Question Type File Name Country Country Code Region Reform (Yes/No) Income Group Type File Name Country Country Code Region Reform (Yes/No) Income Group Type Coding_file_Afghanistan.xlsxAFG AfghanistanSouth Asia Low income Preliminary No reform (some Coding changes) Coding_file_Albania.xlsx ALB Albania Europe & Central Asia Major Upper middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Algeria.xlsx DZA Algeria Middle East & North Africa Lower middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Angola.xlsx AGO Angola Sub-Saharan Africa Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Argentina.xlsx ARG Upper middle Argentina Latin America & Caribbean income Preliminary Coding Minor Coding_file_Armenia.xlsx ARM Armenia Europe & Central Asia Major Upper middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Australia.xlsx AUS Australia High income: OECD No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Austria.xlsx AUT Austria High income: OECD No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Azerbaijan.xlsx AZE Azerbaijan Europe & Central Asia Noincome Upper middle Preliminary reform (some Coding changes) Coding_file_Bangladesh.xlsxBGD BangladeshSouth Asia Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Belarus.xlsx BLR Belarus Europe & Central Asia Upper middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Belgium.xlsx BEL Belgium High income: OECD No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Benin.xlsx BEN Benin Sub-Saharan Africa Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding BIH Bosnia and Herzegovina Coding_file_Bosnia and Herzegovina.xlsx Europe & Central Asia Noincome Upper middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Botswana.xlsx BWA Botswana Sub-Saharan Africa Major Upper middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Brazil.xlsx BRA Brazil Upper middle Latin America & Caribbean income Preliminary Coding Major Coding_file_Bulgaria.xlsx BGR Bulgaria Europe & Central Asia Major Upper middle income Preliminary Coding BFA Coding_file_Burkina Faso.xlsx Sub-Saharan Africa Burkina Faso Low incomeMajor Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Burundi.xlsx BDI Burundi Sub-Saharan Africa Low income Preliminary No reform (some Coding changes) Coding_file_Cambodia.xlsx KHM Cambodia East Asia & Pacific Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Cameroon.xlsx CMR Cameroon Sub-Saharan Africa Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Canada.xlsx CAN Canada High income: OECD No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Chad.xlsx TCD Chad Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeMajor Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Chile.xlsx CHL Chile High income: OECD Minor High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_China.xlsx CHN China East Asia & Pacific Upper middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Colombia.xlsx COL Upper middle Colombia Latin America & Caribbean reform (some Noincome changes) Preliminary Coding COD Coding_file_Congo, Dem. Rep..xlsx Congo, Dem. Sub-Saharan Rep. Africa Low incomeMinor Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Congo, Rep..xlsxCOG Sub-Saharan Africa Congo, Rep. Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Costa Rica.xlsx CRI Upper middle Costa Rica Latin America & Caribbean reform Preliminary Coding Noincome CIV Coding_file_Cote dIvoire.xlsx Sub-Saharan Africa Côte d''Ivoire Lower middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Croatia.xlsx HRV Croatia Europe & Central Asia High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding CZE Coding_file_Czech Republic.xlsx High income: OECD Czech Republic No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Denmark.xlsx DNK Denmark High income: OECD No reform (some High income changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Djibouti.xlsx DJI Djibouti Lower middle Middle East & North Africa income Preliminary Coding Minor DOM Coding_file_Dominican Republic.xlsx Latin America & Caribbean Dominican Republic Major Upper middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Ecuador.xlsx ECU Ecuador Upper middle Latin America & Caribbean income Preliminary Coding Major EGY Coding_file_Egypt, Arab Rep..xlsx Rep. East & North Africa Egypt, ArabMiddle Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_El Salvador.xlsx SLV Lower middle El Salvador Latin America & Caribbean reform Preliminary Coding Noincome Coding_file_Eritrea.xlsx ERI Eritrea Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeNo reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Estonia.xlsx EST Estonia High income: OECD Minor High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Ethiopia.xlsx ETH Ethiopia Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeNo reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Finland.xlsx FIN Finland High income: OECD High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_France.xlsx FRA France High income: OECD No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Gabon.xlsx GAB Gabon Sub-Saharan Africa Noincome Upper middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Georgia.xlsx GEO Georgia Europe & Central Asia Upper middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Germany.xlsx DEU Germany High income: OECD No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Ghana.xlsx GHA Ghana Sub-Saharan Africa Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Greece.xlsx GRC Greece High income: OECD Major High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Guatemala.xlsx GTM Upper middle Guatemala Latin America & Caribbean reform Preliminary Coding Noincome Coding_file_Guinea.xlsx GIN Guinea Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeMajor Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Haiti.xlsx HTI Haiti Latin America & Caribbean Lower middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Honduras.xlsx HND Lower middle Honduras Latin America & Caribbean income Preliminary Coding Minor Coding_file_Hungary.xlsx HUN Hungary High income: OECD Minor High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_India.xlsx IND India South Asia Lower middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Indonesia.xlsx IDN Indonesia East Asia & Pacific Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding IRN Coding_file_Iran, Islamic Rep..xlsx Iran, Islamic Rep. East & North Africa Middle Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Iraq.xlsx IRQ Iraq Upper middle Middle East & North Africa reform Preliminary Coding Noincome Coding_file_Ireland.xlsx IRL Ireland High income: OECD No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Israel.xlsx ISR Israel High income: OECD No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Italy.xlsx ITA Italy High income: OECD Minor High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Jamaica.xlsx JAM Jamaica Upper middle Latin America & Caribbean reform Preliminary Coding Noincome Coding_file_Japan.xlsx JPN Japan High income: OECD High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Jordan.xlsx JOR Jordan Upper middle Middle East & North Africa income Preliminary Coding Major Coding_file_Kazakhstan.xlsx KAZ KazakhstanEurope & Central Asia Major Upper middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Kenya.xlsx KEN Kenya Sub-Saharan Africa Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Korea, Rep..xlsxKOR Korea, Rep.High income: OECD No reform (some High income changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Kosovo.xlsx XKX Kosovo Europe & Central Asia Noincome Upper middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Kuwait.xlsx KWT Kuwait High income Middle East & North Africa No reform Preliminary Coding KGZ Coding_file_Kyrgyz Republic.xlsx Europe & Central Asia Kyrgyz Republic Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Lao PDR.xlsx LAO Lao PDR East Asia & Pacific Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Latvia.xlsx LVA Latvia High income: OECD Major High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Lebanon.xlsx LBN Lebanon Lower middle Middle East & North Africa income Preliminary Coding Minor Coding_file_Lithuania.xlsx LTU Lithuania High income: OECD Minor High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Madagascar.xlsxMDG Sub-Saharan Africa Madagascar Low income Preliminary No reform (some Coding changes) Coding_file_Malawi.xlsx MWI Malawi Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeMajor Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Malaysia.xlsx MYS Malaysia East Asia & Pacific Noincome Upper middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Mali.xlsx MLI Mali Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeNo reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Mauritius.xlsx MUS Mauritius Sub-Saharan Africa Noincome Upper middle Preliminary reform (some Coding changes) Coding_file_Mexico.xlsx MEX Mexico Upper middle Latin America & Caribbean reform Preliminary Coding Noincome Coding_file_Moldova.xlsx MDA Moldova Europe & Central Asia Minor Upper middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Mongolia.xlsx MNG Mongolia East Asia & Pacific Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding MNE Coding_file_Montenegro.xlsx Europe & Central Asia Montenegro Major Upper middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Morocco.xlsx MAR Morocco Lower middle Middle East & North Africa income Preliminary Coding Major MOZ Coding_file_Mozambique.xlsx Sub-Saharan Africa Mozambique Low incomeNo reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Nepal.xlsx NPL Nepal South Asia Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding NLD Coding_file_Netherlands.xlsx High income: OECD Netherlands No reform Preliminary Coding High income NZL Coding_file_New Zealand.xlsx High income: OECD New Zealand High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Nicaragua.xlsx NIC Lower middle Nicaragua Latin America & Caribbean reform Preliminary Coding Noincome Coding_file_Niger.xlsx NER Niger Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeNo reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Nigeria.xlsx NGA Nigeria Sub-Saharan Africa Lower middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding MKD Coding_file_North Macedonia.xlsx Europe & Central Asia North Macedonia Major Upper middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Pakistan.xlsx PAK Pakistan South Asia Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Panama.xlsx PAN Panama High income Latin America & Caribbean Major Preliminary Coding PNG Coding_file_Papua New Guinea.xlsx Guinea Papua New East Asia & Pacific Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Paraguay.xlsx PRY Upper middle Paraguay Latin America & Caribbean income Preliminary Coding Minor Coding_file_Peru.xlsx PER Peru Latin America & Caribbean Upper middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Philippines.xlsx PHL Philippines East Asia & Pacific Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Poland.xlsx POL Poland High income: OECD Major High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Portugal.xlsx PRT Portugal High income: OECD High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Qatar.xlsx QAT Qatar High income Middle East & North Africa Major Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Romania.xlsx ROU Romania Europe & Central Asia Minor High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Rwanda.xlsx RWA Rwanda Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeNo reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Samoa.xlsx WSM Samoa East Asia & Pacific Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding SAU Coding_file_Saudi Arabia.xlsx Middle East & North Africa Saudi Arabia Major High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Senegal.xlsx SEN Senegal Sub-Saharan Africa Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Serbia.xlsx SRB Serbia Europe & Central Asia Upper middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding SLE Coding_file_Sierra Leone.xlsx Sub-Saharan Africa Sierra Leone Low incomeNo reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Singapore.xlsx SGP Singapore East Asia & Pacific No reform Preliminary Coding High income SVK Coding_file_Slovak Republic.xlsx High income: OECD Slovak Republic Minor High income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Slovenia.xlsx SVN Slovenia High income: OECD High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding SLB Coding_file_Solomon Islands.xlsx East Asia & Pacific Solomon Islands Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Somalia.xlsx SOM Somalia Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeMajor Preliminary Coding ZAF Coding_file_South Africa.xlsx Sub-Saharan Africa South Africa Noincome Upper middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Spain.xlsx ESP Spain High income: OECD High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Sri Lanka.xlsx LKA Sri Lanka South Asia Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Sudan.xlsx SDN Sudan Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeMajor Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Sweden.xlsx SWE Sweden High income: OECD No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Switzerland.xlsxCHE SwitzerlandHigh income: OECD No reform (some High income changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Tajikistan.xlsx TJK Tajikistan Europe & Central Asia Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Tanzania.xlsx TZA Tanzania Sub-Saharan Africa Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Thailand.xlsx THA Thailand East Asia & Pacific Noincome Upper middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Timor-Leste.xlsxTLS Timor-LesteEast Asia & Pacific Noincome Lower middle Preliminary reform (some Coding changes) Coding_file_Togo.xlsx TGO Togo Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeMajor Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Tonga.xlsx TON Tonga East Asia & Pacific Upper middle Noincome reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding TTO Coding_file_Trinidad and Tobago.xlsx Latin Trinidad and America & Caribbean Tobago No reform Preliminary Coding High income Coding_file_Tunisia.xlsx TUN Tunisia Lower middle Middle East & North Africa income Preliminary Coding Major Coding_file_Turkey.xlsx TUR Turkey Europe & Central Asia Minor Upper middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Uganda.xlsx UGA Uganda Sub-Saharan Africa Low income Preliminary No reform (some Coding changes) Coding_file_Ukraine.xlsx UKR Ukraine Europe & Central Asia Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding ARE Coding_file_United Arab Emirates.xlsx United ArabMiddle Emirates East & North Africa Minor High income Preliminary Coding GBR Coding_file_United Kingdom.xlsx High income: OECD United Kingdom High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding USA Coding_file_United States.xlsx High income: OECD United States High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Uruguay.xlsx URY Uruguay Latin America & Caribbean High income No reform (some changes) Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Uzbekistan.xlsx UZB Uzbekistan Europe & Central Asia Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Vanuatu.xlsx VUT Vanuatu East Asia & Pacific Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Vietnam.xlsx VNM Vietnam East Asia & Pacific Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Zambia.xlsx ZMB Zambia Sub-Saharan Africa Low incomeMajor Preliminary Coding Coding_file_Zimbabwe.xlsx ZWE Zimbabwe Sub-Saharan Africa Major Lower middle income Preliminary Coding MMR Myanmar East Asia & Pacific Noincome Lower middle reform Preliminary Coding RUS Europe & Russian Federation PPP Central Asia Noincome Upper middle reform Preliminary Coding Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q1 Q1_3_TEXTQ1_4_TEXTQ1.1_A Q1.1_B Q1.1_1_TEXT Q1.1_C Q1.1_2_TEXT Q1.1_3_TEXT regulatory 1. Does the If framework and yes, please provide specify the in 1.1 arelevant link If yes, your country to afor regulatory government–supported If yes, allow which of please framework procuring the 1.1 provide WaterPPPs? the and following Supply, Ifwebsite sectors yes, relevant theplease Sewerage, year where is legal/regulatory the of 1.1provide adoption: Energy above-mentioned the Solid the generation/transmission If Waste yes, mentioned relevant provisions: please Management regulatory regulatory legal/regulatory provide and the framework framework and irrigatio relevan provi dist is Yes regulatory The currentThe regulatory Yes framework framework governing The PPPbe can Law PPPs found Yes provides in in the Afghanistan under The following "Sectors PPP Law is comprised government Yes providesof: of Public under websites: The Private 1) PPP Presidential "Sectors Law - PPP Partnership" provides of LawPublic 2018: Decree Article under Private No. http://o 314 "Sec 6: P The Yes 1. http://atrako.gov.al/wp-content/uploads/2021/11/Ligji-Nr-125_2013-i-azhornuar-me-50_2019.pdf There are two main laws that govern Yes Pursuant Public-Private toYes Article Partnerships Pursuant 4.1 of (PPPs) the PPP Law: to Article Yesin PPPs/Concessions Albania. 4.1 of Pursuant the PPP These to laws Law, may Article arebe PPPs/Concession as4.1 awarded follows: of thefor PPP 1. 2 t La Yes regulatory The generalPublic Acquisition Yes framework Decree on Code: http://www.joradp.dz/FTP/JO-FRANCAIS/2015/F2015050.pdf PPPsNo. in Algeria Yes 04-417consists Lawthe setting No. of regulations conditions 05-12 Yesof 28 on relating Jumada public Lawton° procurement Ethania the 02-01 granting 1426 of 22 Law and Dhou of correspondin 16-09: delegation nthe conces El //w Kaada Yes The regulatory https://mep.gov.ao/legislacao framework Yes on PPPsAccording in Angola is Yes to governed article 2(2) by According of Law theno. PPP11/19, Yes to article Law, this adopted 2(2) law According applies of the on PPP 14 to May equally Law, article 2019 this to2(2) all lawpartnersh of applies the PP (hereinafter Yes In general, PPPs in Argentina are specifically Argentinian Yes According legislation regulated byto is Yes the available article 1 of Public-Private online According Law No from: 27,328, to Partnership Yes http://www.infoleg.gob.ar/ article Public-private Agreements 1 of According Law Noparticipation Law, 27,328, to article The Law 27,328 1 key of Public-private contracts Law relevant (Ley No p a 2 No Yes Procurement Generally, PPPs Yes projects Law on infrastructure at: https://www.arlis.am/DocumentView.aspx?DocID=121796 (Armenian) Pursuant in toYes Article have Armenia Pursuant been 2 (22) of the initiated Procurement toYes Article 2 (22) Law: Pursuant of Related by Government, and the Procurement to Article activities concession 2 (22)https://m the agreem offollow -Law: the P Relat Yes (1) The focus of the this analysis National Yes PPP shall be Policy on According Framework: the to Australian Yes the https://www.infrastructure.gov.au/infrastructure/ngpd/files/N state National of According New PPP South Policy, to Yes the Section Wales National (NSW). 3.1.1, According PPP Australia "for Policy, the to the purposes does Section National not of 3.1.1, have this PPP a PP Po sp "for Yes (1)are The following Thethe Federal main Yes Law on According thethat legislation Granting govern to Noof PPPs the Lawin on Concession According Austria: Concessions, Contracts to (1) Yes The the§4(1), Federal (Bundesvergabegesetz Law "this on According Law Concessions, federal on the to law Granting the Konzessions §8(1)(25), applies Law ontoConcessi of "this concess 2018 ConcessFe Yes (i) BOT are PPPs in Azerbaijan Law:regulated Yes http://e-qanun.az/framework/32612 byPursuant the Law to ofYes Article the Republic 3.1 of Pursuant the of BOT (ii)to Azerbaijan BOT Law: Yes Article on This Order: the 3.1 Law of http://e-qanun.az/framework/342 Implementation Pursuant establishes the BOT to Article the Law: This of legal Special 3.1 Law basis of the Financ for BOTin establis Yes (1) Bangladesh The main regulations applicable Yes Public-Private to According PPPs in Partnership the toYes country the PPP ActGuidelines, № include: According XVIII (1)of Bangladesh 2015 to Section Yes the PPP 3.1, Public-Private Guidelines, "unless According (hereafter, "PPP stated Act"): Section to Partnership the otherwise, https://www.ppp PPP 3.1,Guidelines, Act and№ "unless sta XV sub Yes developedYes various PPP Pursuant laws and Belarus has http://www.economy.gov.by/ru/zakondatelstvo-ru/ to regulations, Article 5, paragraph Yes Pursuant 2 toof dramaticallyYes Article improving the PPP Law, 5 of the thepublic-private country's PPP Law, Pursuant to Article public-private regulatory partnerships 5, paragraphs policy on ca partn Yes https://www.publicprocurement.be/fr/marches-publics/reglementation The following Yesbe based analysis will According on the federal to No Concession According theregulations. PPPsto Law, in Yes concessions the Belgium Concession According contracts are Law,apply to primarily concessions regulated theto Concession work contracts anyunder the and Law Yes Thethe Benin adopted PPPLaw Law: Yes No. 2016-24 According https://www.droit-afrique.com/uploads/Benin-Loi-2016-24-cadre-juridique-ppp.pdf of June 28th, to Yes 2017 Art.3 the of which According PPP specifically Law, Yes toa Art.3 PPP can of the be regulates According concluded PPP Public Law,Private toain Art.3 PPP all can Partnerships sectors of the be conclud PPP of econ Law (he Yes PPP Law: http://mp.ks.gov.ba/sites/mp.ks.gov.ba/files/zakon_o_javno-privatnom_partnerstvu_eng.pdf Bosnia and Herzegovina (BiH) currently Yes lacksto Pursuant Public-Private Yes Article 2 ofPursuant the Partnerships SarajevoArticle PPP toYes Law: (PPP) 2 legislation, of(1) Pursuant the Public-Private necessitating to Article A Sarajevo 2 PPP Law: Partnership of the (1) the A Saraje Publi (h establi Yes (1)are The following the main Yes regulations According http://www.ppadb.co.bw; applicable (2) https://www.finance.gov.bw; to Yes the PPPPolicy, toPPP contracts ThereSection is no in Botswana: explicit 3.16, Yes (3) Public <...> prohibition 1. it Public Procurement is envisaged There no isto Procurement conducting explicit that and prohibition projects Asset PPP Act Dispos projec entere in to th Yes http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/LEIS/L8987cons.htm Firstly, it is important Yes to Brazilianto clarify thatPursuant regulatory Yes Article 2 framework Paragraph Pursuant4defines of to http://www.planalto.gov.br/ccivil_03/_ato2 Article the PPP Yes three 2 Paragraph Law, Pursuant types conclusion theof concessions: 4 ofArticle to the PPP of 2aLaw, common, Public thePriv Paragraph 4a con Yes The The main acts regulating Concessions Yes PPPs Law isArticle available in Bulgaria are 7 of on the Nothe theConcession Concession website According Law of the Law:and Ministry (1) to Yes Athe construction EU Publicof Procurement Regional Concessions Annexconcession No. Development Act. Directive, 2 of 1.the is A newpublic-private Article and aConcession Concessio Public 12(1), W La Yes www.gouvernement.gov.bf/ The regulatory Yes governing framework There PPPs http://www.arcop.bf/ is in nothing Burkina Yes inFaso the applicable There is comprised is nothing legislation Yes of the in the suggesting applicable There is following: Lnothing - aw that legislation n.there 032-2021/AN in the aapplicable sector ofth issuggesting 2t Yes No website PPPs are regulated by Law Yes available Art. n 1/14 of April 3 of 27th the 2015 PPP Law Yes related provides Art. to3the the ofthat general Yes partnership PPP Law provides Art. regime of 3 public ofthat the contracts private may partnership PPPrelate Law partnership provides incontract wholeth o co Yes PPP Law: https://www.ppp.mef.gov.kh/fileadmin/user_upload/Law_of_PPP_EN.pdf The Royal Government of Cambodia Yes ("RGC") Article 8 of has the Yes Law on Article Public-Private promulgated the8 Law of the Yes onLaw Public-Private on Article Public-Private Partnerships 8 stipulates Partnership of thePartnerships that Law"eligible (hereinafter on Public-Priv sectot stipul Yes http://www.ppp-cameroun.cm/index.php?page=textes-et-lois; PPPs in Cameroon Yes are currently governed Art. 2 of by Law PPP Yes Law No. 2006/012 (“LawArt. No.22006/012 of of PPP Yes Law December of http://www.ppp-cameroun.cm/sites/de (“Law December 29,Art. 2006, No.22006/012 29, of enacting PPP 2006, Lawof enacting the("Law December general No. theregul gene 29, 2 2006 Yes Federalconcerning The law in Canada Yes Acts: http://lois.justice.gc.ca/eng/ competitive There are procurement/tendering noYes regulatoryThere Federal barriers P3 are Screening to has no Yes undertaking regulatory been Guides: in development barriers PPPs There https://www.pppcouncil.ca/we are in to Canada nosince undertaking regulatory at 1981 the and federal barriers PPPs is bas inle C t Yes The PPPs in Chad PPP are Ordinance Yes by the governed : https://www.google.com/url?sa=t&rct=j&esrc=s&source=appssearch&uact=8&cd following Article 6 of regulations: Yes Ordinance the - the Article Ordinance define the 6 of the Yes No. public-private PPP Ordinance 06/PR /2017 partnership Article define 6bearing of thethe PPP Legal contract public-private Ordinance as a Regime de fix of P Yes https://concesiones.mop.gob.cl/Paginas/default.aspx; The following Yes analysis focused on infrastructure According toYes awarded article 87 by According of decree https://www.leychile.cl/Navegar?idNorma=161 with to Yes article the Ministry force of Public 87 ofAccording law ofWorks decree No. (the 850/1997, with to article Organic force the 87 of LawConcessio law of ofNo. the8M decree Yes been PPP There have China Public practice Yes Private inPartnership Article China 4(12) since Center, 1980s, Yes of the "China Guiding Article PPP featuring BOTs, Opinions Center", 4(12) concessions Yes of of "Policies" the theGuiding MOF, and Article NDRC other section: Opinions 4(12) and cooperation http://www.cpppf.org of of the the the People's MOF, forms Guiding Bank Opini betw NDRC o Yes PPPs: https://www.dnp.gov.co/programas/participaci%C3%B3n-privada-%20y-en-proyectos-de-infrae PPPs in Colombia Yes are regulated the following by Article 3 of the Yes laws Law PPPand regulations: that regulates Article No 3 of the a) Law PPP its scope Lawn/a that 1508/ 2012 of application regulates “PPP Law� its scope (including of appli considering ge it mo Yes PPPs in Democratic http://www.armp-rdc.org/index.php/fr/lois/file/loi-no-18-016-du-09-juillet-2018-relative-au-partenar Republic Yes of Congo Article are3 of the regulated Yes PPP byLaw the provides following: Article - the Yes Law 3 ofthat depending PPP No.Law 18/016 provides onof Articlethe 309 of that July particularity the depending PPP 2018 on Law Public-Pr provides and condi on the Yes PPPs Most of theAll Laws in Congo and Yes regulation take the can form Art. 2 beof of the found a public Yes PPon service the provides code Art. Ministry concession 2 of of that the Economy's “Public PP contract Yes codeservice website provides and Art.will 2 of delegation� :that be https://economie.gouv.c the therefore “Public PP code areservice the contracts provides object delega by o tha Yes http://presidencia.go.cr/cargas/reglamentoapp.pdf; The Costa Rican Yes has issued Government Pursuant a Regulation toYes article with 2 of Pursuant a specific the http://www.pgrweb.go.cr/scij/ PPP to Regulation, regulatory Yes article 2 public of framework Pursuant the private to for partnership article PPP Regulation, procuring 2 public of PPP´s the contracts privat PPP undR Yes http://www.ppp.gouv.ci/reglementation.html The PPP regulatory Yes framework Art.7 in Côte d’Ivoire of PPPYes consists Decree No. of Art.7 2018-358 the of PPP following of Yes Decree March laws and No. 29, regulations: 2018-358 2018 Art.7 PPPof ofrelating Decree - Decree March to Public No. 29, No. 2018 Private 2018-3 rel 2018-358P Yes https://investcroatia.gov.hr/jpp/institucionalni-okvir; PPPs in Croatia Yes may take Article on different forms8, in Paragraph Yes accordance The with 1 of Concession the Concession European https://www.zakon.hr/z/157/Zakon-o-koncesijam Yes Union Act Act prescribes Directives Article (Article 8, 8, Paragraph for Paragraph regarding which1) activities 1 this prescribes ofmatter. the a con fo F Conc Yes The main laws (1) governing Act № 134/2016 Yes PPPs inColl. According the Czech Public Republic Procurement to Yes are as the PublicAct: According Procurement follows: https://www.zakonyprolidi.cz/cs/2016-134/zneni-20 (1) to Yes Act the Act, № §174(2)(a), 134/2016 Public Procurement Coll. 'an to According award Public the Act,of Public Procurement §174(2)(a), a works Procurem ‘an concA Yes (1) Directive The main regulations Yes 2014/23/EU applicable PPP to The ofEU contracts the Concessions No include: European Parliament Directive According (1) Directive does andto Yes of not 2014/23/EU the the contain EU Council: Concessions an ofhttps://eur-lex.europa.eu/leg explicit the European According to Directive, prohibition the EU art. Concessions on 12(1), carryin Parliament an "th Yes https://unite-ppp-djibouti.com/cadre-juridique/ PPPs in Djibouti Yes by the are governed PPP Lawto According No. Yes Art.3.3 2017-186 the ofPPP 29 May Law, of According Yes to 2017 Art.3.3 (Law on No. of According 2017-186 the PPP Law, of to 29 public-private partnerships, Art.3.3 (Law May of No. 2017), 2017-186 the and PPP a PPP La its Yes https://dgapp.gob.do/categorias/marco-legal/ PPPs in Dominican Yes are subject Republic to2the Article of the Yes following PPP Regulations, Article laws and2 of regarding the regulations: Yes PPP Scope Regulations, (i) Law Article ofNo. application, of regarding theon 247-20 PPPPublic states: Scope Regulations, "This of appl Rer Private-P Yes http://www.asambleanacional.gob.ec/es/leyes-aprobadas PPPs in Ecuador Yes are regulated by: (1) Article 13 of No Ecuadorian the Republic PPP Law n/a states: Object No Constitution , Constitución of delegated n/a demanagement la Republica del Ecuador, contracts. T Yes Law no. 67 of https://www.mof.gov.eg/ar/posts/regulations/ 2010 Regulating Yes Participation the The Yes First Article of the (Issuing Private The First Sector Article) Article of in PPP YesInfrastructure Law (Issuing The provides Article) First Projects, forof Article its PPP general Services Law (Issuing application and Article) Publi provides foro Yes 1) PPP Law: The PPP regulatory framework Yes https://www.asamblea.gob.sv/sites/default/files/documents/decretos/311634B4-FE3A-4A Article in El Salvador 3 ofincludes the No PPP the LawAccording Public-Private that defines to Yes article Partnerships the scope 3 letter Article of application Law, d) 3 PPP of Decree the Lawof PPPs PPPthe 379 Law can Law of that 2013, only and be Le in defi Yes specific There is no There framework are Yes no links to for regulations No PPPs explicit in Eritrea. exemption Yes Consequently, online. No of the explicit the exemption Yes procurement transport is No sector of provided. the guidelines explicit Water Supply, apply. Sewerage, exemption S of the Ene Yes (1) Public Procurement The main regulations Yes to PPPs related Act: The inPublic https://www.riigiteataja.ee/en/eli/ee/505092017003/consolide/current; Estonia Procurement include the No Act following: does to According 1. not Yes the Public explicitly Procurement According prohibit using EU Concessions to Act Directive, the with concessions Public the Article Procurem effective contr (2 12(1), Yes https://chilot.me/wp-content/uploads/2018/10/Proclamation-No.-1076-2018-Public-Private-Partnersh The regulatory Yes for Ethiopia framework Pursuant comprises toYes article a proper Pursuant 4 (1) of the PPP PPP to Law, that Yes Proclamation, article is, the 4 (1) PPP Pursuant regarding the PPP to Proclamation, article scope ofProclamation 1076/2018 4of (1) of regard the (here PP application Yes Act on Public PPP arrangements have been YesContracts carried The and out Concessions Actin practice on No in Public (1397/2016)http://www.finlex.fi/fi/laki/alkup/2016/20161397 Contracts Finland n/a and the Yes Act on Public Concessions The of Contracts Act on entities operating Public and Contracts in the water, and Concessions (1C Yes https://www.legifrance.gouv.fr In France, two Yes categories Article of contracts are L considered 1212-3 Yes of as the Public Article PPPs Acquisition L 1212-3 Yes according to of the Code definition the Article provides Public Lof Acquisition 1212-3 for theacquisition World ofCode the Bank: Public contract conce Acq provides Yes The regulatory PPPframework ordinance: Yes for https://www.droit-afrique.com/uploads/Gabon-Ordonnance-2015-22-PPP.pdf in Gabon is PPPsAccording to Yes made Art. 4out of the According of the PPPPPP Ordinance to Ordinance Yes Art. 4(Ordinance of No. the According 009/PR/2016 PPP No. to 009/PR/2016 Art.of Ordinance 4 11 (Ordinance of the February Ratificati of PPP 11No Fe 2 Or Yes www.matsne.gov.ge The Parliament of Georgia Yes adopted https:// Pursuant a new law ppp.gov.ge/en/resources/laws/ toYes on Article 6 of Public Private Pursuant the PPP Partnership Law: toYes Article 1. Public ("PPP 6 of and Pursuant theprivate PPP Law") on Law: to 4cooperation May Article 1. Public 2018, 6 of and the may which private PPP be cam L c Yes (1) Act Against The main regulations Yes Restraints applicable PPPs to According on Competition in Germany to Nothe PPA, include (GWB), Part The the IV, PPA, Partfollowing: §102(4), IV: §101 http://www.gesetze-im-internet.de/gwb/inde Yescontains (1) ActAccording "sector Against activities a definition Restraints in tothe of theconcession field PPA, onof Competitio Part IV, granto §10 transport Yes (1) The Public PPPs are regulated Yes under Private the Public Section Private 2(1) PartnershipPartnership Act, Yes of the 2020PPP (Act Act, Section Act2020 provides 2(1) (Act 1039): https://mofep.gov.gh/sites/default/files/acts/P Yes of 1039) that PPP thethe which Act Section Actapplies provides came into 2(1) toof all effect that the contracting PPP the onAct 29th Act provid autho Dece applies Yes http://www.sdit.mnec.gr/sites/default/files/legislation/Law_-_PPP_3389-_English_final.pdf PPPs are governed Yes by Law in Greece 3389/2005 Article 2, paragraph No 1 of According (Government PPP Law to theGazette A Yes the provides 232/22.09.2005) EU Concessions There that the arescope Directive, no on Partnerships specific of the Article Law legal provis includ 12(1), betwee Yes https://anadie.gob.gt/marco-legal/ PPPs in Guatemala regulated by are Yes According the Decree to Noarticle No 2 of 16-2010 the n/a PPP that approves Law, YesThis the Law Law shall of Partnerships apply According toto article for 2Economic alliance contracts of In the PPP Yes https://www.invest.gov.gn/page/cadre-juridique-et-fiscal?onglet=essentiel-sur-les-ppp PPPs in Guinea Yes by the are regulated Law No 0032/2017/AN According to Yes Art.3.4 of According the ofPPP the Law, 4thYes to Art.3.4 "[t]his of July 2017 Law of According the applies onPPP Public-Private to toall Law, "[t]his Art.3.4 economic Partnerships Law of the applies and PPP La soct ( Yes PPPs in Haiti www.cnmp.gouv.ht are divided Yes between institutional Yes PPPs A draft of the lawand creating contractual Pursuant to PPPs. the PPP unit article Yes The (the 4 following al. Directorate Pursuant 14 of theto General PParticle Law, research will for a focus al. Partnership 14 on 4 public servic of the Yes https://sapp.gob.hn/ The Public-Private Yes Partnership Article (PPP) regulatory 4 of the Yes framework regulates in Honduras PPP lawArticle the Yes 4 ofthe scope includes PPP law ofArticle the the regulates following law ofthe the laws scope 4 withoutPPP establishing and law the regulates law anyw of regulation Yes The Public The legal framework inProcurement Yes Hungary allows Actthe in the Accordingprocurement to No Hungarian of language According Article 6 of Public-Private the isto Publicavailable Yes Procurement thePartnerships EU Concessions at http://njt.hu/cgi_bin/njt_doc.cgi? Act: According (PPPs). (1) For Directive, to Article In thethe purposes event, 6 Article of the 12(1), of if the thig Publ Yes General The regulatory framework Financial Yes governing RulesThePPPs PPP 2017 are in Guidelines India Yes shall available at: provides beThe focused PPP http://www.finmin.nic.in/the_ministry/dept_expenditur that Guidelines onitYes applies the federal to "Projects The regulatory PPP provides Guidelines thatof itframework. all applies provides to costing sectors States that Rs. cao "Projects Yes (1) Presidential The legal framework for Yes PPP projects According Regulation № in Indonesia 38 of to Yes 2015: the Regulation https://jdih.kemenkeu.go.id/fullText/2015/38TAHUN2015PE consists of:(1) on According Presidential PPPs, to Yesart. the Regulation 5Regulation (1), According "infrastructure on№ to PPPs, 38the of art. that 2015 Regulation can "About 5 (1), be procu on Coo P "infrastru Yes 1) By-Law Several regulations re govern Yes Manner PPPs in Iran. Partnership ofThe Private The main Yes Sector betweenParticipation Executive instrument The regulating Private Order Bodies Yes Sector PPPs took and Participation is a Private the general TheRules Private Sector Order of Procedure Sector stance Performance took in and Participation did a general on notthe expres ofsta Pr ParO Yes http://www.iraq-lg-law.org/ar/webfm_send/1543 PPPs were originally Yes governed by Iraqi Instructions Yes Civil LawNo. no.2 40 2014 ofof 1951 Instructions applies http://investpromo.gov.iq/wp-content/uploads/2013 (articles to Yes No. all 891-899) 2 types of 2014 Instructions ofand projects, applies Articleto and 15all of No. there 2 types the of 2014 is ofno projects applies expre State-Owne Yes http://ppp.gov.ie/key-documents/legislation/ The PPP framework Yes in Ireland Article consists of the 3 offollowing: the No PPP Act, The regarding State Authorities (i) According Public Yes to the EU private Concession Act Article 2002,3 aka of 2017, the partnershipPublic arrangements, PPP Chapter Act, 2, regarding Private Partne bro regulat Yes Mandatory PPPs in Israel especiallyYes Tenders in their Law: procurement The general https://www.mr.gov.il/Information/Training%20materials/Mandatory%20Ten mainly Yes scopefall under The of the general the scope MandatoryYes scope Tenders of the of the Law The Mandatory applies general Mandatory to Tenders scope Tenders the different of Lawthe Law No. Mandat sector 5752- applie Yes PPPs in Italy are governed Yesby the following Article 10 https://www.gazzettaufficiale.it/dettaglio/codici/contrattiPubblici instruments: of Nothe Public Legislative - According ContractsDecree Code to Yes the EUhttps://www.anticorruzione.it/-/part no. 50Article Concessions of 18 April 10 of Directive, 2016 the Public implementing 12(1), "th art.Contracts D Yes (1) Policy and The main regulations Yes applicable Institutional to The PPPsPPP Framework in the Policy Yes country for the include: doesn't The provide PPP (1)an Implementation Policy Policy exhaustive Yes doesn't and of aInstitutional list The provide of PPP sectors an Public-Private Policy Framework exhaustive Partnership ordoesn't sector-specific forprovide Program the list Impl pr an of secto Yes In projects In Japan, PPP https://www8.cao.go.jp/pfi/en/laws/laws.html; Yesmainly carried general: are The Road outAct through Yesrestricts regulatory There the the are of ability no framework Yes the restrictions http://www8.cao.go.jp/pfi/index.html privatecalled There sector regarding Private are to no manage sectors. Finance restrictions and In Initiative operate regardin (Jap (“P ro particular, Yes https://www.pppu.gov.jo/En/Pages/PPP_Law The framework YesPPPs in Jordan governing 3 comprised Article is of the Yes PPP Law of:1/ Article provides 3 ofthat the Yes PPP PPP projects The Public-PrivateLaw Partnership Article provides aims 3 of to that the contribute PPP PPP Projects Law projects Law to provides (17) for the "[. aimsth Yes 1. PPP The main laws that Law: regulate Yes http://adilet.zan.kz/rus/docs/Z1500000379, PPPs in Kazakhstan According to Yes are Article Law of 6No. According the 379-V PPPOn 2. to Law, Yes Public Concession Article PPPPrivate 6 of According could the be Partnership, Law:PPP implemented http://adilet.zan.kz/rus/do Law, to Article PPP 2015in 6 (hereinafte of all the could be PPP impl sectors Yes The The following PPP ActYes legislative 2021 framework Section can begoverns found4(1) at: PPPs Yes http://kenyalaw.org:8181/exist/kenyalex/actview.xql?actid=No.