The World Bank                                                                                      Implementation Status & Results Report
         Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)



Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)


 SOUTH ASIA | Afghanistan | Social Sustainability and Inclusion Global Practice |
 IBRD/IDA | Investment Project Financing | FY 2019 | Seq No: 8 | ARCHIVED on 21-Oct-2022 | ISR53488 |


 Implementing Agencies: Ministry of Economy, Ministry of Finance, Aid Management Directorate



 Key Dates


  Key Project Dates

   Bank Approval Date: 19-Dec-2018                                            Effectiveness Date: 06-Feb-2019
   Planned Mid Term Review Date: --                                           Actual Mid-Term Review Date:
   Original Closing Date: 31-Dec-2023                                         Revised Closing Date: 31-Dec-2023
 pdoTable

 Project Development Objectives

  Project Development Objective (from Project Appraisal Document)
  The Project Development Objective is to strengthen the enabling environment for economic opportunities in cities where there is a high influx of
  displaced people.

  This will be pursued by increasing the returnees' access to civil documents, providing short-term employment opportunities, improving market
  enabling infrastructure, and supporting investor friendly regulatory reforms.

  Has the Project Development Objective been changed since Board Approval of the Project Objective?
  No


 Components Table

 Name
 Regional and National Integration of Displaced Persons:(Cost $4.50 M)
 Short Term Employment Opportunities, Reforms, and Market Enabling Infrastructure under IDLG:(Cost
 $121.80 M)
 Prioritized Urban Investments in Four Provincial Capital Cities:(Cost $18.75 M)
 Market Enabling Infrastructure and Reforms for Kabul Municipality:(Cost $40.00 M)
 Red Carpet and Program Coordination:(Cost $8.70 M)

 Overall Ratings

 Name                                                                       Previous Rating                          Current Rating

 Progress towards achievement of PDO                                        Moderately Satisfactory                 Moderately Satisfactory
 Overall Implementation Progress (IP)                                       Moderately Satisfactory                 Moderately Satisfactory
 Overall Risk Rating                                                        High                                    High


 Implementation Status and Key Decisions

  The Afghanistan Reconstruction Trust Fund (ARTF) in the project was canceled based on the consideration that the project cannot be effectively
  implemented under the current extraordinary situation in Afghanistan. Undisbursed IDA grants under this project will remain suspended until a
  decision is made by the World Bank.



10/21/2022                                                                                                                   Page 1 of 14
            The World Bank                                                                                    Implementation Status & Results Report
            Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




  Risks


 Systematic Operations Risk-rating Tool


  Risk Category                                             Rating at Approval             Previous Rating                Current Rating

  Political and Governance                                  High                          High                          High
  Macroeconomic                                             High                          High                          High
  Sector Strategies and Policies                            High                          High                          High
  Technical Design of Project or Program                    Substantial                   Substantial                   Substantial
  Institutional Capacity for Implementation and
                                                            Substantial                   Substantial                   Substantial
  Sustainability
  Fiduciary                                                 High                          High                          High
  Environment and Social                                    Substantial                   Substantial                   Substantial
  Stakeholders                                              Substantial                   High                          High
  Other                                                     Substantial                   --                             Substantial
  Overall                                                   High                          High                          High



  Results


 PDO Indicators by Objectives / Outcomes



   ACCESS TO CIVIL DOCUMENTS

    IN01204341
    ►Percentage of Afghan Passport Applications in Pakistan Processed (Percentage, Custom)

                                       Baseline                   Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                              0.00                       0.00                          0.00                      80.00

    Date                               01-Nov-2018                27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021              31-Dec-2023
                                       During the project implementation period, number of Afghan Passport Applications in Pakistan processed,
                                       divided by the number of Afghan Passport Application received in Pakistan.
   Comments:                           The Afghan missions in Pakistan has not been able to process machine readable passports yet, since
                                       required equipment has not been procured.

