in eight subjects for over 500,000 grade
  10 students; (c) training of staff to create an item bank, manage the administration and marking of the tests, and make the grade 10 scores
  available electronically to students, directorates, districts, and school principals in less than a month; and (d) equipping grade 10 students and
  teachers with digital learning resources and mapping of the curriculum to digital learning resources on the Egyptian Knowledge Bank for use by
  students and teachers over 2018/2019.




1/29/2020                                                                                                                    Page 1 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                     Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)




  Risks


 Systematic Operations Risk-rating Tool


  Risk Category                                             Rating at Approval              Previous Rating                Current Rating

  Political and Governance                                  High                           High                          High
  Macroeconomic                                             Substantial                    Substantial                   Substantial
  Sector Strategies and Policies                            High                           High                          High
  Technical Design of Project or Program                    Substantial                    Substantial                   Substantial
  Institutional Capacity for Implementation and
                                                            Substantial                    Substantial                   Substantial
  Sustainability
  Fiduciary                                                 High                           High                          Substantial
  Environment and Social                                    Low                            Low                           Low
  Stakeholders                                              Substantial                    Substantial                   Substantial
  Other                                                     --                              --                             --
  Overall                                                   High                           High                          High



  Results


 PDO Indicators by Objectives / Outcomes



   Improve Learning Conditions

   IN00791745
   ►1. Increased percentage of Kindergartens (KG) that reach higher quality standards according to the Quality Assurance (QA) System
   (Percentage, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                         0.00                          0.00                      50.00

    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  07-Jul-2019                   06-Jan-2020              01-Sep-2023
                                       Ministry of Education and Technical Education (MOETE) is taking steps to develop the quality assurance
                                       standards. The Team will continue to follow-up for updated status and explore additional support that
   Comments:
                                       maybe required by the MOETE.



   Improve Teaching Conditions

    IN00791761
    ►2. Increased percentage of teachers demonstrating improved teaching practices (Percentage, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)          End Target



1/29/2020                                                                                                                       Page 2 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                     Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)




    Value                             0.00                         0.00                          0.00                      35.00

    Date                              06-Jan-2020                  07-Jul-2019                   06-Jan-2020              01-Sep-2023
                                       An impact evaluation for teaching practices is subject to further discussions between the Ministry of
                                       Education and Technical Education (MOETE) and the World Bank team. Meanwhile, the PCU indicated
                                       that Teachers First do conduct some assessment of teachers performance following the behavioral
   Comments:
                                       training. The team will review such assessment as they further pursue the component 2 dialogue with the
                                       new Deputy Minister.
     IN00791762
     Percentage of female teachers demonstrating improved teaching practices (Percentage, Custom Supplement)

                                     Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)          End Target

     Value                           0.00                         0.00                          0.00                      40.00

   IN00791763
   ►3. First cohort of students graduates from secondary education under the new GPA based assessment and certification system (Text,
   Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)          End Target
                                                                                                 Current school
                                                                   May 2019 examinations                                  First cohort of students
                                                                                                 graduation system
                                                                   (pass/fail with second                                 graduates from
                                      Current school                                             "Thanawiya 'Amma" is
                                                                   chance in July 2019) for                               secondary education
    Value                             graduation system                                          still in effect for
                                                                   grade 10 is step 1 for the                             under the new GPA
                                      "Thanawiya 'Amma"                                          students transitioning
                                                                   new secondary                                          based assessment and
                                                                                                 to grade 12 in school
                                                                   education.                                             certification system
                                                                                                 year 2019/2020.
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  07-Jul-2019                   06-Jan-2020              01-Sep-2023
                                       MOETE announced that cumulative GPA is subject to Parliamentary discussions and in the interim grades
                                       10 and 11 will be subject to pass/ fail while the grade 12 score will be the secondary graduation system
                                       score.
   Comments:




 Overall Comments PDO

  Given the delays in recruiting the M&E officer and in submitting the Project's progress report, the Team has utilized the updates exchanged
  during meetings and missions as well as verification reports to update the results framework. The Team continues to urge the PCU on the
  urgency to recruit the M&E Officer, which will enable a proper update of the results framework.