%20 in Kenya, of the PPP Section Act along stipulates 4(1)Yes with of enabling that the PPP Act Section Act shall stipulates 4(1) theregulations and apply ofthat to legislation the PPP the Act every Act project that shall stipul ag a fac Yes https://www.kdi.re.kr/kdi_eng/kdicenter/pimac_ppp-low.jsp The regulatory Yes for PPPsArticle framework 2, section in Korea includes Yes 1the of the Act Article on Public-Private PPP 2, section Act Yes 1 of enumeratesPartnerships the Article various2, types PPP Act in section enumerates Infrastructure, of 'infrastructure' 1 of the various PPP Act Act n a ty Yes PPP Law: The Public-Private Partnerships https://gzk.rks-gov.net/ActDocumentDetail.aspx?ActID=2784 Yes Law No. 04/L-045 Pursuant Article toYes (hereinafter 2 (1) Pursuant thePPP of the "PPP toYes Article Law, Law") 2is the (1) provisions the Pursuant of Public main the PPP Procurement of legislative tothis Article Law,law the 2 act shall (1) provisions Law: that govern of the estab PP oP https:/ Yes PPP Law PPPs are governed and by aYes specific Executive Article Regulation: regulatory1(1) framework Yes of http://www.kapp.gov.kw/en/Legislation in Kuwait. the PPP Article Law provides 1(1) The No regulations ofthe thegeneral PPP Law While thatprovides fall PPP definition Article under Guidebook: of the 1(1) a this PPP general of the framework project http://www PPP definitio in Laww in Yes The main Law 1. http://www.ppp.gov.kg/upload/file/KG_PPP_law_ENG.pdf regulating Yes Pursuant PPP in the toYes Kyrgyz Republic Article is2(1) thePursuant of the Law ofPPP the toYes Law, Kyrgyz Article 2. PPP http://cbd.minjust.gov.kg/act/view/ru- Republic, 2(1) applies Pursuant of the toPPP "On to public-private Law, Article PPP infrastructure 2(1) applies facilities partnersh of the an in toPP Yes 1) PPP Decree: Lao PDR introduced Yes https://investlaos.gov.la/wp-content/uploads/formidable/18/PPP_Decree_No.624.Gov a reform Pursuant to the PPP regulatory toYes article 3 (1)Pursuant framework with of the to Procurement the Yes article Public Private Regulations, Pursuant 3 (1) Partnerships of the to Procurement regarding articleNo. 3 (1) Regulations 624/GOV of the scope Prd of app Yes PPPframework The regulatory Law: https://likumi.lv/doc.php?id=194597 Yes on PPPsThe in Latvia PPP lawYes does mainly comprises not define The PPPPPP Regulation: specific the law Yes does following areas https://likumi.lv/ta/en/en/id/199083-p not regulations: of define application. The PPP specific I)law The Pursuant does Law areas not onof to Public-Priva define application Article 1o spec Yes (1) regulating The main laws № PPP LawYes PPPs 48/2017: in Lebanon www.hcp.gov.lb include: According to Yes the PPP (1) PPP (currently Law, There Law №not is2(2), art. no 48/2017 working); Yes explicit "contrary approved (2) prohibition to According any by Public Procurement other the to to Parliament text, conduct the PPP the PPP Law: Law, and provisions projects https://l art. publis o i 2(2 Yes https://www.e-tar.lt/portal/lt/legalAct/425fccc05b2d11e79198ffdb108a3753 The Concessions Yes Law, as revised on May 30, Article 6 of 2019, the No Concessions Pursuant will serve the to as Law provides Yes main Article legal9basis ofArticle the cases inConcessions whenLithuania 6concessions https://e-seimas.lrs.lt/po of thefor Concessions Law, this arewater case notstudy allow secto Law Yes The framework http://www.mef.gov.mg/page_personnalisee/index/menu/21 governing YesPPPs in Madagascar Article 3 of the is mainly Yes PPP Law comprised Article (Law 2015-039 ofthe 3 of thePPP Yes on Law February The following: (Law - L Energy 3, aw 2015-039 2015-039 2016) Law N° on addressing on 2017-020 February adopt PPPsthe3, Ge on 2t Yes Malawi's PPP The main regulations Yes applicable regulations to According PPPs andin documents the toYes country the PPPinclude: can be Policy, According found Section (1) at to Public-Private Yes the the 5.1, website "it is PPP Policy, Government’s According Partnership of the Section PPPto Commission: Act 5.1, the intention PPP "it 23 No. isPolicy, Governme of to 20 encou Sect May https:// Yes http://www.ukas.gov.my The Malaysian Yes has been government According http://www.treasury.gov.my encouraging to Yes Section 2.0 According of the PPPs actively Public since Yes to 1991. Section Private The2.0 Partnership According ofscheme PPP to Guidelines, was the Public Section Private officially Partnershi 2.0 of unveiled PPP invol the P Yes http://pppmali.org The PPP regulatory Yes framework in Mali Art. is made 7 of theYes of PPP Law the Law states Art. No. 7that of the PPP 2016-061 Yes PPP projects of Law December are Art.identified states 7that 30, of the PPP 2016PPP by projects related the Lawcontracting states are to identif that Public Pa Yes (1) In Mauritius, PPPA both - http://bot.govmu.org/English/Documents/Public%20Private%20Partnership%20Act%2025% Yes public-private partnership Pursuant toYes article and 2 of Pursuant the PPP Law, toYes Build-Operate-Transferarticle "Public-private Contracts 2 of Pursuant (“BOT�) the partnership PPP to Law, meet article "Public-private our agreement" 2study’s of the PPP part meL defin Yes All Partnerships Public-Private Yes legislation in in general Mexico According are specifically to is availableYes on articleupdated 2 of its regulated According theversion PPP by the Law, to Yes at: Public-Private article http://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBibl 2 of projects According are theclassified PPP Law, Partnerships to article as projects PPP Law 2whenever (Ley ofarede the PPP Asoth classi Yes 1. PPP Law The main legislations governing - Yes http://lex.justice.md/md/328990/ Pursuant Moldova's PPP toYes Article sector 17 are Pursuant as paragraph 2. follows: Concessions to (2) 1) Article of YesLaw the Law 17 PPP on- http://lex.justice.md/md/376821% Public-Private paragraph Pursuant Law: "The (2) to subject Article of Partnership matter PPP the17 paragraph Law: No. of a 179 pu "Th Yes (1)are The following the State Policy main Yes on Public According Private regulations that apply Partnership: to Yes toPPP the PPPs Policy, https://www.legalinfo.mnnex/?lawid=6653; According in Mongolia: art. 4.1.2, Yes to (1) the"partnerships State PPP Policy, According Policy on may art.Public 4.1.2 to bethe and of Private the PPP 4.1.5, (2) following Policy, Partnershi Law "partne on art. Co4 typ Yes (1) Law on The main legislative Public-Private Yes provisions According pertaining Partnership: to Public-Private to Yes https://me.propisi.net/zakon-o-javno-privatnom-partnerstvu/; the According PPP Law, Article 13, to Yes Partnerships the paragraph (PPPs) PPP in According Montenegro 1,Article Law, 13, to the "in accordance include paragraph PPP with the Law,1, followin the "in law, ac (2 Article Yes regulatory Yes framework Article on PPPs 1 in of Morocco PPP The generalhttp://www.sgg.gov.ma/BO/bo_fr/2015/BO_6332_Fr.pdf Yes Law and consists Article its implementing 1 the of ofhttp://www.sgg.gov.ma/BO/bo_fr/2015/BO_ PPP Yes following: Law and PPP - Article Decree Law No. 1asof 86-12 amended PPP of its implementingLaw24 PPP and don't December itsmenti imple Decree 2 as Yes https://docs.google.com/viewer?a=v&pid=sites&srcid=bWFyY2hlcy1wdWJsaWNzLWFmcmlxdWUuY29 Public Private Partnership YesContracts As per in article Yes Mozambique3 of are PPPregulated As per Law (Law article by 15/2011) (1) Yes3Law of PPP the no.Law PPP As 15/2011 per (Law regulatory article 15/2011) (related 3 framework of to PPP the large PPP Law is (Law regula scale p1 app Yes The regulatory http://ppmo.gov.np/acts_and_regulations; framework Yes for PPPsThe in Nepal is Yes comprised PPP Policy provides http://www.investnepal.gov.np; of The inthe section PPP following Policy 1.1 Yes that provides texts: development The in (i) section PPP Public https://ibn.gov.np/resour Policy Private of 1.1 that essential provides Partnership development public in section and infra Yes Public The regulatory framework Procurement Yes for procurement Act 2012 is There --> no is outlined No provision http://wetten.overheid.nl/BWBR0032203/2016-07-01 in that Article the would Procurement 2a.20 determine Yes of the Act the 2012 There applicability Public Procurement (Aanbestedingswet is no provision of Law PPPs DBFMO that in tothe awould Standa sector Conc 2012), ad Yes (1) Government The main regulations Yes Rules applicable toof In public-private the absence Sourcing. Yes Rules partnerships of for an explicit planning There prohibition are your (PPPs) Yes in noprocurement, sector Newin Zealand specific the There existing approaching include provisions are PPP-related nothe sector regulating following: the specific market legislation, (1) provi and Go where c c Yes (1) Law N The PPP regulatory framework 935 Yes"Public-Private in Nicaragua Article 2 of Partnership is the Yes mainly Law": Law, PPPcomprised Article regarding http://www.lagaceta.gob.ni/gaceta-191-miercoles-12 by: 2 ofi) the Yes Scope the PPP “Public Law, of Aplication, Article Private regarding 2 of Association states: Scope the PPP This of Law, Law Law� Aplication, regardin is (Law Ns appli Yes The legalmeet 2 types of contracts framework Yesthe study’s not Art.definition 2 of the available Yes online. PPP of PPPs: Public-Private Art. 2 of The Law provides: the PPP Yes provisions Partnership Law provides: Art. ofcontracts this 2 of The theshall Law PPP and provisions Delegation apply Law provides: to of all thissecto of Pu Th Law Yes Infrastructure Nigeria operates Yes a federal Concession system of TheRegulatory ICRC Act Yes government,provides Commission thus, both its The federal (ICRC ICRCof scope Act Act): and application Yes provides state http://ppptoolkit.icrc.gov.ng/ laws its where: Theimpact ICRC scope"1. of Act and -application provides apply (1) As from to Bureau PPP where: the its scope projec comm of "1o P Yes The legal framework http://www.economy.gov.mk/page/javno-privatno-partnerstvo for Yes public-private partnerships Article 5 of the Yes PPP in the Law Republic Article establishes 5 of ofthe Yes North thePPP different Macedonia Law Article establishes qualities consists 5 and the of the of PPP forms different the Law of establish aqualitie public following: ( Yes (1) applicable The main laws Yes Public Private to PPPs Partnership Section in Pakistan Authority 1(4) at Yes of the Act federal the PPP of 2017: Section Act level provides include https://p3a.gov.pk/laws/PPPA%20act.pdf; 1(4)Yes of that the thethe PPPPPP Section ActAct following: provides 1) applies Public 1(4) ofPrivate to the that all the PPPPartnership PPP Act kinds (2) of Act provid proj ap Publ Yes Website The PPP Regime wasof created the Yes PPP Panama Article inUnit (PPPbyNational 1 Law of the 93PPP Yes Secretariat/Secretaría of September Regulations Article 1 19, regarding of the 2019 Yes Nacional PPP (hereinafter Scope Regulations Article de ofAPP Application PPP- 1 of regarding SNAPP): Law), the PPP regulated states: Scope https://snapp. Regulations "[...] of by With Exe r Appli Yes PPP Act: The Public Private http://www.treasury.gov.pg/html/legislation/files/acts/2014/Public.Private.Partnership.(PPP) Yes Partnership According Act of 2014 (hereinafter to Yes Schedule 2 According “PPP Act�) of was to the PPPYes Act, passed Scheduleon2According 2of September the PPP infrastructure" includes, toAct, Schedule 2014 without by the 2 ofPNG limitat the PP infrastructure" Pi Yes Regulatory The primary regulatoryframework Yes frameworkprovided The for Public PPP Law by: Private Yes http://app.gov.py/marco-legal/ enunciatesThe thePPP possible Partnerships Law Yes (PPPs) enunciates projects in Paraguay http://snip.hacienda.gov.py/Snip_W that The the PPP can is constituted be Law possible developed enunciates projects by the that the followin under poss the can b Yes https://www.mef.gob.pe/es/asociaciones-publico-privadas/normativa The Peruvian PPP regulatory Yes framework Articleis 20 of Yes the mainly composed PPP Law Article by the and Article 20 of Legislative Yes the 29.3 PPPof Law Decree the Article PPP and1362 Article 20 of("PPP the 29.3 Regulation:PPP Law"), PPPs of Law thepublishe PPP and can Reg Art be us Yes Article Section 20, The BOTII of andthe IRR Yes Philippine are available Section Constitution on: 2.3https://ppp.gov.ph/ppp-program/legal-and-regulatory-frameworks/ Yes of the 2022 states Section Revised that "The BOT 2.3 State Yes ofIRR recognizes the defines 2022Section Revised the theeligible 2.3 BOT indispensable ofIRR types thedefines 2022 of role projects the of the elig Revised p B asP Yes 1. PPP Act: Poland is a country thathttps://www.ppp.gov.pl/file.php?i=przegladarka-plikow/Ustawa-o-PPP-EN-opublikowana-1 Yes follows the Article civil law 2(4) tradition. Yes of the PPP TheArticle legal Act framework 2 item contains Yes a4 broad ofin the Poland definition Act Article on regarding 2 Public-Private of item the 4 term public-private of the "project", Partnership PPP Act part wh co Yes The first law expressly PPP Law (DLYes 111/2012): governing PPPs According http://www.utap.pt/Publicacoes_utap/0270202713.pdf was Decree-law No to 86/2003, article 2 n/a (3) of the which PPP Yes Law, establishedAccording the general this statute to Public applies article regime to all Contracts 2 partnerships of (3)aof the PPP aw P Code Yes PPPframework The regulatory Yes governing The Law: https://www.almeezan.qa/LawPage.aspx?id=8347&language=ar PPPs PPPin Qatar Law does Yes is not comprised explicitly The PPP of:restrict (1) LawYes Law does no. not certain 12/2020 explicitly The sectors PPP Regulating ; andrestrict from Tenders Law does itscertain scope Public not Regulations: of explicitly sectors Private applica h r f P Yes Law 100/2016: In 2016, Romania Yes http://anap.gov.ro/web/1715-2/ transposed Section 45.23 the European directives Noof Appendix on public According Law 1 of 98/2016: the toYes procurement Concession thehttp://anap.gov.ro/web/legea-nr-98201 EUinto Concessions Law national includes Article legislation Directive, 5 of thethe PPP GEO Article by the provides 12(1), follow construction of Yes Website PPPs in Rwanda down Yes are regulated Pursuant by Law Nº 14/2016 toYes article 5 of Pursuant the PPP of 02/05/2016 Law, toYes article governing the public potential 5 of Pursuant the private PPP sectors partnerships to article Law, the for PPPs potential 5 of in (hereinafte infrastruc the secto PPP L Yes specific There is no The legalregulatory framework Yes regarding framework Section governing K.1.1.2. Public YesProcurement the Treasury ofPPPs in Samoa. can Section K.1.1.2. Instructions be PPPs Yes found of arethe here: rather states Treasury Section https://www.mof.gov.ws/servic currently thatK.1.1.2. Instructions the Instructions procured of the states Treasury using that the apply In tot Yes NCP PPPs in Saudi website Arabia Yes are currently and document regulated The regulatory repository Yes and framework https://www.ncp.gov.sa/en/Pages/NCP-In-Brief.aspx procured under The governing regulatory the Private Yes PPPs framework Sector in Saudi The Participation regulatory Arabia does governing PPPs framework (PSP) not in1) explicitly Saudi Thegovern Arab Priva framework ex Yes In Senegal two PPPcategories Law:http://www.armp.sn/images/Lois/Loi_2021-23_du_2_mars_2021_relative_aux_contrats_de_ Yesof contracts Article are2 of the considered Yes PPPas Law PPP provides according Article the Notoits 2 ofthat PPP the provisions Law World Article provides Bank2 of definition: apply the to all that PPP itssectors provisions Law Delegation of econ app o provides Yes (1) PPP and Serbia has developed Concession comprehensive aYes Law: According regulatory http://demo.paragraf.rs/WebParagrafDemo/?did=365439; to Yes the PPP Law, framework According Chapter that governs to Yes II, the Part PPP Public-Private Law, According 3, section Chapter 3.2, Partnerships art. to II,the Part 11,PPP "a (2) 3,concession Law, (PPPs). Decree Chapte section This on m 3.2, Yes Public The PPP Act, which Private governs YesPartnership Pursuant the facilitation, Act (2014), conclusion, toYes Section 2and of hereinafter Pursuant the implementation PPP PPP Act to Act, Yes (http://ppp.gov.sl/admin/images/pages/Pub Section the only 2 PPPs, of of sectors Pursuant thewas PPP into Act, which passed Section the by PPPs the only 2 of are sectors governme the exclude PPP in Yes Law in Singapore Yes http://www.mof.gov.sg/Portals/0/Policies/ProcurementProcess/PPPHandbook2012.pd There is no PPP Handbook: Pursuanthowever currently, Section toYes guidelines 1.5.1 Pursuant of the for PPP toYes Section PPPs have been Manual, PPP 1.5.1 Pursuant written of isthe an alternative to by PPP the Manual, Section Ministry 1.5.1 method PPP of isthe of to anth FinaP a Yes No separate regulatory (1) Yes framework Act № 343/2015 Coll. According is on explicitly Publictodedicated Procurement: §9(6) of the Yes According to Public PPPs https://www.slov-lex.sk/pravne-predpisy/SK/ZZ/2015 inProcurement the to Yes Slovak §6(4) ofRepublic. the Act, According Public "activities PPP to Procurement contracts the in the Article are Act, I,usually First "activ transportatiPa Yes (1) Certain The main legislative Concession Yes framework governing Contracts The Concessions the No Act: relationships http://www.pisrs.si/Pis.web/pregledPredpisa?sop=2019-01-0287 Act does According in the not contain field to Yes ofexplicit PPPs inprovisions The Slovenia Constitution of Concessions the Republic includes on carrying Act the of does following: out not PPPcon Slovenia, pr Ar Yes specific There is no (1) Public law Finance Yes regulating PPPs There and Audit in Act:no isthe http://www.paclii.org/sb/legis/consol_act/pfaaa189/pfaaa189.html Solomon Yes explicit prohibition Islands Thereor isa for no description Yes procurement explicit prohibition ofThere ain type the for no isof transportation aprocurement explicit contractprohibition in the in existin thefo sector. (2 w He Yes Neither The main laws regulating theYes amended PPPs in Somalia According PPA theto norinclude: Yes Regulations the (1) Public PPA, art. According are Procurement, 110(1)(b)(ix), currently to Yes the accessible Concessions "The PPA, part art. According through shall and apply Disposal the to the 110(1)(b)(v), Ministry to"The PPA, all Act activities part art. (hereafter of Finance 110(1) shall rela a Yes (1)Africa PPPs in South Constitution are Yes of South regarded as According a Africa: http://www.justice.gov.za/legislation/constitution/SAConstitution-web to Yes the specialized Treasury form of According procurement. Regulation, to Yes the Section The Treasury starting 16.1, According Regulation, point "“public to is the the private regulatory Treasury Section 16.1, Regula framew "“pu partnership Yes http://www.hacienda.gob.es/es-ES/Normativa%20y%20doctrina/Normativa/Paginas/NormativaResul The main regulatory Yes framework regarding According to PPP is Yes articles the Law14According and of Contracts 15 ofto the of articles Yes LCSP Public that 14 Sector According define and (Law 15 the of to the 9/2017, works articles LCSPconcession of14 November that define and 15cot o Yes The main laws (1) regulating Guidelines Yeson Government PPPs According in Sri Lanka Tender include: to Yes Procedure the(1) Guidelines Guidelines According - PartPPPs, ononII:to Government Private Yes the Section Guidelines 229, Sector According Tender Infrastructure "Infrastructure on Procedure PPPs, to the Section Guidelines Projects -Development Part 229, II: "Infra Privat on P (BOO/B Yes Laws The main laws applicable are available Yes at https://moj.gov.sd/files/index/28 to PPPs The in Sudan PPPinclude: ActYes does not (1) the explicitly The Public PPP list Private ActYes the does Partnership sectors The not explicitly subject Act, PPP2021 to list Act the the does published PPP sectors not Actexplicitly subject in the and Sud to lis provid Yes (1) The analysis of Budget the PPPs Act Yes in(SFS 2011:203): Sweden shall be According(2) based to Public No on the Concessions Procurement the totality According of Act Act, the to Chapter Yes (SFS the provisions 2016:1145): Concessions 1, §20, According contained "for http://rkrattsbaser.gov.se/ Act, the to Chapter in purposes the theConcessions following §11, 3, of "this this Act, Act A regul Yes is a confederation Yes Switzerlandhttps://www.admin.ch/opc/fr/classified-compilation/19940432/index.html# made Art. of2 al. 26 2 of cantons. Yes theThe PP LawArt. provides: 2 al. following study 2 of Yes thewill the Federal PP beLawArt. based Council provides: 2 on https://www.admin.ch/op the al. designates 2 of federal the the Federal PP organizations LawCouncil provide regulatory d fra Yes PPPs The in the PPP Public- Republic Yes Tajikistan isPursuant currently togoverned Yes Article 2 by Law: of http://ppp.tj/files/zakon_en/law4.pdf Law No. Law, ofPursuant the PPP toYes 907 infrastructure on Public Article 2 ofPursuantis defined the PPP Private to Article infrastructure as the Law, Partnerships 2 dated ofwhole com is PPP the 28 De L de Yes Private Yes https://www.ppra.go.tz/ According https://www.taneps.go.tz/epps/home.do to Yes Section 4 (5) of the PPP According Yes to Section Act, the https://www.mof.go.tz/project-categ 4 list (5) According of of categories the PPP to Section Act, of the potential 4 list (5) of cate the of PPP Yes https://ppp.sepo.go.th/contents/65 PPP in Thailand Yes by the Under is regulated Section Yes7 Public-Private Partnerships of the Under PPP Act, Promotion Section the PPP Yes of project 7Act B.E. the Under PPP 2562 that Act, (2019) Section is the PPP ("PPP 7 to subject of project the Act"). PPP that Act Act, The msu t isPP Yes www.jornal.gov.tl PPPs are regulated Yes https://www.mof.gov.tl/category/documents-and-forms/procurement-documents/pr by Decree-Law no. 42/2012 According to Yes of Annex September According 1 of the 7 PPP (as amended Law, to Yes Annex the following by 1 of According the PPP Decree LawLaw, to no. infrastructure Annex the 2/2014 following project 1 of the of PPP infra Janu 15may b Yes n/a framework The regulatory Yes governing Article PPPs6in of the Yes PPP Togo is comprised Law provides of Article 6 the ofthat the Yes following: PPP Law "[t]he provisions 1) Article provides The Law 6 of No. that of this the 2021-034 "[t]he PPP Act Law shall provisions of apply Decem to provideso Yes specific There is no Public regulatory Yes Procurement framework Regulations: Sectiongoverning 3(1) http://www.finance.gov.to/sites/default/files/PublicProcurementRegu of the Yes Procurement PPPs in Tonga. Section 3(1) PPPs Regulations Yes of are the rather provides Section currently Procurement that 3(1) Regulations procured of the the Procurement using provides regulations appl the fo th Yes (1) regulating The main laws Yes Public Procurement Public-Private According and Disposal to Partnerships Yes the of Public PPP (PPPs) Policy, Property According in Trinidad Section to Act Yes and № the 1, "<…> Tobago of 2015: 1PPP Public-Private According include: Policy, https://www.finance.gov.tt/w Section to (1)Partnerships the 1, Public "<…> PPPProcuremen Policy, Public-Priva Sect (PPPs) Yes All the PPPs are mainly governed Regulation Yesby Law and no. Articles 2015-49 statutes 24 canto Yes of be November found 27 on of Law The No.2019-47 those 27, PPP2015 two Law Yes on websites covers public-private all related :to -Articles infrastructure http://www.legislation.tn/fr the improvement partnership 24 to 27 sectors ofcontracts of Lawthe at thew No.2019 investm as - co h exc Yes (1) All the The PPP regulatory regulatory Yes framework Turkiye inframeworks BOT Implementation encompasses and YesDecrees the Decree; According can following: be Article accessed to Yes Article 2 Article of through Law2 No. 47 of Accourding Law the "http://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/" 3996No. on Turkiyish 3996 to Certain constitution on Certain Infrastructure Article Infrast allow 2 of Law No Yes http://budget.go.ug/budget/sites/default/files/Public%20Private%20Partnership%20Act%202015.pdf The regulatory framework Yes in Uganda Section is mainly Yes regulated 2(1)(a) of the PPP by Section ActPublic the includes 2(1)(d) Yes Private the of the sectors Partnership PPP Section Act that2(1)(f) the includes Act,Act 2015 of the the shall issued sectors PPP apply onthat to Act Oct incl oft h Yes (1) https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/2404-17#Text; Yes In Ukraine, public-private partnership Pursuant projects have Article toYes been 4 ofgoverned Pursuant the PPP Law, (2) by to Article several https://zakon.rada.gov.ua/laws/show/155-I Yesthe law 4laws, of applies the including PPP to Law, Pursuant to Article the <...> the "construction following: law 4 of applies the 1) and/ Law to L PPP < Yes United PPPs in the UAE Arab Federal Cabinet Emirates Yes Resolution (UAE) Article are governed No. 4 of PPP No (1/1) Lawby ofprovides: 2017 specific n/a on regulations. ThisProcedures the Law will No apply Manual n/a While the to:1. political Government for systemEntities Partnership between in tha the UAE Yes (1) PFI:framework The UK regulatory Yes that PFI implements was used No https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/private-finance-2-pf2 European for transportation Union According rules toYes on the projects, public CCR but2016, sector notice No sectoral procurement that or PF2 Chapter restriction 2(12), https://www.gov.uk/g was will retired "Specific applies typically ato po asexcla Yes States is a federation Yes ofPursuant states, with The United http://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/ tohttp://law.lis.virginia.gov/vacode/title33.2/chapter18/ Yes §the 33.2-1801.This of is U.S. federal government regulated the PPTA, Yes public-private under and This Thegovernment the Public-private is regulated of partnerships under Education each may www.p3virgin The state be used Fac reg Public Yes http://ppp.mef.gub.uy/1200/2/areas/marco-normativo.html PPPs in Uruguay Yes are regulated Article by the following 3 of the No laws and PPP regulations: Lawn/a provides that a) Yes under Law the Article 18.786 limits adopted 3 established of the in July Law by2011, PPP19, provides the here Const Yes (1) regulating The main laws Law "OnYes Public-Private PPPs in Uzbekistan ThePartnerships" PPP Law the is broad inYes transportation № LRU-537: in nature The PPPhttp://lex.uz/ru/docs/4329272; and sector Law doesn't is include Yes broad in limit the The nature thePPP sectors and following: Lawdoesn't is inbroad (2) 1. which The Presidential limit Law inPPP nature “On the proje Pub an D sec Yes Government PPPs in Vanuatu are not Yes regulated Tenders Act: The by a https://ctb.gov.vu/legislation/government-contracts-and-tenders; Government specific Yes PPP Law. Tenders Rather, TheAct Government does the procurement Yes not provide Tendersa The ofAct particular PPPs Government does not is mainly sector provide Tenders governed from www.pac Act particu aits bydoe th scop Yes http://vbpl.vn/TW/Pages/vbpqen.aspx The basic principles andYes general regulations Article 4 of onYes the PPPs PPP Law are set Article states: out under 4 "Investment of theLaw Yes PPP No. sector, 64/2020/QH14 Law Article states: size 4 "Investment and of theclassification ofPPP theLaw Government sector, states: size of PPP"Ia Yes (1) regulating The main laws Public-Private Yes public-private partnership According Act to № partnerships Yes the 14 of(PPPs) 2009: PPP Act, According in https://zambialii.org/system/files/legislatioct/2009/1 Section Zambia 2, toYes include the "thisPPPthe ActAct, applies According following: Section to infrastructure 2, (1) to the "this Public-Private ActAct, PPP projects Section applies to a Part i Yes (1) Zimbabwe The main regulations YesInvestment applicable to The public-private and Fourth Development Yespartnerships Schedule Agency of the Fourth The (PPPs) Zimbabwe Act: https://investmentpolicy.unctad.org/investme Schedule Yes contracts of inThe InvestmentZimbabwe the and Zimbabwe Fourth Development Schedule include Investment ofAgency the the and Zimba following AcD Yes In Myanmar, there is noYes specific regulatory According http://www.pppmyanmar.gov.mm framework to Yes forAccording the Tender Rules, PPPs the at in to calling Yes national the Tender tender local Rules, for construction, orAccording in to level.calling However, the Tender tender procurement Rules, for cons general tenin Yes (1) related The main laws Federal to Law Yes PPPs include: № 224-FZ About According (1) Federal the to Yes theLaw PPP№ Public-Private Law, 224-FZ According art. Partnership About to 7(1), Yes "an the the PPP and object Public-Private Law, the According of Municipal-Private only a [PPP] certain Partnership to agreement theobjects PPP Partnership and may Law, related the art. be:Mu 7(1 to (1) Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q1.1_D Q1.1_E Q1.1_4_TEXT Q1.1_F Q1.1_5_TEXT Q2_A Q1.1_6_TEXT Q2_1_TEXTQ2_B 1.1 ICT 1.1 If yes, please Social Infrastructure provide If yes, the relevant please legal/regulatory 1.1 provide Other the If yes,provisions: specify relevant 2. and legal/regulatory Besides provide national If yes, provisions: the relevant defense please 2.provide Water legal/regulatory and other Supply, the relevant Sewerage, provisions: matters of nation Solid legal/regu Yes Yes The PPP Law The PPP provides under Law Yes "Sectors provides of Public under Private The "Sectors PPP LawNoprovides Partnership" of Public Article under n/a Private "Sectors 6: Partnership" The No of Public Entity mayArticle enter Private into 6: Partnership" Partnership The Entity mayA Yes Article 4.1 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the PPP to Yes Article Law, 4.1 of PPPs/Concessions Except the PPP for the may Yesabove Law, PPPs/Concessions be awarded sectors Pursuant and for to the purposes, may No Article execution 5, by be awarded (f) of virtue of works the for of PPP the and/or Article execution Law, 4, the the p po Yes Yes Law 2000/03 Pursuant of 5 August 2000, laying toNo Art. 207 of down n/a general the Public rulesAcquisition No on postal and n/atelecommunications Code: No the contracting authority servicesmay, and the reso unless o Yes Yes According to article 2(2) According of the PPP toLaw, article Yes this 2(2) law According applies of the PPP to equally No Law, article this to2(2) all law n/aof applies partnerships the PPP equally No Law, in which this to all law the applies equivalent partnerships equally in of the to a which Yes Yes According to According article 1 of to Law No 27,328, Yes article Public-private According 1 of 27,328, to No Law Noparticipation article Public-private 1 of contracts n/a Law Noparticipation 27,328, No are those Public-private in order contracts to develop are those proje in participation Yes Article 2 (22) Pursuant toNo n/a No of the Procurement Law: n/a Related No the following activities -n/a Notypes of activities in the field o Yes Yes According to According the National PPP Policy, to No Section the 3.1.1, n/aPPP National "for Policy, the No Section 3.1.1, purposes of this n/a PPP "for the No policy, purposes of this the term PPP policy, ‘public the infrastruc No Yes According to Annex the Law on I of the YesLaw Concessions, §8(1)(27), on Concessions According "this Federal No to the does Law Law notdoes list on n/a infrstructure not applyYes Concessions, §4(1), toin concession the social "this federal award sectorslaw as the applie on proceeding Yes Article 3.1 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the BOT toYes Article Law: This3.1 Law Article of the BOT 3 of Law: the No establishes the BOT This legal Law Lawn/a Establishes establishes basis No for investment the thefollowing legal in basis construction for investment sectors: (constru 3.1. i This L Yes Yes According to the PPP Guidelines, According Section to No 3.1,Guidelines, the PPP n/a "unless stated Section Nootherwise,n/a and subject 3.1, "unless stated Nootherwise, to any specific and PPP procureme subject to any s Yes Article 5, paragraph Pursuant toYes toYes Pursuant 15 Article of the PPP 5, paragraph Pursuant Law, public-private toNo Article 4-7, the 14 of 5, partnerships paragraph n/a PPP Law, 13, public-private No can beof 14 implemented the PPP partnerships Law, inPPPs relation to i can be No Yes According to Art. 34 the Concession Law, of the concessions No n/a contracts Concession Law provides apply No for concessions to any n/a work andrelating service Yes to social (art services. 2 ) without restriction Yes Yes According to According Art.3 of the PPP Law,to No a Art.3 of the PPP can n/a be PPP Law, No concludedain PPP all can be n/a sectors of economic concludedNo in all and social of sectors economic life, andin particularly s Yes Article 2 ofPursuant Pursuant toYes toYes the SarajevoArticle PPP Law: 2 of(1) Pursuant the Public-Private toNo Article A Sarajevo PPP Law: 2 Partnership of(1) n/a theA Sarajevo Public-Private NoPPP Law: (hereinafter: Partnership the (1)PPP), A Public-Private (hereinafter: for Pa the purpo Yes explicit prohibition There is no Yes Accordingto to conducting Yes PPP the PPP Policy, According projects Section No to the in the PPP 3.16,ICT "<...> Policy, sector. n/a it is Section However, No3.16, envisaged that the"<...> PPP projects Policy it is envisaged suggests in that that the areas of Yes Federal Law 9.472/1997 Yes Pursuant (stablishes toNo Article ANATEL and n/a 2 Paragraph sets regulatory 4 of No rules the PPP n/a Law, on telecommunication the conclusion No public Private of a Public Partner services) and F No Yes According to Annex No.Directive, the EU Concessions 3 Yes of the Concession Article Annexes 11, "this No.1 Law Noincludes Directive and No. shall 2 n/a of the Social not Services. Concession apply Yesto concessions for the other Law also include ar principa Yes Yes in the applicable There is nothing legislation Yes in the There is nothing suggesting applicable There is nothing legislation Nothere that in the issuggesting aapplicable n/a sector that that legislation cannot No issuggesting there be asubject sector to that a public-pri cannot that is there be Yes Art. 3 of the PPP Law provides Yes the Art. 3 ofthatNo partnership PPP Law provides contracts n/a thatmay No partnership relate in contracts whole or in n/a Yes may part relate to the whole or in design, in part to financing, co Yes Yes Law on Article Article 8 of the 8 of the Yes Public-Private Partnerships Law on Article Public-Private 8 of the NoPartnerships stipulates that Law"eligible on n/a Public-Private stipulates sectorsNo Partnerships that that "eligible are related stipulates sectors to the construct that are that "er Yes Yes Art. 2 of PPP Law (“LawArt. No.22006/012 of PPP No of (“Law Law n/a December No. 2006/012 29, 2006, No of December n/a enacting the general 29, 2006, No enacting the regulations general regulati of Partnership Con Yes Yes There are no There regulatory areto barriers no Yes undertaking regulatory There PPPsare in to barriers no No Canada undertaking regulatory at then/a federal barriers PPPs in to Canada No undertaking level regarding at the this federal PPPs inlevel Canada sector. regardin Section th at9. Yes Yes PPP Ordinance Article 6 of the Article 6 of the define Yesthe PPP Ordinance Article 6define public-private partnership of the No the PPP Ordinance contract n/a public-private define aspartnership aNo fixed-term the public-private contract, contract by a fixed-term which a aspartnership Yes Yes According to of decree with article 87 According Yes to article force87 ofAccording of lawdecree No. 850/1997, to Noarticle with force the 87 ofn/a Concessions law of No. 850/1997, decree Nosystem with force the is ofapplicable law No. 850/1997, to system Concessions th the "Stai Yes Yes Article 4(12) of the Guiding Article Opinions 4(12) Yesof of the the MOF, Article GuidingNDRC Opinions 4(12) and No of the of the the People's MOF, n/a NDRC Guiding Bank Opinions on and No of the Promoting the People's PPP MOF, Bank NDRC in Public on and Service the Peo Promotin Yes Yes PPP Law Article 3 of the that regulates Article 3 of the Yes PPP its scope LawGovernment of application that No regulates administrative its considering scope n/a of application it generally No buildings facilities/ applicable (Law considering to it1955 any infrastruc of 2019- generally appl Yes Yes PPP Law Article 3 of the Article provides 3 ofthat the No depending PPP Lawn/a provides on the particularity that No depending and n/aon conditions the particularity No surrounding the implementat and conditions surrou Yes Art. 2 of the PP code provides Yes that Art. 2 of theYes “Public PP code provides Art. delegation� service that 2 of theNo “Public PP code areservice contracts provides n/a delegation� by which that “Public No one are service contracts of the legal by entities which delegation� one areofc Yes article 2 of Pursuant Pursuant toYes toNo article 2 public the PPP Regulation, the private of n/a PPP Regulation, No partnership public contracts n/a privateare No partnership those in which the Administra contracts are those i Yes Decree No. Art.7 of PPPYes 2018-358to Pertaining Yes of the March Art.29, 4 The of Decree Mining 2018 No. No relating and2012-1151 to Hydrocarbons n/a Public of December sector Private Partnerships Nois governed 19, 2012 contracts: by relating a regulatory to Public PPP fra contracP Yes generally prescribes The PPP ActYes that The PPP Act generally Yes the subject prescribes Theof PPP the Act that No public-private generally the subject prescribes n/a partnership that Yes may the not of the public-private subject be exclusively of the public-priva partnership the deli may not Yes Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording to No Act, the §174(2)(a), Publicn/a Procurement 'an award NoAct, of a works n/a concession §174(2)(a), ‘an award No shall of a works be deemed to be a concession con shall No Yes According to the EU Concessions According Directive, to No Concessions n/a the EU art. Directive, No 11, "this Directive shall Title n/aI, Chapter not to apply Yes I, Section concessions III, art. the for19, principal p "concession Yes Yes According to Art.3.3 of According the PPP Law, to Yes (Law No. Art.3.3 of According 2017-186 the PPP Law, to No of 29 Art.3.3 (Law MayNo. of 2017), n/a 2017-186 the PPP a PPPof can No Law, (Law 29 May be concluded No. 2017), 2017-186 PPP ain allof can sectors 29be Mayof2 con Yes Yes PPP Regulations, Article 2 of the regarding Article 2 of No PPP Scope the Regulations, n/aof application, regarding No states: Scope"This n/aof application, Regulation No states: is applicable throughout "This Regulation is ta No n/a Yes No Article 13 of the PPP Law n/a states: Object n/a No of delegated Yes management contracts. The object of Yes Yes (Issuing The First Article Article) The First of Article No PPP Law provides n/a (Issuing for Article) of its No PPP Law provides general n/a for in application No itswhich: general The provisions application which: inof Th the atta No n/a Yes Article 3 of the No PPP Law. n/a However,No please take note that the n/a YesPPP Law prohibits PPPs for (i) Yes Yes No explicit exemption No of explicit the ICT sector exemption No is provided. n/a of Infrastructure the SocialNo No n/a sector is provided. No Yes According to the EU Concessions According Directive, to No Article the Public Procurement n/a No 11, "this Directive Act, Chapter n/a 1, shall not Division apply Yesto 4, concessions forthe §14(2)(3), “for principa thepurpose Yes article 4 (1) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the PPP toNo article 4 (1) n/a Proclamation, of regarding the PPPNo Proclamation, scope of application, n/a regardingthis Noscope Proclamation of application, shall this apply to P Procl No n/a Yes Yes Contracts The Act on Public and The Act onConcessions Public No Contracts n/a is and to applied Yes this sector. Concessions is applied to public pro Yes Yes In France, the Public Acquisition Article L2211-1 Code No gives a broad n/a restricts the use definition of No PPP of for Hospitals procuring n/a authorities in providing: No which buyer is authorised Any encompasses t the Sta Yes Yes According to Art. 4 of the According PPP Ordinance Yes to Art. 4(Ordinance of the According PPP No. to 009/PR/2016 NoArt. 