     IN01204344
     Percentage of Afghan Passport Applications in Pakistan Processed (for female applicants) (Percentage, Custom Supplement)

                                     Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                           0.00                       0.00                         0.00                        80.00


10/21/2022                                                                                                                  Page 2 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                 Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




   SHORT-TERM EMPLOYMENT OPPORTUNITIES

    IN01204330
    ►Number of vulnerable households in high IDP/returnee cities provided with short term employment support (number) (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                  Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                      6,932.00                    6,932.00                  80,000.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018               27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021              31-Dec-2023

                                      277,287 labor days were generated for 6,932 households (average 40 labor days per household).
   Comments:

     IN01204343
     Of which IDP/Returnee households (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                   Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target

     Value                          0.00                       0.00                        0.00                      10,000.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                15-Aug-2021                 15-Aug-2021               31-Dec-2023


   RED CARPET REFORMS AND MARKET FACILITATING INVESTMENTS

    IN01204329
    ►Number of market enabling infrastructure built or upgraded (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                  Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                      2.00                        2.00                      1,115.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018               27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021              31-Dec-2023
                                      Number of infrastructure built, upgraded, or maintained through MCCG, Gozar and Business Gozar
   Comments:                          Grants, and Priority Investment Projects.

     IN01204342
     Of which at the community level (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                   Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target

     Value                          0.00                       0.00                        0.00                      900.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023

     IN01204345
     Of which at the Gozar level (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                   Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target

     Value                          0.00                       0.00                        0.00                      180.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023

     IN01204346
     Of which at the Business Gozar level (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                   Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)          End Target


10/21/2022                                                                                                              Page 3 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                  Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




     Value                          0.00                        0.00                        0.00                        30.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023

     IN01204347
     Of which at the city level (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                        2.00                        2.00                        5.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023

    IN01204348
    ►Number of processing steps reduced for specific Doing Business reform indicators in four cities (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                   Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                       0.00                        0.00                       13.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023

   Comments:                          Number of processing steps reduced for obtaining construction permits for commercial properties

     IN01204349
     Of which in the three cities of Jalalabad, Herat, and Kandahar (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                        0.00                        0.00                        10.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023

     IN01204350
     Of which in Kabul (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                        0.00                        0.00                        3.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023



 Intermediate Results Indicators by Components



   Support for Afghan Refugees in Pakistan

    IN01204351
    ►Number of passports issued to Afghan refugees in Pakistan during the project implementation period (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                   Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                       0.00                        0.00                       1,500,000.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023

                                      Number of machine-readable passports issued for the applications received at the Afghan Embassy and
   Comments:
                                      consulates in Pakistan.


10/21/2022                                                                                                                Page 4 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                    Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)



     IN01204357
     of which women (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        0.00                         0.00                        600,000.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                  27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023

    IN01204359
    ►Percentage of passport applications processed within ten (10) working days (Percentage, Custom)

                                      Baseline                    Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                        0.00                         0.00                      80.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                  27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023
                                      The number of machine-readable passports issued within 10 working days of application received, divided
                                      by the number of complete passport applications received during the reporting period at the Afghan
   Comments:
                                      Embassy and consulates in Pakistan. The baseline is zero, as machine-readable passports have not been
                                      issued in Pakistan, and there is no monitoring system in place.
     IN01204363
     of which women (Percentage, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        0.00                         0.00                        80.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                  27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023

    IN01204367
    ►Number of people reached through communications activities implemented through the Project (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                    Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target

    Value                             0.00                        0.00                         0.00                      750,000.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                  27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023
                                      Sum of the numbers of (a) followers of the social media accounts created by the project; (b) help/support
   Comments:                          cases logged by helplines and information centers; and (c) people reached by awareness campaigns.

     IN01204370
     of which women (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        0.00                         0.00                        300,000.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                  27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023


   Short-Term Employment Opportunities

    IN01204353
    ►% of CDC members who are women (Percentage, Custom)

                                      Baseline                    Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)          End Target



10/21/2022                                                                                                                 Page 5 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                     Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




    Value                             0.00                        50.00                         50.00                      40.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                 15-Aug-2021                   15-Aug-2021                31-Dec-2023

                                      3,484 of 6,991 CDC members elected for 309 CDCs to date are women.
   Comments:

    IN01204355
    ►Number of COVID-19 economic recovery related work days created in Kabul (Days, Custom)

                                      Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

    Value                             0.00                        277,287.00                    277,287.00                 850,000.00