 Intermediate Results Indicators by Components



   Component 1: Improved Early Childhood Education

    IN00791764
    ►1. Mapping of existing spaces for KG classrooms (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)          End Target
                                                                   MOETE adopting new            MOETE adopting new
                                                                   direction towards             direction towards        Mapping exercise of
    Value                             Does not exist               identifying additional        identifying additional   available public spaces
                                                                   space for KG                  space for KG             conducted
                                                                   classrooms.                   classrooms, including


1/29/2020                                                                                                                    Page 3 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                    Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)



                                                                                                ready-made (highly
                                                                                                equipped) classrooms.

    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020               04-Sep-2023

                                       This is subject to further discussions between the MOETE and the WB
   Comments:

    IN00791769
    ►2. Refurbishment and equipping existing classroom spaces (Percentage, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                         0.00                         0.00                      90.00

    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020               01-Sep-2023

                                       This is subject to further discussions between the MOETE and the WB
   Comments:

    IN00791774
    ►3. Diagnostic study of KG teaching practices (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target
                                                                   Research Design
                                                                                                Data collection
                                                                   developed and data                                     KG Teaching practices
    Value                             Does not exist                                            scheduled for March
                                                                   collection instruments                                 study conducted
                                                                                                2020.
                                                                   piloted in July 2019
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020               04-Sep-2023
                                       Training of master trainers, data collection supervisors, and enumerators scheduled for January-February
   Comments:                           2020.



   Component 2: Effective Teachers and Education Leaders

    IN00791765
    ►4. Developed and implemented Continous Professional Development (CPD) framework (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target
                                                                                                                          CPD framework in
                                                                                                                          active usage as basis
                                                                                                                          for national,
    Value                             Does not exist               Does not exist               Does not exist            directorate, district,
                                                                                                                          and school levels
                                                                                                                          Professional
                                                                                                                          Development plans
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020               01-Sep-2023
                                       This is still work in progress. A committee was established to develop the CPD framework and the new
                                       Teachers licensing. In addition, a new USAID project "teach for tomorrow" is due to start and envisaged to
                                       contribute to the teachers’ licensing and the new CPD framework. Close collaboration is crucial to ensure
   Comments:                           coherence among various service providers and development partners. The Continuous Professional
                                       Development (CPD) will draw on earlier ministry efforts related to teachers professional development:
                                       behavioral training and training on new curriculum for KG1-2 and grade 1.

    IN00791770
    ►5. Updated Induction program for new teachers, school leaders, and supervisors (Text, Custom)



1/29/2020                                                                                                                   Page 4 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                  Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)




                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)         End Target
                                                                                                                        Second cohort of new
                                                                                                                        teachers, education
                                      current induction            Current induction          Current induction         leaders, and
    Value
                                      program                      program                    program                   supervisors hired are
                                                                                                                        trained under the new
                                                                                                                        induction program
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                06-Jan-2020               01-Sep-2023

                                       This is subject to further discussions between the MOETE and the WB
   Comments:

    IN00791775
    ►6. Expanded Teacher Professional Behavior (TPB) program (Percentage, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)         End Target

    Value                             30.00                        0.00                       41.00                     45.00

    Date                              28-Aug-2018                  16-Jul-2019                06-Jan-2020               01-Sep-2023
                                       The TBP Program has been rapidly scaled up nationwide. As of 30 November 2019, 14,500 schools had a
                                       COP functioning at “highly engaged” level, representing 26% of schools.
                                       Climate awareness related behaviors were included in the behavioral framework. Additional information as
   Comments:
                                       to when the climate awareness was included and how many teachers benefited will be included in the
                                       next ISR update.

     IN00791780
     6.a. Percentage of schools with COPs established under the Teacher Professional Behavior (TPB) program (Percentage, Custom
     Supplement)

                                     Baseline                     Actual (Previous)          Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                           4.00                         0.00                       29.00                      75.00

     IN00791782
     6.b. Percentage of female teachers trained under TPB program (Percentage, Custom Breakdown)

                                     Baseline                     Actual (Previous)          Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                           0.00                         0.00                       0.00                       40.00

     Date                            03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                06-Jan-2020               04-Sep-2023

     IN00791784
     6.c. Climate awareness training is included in TPB training program modules (Yes/No, Custom Supplement)

                                     Baseline                     Actual (Previous)          Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                           No                           Yes                        Yes                        Yes

    IN00791786
    ►7. Education Leaders and Supervisors (EL&S) program established (Percentage, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)         End Target

    Value                             0.00                         0.00                       0.00                      45.00

    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                06-Jan-2020               01-Sep-2023
   Comments:                           This is subject to further PCU/WB discussions.