4 Ordinance (Ordinance of the n/a of PPP Ordinance February 11No. No 2016 009/PR/2016 (Ordinance onof Public-Private February 11No. 2016 Part 009/PR/20 Yes Article 6 ofPursuant Pursuant toYes toYes the PPP Law: 1. Public Article 6 of and Pursuant theprivate tocooperation No PPP Law: 1. Public Article 6 of and n/a the may PPP be carried Law: private No1. Public cooperation out in and any maysector be carried private cooperatio of outin public in No Yes According to the PPA, §149(8), There is "this no No explicit Part [award n/aof concessions] prohibition No to conductshall concessions not apply n/a into the Yes the social award of: <…> (8) concessio infrastructure sectors. I Yes of the PPP Section Section 2(1)Yes Act provides 2(1)Yes of that PPP thethe Act Section Actapplies provides to 2(1) of Nothat the all contracting the PPP n/a Act Act applies provides authorities to Noall thatcontracting and the Act applies public sector authorities to projects andun p all contr No are no specific While thereYes There legal areprovisions no Yes specific set legal Given forth provisions by the that No the PPP set PPPforth Law Law, the n/a by does the not Concessions PPP provide Yes Law.Law for The under PPPs specific Article fall into10 the sectors and/or scope specific Yes No According to n/a article 2 of the PPP Law, No This Lawn/a shall applyNo n/a to alliance contracts Yes for the development of economic i Yes Yes According to Art.3.4 of According the PPP Law, to No"[t]his Law Art.3.4 the applies of n/a PPP Law, toNo all "[t]his economic n/a Law and social applies toNo all sectors, economic and social including those subject sectors, Yes article 4 al.Pursuant Pursuant toYes 14 of theto PP No article Law, a al.n/a 14 of 4 public service the PP No concession contract CL 06 2009-009 Law, Law n/a is an Noadministrative setting the general contract by whi rules for Yes Yes PPP lawArticle Article 4 of the 4 ofthe regulates Yesscope the PPP law ofArticle the regulates law ofthe the No scope 4 without establishing PPP law ofn/a the regulates any law specific the No scope without target establishing of the sectors law any without specific or esta tar restrictio No Yes According to Section 5 of the EU Concessions Yes the Public Directive, Article Procurement As the 11, Public "this NoProcurement Act specifies Directive shall n/a the Act not -apply being scope of Yes apublic to general concessions entities procurement for the that principa fall withi act -a Yes Yes The PPP Guidelines The PPP provides that Guidelines itNo applies provides n/a that to "Projects itNo of applies all sectors to costing "Projects n/a of Rs. No all sectors 250 crore orcosting more" Rs. (p.1) 250 crore with o no e Yes Yes According to According the Regulation on PPPs, to No art. the 5 (1), n/a Regulation "infrastructure on PPPs, Noart. 5 (1), that n/a can "infrastructure be procured No based that can be procured on this based Presidential Reg Yes Sector Participation The Private Yes Order The Private No Sector took Participation n/a a general Order No and stance took did a general n/a expressly not No stance and did restrict the not expressly ICT restrict sector from fallis Yes No. 2 of 2014 InstructionsYes applies to Instructions No No. all 2 of 2014 types n/a of projects, applies to No and allthere of typesis no projects, n/a expressNo and restriction no there isor express restrictio limitation regardin No Yes According to Article 3 of the EU Concession 2017, the No PPP Act, Chapter 2, n/a regarding regulation Public No11, "this Directive n/a private partnership shall Yesnot arrangements, concession apply to:(a)broadly co makes Yes scope of the The generalYes Mandatory The scope generalYesTenders of the Law Theapplies generalto Mandatory scope No Tenders the different of the Law n/a applies sectors to Mandatory unless No the different otherwise Tenders Law applies sectors provided. unless to This the othL diffe No Yes According to Article 1 of the EU Concessions the No Public Directive, art. Contracts n/a 11, "thisCode No Directive n/a shall to concessions for the principal p not apply Yes Yes Yes doesn't The The PPP Policy provide PPP an Policy exhaustive No doesn'tlist provide n/a of sectors an exhaustive No list n/a or sector-specific of sectors prohibitions No to carry out or sector-specific PPP project prohibitions t Yes Yes There are no There restrictions are no regarding Yes sectors. restrictions In particular, Since the list regarding No sectors. the not isPFI Act exhaustive, Inprovides particular, n/a a non-exhaustive the PPPsNomay PFI Act be undertaken provides list ofa non-exhaus in other 'Public se Facilit Yes Yes PPP Law Article 3 of the Article provides 3 ofthat the Yes PPP Law PPP projects Article provides aims to that 3 of Nocontribute the PPP PPP projects Law to n/a provides the aims "[...] that No to the contribute PPP construction, projects aims to the "[...] tothe contribu const rehabilitation, Yes Yes According to Article 6 of According the PPP Law, to Yes Article PPP could 6 of According the be PPP implemented to Yes Article Law, in 6 of all PPP couldAccording the sectors be PPP implemented Law, toYes the (fields) PPP resolution of could the in all economy sectors beof implemented (fields) the Governme save ofsp for th in Yes of the PPP Section Section 4(1)Yes 4(1)Yes ofthat Act stipulates the PPP the Act Section Act shall stipulates apply 4(1) ofthat No the to every PPP the Act n/a Act project stipulates shall apply Nothat to every agreement the for Act the project financing, shall applydesign, to ever agreement fo Yes Yes 1 of the Article 2, section PPP Act Article enumerates 2, section Yes 1 of the The various listAct PPP types enumerates NoArticle under of 'infrastructure' 2 n/a section various 1 as is No typesapplicable very of elaborate 'infrastructure' to the and includes, asthis law: includ inte applicable Yes Article 2 (1) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant Article Law, the toYes 2 (1) provisions Pursuant of the PPP tothis of Article Law, No the law 2 shall (1) provisions n/a of govern of the PPP Public this No Law,Private the law shall provisions Partnerships govern of this for Public Privat thesh law p Yes of the PPP Law Article 1(1) Yes provides Article 1(1) No ofthe thegeneral PPP Law n/a provides definition of Nothe a PPP general n/a definition project No in which of it a applies PPP project in which to and it appli does not rest Yes Article 2(1)Pursuant Pursuant toYes toYes of the PPP Article Law, PPP2(1) applies Pursuant of the infrastructure toPPP Law, Article toNo PPP2(1) applies facilities of the n/a and/or infrastructure toPPP No Law,infrastructure PPP applies facilities services. to infrastructure and/or Pursu infrast Yes article 3 (1)Pursuant Pursuant toYes toYes of the Procurement article 3 (1) Regulations, Article of the 2 Procurement PPP No Decree ofregarding scope Regulations, n/a provides: "A regarding No partnership of application, allscope public between ofprocurement application, all sh public and No Yes According to The PPP law the EU Concessions Yes does not Directive, Article define The 11, specific PPP lawNo "this Directive areas does not of define application. shall n/a not apply Yes Pursuant specific to concessions areas to of application. Articlefor 1 ofPursuant the the PPP Lt principa Yes Yes According to PPP the PPP Law, Law art. 2(2), does No not contain "contrary n/a to any an other explicit No text, the provisions n/a prohibition of No this to conduct PPP law shall govern projects social in thePPP infra Projects No Article 9 ofArticle Pursuant toYes 6 of the Yes Concessions the Concessions Law, telecommunications Article Law 6 of the No Concessions provides sector n/a cases when activities Lawconcessions provides Yes cases are not covered are when not allowed. byconcessions the Concesse These a Yes Yes PPP Law Article 3 of the Article (Law 2015-039 3 of the No PPP February on Law (Law 3, n/a 2015-039 2016) No addressing n/athe3, on February 2016) General No addressing and sectoral the General scope and se of applica Yes Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Section to No5.1,PPP the "it is Policy, Government’s n/a Section No intention 5.1, n/a to encourage "it is Government’s No intention innovation toin as many areas encourage innovaa Yes Yes According to Section 2.0 According of the Public to NoSection 2.0 Private Partnership n/a of the Public No Guidelines, n/a PPP involves Private Partnership No Guidelines, the transfer PPP the private toinvolves tran the sect Yes Art. 7 of the PPP Law states Yes of the Art. 7that PPP Yes PPP projects Law states Art.identified are of the 7that No PPP by PPP projects the Lawcontracting are n/a identified states PPP Noby projects that authorities the contracting and are identified listed in theby author the c authorities a Yes article 2 of Pursuant Pursuant toYes the PPP Law, toYes article "Public-private 2 of Pursuant the PPP Law, toNo article partnership "Public-private agreement" 2 of n/a the PPP means Law, No partnership "Public-private an agreement agreement" between means ana cont partnership agr agre Yes Yes According to According article 2 of to Yes the PPP Law,article projects 2 ofare theclassified PPP Law, According No to as article projects PPP of n/a are theclassified PPPthey 2whenever No Law, involve as projects PPP whenever a long termthey services are classified as PPP ag involve Yes Article 17 paragraph Pursuant toYes Pursuant to (2) No Article of the17 PPP n/a Law: "The paragraph (2) No subject PPPn/a Law: of the matter of a "The public-private No subject matter of a public-private partnership may be an Yes Yes According to According the PPP Policy, Section to No4.1.2, the PPP Policy, n/a Section "partnerships may No 4.1.1, be of the n/a following "partnerships No may types: be <…> of the following (4.1.2) types:part structural <… Yes Yes According to the PPP Law, According Article 13, Yes to the paragraph PPP Law, According 1,Article 13, to Nothe paragraph "in accordancePPP with Law, n/a law, 1,Article a accordance "in 13, Noparagraph subject with matter oflaw, 1, the a public-private "in subject matte accordance wp Yes Yes Law and Article 1 of PPP Article its implementing 1 of PPP No Law and PPP Decree n/a its implementing as amended No don't PPP Decree n/a mention as amended No don't mention any exclusion. in the Nothing any ap exclu Yes Yes As per article As per 3 of PPP Law (Law article 15/2011) No theLaw 3 of PPP n/a PPP (Law regulatory 15/2011) No framework PPP is the n/a applicable regulatory No framework to all PPP, is PGD and CE Proje applicable to al Yes Yes provides The PPP Policy The in section PPP Policy 1.1 No that development n/a provides in sectionof 1.1 No that development essential n/a infrastructure public No of essential and services public (including a infrastructure r Yes provision that There is no Yes would There determine is no Yes provisionthe that PPPs applicability may determine would beNo of PPPs used for the all to n/atypes a sector; of projects however, Yes applicability of PPPs (with the to explicit DBFMO a sector; Standard however,A exclusions) Yes No There are no According sector specific provisions to the No Annexn/a 1 to regulating where the Business PPP No projects may Guide, Casen/a may or "note No not that be carriedgovernment current policy out in the Procure Yes Yes PPP Law, Article 2 of the regarding Article 2 of the No Scope PPP Law, of n/aregarding Aplication, states: No Scope of Law This n/ais applicable Aplication, No to states: This projects applicable Law isand to dev contracts pro Yes Art. 2 of the PPP Law provides: Yes the Art. 2 of TheNo PPP provisions n/a of this Law Law provides: TheNo shall provisions apply to of all n/a this Law No shall sectors of economic apply to all and social of sectors econo life. For Yes Yes The ICRC Act The provides its scope ICRCof application No Act provides its where: n/a "1. scope No of -application (1) As fromwhere: n/a the commencement "1. -No (1) As from thiscommencement of the Act, any Federal Yes Yes PPP Law Article 5 of the establishes Article 5 of the No the different PPP Law establishes n/aqualitiesNo and the forms of n/a different aqualities public-private No and forms of a public-private partnership arrangement pa Yes and Regulations The PPP ActYes do Section 1(4) not Yescontain of the PPP anAct explicit Section provides 1(4) prohibition No of that thethe PPP to PPP n/a conduct ActAct applies theNo provides PPP that to projects the all kinds PPP in of Act projects applies the undert to all In ICT sector. k Yes Yes PPP Regulations Article 1 of the regarding Article 1 of the Yes PPPScope Regulations Article of Application regarding 1 of No PPP the Scope states: Regulations n/a "[...] of Application regarding No Within scope Scope the states:of "[...] of the Within Law, projects the state Application scopm Yes Yes According to According Schedule 2 to of the PPPYes Act, Schedule infrastructure" 2 of the PPP According to No Act, includes, Schedule infrastructure" without 2n/a of limitation, the PPP NoAct, assets, includes, without infrastructure" facilities limitation, and includes, services: wit assets,( Yes Yes The PPP Law The enunciates the PPP possible LawNo projects that enunciates thecan n/a possible be No developed that n/a can projects under be the PPPs No developed under in article the PPPs in auth 52: Contracting arti Yes Yes Article 20 of the PPP Law Article and Article 20 of Yes29.3 the PPP of Law the Article and Regulation: PPP 20 ofNo the Article PPP 29.3 PPPs of Law the n/a PPP and can be Regulation: Article used No 29.3 for project PPPs of theimplementation PPP can be used for proj Regulation: PP in: Yes of the 2022Section Section 2.3 Yes BOT Revised2.3 ofIRR Yesthedefines 2022Section Revised the eligible BOT 2.3 ofIRR No types thedefines 2022 of projects n/a Revised the eligible BOT as No "theIRR types construction, defines of projects rehabilitation, as "the the eligible constr types oi No Yes According to Article 2(4) the EU Concessions Yes Directive, of the PPP Article Act Article 11,2(4) "this contains of a NoDirective broad the PPP shall Act n/acontains notof definition the No apply a broad term to concessions definition "project," which of the for principa term "p theapplies No n/a Yes No According to article 2 (3) n/a No of the PPP n/a Law, this statute Yesto all partnerships in which th applies Yes Yes The PPP Law The PPP Law does not explicitly restrict No does not explicitly certainn/a sectors restrict from Noitscertain scopen/a sectors of from Noits application. Article scope ofapplication. 4of the PPP Law prov Article No Yes According to Pursuant to the EU Concessions Yes Article 24 Directive, Article of Appendix the Concession 11, 1 No of "this theLaw, Directive Concession in shall n/a not case Law, of awarding Yes apply Appendix to concessions a concession 1 of theforthat the has Utility Procure as o principa Yes article 5 of Pursuant Pursuant toYes toYes the PPP Law, the potential article 5 of Pursuant the PPP sectors Law, toNo for the PPPs article 5 of potential in n/a the infrastructure sectors PPP No Law, the forand PPPs potential services in infrastructure sectors are forand PPPs sei the following Yes Yes of the Treasury Section K.1.1.2. Section K.1.1.2. Instructions No of the Treasury n/a thatInstructions states No the Instructions states n/aapply the thatto No all Instructions Government procurement. apply Ac to all Govern Yes Yes framework The regulatory regulatory Yes The governing PPPs framework in Saudi The governing regulatory ArabiaNo does framework PPPs inexplicitly not Saudi n/a governing Arabia exempt does No sectors not PPPs Saudi from inexplicitly Arabia its exempt does scope secto of app not No Yes PPP Law Article 2 of the Article provides 2 ofthat Yes its the PPP provisions Law provides apply Article 2 ofthat the No to all PPP itssectors provisions Law n/a provides of economic that apply to all No itssectors and provisions social of life, economic apply to all with the excep and so sect No n/a Yes Yes According to According the PPP Law, Chapter toII, the Yes PPP Part Law, 3, section According Chapter 3.2, Article to Yes II, the Part 11, 3, "a Law section onconcession Public 3.2, Utilities, may be Article 11,g" Artic Yes Section 2 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the PPP to Act, Section Yesthe only 2 of sectors Pursuant the PPP Act, which into Section No the only PPPs 2 of are sectors n/a the excluded PPP which No regard in Act, PPPs the only mining are sectors excluded and in which regard mineral PPPs m extrac Yes Section 1.5.1 Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toNo Section Manual, 1.5.1 n/a PPP isthe of PPP an alternative NoManual, PPP n/a is to method anthe alternative No way the method government delivers to the way thepug No Yes According to The §1, numeral (2) Public (i) of Procurement No Public Procurement the Act, §1(1) No n/a contains Act, "this the Act description n/a apply of the shall not No totype <...>of a concession, the contracts that m thi No Yes According to the Concessions According Act,to Article No 11(1)(14), n/a "this the Concessions Act, Act Article No shall not 15, n/a "concessions apply to <…> Yes for (14) concessions social special servi and otherenabling the Yes explicit prohibition There is no Yes There is for no procurement No explicit prohibition in thefor n/a ICTprocurement No sector. Hence, n/a inthe social No infrastructure therelated regulations apply sector. to the ICT s Hence, t Yes Yes According to The110(1)(b)(iv), the PPA, art. Yes contain PPA doesn't "The part According anshall explicit to Noprohibition the apply toPPA, all activities art. n/a to110(1)(b), relating coduct No"The to concessions part shall concessions in theapply social and to infrastru all in shall pa activ Yes Yes According to According the Treasury Regulation, to No Section the 16.1, Treasury n/aRegulation, "“public Noprivate partnership� Section n/a "“public 16.1, No or private “PPP� means partnership� or “PPP� a commercial m tra Yes Yes According to and 15 ofto articles 14According the No articles LCSP that and define 14n/a the 15 of the No works that n/a definecontract LCSPconcession No the works and concession contract the service and t concession c Yes Yes According to The Guidelines the Guidelines Yes on PPPs, Section on PPPs, 229, Section "Infrastructure According to No 229 the doesn't Guidelines Development list n/a objects theon Projects Noof PPPs, Section a social managed 229, infrastructure by the Private amon "Infrastructure S De Yes does not explicitly The PPP ActYes The PPP list ActNo the does sectors n/a subject to not explicitly No listthe thePPP sectors Act and subject n/a to the providesNo for PPP itsAct and provides general forAccor application. its ge No Yes According to According the Concessions Act,to Chapter Nothe Concessions n/a 3, §4, Act, "this ActChapter No does not §4, n/a 1,apply a subject ifto Yes concessions matter which concession of a are is inten primarily "a se Yes Yes Art. 2 al. 2 of Art. the PP Law 2 of the provides: No the PP Law explicitely Federal Councilmentions n/a Yes designatesthe organizations Swiss PPPs are possible under Yes Federal public Institutes in the of or road Technology private law opera network, but th and d Yes Article 2 ofPursuant Pursuant toYes toNo Article the PPP Law, infrastructure 1 ofn/a the PPP is defined Yes Law, as Law This shall the whole List approved apply complex No to byof all PPP the installations, Governmental projects inbuildings, area of the Decree o in sys Yes Yes According to Section 4 (5) According of the PPP Yes to Section Act, the 4 list (5) According of categories of to No the PPP Act, Section of the potential 4 list (5) n/a of PPP of the PPP projects NoAct, categories the of is potential open list of butcategories also PPP explicitly of is projects poo Yes Yes7 of the Under Under Section PPP Act, Section the Yes7 of PPP project the Under PPP that is Act, Section subject the No 7 to PPP project of the PPP n/a that Act Act, subject the No is mustPPP involve to project the with PPP that the Actfollowing is subject must to infra th involve Yes Yes According to According Annex 1 of to the PPP Law, Yes Annex the following 1 of the PPP infrastructure According to No Law,Annex the following project 1 ofn/a themay infrastructure PPP Law, be financed No the following project through infrastructure may be financedp public-private Yes Yes PPP Law Article 6 of the Article provides 6 ofthat Yes "[t]he the PPP Lawprovisions Article provides 6 of that of No this"[t]he the PPP Act Law shall provisions n/aapply to providesofpublic-private No this"[t]he that Act shall provisions apply partnership of to this contrac Act sh public-priv Yes of the Procurement Section 3(1)Yes Regulations No Section 3(1) of the Procurement provides n/a Regulations No that the regulations provides n/a apply to No that all regulations the procurement apply carried out to all by proc Yes Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Section to No1, "<…> the PPP Policy, Public-Private n/a Section No1, "<…> Public-Private n/a(PPPs) will Partnerships NoPartnerships be used to support (PPPs) will many used beof th Yes Yes Law covers The Concession all sectors The PPP Law ( Law Yes andNo. theThe 2015-49 PPPPPP dated ( Law LawLaw ( Law No n. 272015-49 November No. n/a 2015-492015 dated 27 No related dated November 27 November to contracts 2015 2015 related related to cont between to the Yes Yes According to Article Article 2 of 2 of Law No. 3996 Law Yes on No. 3996 Additionally, Certain Infrastructure on No Certain BOT Infrastructure Law and No. n/a3996 Public Investments and Public No Investments covers theand following: Services and national Services with parks BOT wit Mo Yes Yes of the PPP Section 2(1)(b) Section Act includes 2(1)(c) Yes of the the sectors PPP The PPP that Act includes Act the No Act furthermore the shall sectors n/a apply provides that to of theNo that which Act framework shall ICT projects also apply to ofapplies are which one to:i) of.socia Yes Article 4 ofPursuant Pursuant toYes toYes the PPP law, the law Article 4 of apples the PPP to <..> Pursuant toNo Law, Article "electronic the law 4 ofn/a the communication." PPP applies toLaw, <...> Yes "installation the of to: law applies -manageme modular home Yes Yes Law provides: Article 4 of PPP Article 4 This of PPP No Law Law provides: n/ato:1. will apply This Government No Law will apply n/ato:1. Entities that Government are Yes subject Entities that arebudget to the general subjec No Yes According to PFI was the CCR 2016, Chapter used Nofor social 2(11), n/a "Specific infrastructure exclusions Noprojects. n/a However, in the field of electronic please Yes notice communications:" that PF2 was retired (1) These Yes Yes under This This is regulated is regulated Yes under The Public-private Education The definition Public-private Facilities No ofAndEducation Infrastructure PPPs applicable n/a Facilities under Act No ofPPEA 2002. And isIt not Infrastructure is part exhaustive, of Act Title leav 200 of 56, t No n/a Yes No PPP Law, Article 3 of the n/a Section D: No n/a Social infrastructure Yes including prisons, health ce works, Yes Yes The PPP Law is broad inThe nature PPP and Law doesn't is broad Yes limit in nature the The PPP sectors and Law doesn't No in is broad which limit inPPP n/a nature the projects sectors andNomay doesn't in which be limit implemented. PPP projects the sectors There may in whic is n be i Yes Yes Tenders The Government The Government Act not provide does Yes Tenders The a Act Government does No not particular provide Tenders sector from n/a aits Act particular does of scope not sector No provide from application. aits particular The scope Act provides of applica sector i fr Yes Yes PPP Law Article 4 of the states: Article of the Yes PPP Law 4 "Investment sector, Article states:4 "Investment size and of No the PPP Law classification sector, n/a states: of PPP size andprojects: No "Investment classification 1. sector, PPP of size PPPandprojects: investment secto1 classific Yes According to the PPP Act, Yes Section to According 2, No"this the ActAct, PPP n/a applies Section to infrastructure No 2, n/a projects "this Act applies to and infrastructure No facilities, and the provision projects of s and facilities Yes Yes The Fourth Schedule the Fourth ofThe ZimbabweSchedule No Investment the and ofn/a Development Zimbabwe No Investment Agency n/a and Development Act No provides: "(1) Agency In this Act, Act “PPP ag provides: Yes According to the Tender Yes Rules, in to According calling No tender the Tender Rules, n/a in calling Yes tender for construction, procurement According for construction, to of goods Notification Yes and procurement services, 15/2017, oftransport goods lease se and an Yes According to the PPP Law, Yes According art. 7(1), to "an the object Yes PPP Law, According of aart. [PPP] to agreement 7(1), "an Yes PPP Law, the object may Any of abe: art. transportation-related [PPP] 7(1), <...> agreement (10) "an object Yes underwater may of abe: [PPP] and infrastructure, <...> undergrou agreement (11) theothh Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q2_2_TEXTQ2_C Q2_3_TEXTQ2_D Q2_4_TEXTQ2_E Q2_5_TEXTQ2_F Q2_6_TEXT 2.provide If yes, please the If yes, relevant please Energy generation, transmission legal/regulatory 2.provide ICT If the yes, andrelevant provisions: distribution pleaselegal/regulatory 2.provide Social infrastructure, the If yes,provisions: please relevant 2. including provide Other. the legal/regulatory hospitals, If yes, relevant provisions: specify education, and provide prisons, the legal/regulatory hous rel provi n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Article 5 point Pursuant toYes (i) of the Pursuant toNo Article PPP Law, Concessions/PPP n/a (ç,) of the 5 point YesPPP are Law, notthe awarded Concession/PPP Pursuant tofor Article the construction 5 of lawthe exclude PPP a L n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 21 of the PPP Law 27,328 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a the Law on Concessions, Yes §8(1)(25), According "this Federal No to the Law Law does on n/anot applyNo to concession Concessions, n/a §8(1)(27), "this award proceedings Federal concernin Law does not app n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 7 of Concession Law relatesYes n/a to specific exclusions Article 8 ofin the No Concession water. No to specific n/a Law refers n/a exclusions in the electronic co n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 2, paragraph 4 of the PPP No According to n/a the EU Concessions Yes Directive, Article According 12(1), to Nothe "this EU Concessions n/a Directive shall not Directive, apply Yes to concessions The 11, Article "this awarded supply ofDirective products to:(a) shall to a not publi providea n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 98 of n/a the Law No. No 26, 2012 1/02 of March n/aon the Water No Code n/a provides for concession Yes contracts. Article 12 of the PPP Law provide n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes PPP Law Article 3 of the sets that Article 3 ofregulated the No PPP Law n/a sets which sectors Yes have their that regulated sectors own Article which 3 of the private investment PPP have their Law regime sets own that a privat n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Water Supply Only for Public – Article Only for No 177 Energy generation paragraph n/a - Article the 1 of No Water Act n/a 5 paragraph 3(OG and66/2019, Yes 7 amended Article The PPP paragraph(OG 1 ofAct 84/2021). thegenerally Electricity Market A prescribes n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a the EU Concessions Yes Directive, Title According I, ChapterNo to the I, Section EU Concessions II, n/a Directive, art. 12(1), "this Directive No n/a Title I, shall Chapter apply not I, to concessions Section II, art. 11, " n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 318 of the 2008 Article Constitution: 25 of Yes the 2015 Water a isOrganic Art strategic 14 of law the No for 2015 the Organic national patrimony n/a public service Lawfor ofof public Telecommunications Yes electricity use, it(Ley is an According Orgánica inalienable (Ley to Article del Orgánica and Servicio 13 of dethe Público Teleco PPP imprescrip n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to the First Article (Issu No Law forbids Article 3 of PPP No n/a PPPs in water projects, n/a except Yes for projects for the Article design, 3 of the Yes PPP construction, LawArticle prohibits repair, 3 ofPPPs theequipment, PPP for (i) Law prohibits the opera provisi n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to Procurement the Publicn/a YesAct, §132(1)(5) According andtoNo the (6), “the Public contracting n/a Procurement NoAct, or authority entity §11(1)(1), n/a is“the not required contracting authority to follow the n/a Yes No According to Article 6 of n/a No Proclamation the Investment n/a "1/ Yes The following areas ofto According article 4 (2) investment of the shall P exclu No According to n/a the EU Concessions Yes Directive, art. According to No 12(1), "this Directive the EU Concessions shall n/a not apply Noto concessions Directive, n/a art. 11, "this awarded Directive to:(a) provide shall or not appl n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Beside the general Yes Beside established restriction field the specific by restrictio Article L. 22 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Article 3.1 of Pursuant toNo n/aRegulation No public and private No. 426, n/a No n/a cooperation may be carried out in an NoIV, §101 contains The PPA, Part n/a Yes a definition of concession According to Nothe PPA, grantors that §149(8), n/a explicitly "this NoPart [award excludes the n/a application of concessions] PPA,not of theshall apply § 102(1) n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 2(2)(f) Yesof the PPP Section Act provides that 2(2) of the it does PPP not a Act states are no specific While thereNo Yes n/a legal provisions forth by setWhile there the NoPPP are Law, no the specific n/aConcessions legal provisions Yes Law set under forth Article Article 2(3) by 11 the ofPPP the specifically PPP the Law, Law Conces provid exclude No PPP Law: Article 2 of the Scope. This n/a No Act shall apply n/a to partnerships Yes Article 2 for contracts of the No the PPP Law: n/a development Scope. of This economic infrastructure Act shall apply to p n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/aAssets Act, the National Yes the stateAccording or state-owned No to the entity EU Concessions has n/a the exclusive Directive, No right to n/a Article operate 11, "this or Directive state-own establish shall not a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a the EU Concession Yes ChapterAccording 2017, 2, regulation to No 11,EU the Concession n/a "these regulations 2017, Yes shall regulation There 10, not apply is to: "(1) (a) noThese concession restriction on contracts a secto Regulations sha n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a the EU Concessions Yes Directive, art. Pursuant toNo 12(1), "this Directive Article 15 of shall n/a the Public not No Contracts apply to concessions Code: n/a Provisions awarded to: this in (a) Code shal provide or n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No are no n/a Generally, there restrictions for the social infrastr n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 3 of the PPP Law provides No According to n/a Resolution No. 710, water No (save for n/athe transfer Yes of the right of temporary According Yes to Resolution gratuitous According No. 710, to use land healthcare Resolution right under organizatio No. the 710, PP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Article 2.2.5 Pursuant toNo of the PPP n/a NoLaw, construction n/a Yes generation of new PPP Law The energy does not regulated capacities, apply towa n/a Yes NoHigher Committee KAPP and the n/a No a clarification issued n/a to bidders Yes on the Projects related Al Abdaliyah to Natural ISCC Resou PPP Project i n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 2(1) of the PP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a of the PPP Law Article 3(5) No Yes the following n/a enumerates exceptions Pursuant toNo Articlefor 3 of the the n/a PPP Law, water Yesthe sector if regime a PPPArticle isof toPPPs 3(1) be would of the procurednot PPP in the apply Law to provid form of con n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 9 ofn/a Pursuant toNo Yes Law, water the Concessions sector Pursuant toNo Article activities are 9 of the n/anot Concessions covered YesbyLaw, telecommunications According to the Concessions Article Law. This sector 6does of the activit Conc not pre n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Art.3 of the PPP Law (Law 2015-0 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes After Amendments to Public Priv n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes In accordance with Article 10 of t n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPP Law, Article n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to article 3 (2) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 2a.20 n/aProcurement of the Public No Law inn/a the Concessions No chapter n/a states that n/a explicitlyNo the provisions shall not apply to c n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to 1 to the Business Case Guide, "n the Annexn/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 25 of the PPP Law provide n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 2 of the PPP Regulations g n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Schedule 2 of the PP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 29.8 of the PPP Regulation n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 1. The Philippine Constitution res n/a No n/a Yes The Concessions No Law does n/a not apply No n/a to telecommunications concessions, but a No Article 2/5(b) of Decreen/a Law 111/2012, Yes excludes According to No multi-municipal the Directive systems n/a2014/23/EU, concessions No Title I,n/a Chapter for supply of drinking I, Section water, wastewat II, art. 11, "this n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a the EU Concessions Yes Directive, Article According 12(1), to "this Nothe EU Concessions n/a Directive shall not Directive, apply Yes to concessions There Article are 11, "this awarded no Directive explicit to: (a) shall provide mentions a notin n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes PPP Law Article 2 of the provides Article 2 ofthat the No its PPP Law n/a provides provisions apply that Yes to all itssectors Apart of economic provisions from the apply to all and common sectors sociallegal life, of wit fra econ No According to n/a the Law on Public Utilities, Yes Part II, According "the Yes Article 5, to the communal PPP Law, According activity Article to 3, referred Yes "This the Law to law on in does According thenot Article apply to 2(1) Healthcare, the Article toPPP [supply public-private 30, Law,"the of Article the me p d n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Section 2 of the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a (2) (i) the §1, numeral No Public Procurement Act, "this Act of the the n/a No According to n/aof the Republic Constitution Yes of Slovenia, According Article to Nothe (a), the n/a 70Concessions water Act, Article No is provided supply n/a directly 11(1)(14), "this Act and on a shall non-for-pro not apply to n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes While the PPP Act does not restr No According to n/a Act, Chapter the Concessions Yes 3, §11, According "this Act to Nodoes the not apply n/a to Concessions Act, concessions Chapter No that 3, n/a §4, "this are intended Act does for: not apply (1) to con the provisi Yes Water supply The electricity is a competence NoCantons of the transport / n/a network is Noa public Municipalities. Mostmonopoly. of n/athem prescribe No that Electricity the distibution No public comments is sector ensured by local/canto must hold the m n/a No n/a Yes Clause 9 ofn/a Pursuant toNo Government Yes List Decree No. approved 581 by the Governmen (the List), PPP Law wil n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 2(2) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No The PPP Law 2015-49 dated 27 November 201 ( Law No. n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 4 ofn/a Pursuant toNo NoPPPs are n/a the PPP Law: applicable in: Nowaste management n/a other than collection Yes and4(2) Under Article of the PPP Law transportation. Yesof the Dubai Article 4(2)(A) PPP Article LawNo 4(2)(A) provides, of the Dubai n/a "This Law PPP will No Law provides, apply to:n/a 2 . any "This Project, Law Noapply will regardless to:n/a 2 . any Project, of its regardless type, form, of its t or activities No According to n/a Chapter the CCR 2016, 2(12), "Specific Yes According exclusions to No CCR the in 2016, the n/a Chapter field Yes of water." 