    Date                              01-Sep-2020                 15-Aug-2021                   15-Aug-2021                30-Jun-2021



   Market Facilitating Investments

   IN01204354
   ►Number of municipalities where IDLG holds EZ-Kar coordination meetings with government authorities, Gozar assemblies and Business
   Gozar assemblies (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

    Value                             0.00                        3.00                          3.00                       11.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023

                                      Number of cities that have held meetings with EZ-Kar stakeholders in the cities where Gozar and
   Comments:
                                      Business Gozar Grants are implemented.
    IN01204358
    ►Number of Gozars (hh and business) that have prepared their Gozar economic development plans (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

    Value                             0.00                        3.00                          3.00                       276.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023

   Comments:                          Number of approved Gozar Economic Development Plans

    IN01204361
    ►Businesses in urban areas provided with access to “Improved Water Sources” under the project (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

    Value                             0.00                        0.00                          0.00                       0.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023
                                      Number of businesses that are provided with access to improved water sources through Priority Projects
                                      and Gozar/Business Gozar Grants. Target value for this indicator is currently set at ‘0’, since this Project
   Comments:                          takes on a demand-driven approach and the types and numbers of subprojects to be implemented under
                                      the Project cannot/should not be predetermined, as it will not be accurate. The target value may be set by
                                      the mid-term review by when there will be more information from implementation.
     IN01204362
     Of which through Priority Projects in Kabul (Number, Custom Breakdown)



10/21/2022                                                                                                                   Page 6 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                      Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)



                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                  31-Dec-2023

     IN01204368
     Of which through Priority Projects in the four cities of Herat, Kandahar, Khost, and Jalalabad (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                  31-Dec-2023

     IN01204371
     Of which through Gozar and Business Gozar Grants (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                  31-Dec-2023

    IN01204373
    ►Businesses in urban areas provided with access to "Improved Sanitation" under the project (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

    Value                             0.00                         0.00                          0.00                       0.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023
                                      Number of businesses that are provided with access to improved sanitation through Priority Projects and
                                      Gozar/Business Gozar Grants. Target value for this indicator is currently set at ‘0’, since this Project takes
   Comments:                          on a demand-driven approach and the types and numbers of subprojects to be implemented under the
                                      Project cannot/should not be predetermined, as it will not be accurate. The target value may be set by the
                                      mid-term review by when there will be more information from implementation.
     IN01204375
     Of which through Priority Projects in Kabul (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                  31-Dec-2023

     IN01204377
     Of which through Gozar and Business Gozar Grants (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                  31-Dec-2023

    IN01204379
    ►Businesses in urban areas provided with access to all-season roads within a 500-meter range under the project (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target



10/21/2022                                                                                                                    Page 7 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                     Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




    Value                             0.00                        0.00                          0.00                       0.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023
                                      Number of businesses that are provided with access to all-season roads within a 500-meter range through
                                      Priority Projects and Gozar/Business Gozar Grants. Target value for this indicator is currently set at ‘0’,
   Comments:                          since this Project takes on a demand-driven approach and the types and numbers of subprojects to be
                                      implemented under the Project cannot/should not be predetermined, as it will not be accurate. The target
                                      value may be set by the mid-term review by when there will be more information from implementation.
     IN01204380
     KM of roads constructed (Kilometers, Custom Supplement)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         2.62                          2.62                        0.00

     IN01204381
     KM of roads rehabilitated (Kilometers, Custom Supplement)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                        0.00

    IN01204382
    ►Businesses in urban areas provided with access to regular solid waste collection at the markets under the project (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

    Value                             0.00                        0.00                          0.00                       0.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023
                                      Number of businesses that are provided with access to regular solid waste collection through Priority
                                      Projects and Gozar/Business Gozar Grants. Target value for this indicator is currently set at ‘0’, since this
   Comments:                          Project takes on a demand-driven approach and the types and numbers of subprojects to be implemented
                                      under the Project cannot/should not be predetermined, as it will not be accurate. The target value may be
                                      set by the mid-term review by when there will be more information from implementation.
     IN01204383
     Of which through Priority Projects in Kabul (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                        0.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023

