Office of the Auditor General of Rwanda OA w .00A, gOrw STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDA TED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS For the year endef30 June 2021 in pu Interes . STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 TABLE OF CONTENTS I. INT R O D U C T IO N .... ..........................-..................... . ,.. ......................... ......... 2 2. STATEMENT OF MANAGEMENT RESPONSIBILITIES.............................................5 3. REPORT OF THE AUDITOR GENERAL ........................... .................................5 4. CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2 0 2 1 ...........8...................... ........................... ..................................................................8 DETA ILED A U D IT FINNDDINIG .................. . ......... ............................................. 39 5. REVIEW OF EXPEN DITURE .PN4...................................... .......................-...............40 6 REVIEW OF CASH AND BANK EQUlVALENTS.....................................................41 Office of the A uditor General of State Finances 1 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 1. INTRODUCTION 1.1. Project Key Information Strengthening Social Protection Project (SSPP) is a social protection project implemented under Ministry of Local Government (MINALOC), Local Administrative Entities Development Agency (LODA) and Districts. The details of the project's information are summarized below: Project start date: The date of signing the funding agreement is 2P' December 2017 The pro ect effectiveness date is 21 March 2018 Project end date: The project completion date is 31 December 2021 Project Manager: The project is managed by: -WIHOGORA Janvi&re: MINALOC - Ag. SPIU Coordinator 1NABIMANAJean de Dieu: LODA - Ag, SPIU Coordinator Project Budget 1. IBRD/IDA Loan: JSD 80 million 2. Global Finance Facility (GEF) & Multi Donor Trust Fund (MDTF) grants: USD 23 million 3. GoR counterpart Funds USD 6 million Total cost of the project USD 109 Million (USD) Implementing Budget Implementing Budget Agencies: Agencies - Ministry of Local Government (MINALOC) - Local Administrative Entities Development Agency (LODA) - Districts Project Line Ministry Ministry of Local Government (MINALOC) Project Development To improve the effectiveness of Rwanda's social protection Objective system, notably the flagship Vision 2020 Umurenge Program (VUP), for tarpeted vulnerable groups Main projects a) Improving coverage, adequacy and effectiveness of the components Vision 2020 Umurenge Program (VUP) cash transfers; b) Enhancing access to human capital and economic inclusion services; and c) Strengthening delivery systems, policy and program management. Outputs of the a) Increasing the overall number of beneficiary households projects (coverage), thereby increasing the number of households receiving income protection; b) Increasing the number of days worked for classic public works (cPW), thereby effectively increasing the size of transfers households receive; Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 2 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 c) Expanding eligibility criteria for direct support (DS) to include imore labor-constrained houscholds: d) Introducing a new gender-and child-sensitive expanded public works (ePW) to provide more accessiblejobs to those households that are ineligible for DS but still labour constrained duc to child caring responsibility; and e) Increasing the frequency and timeliness of payments, which will increase the reliability of income support, 1.2. Management team The following is management team that held office during the period of 12 months ended 30 June 2021 and at the time of audit in October 2021: Name Position DUSENGIYUMVA Permanent Secretary - MINALOC from 4 November 2019 to Samuel date NYTNAWAGCAGTA Director General - LODA from 29 July 2019 to date Claudine SEHUKU E1ise Corporate Services Division Manager - LODA from 28 March 2014 to date GATSINZI Justine Social Protection Division Manager - LODA from 15 December 2014 to date UWITONZE Innocent SPIU Coordinator - MINALOC from 7 August 2018 to 18 November 2021 NABIMANA Jean de Ag. Coordinator for SSPP/LODA from 16 April 2021 to Dieu date~~ UWICYEZA Esperance Social Protection Coordinator - SSPP from 1 October 2018 to 'up to 30 March 2021 KWIFASIA Wellars Directo of Finance - LODA oml 5 April 2017 to date MUKANKUBITO Financial Management Spialahst -SSPP from 01 February Bernadette 2014 to date WIHOGORA Janviere Financial Management Specialist - SSPP from 13 August 2019 to 18 November 2021 Ag. SPIU Coordinator - MINALOC from 01 December 2021 to date UGIR1WABO Isaac Nutrition Sensitive Direct Support (NSDS) Financial Management Specialist from 01 Luly 2019 to date Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 3 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 1.3. Funding suinmary Source of Comnmit- Amount Amount Undrawn Exchange Undraw funds ment reccived as received as at balance as at rate balance as at at 30 June 30 June 2021 30 June 2021 30,Jne 2021 2021 A C D=A-B E F=D*E USD USD Frw USD Frw Loan froin 8 66991,790 47 60 375,53,698i ,0953 -987 139F 12,840,922,603 i80,000,000 8960920.5 [rants. 1451,941.25 16,437,570,288 5,47610,17 Grans 5,48,0875 987.13) GFF & 23,000,000 5 8896 M=T oT 69633 307,683,548 56 987,139 5,587,534,280 GbR33967333 30768354 5,660,326.67 counterpart 896 Total 109,000,000 84,783,405.05 77,120,817,534 24,216,594.95 23,905,167,020 Office of the A uditor General of State Finances 4 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJEC1 (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JINE 2011 2. STATEMENT OF MANAGEMENT RESPONSIILITIES Article 66 of the Organic Law N' 12/2013/OL of 12/09/2013 on State Finances and Propcrty requires public entities to submit annual Financial Statements to the ministry of Finance and Economic planning with 2 months following the end of the fiscal year. Article 19 of the Organic Law N' 12/2013 fuher stipulates that the Chief Budget Manager is responsible for maintaining accounts and records of the public entity, preparing reports on budget execulion, managing the financial resources for the public entity effectively, efficiently and transparently, ensuring sound internal control systems in the public entity and safeguarding the public property held by the public entity. As Chief Budget Managers accept responsibitity for the financial statements, which have becon prepared using appropriate accounting standards applicable to Public Entities as defined by Article 99 of the Ministerial Order N*001/16/10/TC of 26/01/2016 relating to financial regulations. These financial statements have been extracted from the accounting records of Strengthening Social Protection Project and the information provided is accurate and complete in all material respects. The financial statements also form part of the consolidated financial statements of the Government of Rwanda. In my opinion, the financial statements give a true and fair view of the stae of the financial afthirs of Streiigthening Social Protection Project- I further confirm that Strengthening Social Protection Project maintained proper accounting records that may be relied upon in the preparation of financial statements- I also confirm that adequate systems of internal control were maintained and operated effectively during the financial year to safeguard the assets of the project. Nothing has come to the attention of Management to indicate that Strengthening Social Protection Project will not continue operating as a going concern for the foreseeable future- Signature: Digitally NYINAWAGAGA Claudine signed by Director General Chief Budget Manager /LODA LODA(Direc Date: Ltor General) Digitally signed by Signature: _MINALOC 4 (1n)2 DUSENGIUMVA Samuel Permanent Secretary Chief Budget Manager/MINALOC Date: I \ & &Ca Office ofthe Auditor General ofState Finances 5 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 3. REPORT OF THE AUDITOR GENERAL REPORT ON THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS - NYINAWAGAGA Claudine Director General/LODA - DUSENGIYUMVA Samuel Permanent Secretary/MINALOC 3.1 Opinion As required by Article 165 of the Constitution of the Republic of Rwanda of 2003 revised in 2015, and Articles 6 and 14 of Law No 79/2013 of 11/09/2013 determining the mission, organization and functioning of the Office of the Auditor General of State Finances (OAG), I have audited the financial statements of Strengthening Social Protection Project (SSPP) for the year ended 30 June 2021. These financial statements comprise of the statement of financial position as at 30 June 2021, the statement of financial performance, statement of cash flows, statement of changes in net assets, and statement of comparison of budget and actual amounts for the year then ended 30 June 2021, and a summary of significant accounting policies and other explanatory notes. These financial statements are set out on pages 8 to 38. In my opinion, the accompanying financial statements give a true and fair view of the financial position of SSPP as at 30 June 2021, and of its financial performance and its cash flows for the year then ended in accordance with the guidelines provided by Ministerial Order No 001/16/1O/TC of 26/01/2016 relating to financial regulations and Organic Law No 12/2013/OL of 12/09/2013 on State Finances and Property. 3.2 Basis for Opinion I conducted my audit in accordance with the International Standards of Supreme Audit Institutions (ISSAls). My responsibilities under ISSAIs are described in section 3.4 of this report. I am independent of Strengthening Social Protection Project (SSPP) and have fulfilled my ethical responsibilities in accordance with the ethical requirements that are relevant to liy audit of financial statements of public entities as determined by the Code of ethics for International Organisation of Supreme Audit Institutions (INTOSAI). I believe that the audit evidence I have obtained is sufficient and appropriate to provide a basis for my opinion. 