2(11), These "Specific PF2 wasexclusions Regulations do not retired in asapply a the field to:(a) policy ofcon tool in ele n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a article 3 of the PPP Law, No services n/a that are to Yes be rendered exclusively According No to by Article the State n/a 3 of and the PPP activities Law, PPPs granted by law contracts in ma n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The existing regulations, includin n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes There are no sectoral restrictions n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes PPPs in fresh Notification water fisheries and relevant Yes 15/2017 explicitly Pursuant services areprohibits explicitly toNo Sectionprohibited 1 (d) n/aserial under administration of4 no Yes electric Section (9) of the 1 (b) power Section Notification serial systems no 1 (a) (2) 15/2017, and serial of inspection the telecommu (4) (5)ofofele noNotification th No Any water-related n/a infrastructure, other Yes than that According definedtoYes in the thePPP PPPLaw, Law, According art. art.12(1.1), 7(1) to Yes cannot the PPP only be ifLaw, aAny an contracting art. infrastructure, 7(2), object of aauthority PPP "an object agreement. other is ofthan a munic a Th tha [PPP] Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q3 Q4 Q4_3_TEXTQ4_4_TEXTQ4_5_TEXTQ4.yes_A Q4.yes_B Q4.yes_C Q4.yes_D 4. Is there 3. Please identify aIf the PPP specialized yes, procuring pleasegovernment authorities indicate the year ofits establishment: and in name(s), entity(ies) the relevant and 4.that [Field-Country] If its yes, legal/regulatory facilitates website(s) what and 4. provide PPP are the (if capacity thePPP available): their basis: main 4.program PPP website(s) building responsibilities promotion 4. (PPP for (if Technical other available): among ofpublic Unit)? the support the agency(ies) public in implemen and/or (check authorities. p Yes The PPP Law Central defines PPPs Partnership in Article 3(1) 2015 as Authority, a, "Partnership Article 12 (Central Yes of thePublic PPP Law between Private Yes oneprovides: or more Partnership Entities (1)The Authority, Yes with Yes one Central Public also or more Private referredPartnership to as Private Central Parties Au for Yes 1. Ministries Concessions of the central government, ATRAKO: Treatment i.e.:2007 - Ministry Decision Agency (ATRAKO): of No. PPA: 1995 Defense Yes 150 dated http://www.atrako.gov.al/ www.mbrojtja.gov.al; 22.03.2007, Yes "On the Yes - Ministry organization The Yes Public of Interior and functioning www.mb.gov.al; Procurement of the Agency (P Yes Concession Article 4 of the The Decree National provides Development 2006 The that Public National Equipment contracts Development Yes Fund (la Yes shall be Caisse valid Equipment and Yes final Fund Nationale only (la d'Equipement Yes after Caisse Nationale they havele pour Développemen d’Equipement been approved b Yes Under Article PPPUnit 2.1 of thePPP Law, a number 2012 ("Gabinete of Técnico Under publicde Article Apoio Yes entities às 8(referred of Parcerias the PPP Yes to Law, Público as the "public Yes government Privadas do partner" Yes inMinistério entities the Law) that da Economia") may procure responsible PPP for decisio Yes 27,328 The Article 1 of Law Public-Private provides that the PPP 2017 Participation regime Articlesapplies Sub-secretariat, 28 Yesto and of the 29bodiesYesin PPP referred the Law National provide No as PPP the Public forUnit: the Yes Sector creation https://www.argentina.gob.a of the Public (or "Sector Público Nacion Private Yes On the basis 1241, of Decree The there are 4of Department types 2019 Public Pursuant of Investment actorsto Yes Section under involved 32 in PPPs: the Yes (13) 1. ofprivate Resolution Ministry Yes of partner Economy No.2. 658, (http://www.mineconomy.am/) public Yes Public Investment thepartner Policy (procuring author Yes The different In addition government ministries to 2008 and thefor agencies the The Infrastructure Infrastructure Infrastructure act asand procuring Yes Structured and Structured authorities NSW Act Finance Yes 2011 Finance within Unit No. Yes23 the Unit (ISFU) provides scope (ISFU) inYes NSWin in of their Section Treasury NSW authority. Treasury; on "Constitution 5 servingA 2011 as highway the formap Inf No According to n/a the Law on Concessions, n/a §4(1), "this n/a federal law No applies to Noaward procedures Noconcession No for public procurers des Yes The BOT Law Article 2.0.4. defines inMinistry competent 2018 of Economy, www.economy.gov.az. Decree authority148 as the No. Yes relevant asYes About ensuring the competent executive activity Yes body of the authorized Yes Agency authority of according to small conclude to the and an medium BOT Law and bu agreeme Yes According to the PPP Guidelines, The Public-Private art. The Public-Private Partnership 4.1(xvii), According "“Contracting Partnership Authority: to Yes the Authority� http://www.pppo.gov.bd/. Authority: PPP Yes Act, means art. 4(1), 2015. a line "as ministry Yes soon as The Yes may orPPPbe division; Unit after under the or any commencemen the office or direc Ministry o Yes According to The definitions Public-Private in Article 2014 1 of the Partnership PPP Decree Law, a "public Center of the Yespartner" (PPP Center) Yes President of is athe procuring is an internal Yesstate Republic of Belarus authority department Yes of and May (subdivision/unit) 25, 2010 could No. 273. be "any within state bo article 2 of n/a Pursuant toNo n/a Law, procuring the Concession n/a authorities No the State; regions, are No No No communities and local authorities; an Yes of the PPP Pursuant Art.10 PPP Unit The Law, 2018 the following is called “Cellule public Art.5 ofd’appui theYes PPP entities aux Law may use PPP�. sets Yes public-private up the No institutional Yes website partnership available. framework Yes contracts public-private of for partn the execution of Article 5 ofCommission Pursuant toYes 2011 the Sarajevo PPP for Public-Private Law, a PublicPartnership Pursuant toNo Article partner 23 is:1) One of No or more the public YesPPP Sarajevo Law: bodies No 1) The Government entering shall establi into an agreement wit Yes According to the PPA, Article A specialist 2, <...> team 2016 of PPP "procuring According experts entity" means to Yes thethe within PPP any organizational Ministry Policy, Yes Section or Department structure Yes 4.13, "a of specialist duly Yes the Ministry authorized teamof of toPPP engage experts Finance in publi and will Econ Yes According to the regulatory PPPs framework, are conducted PPPs 2016 the in can Thebe frame PPI procured of Yes Council a PPP is by Program any Yes established entity which of bythe is Law Yes Government. facilitated 13.334 (PPIbyLaw) Yes a Article specialized of September 1 of the PPP 13, Law 2016, government ent appl Yes According to of the Concession Article 17 Pursuant 2006 to Article 36 of Act: (1) Pursuant the TheConcession public Article toYes Law, body, 36 which of the Yes the performs authorities Concession Yes the actions Law, the having No for functions authorities concession strategic award ofhaving and the functio is a pa develop Yes PPP Law Article 2 of the defines contracting According 2014 to the2022 institutional authorities - PPP Law; PPP -framework as PPP the Decree; Yes or Yes State, in -Burkina one Decree of its Faso, No. Yes dismemberments 2014-628/PRES/PM/MEF two institutions Yes asare its specialized of July in 29th decentralized or201 dec PPPs in Article 2 ofL' Pursuant toYes Agence the d'Appui PPP Law, the2016 contracting à la Réalisation ArticleAuthorities 9 ofdes the Yescontrats PPP Law are: de the -Yes provides: partenariat State;-An Yes the public-privé regional expert Yes or local public (ARCP)" service authorities; known (supporting as "Agence - the public agencyd Yes PPP Law Article 7 of the provides, General "Public 2021 Department entities ofArticle Public-Private with of the 5 the rights Yes Law Partnerships to on Yes Public-Private enter (GDPPP) into No the PPP Partnership Contract, Yes stipulates that acting as the "the Ministry A Implementing o Section 2 (2) Pursuant toYes of the CARPA PPP (Sill 2006 Board Law (Law for Implementing CARPA No. 2006/012 (Sill Board Partnership of December Yes Yes for Implementing Contracts). 29, 2006, YesIts enacting website Partnership the is Yes Contracts) as general regulations was follows: instituted of Partn by th www.ppp-camer No There are multiple n/a authorities procuring Comments n/a in Canada. On the No No Crown Agencies Federal level, No No and Corporations act as procuring au Yes According to article 7 of The theNational PPP Ordinance 2017 the Commission Article Contracting for Public 13 of NoPrivate authorities the ordinance Yes PPP Partnerships which are: provides and No- The the State, Coordination that Yes local “[a]n institutional authorities and Support framework andUnit for public inst PP for s Yes The General The Directorate of General Public Works 2017 Directorate Concessions Law (established of Public 21.044/2017, as (DGCOP, the Works Yes legalConcessions issued successor for its No acronym by the of(DGCOP, the Ministry ofYes the General for Spanish of its Public Direction No acronym Dirección Works ofof Public that General the modifies Works de Concesion Spanish Dirección the Con (DGOP) a Article 16 of Pursuant toYes the Government China Public Private 2014 Procurement Partnerships At the central Center Yes Law, level, the("CPPPC"): central theYes Ministry http://www.cpppc.org/; ofYes government and local Finance Yes ("MOF") governments has http://jrs.mof.gov.cn/ppp established a Governm may designate th Yes Based on its National Planning definition contained in2012 article Agency 1 ofNational the (National (Departamento Planing PPP Planning Law, Agency YesPPPs Agency Nacional -in 1958 Yes-(since Decree Colombia de Planeación can 2012 Yes 1082 bewith procured of-2015; authority "DNP"): Yesby Ministry any https://www.dnp.gov.co/p over state of PPPs); entity. Ministry Finance - Decree As of Fin a conse2 Yes PPP Law Article 6 of the defines The a contracting Unit of Advice 2021 andauthority Article Coordination and 19as any of Yes20legal the of the public-private person PPP Law No provides: Yes partnership governed by public theYes Government "UC-PPP" law or legal shall person of private create a publila No According to of the Public Article 77 n/a n/a Procurement n/a Code: The No State and No No local authorities decentralized No may conclude public ser Yes According to Public article 1 of Credit the PPP Regulation, 2016 Department the PPP in the Article 15Ministry of No contract PPP available of Finance: No to isRegulation any establishes: https://www.hacienda.go.cr/?id=703 of No In addition No to the institutions the requirements mentioned for the as procuring au the Definition Pursuant toYes CNP-PPP: Theof PPP Decree 2012 http://www.ppp.gouv.ci/ No. 2018-358 The CNP-PPP ofYes March is the29, body2018 Yes in charge Yes ofto relating decision, Public Private Yes validation Partnerships contracts and orientation :T of the Yes The role of a Based PPP procuring authority on the Amendments 2019 may be undertaken The Amendments to the PPP by Yes Act any to line OG the ministries, Yes 114/2018 PPP Act OG(which local Yes 114/2018 came and No into (which regional force self-government came on 1/1/2019), into force units the on or 1 Jan se Min Yes According to Procurement the PublicThe For Department Act, the 11Department “State The §4(1), "aBudget� involvement contracting 11Yes “State within authority ofthe Budget� theNo Section Ministry (a)6 is:within the of “Public the No Finance Czech Section Budgets� Republic, in the No 6 “Public concession within in which Budgets� the case award the Ministry within procedure state of Financ the M orga No According to n/a the EU Concessions n/a Directive, Title n/a I, Section I,No I, ChapterNo No the purposes art. 6(1), "for No of this Directive, ‘contractin article 3.2. The Pursuant toYes PPP of the Unit: PPP Law,www.unite-ppp-djibouti.com PPPs 2018 Art.6 are of the entered Yes PPP into byLaw the states State, Yes that a Yes public agencies PPP and Unit is created, Yes companies and local a structure entities. attached t to C Yes No. 340-06 Article 2 of Law establishes Dirección General2020 that de Alianzas the Article 5 Público-Privada of the operating organisms Yes PPP LawYes (General of established the public Directorate Yescontracting of Dirección General Public-Private entities Yes deare: Alianzas Partnerships): a) Público-Priva The htt Central Gov Yes Every public entity manage Interinstitutional their own PPP Committee portfolio. 2015 ArticleThis for 4 ofinclude the Yes / PPPs Comité PPPany Law: Ministry NoInterinstitucional provides: Yes For theof or Agency approval de the Asociaciones Yes central of public Público-Privadas. projectsMunicipal government, and the a We Article 2 ofThe Pursuant toYes Executive the PPP Central 2010 Regulations, Unit under According the the Minister toAdministrative Article Yes Finance of 16 Yes of the Authority, (PPP PPPCentral Law, Yes (As thedefined PPPYes Unit), www.pppcentralunit.mof.gov.e Unit in Article is a “unit ofthe 1 of PPP nature� special Law, as Yes Any governmental Exports entity, and2014 including autonomous Investment Legislative Promotion entities and Yes Agency municipalities Decree of El Yes number Salvador 663can approved (Organismo Yes be procuring in 2014 Yes Promotor authorities de Exportaciones for 2 Inv PPPs (Article e of No Procuring authorities n/a are not specifically n/a identified. n/a No No No No No According to Procurement the Publicn/a n/a n/a Act, §5(1), “the rulesNo established No must be followed in this Act No No by a contracting authority Yes According to PPP article 6 of theDirectorate PPP Proclamation: 2018General: The 1. The PPPContracting Proclamation Yes http://www.mofed.gov.et/web/guest/public-private-partnership-directorate Authority established Yes for aNo Public in Private article the 10Yes Partnership PPP Directorate General, shall be as the Public designated n/a There is no No n/aauthority PPP procuring n/a in Finland,No but any authority No is planning No whoNo a major project that it wishes to Yes According to FIN INFRA Article L2211-1 (Mission of the2017 Public Acquisition d'appui DecreeauxNo. FINancement Code2016-522 Yes : any “public of des Yes 27INFRAstructures. April 2016 buyers� [the Yes on the State, Website mission local Yes authorities, to support link: other the financing public bod http://www.economi o Yes According to The article 5 of thePPP PPPUnit Ordinance 2019 within The The National PPP Unit (Ordinance No. Agency Yes 009/PR/2016 Decree forn°000155/PR/MPIPPP Yes of 11 February Promotion of Investment No 2016 of Yes 18 (ANPI-Gabon): onMay Public-Private 2018 on https://www.an Partnerships), the powers, org Yes framework The regulatory Agency. PPPdoes 2018 not specify the Pursuant PPP procuring Article toYes 9 ofYes the PPP authorities; however, Law: Yes all 1. state The Public Yes entities and can enter Private into PPP using Cooperation Agen Yes According to PD -"contracting the PPA, §98, PD - Partnership Partnership Deutschland: authorities PD - Partnership within Deutschland the in-house No the meaning Deutschland: was created Yes of this advisor at the togeneral Part the Yes public are corporate end<...> sector of 2016 concession Yes on law. by various conversion grantors aspects, within from thethe form including P me Yes The PPP procuring The Public authorities Private in Ghana 2012 byPartnership definition, Sectionas26provided and Yes Office under 27 of inthe Act the Yes Public Public 1039,Investment refer Yesto: Private Partnership a) the and Executive, Assets Yes Act,Division 2020 Legislature (Act 1039) (PIAD) - of and Judicia the M confirm Yes According to Public-Private Article 1 of the 2005 the PPP Law, Partnerships following Article Unit authorities (PPP 4 of YesUnit) the may PPP Law within conclude Yes specifically the Ministry Yes a PPP agreement of Development mentions Yes thewithin establishment & Investments their and responsibi competent sector https:// Yes According to National article 6 of Law 2010 the the PPPAgency Partnerships contracting The PPPauthority Law for Yes the Development established is the entity Yes ANADIE ofor state and Yesinstitution, Economic Infrastructure stated article inYescentralized, 3 (Agencia that itdecentralized Nacional is the de or Al specializeda YesPPP Law Pursuant Art. 3.5 of the that provides to Article this Law 3 ofapplies 2021 Article the Institutional 10 to ofNo Public the PPP Persons Decree, Law Yes the which provides PPP areYes for defines institutional the creation in art. Yes framework ofa 2of the PPP PPP in Guinea Law Unit within and is comprise the Min include article 68 of Pursuant toYes the The PP Law, Central Unit thefor 2012 contracting the Circular Management BM/UCG/PPP/024/11-12 Yes of PPPs authorities Yes for concessions and the National on are Yes the the creation State Yes and Commission of regional the on central and Public management local authoriti Procurement. u N Yes According to the PPP Law, In Honduras, in its article the 2019 PPP 13, COALIANZA Unit Decree COALIANZA. has Yes as one was 64/2019 of As established its Yes offunctions December the PPPtoSuperior Yes exclusively 2019, theCouncil PPP Yes manage Superior (Consejo theCouncil Superior (Consejo contracting proce APP) S a No Hungary has PPP procuring no specificn/a n/a authority; n/ain each project, No No the competent No entity/ministry public No should be considered t Yes Procuring authorities The are nodal main specialized 2005 departments government located The Ministry within Yes of the Finance, entities sponsoring are: Yes a) notification PPP Cell, Yes theagencies (State Department dated or 29th Yes municipal-level November of Economic 2005, Affairs, F.No.2/10/200 line Ministr department of a procuring The identityYes Directorate authority (1) ofwill PPP differ Development Bappenas: (1) depending PPP for 2015; Bappenas: Yes on(2) Public Private PDPPI: the Regulation sector. Yes Partnership 2015; of the According at Yes to President the theMinistry Regulation Yes of the of Republic the on PPPs, National art. of Development 2 (1), "a № Indonesia 6 Min Yes The different Theentities government depending Plan & Budget 2015 Organization on n/a No sector may the relevant No authorities. No be procuring No Article 13 of the Private Se Noserves asn/a Each ministry n/aauthority the procuring n/a for that particular No No in Iraq, ministry No on the relevant sector. For purpo dependingNo Yes The National National Development Treasury Management Agency NDFA: 2003 (hereinafter Procurement Finance Central Agency PPP "NTMA") Yes Unit: of (hereinafter 2006 PPPs inYes established Ireland "NDFA"): is a done National Yes www.ndfa.ie Development No through with (orThe the Central Finance assistance PPPAgency's Policy the (here of)Unit a N Yes According to The Infrastructure the Mandatory Tenders Law in and 2001 Section Projects The Infrastructure Division No that 2 provides the atandany Project Yes Accountant stateDivision, entity General Yes "government ora Department Yes of the division corporation" Accountant in the Ministry General may beFinan of in proc Yes Any public authority Italy may be in According to a DPCM PPP procuring n. 2858/2015, 2015 DPCMauthority. 2858/2015 No the Presidency 38 of the Council ArticleYes Public Yes Contracts of Ministers Yes Code introduces afor - Department Planning qualificatio Yes According to The Summary the Executive 2012 PPP Units of the to the PPP Development According Policy, "the Yes to the Jamaican Bank of Jamaica Yes Executive PPPSummary Policy (DBJ),sets Yes and toout thethe the PPP Yes principles Policy, Ministry of Finance "the that operating (MOF). should The units guide deci will webs single centralized There is no Yes Privateauthority Finance Initiative specifically 1999 Act on responsible Promotion PromotionYes Office for ofof Private theNo Cabinet procurement Finance Office Yes(http://www8.cao.go.jp/pfi/index.html) of PFI projects. Initiative Yes Generally, a project would Yes entity is The contracting the The Public-Private public authority 2020 which Partnership Article concludes 7 Unit of the Yes ("PPP the PPP PPP Law Unit") Yes contract establishes located with Yes "[a]n within a private the organizational Ministry Yes entityof asinvestment unit per Article called and 2 ofPPP the the Uni PPP linked to Yes of the Republic 1. Government of Kazakhstan 1. JSC "Kazakhstan2008 Public-Private (http://www.government.kz/en/); Pursuant to Yes Article 26 of Partnership Yes the PPP Center" (http://kzppp.kz/), Law: 2. Yes1. The Government Ministry Yes of National hereinafter Economy of the referred (http://econ to of Republic the as Kaz Yes “Contracting hasPPP authority�The been Act defined 2014 under under section The section 6 PPP sets 2 up Act of under the YesthePublic PPP section Act Yes Private 6 sets as (a) Partnership at upthe the Yes national Public Committee Yes Private government (the 'Committee') level, a Partnership state depar that i Committee ( Article 2 (4) Pursuant toYes of the Public PPP and Private 2000 Act, the term PIMAC's "competent Infrastructure Investment establishment Yes authority" Management Yes is legally the Yes Center(PIMAC) head under meansregulated Yes of an administrative Article http://pimac.kdi.re.kr/eng/m 23 of the PPP Act agency "Esta in charg Article 3 of1. Pursuant toYes the PPP The Law: Public-Private 2009 1.2. Public Partnership Article 16 Committee Authority - Yes of the means: PPP1.2.1. Law (PPPC) Yes one (link or more at: Yes establishes the http://pppkosova.org/?cid=2,1) ministries Public-Private Yes or agencies Partnership of theCommittee. 2. Central Governmen Yes PPP projects authorities procuring Kuwait 2008 in Kuwait Authority for Partnership shall Article be the Projects relevant 4 of Yes PPP(KAPP) the Law public Yes provides (formerly entity that, Yes (anyPTB) government, "A http://www.kapp.gov.kw/en/Home public Yes Ministry authority or Department, called or a “Kuwait Autho Yes (i)Cabinet of The Ministers of the Center June for Kyrgyz Republic Public-Private 28 2019 (the Pursuant "KR") to (www.gov.kg); Yes the Resolution Partnership underNo (ii)Ministry the the Cabinet No ofMinistry ofof Finance of Ministers No Economy of the of the KR of (www.minfin.kg); the Kyrgyz Kyrgyz Republic Republic (iii)Ce (www No of the Procurement Article 2(6) Yes has been PPP Unit Law 2018 established provides, Chapter "Procuring within VIIIEntity Yes the of the Investment or Project PPP Yes Decree Owner Promotion is dedicated meansDepartment Yes to Yes the Government the Committee (IPD) entity infor the Ministry and state Investment en of P Pr Yesin LatviaThe A public entity mayCentral act as a Finance procuring and PPP2009 The Contracting Authority authority Yeswas according established Agency Yes (PPPtosupervisory the PPPYes definition pursuant to theYes of PPP institutionArticle and Supervisory functions 1(1) of the of a PPP competenc Law, Institution wh Regu Yes According to Theart. the PPP Law, High6, Council "<...> after 2017 for Privatization the According Council ofand Yes to the Ministers PPP: PPP Law, approves Yesart. 3(1), to Yes proceed https://hcp.gov.lb/. "the designation with No of the the PPP "High the Project, project Council co for Pr Yes Procurement The authorities are Central generally official 2010 Project Management entities Investments Agency Yes at theLaw, national Law (Centrinė or Yes on municipal Concessions, Projektų level Yes PPP Valdymo that resolution, Yes Agentūra initiate the The -PPP Resolution project. CPMA), For No exam website: ww 1480 Yes According to article 2 of Articles the PPP to 6 (Law 4 Law 2017 of the 2015-039 PPP Articles Law on (LawtoYes 2015-039 4 February 6 of the 3,PPP 2016), on Yes Law February the (Law Yes 3, State, 2015-039 2016) local and entities on Yes the February PPP and public 3, 2016), institutional institutions a Decree PPP Unit can 20p a Yes According to The the PPP Act, Section Public-Private 2, ""Contracting 2011 Partnership Authority" Commission: According Yes to themeans PPP http://www.pppc.mw/ Policy, aYes Ministry, Section Government Yes 9.1.5, “theDepartment, Public Private Yes Partnership agency, Comm parastatal o Yesauthorities PPP procuring involve Public Private all 2009 governmental Public Partnership levels Unit, Private Prime from Yes Partnership Federal Yes Government Minister's Department Unit, Prime Yes(ministries/agencies) Minister's http://www.ukas.gov.my Yes Department state government to http://www.ukas. Article 2 ofL' Pursuant toYes Unite the Law, PPPde Partenariat 2017 the procuring Public-Prive Article 6 of the No entities are [the PPP PPP the Law Unit] Yes establishes State, autonomous WebsiteNo :the http://pppmali.org/. public-private regions Yesand their partnership unit which w public institutions, is Yes According to The Article 2 of BOT the PPPA, Projects the contracting 2016 Unit :The http://bot.govmu.org authorities BOT Yes unit wasare created Yes : The in 2016 (Art. Ministry, Yes a Government 4 of the Yesdepartment, BOT a mission's Act), which was e local authority, Yes Law, any Under the PPP Investment ministry or 2016 Unit agency can (Unidad Article act de as 21 a procuring and Yes23 of Inversiones). authority. the The link Yes PPP Law; is: Article article Yes4 of34 http://www.gob.mx/shcp/acciones-y-programas/ the ofPPPs Yes the Federal Law ofthat Law provides the and Budget Fi follow Article 3 ofThe Pursuant toYes the Public Concessions Property 2017 Law, which Agency The Law has provides a PPP No 902 Yesa list of 06 Directorate of November definitions, Yes (PPP Unit), "contracting Yes which 2017 on the organization Yes coordinates authority"PPP - and means projects [any] (http://w public functioning a of th Yes According to The Public-Private the Concessions art. 3.1.7, Law, 2016 Partnerships ""authorized Annex toDivision the Yes Resolution within entity" Yes the meansofa the Department state Parliament No ofof Investment Mongolia Yes administrative Policy № body in charge 12 of and21 of the Julystate-ow 2016 Ab Regulation o Yes According to Montenegrin the Concessions Investment Law, Part I, 2020 Article According 4(3), "a (MIA). Agency grantor No to The the Article shall MIA's Yes mean: 18 of the - the website Yes PPP Parliament https://mia.gov.me/ Law, theYes of Agency (MIA):1) Montenegro approves projec (hereinafter, "Par Article 1 paragraph Pursuant toYes The PPP 2 Division of 2016 PPP within the 2020Law The thePPP asDirectorate amended Unit Yes the wasof created Public PPPNo procuring by the Decree authorities Yesand Enterprises No. Privatisation 4075-15 are Yesthe following ofof 15th Ministry :-the State; the February 2016 of - the Econoest No According to n/a 6 of the Articles 5 and n/a PPP Law: In n/a terms of institutional No framework,No No No are made by the Governme the PPP projects Yes The PPP and Act, 2075 InvesmentOffice (2019)2011 of Investment defines Board Article Nepal: 12.3 Yes "Relevant of Entity" https://ibn.gov.np Nepal's and PPP project Yes of Yes Policyand 2015 entities provides responsbile Yes that a for implementing Public-Private proj Partner Yes Under Dutch The Ministry law the procuring 2006 ofat entity Finance a national Rijkswaterstaat is responsible level isYes always was for the created the No overall State in of DBFMO theYes the Netherlands. policy. wake of theItNo ensures European However, proper depending application Commission publishin on of DB the su Yes According to The New the Procurement Zealand Rules, “the 2018 Treasury's Rules A notice areInfrastructure of the Yes ITU mandatory for establishment Transactions the No Unit agencies listed No is (ITU): provided in Rules https://treasury.govt.nz/informatio on Yes theand 6.1 6.2. For Treasury's these agencies website: https:/ Yes The PPP Law Article 3Direction defines inGeneral 2016 the procuring of Public Article authority Investment (Institucion 6 of Yes PPP the Law (DGIP): contratante) Yes http://www.snip.gob.ni/Nosotros/Dgip and articleNo as 3 of any the government PPP Yes Regulation department PRONICARAGUA assigns or a agency role th of a P article 2 of Art. Pursuant toYes 4 of Law, the PPP the PPP procuring 2018 Law makes Art. authorities of theNo are PPP 4provision the Law for aState, PPP makes Yes Unit regional provision "La Structure Yes authorities for a a d'PPP Yes Appui or their Unit. au It Partenariat is worth groups, mentionning Public-Privé departments of m Yes In Nigeria, all At the national Federal Government level 2005 Ministries, the Departments, Section "Infrastructure Yes 14 of and the ICRC Agencies Act Concession Yesprovides: (MDAs) Regulatory (1) as well Yes Commission" asis There Yes respective established (ICRC States - body a Governments to be website: known ca www.icr the Article Pursuant Pursuant toYes 4(5) of the to PPP Article Law, 2012 of 13"Public Articles the PPP partner" Law, Yesand 13,14, the is Government 21 of a legalYes entity the PPP of Law that the awards Yes Republic (elaborated a contract Yes of in North formain the establishment question). Macedonia hasof a pu establi Yes According to The the PPP Act, Public 2(g), Section Private ""implementing 2017 Partnership Accordingagency" to Yes Authority: the PPP means https://p3a.gov.pk/index.php Act, No any Section of the 3(1), Yes line"as ministries, soon Yes it deems departments, as attached body appropriate after t Yes Each Ministry PPP and public National entity conducts Secretariat 2019 its own (Secretaría contracting Article Yes 12 of the Nacional process, PPP LawYes in created de APP): accordance https://snapp.gob.pa/ Secretaría Yeswith its Nacional Yes laws special and the PPP Público-P de Asociaciones Law. The Yes Bodies,The Relevant Public Public include: The 2014Independent 1. Private Partnership Pursuant State Centre toof Section Yes established Papua New 14 Yes of the Guinea. under PPPthe Act: Yes 2. Public (1)The Provincial Private Public Yes or Local-Level Partnership Private Partnership Act. This Centre Governments. 3.no has i St Yes of PPP The procurement Public-Private projects encompasses Partnership 2013 The Project Public-Private multiple Unit: institutions. Yes https://www.stp.gov.py/v1/direccion-general-de-proyectos-de Partnership Typically Yes theYes procurement Project Unit is aYes specialized a sectorial ministry is lead byDepartment of the T Yes According to Proinversion the PPP Law and its Regulation, (www.proinversion.gob.pe) 2002the Forprocuring Proinversion: Yes Supreme and the Yes authorities are Ministry Decree called Yes "Organismos of Economy Yes and 027-2002-PCM.Promotores For Finance DGPPIP: de Supreme la Inversión ("MEF") Decre Pri (www.mef the BOT Law: Section 3 ofYes All government Public-Private Partnership 2010 infrastructure By virtue Center agencies, of Yes (PPPC). the Executive The including YesOrder website isNo. government-owned http://ppp.gov.ph/ Yes 8 series of Yes andas 2010, amendedcorporations -controlled by Executive Article 2.1 of Pursuant toYes Since theSeptember PPP Act, the 2018 2018, Articles following whenentities the 16a, PPP Yescan Actand 16b, amendment 16c carry out Yesof PPP theprojects PPP YesActforce, entered as establish public Yes theentities: Ministry the role1) of MFDRP Development public together finance Fun sect Yesentities may The procuring vary,Técnica Unidade depending de 2012onThe Acompanhamento thePPP nature Law of Nocreated the depublic Projetos and Yesentity established (UTAP) envisaging Yes - The the Technical to contract UTAP.Yes According Unit via PPP. forto the article The Monitoring 1 (b) PPP ofof Law app P the Yes entitiesPPP All government competent to are Department atpropose theThe 2020 Ministry PPP a PPP of project Yes Unit is referred Commerce to the No and to in Industry the PPP Minister Yes of Commerce https://www.moci.gov.qa/en/about-the-m Law as “the Noand Industry (Minister) Competent (https:/ Department� def Yes According to Central the PPP GEO, the entity: public partner Ministry 2018 (i.e., of Public PPP GEO the contracting Finances Yes authority) Yes https://mfinante.gov.ro/despre-minister). (website: No is represented by Noany authority identified under The Dep Yes PPP Law Article 2 of the defines The a Contracting 2008 Steering Committee Authority Article and the 6 of Rwanda asYes "a PPP the Development Law public institution Yes indicates:Board inYes charge whose Public institutions of PPP No website agreement". is: www.rdb.rw playing The role PPP Guide in PPP s are the No Article 88 of Finance Management the Public n/a n/a Act n/a2001 establishes No No a Government Tenders Board. No No Article 89 of the same instru Yes There are no Nationalauthorities specific procuring Centre for 2017 Privatization setThe out National as part Yes of (NCP): Center the https://www.ncp.gov.sa/en/Pages/Home.aspx forYes Privatization regulatory Yes framework. Regulations The government Yes(enacted on 6/3/2017), entity andth sponsoring in Yes According to Unité Article 3 of PPP Nationale Law, any public d'Appui 2021authority, aux PPP Article 7 of including (UNAPPP) the No PPPthe Law https://www.economie.gouv.sn/fr/missions-objectifs/parte Yes establishes State, No local authorities, a “[…] structure Yes public called the "National establishments, Publico agencies Yes According to Theart. the PPP Law, 4 (9), "a "public Commission 2012 for Public Decree partner"on isThe Private one Yes Partnerships Establishment or multiple Yes (hereafter, of the public Yes "PPP bodies, Public-Private Commission"): i.e., Yes a legal Partnership http://jpp.gov.rs entity Commission that ("O is, in complianc Section 1 of Pursuant toYes the PPP to Pursuant Article Act, 2014 "public 27 authority" of Pursuant the PPPto Act: Yes means Article ... a "the 27 Public of Ministry, Yes theGovernment Private PPP Act: Yes Partnership department, ... "the Yes Unit Public islocal Private hereby Partnership authority established Unit or with is h other s the GPA, Section Pursuant toYes 2, which The Ministry ofcontains 2010 FinanceCP2M had the definitions established is mentioned No of various the Centre in the YesPPP terms for Handbook inYes theProject Public in“contracting Act, Yes Management multiple instances, authority� ("CP2M") most notably within means th un a min Yes According to There §7(1) of the is no Public Procurement n/a designated Act, - PPP PPPunit Methodological "for the in the Yes purposes Slovak Guidelines: Republic. Yes of However, this Act, https://www.finance.gov.sk/sk/financie/ppp-p Yes the contracting the Ministry No authority shall be: of Finance (a) the Slova performs seve Yes According to the Concessions The Investment Act, Article Division 21(1), 2007 Thewithin a grantor PPP themay Yes Unit was be Publicoriginally Assets in the Yes Directorate established form Yesof of "<...> in the (a) 2007, authorities Ministry No but went the through Republic of Finance: a series of Sloveni of or https://www.g the PMFA identifies Part 1(2) of No n/a the n/a governmental n/a authorities Noabide by No No that must No rules and further addresses its procurement Yes According to The the PPA, art. 3(25), Concession "Procuring 2015Entity Technical According Unit means to a established Yes public the PPA, entity under Yes art. making the 121(1), Ministry "There aYes procurement of is Finance: Yesto the established, which website within this Act is not the Ministry, available. applies." au Acco Yes According to The the Treasury Regulation, PPP Unit PPP section unit the within was 16.1, The National establsihed Government a“public Yesin Treasury private 2003 Technical is part and partnership� Yesof the Advisory the Government Yes newly orCommittee formed “PPP� means unit Technical Yes (GTAC) reponsible a commercial is Advisory agency an for the Centre transaction regulation within (GTAC) the beo No According to of the LCSP,n/a article 12 n/a it is stated n/a in general terms No that the No Noentities of sector can celebrate a PPP contr the publicNo Yes on PPPsThe The Guidelines don't National provide 2017 Agency for a definition According Public of a Private to Yes the Partnership procuring entity. Yes cabinet However, decision (NAPPP)Yes according № was 26 Establishment established to Yes the Public byof theProcurement cabinet the National decision Agency Guideli №f Yesauthority The procuring may The be any Governmental Supreme 2021for Council Article theEntity PPP 6.1 and Yes inthe of the PPP Sudan. Central In Actthis Yes Unit regard provides for Yes for the thethe PPP. definition Yesof "Contracting establishment Party" under of the Partnership Cout No According to n/a Act, Chapter the Concessions n/a 1, §20, n/a "for theNo purposes of No contractingNo this Act, aNo entity shall mean an entity that No authorities PPP procuring n/a n/acan be any office of the n/a local/cantonal/federal No No administration, No No public firms. The overall res including Yes Per Article 2 Law, Enterprise of the PPPState 2013 the PPP procuring on Implementation Article authorities 2 of the (public ofPPP Yes partner) Projects PPPLawYes defines are (www.ppp.tj) the the authorized central Yes and (the Yes governmental PPP local Council) executive authorities body (mi in the area Yes According to Public-Private Section 3 of the PPP Act,Partnership a "contracting 2010 TheCentre PPP Centre (PPP Yes was Centre); authority" means established Yes no anywebsite byYes Section available Ministry, government 4 of Yes thedepartment or There PPP Act:4.-(1) is estab agency, local Yes According to State Section 4 of PPP Act, 2002 theEnterprise"State PolicyAgency" Reorganization Office means Yes (SEPO) plays government of Ministry, the Yes role Sub-Ministry, of agency, a PPP Yes state Unit and enterprise, in Department Yes Thailand. local https://ppp.sepo.go.th/ Act, administrative B.E. 2545 (2002) organ T Yesresponsible The Ministries National for the Directorate relevant 2020for public Article Public-Private sector. 2 of According the Yes PPP Regulation, to Yes amended Partnership (Direção which Article Yes had 3(2) previously Nacional Yes dethe of Parcerias PPP established Law, Público-Privadas "the minister the of -D Public-Prit Yes PPP lawPublic-Private Article 5 of the “the 2022 contracting Article provides that Partnership Unit11 There ofYes the is no PPP authorities website under Law Yes public yet. that states Yes law are: a PPPthe Unit State, Yes local shall authorities, be created public Arti by decree. esta No According to n/a Section 3(1) of the Public n/a Procurement n/a Regulations No No the Regulation's stating No No of application to any procurem scope Yes According to The Public the PPP Policy, Private Section 2, "a 2012 “Public-Private Partnership AccordingUnit Partnership� Yes to the PPP within the Policy, Yes Ministry (PPP) is a oflong-term SectionFinance: No7.2, "the https://www.finance.gov.tt/about- contract Ministry Yes between of Finance a private has establishe party an Yes PPP Law Article 3 of the The (Law regulatory n. 2015-49 2016 dated functions The 27 for November PPPs are regulatory Yesdivided functions 2015 related between Yes on PPPs to contracts different are Yesdivided between bodies among Yes in Tunisia. the different public Theand bodies closestprivate thein Tunisia. unit w to se Yes The PPP procuring authority Turkey's will PPP unit 2018 depend part on the of Pursuant the sector Presidency toinvestment. of Article Yes Strategy of5 the ofYes (Note: Presidential and the sectors Yes Decree Budget. are Its official widely NoNo. name listed 13, (1)is The under "Department the BOT service units of Law of PPPN t Yes PPP ActThe Article 4 of the Public-Private provides 2015 that any authorized Partnerships Sections government Unit 10 Yes and established contracting 11 of Yes the under PPP Act the provide Yes "Ministry authority, and for responsible the Yes thisestablishment for includes finance" and functions government departo mention Yes a PPP project n the case when (1) Investment is regulated 1) PPP Department division by general Thein of PPP the the PPP division Ministry Yes Department legislation of the of of (the Yes Economy Investment Investments "PPP -project"), http://www.me.gov.ua/ Yes Department of the the MoE: Yes authority of the 2017 2) that MEU (2) PPP - Regulation may The Agency State be treated Organiz on esta was as the Yes Dubai PPP Article 4 of the Law provides Department its 2019 scope of Finance Article for ofthe application Government 11 of Yes the Dubai to, "1. Yes PPP of Government Dubai Law provides, Yes "DoF",Entities which " Anthat Yes hasinternal established are subject committee PPP ato the named Unit general the "P bud Yes According to Infrastructure the Regulation 4 of the CCR and 2016 2016: Projects “contracting Authority: Yesand Infrastructure authorities� https://www.gov.uk/government/organisations/infrastructure-a Projects Yes means State, Yes(IPA) Authority was regional Yes formed or local on 1 January 2016 authorities when (including article § 33.2-1800 Pursuant toYes of the 1995Va. Code Virginia Department ofThe Transportation, Ann., Department "Responsible Yes Office public Yes of Transportation's of Public-Private entity" Yes means role is a delineated public Yes entity, Partnerships in the (VDOT including P3 Code of local Office) : http:// govern Virginia, u Yes PPP The Public Administration in general, Project Unit PPPorProject "Unidad each entity PPP de Project Unit: Proyectos 2011; that represents Yes Unit CND: "Unidad de Participación it,Yes 1985 debe can Proyectos a Público-Privada:" procuring Yes de Participación authority, Yes https:AM32//www.mef.gub.u Público-Privada" according 2 of P to Article create Yes legislation The PPP-related Public-Private The doesn’t 2018 define Partnership a specific PPP development list Development of Yes agency Agency government entities Yeswas under established responsible Yes the Ministry by for Yes the Decree of Finance the procurement on PPP of the Framework Republic of of De U a PPP proje No As per the Government Tenders Act n/a n/a Section 1, n/a a government No contractNo No No involves a “Government agency�, which means:(a) a Mi Yesentities are The procuring The PPP steering ministries, ministry-level 2012 Committee. Decision In No. addition, Yes agencies and each 2048/QD-TTg provincial Yes ministry/ministry dated people's October Yescommittees, 27 2016 level agency/provincial No on in accordance consolidation with of article PPPcomm people's 5 stee Yes According to The the PPP Act, Public-Private Section 2018 3, ""contracting Partnership According authority" Department toYes means the Amendment the Yes PPPunder public the control authority Act, No and Section supervision that 3, has Yes the power which of repeals the Ministry toand enter into responsi replacesan a Se Yes According to Public the Zimbabwe Private Partnership Investment 2016 and Development Section Unit 34(1)Yes Agency of the Agency of the Act, Zimbabwe (Zimbabwe No Fourth Investment Investment Yes Section Schedule andand No Development 2, Development Interpretation Agency): Agency Act № defines ""con 10/ https Yes Union Departments areThe theMinistry procuring Planning 2016 for ofbodies The and national Ministry No procurement Finance of Planning has No established and processes. the Project FinanceNoUnion, has established Appraisal Region, No or andthe State Progress Project Appraisal Reporting Departments and or Or Dep Yes According to Theart. the PPP Law, 3(4), 2008 Department“a public for the partner Development Deceree contracting [aon theof Yes Ministry theauthority] Sectors Noof Economic the ofis No Economy the Development. Russian Federation, within No on behalf the Ministry Economic of of which th D Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q4.yes_E Q4.yes_F Q4.yes_G Q4.yes_H Q4.yes_I Q4.yes_J Q4.yes_K Q4.yes_L Q4.yes_12_TEXT 4. Revision 4. Identification of 4. Consultation fiscalof and selection PPP risks 4.borne Approval projects withby affected from 4. ofUndertaking the PPP Government. the communities projects. pipeline. 