     IN01204384
     Of which through Gozar and Business Gozar Grants (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                        0.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023

    IN01204385
    ►Businesses in urban areas provided with access to electricity under the project (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                    Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target




10/21/2022                                                                                                                   Page 8 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                      Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




    Value                             0.00                         0.00                          0.00                       0.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023
                                      Number of businesses that are provided with access to electricity through Priority Projects and
                                      Gozar/Business Gozar Grants. Target value for this indicator is currently set at ‘0’, since this Project takes
   Comments:                          on a demand-driven approach and the types and numbers of subprojects to be implemented under the
                                      Project cannot/should not be predetermined, as it will not be accurate. The target value may be set by the
                                      mid-term review by when there will be more information from implementation.
     IN01204386
     Generation Capacity of Renewable Energy (other than hydropower) rehabilitated under the project (Megawatt, Custom Supplement)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00

     IN01204387
     Generation Capacity of Renewable Energy (other than hydropower) constructed under the project (Megawatt, Custom Supplement)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00

    IN01204388
    ►Businesses with improved access to ICT services under the project (number of business subscribers) (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                     Actual (Previous)             Actual (Current)           End Target

    Value                             0.00                         0.00                          0.00                       0.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023
                                      Number of businesses that are provided with access to ICT services through Priority Projects and
                                      Gozar/Business Gozar Grants. Target value for this indicator is currently set at ‘0’, since this Project takes
   Comments:                          on a demand-driven approach and the types and numbers of subprojects to be implemented under the
                                      Project cannot/should not be predetermined, as it will not be accurate. The target value may be set by the
                                      mid-term review by when there will be more information from implementation.
     IN01204389
     Of which through Priority Projects in Kabul (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                  31-Dec-2023

     IN01204390
     Of which through Priority Projects in the four cities of Herat, Kandahar, Khost, and Jalalabad (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                  27-Jun-2021                   27-Jun-2021                  31-Dec-2023

     IN01204391
     Of which through Gozar and Business Gozar Grants (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                     Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

     Value                          0.00                         0.00                          0.00                         0.00


10/21/2022                                                                                                                    Page 9 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                        Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




     Date                           01-Nov-2018                   27-Jun-2021                    27-Jun-2021                   31-Dec-2023

   IN01204392
   ►Number of market enabling investments under the project that address the gender gap in access to urban economic centers/ markets
   (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                      Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

    Value                             0.00                          0.00                           0.00                        35.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                   27-Jun-2021                    27-Jun-2021                 31-Dec-2023
                                      Number of market enabling investments under the project that close gender gaps in women’s access to
                                      markets, which can be in the form of (i) specific subprojects exclusively for women, e.g. restoration of
   Comments:                          women's markets, rehabilitation of toilet facilities for markets; or (ii) subprojects that are inclusive for (and
                                      do not exclude) women, such as extension and upgrading of pedestrian walkways, bus stops and street
                                      lighting that link to markets.
     IN01204393
     Of which through Priority Projects in Kabul (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                      Actual (Previous)               Actual (Current)             End Target

     Value                          0.00                          0.00                           0.00                          1.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                   27-Jun-2021                    27-Jun-2021                   31-Dec-2023

     IN01204394
     Of which through Priority Projects in the four cities of Herat, Jalalabad, Kandahar, and Khost (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                      Actual (Previous)               Actual (Current)             End Target

     Value                          0.00                          0.00                           0.00                          4.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                   27-Jun-2021                    27-Jun-2021                   31-Dec-2023

     IN01204395
     Of which through Gozar and Business Gozar Grants (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                      Actual (Previous)               Actual (Current)             End Target

     Value                          0.00                          0.00                           0.00                          30.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                   27-Jun-2021                    27-Jun-2021                   31-Dec-2023

    IN01204396
    ►Number of businesses receiving cash grants (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                      Actual (Previous)              Actual (Current)            End Target

    Value                             0.00                          0.00                           0.00                        20,000.00

    Date                              01-Sep-2020                   27-Jun-2021                    27-Jun-2021                 30-Jun-2021

     IN01204397
     Of which women owned (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                      Actual (Previous)               Actual (Current)             End Target