3.3 Responsibilities of management According to Organic Law N' 12/2013/OIL of 12/09/2013 on State Finances and Property, management of Strengthening Social Protection Project (SSPP) is responsible for keeping accounting records and books of account, and preparation of financial statements in accordance with the financial regulations prescribed by the Minister in Ministerial Order No 001/16/1 0/TC of 26/01/2016 relating to financial regulations. Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 6 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 This responsibility includes the design, implementation and maintenance of internal control relevant to the preparation and presentation of financial statements that are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error. In preparing the financial statements, management is responsible for assessing the Strengthening Social Protection Project (SSPP)'s ability to continue as a going concern, disclosing, as applicable, matters related to going concern and using the going concern basis of accounting unless Government either intends to discontinue operations of the Strengthening Social Protection Project (SSPP). 3.4 Auditor General's responsibilities for the audit of the financial statements My objective when conducting an audit is to obtain reasonable assurance about whether the financial statements as a whole are free from material misstatement, whether due to fraud or error, and to issue an auditor's report that includes my opinion. Misstatements can arise from fraud or error and arc considered material if individually or in aggregate, they could reasonably be expected to influence economic decisions of users taken on the basis of these financial statements. An audit conducted in accordance with ISSAIs requires an auditor to exercise professional judgment and maintain professional skepticism throughout the audit and involves: * The identification and assessment of the risks of material misstatement of the financial statements whether due to fraud or error; design and perform procedures responsive to those risks and to obtain sufficient and appropriate audit evidence to provide a basis for the auditor's opinion. The risk of not detecting a material misstatement resulting from fraud is higher than for one resulting from error, as fraud may involve colLsion, forgery, intentional omissions, misrepresentations, or the override of internal controls. * Obtaining an understanding of internal control relevant to the audit in order to design audit procedures that are appropriate in the circumstances, but not for the purposes of expressing an opinion on the effectiveness of internal control. * Evaluating the appropriateness of accounting policies used the reasonableness of accounting estimates made by management. * Concluding on the appropriateness of management's use of the going concern basis of accounting and, based on the audit evidence obtained whether a material uncertainty exists related to events or conditions that may cast significant doubt on the Strengthening Social Protection Project (SSPP)'s ability to continue delivering on its funding objectives within the project duration as well as evaluating the presentation of the financial statements. * Evaluation of the overall presentation, structure and content of the financial statements, including disclosures, and whether the financial statements represent the underlying transactions and events in a m N WAIieved fair presentation. KAMUHIRE Alexis AUDITOR GENERAL ................. 2021 Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 7 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 4. CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 4.1. CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL PERFORMANCE FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Deseription Note 12 months to 12 montlis to 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw Revenues Revenue from non-exchange transactions Transfers from central Treasury 2 35,000,000 0 Grants 3 11,404,289,102 1,568,299,220 Revenue from exchange transactions Other revenue 4 433,464,550 645,092,816 Borrowings External borrowings 5 8,289,138,432 20,790,549,352 Total revenue (A) 20,161,892,084 23,003,941,388 Expenses Compensation of employees 6 82,330,767 Goods and services 7 2,750,186,686 2,199,636,010 Social assistaice 8 28,634,507,383 24,883,422,416 Acquisition of fixed assets 9 33,803,885 Total expenses (13) 31,500,828,721 27,083,058,426 Deficit (C=A-B) (11,338,936,637) (4,079,117,038) These financial statements should be read in conjunction with the accompanying notes (including accounting policies) set out on pages 14 to 38. Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 8 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 4.2. CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF FINANCIAL POSITION AS AT 30 JUNE 2021 Description Note Balance as at Balance as at 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw ASSETSiFn Current assets Cash and cash equivalents 10 5,699,715,822 17,409,821,495 Advance payments 11 518,057,391 149,210,869 Total current assets 6,217,773,213 17,559,032,364 Total assets (A) 6,217,773 213 17 559,032,364 LIABIITIES Current liabilitiesII Accounts payable 12 222,700 (2,426,414) Total liabilities 222,700 (2,426,414) Net assets C A-B 6,217,550,513 17,556,605,950 Accumulated surplus from previous year 13 17,556,605,950 21,631,714,618 Prior year adjustments 14 (118,800) 4,008,370 Deficit of the period (11,338,936,637) (4, 079,1 17,038) Total Net Assets 6,217,550,513 17,556,605,950 These financial statements should be read in conjunction with the accompanying notes (incIuding accounting policies) set out on pages 14 to 38. Office of the A uditor General of State Finances 9 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 4.3. CONSOLIDATED STATEMENT OF CASH FLOWS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Description Balance as at lalance as at 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 Fv Frw Fn Casli flow from operating activities Revenues Revenue from non-exehange transact .. s Transfers from central Treasury 35,000,000 0 Grants 11,404,289,102 1,568,299,220 Revenue from exchange transactions Otlher revenue 433,464,550 645,092,816 Expenses Compensation of Employees (82,330,767) 0 Goods and Services (2,750,1 86,686) (2,199,636,010) Social Assistance (28,634,507,383) (24,883,422,416) Adjusted for: Changes in receivables (368,846,522) (149,210,869) Changes in payables (2,203,714) (5,727,890) Prior year adjustnents (118,800) 4,008,370 Net cash flows from operating (19,965,440,220) (25,020,596,779) activ2 (es I Cash flows from Investing Activities Acquisition of fixed assets (33,803,885) 0 Net cash flows from Investing (33803885) 0 Activities Cash flow from Financing Activities Procceds from borrowings 8,289,138,432 20,790,549,352 Net cash tlow from financing activities 8,289,138,432 20,790,549,352 Net increase/(decrease) in cash and (11,710,105,673) (4,230,047,427) cash equivalents Cash and cash equivalents at17,409,821,495 21,639,868,922 beginning of period Cash and cash equivalents at end 5,99,715,822 17,409,821,495 period These financial statements should be read in conjunction with the accoipanying notes (including accounting policies) set out on pages 14 to 38. Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 10 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 4.4. STATEMNT OF CHANGES IN NET ASSETS Deseription Accumulated Adjustments Total surpius/loss1 FrWj FnivFm Ikklances as at 30(1I June 2019 21 63171468 0 21,631,714,618 Prior year adjustnents: Cash and cash equivalent 0 4,008,370 4,008,370 Net (Deficit) for the financial year (4,079,1i7,038) 0 (4,079,117,038) IBalance as at 30 June 2020 17,552,597,580 4.008.370 17,556,605,950 Prior year adjustments: Payables and other liabilities 0 (118,800) (118,800) Net (Deficit) for the financial year (11 338,936,637) <> 1 Balances as at 30' June 2021 6,213,660,943 3,889,570 6,217,550,513 These financial statements should be read in conjunction with the accompanying notes (inoluding accounting policies) set out on pages 14 to 38, Office of te A uditor General of State Finances 11 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 4.5. STATEMENT OF COMPARISON OF BUDGET AND ACTUAL AMOUNTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Description Budget Actual Variances C=A- Perfor A BI 1 mance (B/A)*1 00 Fi Frw Frw RECEIPTS Grants 11,995,643,182 1 ,404,289,102 591,354,080 92% Transfers from other 35,000,000 35,000,000 0 100% government entities ..1 . Other revenue 433,464,550 -433,464,550 % Total reecipts 12,030,643 182 11,872,753,652 157,889,530 95% EXPENDITURE Compensation of 107,961,606 82,330 767 25 630 839 76% emnployces Goods and services 3,266,916,098 2,750,186,686 516,729,412 84% Social assistance 30,827 4 70 956 28, 634,507,383 2,192,963,573 93% Total paynents 34,202,348,660 31,467,024,836 2,735,323,824 92% Operating balance -22,171,705,478 i-19,594,271,184 -2,577,434,294 Transactions in non- financial assets Capital expenditure 572,499,999 33,803,885 538,696, 14 6% Net borrowing -22,744,205,477 -19,628,075,069 -3,16,130,408 Financin g Borrowings- Externa] 22,744,205,477 8,289,138,432 14,455,067,045 36% Total net incurrence 22,7440,477 8,289,138,432 14,455,067,045 of liabilities ExpLanation of significant variances: Other revenue The budget line is made of gains and losses on translation during the financial year being implemented. Ii is not simple to plan for losses and gains as a result of exchange rate translations. Capital expenditure The total budget for acquisition of ICT equipment to strengthen Civil Registration and Vital Statistics CRVS at cell level was not consumed The supplier couldn't provide 790 lap) tops (Lenovo) as planned. This is the reason why the Last Purchase Order/LP0 has been cancelled Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 12 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Proceedsfrom borrowings During the year ended 30 June 2021, the plannedfunds to use were Frw 22,744.205,477 while the finds requested and received from the World Bank (WB) were Frw 8, 289.139,432. The reason is that SSPP had enoughfunds on the Designated Accounts as opening balance as cash and cash equivalents as at Ist July 2020. The prior figures show the amount received from the WB so as to execute activities in thefinancial year ended 30 JAme 2020 and oier activities of the financial year ended 30 June 2021. These financial statements should be read in conjunction with the accompanying notes (including accounting policies) set out on pages 14 to 38. The financial statements were approved by SSPP Project management and were signed on its behalf by: byMUKANKJODM Prepared by! MUKANKUBITO Bernadette om'o2 Accouxitant/SPTU-MINALOC Signature Date WHOeDRA JARVIERF -. 