4. Oversight the procurement potential of on 4. PPP implementation. impact of Post-project 4. PPPs. Other: appraisal Please of PPP and audit. specify: projects. Yes Yes No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No No No Yes No Yes The Concession Treatment Agenc Yes No No No No Yes No Yes The National Development Equip No No No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No Yes No Yes Disclosure and document gatheri No No No No No Yes No Yes Maintains the PPP projects datab No Yes No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No Yes Yes No No n/a Yes No No No No No No Yes 1. Evaluation of PPP project conc No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No No Yes No No No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes No No No comments Yes No No Yes No Yes No Yes n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes Pursuant to Article 4 and 5 of the Yes No No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No Yes No No n/a Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes Modification of existing contracts No No No No No Yes No Yes (I) collecting and sorting PPP-rela No Yes No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes No No No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes Cooperating with public bodies in No Yes No Yes No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No Yes No No No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No No Yes No No No Yes Termination or extension of the c No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes Yes No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No Yes No No No comments Yes No No No No Yes Yes No n/a Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes Pursuant to Article 3 (L) of Resolu No No No No No Yes No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes No No According to section 27 of the Pu Yes No No No No Yes No No n/a No No Yes Yes Yes Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes Yes Yes Yes No Yes No Yes The Central Unity of PPP monitor No No No Yes Yes Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes Provision of financial support to c Yes No No Yes No Yes No Yes (1) Provides support / handholdin No Yes No Yes No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes Yes No No Yes In some cases, NDFA can act as a Yes No Yes No No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No No No Yes The DIPE's competences in this fi No Yes No No No No No Yes The DBJ's PPP Unit additionally h No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No Yes No No n/a Yes Yes No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No Yes PIMAC is in charge of conducting Yes Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes Outreach to stakeholders and pu Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes Article 62 of the PPP Decree state No Yes No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No Yes No Yes No No Yes The Council is in charge of all asp No No Yes Yes No No No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes No No No No No No No Yes Yes No No n/a No No No No No Yes No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No No No No Yes No No n/a Yes No No No Yes Yes No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes No Yes According to Article 18 of the PPP No No No No No No No Yes 1. Ensure the secretariat and follo No No No No No No No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No Yes The PPP and Investment Regulati No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No Yes No No n/a Yes Yes No No No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No No comments No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes No No No No n/a Yes Yes No No No Yes No Yes Article 12 of the PPP Law provide Yes No No Yes No Yes No Yes To manage and administer funds Yes No No Yes No Yes No Yes According to Article 9 of PPP Law Yes Yes No Yes Yes No No Yes Proinversion participates in the jo No No Yes No No Yes No Yes (a) Manage and administer a revo No No No No No Yes No Yes Monitoring, evaluation, informat No Yes No No No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No Yes RDB acts as a lead negotiator for No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No Yes No No n/a Yes No No No No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No No No No n/a Yes Yes No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes No Yes MoF especially:- Develops and up No No Yes No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No Yes No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes Yes No No No Yes No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes No Yes Pursuant to Article 10 of the PPP No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No No comments No Yes No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No No No No n/a No Yes No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No Yes No Yes Article 3 to 7 of the PPP Unit Dec No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No Yes No No n/a Yes Yes No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No Yes Yes No Yes Yes Yes PPP Agency: 1) Keeping records o No Yes No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a No Yes No No No Yes No Yes a)Budgetary aspects, b)risk asses No No No Yes No Yes No Yes The other roles and functions of t No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No Yes No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes No Yes No No Yes Yes No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No Yes Some of the other related functio Boolean Boolean Boolean Q4.1 Q4.yes_13_TEXT Q4.1_4_TEXT Q4.1_3_TEXT Q5 Q4.1_5_TEXT Q6 Q6_1_TEXTQ6.1 4.1.the Please provide relevant If yes, Additionally,legal/regulatory is please the there a year indicate central of provisions: its establishment: and project the development name, and5.its relevant Please website legal/regulatory provide fund 6.(if Does available): (support any the additional basis: Ministry If yes, please of mechanism) information 6.1. Finance provide for project Doesor the or Central Ministry relevant comments preparation? Budgetary of legal/regu on Finance theAu an Yes Article 13 of Project PPP Law on "Powers Development and Functions 2018Fundof PPP The (it Central has Lawcomment Partnership provides not been established under Yes Authority" yet "Project The provides: and PPP thus lawThe no No under Development website Central Fund" "Powers Partnership is in Article and Functions 49 available) that:(1) of Authority Article 12 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a n/a 1. The Concession n/a Comments Treatment Yes (ATRAKO) Agency Pursuant shallto beArticle under10 Yes the of the PPP Law, the subordination "M of the Art. 5 of the CNED Decree No No. 04-162n/a n/a(Decree n/a of 5 June 2004 n/a on the status, No n/a organization, No and responsibilities of the Nat tasks No According to n/a article 2 of n/a Decree n/a the Executive no. 10/12 of Comments January 5,No n/a 2012 on the No Rules of Procedure of Public-Private Partne No Article 28 of n/a the PPP Law contains n/a the main functions n/a Comments of the PPP Unit: Yes (a) centralizing According to Noarticle 6of the regulations ofthe thePPP Regulations PPPcontracts, (b Article 8 ofNo Pursuant toNo n/a the Law <...> n/a 1. The PPP unit shall:Comments (1) provideYes the public partners Pursuantandthe competent toYes Article 2 paragraph PPP Law authorities — in the No According to Section 2.2 n/a of the NSW PPP2017 Guidelines, n/a is responsible n/a the ISFU Yes for:oIn NSW NSW, PPP noted Yes in Sections asGuidelines 3.2 and (TPP17-07) ensurin and3.3 of t n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Yes Yes According to the art. 58 (2) of the Federal Bu No BOT Law and n/a BOT Rules n/a in particular articles 5 n/a and 6. Furthermore Comments No No. 148. Order n/a Yes Yes According to There the PPP Act, art.are 9(1), several "the (1) power Theschemes Public-Private (1) and The in Bangladesh functions Public-Private Partnership n/a of the that PPP Partnership Yes areAuthority aimed Technical Assistance at Technical According supporting shall be Financing Assistance as tofollows: No PPP the development (PPPTAF) Financing (a) Screening promulgating, Fund: (PPPTAF) Manual, of PPP 2012; project appro Fund (2) Crite T No Center'sn/a The list of PPP functions isNo published on n/a Comments the official Yes website of the National According AgencytoYes Article for 14.1 in and Investments Privatization: the Regulation on n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a No n/a No article 4 of n/a Pursuant toNo n/a The PPP PPP Unit Decree: n/aUnit :- Advises n/a the government Yes on all Art.6 ofmatters theYes PPP Law provides: relating Provides to PPP;-the assi Council of Article 24 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law, n/a the Commission n/a Comments shall perform the Yes following Pursuant tasks:a) toYes Article carry out 14 the(4) evaluation Sarajevo (a) of theand appro No According to n/a Section the PPP Policy, n/a 4.14, <...>n/a the role of Comments Yes the PPP Unit, According as the custodian of the to No PPP the Policy, PPP Policy, is to Section ensure the"the 5.6, suc Yes The competencies The of the PPI main Council suchare2017 delineated fund is known Federal under asLaw theArticles 13.529/2017 Support Comments 2Fund and Yesand 7for ofFederal Structuring PPI According LawDecree andand to9.217/2017. No art. Development 14, Article 10, II, III IThe and and IV of of FEP Concession III, of the is managed PPP the PPP Law. andA L 37 of the Concession Pursuant toNo n/a n/a the Council Law, Comments n/a of Ministers defines Yes the state policy Pursuant toNo Article 39(2) for concessions of the Concession as follows: A 1. approves PPP Decree; - PPP Law;- Yes - Decree The National No. 2014-628/PRES/PM/MEF 2012 Project Preparation The 2019 Budget Fund n/a and Law of July programs provides Yes 29th 2014 for Article underspecific is related the authority 22 funds of to the No for of creation, PPPthe theLaw FONEPP Treasury provides attributions, and (the National Public comp that: AP “No No of the n/a The attributions n/a for then/a Support Agency Implementation n/a of Public-Private No PartnershipYes n/a Contracts, its organization and it Article 4 and Pursuant toYes 5 of the Project PPP law, 2021 Development the Facility Article General 12 Department of Comments (PDF): the https://ppp.mef.gov.kh/project-development-facility PPP Law of Yes Public-Private thePartnerships Project establishAccording Yes to article (GDPPP) Development 10(2) of should Facility the PPP (PDF) have the toreg Law, pr fo Section 3 (1) Pursuant toNo n/a Decree (Decree of CARPA n/a n/a / 035 organizing n/a No . 2008 Yes and Section 8 (new) creating NoNational the Decree No. 2008/011 of PPP Partnership Contracts n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Yes Yes If the project is receiving federal funds, then No Article 13 of n/a the PPP ordinance n/a establishes an n/a institutional n/a framework No n/a for steering No PPPs which includes: a National Commissio Yes Article 2 and Infrastructure 3 of the Concessions Law and Fund 2018 (Fondo Articles Law No. 22Infrestructura de 21.082, bis and 22 the ter Comments creation S.A. of Yes the Organic of the (FOINSA) Infrastructure Law of MOP According toYes Article ("OL FundMOP"). wasof 14.3 the Concessions approved through Yes According to CPPPC website, China PPP the China Fund (which 2016 Private Public The provides China Partnerships Public financial Comments Private support Center Yes Partnership to ("CPPPC") PPP projects, Pursuant Fund is mainly not (China toYes Article only responsible PPP 7A project Fund), of Circular preparation): for approved the policy Issuing on by the resea St http:/ No Functions attributed the different ton/a n/aPPP unitsn/a by the PPPComments Law and the Yes regulatory applicablea) No decrees Article 11.3 PPP Law: When the PPP moda No According to of the PPP Law Article 19 n/a n/a and Article n/a 3 of then/a PPP Unit Decree, No n/a the UC-PPP the following missions:a. to imp haveNo n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 15 of n/a establishes: PPP Regulation n/a to theComments n/a In addition Yesfor the start requirements According of the to procedure No set article 15 the PPP of forth Regulation in article 7 of Art. 4 and 5 Pursuant toNo of Decree n/a n/a n/a No. 2018-359 of March n/a 29, 2018 relating No n/a to attribution, Yes organization and functioning of the No Act on the Article 3 of the n/a of the n/aEstablishment Agency for n/a Comments Investments Yes Pursuant toNo and Competitiveness (OG 53/2012, Article 56/2013, 9 (10) of Act, the the PPP 152/201 No According to n/a provided the information n/a n/a on the Ministry of Finance Comments No for then/a website Yes Department 11 "State Budget" within the S n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a No n/a No Yes PPP Unit's attributions Theas are follows PPP Fund pursuant 2017 Article to article 7 of n/a of the 6 the PPPPPP LawNoestablishes Law: n/a - To watch a PPP the implementation, Fund Yes to support financially the imple the evaluation, the s No PPP Law Article 9 of the describes the n/a n/a functions n/a and attributions Comments No of the It provides:No PPP Unit. n/a "1) Administrative functions;a) Pr No PPP Law Article 6 of the states the n/a n/a responsibilities n/a of the PPP Comments Yes Unit in Ecuador andArticle includes: 5 of 6.1. No Define the General sectors Resolution in which the us for the Pr No Article 16 of n/a the PPP Law provides,n/a "The PPP Central n/a Unit shall n/a be competent No n/a to provide No financial, and legal expertis technical, No Article 14 of n/a PPP Law: "PROESA board n/a of directors n/a shall have the following Comments Article Yes functions, in 19 all matters of NoPPP Law: that pertain "The to this ministry financ oflaw: a n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments No n/a No No According to n/a article 12 of n/a the PPP Proclamation, n/a Comments which addresses duties and responsibilities the No n/a No of the Directorate General, it n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments No n/a No Art. 2 of the Pursuant toNo n/a PPP Unit Decree n/a (Decree n/a No. 2016-522 Yes n/a dated 27 April 2016 According relating toto Article Yesthe mission R.2221-1 of support the fin of the Public A No The PPP Unit n/a n/a Decree n°000155/PR/MPIPPP of n/a 18 May 2018 n/a No on the powers, n/a organization functioning of the Steering Com andNo Article 9(2)n/a Pursuant toNo Law, the Public of the PPP n/a Comments n/a and Private Yes Agency Cooperation Pursuant shall, within toYes Article 10 of the PPP its competence, Law, the perform Mi the f No In respect of n/a Partnership Deutschland n/a (PD), as n/a a public company, Comments No holistic PD offers n/a No organizational advice and sup strategy and Yes Section 27(1) Project of the PPP Development Act provides that 2018 the Facility PIAD The shall promote National Policy on Comments efficiency Public Yes Private effectiveness Partnerships and According Yes to inhad section the provided development 37(11) of that the PPPGover the and Act, a implem Yes PPP Law Article 4 of the specifically The Ministry mentions of Development 2020 the PPPestablishment Law, andArticle Investments Comments and 29, paragraph responsibilities No created4a PPP n/a (as of project amended the Special Yes preparation in 2020) mechanism, Secretariat. Article 4 of the which it No According to n/a Article 7 of the PPP Regulation, n/a n/a the Comments ANADIE is responsible Yes for ensuring Article 37.b) Noof the with the compliance PPP Law the PPP indicates that Law and aR its article 10 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law: n/a in ordern/a to assist Contracting n/a Yes Authorities in Article implementation of theof 10-2No their PPP PPPs provides Decree that and ensuring No n/a Circular BM/UCG/PPP/024/11-12 n/a on the creation n/a of the central n/a management No n/a unit Private Partnerships. Article 10 o for Public No No According to n/a Art.11 of Decree 64/2019, n/a the PPP n/a Comments Superior Council withYes the support Pursuant toYes articles of the Technical Secretariat 18 and 19will of PPP have the(re Law fo n/a Yes 2018 Pursuant to Article Government 2 ofGovernment Comments Decree Decree No. No. No 233/2018n/a 233/2018. of the Investment Preparation Fu on the useNo Yes Partnership The Public Private (PPP) The India Cell 2013 Infrastructure is responsible The Project Scheme forn/a matters and Guidelines Development Fund Yes of concerning (IIPDF): the Public India In addition Private https://egazette.nic.in/WriteReadData/2022 Infrastructure to No Partnerships, the presence Project Development of the Ministry including Fun o policy, sch Yes According to The the art. 376 ofProject the Bappenas Development 2018 The Regulation Facility Ministry № 4/2016, within Comments the theMinistry of FinanceYes issued main functions of the There MOF Finance: ofReg the is http://kpbu.djppr.kemenkeu.go.id/fa 73 no Directorate No approval on July 13, of2018 Public to requirementPrivate clarify for every and o P Partn Participation The Private No Order mentions n/a n/a in Article n/a 1 provides n/a a definition n/a No No of: E) Organization: Country Management and Plan n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a No n/a No No (1) NDFA Functions: n/a Procurement functions n/a n/a are described of NDFA Comments in detail Yes in "Guidelines According State No toto (Section "General PSCAuthorities Condition regarding the Na No According to n/aDecisionn/a Government n/a 3012 of 03.09.2017 onComments Multi-annual YesInfrastructure The Mandatory No Tenders Development Regulation Program provides in Israel: 2. To ta Yes Article 1, paragraph Name: 589, Fondo of Law 28 December Rotativo 2018 per Section 2015, No. 171 208. n/a of Law la Progettualità Article No. (FROP) 18 No 145/2018 managed of (https://www.gazzettaufficiale.it/eli/id/2018 n/a by Cassa Law 183/2011 (Stability Depositi No Act Prestiti e 2012) Website: Article https: 33 of Decr No According to n/a section the PPP Policy, n/a 4.0.2.5(a),n/a "responsibilities Comments No with respect n/a PPPs No to specific [of the DBJ's PPP Unit] are as foll Yes PFI Project Assistance Private Finance Committee that is Initiative 2013 established Promotion with Chapter the 5 (Article Corporation PFI Promotion 0 No 31-65) ofthe of Japan Corporation PFIn/a (http://www.pfipcj.co.jp/) Act No - Article 45 of the PFI Act (as amen Yes According to Account Article 7 of the PPP Law, of Public the Private PPP Article 2020 Partnership Unit 8 of shall "assume the n/aProjects Law PPPthe following providestasks: No n/a :1- that " A. Helping A separate No government agencies account establis shall be in identi Article 26 of Pursuant toYes the LLP PPP Law:1. Project "Kazakhstan 2014 The Government According Preparation to Comments ofGovernment the Republic Fund" YesDecree of Kazakhstan on (https://kppf.kz/), Pursuant Determine a joint determines toventure Article Yes the 21 between the Legalof goals, Entity the PPP JSC objectives, to Support Law, theand "National ce H the Yes Section 19 of The the PPP Act provides Public Private that the Partnerships Directorate 2017 Section 81 Project shall of Comments the Facilitation be PPPlead the Yes Act establishes institution Fund Clausethe in the Project 3.8 implementation Yes of the Facilitation Policy Statement of Fund. a public The private Fund wa requires p a Yes Article 23 (1) Infrastructure of the PPP 1994 Act regardingCredit the Establishment Guarantee The FundServices of is established PIMAC n/a - https://www.kodit.co.kr/html/english/serv_kodit/infra_gua Public Yes under SECTION The process Investment 4 Infrastructure No Management of obtaining Center Credit forGuarantee Infrastructure approval FundF is regulate Article 16 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law n/a n/arelated to n/a the PublicComments Yes Private Partnerships Committee Pursuant to (PCPC) Yes Article 16 :1. (7)Committee The Law, of the PPP for the Publ No PPP Law Article 6 of the provides, "The n/a n/a(KAPP) shall n/a Authority Yes and cooperate n/a collaborate Article 2with of the Yes the Public PPP provides, LawEntities the for"In imple accord Article 9 ofProject Pursuant toYes the PPP Law, the2014 authority Development Support Pursuant of the Facility toComments Resolution (https://mineconom.gov.kg/en/direct/7/192). authorized Yes public No. 147/2014: agency Pursuant 1. Create shall toNo Article a fund include the following: 10 forof financing implementing the -PPP Law, the if the prepara of the PPP n/a Chapter VIIINo n/a Decree is dedicated to n/a the Committee Comments for Investment No n/a Promotion ManagementIts article 61 provid and No Finance and The CentralNo n/a Contracting n/a Agency (CFCA) supervisoryYes n/a is the Comments institution Article and a PPP 8(2) competence of the PPP Law No center provides within the the Min follo The PPP law covers then/a No n/a of the Council responsibilities n/a in the n/a art. 4 to 6, No n/a 11 and 12. No to the PPP Law, art. 4, the Thus, according No defines Resolution 1290 Nothe functions n/a of the CPMA n/a as follows: 2 . Define Comments Yesthe following Pursuant functions toYes Articles of the Central 23-25 Project of the Resolu PPP Manage article 9 of n/a Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP institutional Decree: n/a The PPP Yes n/a Unit has the following Pursuant missions: toYes 1. to assist article Decree 7.6 ofand 2017-149, advise t the Natio provides the The PPP ActNo n/afunctionsn/a of the PPP n/a Commission in Section Yes Comments 10(2) and Section According 11:“10.__(2) to Yes the PPP Act, Section Without 38(1) "On derogation c from No introduction After the official n/a n/a of PPP 9th Malaysia under then/a Plan, theYes Comments Privatization Section and Private of Finance 4.0 No Initiative the Public Partnership PrivateUnit was esta No Decree n/a Article 2 of the n/a no2017-0050/PM-RM indicates n/a n/a the Yes PPP Unit missions: ToArticle supply11 assistance Yes anof and requires the PPP Law the Minist an expertise to the section 3B n/a Pursuant toNo of the PPPA, n/a the BOT Projects n/a Unit n/a Yes an assessment shall - (a) make According of to aYes project PPP Manual section submitted 2.6 to it : The and co give Yes Articles 8, 23 the PPP Law and 24 ofFONADIN: https://www.fonadin.gob.mx/ 2008 and internal FONADIN isComments governed regulations by of the Finance Yes the decree Ministry. PPP Law that Articles No it, 21, created the24 trust and Articles 31 its agreement, 34 to rul No Article 14 (1) n/a of the PPP n/athat then/a Law provides Comments competence of the Agency Yes is to:a)Pursuant coordinate the Article toNo 13 of the beginning PPPpublic-priva of the Law, the M No According to the information n/a provided n/a on the website n/a Comments of the PPP Division Yes online,According its main functions to Nothe Concessions Law, art. are:"- developing and app 9.5, " No According to 18 of the PPP the ArticleNo Agency (MIA): n/a Law, then/a 1) approves Comments Yes project According proposals to on Yes public-private Article partnership 33, paragraph in ac 9 of the P Yes The PPP Unit created by the has beenMohammed Decree 2020 Law VI Investment No. 4075-15 Fund n° 76-20 of adopted the 15th Comment Yes on february 31 December 2016 Pursuant 2020toestablishes No the PPP establishing, within Decree, Mohammed thethe awarding VI Investm Directorate pr for n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Yes No Regulations states that the M Article 6 of PPP Article 12.3(4) Pursuant toNo n/aPolicy, the n/a of the PPP n/a of PPP Center functionsComments Yes shall be Pursuant as follows: to(a) No Article 11.4(6) Carryout of PPP Policy, feasibility Proj study, inde No by then/a PPP is promoted n/a State of the Netherlands n/aon the governmental n/a No n/a No website www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/publiek-p No ITU is specified The role of the n/a n/a in the Updated n/a Procurement n/a Yes Rules. According to the The Treasury Updated Yes Procurement Vote team recommend Rules, Rule (or not) 64(1), " Article 3 ofn/a Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Regulations, n/a (General DGIP Direction Yes Comments of Public Investment) Pursuant to performs Article 16 No of following the functions: the PPP Law, selecti No PPP Law Article 4 of the n/a provides: A n/a Public-Private n/a Support n/a Partnership YesStructure Article is hereby 5 of the Yes PPP created inLaw charge provides: The Minist of :- providing su No Section 20 of n/aprovide:n/a the ICRC Act The Commission n/a shall:a. Comments Yes of everyAccording take custody concessionto NoSection 6 of agreement the PPP made Policy under Act this "The No Article 13 of the PPP Law: n/a(...) the Government n/a of the Republic n/a of North Comments YesMacedonia Pursuant has established Article a toNo 50Public of the PPP Law: Private "if on Partnersh Yes According to The the PPP Act, Project Section 4(2), Project Development "without Section prejudice Facility Development 11Facility (IPDF): of n/a tothe thePPP (IPDF): www.ipdf.gov.pk. generality Act Yesestablishes of the Developed According The powers in the 2022 Viability Viability conferred under to YesGap Gap the Regulation Fund. by Fund PPP subsection Act 9 ofa as via the non-lapsable amendment PPP (1),Regulat the Au f No Article 12 of n/a the PPP Law provides:n/a "For the purposes n/a Comments of this Law, the Yes Secretaría Nacional Article 18 de No of the (PPP APP PPP Law National states in its last par Secretariat) is No Part III of the n/a specifically: PPP Act. More n/a n/a 15.FUNCTIONS OF Comments THE PPP CENTRE. No n/a (1)The of the PPP Centre are to -(a)enco functionsNo No PPP Law: Article 9 of the "the functions n/a n/a of the n/a Public-Private Comments Partnership Article Yes Project Unit 17 are: a. ofYes the To promote PPP Law: and coordinate "Previous with assessm Yes Articles 9 and PPPPrivate 23 of theThe Investment Regulations 1996 regulate Article Promotion the functions 19 ofFund the PPP of (FONCEPRI) Comments Law DGPPIP Yes and and Proinversion, The Article 28 of therespectively. Yes PPP regulatory framework Regulation. "Article in Peru 9. General "Article 19 of the Di (Legislativ Yes No. 8, series Executive Order Project Development of 2013and 2010 outlines Pursuant theMonitoring powers Section Comments andFacility functions of Executive 2 (d) Yes Under of the PPPOrder Center, Section No.as Yes 8, the 2.9 PPP of a) follows: Center theConduct BOT Law shall project cover IRR, facili all the apt Article 16a No Pursuant toNo n/a The tasks of the PPP Act, n/a Comments of the minister responsible Yes for regional Article 18 development No of in terms the PPP Law of thethat stipulates incl Lawcons No Article 35 of n/a the PPP Law sets out the n/a mission n/a and roles of the PPP Unit Comments Yes (UTAP). Furthermore, Pursuant toYes Article Article 34 14 defines (1), (2) and the nature (3) of of the P No of executive In the absence n/a the PPP n/a regulations, n/aDepartment’s n/a responsibilities No n/a are No listed incidentally in different provisions of Yes The previous The Fund PPP Unit (i.e., the Central for theUnit 2018 financing Pursuant for of the Coordination theto PPP Comments Article contracts 13PPP) of Yes of the (inappears Romanian, PPP GEO: Pursuant to be 3) "Fondul In disbanded toNo Article de order to finanţare establish 44 (b) of followingaand the contractor PPP abrogation use GEO public No. pa fun of de 88/ No Article 10 of n/a the PPP Law Pursuant to provides:n/a n/a this Law, Rwanda Comments No Development n/a plays the Board No following role:1º to issue gene n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments No n/a No No NCP Regulation Article 4 of the n/a n/a "Without provides, comments n/a prejudice to the specializations Yes and responsibilities Article Yes15 of the 14 and other entities, Regul of Implementing the Ce Yes PPP Law Article 7 of the establishes aPartnership Public-Private 2021 “[…] Article structure Support called 11 ofcomments the the PPP Fund Law Yes "National establishes Public-Private Article a support 21 ofYes fund PPP Law Partnershipfor Support public-private provides Unit� which that partnersh the has t UNAP No Article 68 of n/a the PPP Law lists the competencies n/a n/a Comments of the PPP Yesand provides Commission According that the to NoPPPPPP the Law, Article Commission shall: 27, for (1) a PP assist No Section 28 of n/a the PPP Act n/a establishes the functions n/a of the n/a PPP Unit:"(1) No n/a public awareness, ... (a) develop No education and sensiti No The key roles of the CP2M, n/a as detailed n/a on the website n/a Comments of the Ministry Yes of Finance, Section are to:(a) 3.2.2(b) Yes with work government of the agencies PPP Handbook, to provid No According to the Proposal n/aon Technical n/a Assistance n/a for PPPs, Part 2, section Comments Yes 2.2, "<…> The the Act Ministry on Budget Yes of Rules doesn't Finance of the Slovak vest Rep an app No According to n/a the PPP Act, n/a "the ministry Article 20(1), n/a responsible Comments No for finance n/a "Ministry") (hereafter, No shall establish a special org n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a No n/a Yes No According to the PPA, art. n/a122(1), "The n/a generaln/a functions of the Unit are: n/a Yes(a) Policy According guidance to and No capacity the building- Concessions defining Manual, con Sectio Yes According to The Southern the PPP Manual, "theThe National Africa Southern Treasury In August Africa Development has Development 2006, a Community Comments dedicated the SADC Community PPP (SADC) Yes Unit HeadsProject which ofAccording (SADC) State Preparation has Project the to adopted Yes following theand Preparation and section signed Development core 16.4.2 functions: and the of Protocol Developmen the Facility provid on (P •TreasuFi n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Yes No According to article 324.6 LCSP, in the scope No According to Finance Circular, the Publicn/a n/a Section n/a 5, "the recent Yes institutional n/a significant According change to Nothe in Guidelines this regard ison the creation PPPs, of t Section No PPP Actn/a Article 7 of the n/a of the n/a lists the powers Partnershipn/a Council which No include,n/a No without limitation, the following: (i) to provi n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a Yes No According to article 13 of the Ordinance on f No According to n/a Article 5 (1) of the PPP n/a Law, the PPP shall have the n/a Council Comments Yesfollowing According objectives: to Yes To submit to - Resolution the No. Government 290, o the membe Yes (established The PPP Centre, Private Public under Partnership 2015 Section 4 of Pursuant the Facilitation PPPtoAct) Comments Section Fund 10A fulfils Yes the of following the PPPThis functions Act,is regulated there is No (as a Public under under Section Private Section 5 Partnership the of7B the Act) ofPPP Fac PPP Yes Public-Private The main responsibilities 2019 of SEPO are set out in The PartnershipSections Promotion Fund is 12regulated and Fund 21 of Comments Yes the PPP under PART Act; VI Under of the SEPO has PPPNo to SectionAct: prepare 29PUBLIC-PRIVATE of the the PPP arrangement Act, the proposa plan PARTNERSH Yes Article 8 of Decree-Law 28/2019, theFund Infrastructure 2016 Decree Organic Law of the LawMinistry Comments no. 13 /2016, Yes18 May, of Finance, According as amended governs and by to Noregulates Article 3(3) Decree-Lawtheof 43/2020, Infrastructure the PPP Law, Fun states: "N the No According to n/a Article 3 of the PPP Unit n/aDecree ,n/a the PPP Unit n/a Yes has the following responsibilities: Article 20 ofYes "- draw the Law PPP up national strategy a provides fo that Minis n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes No According to n/a Section the PPP Policy, n/a 7.2, "<…> n/a The responsibilities Comments YesPPP Unit of the According are as follows: toNo the PPP Policy, - Develop and disseminate Section PP 7.4, "be Yes Article 1 of Presidential Decree The Public-Private n° 2022-451 2022ofDecree-Law May 6, (PPP) Partnership 2022, Comments No. Support concerning 2021-21 Yes of Fundthe created 28 December Article under7 organization2021, Article and of the No the onPPP 13 attributions the ofLaw Finance the (2022 of LawLaw No. Finance the49-2015 ofthe for Act. the Ge yead No Presidential Article 9 of the No. 13 on the n/a Decreen/a Comments n/aDepartment of the Strategy Yes According and to NoArticle 4 of the BOT Law No. 39 Budget (https://www.mevzuat.gov.tr/Mevz Yes Section 11 of The the PPP Act outlines Projectthe 2015 Facilitation functions Section Development of the29 PPP PPP Comments Fund. Actwhich Unit, provides It has Yes includes forestablished not the serving Section establishment as 23(4) yet, a secretariat No and the ofofusing the PPPthe and Act Project same technical addresses Facilitation website arm of to De the tt ci Noand 22 of (1) Articles 21 the PPP Law; n/a n/a(2) Paragraphs n/a 4(2.8)-4(2.10) Comments Order of the of Yes According President toof Article No Ukraine 13No. of the 634/2011, dated Procedure of c3 No Article 11 of PPP Law provides, the Dubai n/a n/a internal committee " Ann/a n/a named Yes the "Partnership Article 8 of the Yes Dubai PPP Committee" be formed willLaw at each provides, "a. A No The IPA is responsible n/a for n/a the overall project delivery n/a system; the projects, Comments For Yes people, and a project Yes with processes that thetogether featurescreate of the the case st righ No For transportation n/a the Transportation projects, n/a n/a Public-Private Comments Partnership n/a No Advisory No Committee must review and certify that a No Article 13 of the PPP Law n/a Creates the n/aPublic-Private Comments n/a Participation Projects Yes Unit which According will depend Yes to article hierarchically 18 of PPP Law, on the Ministr the asses Noresponsibilities The roles and n/a n/a of the n/a PPP development agency Comments No with different are defined n/a Noof detalization in Article 12 of levels n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a Yes the Government Tenders Act pro Section 3 ofYes Yes Article 2 of Decision PPP No. 369/QD-BCDPPP Project2013 Development dated for PDFFor 2016 November Fund PDF, Decision (PDF) for PPTAF Comments 23, under 2016 No.ODA on Yes 1552/QD-BKHDT promulgating Project by Article ADB dated the and 91 of regulation 19 No AFD the October PPPof namedLaw:" the 2018 P3SPl Duties Public (replacing development - Private and power Decisi a Par According to the PPP Amendment No n/a Act, n/a Sectionn/a Comments 3, which repeals Yes and replaces Section According 4 of the to PPP Yes the Act, PPP "(1) Act, there Section 19(1), "sub is established According to section 34(2) Yes Project Theof Preparation 2016 the Zimbabwe Investment Infrastructure and Development and Comments Development Yes Fund Agency Bank (PPDF) of managed According Act Zimbabwe №by to the No Procedure the 10/2019 PPA, Infrastructure [Chapter Section Manual 14:37]: 20(3)(a)(i), and Development "(2) Disburse The"be Pu B The Ministry of Planning No and Finance n/a n/a n/ahas established the Project Comments No and Progress Appraisal n/a No Reporting Department (PAPRD) as a According to the Decree No n/a on the Ministry n/a of Economic n/a Commentsart. Development, Yes5.2.28(187) According to (190), to “the No the PPP Ministry Law, art. 10(4), “if Deve of Economic durin Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q6.2_A Q6.1_1_TEXT Q6.2_B Q6.2_1_TEXT Q6.2_2_TEXT Q6.2_C Q6.3_A Q6.2_3_TEXT Q6.3_1_TEXT 6.2. If yes, please Does the provide Ministry relevant If yes, please of legal/regulatory 6.2Finance Reporting provide (or the If yes, government relevant liabilities provisions: please 6.2 (explicit provide legal/regulatory Accounting moreand broadly) the If implicit, relevant liabilities yes, please have provisions: direct legal/regulatory 6.3. a(explicit provide specific If and yes, contingent) the and please system If yes, relevant implicit, provisions: indicate please of: arising Budgeting direct legal/regulatory provide which from and for the of contingent PPPs the PPP relevan provi (e.g., proj follow n/a Yes No The PPP Law provides under n/a "Affordability No ProtectionNo andn/a Article 23:(1) The Public Private P of User" in n/a Article 10 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a No the� Ministry n/a responsible No for finances� n/a No evaluates n/a and approves in advance all concessio n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No According to n/a Article 6 of PPP Law, expenses No n/a and No incurred contributions in connection with PPP project n/a Article 4 ofPursuant Pursuant toYes toNo the the PPP Law, for Article the objectives 2 of the PPP n/a No of managing Law paragraph fiscal n/a risks 1(16) Permissible No and ensuring fiscal n/a limit of PPP contingent sustainability, liabilities the authorize Yes According to According Section 3.1 of the NSW to Yes the PPP Guidelines, NSW PPP According Guidelines, "Government to Yes the NSW approval Section Budgeting 6.1, NSW The will "Responsible PPP for be NoGuidelines required Agencies n/a Availability atin based various Section are required PPPs project 