     Value                          0.00                          0.00                           0.00                          2,000.00

     Date                           01-Sep-2020                   27-Jun-2021                    27-Jun-2021                   30-Jun-2021


10/21/2022                                                                                                                      Page 10 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                  Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




   Red Carpet Reforms

    IN01204352
    ►Number of reform implementation plans prepared (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                   Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)         End Target

    Value                             0.00                       5.00                        5.00                      5.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023

   Comments:                          Number of construction permit reform implementation plans prepared

     IN01204356
     Of which at national level (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        1.00                        1.00                       1.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023

     IN01204360
     Of which in the three cities of Herat, Jalalabad, and Kandahar (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        3.00                        3.00                       3.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023

     IN01204364
     Of which in Kabul (Number, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        1.00                        1.00                       1.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023

    IN01204366
    ►Reduction in time taken to obtain a construction permit for commercial properties in Jalalabad, Kandahar, Herat, and Kabul (Days, Custom)

                                      Baseline                   Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)         End Target

    Value                             0.00                       0.00                        0.00                      77.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023

   Comments:                          Number of average days reduced for obtaining construction permits for commercial properties

     IN01204372
     Of which in Jalalabad (Days, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        0.00                        0.00                       14.00




10/21/2022                                                                                                              Page 11 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                  Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023

     IN01204374
     Of which in Kandahar (Days, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        0.00                        0.00                       6.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023

     IN01204376
     Of which in Herat (Days, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        0.00                        0.00                       18.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023

     IN01204378
     Of which in Kabul (Days, Custom Breakdown)

                                    Baseline                    Actual (Previous)           Actual (Current)           End Target

     Value                          0.00                        0.00                        0.00                       39.00

     Date                           01-Nov-2018                 27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021                31-Dec-2023


   Project Management

    IN01204365
    ►Number of access to information inquiries responded to within agreed service standards (Number, Custom)

                                      Baseline                   Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)         End Target

    Value                             0.00                       5.00                        5.00                      50.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023

                                      Number of individuals and organizations (including media and NGOs) that received project related
   Comments:
                                      information in accordance with agreed service standards.
    IN01204369
    ►Percentage of complaints / grievances resolved following agreed EZ-Kar service standards (Percentage, Custom)

                                      Baseline                   Actual (Previous)            Actual (Current)         End Target

    Value                             0.00                       100.00                      100.00                    80.00

    Date                              01-Nov-2018                27-Jun-2021                 27-Jun-2021               31-Dec-2023

                                      The number of project related complaints or grievances resolved in accordance with EZ-Kar service
   Comments:
                                      standards, divided by the number of project related complaints or grievances received.


 Performance-Based Conditions




10/21/2022                                                                                                              Page 12 of 14
           The World Bank                                                                                   Implementation Status & Results Report
           Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




 Data on Financial Performance


 Disbursements (by loan)

 Project       Loan/Credit/TF    Status       Currency        Original   Revised     Cancelled     Disbursed      Undisbursed             % Disbursed


 P166127       IDA-D4160         Effective    USD             150.00      150.00           0.00         22.02           124.29                   15%

 P166127       TF-A9092          Effective    USD               50.00       7.40         42.60           6.21             1.20                   84%


 Key Dates (by loan)

 Project        Loan/Credit/TF    Status      Approval Date       Signing Date     Effectiveness Date     Orig. Closing Date     Rev. Closing Date

 P166127        IDA-D4160         Effective   19-Dec-2018         06-Feb-2019      06-Feb-2019            31-Dec-2023            31-Dec-2023
 P166127        TF-A9092          Effective   19-Dec-2018         06-Feb-2019      06-Feb-2019            31-Dec-2023            31-Dec-2023


Cumulative Disbursements




  Restructuring History


  Level 2 Approved on 09-Oct-2020


  Related Project(s)


10/21/2022                                                                                                                Page 13 of 14
         The World Bank                                                         Implementation Status & Results Report
         Afghanistan: Eshteghal Zaiee - Karmondena (EZ-Kar) Project (P166127)




 There are no related projects.




10/21/2022                                                                                   Page 14 of 14