57924

              Unmet need for contraception1
                                                                                                          at a glance

The concept of unmet need                                children but are not using any form of fam-
                                                         ily planning (unmet need for contraception
                                                         for limiting) or currently married women
The concept of "unmet need for contraception",           who want to postpone their next birth for
which refers to the proportion of women who do           two years but are not using any form of
not want to become pregnant but are not using            family planning (unmet need for contracep-
contraception, has been used in the international        tion for spacing)[2]. The unmet need measure
population field since the 1960s. The concept was        gives an estimate of the proportion of women who
developed from the first family planning and fertility   might potentially use contraception. Women who are
surveys conducted in developing countries, which         using contraceptives are said to have met need for
found a disconnect between women's knowledge,            family planning. The total demand for family plan-
attitudes, and practices (KAP) about contracep-          ning is made up of the proportion of married women
tion. This gap between what the respondents knew,        with unmet need and married women with met need
their fertility preferences, and behaviors to achieve    for family planning.3
their stated preferences, became known first as the
"KAP-Gap" and was used as a strong rationale for         The existence of unmet need is sometimes interpreted
investment in family planning programs (Casterline       as evidence of lack of access to a source of contra-
and Sinding, 2000)[1]. The subsequent development        ceptive supplies. However, there are many reasons
of the unmet need concept has been supported by          why women do not use contraception, and unmet
the availability of datasets from over 75 countries      need should not be equated with the lack of access
collected by the Demographic and Health Surveys          to contraception due to supply constraints (such as
(DHS) program. Difficulties with the measurement and     distance to a source for obtaining contraceptives,
interpretation of the concept have been described in     stockouts of contraceptives among providers, or legal
several papers by Westoff and coauthors since the        obstacles), or to financial costs associated with using
1970s[2�6]. In this note, we summarize the strengths     family planning. As assessed by surveys, women
and weaknesses of the unmet need indicator, discuss      with unmet need may still not have any intention to
the differences between demand and supply factors        use contraception were it readily accessible and of
for unmet need, show the differences between unmet       good quality. Non-use of contraception may be due
need and the intention to use contraception, and         to demand side reasons, including cultural or reli-
clarify the relevance of the concept for investing in    gious objections to contraception, objections from a
family planning programs.2                               spouse, lack of knowledge, or fear of side effects.

Unmet need for contraception is one of several           In countries such as Niger or Nigeria, in which large
frequently used indicators for monitoring of family      families are the norm and women do not want to
planning programs, and was recently added to the         space or limit fertility, both contraceptive use and
MDG goal of improving maternal health. Some other        unmet need are low (Figure 1). In countries in which
indicators that are used in combination with unmet
need are the contraceptive prevalence rate (CPR),
the method mix, sources of contraceptive supplies,
                                                         1
                                                          This note was written by Samuel Mills, Ed Bos, and Emi Suzuki, of the
                                                         Human Development Network at the World Bank. Correspondence
and reasons for not using contraception. In this note,   to: smills@worldbank.org . Peer reviewer comments from John May
we deal mainly with the unmet need indicator, but        (AFHTE) and Thomas Merrick (WBIHS) are gratefully acknowledged.
believe that other indicators should also be part of     2
                                                           This note will not review the extensive literature on the predictive
monitoring and evaluation of family planning pro-        validity of stated reproductive attitudes and intentions on contraceptive
                                                         demand and reproductive behavior. See, for example, A. Bankole and C.F.
grams to broaden the understanding of the use of         Westoff, The consistency and validity of reproductive attitudes: evidence
family planning in countries.                            from Morocco, J Biosoc Sci. 1998 (4):439�55; and T.K. Roy et al., Can
                                                         women's childbearing and contraceptive intentions predict contraceptive
                                                         demand? Family Planning Perspectives 2003, 29 (1): 25�31.
The indicator unmet need for contraception is            3
                                                          A better term would be "total market for family planning", as those
defined as the proportion of currently mar-              with unmet need may not have a demand for contraception at the time
ried women who do not want any more                      unmet need is established.