1/29/2020                                                                                                                 Page 5 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                      Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)




     IN00791789
     7.a. Percentage of female EL&S trained (Percentage, Custom Breakdown)

                                     Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                           0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         40.00

     Date                            03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                   06-Jan-2020                  01-Sep-2023


   Component 3: Comprehensive Assessment Reform for Improved Student Learning

    IN00791766
    ►8. Grade 10, 11 and 12 tests in eight subjects designed, developed and administered (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target
                                                                                                  Grade 10 test
                                                                                                  designed and
                                                                    Grade 10 test designed
                                                                                                  developed using item-      New grades 10,11,12
                                                                    and developed using
    Value                             Does not exist                                              test bank and              tests administered
                                                                    item-test bank and
                                                                                                  administered               nation-wide
                                                                    administered nationwide
                                                                                                  nationwide in May
                                                                                                  2019.
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                   16-Jul-2019                   06-Jan-2020                04-Sep-2023
                                       Around 500,000 students sat for grade 10 computer-based tests in May 2019 and received their results in
   Comments:                           less than a month.

    IN00791771
    ►9. Grade 4 sample-based national assessment test designed, developed and administered (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target
                                                                                                                             Grade 4 national
                                                                                                                             assessment
    Value                             Does not exist                Does not exist                Does not exist
                                                                                                                             successfully
                                                                                                                             administered
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                   16-Jul-2019                   06-Jan-2020                01-Sep-2023
                                       The December 2019 mission agreed: (a) the grade 4 assessment will be sample-based, paper and
                                       pencil test, managed and administered by the National Council for Examinations and Educational
                                       Evaluation (NCEEE); (b) the sample will cover public and private schools; (c) the sampling will draw on
                                       previous related experience from Egypt’s participation on international assessment tests such as TIMSS
   Comments:                           and PIRLS; (d) the reporting will be at the levels of the school, district, directorate, and national, but the
                                       test will not provide data on individual student performance; (e) the baseline data collection will take place
                                       in October 2021 and the test will then be conducted every two years; and (f) the assessment will also
                                       include context questionnaires for students, teachers and principals, and parents.

    IN00791776
    ►10. Grade 9 new national test designed, developed and administered (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target
                                                                                                                             New grade 9 national
                                                                                                                             assessment
    Value                             Does not exist                Does not exist                Does not exist
                                                                                                                             successfully
                                                                                                                             administered



1/29/2020                                                                                                                       Page 6 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                     Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)




    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                   06-Jan-2020               01-Sep-2023

    IN00791779
    ►11. Restructuring and strengthening NCEE capacity (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)          End Target
                                                                                                                           NCEEE functions as
    Value                             Does not exist               Does not exist                Does not exist            the national center for
                                                                                                                           tests and examinations
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                   06-Jan-2020               01-Sep-2023

                                       The proposal for restructuring has been submitted to the Board of Directors of NCEEE.
   Comments:



   Component 4: Enhancing Education Service Delivery through Connected Systems

    IN00791767
    ►12. Established education technology entity (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)          End Target
                                                                                                                           Education Technology
                                                                                                                           entity fully operational:
                                                                                                                           (a) adequately staffed;
                                                                                                                           (b) sufficiently funded;
                                                                                                                           (c) actively monitor
    Value                             Does not exist               Does not exist                Does not exist
                                                                                                                           and report on
                                                                                                                           implementation; and
                                                                                                                           (d) produce annual
                                                                                                                           operational plans


    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                   06-Jan-2020               01-Sep-2023
                                       The Terms of Reference for the Technical assistance to support the establishment of the new entity was
                                       drafted, and will potentially by supported under the project. A mission is being scheduled for March/April
   Comments:
                                       2020 mission to advance the dialogue towards the establishment of the new entity.

    IN00791772
    ►13. National Education Decision Support Dashboard operational (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)          End Target
                                                                                                                           Fully operational
                                                                                                                           National Education
                                                                                                                           Decision Support
                                                                                                                           Dashboard: (a)
                                                                                                                           populated with data
                                                                                                                           from four data sources:
                                                                                                                           training data, grades 4
                                                                                                                           and 9 assessment
    Value                             Does not exist               Does not exist                Does not exist            data, digital learning
                                                                                                                           resources usage data,
                                                                                                                           and EMIS data; and
                                                                                                                           reporting tools; and (b)
                                                                                                                           evidence of utilization
                                                                                                                           to support evidence-
                                                                                                                           based budget
                                                                                                                           preparation and
                                                                                                                           allocation at


1/29/2020                                                                                                                     Page 7 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                    Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)



                                                                                                                         governorate and
                                                                                                                         district levels.