2011.1231 Reviewed by: WIHOGORA Janviere )4812 e Ag. Pro ect Coordinator Signature Date Approved by: NYINAWAGAGA Claudine signed by Chief Budget Manager/LODA Signatut LODAect or General) -TYUMV signed by Approved by: DUSENGIYUMVA Samuel MIN-O-(51 Chief Budget S±,mJase Date Managcr/MINALOC Offlee ofthe Auditor Genera! ofSate Finances 13 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 4.6. NOTES TO THE FINANCIAL STATEMENTS 1. Accounting policies 1.1. Significant accounting policies Public entities maintain their books of account on a modified accrual basis of accounting as prescribed in basis for preparation. I... Statement of compliance The financial statements have been prepared in accordance with the Organic Law No 12/2013 of 12/09/2013 on State Finances and Property and related legal framework. The presentation and classification of items in the financial statements are consistent from one period to the next and takes into consideration progressive improvements as contained in the Government of Rwanda roadmap to migrate to accrual IPSAS. 1.1.2. Basis of preparation The financial statements have been prepared on the basis of historical costs unless otherwise stated. The statement of cash flows is prepared using the direct method. In this context, modified accrual basis of accounting means that financial transactions and events shall generally be recognized in the books of account when they occur and not only when cash or its equivalent is received or paid, except in the following circumstances when transactions will be treated on a cash basis; (i) Inventories - these are assets: Inventories include assets such as consumable stores and maintenance materials. These will be treated on cash basis and recorded as expenditure during the year of acquisition and treated as revenue in the year of disposal. (ii) Non-exchange transactions: - These arise where an entity receives value from another entity without giving approximately equal value in exchange. These include taxes, fines and penalties, transfers, gifts and donations and shall be recognised when cash is received- (iii) Non-current assets (tangible and intangible assets): - such as vehicles, furniture, equipment, finance leases, Plant and tools and investment property will be treated on cash basis and recorded as capital expenditure during the year of acquisition and revenue in the year of disposal. The financial statements are presented in Rwanda Francs (Frw), being the currency of legal tender in Rwanda which is the functional and reporting currency of the Government of Rwanda. 1.13. Reporting entity The Financial Statements have been prepared by SSPP pursuant to Articles 19 and 66 of the Organic Law on State Finances and Property No 12/2013 of 12/09/2013 that empowers the Chief' Budget Manager to prepare the financial statements. Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 14 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 1.1.4. Reporting periods The Government of Rwanda Fiscal Year runs from I' July to 30' June. These financial statements cover the period from 1" July 2020 to 30' June 2021. The comparative figures reflect the 12 months ended 30 June 2021. 1.15. Key assumptions and judgments These financial statements, as a component of the Government consolidated financial statements, reflect the Government's financial position as at 30"' June 2021, and the financial results of operations and cash flows for the period/year ended on that date. Included in these Financial statements are a number of judgements, estimations and assumptions. The assumptions are based on information available at the time of the preparation of the financial statements. It should therefore be noted that actual results may differ from the assumptions stated and thus have a material impact on the financial statements. 1.1.6. Presentation currency The functional currency of the Government of Rwanda is the Rwandan Franc. For reporting purposes, the financial statements are translated into Rwandan Francs. The rates used to translate foreign currency balances is the average rate applicable by National Bank of Rwanda as at 30"' June 2021. 1.1.7. Areas of significant estimation These financial statements do not have significant estimates so far, For the non-current asset and inventory balances disclosures, the acquisition cost before depreciation has been used, 1.1.8. Adoption of new and revised standards The government is in the process of transitioning to IPSAS through a phased approach that involves a six-year implementation plan. The current year is year 3 of the transition process. By the end of the six-year implementation period, the government plans to have fully transitioned to IPSAS and adopted all relevant standards. 1.1.9. Recognition 1. Revenue recognition a) Revenuefrom nion-exchange transactions w Grants The following applies to grants and transfers: * Grants are recognized in the books of accounts when cash is received. In case of grant in kind, such a grant is recorded upon receipt of the grant item and upon determination of the value. * Transfer from Treasury are recognized in the books of accounts when cash is received. Office ofthe Auditor General of State Finances 15 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 * Transfers received from Government entity for onward payment to a third party are not treated as an inter-entity (revenue) rather; such transfers shall be recorded as transit fund (liability) in the books of the receiving entity. * Transfers from Treasury that are not related to current fiscal year budget are not treated as cash transfers. Instead, such transfers shall be treated as inter-entity transfers, b) Revenuefrom exchange transactions * Other revenue These are other revenue not classified in other classes ofrevenue. This related to gain of foreign exchange. Revenue from exchange transactions shall be recognized on accrual basis. c) Borrowings The Ministry of Finance and Economic Planning is the principal borrowing agent lbr Central Government. Public debt and associated interest is recognized on cash basis. Proceed from loan borrowing is recognized as revenue during the year of receipt at cost and repayment as expenditure in the year of repayment. Cash is considered as received when recipient entity received a transfer advice fi-orn the partner rather than when cash is received in the bank account of the receiving entity. II. Expenditure All expenditure is recognised on accrual basis however, the point of recognition may be diflTrent according to their categories. a) Goods and services Goods and services consist of the value of goods and services received/ paid for. b) Social assistance Social benefits are current transfers receivable by households intended to provide for the needs that arise from social risks-for example, sickness, unemployment, retirement, housing, education, or family circumstances. These benefits are payable in cash or in kind to protect the entire population or specific segments of it against certain social risks. Social assistance is accounted for on cash basis and recognized in the books of accounts when cash and cash equivalent is paid out. Cash is considered as paid when consideration for payment such as EFT, Cheque, Payment Order are signed rather than when cash and cash equivalent are debited from the bank statement. c) Acquisition offixed assets The expenditure on acquisition of property plant and equipment items is not capitalized. The cost of acquisition and proceeds from disposal of these items are treated as expenditure and income items respectively. Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 16 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Ill. Assets and liabilities t) Cash and cash equivalents Cash comprises cash at bank. Bank account balances are amounts held at the National Bank of Rwanda at the end of the reporting period. b) Inventories Inventories are expensed in the period in which they are acquired by the Government and its entities- c) Receivables These receivables are from prepayments. d) Payables These mainly relate to returned payments. These are recognized as liabilities for that specific fiscal year- IV. Other relevant information a) Changes in accounting policies and estimates When presentation or classification of items in the financial statements is amended or accounting policies are changed voluntarily, comparative figures are restated to ensure consistency with the current period unless it is impracticable to do so. b) Foreign currency transactions Transactions denominated in foreign currencies are initially translated to the Rwandan Franc at the foreign exchange rate at the date of transaction- The National Bank of Rwanda provides exchange rates for major foreign currencies on a daily basis. These are presented for selling rate (rate the bank will sell foreign currency to its clients), buying rate (rate the bank will buy foreign currency from its clients) and average rate (average between the selling and buying rate)- During the year, revenue items are translated using the selling rate (this equals the Buying rate presented at BNR website) of the transaction day whereas the Expense items should be translated using the buying rate (this equals the Selling rate presented at BNR website) of the transaction day. The associated exchange losses are recorded as other expenditure while exchange gains should be recorded as other revenue. At the end of the year, book balances, Assets (such as bank and cash and accounts receivables) and liability (such as accounts payables), denominated in foreign currencies are converted into the Rwanda Franc at the average rate of exchange ruling Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 17 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 on that closing date, as issued by the National Bank of Rwanda. The associated exchange losses/gains are recorded as expenditure/incone in the books. c) Comparativefigures Adjustments have been made on the opening balances of the culTent financial period with respect to adjustments made by individual entities relating to the comparative periods. d) Subsequent events There have been no events subsequent to the financial year-end with a significant impact on the financial statements for the year ended 30 June 2021. 