                                                                                                              March 2010
    desired family size has been declin-
    ing and couples want to space or limit        Figure 1. Unmet need for family planning vs.
    the number of children, as in Uganda          contraceptive prevalence rate, 2000�2008 DHS
    or Ethiopia, unmet need frequently            reports, selected countries
    increases. In these countries, informa-
    tion on contraceptive methods, or                 50
    where to obtain them is incomplete, or
                                                      45
    family planning services do not cover                                                  Uganda
    the entire population. Over time, fam-            40




                                                                            Unmet need for Family Planning
                                                                                Rwanda                   Haiti
    ily planning programs in countries with           35
                                                                    Liberia                    Ghana
                                                                                Ethiopia
    declining desired family size (such as                   Mauritania
                                                                            Senegal                            Lesotho
                                                      30             Mali            Benin
    Zimbabwe or Namibia) are often able                                        Burkina Faso
                                                              Eritrea Congo Democratic
                                                                                                         Gabon
                                                                                                          Malawi
                                                                                                                     Zambia
                                                                                                                                   Nepal
    to improve supply of contraceptives               25
                                                         Median Unmet need=22
                                                                                Republic       Pakistan
                                                                                                     Madagascar Kenya
                                                                                                                        Cambodia
                                                                                                                               Azerbaijan
                                                                                                                                           Swaziland
                                                                                                                                                        Bolivia
    and improve information on method                 20   Chad      Guinea             Cameroon
                                                                                                    Tanzania
                                                                                                                                 Philippines
                                                                                                                                                   Namibia
    availability and safety, leading to an                            Niger
                                                                                Nigeria Mozambique                     Congo
                                                                                                                 (Brazzaville)
                                                                                                                                                    Bangladesh Honduras
                                                      15
    increase in contraceptive use and a                                                                                             Armenia       India
                                                                                                                                                           Zimbabwe
                                                                                                                                                      Jordan Ukraine        Dominican
    decline in unmet need. It is important            10                                                                                Morocco Egypt                  Peru Republic
                                                                                                                                                  Indonesia Turkmenistan
    not to interpret high levels of unmet              5                                                                                                         Moldova
                                                                                                                                                                               Colombia
                                                                                                                                                                               Vietnam
    need as the failure of a family plan-
                                                       0                                                                       Median CPR=44
    ning program, as unmet need is a
    dynamic indicator that changes from                  0 5 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 50 55 60 65 70 75 80
    low levels in countries in which fertility                                                 Contraceptive Prevalence Rate
    preferences have not started to decline
    to higher levels during the transitional
    period between high and low fertility,
    when the demand for contraception
    has been created, and back to low levels as the                  of unmet need does not include an assessment of
    demand becomes fulfilled. Trends in unmet need                   whether women want or intend to use contraception.
    observed in countries will be discussed in section 6
    below.
                                                                                                             Reasons for unmet need
    How unmet need is measured                                                                               Knowing the level of unmet need in a given area
                                                                                                             at a certain time does not by itself provide informa-
    Unmet need for contraception is generally measured                                                       tion on why unmet need exists, or what the potential
    with household surveys, in which married women of                                                        future demand for contraception might be. Women
    reproductive age respond to a number of precisely                                                        may have one or more reasons for not intending to
    worded questions. The steps involved in calculating                                                      use contraceptives which may be related to desired
    whether unmet exists are illustrated in Figure 2, which                                                  fertility (wanting to have more children), to opposi-
    shows a flow chart for how information is collected                                                      tion to contraception for cultural or religious reasons
    used to calculate the level of unmet need. A woman                                                       (by women or their husbands, or others), to lack of
    is first asked whether she is using any method of                                                        knowledge of methods or where to obtain them, or
    contraception, whether for the purpose of limiting or                                                    to fear of side effects or health concerns. Knowing
    spacing births. If she is using contraception, includ-                                                   why women have unmet need is useful when plan-
    ing traditional methods, she is considered to be a                                                       ning information, education, and communication
    contraceptive user, and therefore does not have                                                          (IEC) campaigns and behavioral change communica-
    unmet need. Women who are not using contracep-                                                           tion (BCC) programs to generate demand for family
    tion are then asked whether they are pregnant or                                                         planning services. For example, women with unmet
    amenorrheic (not menstruating, often due to a recent                                                     need who are not planning on using contraception
    pregnancy or lactation). In the calculation of unmet                                                     because of health concerns may be provided with
    need, pregnant or amenorrheic women whose preg-                                                          information on several alternative contraceptive meth-
    nancy was mistimed or unwanted are added to the                                                          ods or counseling on side effects. In contrast, women
    proportion with unmet need, even though they do not                                                      with unmet need who want to use contraception in
    at the time of the survey have an immediate need for                                                     the future may need information on where to go or
    contraception, given their prgenancy. Women who                                                          need help with the cost of a contraceptive method.
    are not pregnant or amenorrheic and are infecund
    do not have unmet need, nor do women who want to                                                         The Demographic and Health Surveys asked the
    become pregnant soon. Note that the measurement                                                          reasons for non-use of contraception of women who