    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020              19-Mar-2019

                                       This is subject to further discussions between the PCU and the WB team.
   Comments:
     IN00791777
     13.a. Data provided through the dashboard are disaggregated by gender (Yes/No, Custom Supplement)

                                     Baseline                     Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target

     Value                           No                           No                           No                        Yes

    IN00791781
    ►14. Connected school infrastructure established (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)         End Target
                                                                                                                         Connected school
    Value                             Does not exist               Partially operational        Partially operational    infrastructure
                                                                                                                         operational
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020              04-Sep-2023
                                            1. 2,632 secondary schools already have internet connectivity through fiberoptic
                                            2. Grade 10 students in 2019/ 2020 have started receiving tablets in November 2019.
                                            3. digital learning resources in 8 subjects available for grade 10 students and grade 10 teachers;
                                               additional information on number of students and teachers receiving tablets, number of
   Comments:                                   classrooms with smartboard will be provided in the next ISR update.
                                           4. it was decided not to use clickers for KG1-2 and grade 1
                                       **Considered operational when (a) 80 percent of classrooms have function classroom technology
                                       packages; and (b) 80 percent of target schools have functioning Internet connectivity.

    IN00791783
    ►15. Digital learning resources utlized (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)         End Target
                                                                                                                         Digital learning
                                                                                                                         resources utilized:
                                                                                                Digital Learning
                                                                                                                         a.80% of unique
                                                                                                Resources developed
                                                                   Digital Learning                                      monthly users: users
                                                                                                for grade 10 and
                                                                   Resources developed for                               include students,
    Value                             Does not exist                                            partially for other
                                                                   grade 10, and available                               teachers, and schools
                                                                                                grades, and available
                                                                   for students and teachers                             b.80% unique monthly
                                                                                                for students and
                                                                                                                         user sessions: users
                                                                                                teachers
                                                                                                                         include students,
                                                                                                                         teachers, and schools
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020              04-Sep-2023

                                       Teachers guide for KG1-2 and grade 1and 2 teachers available online.
   Comments:
     IN00791785
     15.a. Percentage of female unique monthly Student users (Percentage, Custom Supplement)

                                     Baseline                     Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target

     Value                           0.00                         0.00                         0.00                      65.00

     IN00791787
     15.b. Percentage of female unique monthly Teacher users (Percentage, Custom Supplement)



1/29/2020                                                                                                                   Page 8 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                   Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)



                                     Baseline                     Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                           0.00                         0.00                        0.00                       65.00

    IN00791788
    ►16. Computer-based assessment management and delivery platform (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target
                                                                                               Training of more than
                                                                                               25,000 teachers and
                                                                                               school administrators
                                                                                                                         Functional Platform:
                                                                                               to create an item bank,
                                                                                                                         a.platform designed,
                                                                                               manage the
                                                                                                                         tested and deployed
                                                                                               administration and
                                                                                                                         b.data transfer,
                                                                   Item-test bank developed    marking the tests, and
                                                                                                                         management, analysis
    Value                             Does not exist               and used to create grade    make the grade 10
                                                                                                                         and reporting platform
                                                                   10 examinations             scores available
                                                                                                                         for individual
                                                                                               electronically to
                                                                                                                         assessment results
                                                                                               students, directorates,
                                                                                                                         developed and
                                                                                               districts, and school
                                                                                                                         deployed
                                                                                               principals in less than
                                                                                               a month.