2. Transfers from central Treasury ID account Description 12 months to 12 months to 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 139101 Treasury direct paynents 0 139102 Treasury direct cash transfers 35,000,000 0 Total 35,000,000 0 3. Grants During the financial year ended 30 Jne 2021, SSPP received grants from developrnent pai-tners as shown in the table below: ID Name of Date Amount Exchang 12 months to 12 months to acco Donor received in foreign e rate 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 unt currency US6 Fr Frw Internation 138 Organizati ons GFF 28/09/2020 950,295 956.2415 908,71 1,598 44,582.745 86 GFF&MDT 21/12/2020 893,984.2 961.71 859,749,609 133,748,228 F J6 GFF&MDT 23/12/2020 2,6811952 962.11 2,580,339,260 347,491,599 F 79 GFF&MDT 30/12/2020 4,529,967 962.75 4,361 209,838 1,042,476,648 F 39 GFF&MDT 31/12/2020 1509,989. 962.85 1,453,889,309 F 13 GFF 24/06/2021 1 1,269,705 976.91 1,240,389,488 Total 11,835,89 11,404,289,102 1,568,299,220 3.57 Office of the Ä uditor General of State Finances 18 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 4. Other revenue During the year ended 30 June 2021, SSPP made other revenue in form of gain on foreign exchange rate as detailed in the table below: ID Description 12 months to 12 months to Account 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw 1451 Gain on foreign exchange 433,464,550 645,092,816 Total 433,464,550 645,092,816 5. External borrowings During the year ended 30 June 2021, SSPP received proceeds from borrowings from International Development Association as shown in the table below: Name of Date Amount in Exchange 12 months to 12 months to Donor received foreign rate 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 currency USD Frw Frw 162 Foreign Loan (Loan Received in Cash) IDA 30/12/2020 8,447,996.80 962.746409 8,133,278,582 10,3 10,022,085 IDA 26/06/2021 159,543,46 976.911 155,859,850 10,480,527,927 8,607,540.26 8,289,138,432 20,790,549,352 6. Compensation of employees These comprise of the remuneration payable to employees in return for the work done. In addition to wages and salaries, compensation. of employees includes social contributions made by general Government Unit on behalf of its employees. ID Description 12 months to 12 months to Account 30,June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw 2116 ProJect stal remuneration 82,330,767 0 Total 82,330,767 0 7. Goods and services During the financial year ended 30 June 2021, SSPP incurred expenditure for use of goods and services as detailed in the table below: Office of Iie Auditor General of State Finances 19 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 ID Description 12 months to 12 months to Account 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw 2211 Office supplies and consumables 105,400 2214 General services 33,452,000 177,126,404 2216 Bank charges and commissions and 98,348,732 0 other financial costs 21 P Iublic relations and awareness 104,587,807 0 2221 Professional and contraetual services 1,726,402,362_1 1 207535,989 2231 Transport and travel 437,520,411 188,940,971 2261 Training costs 349,769,974 626,032,646 Total 2,750,186,686 2,199,636,010 8. Social assistance During the financial year ended 30 June 2021, SSPP through the Districts has made paynents for social assistance as detailed in the table below: Deseription 12 months to 12 months to 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw Ngorna 459,509,235 725,911,673 Bugesera 1,608,217,012 1,034,006,966 Gatsibo 649,963,877 835,884,820 Kyonza 850,415,190 682,076,983 Kirehe 488,334,540 624,959,745 Nyagatare 581,078,611 683,764,945 Rwanagana 181,839,251 313,994,336 luye 1,052,911,929 680,878,473 Nyarnagabe 1,449,314,022 1,022,066,584 Gisagara 1,220,280,781 1,399,350,983 Muhanga 450,043,658 467,362,302 Kamnony 492.739,528 349,073,241 Nyanza 687,481,306 782,359,530 Nyaruguru 2,065,011,496 1,076,047,751 Rusizi 1,179,633,199 1 625,098,934 Nyabihu 1,015,023,901 489,756,200 Rubavu 1,259,369,430 1,166,334,000 Karongi 1,080,218,669 .1178,5,45 Ngororero 1,638,145,867 1,127,487,430 Nyamasheke. 2,164,037,721 2,326,253,390 Rutsiro 1,173,537,294 943,466,682 B3urera 1,245,654,509 662.002,487 Gicumbi 1,353,501,341 1,316,289,697 Musanze 438,361,401 650,252,183 Rulindo 436,469,014 556,473,660 Gakenke 1,180,146,726 913,946,591 Office of the A uditor General of State Finances 20 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Deseription 12 months to 12 months to 30 .June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw. Ruhango 1,303,807,028 1,131,457,873 Nyarugenge 0 30,153,100 Kieukiro 0 57,169,950 Gasabo 0 178,150,224 City of Kigali - 929,460,847 952,888,233 Total 28,634,507,383 24,883,422,416 9. Acquisition of fixed assets During the inancial year ended 30 June 2021, SSPP has made no payments for capital expenditure as detailed in the table below: ID Deseription 12 months to 12 months to account 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw 231 Acquisition of fixed assets 33,803,885 0 Total 33,803,885 0 10. Cash and cash equivalents As at 30 June 2021, SSPP had the following bank balanres in LODA, MINALOC and Distriets: ID Bank Account Accou Amount in Exehange Balance as at Balance as at Acco name number nt foreign rate 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 iunt curren currency ey Frw Frw 31 4 P 1006044 2,156,758.79 987.139896 2,129,022,648 327013541 01 Designate 144 IJSD d account 31 Il SSPP 1000043 USD 3 5908 987.139896 3 446, 466 13,588,252,299 01 Designate 733 d accouiit 3113 Strengthe 1000044 Frw 33,148 987.139896 32,721654 34,986,482 01 ning 179 Social Protection 9ioa 2,225,814.79 2,197,190,768 13,950,252,322 Distriets Bank Accounts/Local Carreney 400 Ngoma 1044 Fw 160,957.53 987,.139896 158,887,600 89,605,488 454 Office of the Aiuditor General of State Finances 21 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 ID Bank Account Accou Amount in Exchange Balancens at Balance as at Acco name nunber nt foreign rate 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 unt curren eurrency i Cy Frw Frw 4100 Bugesem 1000044 337,076.18 987.139896 332,741,341 207,606,046 535 F1 4200 Gatsibo 1000045 79,760.79 I 987119896 78,735,061 84,612,187 671 4300 ayonza 100004 2 16,39 1,9 987139896 2 13,609,068 102,237,808 1322 rw 4400 Kirehe 1000044 52,691.3 987.13986 52,014305 90,190,763 829 Frw 4500 Nyagatare 1000044 134,584.91 987 39896 132,854,137 3,806,509 276 Frw 4600 R wainaga 1000044 Frw i 11,170.57 9871398026 ,915 27,724,605 na 799 4700 Huye 1000044 Frw 16 002.07 987. 139896 15,796,279 63,504,086 241 4800 Nyarnaga 1000044 frw 157,084.57 987,139896 155,064,451 214,030,394 4900 100044 65,669.73 987 139896 64,825,210 06,423 Gisagara Frw 500o Mullanga 1000045 Fm 108,765.83 87 139896 107,367,088 1 4,304,715 108 5100 Kamony! 10000415 Frw 26,600.37 987.139896 26,25,289 78,008,423 225 5300 Nyarugur 22500¯4 Frw 82,677.67 987.139896 81,614,427 271,189,104 ui 926 5400 Rusizi 1000045 Frw 93,922.29 987.139896 92,714,444 67,067,891 639 5500 Nyabihu 1000045 Frw 171,741.56 987.139896 169,532,941 183,093,082 I 132 5600 Rubavu 1000045 Frw 31,681.84 987. 139896 3 1,274,409 38,094 ,152 .1 '9 I 5700 Karongi 11000045 Frw 213,680,74 987 139896 210,932,784 18,965,347 647 ,.. 5800 Ngororero 1000044 Frw 193,420,88 987 139896 190,933,471 268,062,167 942 5900 Nyamashe 1000045 Frw 16,650,89 987 139896 16,436.758 253,936,761 j- :221 ... . . 6000 Rutsio 1000045 175,069.68 987.139896 172,818,262 116,035,682 124 Frw 6100 Burera 1000045 271,638.72 987. 139896 268,145,422 343,595,053 752 1rw 6200 Gicumbi 10.00044 256,279.41 987.139896 252,983,626 292,491 340 292 IFrw 6300 Musaize 1000044 Frw I 110,72 97 1 3 9896 109,400,493 26,104,895 788 I 6400 i Rulindo 1000045 103.531.98 987.139896 102,200,546 97 728 581 687 F 6500 Gakenke 1000044 546.33 987.139896 539,301 13,380,575 77i GFrw OfficÉ øf th e A uditor Ge-neral of State Finances 22 STRENG THENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 ID Bank Account Accou Amount in Exchange Balance as at Balance as at Acco name number it foreign rate 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 unt curren currency Frw Frw 6600 Rubargo 0004 r 30,44.2 9 9896 129,260,252 84,549,155 3 14 7000 City of 1 000053 276'59309 987.I39896 273,036,075 152,544,834 Kigali 593 Frw Subtotal 3,548,154.69 3,502,525,054 3,459,569,539 Tota,l 5,773,969.48 5569967157822 17,409,821,861 11. Advances payments At the end of the financial year ended 30 June 2021, SSPP through LODA had accounts receivable relating to advance paid to Imbuto Foundation as a consultant whose contract is at Lumpsum-based: ID account Deseription Balance as at Balance as at 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw 312101 + Accounits receivable - Imbuto 421,944,806 149,210,869 322101 Foundation Districts: Nyamagabe 6 642,125 Ruhango 10,783,340 Gisaara . . 59,449,170 Karn.gi ! 