2
  Figure 2. The Measurement of unmet need among currently married women,
  Zambia 2001�2002

                                                  Currently Married Women 100%




                         Using for       Using for                                 Not Using Any Method 66%
                       Spacing 19%     Limiting 15%




                    Pregnant or Amenorrheic 33%                                             Not Pregnant or Amenorrheic 33%



        Intended 18%         Mistimed 10%         Unwanted 5%                            Fecund 24%                      Infecund 9%




                                                                                        Want Later             Want No More         Want Soon
                                                                                          6%                        6%                11%



                                Need for              Need for                       Need for                     Need for
                              Spacing 10%           Limiting 5%                     Spacing 6%                  Limiting 6%




                                                        Total Unmet Need 27%




  Source: Westoff 2006.




are not planning to use in the future.
Figure 3 shows the mean values for                     Figure 3. Reasons currently married women who
South Asian and Sub-Saharan African                    are not using contraception do not intend to use in
countries of all surveys conducted                     future, 2000�2008 DHS reports, regional means
from 2000 to 2008. For women
whose reasons for not using contra-
ception are not related to a desire to                                                                                                       54
                                                             Opposition to use
                                                                                                                                       45
have more children or other fertility-
related reasons such as infertility
                                                                                                                              37
and infrequent sex/no sex, the most                    Health concerns/effects
                                                                                                                               39
important reasons are opposition to
use contraceptives, and a fear of side
                                                                                        5
effects and health concerns. Lack of                        Lack of knowledge
                                                                                                    14
knowledge is somewhat important
in Sub-Saharan Africa; the costs of                                                     4
contraceptives or access to a family                              Cost too much
                                                                                  1.2
planning provider are not important
reasons in either region. This indicates                                          0.4
                                                         Lack of access/too far
that family planning programs must                                                0.5
do more than supplying methods of
contraception at affordable prices.                                           0              10          20         30        40        50        60
An understanding of the nature of                                                                 South Asia               Sub-Saharan Africa
concerns of side effects, and the
reasons for opposition to use is critical              Note: Fertility-related reasons such as wanting more children are excluded
to design appropriate communica-