    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                 06-Jan-2020               04-Sep-2023



   Component 5: Project Management, Communication, and Monitoring and Evaluation

    IN00791768
    ►17. Project communication plan developed and implemented (Text, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target
                                                                                                                         Project communication
                                                                   Draft communications        Draft communications      plan implemented as a
                                                                   strategy and draft plan     strategy and draft plan   tool for citizen
    Value                             Does not exist
                                                                   developed in mid-June       developed in mid-June     engagement in the
                                                                   2019                        2019                      education reform
                                                                                                                         process
    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                 06-Jan-2020               04-Sep-2023

                                       This is subject to further discussions between the MOETE and the WB for transition to implementation
   Comments:

    IN00791773
    ►18. Percentage of planned communication activities, by media category, implemented (Percentage, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                         0.00                        0.00                      80.00

    Date                              03-Sep-2018                  16-Jul-2019                 06-Jan-2020               01-Sep-2023

    IN00791778
    ►19. Grievances resolved within the stipulated service standards for response times (Percentage, Custom)

                                       Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                         0.00                        0.00                      70.00



1/29/2020                                                                                                                  Page 9 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                     Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)




    Date                                 03-Sep-2018                16-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020               04-Sep-2023
                                         This is subject to further discussions between the PCU and the WB to establish the project Grievance
   Comments:                             system per project operations manual.



 Overall Comments IR

  Given the delays in recruiting the M&E officer and in submitting the Project's progress report, the Team has utilized the updates exchanged
  during meetings and missions as well as verification reports to update the results framework. The Team continues to urge the PCU on the
  urgency to recruit the M&E Officer, which will enable a proper update of the results framework.




 Disbursement Linked Indicators

    IN00791790
    ►DLI 1 DLI#1: Increased Access to KG (Number, Output, 41,000,000.00, 0.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)             Year 5

    Value                         1,244,052.00                    1,244,052.00                 1,244,052.00                 --

    Date                          --                              07-Jul-2019                 06-Jan-2020                   --

                                 Number of additional children enrolled in KG (50% of whom are in the poorest districts as identified by
   Comments:
                                 CAPMAS) Target: 500,000 additional students
    IN00791791
    ►DLI 2 DLI 2 Strengthened Quality Assurance (QA) System for KG (Text, Process, 34,000,000.00, 0.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)             Year 5
                                                                                              Steps taken to develop
                                                                                              QA standards/ system. In
                                                                                              addition, the planned data
                                                                                              collection which primarily
                                                                  Steps taken to develop      caters for the diagnostic
    Value                         No QA system                                                                              --
                                                                  QA standards                study for KG teachers will
                                                                                              also include data
                                                                                              collection towards the
                                                                                              baseline quality assurance
                                                                                              ratings.
    Date                          --                              07-Jul-2019                 06-Jan-2020                   --
                                 Quality Assurance (QA) System for KG has been established and made operational Percentage of KGs
   Comments:                     assessed through the newly established QA system (Target: 100% of KGs) Percentage of KGs that have
                                 improved quality as per the QA System based on baseline assessment (Target: 50% of KGs)
    IN00791792
    ►DLI 3 DLI#3: Extending KG in-service Teacher training (Percentage, Output, 16,000,000.00, 0.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)             Year 5

    Value                         0.00                            0.00                         0.00                         --

    Date                          --                              07-Jul-2019                 06-Jan-2020                   --



1/29/2020                                                                                                                   Page 10 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                               Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)




   Comments:                     100 % of public KG teachers have completed the new KG teacher training modules

    IN00791793
   ►DLI 4 DLI#4: Improved Quality of Teacher and Education Leader Professional Development (Text, Intermediate Outcome, 30,000,000.00,
   0.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)       Actual (Current)            Year 5
                                  No CPD framework, current    No CPD framework,          No CPD framework,
    Value                         induction system under       current induction system   current induction system    --
                                  Teacher Cadre                under Teacher Cadre        under Teacher Cadre
    Date                          --                           07-Jul-2019                06-Jan-2020                 --

   Comments:                     Improved Quality of Teacher and Education Leader Professional Development

    IN00791794
    ►DLI 5 DLI#5 Expanding Teacher Professional Behaviors (TPB) Program (Number, Output, 60,000,000.00, 43.33%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)       Actual (Current)            Year 5

    Value                         1,870.00                     0.00                       14,500.00                   --

    Date                          --                           11-Oct-2018                06-Jan-2020                 --

   Comments:                     baseline To be provided by project effectiveness

    IN00791795
    ►DLI 6 DLI#6 Expanding Education Leaders and Supervisors Program (Text, Output, 10,000,000.00, 0.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)       Actual (Current)            Year 5
                                                               No Pilot                   No Pilot
    Value                         No Pilot                                                                            --

    Date                          --                           07-Jul-2019                06-Jan-2020                 --