414,000 Nyabihu 13,5 13,200 Gicumbi 5,310,750 Total 518,057,391 149,210,869 12. Accounts payable As at 30 June 2021, SSPP through LODA had payables as detailed in the table below: ID Deseription Balance as at Balance as at account i 30 nre 2021 30 June 2020 Frw Frw 4,121 Accounts payable -Third parties Returned payments (See attached 222,700 2,426,414 list- NoLeI5.7) Total 222,700 2,426,414 Office of the Aditor General of State Finances 23 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 13. Accumulated surplus from previous year These include cash book reconciled bank balances and accounts payable balances existing at the beginning of the year along with the closing balance of the prior year adjustments and the accumulated balance as of the last year: ID ..A ccumulated smplu/(Deficit) account Description FY2019/2020 FY 2019/2020 June 2020 une June 2020 (Submitted for 2020 (After audit Consolidation) (adjustni adjustment ) ents ) Frw Frw Frw Fn 511101 Éash and 17,409,821,495 17,409,821,495 21,639,868,922 cash equivalents 511102 Accounts 149,210,869 149,210.869 receivable 511103 Accounts (2.426,414) 0 (2,426,414) (8,154.304) payable Total 17,556,605,950 | 17,556,605,950 21,631,714,618 14. Prior year adjustments The following are the prior year adjustments to opening balances: ID Deseription 12 months to 12 months to Account 30 June 2021 30 June 2020 Frw jFrw 512101 Cash and cash equivalents (MINALOC) -0 3,268,870 Cash and cash equivalents (LODA) 0 739.500 512103 Payables and other liabilities (118,800) Total (118,800) 4,008,370 Adjustients on cash and bank balanees LODA: During the year ended 30 June 2020, there was reversal ofpaynent for manpower used in SP-c PW Creation of'Kayumbu lDP Model in Kayumbu Sector (3 lum) amouing to Frw 813,000 (in Kamonvi District), There ivere also unrecorded paynent ir suppot to Child CHBCC Community -based childcare project in Jabana Seetor amiuntng to Frw 73,500 (in Gasabo Ditrici) Total = 813,000 - 73,500 = Frw 739,500 MINALOC: There wereversedpayments vouchersfor ihef inancialyear ended30 June 2019 which were uploaded tice in IFMJS and not cancelled in du time. Total: Frw 3,268,870 During the financial year ended 30 June 2021 payables analysis was done and /ound out there was an error of posting 118,800 as payable when il was not. Thejournal voucher has been reversed. Office ofthe A uditor General of State Finances 24 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 15. Changes in accounts receivable and accounts payable These comprise of changes in account receivables and accounts payables from previous year to this year. Once the change in accounts receivable is positive, it represents the cash outflow while the negative change in accounts receivables implies cash inflows. As far as accounts payable are concerned, the positive change implies more cash inflows whereas the negative trend of accounts payable implies the cash flowing outside the entity. Below is the movement within accounts receivable and accounts payable. Description Balance as Movement Balance as Movement at 30 June during the at 30 June during the 2020 current year 2021 previous year Frw Frw Frw Frw Movement in accounts 149,210,869 368,846,522 518,057,391 149,210,869 receivable Movement in accounts 2,426,414 2,203,714 222,700 2,426,414 p)ayable 16. Important disclosures 16.1. Undrawn loan and grant balances The following are the balances of undrawn loans and grants that currently exist, as at 30 June 2021, the drawn amounts have been included as income during the current and previous periods: Source of Commitnient Amount Amount Undrawn Exchange Undrawn funds received as received as at balance as at rate balance as at at 30 June 30 June 2021 30 June 2021 30,June 2021 2021 A1 B C D'A-B E F=D*E USD US) Frw USD Frw Loan loin 66,991,790.47 60,375,563,698 987.139 I12840,922,603 IDA 13,008,2093 896 Giants I 17,451,941,25 16,437,570,288 5,476,710,137 987.139) (I, & 23,000,000 5,548,058.75 896 GoR 339.673.33 307,683,548 987.139 5,587,534,280 6.000,000 : v5,660,326.67 counterPart 42896 Total 109,000,000 84,783,405.05 77,120,817,534 24_1659__ 23,905,167,020 16.2. SSPP SPIU MINALOC designated account reconciliation statement (Account number: 1000044144) Elements Amount in disbursement PART I 1. Cumulative advances up to end of last reporting period 2,439,391.16 Office of the A udifor General of'State Finances 25 STRENGT.HENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Elements Amount in disbursement currencySD 2.World Bank's share of eumulative expenditures up to end of last 1,476,67199 reporting period 3.Advance recovered by World Bank 4.Outstanding advances to be adjusted (1-2-3) 962,719.17 PÄRT II 5. Opening advance balance at beginning of current reporting 962,719.7 period 6. Add: advances received during reporting period 1 ,4297248.46 7. Outstanding advances to be adjusted (5-6) 2,391,967.63 8, Less: World Bank's share of Expenditures for current reporting 235,208.84 quarter/period (paid from DA 1) Breakdown by disbursement category Category 5 (SSPP) 33,297.10 Category 6 (CRVS) 201,911.74 9. Adjustment: (exclude SC, Direct Payment, Reimbursenents) 10. (a) Closing advance balance at end of current reporting 2,156,758.79 quarter/period (DA 1) 10.(b) Closing advance balance at end of current reporting 0 quarter/period (Districts accounts) Total available cash balance at the end of reporting period (10al-Ob) 2,156,758,79 PART 111 1l, Total forecasted amount to be paid by World Bank in next 6 months (exclude expected SC, Direct Payment, Reimbursement) Category 5 365 269.22 Category 6 1,791,489.57 Sub total 12. Less: Closing advance balance at the end of the reporting period 2,156,758.79 (itein 10 above) 13. Fund requirements from World Bank for next 6 months (11-1 2) Category 5 Category 6 - 16.3. SSPP SPIU LODA designated account reconciliation statement (Account Number: 1000043733) Elements Amount in disbursement (USD) PART I 1. Cumulative advances up to end of last reporting period 80,575,092.65 2.World Bank's share of cumulative expenditures up to end of last 64,933,993.71 reporting period Office of the A utditor General of State Finances 26 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Elements Amount in disbursement (USD) 4.Advancec recovered by World Bank 5 Outstanding advances to be adjusted (1-2-3) 15,641,098.94 PART II 5. Opening advarice balance at beginning of current reportng period 15,641,098.94 6. Add: advances received during reporting period 7.Outstanding advances to be adjusted (5+6) 15,641,098-94 8. Less: World Bank's share of Expendi t.ures for current reporting 12,057,036.00 cluarter/period (paid from DA) Breakdown by disbursement category Category 1 2,838,312,65 Category 2 1,665,731.60 Category 3 6,115,237.35 Category 4 1,084,160.65 Category 7 353,593.74 9. Adjistment: (exclude SC, Direct Payrnent, Reim.bursements) 10. (a) Closing advance balance at end of current reporting 35,908.25 quarter/period (DA2) 1 0(b) Closing advance balance at end of current reporting quarter/period 3,548,154.69 (Districts accounts) Total available cash balance at the end of reporting period (1 OatI Ob> 3,584,062,94 PART III 11. Total forecasted amount to be paid by World Bank in next 6 nonths (exclude expected SC, Direct Payment, Reirnbursernent) CAT1 6,540,961.50 CAT2 3,266,778.51 CAT3 5,025,414.98 CAT4 1,385,356.49 CAT7 2,471,866.16 Sub total 18,690,377.64 12. 1 ess:Total available cash balance at the end of reporting period 15,106,314.70 (1 0a--10b) 13. Fund requirements from World Bank for next 6 months (11-12) Category 1 4,701,244.99 Category 2 Category 3 897,418.57 Category 4 Category 6 Category 7 - Office of the A uiitor General of State Fiances 27 � д и 4 4 д Ф в;... ', 4� q",, 6;_.. 8 8 I Ф I 4 . I 8 G @ 1 Q II 4 i � � 8 4 ' � @ � Р � � О � ��.. \ I _ � �, I I . , , � � в �... �.� � г~... i. 4 ���1. � I�.. I, � � П Э� I � н i° '. � �I ; t� . . ...,..,. г ,.,. ...,.,.,.. 1 q�.. .' '. i � - � � � а � �1 :i.. о# �G?+ ; S4� й �I рΡ I � м ; ,rч -i' г° �1 � . 1г"У I й7 �г г�{ � Мч .� '? `,Э � � ... � 4 � гп � Эл taa. { � " +� , .�- , га гз � с4 г1 9 ' rл �о "�1��� �1�I � t tt1°, [з jг+ч �гi гл � п й�� � 1 { �г7 Г Э . �j т т� С4 {[ti йi � � г Е Zh �' ; д� г•У. 1�l I' Е � G7 � �� [ СС? С�,Г,1 j �i I и�rЭ �{ h� i 9 h1 � �з �� гт^}�� � � ! Г^4 "г� ' r"У [? I rь � f- Сй h� гfч � t^ й� Л I с г� �-� м � v�й ' � _ i �О I � � (s] � II i � n1 Ф ! � т N.,_ . _ . . Ф � i �Са � ®У г*5 ^ � � I , � . . .... �� � ..�..., .,. .., . 1 � { �� " . 1._ _..,. ; " �I _ �' � ЕΡ� ! �, С+ �. ; . � ... � ., I, I } � с�и " ; . iI! � СС U у I р�� �,м Ф� „� �� �� �,м � �� � #� ry Isa и����f i�;�I �,��1� �l � � g',,о� �i ��� � i��.'� h 1 � � с О б� 1 . Э 8О Э г"5 ЕГ^` [ � ��С} СТ �г7 С7 { � ! С�`! ; °� I � G� I� и� б✓ 4 r `'"�' ' а!t дч r"7 М Ф' I� Ф 1�: II s7 'fi "� � S� См �I �? �+ ° � � ' п1 rn '�, °'` сл I � I � с+ I °а ц� G ' � �' 1 (� �... �, 4 � � � � ... �. ` .. ... .. .. ... тп i -У '"'Г i 1 "h г CL ...J r"м � r�1 +, �. I '--г � - " � � � ' � ь ^ ; р Ii , . .._. _.. �.... . . . . _ ' � � � � I !--уΡ {сп��д g ra,,,�'i1 r� �'I,� СΡ} �O° � ,Iгq� "п ' C�i. � ^ I II � � �,, ",tT,.y' i О II г`.� �. �. � i f: г Ф�i. � � � � I��I � С� П '��,, � � � � '�, � I �I�° �!�i ,� � !� �; � �;�', � �i � '' � � ' . ' � � r� ' ��; �� � " � � ���,; � � �, � ,� r� � �j � �. � i +. ,� у� �r, а� г� г'; �з о 1 � л �, Ф -г " а _ . ргу , С.� 7; �� I� � Эгу .I.. I , I va I++� . V С +� .'S ' ~ Г' „. � . , � � 61 I 8, о � в о а . п . . .. ,.. 4 # �� ......... ........ . ......". у� , � ' � � � � I� 1 ! I 1 � � й ! � � � 4 G + � \ I '� � III ё 8 't д7 Ч� ,.. .. ., ., . . . � � " н¢I G � ,�'� � �зG iL ., G ._ �!t] , Iq$ �� , � '"�^ � \ \ � ,,. 1 с 1 4 � � ;�� ,�, ,I�, ; � ;� r� i � � I° � � '� i� ` I!�; `оа { ;� tг, 1 ' {� , , р"" т w � .. I a.w �, II � � �... л.. ! 1 . ' �I '. . " � �. ..... � ,.. ......! . . � � , ® � �^" or 1 � �г^ ' ! � +� .�.�. j "'" �¢г+�- 'Г-" �цй � ; � �N ',л '�р '� �М ;� .n...... I � g'� м� � U��! '^�' I... '^ I г ��� ;� . i� rn; �� �о€r ,ца i� °м� i � � � { .�. '��'"!L' I,.� �тt ��г" С7 ц7 ,tЧ � 41 ��f .+�,В I� � Ф �� ;t� i4: "�Ci 1� � 1 � !! 1 � ° �� � �N � U ;� �,,�� ��г', Iir, !цх '� iёг. � � Е , � , '� °а ",.« � а`�`+ �'- а�'-`i { � I ^ II � � � � `'" Э' �° � Э " � � 1 .., ,. � , ,..,.., . , Э . . . . , � � � 4 ���,, � ,...,....,.., .. �.......� � .., .. .. .. ,�,.. I , ... ....�...,., ....._..... . �...