                                                                                                                                                       3
    tion campaigns. IEC efforts need to
    address the reasons for opposition to           Figure 4. Reasons currently married women
    use (this could include opposition from         who are not using contraception who do not
    husbands or other family members, or            intend to use in future, 2000�2008 DHS reports,
    religious reasons), as well as provide          selected countries
    sufficient information so that women
    can make informed choices about the
                                                                                                                    44
    significance of side effects and poten-              Opposition to use                                35
    tial health impacts. Such information                                                                                             62
    efforts need to take individual country
                                                                                      9
    findings into account, as reasons for           Health concerns/effects                                                      58
    not intending to use contraception                                                             27
    may vary substantially in different                                                                             45
    socioeconomic contexts, as shown                    Lack of knowledge         5
                                                                                      10
    in Figure 4. Lack of knowledge is the
    most important reason for the inten-                                   1.0
    tion not to use contraception in Chad,                   Cost too much 1.1
                                                                           0.6
    whereas this is unimportant in Ghana,
    where health concerns and side                                          0.3
                                                     Lack of access/too far 0.5
    effects are the reported reasons for                                    0.4
    non-use. In Senegal, more than half of
    all women who are not using con-                                       0          10      20    30         40        50      60        70
    traception are not doing so because                                                Chad              Ghana                Senegal
    of opposition to family planning (the
    exact nature of which is also collected         Note: Fertility-related reasons such as wanting more children are excluded
    in the DHS).

    In most low- and middle income
    countries, knowledge of contraceptive methods and                cent (Middle East and North Africa) to 26 percent
    where to obtain them is high for married women                   (Sub-Saharan Africa); met need (Contraceptive
    of reproductive age (between 90 and 100 percent                  Prevalence Rate) ranges from 25 percent (Sub-
    of survey respondents), but in a few Sub-Saharan                 Saharan Africa) to 63 percent (Latin America and
    African countries (include Chad, Mali, Niger), knowl-            the Caribbean).
    edge of at least one contraceptive method is much                The total demand for family planning across
    lower (between 60 to 80 percent). In these countries,            regions ranges from 51 percent (Sub-Saharan
    both contraceptive use and unmet need are low,                   Africa) to 80 percent (Latin America and the Ca-
    as the desired level of fertility is high. IEC efforts in        ribbean). In Africa, only 45 percent of demand is
    these countries need to focus on the potential benefits          satisfied, contrasting to 70�84 percent in the other
    of small family sizes and the untoward health effects            regions.
    such as low birth weight, preterm birth, high infant
                                                                     In Sub-Saharan African countries, unmet need for
    mortality, and high maternal mortality.
                                                                     limiting is very low in Chad, Congo, and Niger
                                                                     (below 5 percent); it is also low in Zimbabwe (5
    Levels of unmet need in low-                                     percent), where most of the unmet need has been
                                                                     addressed through increased contraceptive use.
    and middle income countries
                                                                     Different levels of unmet need and total poten-
    Table 1 shows the levels of unmet need in recent                 tial demand for family planning in Sub-Saharan
    DHS country reports during 2000�2008, showing                    African countries reflect the non-linear pattern of
    aggregate results for the Bank regions, and detailed             unmet need over the fertility transition, pointing
    country results for the Africa region. Some of the key           to the need for careful interpretation of levels and
    findings from this table include:                                trends of the unmet need indicator.

     Unmet need is higher for limiting than spacing
     childbearing, in all regions except Sub-Saharan
                                                                    Levels of unmet need by
     Africa, where unmet need for spacing is almost                 poverty quintiles
     twice as high as for limiting
     Across regions, unmet need ranges from 11 per-                 Unlike many of the other health indicators,
                                                                    levels of unmet need do not show clear
4
Table 1. Unmet need, met need, and total demand for family planning. Countries
with DHS surveys 2000�2009 (unweighted means for regional aggregates)

                                                                                   Total
                                    Unmet          Unmet      Unmet      Met     demand      Percentage
                                   need for       need for     need     Need    for family   of demand
                                   spacing        limiting     Total    (CPR)    planning     satisfied
  Region/Country                       A              B      C (=A+B)    D      E (=C+D)      F (=D/E)