6.1 Guideline provides to milestones prepare that (p. and 6) thr de Res Yes Art. 60. (1) of Section the Federal Budget 60Act of Yes states the Federal that Section Budget the competent Act Yes 60.3 of regulates the line ministry European Federal particular Budget shall System budgetary No Act mandates of reach agreement Accounts requisites n/athatapplicable with to be within the one met Federal month in order Minister from according ex t to th Yes The Ministry For of Economy shall aid cooperation coordinate No and with the guarantee n/a Ministry No obligations of Financefinancing, the draft each n/a investment No year a agreement n/a certain amount with is allocated the tech winner,to th n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to of the PPP Law, Article 10 n/a No the Ministry n/a of Finance No shall "consider n/a No and n/a concerning public-private p evaluate offers n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No ESA 2010 (European n/a regulation 549/2013 article 91 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a n/a No signed contracts are No n/a sent by the No national direction n/a controlling public procurement cont Article 18 (1) Pursuant toNo n/a No of the Sarajevo PPP Law, n/a prior to No n/a the Decision No partner on the private n/aselection, the competent publ n/a Yes No According to n/a Section the PPP Policy, No5.2, "Government n/a No Sponsoring n/a Institutions have the primary respon n/a Yes Yes According to III, of article 10,The contingent the PPP YesLaw, liabilities The or National financial obligations fiscal Yes risks Treasury assumed undertaken Secretariat IPSAS in the by 32 (PPPs) Public context is empowered of Administration wasPPP adopted contracts to deve bym t n/a Yes Article 155 n/a Pursuant toNo Yes of the Concession Law:The (1) The European monetary No System of n/a Accounts proceeds (ESA 2010)fees for sta from concession n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 15 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a No a partnership n/a contract No may be n/a Nocontracting signed by the n/aauthority only after the agree Yes According to Article article 10(7) 4 of of the PPPthe NoLaw, PPP Lawn/a provides regarding Approval under No ofroles the Final n/a responsibilities and the PPP Draft ofNo of Contract: the n/a "After Ministry Economy of the and Finan conclusion of n n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Contract approval n/a by the No (TP) is Treasury Board n/a required, as No the Supply No set out inn/a n/a Manual, "Public-Private Partnerships (P3s) m n/a Yes No PPP Ordinance Article 9 of the n/a provides No : The total No present n/a cumulative value of firm and conditional qu n/a No Concessions Article 8 of the Yes n/a Law determines Thethe that Contingent Contract Yes Liabilities awarded will bePPP contingent Report (Informe through Yes liabilities ade Supreme Pasivos Resolution Decree Contingentes) 16/2015 are annuallyof included theissued Ministry elaborated in the by of Co Co P Yes Article 16 of Article 18 Interim Measures for ofYes Interim the Measures Administration Article 29 of forFinance Yes the of Interim Administration for Measures Public-private Chapterof for V of Finance No thePartnership Administration for Interim Measures Public-private n/a Projects of forFinance provides the Partnership Administration for Public-priv that Project after of th n/a Yes Yes Article 26 of Availability the PPP Law governs thepayments Yessystemfor by Lawwhich 448 PPPs of and future 1998 No contingent regarding n/a liabilities reserves treatment required are to reported pay of contingent for PPP project in the me liabi n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a 2009-160 of Decree No. No 20 May 2009 n/a No laying down n/a the procedures No approving No forn/a n/a public procurement contracts provides at its n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Art. 24 of the Pursuant toNo No (Decreen/a n/aPPP Decree No. 2018-358 No of March n/a No 29, 2018 relating n/a Private Partnerships contrac to Public n/a Yes No According to Article 4b n/a (1) of the PPP PPP YesRegulation, the treatment application No by the for European n/a issuance of System prior consent of Accounts (ESA of the M Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording No to Act, the Budgetary §186(1), n/a in case Yes Display of ofconcession PPPs Methodology, According contracts No to“the "in theorder European to displayn/a of close System PPP aprojects contract of Accounts in contracting athe 2010, state wh buda n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a System of Accounts 2010, wh the European article 8.2. n/a Pursuant toNo No the Ministry of the PPP Law, No n/a of Economy and Finance n/a No acknowledges n/a PPP contract with all notices the n/a Yes Yes Article 23 of the PPP Law Article states: 23 "Powers of the PPP No the of Law n/a Ministry states: "Powers No of of the Finance. The n/a Ministry Ministry Finance. ofof willMinist FinanceThe fulfill n/a Yes No Article 34 of the Regulation n/a for theNo PPP law establishes n/a No that n/a the limit of the value of a PPP contract can n/a No n/a Yes Article 15(2) No Law provides, of the PPPn/a n/a No "No later than three months from the en n/a Yes No Article 19 of n/a PPP Law: "Functions of Yes Article the Ministry 19 of No of Finance:PPP (...) d) Provide Law: n/a financial "Functions of the opinion Ministry favor in of or Finan n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Regulation of n/a Standards Board on the Ap the Accounting Nobasis No regulatory n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a ESA 2010. Furthermore, the decree of State budget (124 Yes According to Pursuant Article R. 2223-1 of to the Yes Public Article R2212-9 Acquisition The circular of the Code: Public of May Yes "A Acquisition partnership 9, 2012 All European Code: contract No relating to countries thepartnership may budgetary only follow n/a be contracts sustainability signed the European requires by thestudy State System takes with that ofint any A thd n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 10 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Law, Yes Article the Ministry Atthe 29 of of thePPP end Finance Law: of Yes 1. of 2018, The Georgia Georgia upper Statelimit performs amended Treasury of Yesthe (under thethe state following country's the liability IPSAS Ministry main Fiscal within functions of Rules the Finance) (Organic related framework actively Law toof pub co th o n/a Yes to PPP projects, Not specificYes but the The budgetaryYes relevant information provisions According exist, to related to NothePPP inEuropean general, projects n/a for can the be System of large found Accounts construction in the 2010, pro annual b wh and 37 of the Sections 36 Yes Public Section 33Private of Yes PublicSection Financial thePartnership Act, 33Management 2020 of Yes the PFM (Act 1039) Act Section Act, explicitly and 17 2016 Regulations (a) (Act Yes mentions of921) the 23, Public which reporting Section 24, Private deals and 17 25 liabilities with (b) Partnership of of the Multi-Year the Public for multi-year Act, Financia Public Privat 2020 Expend Yes According to The the PPP law Special No Secretariat (3389/2005, Article 3), n/a (PPP the Minister Unit) Yes of Economy regularly Greece and publishes on applies Development, its No the European website n/a having System theall (sdit.gov.gr) competency data of Accounts, of on the which the co total Pu n/a Yes No Article 31 of the PPP Law n/a regulatesNo commitments budgetary n/a n/a PPPs: In cases where the PPP No arising from n/a Yes Organic LawNo of public finance n/a (L/2012/012/CNT) No n/a in terms ofn/a provides,No budget, an authorization of enga n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Paragraph 5 of article 18 Yes of PPP Article of No 26Law the (as PPP Law n/a reformed by Decree states No that the No. 115-2014) n/a and amounts limits No states that of quantifiable once n/a the content of a firm and PPP contract contingent commha n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No commitments The public sector n/a to the existing PPP proje n/a No n/a Yes The Estimation Yes of Contingent Liabilities No of The Estimation from Contingent n/a Liabilities PPP-User for Online Manual from Toolki PPP-User M n/a Yes Yes The MOF Reg 260/2016, According art. 8 to 10 No to are MoF the devoted Decree n/ato the description (KMK)No№ 222/2016 ofn/a theon budget allocations for the Management Gove ofmakin n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No is agreed Budget for PPPs Yesin Chapter n/aand set out Ireland 4 "Non-Exchequer follows No the European n/a System Investment" of National in the and Re Capital Plan. It n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Israel Government Yes Accounting The Standards Board Israel Government app Accountin n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No All European follow the European System of A countries n/a n/a Yes Yes According to According to the FAAA Instructions, Yes Section the PPP6.4.3, Policy, According Section "(i) public No All to the 5.0.1, investment PPP the n/a "- Policy, Ministries, Section proposals/projects 2.0.1.4, Departments "themust, and as PublicA n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 10 of the PPP Law There provides No that " A. A technical is a requirement n/a to publish committee aNo report on each n/a the called PPP(Technical project which Committee for includes i Article 21 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Law, Yes Article 9 ofPursuant the the central authorized PPP Law: toYes 1. body Article Financing 23(5) forAccording budget of ofthe theexecution PPP public-private to NoArticle Law, the (i.e. 12(3) authorized Ministry n/a partnership of theof PPP body Finance): project Law, of the while can respective 1) be implem carrie implemen provides in The PPP ActNo sections 59 n/a Yes and 60: "59. Section 19(2)(f) Approval of project No of the and PPP n/a financial Act provides No that the n/aPPP risk assessment reports Directorate by the Committee shall (1 monitor n/a Yes Yes under This This is regulated CHAPTER is regulated II No INFRASTRUCTURE Article 7 under n/a PROJECTS of No the PPP SECTION n/a Act, 1 Master which requires Plan for for Public-Priva the Master P Article 16 (7) Pursuant toYes of the Article paragraph No 3, PPP Law, the 1.18 PPPC n/a shall of the PPP No Law make decisions indicate n/athat the on the No financial approval ofobligations projects n/a to be and borne by the agreements maj by aPubl No PPP Law Article 2 of the provides, "In n/a No accordance n/awith this No n/aCommittee Law, a Higher n/a No called the "Higher Committee for Public-P n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 32 of n/a the Budget Code:1. Budget Yes Pursuant investments toNo Article for 119 n/a the of the implementation Budget Code: of Accountin 1. public-priv n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes of the PPP Law Article 9(5) Yes Supervisory Yes PPP provides, <...> Institution in order Article Regulation to 9(5) No of that ensure the Article PPP the Law 7 n/a provides, PPP does not provides, <...> have <...> thean in order unacceptab public to ens partne n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No The Ministry must ascertain of Financen/a According Yes the compliance requirements to Yes The before Articles 37-40 of the Order theNo PPP PPP No1К-435 Resolution, negotiations n/a of Minister are thethe Procuring concluded, of Finance Authority and on the mus awa the 2 article 9 of Pursuant Pursuant toYes the PPP Law toYes article and articlePursuant 8.6 43.4-7 of of the PPP toNo the Decree article Law, 43.4-7 The 2017-149, n/a Public of the authority the Ministry NoLaw, PPP has The of toFinance Public publish n/a person must everyapprove has to year a list publish any the ever PP ofcontra Yes According to Section Section 57(6) 32(1) of the No PPPof Act "prior the n/a PPP to the Act states signing No a "duty of ato include PPP contract, n/a the project PPP No Commission costs n/a shall obtain in annual the written budgets:" app "32.__(1) Su n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 22 of Articles the PPP Law requires 16 and the No Ministry 17 of Lawof no n/a 2013-028 EconomyNoto of approve n/a State July 11th PPP 2013 related No contracts to Finance n/a Laws before signature. their are related to the bud No pp. 5-11, The PPP Manual, No n/a requires n/a an approval of Ministry No n/a of Finance No in the n/a for any change terms of agreement which impac n/a Yes Yes Article 24 of Article the PPP Law establishes 14 of No that the required PPP n/a Law (last expenditures No paragraph) states will n/a be that committed following "the Ministry the prov of Finance a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No of the accounting The elaboration n/a record is performed a n/a Yes Yes According to the Concessions According Law, toart. the No Debt 9.1, "relations Management n/a No Law, related art. to the development 42.3, n/a "information of the about the draft list con of the Article 63 of Pursuant toYes the PPP PPP Law and Law, No <…> the upon n/a completion Rulebook Noof determine the the method n/a of Budgeting procedure No to referred PPP forin n/a Art. projects 61 and on the 62 of methodology this f law, the pub n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to No of the PPP Law: Article 24 n/a n/a No 1. PPPs, PGDs and ECs should have an a n/a Yes Article 13.1(1) Pursuant toNo n/a of PPP Policy No "Budgetary n/a Provisions", No n/anational level projects, PIA sha for the n/a Yes depends on PPP budgetYes The theMinistry available Yesbudget of per FinanceESA supervises Ministry 2010 No PPP of projects the n/a State of inthe TheNetherlands. has Netherlands,In a coord general, t No According to n/aProcurement the Updated Rule Yes Rules, The annual 64(1)(e), Yes Financial "agencies The considering liabilities Statements the ofYesthe in relation Government procurement The to PPP ofof projects New infrastructure Treasury Zealand must follows so-called be published with reporte a ( PB n/a Yes No PPP Law Article 8 of the n/a 935 provides, No that then/a No procuring authority n/ainclude in its project budget fo shall Yes Art. 36 of the Article 55 PPP Law provides : of The No tender the commission n/a PPP Law provides classifies No : The budgetary all n/a entry of compliant Nooperations bids. It transmits n/a relating to Public-Private this classification Partne as well as n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Article 49 of n/a the PPP Law contains provisions No n/a regulating No on the liabilities limits n/a that may be undertaken Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Section to NoK(iii), the PPPA “theAct, high-level n/a Sectionapproval Yes 4(2)(d) & (e), process According “without by relevant toprejudice No public to n/a institutions the Policies the Accounting generality follows andof Procedures the the key stag powers co Ma n/a Yes Yes Article 17 of the PPP Law: Article Functions 17 of No of the the PPPMinistry Law: n/aFunctions of Economy of the No Ministry and Finance. n/a of The Economy Ministry Finance. andof EconomyTh n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 10 of Article PPP Law states the 10Ministry of Yes of Finance the Law Article 5102/2013: has 10 to" The of PPP Yes issue Ministry Law: binding "The of Finance Article technical Ministry 10 of shall NoPPP of opinions have Finance Law: the "the in n/a shall the ministry areas following have the of functions ofits following finance" competence, in(will) the function "c. ba cont Yes 41 of PPP Articles 40 and Law and Article 36 of Article Yes PPP Law and According 55 of the the PPP article to Yesthe 41 of Regulations reporting the require PPPsystem regulation the Articles 24approval and Yes for liabilities 60 requires ofthe PPP Directorial an arising Law Ministry approval and from 141 Economy of ofResolution PPPs, of the the Public Ministry and PPP 010-2021-E Financ Regula Entitie of E Yes Section 2.12 of the BOTDepartment Law IRR provides Yes of Budget that The "[...]Development and Prior to Management Yes approval National Budget Pursuant of the Coordination Budget Head toYes Circular the of Agency/LGU, PPP Committee Governing Government No. 564, the (DBCC) issued Board draft on Resolution Accounting contract Policy 8 JuneCircular shall 2016 No. Manual unde 2015 cove No. n/a No n/a Yes Regulation of Yes Pursuant the Minister toNo of Finance Article of 1118a January of the n/a PPP on 2022 Actbudget and secondary leg reporting.R No The decision n/a to contract Yes of the Pursuant and the award PPP contract toYes Articles is a joint decision ESA 26/2 and2010 33 the No of(b) PPP Law, ofmember of n/aUTAP the Minister of Finance is responsible and for the o ela n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Article 22 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP GEO: Yes From the substantiation Pursuant Article toNo study 22 of n/a it the must show PPP GEO: to From what the substan extent the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 99 of Ministerial Decree N n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 8 lisiting PSP Law Article the functions Internal No and on Document powers the n/aWork Mechanism of the No Minister of Regulating Finance n/a PSP No (MOF) states in Projects Within n/a its paragragh (3) that the Ministry MOF shall of Finance (Int No Article 98 of n/a provides the PPP Decree No that the n/a final version No n/a is submitted of the contract No n/a to the Minister in charge of Finance fo n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Decree on the YesApplication Theof Act on the the Budget System, International Ar Accountin n/a Yes Yes under This This is regulated is regulated Section Yes 35 of theunder Public IPSAS Financial rules Section of Yes arethe 35Management mentioned Public IPSAS Actspecifically 35. rules (1) Financial are Management Theunder mentioned Minister Section shall specifi Act 87 an 35. (1 No of the PPP Section 3.2.2(b) No provides n/a Handbook, n/a that Government No n/a Entities Procuring should follow the MOF gateway No ("GPEs")n/a No According to the Policy n/a for the Implementation No of Public-Private n/a According Yes Partnership Projects to Nothe Proposal (PPPs), n/a theon rules Technical Assistance for for municipalities, PP highe n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a System of Accounts 2010, wh the European No Section 4.11 n/a of the Procurement No Manual provides, n/a "Standard No SIG contracts No n/a for different n/a types of procurements have been inc n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to the section n/a 16.6.5 of the Yes Treasury Regulation, According to Yes after the sectionThe 13.1.4 Treasury ofof the evaluation Yes the theRegulation, Treasury bids but All Regulation, prior institutions Part and 7to section the entering are accounting required into 16.7 negotiati to are rela co offic n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No European regulation n/a 549/2013 and ESA 2010 set rules fo n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No According to the Budget n/a Act, Chapter Yes7, Section 5, the main According No to the rule European n/a is that System funding for ofthe Accounts 2010,in investment whi n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Art. 1 of theYes Ordinance Accounting would on recognized be made accounting accor standa No According to n/a Resolution No. 290, the Nomembers n/a of the PPPNo n/a the following Council include No n/a of Justice; Minister of Finan : Minister n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No that the The law provide PPP Centre shall prepare the bo n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes in paragraph Article 39 povides 4 of Article 21 No that the when PPP Law n/a the specifically contractingNo authority address budgeting is the State: n/a No"(…)the stating thatpublic-private the n/a partnership PPP project contract should list it in the No Section 16(5) n/a Procurement of the Public No Regulations n/a provides No that where n/a a contracting No n/a entity initiates procurement proceedi n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes According to the Budget According law No. 2019-15 to Nothe Budgetn/a law No. of February 19, 2019-15 No 2019 article n/a 46 states of February 19,that 2019 article "an annual states 46 repor n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the ArticleAccording Public 49 of the to Finance Article the Law 49 of Manage n/a Yes Yes Section 13(2) Section of the PPP Act also 11(2) precludes Yes an Section (g) of the PPP Act11(2)(p) requires accounting officer No of the from thePPP PPP entering n/a Actto Unit into requires collate, anthe agreement analyze and PPP Unit to dis that n/a Yes Yes Article 18 of The the PPP Law provides Budget Yes for Code of Ukraine various The Budget formsintroduced of state No Code (1) of Ukraine the support n/a within approach introduced the PPP to accounting, (1) the project approach reporti implemen No Dubai PPP Article 8 of the No "a. A Partnership n/aLaw provides, n/a No Project willn/a No be approved DOF (Department of Finance), wh by:3. the n/a No A second approval n/a by the of Finance or Ministry Yes According Central Budgetary to Yes the Private PPP Finance treatment Authority is Initiative required No by thein the and n/a Private UK before European Finance System signing 2of projects: the PPP Accounts cont (ESA 2018 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to of PPP Regulatory Article 19 n/a Yes According Decree, the project's to Yes procuring Article of PPP terms 87 Article 60 Regulatory of and No the the Decree, draft PPP n/a Law of regulates the all procuring the accounting contract authorities shall treat mus be present n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a the Government Section 3 ofNo No Act provides: n/a Tenders n/a "(3) Prior No to entering n/ainto a Government No n/a Contract a minister must first:(g) e n/a Yes (d) of the PPP Article 13.2 Yes Law: Article 22 Procedures No of No. Circularforn/a making 88/2018/TT-BTC decisions No states on n/a investment as follows: policies “Article PPP for22. project Examina No According to n/a the PPP Amendment No Sectionn/a Act, 9 which amends No the Section n/a 26 ofNothe PPP Act, among others, "(26)(1) after th n/a n/a Yes According to No the Investment n/a Guidelines, No Section 114, "theNo n/a n/aof the key financing instrumen Budget is one n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a n/a Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q6.3_B Q6.3_C Q6.3_2_TEXT Q6.3_3_TEXT Q6.4 Q6.4_4_TEXT Q6.4_3_TEXT Q7 Q7_3_TEXT If yes, please 6.3 Other international 6.3 standard provide Other (e.g. the If yes, European please relevant legal/regulatory 6.4. specify System Does and the ofIfAccounts). yes, provide Ministry provisions: please of and the provide Finance relevant specify the (or legal/regulatory the 7. government relevant website: Besides the legal/regulatory If yes, procuring more provisions: please broadly) authority specify disclose the and relevant provisions: the M PPP li No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes High Economic Council and the C Yes Article 8 (6) Pursuant toNo of DCM 575/2013, n/a No The n/a risk allocation No n/a will also n/a be used as a basic tool for establishing if a P No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Ministry of Environment and No n/a No n/a Yes The PPP liabilities https://minfin.am/en/page/budget_of_ministry/ are disclosed Yes Government in the of the Republic budget message of A and can be fo No n/a Yes No Corporations n/a the Australian Act 2001 and n/a Accounting Yes The Cabinet Standards Board and (AASB) NSW Minister set fo the accou Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010 No n/a (ESA 2010) n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Cabinet Committee on Econo No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes First, apart from the Ministry of F Yes No ESA 2010 (European n/a regulation 549/2013 No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes (1) The PPP unit(2) national direc No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The PPP Commission No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The project committee and the P No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes PPI Council, Federal Audit Office Yes No System of The European n/a Accounts No (ESA 2010) n/a n/a Yes The Municipal Council - for munic No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The approval of the council of Mi No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The PPP agency approves every p No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Support Council for the Reali No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Approval-in-principle is required No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes PPP Projects are approved by the No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Concessions Commission (in No n/a Yes Yes China's government accounting Article 36 ofProject Interim standards, Management China's Measures No enterprise Library for the n/a Administration accounting of National standards. of Finance PPP for Integrated No n/a Yes National standards. No n/a Law n/a 448 of 1998 regarding Yes of contingent treatment According liabilities to the PPP Law - Article and the e No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Regulatory Authority on Pub No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Ministry of National Planning No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The CNP-PPP established by Decr Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010 No n/a n/a Yes The Ministry of Economy and Sus Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010 No n/a (ESA 2010) n/a No n/a Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010 No n/a (ESA 2010) n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Council of Ministers No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The National Council of Public-Pr No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Interinstitutional Committee No n/a Yes No The Egyptian n/a Accounting Standards n/a (EAS) are applied Yes The Supreme as issued Committee per the Decree No.243/200 No n/a Yes No National accounting n/a regulated system n/a by the articles Yes 98 and PROESA (as seq. of the the PPP Unit)Decree Legislative and Co No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010 No n/a (ESA 2010). n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes PPP Board Yes ESA 2010 No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Government of Georgia; Spe Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010 No n/a (ESA 2010) n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Although there Ministry specific is noof Finance Yes requirement website, Parliament, to disclose such asCabinet, https://www.mofep PPP PPPC, Gener liabilities o Yes No of Accounts European System n/a (ESANo 2010) n/a n/a Yes The Inter-Ministerial Committee No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Besides the Ministry of Finance, a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Administration and Control o No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes National commission of public pr No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The President of the Republic in C Yes ESA 2010. No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Hungarian Government. No n/a No n/a Yes Rule 50(3) of https://www.pppinindia.gov.in/infrastructureindia/proje the General Yes Rules provides, FinancialPPPAC "The and Cabinet detailed est Committee o No n/a No n/a Yes Contingent The liabilities are National NoAccounts reported in (LKPP) n/a whichto the Notes the Balance cover Sheet PPP continge No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Ministry of Planning Yes No the European Ireland follows Yes n/a System The of National and Parliamentary https://data.oireachtas.ie/ie/oireachtas/parliamentaryB Regional Budget Yes(ESA Accounts Office 2010) (PBO) An and prepares Eurostat Agency, a Briefing February Department Paper or 2004 Sectio gu on No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes ESA 2010 No n/a Yes Article 73 of Yes Pursuant tohttp://www.mef.gov.it/documenti-pubblicazioni/open-d the PublicPursuant Contracts to art. 200 Code and 201 of (hereinafter: t PC No n/a Yes The public sector Yes accounting Further standars https://mof.gov.jm/budgets/fiscal-policy-papers.html that are amendments to Yes used the Financial The by the Ministries, Administration Public Investment Departments and Managem Audit and Ag (FAA No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Diet No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The High Committee and the Cou Yes Article 16 of Pursuant toNo Law No. 234 n/a n/a and Financial No on Accounting n/a Reporting: Yes Line sectoral Organizations government carry and Ka out the preparati No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The PPP Committee, the Cabinet No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes PPP review committee or, in som No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant towww.pppkosova.org Article 14 of Yes The1. the PPP Law: Notwithstanding PPP Committee paragraph No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Higher Committee for PPP Pr Yes Article 2 ofn/a Pursuant toNo No Law:2-1. the Accounting n/aThe unified n/a Yes methodological Ministry basis of Economy of financial accounting and fi na No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Committee for Investment Prom Yes No Article 29 of 1152 provides, Regulationn/a Yes <...> inPursuant evaluating tohttps://www.fm.gov.lv/en/s/fiscal_policy/ Council the Directive Yesimpact estimated 2011/85/EU of The Cabinet; the on requirements thereferred conditions council of for tothe budg in lo th No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The High Council for Privatization Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010, Yes Order No. Eurostat Manual Government on 1K-489 https://cvpp.eviesiejipirkimai.lt/Notice on Approval Yes Deficit of and With the Debt. Rules regard for Providing https://ppplietuv to central PPP projec Information No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes PPP Unit No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Cabinet. No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Cabinet No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The PPP Unit No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes (1) Central Tender Board for auth No n/a Yes No General Law of Governmental n/a n/a Accounting Yes (I) The Scientific and Technologic (http://www.diputados.gob.mx/LeyesBiblio/pdf No n/a Yes No of the accounting The elaboration n/a record n/a is performed Yes Government according and district to National public St Accounting a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Government of Mongolia. No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Protector of Property and Legal I No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Interministerial Commission No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes IBN Board Yes ESA 2010 No n/a Yes Dutch government https://www.rijksoverheid.nl/documenten/kamerstukke information No is always n/a publicly available, unless t No n/a No n/a Yes The direct and https://treasury.govt.nz/publications/financial-statemen contingent Yesliabilities, The including Cabinet. the ones related to PP No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Prime Ministere after a favor No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes (2) The Authority that approves p No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No agencies The Government n/aaccountsYes n/a keep their using the set The Board of of the standards PPP Authority. described A in the T No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Governing Body (Ente Rector) No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes 1. The PPP Steering Group is a su No n/a Yes No Article 10 of n/a ministry PPP Law: "the n/a of finance" Yes Technical (will) "c. To Secretariat ensure fiscal of Planning consistency of the No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Another authority that has to issu No n/a No n/a Yes The Joint Memorandum https://ppp.gov.ph/project-database/ Yes Circular No. The NEDA Board, 2018-01 upon between the Departm recomme Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010 No n/a (ESA 2010) n/a No n/a Yes ESA 2010 No n/a Yes Pursuant tohttp://www.utap.pt/ Articles 26 No (2) and 33 (b) n/aof the PPP Law, UTAP is in cha No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Minister of Commerce and In Yes No 549/2013 Regulation EU n/a (ESA 2010) No n/a n/a Yes The National Agency for Public Pr No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Steering Committee.Article 7 No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Cabinet of Ministers No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Approving Authority could be No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes the Minister of Land Managemen No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Government;The Governmen No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Cabinet No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/aon Technical the Proposal No Assistance n/a for PPPs, n/a Yes 3.2.1, "The Part 3, section Ministry of Finance The Government in the Re of the Slovak ar Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010 No n/a (ESA 2010) n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Inter-Ministerial Concessions No n/a No n/a Yes PPP contingent http://www.treasury.gov.za/documents/national%20bu liabilities No were most n/arecently disclosed during the 20 Yes No of Accounts European System n/a No n/a n/a Yes Council of Ministers No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Cabinet of Sri Lanka No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Partnership Council. Yes No of Accounts European System n/a 2010 No n/a (ESA 2010) n/a Yes The Parliament No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Parliament would have to ap No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Prior to launching the procureme No n/a Yes No that the The law provide PPP Centre n/a n/a shall prepare Yes the books of accounts All PPP approved projectsand by reco maintain the No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Public-Private Partnership Pr No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Council of Ministers, in addit No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The PPP Unit and more precisely No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No No No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Cabinet No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes A General Commission is set-up w No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes According to Article 5 of BOT Imp No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The PPP Committee and the Cabi No n/a No n/a Yes According to https://openbudget.gov.ua/ the recently Yes changesMinisters adopted Cabinet of Ukraine. to the Budget Code of U No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Supreme Committee of Fiscal Pol Yes Norules determine The ESA 2010 n/a whether Yes or not According the PPP is to recorded https://www.gov.uk/government/publications/private-f onYes the Privateor Finance off theInitiative government's The Major Private balance andProject Review Finance sheet, Group pro 2for e No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes For transportation P3's, Federal H No n/a Yes and reporting Accounting No n/a n/aaccording to local standards. Yes The Planning According and Budget to Article Office, 87 of PPP Reguw No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Cabinet and the PPP develop No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Attorney General, Central Tender No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Prime minister, Ministries, Heads No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Public-Private Partnership Co No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Cabinet No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The President's Office and the Un n/a n/a n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes At the federal level, the Ministry Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q7_4_TEXTQ7.1 Q8_A Q7.1_1_TEXT Q8_1_TEXTQ8_B Q8_2_TEXTQ8_C Q8_3_TEXT theBesides and provide7.1. Ifthe relevant yes, legal/regulatory procuring please 8.provide Please authority provisions: the If and yes, selectrelevant the the please option legal/regulatory 8.specify The that Ministry of regulatory best and Finance yes, provide provisions: framework please If describes or Central the 8. theThe relevant way provide Budgetary prescribes procuring your the If legal/regulatory relevant government yes,authority the Authority, please need legal/regulatory elaborate for does ensures does provisions: PPPs not anyand that to evaluate other bePPP con au provi Yes According to TheThe the PPP Law, PPP Law No Central under Partnership "Power n/a Authority Yeswith and Function the of The High the Government PPP Economic Law Nounder Council "Project n/a would (Cabinet)" Identification" havein provides a Article role in 9" approving (1) The provides AP inGo n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 22 of n/a DCM No. 575/2013: No n/a 1. On the basis of the expenditure n/a No n/a No n/a Yes the National In practice, No Investment Commission makes n/a n/a Yes No According to article 16 n/a of the PPP Law, Under Yes without prejudice Article No of 11/1 specific of n/a the PPP Law, (b) competence provided one ofin the prereq Public Pr No 1 of Decree Article 5, Annex n/a 118/2017, No Article n/a 16 of PPP Law, No and Article Yes n/a 15 of Law 24.156. According to article 6 of PPP Law Yes According to point 10 of Pursuant chapter to 1 Yes Article of Section of 12(2) IIPursuant of Government of PPP toNo Law, Article The4(3) draft n/a DecisionofNthe PPP 1241-n PPP contract Law, of 20 No to shall September render n/a be approved a decision 2012 by on the PPP by the decision project Governmen of th scree Yes In terms of Cabinet NSW PPP approval, Guidelines Yes to Section according provide According 3.1 in of Section the No to NSW 3.1,PPP Section 4.2 "inn/a general, Guidelines, of the National No"ThePPP Cabinet Government PPP-related n/a approval Guidelines Policy approvals process Framework are for require docu funding n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a of the Federal the art. 58(1) No n/aAct, a project may only be exe Budget n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes There is no specific regulatory or Yes According to According the PPA, art. to 14, "the in-principle Yes the PPA, art. The <…> PPP approval 14, "the Guidelines, No <…> final for a PPP Chapter approval n/a project "Procedures shall II for No a be granted PPP project forn/a Indetification shall by the granted beCabinet Phase" Committee." by the provide Fur ad Cabinet Yes Article 14 of Article the Regulation Preparation on16 inNo the PPP stipulates Law stipulates n/a "the that project thatYes According concept "Decisions on public-private to shall No be sent Article project n/a (…) 34.1 of to the the implementation Regulation on republican Preparatio shall be m governmen No Walloon government n/a of theNo decree 2017 laying 3rd augustn/a Nodown the functioning n/a of the government. Yes Articlerequirenment No regulatory exis 3(1) of the Royal D Yes Pursuant (1)The PPP unit: to section (1) Pursuant to Yes5.1.2 section of the The 5.1.2 Decree of theNo Guidance Guidance Note, No. 2018-424 theNote n/a socio-economic September ofthe No and 19th socio-economic externalities established n/a and externalities study, a catalogue study, ofmandat mandatory for e project Article 18 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the Sarajevo toYes Article PPP 18 of Pursuant Law: 1) the prior Sarajevo tothe to No Article PPP Decision Law: 14 (4) 1) on n/a(b) prior the the to the No of private Sarajevo Decision partner PPP n/a on selection, Law, the thethe private public competent partner body selection public shall sub Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Section to Yes the PPP 5.6, "thePolicy, feasibility According Annexure to Nothe study 3,PPP report for Policy, awill n/a contract Section award conclude whether No an 5.2, "Government approval or n/a not fromproject the Public should theSponsoring Procuremen be procu Institutions h Yes According to the PPI Law, Pursuant the PPIto council Article Yes must Art. The 7 give the opinion, Law ofobligations No 13.334, to be the before the undertaken n/a consideration PPI Council by No the is tasked of the president, n/a with giving governmental of entity its the opinion proposals during prior the presen to th contrac Article 37(2) Pursuant toNo n/a Yes of the Concession Law, Pursuant the Council Noof 37 Article of the Ministers n/aConcession shall <...