    IN00791796
   ►DLI 7 DLI#7 Successful implementation of reform of secondary graduation and assessment system (Text, Intermediate Outcome,
   60,000,000.00, 20.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)       Actual (Current)            Year 5
                                                               Grade 10 examinations      Grade 10 examinations
                                                               framework developed.       framework developed in
                                                               Item-test bank developed   2018/2019. Item-test bank
                                                               to create grade 10         developed to create grade
                                                               examinations. Grade 10     10 examinations. Grade
                                  No framework, no current     examinations piloted for   10 examinations piloted
    Value                                                                                                             --
                                  item-bank                    580,000 students,          for 580,000 students,
                                                               including 500 school who   including 500 schools who
                                                               took paper-based exams.    took paper-based exams.
                                                               Results were delivered     Results were delivered
                                                               online within 1-month of   online within 1-month of
                                                               examinations.              examinations.
    Date                          --                           07-Jul-2019                06-Jan-2020                 --

    IN00791797



1/29/2020                                                                                                             Page 11 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                   Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)



   ►DLI 8 DLI#8: Grades 4 and 9 national assessments designed, developed and successfully administered (Text, Intermediate Outcome,
   25,000,000.00, 0.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)        Actual (Current)               Year 5

    Value                         No framework document       No framework document        No framework document          --

    Date                          --                          07-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020                    --

    IN00791798
    ►DLI 9 DLI#9: NCEEE restructured as a national testing and examination center (Text, Intermediate Outcome, 35,000,000.00, 20.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)        Actual (Current)               Year 5
                                                                                           Training of staff to create
                                                                                           an item bank, manage the
                                                                                           administration and
                                                                                           marking the tests, and
                                                              Restructuring plans          make the grade 10 scores
    Value                         No plans                    drafted, capacity building   available electronically to    --
                                                              plan drafted                 students, directorates,
                                                                                           districts, and school
                                                                                           principals in less than a
                                                                                           month.


    Date                          --                          07-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020                    --

    IN00791799
    ►DLI 10 DLI#10 Educational Technology enabling environment and platform (Text, Intermediate Outcome, 70,000,000.00, 0.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)        Actual (Current)               Year 5

    Value                         not established             not established              not established                --

    Date                          --                          07-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020                    --

    IN00791800
    ►DLI 11 DLI#11: Digital Learning Resources (Text, Output, 30,000,000.00, 0.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)        Actual (Current)               Year 5
                                                                                           Digital learning resources
                                                                                           for grade 10 developed -
                                                                                           IVA reports for 11.1, 11.4a
                                                              Digital learning resources
    Value                         Not mapped                                               and 11.4b being revised        --
                                                              for grade 10 developed
                                                                                           by the agency to
                                                                                           incorporate WB
                                                                                           comments.
    Date                          --                          07-Jul-2019                  06-Jan-2020                    --

    IN00791801
   ►DLI 12 DLI# 12 Successful Implementation of computer-based assessment management platform (Text, Intermediate Outcome,
   60,000,000.00, 0.00%)


                                  Baseline                        Actual (Previous)        Actual (Current)               Year 5



1/29/2020                                                                                                                 Page 12 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                     Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)



                                                                   computer-based              computer-based
                                                                   management Platform         management Platform
                                                                   developed and students      developed and students
    Value                         No Platform                                                                                --
                                                                   able to access grade 10     able to access grade 10
                                                                   results for May 2019        results for May 2019
                                                                   session                     session
    Date                          --                               07-Jul-2019                 06-Jan-2020                   --



 Data on Financial Performance


 Disbursements (by loan)

 Project        Loan/Credit/TF    Status       Currency         Original   Revised     Cancelled     Disbursed       Undisbursed             % Disbursed


 P157809        IBRD-88520        Effective    USD              500.00      500.00           0.00         231.25           268.75                   46%


 Key Dates (by loan)

 Project         Loan/Credit/TF    Status       Approval Date       Signing Date     Effectiveness Date      Orig. Closing Date     Rev. Closing Date

 P157809         IBRD-88520        Effective    13-Apr-2018         21-Apr-2018      28-Aug-2018             01-Sep-2023            01-Sep-2023


Cumulative Disbursements




1/29/2020                                                                                                                    Page 13 of 14
            The World Bank                                        Implementation Status & Results Report
            Supporting Egypt Education Reform Project (P157809)




  Restructuring History


  There has been no restructuring to date.


  Related Project(s)


 P173072-AF-Supporting Egypt Education Reform




1/29/2020                                                                      Page 14 of 14