East Asia and Pacific                   6             8        14        57        71            79
Europe and                              4             9        13        60        73            83
Central Asia
Latin America and                       7             10       17        63        80            77
Caribbean
Middle East and                         4              7       11        57        68            84
North Africa
South Asia                              8             12       20        47        67            70
Sub-Saharan Africa                    17               9       26        25        51            45
 Benin                                 18             12        30       17        47            36
 Burkina Faso                          22              7        29       14        43            32
 Cameroon                              14              6        20       26        46            56
 Chad                                  18              2        21        3        24            12
 Congo, Rep.                           13              3        16       44        61            73
 Congo, Dem. Rep.                      19              5        24       21        45            46
 Eritrea                               21              6        27        8        35            23
 Ethiopia                              20             14        34       15        49            30
 Gabon                                 20              8        28       33        61            54
 Ghana                                 23             13        35       24        59            40
 Guinea                                13              8        21        9        30            30
 Kenya                                 14             10        25       39         64           62
 Lesotho                               11             20        31       37         68           55
 Liberia                               25             11        36       11         47           24
 Madagascar                            11             12        24       27         51           54
 Malawi                                17             10        28       33         60           54
 Mali                                  21             10        31        8         39           21
 Mauritania                            23              9        32        8         40           20
 Mozambique                            11              8        18       26         44           58
 Namibia                                9             12        21       55         76           73
 Niger                                 13              3        16       11         27           42
 Nigeria                               12              5        17       15         32           46
 Rwanda                                25             13        38       17         55           32
 Senegal                               24              7        32       12         43           27
 Swaziland                              7             17        24       51         75           68
 Tanzania                              15              7        22       26         48           55
 Uganda                                25             16        41       24         64           37
 Zambia                                17              9        27       41         67           61
 Zimbabwe                               8              5        13       60         73           83

Source: Demographic and Health Surveys (2000�2009).



                                                                                                          5
    patterns by poverty quintiles
    as shown in Figure 5. In some                  Figure 5. Unmet need by poverty quintiles,
    countries such as Benin, Chad, Mali,           1990�2008
    and Nigeria, women in the wealthi-
    est quintile have higher unmet need                  50
    than the women in lower quintiles,                   45
    whereas in other countries such as
    Bolivia, Ghana, Togo, and Zimbabwe,                  40

    the patterns are reversed. The rea-




                                                        Percent with unmet need
                                                         35
    sons for these patterns are essentially
                                                         30
    the same as for differences among
    countries at different stages of fertil-             25
    ity decline. Countries in which unmet                20
    need increases with increasing wealth
    tend to be in the earlier stages of                  15
    declining desired family size, which                 10
    declines first in urban areas, among
                                                          5
    more educated women, and among
    wealthier households. As family plan-                 0
                                                                         Lowest quintile                      Highest quintile
    ning programs and other providers
    are at first not able to fill the increased         Bangladesh 2007                Egypt, Arab Rep. 2005        Togo 2006
    demand for contraceptives or ad-                    Benin 2001                     Ghana 2003                   Uganda 200�01
                                                        Bolivia 2003                   Kyrgyz republic 2005�06      Zimbabwe 2005�06
    dress concerns about health and side
                                                        Chad 2004                      Mali 2006
    effects, unmet need increases in the                Central African Republic       Nigeria 2003
    wealthier quintiles, while it remains               1994�95
    low in the poorest quintiles where
    demand for family planning remains             Source: Demographic and Health Surveys, Multiple Indicator Cluster Surveys.
    low. Over time, contraceptive use in-
    creases among the wealthier quintiles
    and met need reduces unmet need, at
    which time the patterns reverse. At the
    pre-transition and late transition phases of fertility            response to a BCC programs instituted to influence
    decline, unmet need may be uniformly low for all                  couples to desire smaller families could be interpret-
    quintiles.                                                        ed as a success; subsequently, unmet need should
                                                                      decrease with increasing access to quality family
                                                                      planning services.
    Trends in unmet need
    As discussed above, the extent of unmet need for                              Summary and implications for
    contraception in a given country changes over time
    as desired family size and contraceptive use patterns
                                                                                  Bank operations
    change, and does not necessarily decrease with
                                                                                   It is important not to interpret high levels of unmet
    improved access to family planning services[3]. Thus,
                                                                                   need as the failure of a family planning program,
    low levels of unmet need do not always in-
                                                                                   as unmet need is a dynamic indicator. It changes
    dicate success of family planning programs
                                                                                   from low levels in countries in which fertility prefer-
    and vice versa.
                                                                                   ences have not started to decline to higher levels
                                                                                   during the fertility transition period, and back to
    Indeed, as shown in Figure 6, in the past two
                                                                                   low levels as the demand for small family size
    decades unmet need for contraception increased
                                                                                   becomes fulfilled.
    in Uganda, it decreased in Egypt, and in the case
    of Ghana there was no appreciable change. In                                   The existence of unmet need is sometimes inter-
    Bangladesh contraceptive use increased from 45                                 preted as evidence of lack of access to a source
    percent to 56 percent during 1993�2007. Dur-                                   of contraceptive supplies due to supply constraints
    ing this period, unmet need first decreased, then                              or to financial costs. However, there are many
    increased.                                                                     reasons why women do not use contraception
                                                                                   and family planning programs must do more than
    In a country with high TFR but low unmet need                                  supplying methods of contraception at affordable
    such as Niger, an initial increase in unmet need in                            prices.