> No Law: <…> approve, n/a prior Theto Council the issuing thereof, of Ministers the d determ YesThe Council Art.9 PPP law: of Ministers Pursuant article toYes is responsible 9 of Pursuant the PPP for Law, adopting to article No 24 by recourse of n/a decree to PPP the is the PPP Law, made public-private No Public-private for the n/a projects partnership partnership programme appearing in the program projects appro of the Yes Article 11 of Pursuant the PPP Law provides: toNo article Any public-private 7 of n/a the PPPpartnership No Decree Agency n/a project andmust art. 15 beof No the PPP subject ton/a Law, a prior the council of by evaluation the PPP ad Ministries Ag n/a Yes No According to n/a article 10(7) No of the PPP Law, regarding n/a Approval Yes of the Final There are of Draft explicit nothe provisions"A PPP Contract: w section 10 Pursuant Pursuant toYes toNo section of the CARPA Decree 31( n/a (4) Decree No. of PPP No Decree 2008/035 No. 2008/0115/PM of n/a January 23, of January No2008, n/a organizing 24, 2008 and (regulating creating the Nationa the PPP L No in the n/a This is stipulated Yes under Section Supply Manual, On the federal 9.5.1: No A project b.level, n/a Section is deemed (2) of No the be an MCP n/a toCanadian when its Strategic Infrastructure estimated cost will Fund A No PPP Ordinance Article 7 of the n/a provides: No Public-private n/a Yes partnerships Article shall be used 9 of the No for PPP Ordinance n/a projects listed in provides the public-private partn that the total cu of the Concessions Article 1 bisYes Law The General Comptroller creating the Yes The has Concessions regulatory to also No framework Commission; approve n/asigned the provides Lawcontract. 10.336 Nofor the ofinclusion the The Supreme Comptroller n/a of PPPs Decree General in the awarding of the the national pub c Rep n/a Yes No 2014, article PPP Guidelines No the negotiation, n/a 21 - After n/a the Yes procuring The regulatory entity framework should sign does n a negotiation m No PPP Law - Articles n/a 26 and Yes 27; Decree 1082/2015 The regulatory - Title about 2 -No framework PPP, n/a Chapter providesRegulation for the inclusion 1 -No of the of n/a PPPPPPs Law, the national inSections pub 5 - PPP No Article 21 of n/a the PPP Law provides:No regulation n/a a priori andYes Pursuant a posteriori control of toNo the Article 17 and n/a 18 conclusion procedure of the PPP of the Law, the institu public-priva n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to of the PPP Regulation, article 15 n/a Yes a SNIP-MIDEPLAN, No assessment prior positive Law of n/a theof National NoSystem the Ministry of of National n/a Public Investment Planning must exist. (SNIP) - Ley d Yes Art. 11 of the PPP decree Pursuant provides toYes Art. the that 21 and choice Pursuant 24 of Decree the toprocedure No Art. No. of for Decree n/a 102018-358awarding of No. March 2018-358 PPP No contracts, 29, of n/a 2018March relating the29, consultation to 2018 Public relating documents toPartne Private Public Article 9, Paragraph Pursuant toNo n/a 10No of the PPPn/a Act, the Ministry Article 11 Yes of Economy andof Sustainable Nothe PPP Act Development provides for the n/a (formerly Ministry the Agen of Fin n/a Yes No According to the Road Act, n/a §18a, "construction, Yes According to operationNo and themaintenance n/a to attachment a motorway ofthe Resolution or a class on PPP C I n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The regulatory framework does n Yes Article 8.1 of the PPP Law Pursuant provides toYes that the article 11, use the The ofNational PPP Unit PPP No Commission prepares the is conditionedn/a toof a list public mandatory No procurement approval of projects n/a which gives could from an be thedeveloped Council opinion on ofthrough the Ministers respec PP Yes Article 15 of the PPP Law Article states: 15 "The of the No National PPP Law n/a states:of Council Public-Private YesNationalArticle "The Partnerships 16 Council of ofNo theis PPP made Law n/a up Public-Private provides: Partnerships of the following "The made members: up Counc is National 1) of the No According to Article 6.3n/a of the PPP No Law, the Committee n/a Yes has to approve According the proposals to NoArticle 13 n/a of the submitted the procuring by PPP authorities Law, the Interinstituti No Articles 3 bis, of the PPP Law 3 and 17 n/a Yes outline Article the process 3 bisNo of the for approval PPP n/a Law of PPP provides, No “[…]the projects n/a to commencement prior Administrative Authority of the procur when su Yes Article 32 of Approval PPP Law states from No activities that:"(…) the PPP-Unit n/a previous Article to14 the No PPP Law: n/a"the oftendering process board Yes (…) of directors While "Feasibilityof study" PROESA article 32 (of PPP will of have project) the theAct PPP therea follow n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Including PPPs with other govern n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes There are no specific rules about Yes Section 9 (1) Section (a) of the PPP 9 (1) No Proclamation (a) ofgoes the PPP n/a on to say that No the goes Proclamation Boardon n/a shall to say have Yes the that responsibility the Board Contributors shall have of approving the provided responsibility that, the proj of PPPwhile n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes There is no specific legislation co n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to our contributors, an n/a No n/a No n/a Yes As indicated in article 36 No of the strategic plan for emergi n/a Article 13 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant No Article Law: 3. The 18(8) Authorized n/aof the PPP Yes Law, Body the shall submit results Pursuant the of the toNo Article evaluation project 12(2) n/a conceptofof together the theconcessionaire PPP Law, with identification the selectionap recommenda n/a No n/a Yes PPP projects No n/a infrastructure like any other No n/a will have to follow the genera projects Yes Per the First Schedule of The the Minister Yes of PPP Act, Parliamentary FinanceSection and the approval Sector 25 No of the is required Public Ministern/a Financial for the for Partnership contracting Management No Projects n/a authority (Public which concerned Investment are Managemen require tax required waivers t or Yes PPP Law Article 3 of the provides The Court of that Yes Audit (Law ICPPP shall: As regards a. approve 4820/2021) No PPPs, approves the a cap inclusion is n/a PPP currently projects' of Partnerships No in use contracts that under n/a before was established the signing. provisions in 2012 TheofSpecial this and amen Secre law or r Yes Article 37 of According to the PPP Law. Noarticles 13n/a d) and 62 of Yes According the PPP Law to No and article Article 139 of the 13 (c)PPP n/a of the Regulations, PPP Law, the Council before o its sign Yes PPP Law Article 2 of the provides Article that 9 paragraph No the Administration 2 of n/a the Institutional Yes Control and Pursuant ofstates Decree to Majorthat Projects No articleand 11 of the DNCMP n/a the shall PPP Procurement provide Law, (ACGPMP)'s its non-objection the mission PPP must be c Yes Article 5.2. of Article the PP Law 68 of provides No that the the PP Lawn/a requires award the NoNational procedure for concessions n/a commissionYes of must public be validated procurement Appreciation by the national to is validate made departmen the proce or project by p Yes Article 18 of Article the PPP Law 16 (d) as amended ofaccording Yes DecreeArticle 64/2019 to Decree 17 provides: of the No. PPP No The Law n/a PPP 115-2014. states This Projects that decree No Technical thereforms cycle n/a of Unit projects will 18 article have can of the following PPP have Law and a public or e funcp No A general regulatory n/a framework No applicable to any n/a projects/procurements No Yes n/a could be The regulatory used, according to which the prior approv framework does n No According to n/a the PPP Guidelines No (for the formulation, n/a No and approval appraisal n/a No projects)n/a of PPP (https://www.pppinindia.gov.in/ n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the art. 21 (2) of the Regulation on PPPs, in n/a n/a Yes The Private No Participation n/a Order mentions Yes The Private in Article 1 provides No Participation n/a OrderE) after defining: Organization: provides Country in Article 13, "A No According to n/a of the Government Article 2(1)(b) No Contracts No n/a Instructions, n/a no government may list a to Yes entityAccording our contributors, project alt in the Federal No Article 1.8 of n/a the PPP Guidelines Yes provides: Approval Department No of should Function be Public Expenditure n/a carried out No and a separate asReform limits n/a function the total from annual cost project of PP assess n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a Israel's Multi-year Infrastructure Program f No According to n/a Articles 200 and 201 of No the identification the Code,n/a Yes According of the priority infrastructures to No n/a Article 200 and of the settlements Public Contracts Code, for the In develo Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Section to Yes 6.0.2(a) the PPP and Policy, According (b), "theto SectionPPP No6.0.2(c), theProcess FAAA"the Instructions, n/a includes PPP Process three Section No includes 6.4.2, required “Review n/athree "(i) Every required andpublic Approval� investment “Review and App points. No A resolution n/a by the Diet or the local No n/a council (as Yesbe) must the case may Pursuant be obtained toNo Article in advance the 7 ofn/a order in PFI for Act, Article the national 7 When admi or loca Yes The High Committee Articleby created 7.B.4 Article Yes of the PPP 6 of the The Law PPPstates Law Unit ensures isNo that in charge that the PPP all of n/aapproving PPP shall Unit projects review No the registration that"draft are n/a eventually PPP Contracts of registered and a qualified PPP [submit] inproject the Regis w its Yes of National Order of Ministry The PPPEconomy Center No makes an n/aexpert of the Republic of conclusion, Yes Kazakhstan Article No. as the per157 of 2 "On Order the No PPP of the Law approval Ministry of n/a sets rules out on ofthe National organization Economy objectives oftender of of the t PP Yes The main PPP Committee Section approvals 60 provides Yes that are provided Under the for PPP in the Committee No Sections following 25 and provisions n/a 26 of shall approve the PPP of Nothe the Act, project, PPP Contracting Act: n/afollowing Section Authorities which 33 (3) for the are feasibility required stt contracting Yes Article 38 of the PPP Basic According Plans speaks to NoArticle of the 15 n/a of Committees Yes foraReview the PPP Act, This on detailed PPPs implementation is regulated : (1) NoMatters by plan Article n/a needs subject 7 ofto to thebe PPP prior approved review Act:Article byby the 7 of the co Revt Article 22 (2) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the PPP toNo Article 16PPP Law, all (7), n/aProjects the PPPCare shall Yes subject maketo decisions formalto Pursuant approval on No Article 23 by of the n/a the approval PPPC theof PPP projects before Law:1.the Prior and Public to initiatin Authob agreements Yes The Higher Committee for PPP The Projects Higher No (Higher Committee n/a for Committee) Yesas (Higher PPP Projects Article Committee) per Article 3(a) 3 of the No ofPPP as the Law, PPP per Law which n/a provides, Article 3 provides, of the PPP "The "The Law,Higher which Higher Com prov Comm No According to of the PPP Law, Article 10 n/a No A proposal n/a for theYes implementation of a PPP The program Nofor project development n/a or a proposal of PPP for isa private initiativ provided for 201 Yes Article 62 of Article the PPP Decree 38 of No states: the Committee PPP Decree n/a for Investment Yes "Procedure provides: Clause Promotion and for1Agreement of Management No Article 5Signing: n/a hasPPP of the An agreement the Decree rights and states responsibilitie signing shall that the PPp Article 16(1) Pursuant toNo n/a Yes of the PPP Law, <...> if Consistency the opinionof NoofPPP theprojects Ministry n/a with of Finance No regional, local, n/a and finds that the national potential public-private development p plan No According to n/aart. 4(2), the PPP Law, No n/a General "the Secretariat Noof the Council n/a shall prepare Yes Usually, each an adequate ministry study prepares P of the proposed it No of the Law Article No 15-2 Yes n/a on Investments, Article Article No14 of No 14of the theInvestments n/a Law on Law provides, No Concessions. n/a "The state investment policy shall b No PPP Law Article 9 of the (Law 2015-039 n/a Yes on February The PPP 3, Decree No and 2016) (Decree article n/a 2017-149 7.6 of the from NoPPP2 institutional March n/a2017, elaborating Decree on the appl No. 2017-149 req Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Section to Yes 8.1, PPP the "it is Policy, also According Section GoM’s intention to the 9.1.6, No PPP“Regulatory to Act, n/a support Authorities projects Section No “in 39(2), that (RAs) assessing n/a fall within will need the national to liaise with itssuitability of any theprop Con developmen Yes The third and The approval seventh step No the process from Flow the ofn/a PPP Projects Cabinet the for No isselection consideration n/a of theand Yes evaluation private There of is operator PPPrequired is proposal before and submission negotiation no regulatory t provision r Yes According to Articles 11Pursuant and 12 of tothe Yes Article Law, PPP 22 II Article and and III7of Article ofthe the No 4.PPP III. PPP Law, Law of the n/a indicates: an approval PPP DecreeNo I- Contracting : ofThe thepreliminary contract n/a authorities required identify is evaluation before must projects signing be passe suf Yes (1) Pursuant 4 of PPP to section The Manual No(d)requires the PPPA wheren/a appropriate, from approval No (1) Central submit request an/a tender forYes proposal Board (CTB) the : Upon toPPP Boardreceipt toare Projects obtain of listedits the approval in the PSIP written ao No Articles mentioned n/a(fundamentally, above Yes Article According 24 PPPto Law) No n/a of the PPP article 15(IV) n/a No Law the procuring authority must ensure: Nowith Article In accordance No(b) of then/a n/a11 (a) and PPP Law, the Yes Pursuant Government toNo approves Article the list 5 c) of the ofn/aAnnex State1property of Government Resol goods and th Yes According to According the Concessions Law, toart. the Yes 6.1.1 Concessions and According Law, 6.1.2, "the to No art. Government the19.1, Budget "the n/a Law, shall art.exercise 28.1, No "the Government shall the public grant following n/a a permission investment powers:(6.1.1) program to conclude approve shallan t inc Yes According to paragraph Article 33,According No 6 Article to of the PPP 64,n/a paragraph Law, the public Yes 1 of the PPP According Law, authority contracting to No the public Article is partner obliged 32,n/a makes to obtain the paragraph the decision 2, point opinion 15 to award ofof the the PPP Pr a p Yes According to Article Article 5(1) of the PPP 10 of NoDecree, the the n/a PPP Law provides PPP Commission No that: "PPP provides n/a its opinion contracts Yes on the concluded The by the pre-feasibility State National are PPP evaluation Commission approved decree is r byreport n/a No n/a Yes Articles 20(2) No n/a for the and 24 provide No of PPPs in the State Budget. In fa inclusion n/a Yes PPP and Investment PPP and Investment Regulations, No Section 31, Regulations, regarding n/a Section Yes 32, Provisions regarding Pursuant Relating Investment Provisions toNo Article 13.1(1) Relating n/a Aproval, of to provides: PPP Implementation Policy (1) An"Budgetary investor willin Prov of Projec n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No of Finance's policy It is the Ministry 0 to consider PPP proj Yes According to the Business According Case Guide, to Yes theAnnex PPP Guide, 1, According Section "Cabinet approval No to 7.26, the PPP "during isPolicy, also n/a required the Section preferred No5.14, for bidder "if, on n/a investmentstage, theproposals basis theof procuring that the haveentity initial significa will qualitativ n/a Yes No Article 23 of the PPP Law n/a establishYes According that PPP Contracts to andNo it article 12(1) n/a amendments of have the PPP to be Law, the selection approved by Lawo Yes Article 26 of the PPP Law Art. provides: 36 of theThe NoPPPprocedure Law provides n/a for awarding Yestender : The commcommission According partnership to No contracts article may classifies of n/a the 6 only all bePPP initiated compliant Law, the bids. Contracting with It authoriz the Au transmit Yes (1) Section 2 ICRC (1) of the A Act establish second No approval "Every of the n/aFederal project priority Yes for concessioning Government Ministry, There is noAgency, No specific from Corporation procedure The n/a Federal or to Executive ensure body shall consistency Council is requ prioritize its of P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Public entities in the Republic of Yes According to the PPP Act, According Section to 14 No (1):PPP the "For Act, all n/a Section 19(3), qualified projects, Yes subject Section "subject to to final 3 theapproval of the rules No and Public ofregulations the Private n/a Board Partnership made [of the under PPP Authority Authority], this Act, (Ap t No Article 11. Functions the governing ofn/a Yesbody (Ente “Article Rector). 7 ofNo the governing The n/a PPP Law provides: body willOrigin Nohave the of PPPs. following n/a The projects functions: be executed to [...] 2. Approv the PPP Act Section 5 ofYes Section 11 n/a Pursuant toNo of the Procurement Yes Pursuant Act: toNo Section (6) Contracts with a 4 value of n/a the PPP in Policy: excess 4.1 The Governm o fKl0,000,000.00, o Yes Article 31 of Article 67"Intervention Decree 4183/2020: No of Decree 4183: n/a of the "Before Yes the Office the General of signing of the PPPs will Comptroller contract, beNo attributed offavorable the n/a a "code" the Republic. opinion within Theof Office the national the of the syst General Co Gen of the PPP Law Article 41.1Yes states Article Yes of the 55.1that Proinversion PPP Regulation The PPP needs LawNo to and get states that Regulation technical Proinversion n/a binding set forth (or No that the the correspondent opinions n/a regarding MEF prepares the Private the National draft Investment PPP Infra contract f P of the BOT Law Section 2.9 Yes Section IRR,2.12 the approval of the BOT Yes of Section Law projects IRR 2.4proposed No provides of the BOT that under n/a "[...] Law the IRR Prior mandates: BOT No toLaw approval shall Concerned of be n/a in the Head accordance Agencies/LGUs of Agency/LGU, with the are tasked the d followin n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 17 of n/a the PPP Act states that the total amount up n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The regulatory framework on the No PPP Law Article 5 of the n/a provides that: No "[t]he Contracting n/a No shall prepare Entity n/a a report Yes on anyWhile the PPP conceived law does Project, not addr including a su Art 5 (2) ofPursuant Pursuant toYes Government toYes Article OrdinancePursuant 17(1) no of the 98/2017 PPP toNo GEO: on GEO PPP In ex-ante the No. n/a order39/2018, tocontrol conclude No the public and start function partner n/a in the theprocess execution can contribute of award of theto obligation of public the p fina Yes The Steering according to CommitteAccording No to Article21 article 8 of of n/athePPP the Law, Yeshas PPPLaw the Contracting the responsibility According Authority toNothe to approve then PPP n/a prepares and oversee guideline, section an evaluation PPP 2.2.3 : Project’s report projects. Theinc S Yes According to (c) the Public article 89 According No to paragraph Finance Management 3.01 of theNo n/a Act 2001, the Guidelines n/a for Government Yes Procurement Tenders There Board no recommends identified isGWGS, [...] the policy to proposed Cabinet in pla Yes Article 13 of the Implementing All the sectors Regulations YestargetedAll forthe provides PPP in sectors itsPrivatization & first No and second targeted are n/a for PPP required paragraphs & Privatization No "The Board to prepare are their n/a ofPSP required Directors plans. to prepare shall:1. These their Withou plans PSP ide No Article 21 of n/a PPP law provides thatNo in addition n/a to requiring the favorable Yes Theopinion identification No of the and initiation n/a of Finance, Minister of PPP the projects UNAPPP mus are the r No According to n/aChapter No the PPP Law, n/a 1.1, Article III, Part 1, Section No 26, for n/a Yes without a PPP project a concession There element are no specific "a publicp regulatory Yes Section 38 of Pursuant the PPP Act toNo states that Section the Cabinet 25(6) n/aneeds of toNo the PPPapprove Act, thethe Parliament n/a project before Yes launching needs Even to ratify the the though PPP procurement the policy agreement. (6) documen The PPP process. n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes There is no express provision in t No According to n/aon Technical the Proposal According Yes Assistance for PPPs, to No section 2 section of n/a 4.2, the "the Government No shall Methodological n/a Document decide on ona Feasibility aPPP before projectStudy, “ n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a Act, Article 25(1), "a feasib the Concessions n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No specific PPP procuring framew No Article 117.1 n/aProcurement, of the Public Yes Concessions According and No Disposals to art. n/a the PPA,Act states 125(1), The No Inter-Ministerial "the n/a Minister responsible Concession for Finance shall Committee de sha n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No The National n/a Plan specifically states that P Development Nothe LCSP n/a Article 324 of No Council n/a states that the Yes of Ministers The (with regard toevaluation central No of the suitability governmentn/aand state of apublic PPP (or sector entities any public c Yes According to the Guidelines According on PPPs, to No Section the Guidelines 227, n/a at on PPPs, the YesSection 235, preliminary The “since screening vetting stage, negotiations No procedure occurs n/a on project “<…> once thefor clearance the proposals PPP from projects the may to Minis con result Article 7(a)According Pursuant toYes to of the PPA Act, Article No the Partnership 7(g) n/a of the PPPYes Act, the Council Partnership shall According be competent Council to No to set Article is competent 7 forth of n/aand the Law, approve tothe Partnership recommendation "approve Counc the award o No According to n/a the Budget No7, §5 of the Act, chapter n/aBA the main No rule is that n/a fundingYes Neither Concessions for the investment not Public in infrastructure P projects Nofinances of Ordinance on n/a No the Confederation (611.01). n/a No n/a No n/a Article 7 ofPursuant Pursuant toYes toYes Article the PPP Law, 5 of 2. Upon completion Pursuant the PPP Law, toof No the feasibility PPP Section Council 7 ofn/a Resolution study shall and have No. No 81, thewhen following consultations n/aselecting with objectives: the PPP authorized projects, govern the to review pro the Yes Section 18 of According the PPP Act to required No an Section approval 7A by of the PPPYes n/a Steering Act, the PPP Committee Section Steering 5 (2)(a) Committee Noa of and the PPP vetting n/a approves by the Regulations Attorney the agreement. General. (2020) 7A.-(1) 18.-(1) P requires T project having For the PPPYes Attorney The the PPPYes project's Generalvalue Section and the equal Responsible 12to of Noor the exceeds Minister PPP n/a THB Act: SEPO approve 5 billion, has Noto the the prepare PPP following n/a contract the Strategic Sections betweenPlan willsigning, apply: of PPPs Section which pursua 2 Yes According to According Article 3(1) to of the PPPNoLaw, Point 17 of n/a Public Annex 1 Private Partnership to No Regulation, n/a the PPP Agreements are NoBoard the approved of n/a Infrastructure by the Council of Ministers. Fund And would decide Yes Article 20 of Article the PPP Law 39 of provides No that the the PPPPPPn/a Law of 2021 Unit No shallprovides give its motivated that n/a opinion "[a]t the Yesof end before the negotiation, launching There is athe procedure the contracting of identifica procurement proce autho n/a Yes No Procurement The Government n/a No Committee approves n/a PPP projects Yes There before the is contract no identified is signed. Sectio policy in pla Yes According to the PPA, Section According 7.4,to "a No PPP the PPA, must n/a be approved Section Yes 7.4, "a PPP by Cabinet must be According atapproved two key to No stages: by PPP the Business Policy, n/a Cabinet at two Section Case key 5, stages: "to ensure (approval to implem <…> the ob Transac the PPP law Articles 7 ofYes Article No. 49-2015 19 paragraph Yesprovides 1 of that: Thethe PPP "For PPP projects aNo project Law areintended 49-2015 n/a intended provides to tobe that becarried Noincluded the PPP out in contract in n/a the the national is presented form ofinvestment a partnership to the and con de Gen No to Article (1) (i) Pursuant 5 of the BOT n/a Yes Implementation Turkey has Decree, No thedocuments strategic n/a President which that No is the approving define n/a the framework authority of the priority under BOT theinvest Yes Section 22(5) According of the PPP Act provides to Yesthat a contracting Section 17(4) Section and 2(2) 26(1)a authority No of the of the shall PPP n/a Act PPP not Act ensures procure whichthat Noprovides a private PPPs fall for n/a party the under without need theof the scope Cabinet prior of the approval written Nationa of Ministers The CabinetNo n/a No of Ukraine decides on the implementation n/a Yes of According a public-private to Nothe Methodology n/a orfor partnership the inexpediency analyzing of its i the effectiv Yes Dubai PPP Article 8 of the Law8 Article of the Yes Dubai provides, "a. APPP Partnership Article Law6 of the No provides, Project Dubai "a. willPartnership n/a APPP be Law approved provides, No Project "When by:4. willn/a the beselecting SFC,approved where Partnership the by: 4. the total SFC, Projects, cost be in to wher Yes Major Project approvalAny and project assurance Yes over a value guidance, Prioritization of April £10M is No 2011: reviewed is All carried majorin out n/a projects 2 through stages are No bya approved the range Cabinet approaches. through of n/aOffice. one The offirst Financial thestage following sign-off is to pro use out No will be used, If federal funds Yes n/a Federal Highway Administration's The VirginiaNo Departmentn/a approval of is necessary Transportation No in ordern/a to enable (VDOT) RFP issuance assembles andtransp a four year cons Yes According to of PPP Law, article 18 According to No the assessment Article 19 n/a of PPP studies Regulatory Yes Decree, and the Thisthe principle procuring terms No project's is regulated procuring n/a byterms guaranteed through article 17 and the of thethe draft same intervention of the law,co ofs Yes According to of the PPP 9 Article 18 Paragraph No (b) of Law, thethe concept Decree n/a ofon PPP Yes a PPP Agencywith project The a indicates existing total that value PPP No regulations PPP development n/a an theexceeding don't equivalent contain agency an of"conducts 10 explicit million ex U obl the Government Section 3 ofYes Tenders Section the 3 ofNo Act Government provides: n/a (3) Prior No Tenders Act to provides: entering Section into (3) a3Government ofNo the Prior entering Contract n/a to Government into Tenders aaGovernment minister Act must Contract first:(3) provides: Pr (a)aem No Article 21 of the PPP Law provides:Yes n/a Authority to Pursuant approve to No Article PPP projects: 7.1 of n/a 1. The the PPP Law, Prime No Minister the management n/a shall be vested with authority of investment fo in the to According to the PPP Act, Yes Section to According No 19(2), the PPP "theAct, Technical n/aSection 38(3)(b), No Committee "a shall contracting n/a authority the project consider Yes The proposal shall not contributors award and the proposed project anyclaim oragree that sign such Cabinet is required Approval ofYes According terms intoYes the Zimbabwe of section Zimbabwe Investment Investment 34(2)(h)No and of the Zimbabwe Development and n/a Development Investment Agency No and Actn/a AgencyDevelopment [Chapter Act [Chapter 14:37], Agency no contracting 14:37] section Act № 10/ 2sa Rules specify The Tender Yes different After sendingrequirements No draft contract n/a to Union depending Department Noon n/a of the scale Region orthe PPP, Yesor the Department State Government While or the Tender Organisation Board, Naypyi Rules requesti rules do n Taw C According toNo n/aart. 8(1), the PPP Law, No "if the initiator Yes is a public n/a of a project According partner, to then Nothe PPP he shall Law, n/aensure art. 8(3)(2), as part of obtainin the development of a p Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q9#4_1 Q9#1_1_5 Q9#2_1 Q9#3_1_4 Q9#4_2 Q9#1_2_5 Q9#2_2 Q9#3_2_4 Q9#4_3 the following 9. Which of Relevant legal/regulatory Is there assessments a specific If yes, are provision methodology? please conducted 9.2. Fiscal when elaborate Relevant identifying legal/regulatory Affordability Is assessment, and there preparing If including yes, provision a specific please PPP the in a methodology? 9.3. elaborate order identification Riskto informofthe the decision identification, required to allocation Yes No According to Article 13 n/a of the PPP Law Yes provides According to No that the Central Article Partnership of the PPP 13 n/a Authority Law Yes about is entrusted: 3.To Partnership the Central review Par Yes Article 19 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law, Yes a feasibility Pursuant of studyto Article Nothe Concession/PPP 19 (5) n/a will (b) (c) (d) ofbe Yes the conducted. PPP Law, the The feasibility s Concession/ Yes Article 5 ofn/a Pursuant toNo the CNED Decree Yes No. 04-162, Pursuant toNo Article National Fund 5 of for the n/aequipment’s CNED Decree No development No. 04-162,gives an opinio National Fund Yes No According to Article 11.1(c) n/a of the PPP Yes Law, procuring According to No authorities Articlemust 11.1(g), n/a the refer the launching specific Yes and contracting purposes of a part of the PPP, as w Yes Yes According to Section 4.e On PPP Law, Yes ofDecember when 10, 2019, structuring According Provisionto 2/2019 Yes PPP Article of13 projects,the the On ofUndersecretariat procuring December PPP Law Yes prior entity 10,to 2019, of the must Public-Private call Provision estimate for tendering 2/2019 Particip the to of econo No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Chapter 2 Section n/a Yes 2 (f) of Decision No. 1241, a feasibilit Yes Yes NSW PPP Guidelines provide Appendix in Section 1 Yes and 2 of the 5.1, "The According NSW Responsible PPPto Yes Section Agency Guidelines provide The must 5.3 ofNSW the identify detailed NSW PPP YesGuidelines PPP guidance Guidelines public in on infrastructure Section the provided, steps needs 6.1 to "To to dev provia m Yes Yes According to the art. 17According (1) of theto Yes the art. Federal Budget 17 (3)Act of the According all entities to Federal Yes the Federal Budget assigned AsBudget part Act, to make the of the No Federal Act, §17(4), preparations assessment Chancellor " thefor required following or Federal by issuing legal Sectio Mi ru principl Yes No According to n/a and 2.1 Yes Articles 1.3.3 Rules (Azeri of the BOT Pursuant toNoArticle Version-http://e-qanun.az/framework/34279), n/a 2.1 of Yes the sector organization the BOT Rules, sub the com Yes No According to n/a the PPP Guidelines, Section Yes 14.1,Fiscal affordability "to test overall theNo isviability performed n/a andas in Yes order part to of the finalize viability scope thegap and co financing Yes Yes 1. According to Paragraph Paragraphs 31 of the12-18 Regulation Yes of the According on Instructions Preparation Yes to for ofEvaluating the Article 26 PPP Paragraphs of the project, PPP Regulation Project Yes 7-11 "theof Proposals development onthe Preparation, Instructions approved of proposal "theby for Evalu thed devel No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Article 12 of PPP Law require n/a four studies Yes Article for any 1. Feasibility PPP12 ofNo PPP Law requires n/a 2. Social studies; fourYes studies: and environmental 1. Feasibility studies; 2. C studies;3. s Yes Article 10 of Pursuant toNo n/a the Sarajevo Yes Concession Pursuant tothe Law: In Article No development 10 of n/a of theYes justifiability the Sarajevo Concession study Law:for concessio In the develo No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Policy, The affordability ArticleYes 3.19(e), “a is check performed as public-private part partne Yes Yes of the PPP Article 4, "VII", Law provides In October 2021 Yes the thatEconomy one Affordability of the guidelines No Ministry assessments developed forn/a procurement a General are Noproceedings Guide required before onthe Socio-economic of procurement PPPs is the cost fina of a Yes Article 57 of Pursuant toYes the Concession Pursuant Article toYes Law: 28 (1) of Pursuant the TheOrdinance grantor Article toYes for27 shall the of ensure Pursuant financial thethat Ordinance preparatory to and Yes Article for28 economic the actions offinancial elements the Ordinance are carried of the and for out con economth Yes article 21 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law, Yes PPP projects Art.21 PPP are subject law No providesn/a to feasibility that “Public-private studies Yes partnership of technical, projects are socio-economic, Yes article 12 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law, No a partnership n/a contract be prepared No can onlyn/a if the evaluation realized by th Yes Yes No Article 10(4) of the PPPn/a Law, regarding No Project n/a Approval states: n/a Yes No If the Implementing Agency endorses the findings o Yes section 6 (1) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP Yes Law (Law No. 2006/012 Pursuant section toNoof December 8 of n/a 29, PPP 2006, Decree Yes (enacting Decree No. general regulatio the2008/0115/PM o Yes Yes The Business Case Guide The issued Business the Case by Yes Board Guide of The issued Treasury Business byon Yes the Case Board the Federal Guide of The Treasury issued Federal level provides byon Yes the Procurement Board the the Federal methodology of Treasury level Analysis provides Guide at the for the Fede in S socio Yes No PPP ordinance Article 8 of the n/a provides: Yes the use Article of a public-private No PPP ordinance 8 of the n/a partnership provides: shall Yes give the use rise of to aa public-private prior assessmen p Yes Yes Article 2, final Assessment paragraph and Article Yes methodology 6 bis of the General to obtain studies No Concessions Law: social by the return Then/a projects qualification Planning to Nobe developed Direction of the Ministry through by Ministry the of of conc Soc Public W Yes No Article 14 of n/a the Guiding Yes Opinions of the MOF,Pursuant NDRC and Yes Article tothe 3(6)The People's of Bank the Affordability MOF on Yes Guiding PromotingAssessment PPP Opinions, in Public a long-term Service Guidance req setsb Yes of PPP LawThe Article 11.2Yes procuring establishes that Yesentity among can Article utilize the 26the of Yes requirements "Metodología PPP Law to and open Manual General the regarding selection articles Yes 2.2.2.1.6.3 para Formulación process contingent and 2.2.2.1.6.4 for liabilities y Evaluación the ofand thed executions cP Yes No Article 24 of the PPP Law n/a provides:Yes Article The conclusion of24 the - The No public-private n/apartnership conclusion Yes contract is of the public-private subject to the partnership follo contrac No n/a No n/a Yes According to No of the Procurement Article 25 n/a No Code: During the prepar Yes No Article 15 of n/a the PPP Regulation. Preparatory Yes According actions No andto other article preliminary of the PPP 15 n/a Regulations No requirements: Inthe addition to the requi pre-investment fe Yes Art. 10 paragraph Pursuant toNo n/a 2 of No Decree No.n/a 2018-358 of No 2018 relating March 29,n/a No to Public Private Partnerships No n/a No n/a Yes Article 9(3)n/a Pursuant toNo Act, the PPP project proposal sha of the PPP Yes Yes Yes According to The VfM the attachment Methodology to theYes ResolutionAccording and on PPP Center, to Yesthe Feasibility Part PPP2, Study Methodology Preparation The section Feasibility (a) Yes 2.2Manual, provide and StudyStage a (f), Methodology. guidance some 1, one of the of performin on The pre-requi the Budg check No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes article 4.1 of Pursuant toNo n/athe PPP Law, Yes a procuring Pursuant toNoarticle authority can recourse 4.1 of n/a toPPP the Law, No a PPP only a procuring authority if the project can rec is economica Yes Yes Article 33 of Article 34 of the PPP Regulations Yes prescribes: the PPP Regulations "Scope Articleof 33 of states: the evaluation the PPP Yes "Methodologies. Regulations Article phase.34 of prescribes: The The evaluation Yes themethodologies PPP Regulations "Scope of public-private of for the states: each evaluatio of "Meth part Yes No According to of the PPP Yes article 3.6n/a Accordingof Law, the profitability to Yes article the 3.1Article public of the 5 project PPP must of the Law beGeneral Yes calculated during the Resolution structuring in aggregate for the cont and ev Pr Yes No PPP Executive Article 2 of the Yes n/a Regulations provides, Article "[t]he 2 of the Administrative Yes PPP Law provides PPP Authority Guidelines that Yes that Chapter a desires Three financial study to implement on under the "Value for su one M Yes Yes Article 32 of Section PPP Law states 4 of that toYes "Methodology start the procurement Article Evaluation for18 No of the of a PPP ofLaw: PPP n/aprojects" "Functions project, Yes detailing the procuring of the authority Ministry the costof must Finance: present benefit "a) analys No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Guidlines for conducting n/a PPP projects, 5 Project Identification Yes ChapterGuidelines for No conducting n/a states, for No the sake PPP projects, Chapter of clarity, 5 Project Identificat it should be no Yes No Article 17 (2) (c) of PPPn/a proclamation Yesstates in Article undertaking No 17(2) (e) a feasibility of PPP n/a Proclamation Yes study under states Sub-Article that the (1) contracting aut of this article, a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes preparation PPP projectYes has been Report "Quinet" reinforced. Yes 2013 regarding The PPPPublic project Acquisition Yes preparation socioeconomicCode https://www.economie.gouv.fr/fininfra/letu has evaluation requires been reinforced: Yes of thelarge procuring public The authority Public investment Acquisition to proje cond Yes No Art 15. of the n/a (Ordinance PPP Ordinance No No. 009/PR/2016 n/a No n/a 2016 on of 11 February NoPublic-Private Partnerships) pro Yes Article 13 (6), Pursuant toYes the preparation Pursuant Resolution toYes of the Pursuant No.public-private 191, Article toYes Article(D) 10the of Resolution the economic 8 partnershipPPP project Law, No. Yes analysis the 191Ministry shall be consists carried provides of that of out Finance an in availabil three stages of Geo accorda Yes Yes According to For the Federal Budget example, Yes at(BHO), Code the level §7(2), Forof example, "appropriate the Yes state ofthe at the profitability level North For Rhine the (economic) state Westphalia ofexample, at Yesofthe thelevel studies North Economic the shall ofRhinestate Feasibility be Westphalia perform of theSN Yes 36 and 37 of Section 11, No n/a the PPP Act, Yes2020 (Act Section which 1039) 6 the ofNo deals PPP with Act, n/a Value(Act 2020 for Yes Money 1039) deals assessments , Project Con with Affordability a Yes of the PPP Law Article 4(2) Yes provides, As in Yes <...