��., � I � � I ........_... .!. ..,..,. �� i ...,..,..,. ..,�. I �ы _ FSy � �` {� `� и`"� v G�4 40 � сз , I,� I �II � I га ( Si пй �[ � � � IIN с.°_ � � I1 �� �I� �� G� `�,�-� i� �, и� I , I{`,£+, I� � I1'г�л� j� I1 �,. � С1 +д L � Vi {',1 4'7 � п [`� ч�1 1 � I i+� : rr; i ьt� � i п'7 �' � 11� � � +�. �':,y�I угh'� tt ja� 1� � о � � �i ;�ч � �1N �,`� �r ��... "� С7 I, С�с1 ��� ��" т I r'i' �п сб.. �,� �^ I I I ьгi . м -r '� f оо 1I дС.М ,-, � , � а, � q� n мц� I r 1 Ь� �,� I{^ 1 II 1 " , т м I, гхч Ё„ � � �" 4Л II � " i .�ь i ++ ( 6 � � � � �� � � � � �,... � � � � { G � � � � I гЛ � .rf �„ ...,.... , , tF � �,.._ � ^.. С , ' � . ..._. __ ,_.. __ .� , __ _ .. ._ _.. b � � � tj � 9�,.i , �. �,.. , ,� С � � � ; [ � '�+r � . � I {lj с ь . I � т 1 � I . I � ц3 I, r.� � � 44 � ! �t �1 Uэ I 1 " �`�' . t.C1 .. ��.7� +.� Ii�, �.°�' I,у °-� I о w� г� с' ' г, I ь1i Iг г а . I� � rwk ; ла R� 1I у С ь . г� 1 п� ! Г1 �� г.4 �.� 1 � Сп , [`1 � �� � I у� �. �I1 ^•3 � Ir-. i.� I� � h� С i� � �'f' I,п j ( Q �ч � .Гч id ._. 1 г,С � .гs ,.,, а; гл ',. 1 оФ ,° j �,�;� I С � С�' �' I � � ; �1 � � w °' �" n�i , � I � , �; оо "r Э � { na . г� � �� � � ее9 � [� ы� 1 ы'�. 1 4 ч� i�� � мС �1 т ii г,7 � � � �`�j � мr .;? V�^ � ni !� цi I`° г ,Н? i г� г� �, е.,..е.,.., �' I�, � С�? 4� SC 1 ; ;'k�, � ! I I ., . � ' Г , �'� ,.. .. � -..,.. .....I'� � i.4, Q.Y � � ...,... .. ., .,..� � . . { I ' п ' ._ „ Э 1�в i � �� I � �+уΡ � I 1 I � *� I � � ]��Ч �1 � � �i I ,� � � � д� С� . �r; � � � � � � I рΡ II, � �,,� i � � '� Cj i"ч G ' � �h I ео N °� i г i � � �`�. rJ �� � СС � д.й G �!� i. �. � t^�1 i � �' ° 4'~ �fэ { � � �1 � � •, е? � � � , С. ; }д �Оа Гт� w �.г � `� "� �" � о м г t� °° i c-i 4� ��, � л � � i�, � Ф I :.,и� �, � � i � ,II II � � I� "� � йр �_ С '.� � г '� а г� '� З О +�r� . , - � ; � � � � � г+ч С-- ', "".Э 4 � Г^! ++ , I j " �k , " ._ i " " ь V1 ..�._ � �, .....ё.._.� ....... .. �,,.,. ,. .. oI , . i � "_ .. , ,...... . . а . � � � I ,., �i. . � ( . .,. " . � II ,... '^ �i. У � ..�. Э � � ... _ 4i �i., Т��q , 1 7��•!" I � �i , � .. + � � � 1Е-Э � i, I W1 ( II �( � �( 1 Г/} W L" I � I С � � ; v�.CJгr � _ й �JS� 4�1 �� 'R ���..., �' •� I А{I U 4 гi7 Ci и у С�, °G йQ 1. Г Ч..' � G r б L 'fJ = д] "ц 1 '�°i I�� �г �"'� , I �ч , � I i..1 Ci. � � i „U 4 i W? : �J Э'' � �у , 4/1 �' . ,. � � 4к t!] L I , I� I , С4 г.r � k �, , , � � �са � � , � � I �, � Е с ,, � �F� 4� I � ц с� � -о Сд р `+.г' ,(� s� О � � ,�у Э `�" aJ � ��`- � ,fi w �` j sл � I � м т �I тЭ � I � ,�ч Х`" '+.. ' 1� м ' W, ;��ч, `" 1� У iy � С I�' �;;� а 1 i�'""' i с �, 1 -� ]'��1 EW � I °. ,, '� . . � " sгF., i � й ы4 °�' -� ?, � � � " �а � I � г� I� � ! � � ' �1 � '"� � � II� � ! 1 .��, �� � " � гг У СрΡ � � 'а ш N �, 1 1 '� = 1 v � � 1 зli II W � ; t*7 � �м bA 1 L7 � 'и° й .� --� � � �' � ; 1' д ^ 1 а. 1'® 'о `� w °ra � � � �.w �,] 'L7 II ' I � � � fr ', р- ai � �с "' � G+ s� ; � и .ft? I G ( м � �,. 1 � = ; 47 ч�,.. �I � � � � 4� V} и W К o-� ,fl I� иСΡ �!� sj с� � L �� �� �' С � � � �I,i р 1 '�-г VЭ Э ц ',,'д � � й � � �1 0. �'i L � `р { � � �. I � � � �• � I � ' �+ q � �„ � Э '� и�i .s w f � �. 1I 4[7 1 (� � Уд '� U 1 U � 1 � Э I� qcl,ь и � � С '��' '� д� 2} 4а.., I� с'Э С} 1� [j � '�'Э й �- I� ^-' ( й� � С! �у ^� °-.i' I � i 6J �_ с� ';� а � с(� й�� I ��i гл 1 v� � b� i� i� i.��i I м Э.: I� I ы` � I�у •-� , Г � уΡ �/] �ч � III � { � V �� I CJ �, W � Li. ' С.) "� G� ы�" �!� Э U_._ I � С'S Гл � и7 � С� i U �и 1, 0. i С/9 ,._ � Гь.� � � ', �i � 1 1 I 1 Э . i И 1 . ―뒈― STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEME NTS FOR TTIE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Explanatory notes to the variances- L Financial support in e-PW-ECDICHBCC (27%) The low pe fbrmance was due to COVID-19 restrictions measures, which stopped the operationalizazion andfimetioning q1'HB-E(,.7Ds across different districts hence leading, to low iililiz4ilion(?f,'Iiti7tl,v..Alfoi-8e 'If ff,all goes Ivell. fi. Conduct E nvironmental Impact Assessments (ESIAF) and Resettlement Policy F,rameivork (RPrs), ARAPs, F.SMPs, CMS (6%) No prqlects with mqjor impacts ivere proposed tinder P TVs that required EWA& and RAPs. Resettlements and Policy Frameivork and F,5AIlFivere alreatty developed, Districts stcfff),Nth lechnical supporifton? LODA stqfff developad F,,5A4Ps and ARAPs, Training qfLU slqfI'on Citizen Trzonitoringsystem is to be conduct in respect with COVID-19 restriction measures, Therelbrr., the rem aining balance will be reallocated to cP W cash tran# r to cover the gap in FI'2021-2022, iii. Asset Transfers (45%) 7'he delqv in para social ivorker establishment and operafionalization also dolayed the implementation qf pi-odoctive asset. A houscholds being provided with productive assel inust also be assigned with para social ivorker _/br proximity advisoij) services, Thus, the Procurement process started a bit later and request oljimds was possible almost at the end o the financialyear. iv. Case workers (31 Due to COVID-19 restriction inea-wires, para social workerrecruitment and trainhq delayed and it was the pre-requisile.1bi-fimd request and disbzirsement, Currently, 1he r(icridimew ivas finalized in all concemed Districts and the remaining amount is being disburscd./br trainings, health insurance, comintinication, and on cl ff ,renl ivorking materials like registers, papers, pen... v. Work i Pith stakeholders to develop BCC materials in accordan ce BCC Strategy (0 yo) BCC inaterials were to be developed by the consultant. Cia-rently the consullant is on bourd and the developinew of BCC materials ivere to be preceded by the communicationstrategy which we are having today thefinal drqfi and hus started to develop BCC materials. This arnount will be wilized.for dissemination. vi. Skills development (53%) Due to C011ID- 19 pandemic. training calendar i,vas distio-bed and 17-ainingprocess took inore time than expected As qf'nom, trainingy are ongoing and disbursements are donefi)llowing signed Alb Us. Office of th e A uditor General of State F Mances 30 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 vii. Public conimunication (IEC and media) (13%) Recruimnent of public commznunication and sensitization consultant look time duc lo proceuremeni challenges. The Consuliani is now on board Ii is expected that funds ivill be consumed before end of the project by December 202L. viii. Training of LG staff on NSDS guidelines und TA (62%) Th1e /ow budget execulion in lrining of LG slaffon the NSDS guidelines is associated with two mean reasons. The first is persistence of the COVID-19 pandemic disease and associated pyrevenltive measures restricting peoplye movement and meetings. LODA managed to provide planned frainings using Virtual means. Secondly, LODA have adhered to the instruction i1-om ilie Prime Minister's Office of 04/12/2020 guiding institutions to use available public buildings lo host organized meeting and trainings, ix. Monitoring of NSDS implementation und comunnity mobilisation, CIWS Trainings at District level (48%) The low budget execeion in Monitoring ofNSDS iiplementation and communily iobilization, CV HS Trainings at District level is associated with tvo miain reasons. The/first is persistence ofthe COVID-! 9 pandemic and associaledprevenlive measures restrieting people movemenl and meelings. Ditricts namged to organize initedfield monitoring and local meetings with fe'er people than was planned. Secondly, DistricIs have adhered to the instructions fion the Primne Minister's Office of 04/12/2020 guiding intuitions to use available public buildings to hosi organized meeting and frainings. x. Monitoring, reporting and evaluation on NSDS (10%) The 1iow budget execution in moninoring, reporting and evaluation of the Nutrition Sensitive Direct Support (NSDS) is associated with persistence ofthe COVID-1 9 pandemic limiting the central levelfion executingplanned field monitoring session due to lockdown and other social movement restriciion. In addition, the NK consult ing Grup recruited for the operational review o/the NSDS was lim/ted (with lockdown) to conduc field dala collection. The delay in data collection led to the delays in report submission and consequently the services wtas not jelly and timely delivered för payment process. xi. Conduct training tc LG staff on MIS Module (52%) The aclivity is primarily based on trainings and other fce-to-face suppori by central staff to Local Governtnent sta/f on use and1 fill utilization of IvIS on the efjéctiveness of the implementation on Social Protection safty-net activities. Since the start of COIVID-19 measures (March 2020), iraining-related activities were impleiented down wise; leading to low perif ance. Office of the Auditor General of State Fin ances 31 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 xii. Other Project operation Costs, MEIS use and follow up PW, DS and data input, Bank charges etc. (54%) Due to C(OVID-19 restrictions measures, running cost ofproject,or the imiplenentation ofthe projects compone nts and categories was decreasingly consuned. There hope is to speed up the consumption offinds once Covid-19 restricting measures are simiplified xii. Acquire and manage ICT equipment (nd other needful operating costs (Counterpart) 5% The central Treasury deposited only Frw 271,351,040Frw out ofFr 5,064,450,000 through the separate counterpart account With relrence to World Bank hnplementation Support Mission oflNovember 16-20, 2020 and other correspondences via emails, the GoR has furiher explained that the remaining counterpart frnding has been earmarked to Districts' accounts across the country to strengthen social protection activities at both district and sector levels. Sofar. Waiver request on counte'partfinding requirements was approved by World Bank. xiv. CR VS (40%) The low pel:1ormIance on Civil Registration and Vital Statistics (CR VS) is a resui ofCOVID- I 9 pandemic that has a(fected different planned activities (Training of Civil Registrar and Civil RegiStration Officer at Sectors, Cells and health ficilities) and related delays in procurement process (Procurement of E-consent, the strengthening of Inbrination Communication and Technology at cell level), xv. Strengthened M&E and Learning in the Social Protection (59%) The low performance on Strengthened Monitoring and evaluation in the social protection is a result of COVID-19 pandemic that has affected different planned activities (Dissemination of the Social Protection Policy: training of Social Protection Actors in central and Local Government up to cell level, National Dialogue on Social Protection, monitoring and the implementation muki-sectoral planning in local government) and related delays in procurement process (delayed finalisation of the integrated Social Protection Management Infbrmnation System Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 32 -,[;위, 'с��г� � � � I,� С? Ф�IФ�C7I�;�IQ �7'� � � 01С7�с� ;i �i� C31� С'� �I�I�и�I� ;�;� Э� О С>�G?