6
  Figure 6. Trends in unmet need and CPR during 1990�2008, selected countries

                            Bangladesh                                                Egypt
  70                                                         70


  60                                                         60


  50                                                         50


  40                                                         40


  30                                                         30


  20                                                         20


  10                                                         10


   0                                                          0
   1990          1995          2000          2005     2010    1990       1995           2000      2005      2010
                      CPR                Unmet need                             CPR            Unmet need


                             Ghana                                                    Uganda
  70                                                         70


  60                                                         60


  50                                                         50


  40                                                         40


  30                                                         30


  20                                                         20


  10                                                         10


   0                                                          0
   1990          1995          2000          2005     2010    1990       1995           2000      2005      2010
                      CPR                Unmet need                             CPR            Unmet need


  Source: Demographic and Health Surveys




 In monitoring and evaluation of family plan-                 In the design of projects which aim at improving
  ning programs, an increase in unmet need or no               access to and quality of family planning pro-
  change in unmet need does not always imply that              grams, it is important to understand the reasons
  the intervention was not successful. One needs to            why women are not using contraceptives. Infor-
  take into account other indicators such as CPR,              mation on the reasons for not intending to use
  TFR, fertility preferences, method mix, and reasons          contraceptives is available in the DHS and other
  for not using contraceptives.                                surveys.




                                                                                                                   7
    References

    1. J. B. Casterline and S. W. Sinding. 2000. Unmet Need for Family Planning in Developing Countries
       and Implications for Population Policy Population and Development Review 26: 4 691�723.
    2. Westoff, C F. 2006. New Estimates of Unmet Need and the Demand for Family Planning. DHS Com-
       parative Reports No. 14. Calverton, Maryland, USA. Macro International Inc. Available on the Web
       at http://www.measuredhs.com/pubs/pdf/CR14/CR14.pdf. Access February 22, 2010.
    3. Robey, B., Ross, J., and Bhushan, I. Meeting unmet need: New strategies, Population Reports, Series
       J, No. 43. Baltimore, Johns Hopkins School of Public Health, Population Information Program, Sep-
       tember 1996. Available on the Web at http://www.infoforhealth.org/pr/online.shtml. Accessed Febru-
       ary 22, 2010.
    4. Westoff, CF. and Bankole, A. Unmet need: 1990�1994. Calverton, Maryland, Macro International,
       Jun. 1995. (DHS Comparative Studies No. 16) 55 p.
    5. Westoff, CF. and Ochoa, LH. Unmet need and the demand for family planning. Columbia, Mary-
       land, Institute for Resource Development. Macro International, Jun. 1991. (Demographic and Health
       Surveys Comparative Studies No. 5) 43 p.
    6. Westoff, CF. The unmet need for birth control in five Asian countries. International Family Planning
       Perspectives 10(3): 173�181. May�Jun. 1978.




8