�Ф �� � �!�i� �,� о1�сэ�с� �i�.�.!c�ie:. Н �г�lс� в`.�i�i����aa,и ��сз с��i� ia;�з��r c�i ra �.-д;,-+ ,.-+•.�,�1w, 1� ,.�j� r-• '...�I�,L�S N i , � ,"_'+ i С[ i � г 1 � � I � ' + I �! Е II Э ( i ! � i i ` � i , I I иJ �' � I 1 1 ; Э i I' I i I I Э i Э I � � , i i i, , � I , , i , t , , : и . ,. �и ,. � I ,. ( I,:.. , , г � I ,.._и . , � и .,. , � .i .. � ; ...s.. Е , , ' .. . 4 ., .., i„ ..,. .. .,.. ..�..,._.... . V __ ....... . . .... ,..,... __.. ..,, . ® I� ' ! I k Э Е �I � L Е � I Э � 1 I ! i ', , � �II � Ci ... � I . � I , � J'а . ( I .. �'I I ♦ �з ... III � � � � I i ,.� ; , � и Э , � i 1 , , � � , � и ь I , 1 , � � , � � � ! ` I ; �, � 1 i ь i . S , ' `� 1 и � k Lт� i I , 1 F , i � I � , , �' f �� 1 � .., I ,,. � , II ! � I . , � � �, � � � Э �. ' � i L� � � . . ,. , ,. ,.� ...,..,..,. .i .{ и � i 1 '' ' � �i! i i� I�.��c� С� � О � k+; �1OI�I�!s��C?IC Сг�v Q,C? О�? =� �+'S' и,� �, �]1д C�;Qi���?;G � �? 1C��I� ��[д+;[ � � �t � t,:.. 1.1.,��.,�i'I�3�'16{7;�ч.i�j� �'�...� ,,:�1I�,�3kCз � � � а.и ,I i �I 1 ' � i 1 1I I +� � � I Э ,i � 'I 1 ' II , �.I � �I � �I ( � I � , I � � � � ' ' ' � �i , . I' .,. _ ' I�I 1 � sд �� �i�1 I i 1 i � � � Yr � `г.� �1 1 I ! � I I � �у гw I"~1 I�" Э� , �� ,, I � , ! i i I� �ь н ,t,.�i !� 1Л " �-, i�м i , i � N � 1� 1 ' � , 1 i II, f f�г� 1 � , � +� � � , ' 1 , 1 1 а � ; � 1, , � I ; ,, , , � i и i �'' � � I ! , f , ( I� I � i ` � � �_..... ..,.......I. . и _ .--. �� I,,.' I { Е � i I II � � 1 i iI � ь � �н W z� � � I � 1 , ь � � � � � 1 ,.�� '� W с3 ! � Ii � � I � ' � i � � i 1! �; 1 г 1', i � i И , . ' � �� � I � � � � � , , � II i I I � и , � � � �� ,� i и I � , . 1 .._.. _, . ... . .,. и , ._ . r�'' v, � !I � i � р �`� � �° ��� �; II � i �,,, � �� � �� � �1� �� Э I I I i � � � � � �� !'�, I' и � � w Gт~ � � i 1 � 1 4 �I , 1 -� �! r-� I, i i N � Э � i �, � � � , � , , , Э i � w �""' � j � Э , i , � � � � � � � Е"' � " { .�, , , � � С � i г , , � „ i Ir � . , _и , I _..., � С� �r I I Г' 1 � ' � 4 и,. � ! 1 , �1л и.� � 4 1 1 1 ! ,�, V � 1 1 i а� � � �ечs ' ' I'I � , � �I` I � г�м -�-, Wr.[ Е I 1 9� и I � I�q � q� ,' ,i I S� U ' � � �-� , � � ' �, � ' °� G �U � � Е й, � � °С ��г �� �`г� �� ` � (/� ,. r�] I � ц1 I, СtЯ �; и ��� i,м W � 4б ; . V' �г � I �� � аLг` г�� �;�Э,с''i�(` � �' ��г�.� � �i ��' *С��ч � F� �л с,; I �isl�i�3 �Iua; � �+.7 �i � �;w� �i `��, w � � � w���i�-';�I�ЭЭЭ�i���I�iй1"�p�i�(� �� �i � � � �, �', �,�i,�'� � I�i�,ш �Э � �; '�I '� � � � �, � �',�, ,�,,�j� � �'� wi�'�!�l���� � С7 � i ��I Ic�,�i� C,7I�I N I с � � r � � � � � ����I�i�������,�'��I�'� ��� �;� ����� й . , � � F-� � � й � �� �Ii�I���I'��,���I�Ii��� �.�Ii�'�'й!["�'' � г�] � , ' � ' r г i � I Э � I I ... I, . � � � It д .i. � I � I � Э I � lГ3 �� I С 4�w�1-+ � a�.L �i С% '*� I � ��I ` � ' � ( '� �' М � j� '� Ч � Q � � i i, ! i, '.i �� � i � I Q`� ; 1�': � '��.'',.i � ( �д. ', � � � 'I I Ii �. � i � � I (� I � �,.в� � т �`, . �{ � I гу � �� i,i �. � � 1-Р1 у � ��..� I 1 � � ; � ',; � �. � '.. � � д ii , � � � ! ( � � i . � ь � � �уΡ.��уΡ � �� � � � '� .; ry�,} � , С%i 1еч �'"J I�i � I �'I '� � ' �' � в� i � i �757 i Q i 'т' �� � II � ' ' ' � . � l'�1 ( I �? I fV i Г�1 i (�1 � �t г ' ' � � i ,--У � F I � Ir � i IIC � f� I �--� . ... .. ..._._. У_..а,. � _..,.' ......,. ,. . i . i � ,...1.... е ......... __,.,,.,. ......._... .__. i � i. i _, � i i I У i 1 I � г.�.. �', i � ' С7 I ! � i� � �+�+?j+ �' � � I� �` � I �7 У�+ I � ; � з� i �Л , � � г� 1 �' I 1:� �r ' I �ага "� � i°° i� ! I� kв � 1� '� i� �г� .� � i , г о �- � i� �л ,,�-r I i� о 0�0 I �с• � I �� ( � � `'' '� ' � ' ;� �►' м �� I'� л с °� �, � � �r" � � f � i � � � �а ,.� ,� � �r � му � � � � � !� � i 11 � ,.�.,° , м ( � Б i �`'" '� а � 'i °г' � I1 � I'�, г°' � � � rч � � ; � I .. , � е�е � ,ч м , �� � F�+ �w � ' i дi i(V ,...... ' � ' �. У , .Iь _ .,,i..,, У..,..,..,,. , I,.,,,...... t�,,y � �' ` ' I а.� � , ' ' ... ' �� i �, ' � � i � I ._. .. . . ..... � '� � � � Э II � и У 1 � I с� 'I I М � �.` �'*1 С '� �j ,�? ' . I , � г-�'-- � 1� 1 р I � 4�уΡ qCj � р �/т . � i . i � , � � i � � I �#`� � � � ��; �и j М` # , � Г'7 `%.-� wд'" ,. 4 ' ,. ff1 � I М i � , � ,: � � � �Cf �i1 � � гл� �L I ; �[�- � �[- � 1 � Гr5 r+`i j�{у� w �г � �. � �- ; ' I С� � , wG �? : rry � М й � � � , �а , � с�а j I яо. �а �+--У с, М , Гт. � � , . ; � ; � i г г� (� � � � г � � � г ... . . . �.. , . .. . , . � � ` . , i . i ; _...f,. . ., ...,.,..,.. . i...,..... iг� ..... , . г � �в ГV � � 1 ' � � �� � �4 ( 1 � Г•] il7 � t�э � мf �� q� i 1 т- ,<� т� ; �., � ; . S� i Об I � i `л .�. I � �: "'�„ "� �' �' � ., .. 1 С ' О I � ' С�]ч � �; I� I ! � in ; � , �°1 �ь+ � �у ±� � , Ii � �. I ;. �. i �. С4 =.� 1 ! � � ; ! �г1` ' � 4? ,� ��. ^У . � � 7 ; С�1 � ; � � 1 �� � � � � м- � м� '� �I� � Ii '�� ц°l t �. I ' !'� ; ,'�� Г*� � i ! г � ["�`- i �, �� � Oti А? . су � "�V I� � � Г г � Г'"У I � j ' � '� 'i. 1 � ; М н 43 'r I _ � , , , 1 , , � � II � Gч � i � 1i � ^� 1 � Е� i� i М � �'' и � � � г . � ...,. � � _.. ..... . ..�. ,.....` ,. .. , г , о г У i { I { �. � � I '� ' � �I� � � I 4 I Э ,� U � � 'I � I �I � � � '�г С� � У� . � !г �,,. � Г"�i I � I W� У � а' дУ"�.�,7. � � I � } I ' � ( �г г �� i � � I �. ' I г � � � ( V `�` � ��.. +� �' j �.. � г У i �l Э �� II` L� I �� �� i � �� г� � �-' �, � "� I � ', ' ' �` I 1 � � � Э � � �-' i ' ``� У �,; ; `g' . � � � I', м~м , ( `ж � � ' � Э ; `г' �1 *� 1 ! о{ � � �' i � 'I � °�r', Е-У *� � ' �' � '' Э � ',, � � � *" � V� � � • , � � С� � I � t I � _ � � � ...,..,.. ............. а .,..,. � У.. .:. i I � г , ��,.. ��, � � � � i I � � i � I q�.Y и . 1 � � V � � rry � N 1;.t �f} 1 i ц� f Cti G� G� ' � � � � � Fl � I i I ! i �, � � � �3 Gi.г . , т , . .. . , . ,. . . ;... ..... ; ...., т.а . ., . j Э. I � � � � � � � � . '.,т Э. �. ' ', '� � , � I � � � �:� �, � Г�-� ь-��- � д ' !' 1 ; : �' гs � � А � � 1 � I � д � I,, I ; ` � �! � �. �� � � � �� i 1 �с�� , ; � � c�i.Y � �U � I � � � � i� � i i � 'I Iг а� `°� г-� � � Г�, i ы ' �• � i � , � и :' I •�'., � � `� � w, д i nn � � . � � � v ' �i г. � � �� � � "�^д � ° й"= ,�I I � �° сп � � � � � t� U � Е., �' '', ы � F � � '� � � i ,� � � � `"" � �� � � � �� �;�i� i Ё� и� �1I � l�� � й w r У �, � Нr.+ '°� � � I � , � � , ' '� � . ° I�1 1 � '� � � , � ', ' � �, � � мы м� а С . 4у а j д7 � г 1 � ;� L i G � �С� *� ;' + � I ;' � п � � �.. �] � � 1 1 � 4 , � ; � i � di j С� б � CJ � ,� � I � � , � L! [t � �J I С3 j 9 i 4 � 1��I дi гА '� •г�. I� !� Ii k. ,. � У.. � Э.7-i � I, � и �j .i у� iи �( 1 vг Г; 1 у�''�м Sлу �ч (� '� iJy 'I 'п � 1 гч•ч 9} G ! �р Уу � � [Л `�1 '� ' гл � �g„ . � ` ��++ ��у � � '�!� I 'а,'ы, i� а�л '� i� ��� � `� т �,I'� ��'а�3 v' � о � Е� R д д л И,��, ;�`*',., � s� `,� �� '-' д S. 1 rл ,�r� i I� F�..' ��, w а� а� г� г� �� �, � I сС � �7 I пt `� �:7 1 д. "' �а �уΡ У+ � г р,у L � ч�.+n 47, ��+-� 9 С7 � ' G' ,✓ Ь �Т �. � I� OG 4� S? G1 'с�'а сгК'... � L У 47 '�" С? /�i � W Yi � ц:i: � 4.-f I� f"1 У С7 "� 1" °�1 F� �о � t� �' �� Е°� pG О С� SS] � Cf"? � та т� ! b�k , ; ���� , I Еу ��; С� � С� t� � С!} -еС �, Н Cl� �' � „ + � �. I�,.. . � . 1 ��1I � � � � IIII �г� �, ��г V Ч л � I��! �л �II � 4 � г � � Р1 I. г-э !г г5G? �{у 4 (•� 'у II ЕЛ � 1� I�1 С�' г� � IГ} V�1I � � I л1 � �F и. iiIY '� J♦i�ьh I .�г t�`1 � :��iа 4� А l l'�{IY �I sь�1 ' ��в 1 + �V9 � �i � I 'г•Тд•' г �' (� t w® . W г " г г i � � � , *.1 It� � ' �Гд Э I �. II Чi � �Сцi' I � '� �'.. Ч � ' � i �j, � � ; ' ';r I � г �f"`i ; Ц�1 �� h1 I 1f1 ', kГ `. �7 ' S.. � � 1 п i г I t,�., ' �! п� 1 �1 I II е��1 hJ � r�i F'у , t , � т�е_...... �....._ ..,.1... а � . .., .. i.. . .,.,., i ....... � .... . I ....... _ r.. i + '��., � t .а._. ... 1 1 �� �� ту I' п� r,W г� � � + � п�м �р � С1 � � ! ("�у i � 1 fF `� � ц� I Е fry' Эи °.. � i �I � �' � м I � �' Ii �у„�К , f ��.. ь [-�., I k`д � � �. CFt I � 1� г�. I С-- � уГ1 I t� � � r- I N+ lГ7 � ргj Н�� С I II � I CG т�-Э ;� � .��.. �� у,�„� ,... kf�`й ч�-� � ;. .�-1 � ......... � I {� � . � � f`-�„ � !+i I �I � !`� !, f � � 1, � " !'Ч i i II� � � �\G ' � �� ( .� itlj � � ; 1 j � � � ; г � 1 I ; ; 1 � { Г'й N Е =.. g . .,.�.. ..�.. . __� ,._,._. .. йi i г ` I ' 1. i � �.,.. � II � I i � � { 1 ! ��I � 44 � ',.�. II 'ь�� ��I , й � . � " � � � k1`J � %� � i �в ; � � цу I +''� �` � '�, 1I �+ I : Г+ � �ч !, i t+ м✓ rт�� 'ft! ы.. L� l. 1 ;.�� ' j� I п--+ �� i � й. � � iI � 'IiI I`�9 `� � � I � i,. w � 1 ., �� � У � ,, I � III 'i ; � I �• I i � ! � � U �i � �'�й � � � f'А? '�,� �I � 1 � (Cj. I �'. II i �^ , � � г � I `. � � !I _ f . __ . .. . � , г �...� Sб ,,. ' iI ` _ 4 I � j Р� � � II I I ; +[] 1 t� I� � �G II I �.С `� � !� � � � I ' �� '� � !i I� ' � •,�. � !I� 'q '� � ма � + , � ; ;r I tч ',1 ' � I � � г � � p��,I � г '�t` 1 т~ �--� � .-� ; ! '� �--� �.у ; 4✓ � . � . �Л ,� ,,,•� I � f'�1..• � , Г•7 i ,� � �'Ч � У-� '� �7 �I. �+, 1 С 1 �' = i ,i � ., �j. г;� 1 I 'I `� � CV GM ' Gt � Cw �� г�. �� 1 ! �+ �,.� i I � , °гG ' �t '+И' 'е1' тС 'I � гл� I cn ;"�' � � I II � �, j , , I � '-' 'Ii i , � , . , .. ;,..,....... � � I � I г . ..LL .. .._. . . ' ' 1 1 � � �� II i ��� со ' 9г] � С4 � . � гЭ4 I I � I СО + it� .± � р7 (� I � '1 � � + � � � ; �� д � wD � �ы У�, � г'°а ' t'V , � iЧ � � � ^ � Е� 1 � � , I � Ii ('`� °° � � "� � i � � �' � � , о � � �' ,ж� ; ,`-•�'ч � � С� �' � �'- �д 1 �� €Л I д1 СЛ �� СС Ii �' ^_ '� С4 �r F � � I�!I �-м � � •��г �1, С�Е � ь � Г � � G�O ,-�-� Е'+ С� � .. .. .. � � , �� � ���� �� �j �г.т ..._� � � Е ; � г �1 r+ . . ........f... . _�.., � �.., ., I _._а ; ; Е j . У � � � I 1�, i ' � . � � � � V] �+�ii О � тК ! � � i �`# 1 �+„� ', � � V �V � {1I 1�{ ы �1I I � r �-уΡ i нjF^ 1�, � � I' ".. ,� I �.. м , � ... .... ... . .. ...... .. . . .. . . . . ., ., ., ...... � . 1 е � � А � � i i � i i I I .I. � �w � � � � ( , � � I ; �� Н�" � �'� ,, , i � � �, � �� � � � � ; � г I I ! � д� � � С ,, ' � �I ,I i ; ' `� F� ` Ii � � ' i � � �r� � � I�f i I� ; � г� � W F f ��, V7 �II j I ��I�i � ,. ' ь;, �' �r� � ; , �I I ! '� ,� ,� ', � V� � � � I�I � I I .. { ( � у� ��i Q} 4 � � � FF��-� ( I' I•� ,1 � � II�' +� .I,� С � � � ,I� � � 4 �м I�i fs] 1 I � � � �,�, � и � 11 � и � I •+� ; � �" F� U � � �, �. ,' � I � -� � � � � и � �'м Р� � � , `� � гс+ � �. I � ; +�'-� sd I �+, '�С ,w � , ta �. ! 4и � пу а� +. ч�. � � ��� � � �, � � � i�II� � � �( !� � � � � �_ � � � � ;�е� С�} L °й � , а�.ь ; м ' в+ С? С�� � L"`" 'r.' w1 �у � 4G 0.а i/} I' .-i Ri � ,, С3 " 0 . � й7 .. t� � ,` � f �G � Е�+ � А -� U � �С I С/} �" тм 1 1 Lw 1 Е� ;i м7 � i � Q 4� i Г� I i Q � I й i Ii �� � i ;� I� 4� 1 i � и .I III � 'i � �,1 Г*1 � fw11 ��, м 1 и� �I �L � 4� , � 4�� 1 С�7 .-.� � ��7 r � , II r� 1 М *' N ; � � ас� � 1 � N 1 �s г'� 1 � 1 , , ,� ', � ' G� I , . ~� �� 1 I сс� " � � м , � ' � � ' et� � ЕЧ � � 1 ;� ¢ Г*1 I 1�D � С� '� �' ; j С°- ��у i 4� . ,' ел 1 1!у I о � i С � �; � �`#, � -к � `�`' р .г -� � �� ' ��� г е*] С� 1 � � i � е� +� ! о�,Е� � i � I �Р '�� IpG I СЛ�I� �I�б h1 � �� 1См i �"7 ; 4 � гг� �' ц1 � С� ; , r- tц � �у ®. i �G � I I C�I ' I� �, ' I I N ; �� N I : *'" i i k I и , � 1 , .- 9 а, � ,.., i + ,. . . .�I ._ . '.. _.,. ..,..,. ,. . у. . ..,. � . ... _ ,. � � . � 1 ;�I i � �, 1 � 1 1 .. I. Э �I ��, С � 1,.� I i гц I �'� N е'! Э �''� �т7 1�л � , г�+з и г��3 1 �� �� i ��.� Э� �", � �� � {,у,�„у �G ��1 � и.l]С � Э� г� 1[а ,, �� ; гу �' i г�' ��' 1�'а Ih °'�,� с� �, ` !� I мi �° � Ik м 11 м� l М; г4л� I � ��r Э� �iм .� 3 � ,� о3 ,�, Е � iCy i� ,� F�, , � , ,з I �" �I м � ' �' i Е I .� � I асэ I �а � � � � 1� �� 1 1М 1 �q�p � I�I �" I� l�' '-iI 4� 1в ,Mj Irry � 'q� �q� 1 � I i 1� I � i�` I��`,j I lN � � � i� i I� h� i �II� i� I , � [`7 i 1 r � j 1 i I : � � � � I�.. - ._. " ь. � _ __ . _ , _..;..._. . . _ _ � 1 1 � I i I I;� у i ; 1 � г*1 Iи 'I , о"7, ! 1 � �' ' � , i i �� i ;��-; ;� � 'и_ { II �I , О �'°'" . 1 tП � а F�- ��"а iи ьУ1 I �; � I Гr5 й1 1 ,L � .. ! . I П � ; I� 1 � (•.1 1 i. �il � ; '�, �I � й �' .. I � � � I `� 1 �-, i ; � '� ги+у w �v � �; �, � � � i 1 i �л й � � д, � � ; I1 1�.в 1 � ''� �` � � ; I � а ! � � i г � i � 1 ,� � ''�, 1 'I I �. 1 i i а � � i i : h i i , W : � , I � � � � I L�ч � м�i � ; 1 ' , � � " � . г _. , - � 1 I! ® - I � � ' и i , � i � I I � , j.. '; i° w � � ,�v 1 ! i ! ! �л 1; омс. I j �1I � i �'I � г�а � гд "� � � .�..�.. . . � � i `_' � �V�-, 1 "* ' I � i . , � i 'i "' `� �1 ; ° ` °� W � а � р��`. 1� I i�у � !„�; I, irь �� .�"i`�� � !i �t' � I 4� фСа ргу � G� � � ь� й�- ,� �� � о "°,�и I`'' I ! л м rrs i,[� ; � ,г� � и+� ,� i �' ���s ° 1�' � '° ''�t °� � t�? ;г� ; � � га � '� ;;Г j,� i`� i �;�� �� i � �� « �м ' �г� �+`�'r, , � "�` �`'а � г*7 i � оа � � Су � ' t`� � ; � гл I чw 1 г,`� � Со � i � +--i 1 � г � � . , . ( ' 1 Г� , , : ,� I � I , ��� ��� ' � � оз ,аз ь , � , , � :... � 1 Г� � _ {' Р I 1 : ', i 1 � 1 I,.., I ; ' ` �. i � � � 1 � � � л� , " � � ; 1 i j I д i ��f�Y � � V 1'� � 1и � I I � I S � � � 1 � + 1 I � �УΡ�. � �(уΡ � 1 Ц`S Ifj ! ц� � � � ; ; { +�т-. �+ 1 � � J-ь I ( �I � � +т' ' i. ' ' : и `{�{� I {`� I ЙF-м,J _'4 �у 1 � � I �у � М� � �� +i.°�7 � � 40 � SC ' I � # Ч. i +г. ( tCy � � �� �® � I N I ' r'1 � 1 � I ; � р I OG '� 1 i ! ЗЭ О�д p�Q� ' (F,��j� � х � � � , ( iI � � I � � ? � � �ry 1� 1 � �`?. ® � { � , ; �д ��hq � �k'� . i. � '(%�J ��.�4 II , i{�1 �' � { �� 1ЧI � I� г i�`� � � � .-ц �� I ,. I `.�/ � i rI О�/� р/+�уΡ �� � � i j , �1 � MW _-Ч i I д� � 4./ 1' ,, . � . 1 , ! . i ._..._..I . .,.,а1.. '-. ,... ._ __ �I �. t .. 1 и .'i... � . � � � I � � т . i . � .. I � � �1 I ; �I � I .�,.. .,.I,, iI � �Ii ,� � � С!) I � I � 1 , � � � I ; i 1 I ; � 1 1 �I � w � �i � 1 � � � I .�' i I � i r ' III i г �I � 'I I II .� � � � �� G4 I � � � � 1 I i '} ' ггs I I® {"" � I � � � � �ь i i ' � � II i�ч , °4У' I�I � j "и ++ 1 '� �� � .: iЧieF I 4 S/J , , , U I .'Yr � �ь , I .� i � � 1 i 'х : г.Г� 1 s,г � � � I и 1 1 �'"�-+ . , е� Q� м� е� I ° •� � � i 'а��.+ ! , I -��. ' г 1 � � Gp II'I .,, 1 f�' i� Сд �1 � (,� �� , +..� I I � I �л ' ti ; � . 1 . о � I �1 С i � � , � � ' С' �' и 0.. � бг° 4} ; I � 1*. I �•�, � g� � � � � 1 bЛ � I с'о .r � � � �-.' 1 I �tl � GA I � д�1 �; �s1 G� � � j С ыа � 1� б, I I �" � j`.Э �� � р С " � � � I I �', C�i3 ! I� � - Q] ! � � i3,1. ,... II1 и � I •�vr i гг� . � � � � . � '�С, � � � F.и � v_ i+ ��� , д� :� �и й} � еб W fi.� L �^ � � v � 1 ь... 1 �I 4ц � гл1 1 �] и С Е� '� � С С а i t+ �7 Г� Lz1 , С�. � �-' sэ � и �`, а.� 1 аг � ;• т� i� .'��, о �;,_, са С � �г Ф �,i �oj � аг;ш _ ; иL �,�Ë�,I.� с) �� � I � I й C..I С �!`-'��,� '�,'�°�`�.., ��,�з`�' ��.o ,s 'ti �� F I 1 � � E�w ��, �У���'�� �'`�1� � ��с�1�1���Р;� � �� С I � I г„_, � �(� I tн Ii ' �л i}• г`�i5 Il � � ��� о� и � � С 1'в-и +',�? � CS � � "� а 1 �r � `'-' `'^�,w и�й �1Т�.�а,� о с1`,�^�у�_С �,'��ц,.а� � �.,,Jь (/} �^ , , � 1 О 1 � ь. s.�. ' 'r` I *' � �" : С г,•� '1 ��„ ,� 1 ' � ,^5 у� р � - ,С {� и ' ,С � � � � ' •Zy 'I � � I С у��, � г`� г.� ! � � 4Ci i �.и � i и II � I � �!1 I �1 � J7 с�9 1 �'н � � й5 � ; �н � i � С = wr М Са I й { г �I . Э � � j +J � � � Э G С � ��, г�б { еод с .. ! � 1 гЭ" +. ! � I � � +, w � � � А � ',,� "r�� С7 �Н Н г�7 1й�i��и;С� �t71�сл t U I� � �;� �U ;`� �''� ; � иа � ; � гл � ;� � i i � � ' 1 �� � ` � 乍 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON' CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 DETAILED AUDIT FINDINGS .fice of the A udifor General of State Finances STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 5. REVIEW OF EXPENDITURE 5.1 Inconsistencies noted in recording project employees' costs Observation During the review of SSPP books of account for the year ended 30 June 2021, the audit noted that some of employees' costs are recognized under goods and services while others are recognised under compensation of employees. See details in the table below: Account Description Amount Frw 21 Employees' costs recorded under compensation of employees 82,330,767 22 Employees'costs recorded under goods and selvices 89 1,259,251 This gap is attributed to inadequate planning during budget preparation by SSPP management. Risk The balances of the affected ledger accounts were misstated and therefore users of SSPP financial statements may be misled in their decisions. Recommendation Going forward, SSPP management should properly review its budget during planning exercise to ensure expenditure are correctly allocated to appropriate budget lines. Management comments Since the start cfthe project, the project employees 'costs have been recorded under goods and services via professional and contractual service bidget line (2221) ay per budget law /f1r related fiscal year. The management ofthe project/bfr both sides will maintain the consistency in recording employees cost mainly in planning process. Office of the A uitor General of State Finances 40 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 6 REVIEW OF CASH AND BANK EQUIVALENTS 6.1 Differences between audited bank balances and corresponding opening balances as at I1t July 2020 Observations Consolidated statement of financial position of SSPP as at 30 June 2021 includes cash and cash equivalent balance of Frw 3,502,974,224. Review of SSPP cashbook revealed unexplained difference of Frw 6,662,500 between the audited cashbook balances reported in SSPP consolidated financial statements for the year ended 30 June 2020 and corresponding opening balance as at 01 July 2020. Refer to the table belowfor details: District Account Audited cash book balance Cash book balance as at 1 Unexplained number as at 30 June 2020 July 2020 difference Frw Fr- Frw A B CA-B Burera 1000045752 343,595,053 343,064,053 531,000 Musanze 1000044788 26,104,895 19,973,395 6,131,500 Total 26, 104,895 369,699,948 363,037,448 6,662,500 This anomaly is attributed to adjustments in the SSPP cash books nade by respective districts but these adjustments are not considered in the report of SSPP Risks The completeness and accuracy of the reported cash and cash equivalent balance could not be confirmed, Hence, SSPP consolidated financial statements have been understated, Further, there is risk that the amount not reported have been misused. Recommendations SSPP management in collaboration with districts should set control mechanisms to ensure any adjustments made in the district cash books is reflected in the consolidated financial statements prepared at Project level. Where possible, necessary disclosure should be made. Management comment The difference of Frw 531,000 represents additional payments in cash book after the submission of 5PP financial report fi June 2020 to LODA by Burera District. This adjusinent was approved by the district management. Date Description - Amount in Frit 30/0612020 Pamet ofsuperwso of5'P cPW 8 Rehabiitadon of CYANIKA RYABITEYI 231,000 NYA GA HING,I GAS17A hi Cyanika ect or 15Am 30/0012020 Paiynent of supervisor of Sl' P lW B3 Rehabiliation qf C YINIKA RYA1BITEY 300,000 NYAGAIIINGA GAS//A in Oanikacor 15km Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 41 STRENGTHENING SOCIAL PROTECTION PROJECT (SSPP) AUDIT REPORT ON CONSOLIDATED FINANCIAL STATEMENTS FOR THE YEAR ENDED 30 JUNE 2021 Date Description Amtount in . . ..... ...F rov Total 53 1, 000 The difference of Frw 6,131,500 represents the deposit in transit reported in the bank reconciliation by error by the system (IFAISi) It was a correction made on VUP Misanze Sector. With the assistance ofMINECOFIN, the error iwas later corrected by the District and the actual cash book balance became Frwv 19,973,395. This correction was made and approved by the District management on 23 September 2020 as indicated on the bank reconciliation report. Office of the Auditor General of State Finances 42