> the Guide for Pursuant the Article Evaluation its 4(2) of Yes of Proposals the PPP Law responsibilities a. for As regards to provides, j. above, the PPPs, Yes<...> it shall a cap implementation Pursuant collect is currently of PPPs its theresponsibilitie (pp. in use 23, that information31) Yes No Article 37 of the PPP Law n/a requires conducting Yes a economic Article No 37 offeasibility the PPP Law n/a requires (37.a) assessment Yes the that and Ministry a studyof the social ofFinance condan Yes article 11 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a Yes this needs Pursuant analysis No article tomust be11 accompanied of n/a by Noan the PPP Law: analysis this needsof analysis the social must beec and a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes The PPP Law General in its article methodological 18 and article Yes 69 of the The guide PPP PPP for Lawthe No regulatory establishes formulation decree, n/a its and insay that evaluation Yes to18 article determine that ofthe project theInvestment Public thatparticip private be willPro No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes includes, for The Toolkit Yes Benefits highways, andInfrastructure No n/aprojects costs included in an economic No will oftenassessment n/a significant have include: Yessocial - Market and environmental impa valuations of the i Yes Yes According to the art. 23 (4) and Attachment Attachment Yes Chapter III Chapter According part B III, of to No (7)Part the the B, Bappenas 7 art. of 30n/a the Bappenas Regulation (2)(e) of the Yes Regulation Regulation No. 4 provides №on preparation the methodolo 4,PPPs, of a a pre-feasi No n/a No n/a Yes Article 5 of the No Private n/a Yes Participation Order provides - All executive a No n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a Article 2 of No the Government Contracts Instructions, the Yes Yes PSC, Section D-01 (3): "The A detailed general Yes principle guide on howof Pursuant cost to carry benefit out to Article Yesa CBA 1.3 analysis is (CBA) set "Affordability" Affordabilitiy out is in to PSC assess assessment D.03 Yes ofwhether PPP - Guidemechanisms or Guidelines, tonot Economic the thesocial are Appr State an A de No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Procuring authorities are This required is doneNo through to the conduct Guides to using preliminary the adjustme Yes Yes According to Article 181 According of the Public to Yes Article 181 Contracts According (3) Code: 3. to of the The Public Yes Article choice Contracts (of 181 Article of the the procedure) 167 New Code public of Yes the entities, Public Public is Contracts preceded Contracts before by Code, launching an appropri 3. The Code ch t deal Yes No According to the PPP Policy, n/a Section Yes 7, "the PPP criteria are According No to the standards PPP Policy, that Section n/a Yes a candidate 7, "the project PPP criteria are standard must meet to be de Yes Yes Article 11, Paragraph of PFI Act 1 Section 3-1 Yes mandates (1) of thethat Process Provision in conducting Guideline (2) ofthe 3 Yes theselection Basic Applicable stipulates that PFIof Policy the a methods specific Yes selection project are standard that requires provided under the is evaluation whether Article for under th of S 7 an Yes report is prepared A feasibilityNo n/a Yescontracting by the A feasibility authority report with the Yes assistance The 2022 is prepared byof Fiscal the the Yescontracting Commitments PPP Unit. It authority is defined And Continge in Arti with the Yes No According to Order No.n/a 725, the evaluation Yes the social and of According No to Order economic 725/2015, effectiveness No.n/a a preliminary Yes project, including of the PPPassessment of the t Yes No Section 32(2) (c) of the n/a PPP Act requires Yes a contracting Section 32(2) No(d) of authority tothe undertake n/a PPP Act a feasibility Yes that requires study as part of the of the feasibilit project it in Yes the guidelines Pursuant toYes methodology Theon (1. Standards VfM Yes for this Pursuant for assessment Feasibility toYes Articleset 8.2 out (2) During inof isAssessment the As the the discussed PPP VfM Yes Act, General test Guidelines with above, under respect the for VfM Preliminary to infrastruct feasibility assessmFe Guideline Yes Article 23 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a Yes 1. Before Pursuant initiating No Article tothe tendering 23 of n/a the PPP Law: Yes procedures of 1.any Before PPP initiating thePublic project, the tender A Yes No PPP Executive Article 5 of the Yes n/a Regulations provides, Article "If 5 theYes approval of the of PPP Executive Article the project Regulations 11 of Yes in accordance the PPP provides, Executive with "IfRegulations theapproval the PPP Modp Yes Resolution n/a Pursuant toNo No. 160 and Yes its annexes, Pursuant toNo Article 5(16) <...> assessment of social n/a of the issues PPPthat Lawmay Yes the arise feasibility as a result is defin study of the p Yes No Article 26 of the PPP Decree n/a provides: No “A feasibility n/a study No n/a is a setNo of a partnership of documents detailing model, c Yes Regulation Pursuant Pursuant toYes toYes PPP 1152, Section (5), financial a characterization A fiscal and economical Yes of thecalculation affordability assessment Article current situation 10 development is ofYes required Regulation and theguidelines, justification by Article 1152 provides 14(1) Section forof implem the 2.1 P comp N Yes No According to n/a art. 5, "the the PPP Law, No project committee, n/a assisted by n/a No No the working team, shall be responsible for p Yes Yes The PPP Resolution Article The 6.4 Socio-Economic refers Yesto the Methodological Methodology Article 15-2Yes highlights ofDocuments, the Investment Assessing the approved Law impact by the Yes provides: PPP by financial projects the "2. feasibility CPMA, on Before ashealth part deciding impleme ofof theto care, soc a eva Yes article 8 of n/a Pursuant toNo the PPP Law Yes (Law 2015-039 Pursuant toNo article3, on February 9 2016), of n/a the PPP Law before Yes launching (Law 2015-039 a PPP project, the proc on February 3, 2 Yes Yes According to The PPP the PPP Policy, Section Manual Yes "all PPP 7.2,provides According arrangements a detailed to Yes the guidance in Malawi PPP for The Act, Section some PPP shallManual, be elements 11(a)(i), Yes guided Procedure of by “the the the functions socio-economic process #2.5: PPP outlined of Projec the an Comb Yes No will only A PPP proposal be considered n/a No if theren/a is a need on No n/a the part of Yes the Government for the project after taking Yes of the PPP Law Article 9. 1. No n/a requires Yes the evaluation Article include to9.3 No of the an analysis PPP n/arequires Law demonstrating Yes the evaluation that theto include project an ana presents No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Section 5(2)(c)(i) Section the of4.2.5 Yes PPPA, of thethe PPP Manual is feasibility related study to shall Yes Yes Article 14 of the PPP Law: Cost "To determine Yes benefit Analysis theGuidelines: viability Article 14 of a Yes proposed of Set out the PPP theLaw: types PPP, Included the of socio-economic "To procuring as Yes part ofauthority determine the theviability Guidelines assessments should of ato make that determ an app proposed Yes Article 25(b) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP Yes Law, the public partner, Pursuant Section toNo an expert 28 n/a ofgroup, or the Yes person Government Resolution designated No. 476, the go byifthem co Yes No The socio-economic n/a is performed analysis No at the n/a No Public Investment stage of the n/a No Program planning, when priority p Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Law, Yes Part IV, Article According to No 17(1), "theArticle procedure 32,n/a for awarding paragraph Yes 2, point concessions 8 of the PPP be initiated shallLaw, the jus Yes Yes According to The Articles 2(3) the PPP of"Guide Yes toLaw, Public-Private prefeasibility According studies to NoArticles Partnership “[…] Contracts 2(3) must n/a take of the into PPP (PPP), Yes Handbook account, Law, prefeasibility in of particular, good practices" the comp studies (20 “[…] Yes Yes PPP Law Article 4 of the According provides that to No the contracting Article n/a 4 of the PPP of Law, PPP, No LSP The or BC n/a undertakings contracting of PPP, Yes is LSP subject undertakings or BC to with conformity is sub Yes Article 11.3 Pursuant toNo n/a of the PPPNo Policy, the n/a selection criteria n/a No for PPP No project cost, implementation projects are Yes Yes Module 3 (Quantitative Analysis) Module of Yes 3 (Quantitative the PPC Provides Pursuant Analysis) for of conducting to the thePPC: Yes PPC In Provides aThe case Socio-Economic PPC offor aaddresses long-term conducting Yes Analysis. contract the Socio-Economic The aissue of between PPC fiscal sustaina the Ana addressesgo Yes Yes According to Such methodology the Procurement Yes Rules, "all procurement is contained According covered into Nothe the Business by the Guide ton/a Rules Social Case Cost Guide, Yes should besection Benefit supported Analysis devoted by issued robust ato by “Finan the busin the Tr Yes article 12 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law, Yes the identification Pursuant to No Article and selection 3(1)n/a of the projects PPPPPP No Regulations, requiresDGIP development affor conducts of pre Yes Yes Article 24 of the PPP Law The provides: study isYes PPP contracts detailed byArticle theshall feasability ofNo 24give rise the PPP study to a Law guideline prior n/a evaluation, issued provides: PPP Yes bycarried contracts the PPP outshall by (Canevas Cell give the riseetud to a contractin Yes No According to n/a Section 9 of the PPP Policy Yes Project Development According No to Section of the 9 PPP n/a of process the PPP Policy Yes will include Development Projectthe of the "(…) preparation Yes Yes Article 16 of Article the PPP Law 6 of states: The the Yes preparatory Feasibility Article activities 6, Regulation Study No Item 9 of shall especially the provides n/a Feasibility a short Study Yes include: the Regulation: -methodology preparation for Forthe projects of feasibility tha a socio-eco Yes No According to n/a the PPP Act, Section 4(2)(b), Yes According "<…> to No a public private the PPP partnership Act, n/a Section (PPP) Yes arrangement 4(2)(c), "without yields prejudice forthe value to mo Yes of the PPP Law: Article 27.2No Yes analysis. n/a Cost-benefit It must Article 27.5No include of the PPP a preliminary n/a Sustainability Law: Yes that analysis feasibility study. and compares It m the econom Yes No According to Section 8.1.4 n/a of the PPP YesPolicy, the Pursuant toNo analytical framework Section 8.1.4 n/a which should of the Yes PPP Policy, accompany the analytical framework the Concept Note Yes Yes Article 35 of The PPP-Unit Decree 4183/2020 Yes within website section provides "Structuring Article different 35 ofNo Decree and guidelines preliminary 4183/2020 n/a for evaluation within Yes studies the for the (including section PPP Projects "Structuring from publ and cost-benefit an Yes of the PPP Regulations. Article 44.2Yes Yes PPP Invierte.pe was created Projects The by Legislative Evaluation classified as Decree Yes Report 1252. co-financed required Ministerial must Under satisfy by Yes Article Resolution the INVIERTE.PE all44.2 the 048-2015-EF, requirements of thesystem, PPP Regulatio the of the which re ide Yes Yes The ICC Guidelines otherproject and Basic Yes relatedevaluation ICC and NEDA Basic procedures project Board instructions for evaluation Yes development Section procedures details projects, theYes 4.3.2 for of PPPGB including project development evaluation Policy PPPs, Circular standards are based No. projects, an 01 on inclu Yes Yes MFDRP's PPP MFDRP's Guidelines 3.8 Yes in pointPPP delineate Guidelineseconomic-financial provide MFDRP a No PPP detailed Guidelines analyses. methodology n/a in point 3.8.5 One Yes of state forthe thecomponents economic that for each is project, a socio-eco analysis, an which Yes Article 6 (1) Pursuant toNo n/a (f) of the PPP Yes Law, a cost-benefit analysis Article 6 Pursuant toNo is(1) conducted n/a (b) of theprior Yes Law, PPP prior to the launch to the of the procurem launch of th No n/a No n/a Yes Article 7 of the No PPP Law provides that: n/a Yes "The Contracting Authority sh Yes Article 24 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP GEO: Yes (1) The project's toNo Article 19 Pursuanteconomic efficiency of n/a is demonstrated the PPP Yes The grounding GEO: study should by the elaboration h an Yes article 13 of Pursuant toYes the PPP Law: Guidelines for Yespreparation prior to Pursuant a tender and assessment toYes article notice, the of 13 Contracting of Feasibility Guidelines the PPP Authority Study for Yespreparation Law: Reports Priormust to a have tender conduct andbeen assessment a feasibility drafted notice, the ob C No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes Yes No The Implementing n/a Regulations (Article Yes 52) provides Article 53socio-economic for Yes of the Implementing The assessments Regulations Yes toManual Privatization take provides place provides in that thebusiness Businessc guidance Yes No Article 21 of n/a PPP law provides for aYes socio-economic assessment Article No 21 of the PPP in broad Law n/a terms:Partnership provides Yes that preliminary agreements evaluations shal involve ap Yes No According to n/aChapter Yes the PPP Law, III, Part 1, Section According 1.1,to Nothe art. PPP 27, forLaw, an/a PPP project art. Yes 27, for without a PPP project a concession element, without a conce No n/a No n/a Yes Section 27 n/a Pursuant toNo Yes among the activities required of the PPP Act, No n/a No n/a Yes Section 2.2.11 No of the PPP n/a Yes Handbook provides that the project mana Yes Yes According to the PPP Policy, The Methodological Part 3,Yes section 3.1, According Document "a prerequisite on Yes a the to Feasibility for Actany on Study Budget According PPP investment contains Rules, to Yes thespecific Act should §19 on guidance (15), be Budget "a subject thatRules, such for ofthe the §19 an asse pu (1 app Yes Yes According to The Methodology the Concessions Act, Article Yes 25(1), for Preparing According "a feasibility to Nothe study InvestmentConcessions for Documents n/a the concession contains Act, Yes shall Article a more <…> 25(1), "a include feasibility detailed compara study f a guidance No n/a No n/a Yes Section 2.2 No of the Procurement n/a Yes outlines the project procure Manual No n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a Manual, the Concessions Yes Section 5.1.3(d), "the purpos Yes Yes Module The PPP Manual, PPP Feasibility Yes 4:manual, Module Study4 prescribes According (p.40) requires to Yes the tosection various (i) Give stages Module in 16.4.1.(c) athe clear feasibility 4 economic (Part of the Yes of Treasury rationale theof 6) study PPP aRegulation, PPP Manual for project. the project; amon One require Yes Nothe LCSP n/a Article 247 of requiring a Yes feasibility report Article duringNo 324.6 of the the preparation LCSP n/a of work states Yes that before concessions authorizing the (PPP) contracts co that inc No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Article 14 of n/a the PPP Act provides that Yes "[…] the Article 14committee project No of the PPP shall Act n/a provides aNo prepare that comprehensive "[…] the project feasibility study committee s No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes The Federal, No n/a of theNo as well as most Cantons and many municipal gov Yes Article 7 ofn/a Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: Yes Pursuant authority 1. The contracting Section toNo shall 59 n/a of undertake Yes a preliminary Resolution feasibility No. 81, Corporate study of preparation Yes No Section 13 of n/a the PPP Regulations provides: Yes Section 13.-(1) 13 After the of Noapproval the n/a PPP Regulations of the pre feasibility provides: Yes study, the 13.-(1) contracting After au the approva Yes Yes Section 22 of the PPP Act Pursuant requires toYes Clause that 3 (1) a feasibility Pursuant andstudy (6) of to Yes the be Section undertaken Project 22 Clause Appraisal (2) and for each 3(4) (2) Notification, Yes PPP of of the project. the PPP Project Act, a project The when Appraisal feasibility proposing Notificat study appraisal th rep No n/a No n/a Yes NoArticles 6(1) In addition to Yesand 6(2) of the PPP Regulation n/a of the PPP Yes No Article 20 of n/a the PPP Law of 2021 provides Yes Article that projects “[t]he20 No of the PPP of public-private n/a Law provides Yes of 2021 partnership that give the"[…] Before rise to givin a prelimin No n/a No n/a Yes Section 12(1) No n/a Procurement of the Public No Regulations provides that p Yes No According to the PPP Policy, n/a Section Yes 5, “to ensure the objectives According toNo the PPP of the Policy, n/a program PPPSectionNo 5, and “to ensure the potential benefits of the objectives of t Yes No PPP Law Article 7 of the n/a No. 49-2015 Yes that "the provides Article 2No of PPP Law 7alprocuring authority n/a ( Law No. 2015-49 Yes should subject dated the 27 PPP project to November a st 2015 Yes No BOT Law Article 4 of the n/a No. 3996 provides Yes (1) that Article 4No of the investments andBOT services n/a Law provided Yes No. 3996 provides under thefor BOT affordability anmodel as will requ Yes No According to Section 21(1) n/a of the PPP YesAct, "Where According to No a contracting Section authority n/a (f) 22(2) identifies (i) ofYes theaPPP project theimplementation Act, for project should d Yes Article 11 of Pursuant toYes Order the PPP “OnLaw, Yes an analysis approval of the Pursuant of Methodology PPPto performance Yes Section the of 23 of shall PPP Order Order Efficiency be “Ondone approval No.Yes 384 based Assessment� (Procedure): on of the the Methodology PPP approved Where, proposal: by in ofth 1) accot Yes Yes Dubai PPP Article 5 of the TheLaw Department outlines Yes the terms of Finance Article of PPP partnerships Guidelines 5 of the Yes Dubai and issued PPP The provides, in Law Dubai 2019, outlines " PPP b. state YesTo Manual the conclude that the terms pp. of a social 109partnerships inimpact 2.6 under Partnership Con an asse" Yes Yes According to the GreenAccording Book, the to business Yes case the GreenThe Book, in Green support following Yes of a states Book new the policy, The identification thatGreen the new strategy, Book and Yes measurement business case new provides inprogramme, support that of authorities of a the costs or new new an po mu Yes § 33.2-1803(C) Pursuant toYes of the Section Yes 3.4Virginia of the PPTA Code, In Implementation accordance the Yeswith responsible public 2017 § 33.2-1803(F) Manual The entity PPTA may Implementation and of Guidelines determine Yes the Virginia outlines that Manual Code, developmen for thethe Appendi any pro - methodo Yes the PPP Law, Pursuant toYes Theprior Planning Yes to theand beginning Budget Pursuant Office of has toNo the on its PPP the procurementwebsite Law, procedure, n/a previously the support material to Yes the beginning and procuring entity methodologic shall of procure thehave an guid Yes No According to n/a the Decree on Examination Yes of the According to NoArticle Project Tender Documentation, 16 n/a of the PPP Law, No when Appendix 4, №a PPP “the typical project prepa isconten No n/a No n/a Yes the Government Section 3 ofNo No Act provides:"(3) Prior to ente n/a Tenders Yes Articles 14(3)(d) Pursuant toYes and Section D.IV 19(2)(i) Yes of the of Form No. Article PPP 01 under 14.3 Law, in Yes (dd) Annex the of II the process attached Article PPP of Law PPP ofprovides: project Decree Yes of 14.3(dd) 35 preparation, the "Pre-feasibility provides PPP Law the regulates the socio-econ study repo guidance o tha Yes No According to n/a the PPP Amendment Act, Yes SectionAccording to No 9, which amends the PPP theAmendment section n/a 31 of Yes theSection Act, PPP Act, which amends 4,among the others, "(31 Yes No According to the Investment n/a Guidelines, Yes Section 20, "as Section 4 of the No the Zimbabwe project initiator, n/a Investment the Contracting Yes and Development Agency Ac Authority identifies a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a n/a n/a No Yes Yes According to the PPP Law, Theart. Methodology Yes "assessment 9(2)(2), on PPP According Assessments, of the to Yes effectiveness the Part IV PPP Law, provides Theof art. Methodology a project 8(3)(7), aYes detailed as part on shall guidance PPP be of performed obtaining Assessments, on howa mandat to Part before co per Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q9#1_3_5 Q9#2_3 Q9#3_3_4 Q9#4_4 Q9#1_4_5 Q9#2_4 Q9#3_4_4 Q9#4_5 Q9#1_5_5 Is there a specific If yes, Relevant legal/regulatory methodology? please provision9.4. elaborate Comparative assessment Relevant Is there to legal/regulatory a evaluate specific If yes, provision methodology? please whether elaborate 9.5. a PPP is Financial Relevant the viability bestlegal/regulatory or bankability option assessm provisio when compared No According to of the PPP Law Article 13 n/a Yes about the According Central to NoArticle 13 Authority's Partnership n/a of the PPP Law functions Yes aboutthat According the include: Central to Partnership 3. Article To review of Partnersh the PPP 13 Authority' Article 7 (11) Pursuant toNo n/aof DCM No. Yes575/2013 Pursuant toYes Article and Article 19 (3)3(3) of the Article of PPP DCM Law, 8 of DCM No. a Yes 575/2013, qualitative 575/2013 Pursuant asand adescribes first quantitative to stage Article the of the methodology 19 risk feasibility of analysis the PPP ts sh n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a of the PPP Article 11.1(i) According Yes Law, the launchingto of No a PPP 11.1 article n/a must include (a) of theaYes PPP statement According oflaunching Law, the be risks to toand article borne contracting by each 4(f) Party ofPP of the a Yes According to of PPP Article 13 On December Law,Yes prior 2019, 10, to the According Provision call for tendering to 2/2019 Yes articleto 13 of award On of Undersecretariat the PPP December a Law, PPP No prior 10, to contract 2019, of the the n/a Provision call Public-Private procuring for tendering 2/2019 authority Participation to the of must award Underse was issue a PP p Resolution n/a Pursuant toNo Yes II (2), No. 1241, Section Pursuant the content toNo Chapter of and list 2 n/a Section documents 2 (f) Noof Decision submitted byNo. n/athe1241, public party for approval a feasibility t study of o Yes According to Section Sections 5.1 and 5.2 3 of of Yes the NSW Volume PPP 1 of According the Guidelines, National to Yes Section the Guidelines PPP 5.2 Business Sections of the Case NSW 2& setsand Yes out 3PPP Procurement risk of Volume Guidelines, assessment The 1 NSW ofStrategy the In components NSW, PPP National may for likely be PPP Guidelineswithin informed Guidelin PPPs, (Section the ap n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 2.1 of Pursuant toNo n/a No the sector the BOT Rules, No submits n/a organization n/aan investment Yes project Pursuant competent to the to authority Article 2.1 on of the BOT Yes and risk Risk assessment matrix The PPP Screening are Yes Manual, performed as part According Screening ofto the Nothe bankability Condition PPP Screening n/a assessment. 8: Manual, Bankable, Yes Criteria Thus, SectionAccording 8.1. according 2.2, "Has “<…> the to to the there the riskPPP PPP matrix is Screening aGuidelines, need been co M to com Yes Article 43 of the Regulation Chapter on Preparation 4, "Estimation Yes According stipulates of Comparative that to Yes Article the Advantage," organization 31 Chapter of theinRegulation the responsible 4, "Estimation Yes Instructions on forPreparation, public-private According of Comparative on to the Article the Methodology partnership development Advantage" 31 of of develop the the of Mo in th p Reg n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 13 of n/a the PPP Law Yes state that feasibility Article studies12 has ofto PPP No Law show the requires n/a sharing fourYes studies: table 1.Additionally, of risk. Article 12 of Feasibility studies Section PPP Law 2. social require 6.2.1. of the and en fou Article 13 of Pursuant toNo the Sarajevo n/a Pursuant YesPPP Law: (3) The project toNo Article 15 (2) n/a (b)study justifiability of theshall Yes Sarajevo PPP Pursuant include: project e)Law, into the implementation Article evaluation 13 of therisks Sara of receiv No According to n/a Article the PPP Policy, 3.19(e), "aAccording Yes public-private to Yes partnership the According must PPP Policy, Article demonstrate to Nothe PPP“a 3.19(e), n/a “Value-for-Money� public-private Policy, Annexurepartnership 3, Section based 29, must upon < d "the n/a No n/a Yes Nothe PPP Law Article 10.I of Yes n/a requires the approval Article to procure a the 4, VII of to be PPPPPP based Law indico Article 6 ofAnnex Pursuant toYes No. 1No of the the Ordinance for the Ordinance financial n/a for the and economic No elements financial n/a and economic of Yes elements the Pursuant of the concession: (2)concession For to Article the purpose provides 25 of dete of the the Ordi No Article 25 of n/a the Implementing Decree Yes provides Article that “[t]he No 24 of feasibility the Implementing n/a study shall Decree Yes provides include Art.21 technical, thatsocial, the PPPcomparative lawenvironmental, providesanalysis “Pus that finan article 12 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a Pursuant Yes a partnership contract toNo article can 12 of only be the n/a prepared PPP Law, Yes ifathe partnership rsuantcontract evaluation realized to article can by 12only the of the bePPP PPP Agenc Law prepar No Article 10(4) Law, regarding of the PPPn/a Approval states: No Project n/a n/a No If the Implementing Yes Article 10(4) Agency endorses of the PPP the findings Law, of the rega Feasib section 6 (1) Pursuant toNo n/a Yes of PPP Law Pursuant No. 2006/012 of December toNo section29, 2006 n/a 6 (1) (enacting of PPP LawYes No. 2006/012 the Pursuant general of December regulations to section of 29, Partnership 6 (1) of PPP 2006 Co L (enac the PPP Screening Pursuant toYes 3.5 Yes Section criteria of the in Section Business Section of the 5 Case6.2 Guide Federal Yes of the outlines Federal Implementing Sections risk Implementing assessment 6.3 Guidelines, Yes and 6.4 Guidelines factors, of the Section the"The Federal provides, 5potential of Implementing tolerance the levels, "Value Federal value provides of for Impleme money a Guidel a ta P3 de No PPP ordinance Article 8 of the n/a Yes the use provides: Article of a public-private 8 of the No PPP ordinance n/a provides: partnership shall Yes give the use rise to ofaa Article prior public-private 4 ofassessment partnership based on the Implementing De n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Notice of Theof the Ministry Notice Finance of Yes on The the Ministry Guidelines PPPof Guidelines, Finance for YesPPP article on The Operations, Guidelines 8: "PPP PPP Value center article for Yes Forshould 11(2): Money PPP Operations, In evaluate Article accordance Assessment the 3(2) article project's of with Guidelines" therisk MOF 11(2): quantitative In allocation accordanc Guiding gives spe oO Yes Section 11.5 Article 11 The PPP Colombian Law establishes Yes Procurement that PPP Law before Agency art. opening Yes 11.3 (Colombia the selection Several Compra indicates guidelines that one process, Eficiente), Yes the and of the requirements the procuring methodologies Article National 11.1 entity Planning that of PPP must specifically theLaw procuring Department prepare and Articl the ent applic No Article 24 of the PPP Law n/a provides Yes that the conclusion of- the Article 24 The No public-private conclusion n/a of partnership the public-private No n/a partnership contract to the following is subject contract pre is subject t n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 15 of n/a the PPP Regulations. […] YesA study for the 15 Article of the PPP of development the proje Regulations n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Art. 10 paragraph 2 of PPP Decre Article 5 ofThe Pursuant toYes PPP Regulation, the Handbook Yes for preparing one Pursuant and of the to mandatory implementing Yes Article 9elements The public paragraph Agency of projects 8the of Yes for the Public Investment combining PPPSector Act, Pursuant and one Comparator European of Competitiveness to theArticle key Structural (PSC) criteria 6 ofis the for aand (AIK) quanti PPP appr InvR (t Yes The PPP Risk Methodology The provides PPP Risk Yes Methodology PPP project sponsors According provides to Yes the with PPPinformation attachment project The VfM to onthe sponsors Methodology how Yes with Resolution information and whenAccording on toPPP identify Center, on how to potential the andPPP when Part 2, Preparation risks, section to ident 2. how Yes According to The on the Guidance Guide Public on YesPublic Construction, According Construction, section to section Yes 5: the Guide 4 provides The contracting onauthorities Public Guide a detailed on Yes Construction, Public should guidance assess Construction, Guidance section on the how risk on 4, section "the to this associated perform topic 4 provides is an developer with explicitl assess must, ad the n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo article 4.1 of n/a No a procuring the PPP Law, n/a authority can recourse to a P Yes Article 33 of the PPP Regulations Article 34 of prescribes: Yes the PPP Regulations Articleof "Scope 33the of states: evaluation the PPP Yes Regulations Article phase.34 "Methodologies. The of prescribes: The evaluation themethodologies No "Scope n/a PPP Regulations of public-private of for the states: each evaluation of "Methodologie the phase. analyzes partnership Th initi Yes According to all PPP article 3.2The General must Yes Resolution undertake for an the According identification Presentation to article Yes 3.3 and and assessment The of Approval the General PPP Yes of of Law Resolution the PPP projects risks Projects According and for procured the benefits includes Presentation to asarticle of a PPP Risk the project, 11 should Managemen and of the get Approv PPP the whic Yes Article 52 (b) Section of the PPP Two Executive Regulations Yes of ChapterArticle One of25 the mandates of that Yes PPP thethe PPPPPP Law Guidelines Section Central states: on the Unit "A TwoPPP Yes of committee "shall Chapter Structure, coordinate Article One including entitled of2with the of technical the Making PPP the Guidelines financial PPP Law and the PPP provides financia cover Choic transac Yes is included Risk assessment as part Section 7 ofYes of the "Methodology the Article value 32 for money for ofEvaluation analysis Yes PPP Lawrequired states of Section PPPthat by 6 of to projects" Article Yes "Methodology start that thedetails procurement 32.a) of Financial PPP for theEvaluation evaluation viability Law as ofdescribed a PPP is ofand project, PPP in included assessm project theas the M p n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Guidelines for No conducting n/aPPP projects, n/a No Chapter 5 Project Identification states: E No Article 17 (3) n/a of PPP Proclamation Yes that [...] states Article the 17(2) feasibility No(d) of PPP n/a study Proclamation shall describe Yes states that Article the structure the proposed contracting 17 (3) offor PPP authority Proclamation the shall project inc n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes to article "Bilan" Pursuant 2211-6 TheLPPP Unit’s Yes of guidelines, the Public PPP which project Acquisition should Yes preparation be renovated Code: demonstrate has to The PPP been to Unit reinforced: Yes take Guidelines that into the PPP The account Article (Plan balance Public the R2211-4 type recent Acquisition du is more rapport of changes the favorable Code Public d'évaluat in the requ Acq tha L n/a No n/a Yes Art 15. of the No n/a (Ordinance PPP Ordinance n/a No No. 009/PR/2016 of 11 February 2016 Article 10 of Pursuant toYes Asthe part PPP of Law, Yes the seven the Ministry stages Pursuant of of project toNo Finance Article evaluation, of Georgia 9 ofn/a Resolution performs as per Article Yes No. the 8 following of 191: 2. Resolution Pursuant If anmain economic to No. functions Article 191: entity E10 related ) Risk is of Resoluti analysis to pub considerin Yes According to For the Federal Budget example, Yes at(BHO), Code the level §7(2), According of the "appropriate to Yes statethe of the Federal profitability For North Budget example, Rhine Code Westphalia No (economic) at(BHO), the level studies Economic §7(1), n/a of shall the "the state be principles performed Feasibility of theStudy North of economy for Rhine all ac Guidel the PPP Act, Section 5 ofNo n/a 1039) deals 2020 (ActYes Section with risk 11allocation of No the PPP Act, n/a and requires 2020 (Act that Yes 1039) requires Sections all documents that the 36 contracting set andout 37 of authority the the PPP Acto partnersh No Guide for the n/a Evaluation of Proposals Yesfor the implementation Article 4(2) No of PPP of the PPPsLaw n/a (p.24) provides, Yes Article <...> Pursuant its 4(2) responsibilities of the PPP Law provid a. to j. ab Noassessment The feasibility No n/a regulated by articlen/a 37.a of the No n/ainclude an PPP Law must Yesassessments According risk of the to associated article with 37.a of P the th n/a No n/a Yes of public procurement The ManualNo n/a Yes procedures Pursuant to indicates Chapter inarticle ofSection 11 2, the PPP3 n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo article 118 n/a of the PP Decree, No n/a the commission's opinion is required o No The PPP Law n/a in its article 9 establishes Yes the following Articleregarding 69 of Nothe risks: Inherent n/a PPP Regulatory risks decree Yes andindicates distribution that69 costs Article toof determine between the PPP Regulatory the parties the privateD n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The VFM Indicator include ToolThe VFMrisk Indicator Yes identification include ToolAccording and allocation. risk toidentification No There the PPP Toolkit n/a are and(page several allocation. Yes 4): different project theMore The specifically: must types of risk financial be that commercially analysis Allocate impactrisks: a use will viable Oninfo th project Yes According to the art. 30According (2)(e) of the to YesRegulation the Attachment According on PPPs, to the to No a Bappenas pre-feasibility the Attachment n/a Regulation to the study № shall Yes Bappenas 4, provide Chapter conclusions, Regulation According III, Part B, to 10, including the No. 4, the Attachment Chapter risk the assessme II, C risk ide to t (3 No Roads Construction Article 5 of the n/a Bylaw provides- No No n/a On any of the plan n/a YesincludedArticle and projects 5 of the Roads in the participation transfer pl orConstructio n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 3.9 of the PPP Assessment Article 3.9 of Yes covers the PPP Assessment Article different types 1.14of specifies Yes ofrisks the PPP the Guidelines Article types inherent of the to1.14 risks provides Yes management of the to be that PPP allocated Guidelines Article two of adifferent typical between 3.5 of provides PPP PPP levels Assessment: project. the two that at which four partners It prov "V Th form n/a No n/a Yes Comparative Yes assessments compliance PPPare partYes of the tests preliminary Procuring adjustment contained in authorities the Guides examinations to require are using th Yes According to The Article 181 of the PPPPublic Guidelines YesContractsArticle Code, detail in Article 181 the (3) Yes choice 3.1 of the the(of distinctive Public the The PPP procedure) Contracts elements Guidelines Yesis Code ofin the preceded provides Article According concession by5.2 an for appropriate the address to with Article use respect the of165(3) comparative choice inquiry to the of wit the of c th No According to n/a Section the PPP Policy, 7, "the PPP Yes According criteria are to Nostandards the n/a that Section PPP Policy, a candidate Yes 7, "the PPP According project must meet criteria are to the standards to be PPP developed Policy, a can an that Secti Yes The risk assessment is discussed The methodology inYes detail is the The in provided Guideline comparative in the Yes relating assessment to Risk Guideline relating Allocation, Section to is1-1 addressed Risk No (5) of etc. Allocation, in with the detail n/a respect VFM etc. Guideline in the with toGuideline PFI respect provides projects relating to PFI projec that toV the V Yes According to The Article 4 of the PPP PPP Regulation, Yes guidelines (page the Article contracting 30) 9 of the provides No authority PPP information n/a should Regulation on provides how include to identify Yes that risk allocation "[t]he Article and Feasibility 9and evaluate of the mitigation risks. PPP Report Regulation They in provide as approp its pr conc Article 14 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a Yes1. The list Pursuant of risks arising Order toNo in No. the 725, various n/a Appendix stages 2, point No of 3.5 a public-private n/a (financial partnership section), is determin the projec No Clause 3.7 of n/a Statement the PPP Policy Section Yes provides that in 32order (2) No(d) to be of viable, the PPP Act n/a PPPprovides projects Yes must that the carefully authority Section 22(1) allocate (b) willof consider the all PPPthe Actris relevant r af Yes for VfMThe The Guidelines requireYes (D.) General Guidelines Risk The Quantification. for Preliminary Guidelines More Yes for precisely, Feasibility VFMTheTest after Studies Guidelines require making (Table Yes tofor an compare adjustment VfMFinancial 3-21 identify different for 3 Second-Stepfeasibility stages the procurement Qualitative like-for-like toanalysis realize solutio compa ais com con Evaluatio Directive one Section 5 ofNo Yes n/astates:The feasibility study will Section 5 ofcontain, No Directive one n/astates: where The Yes applicable, feasibility the following: Pursuant study will (v) to A matrix contain, Article onwhere project 23 applica of the PPP risk Yes PPP Executive Article 8 of the The PPPRegulations Guidebook Yes provides Article provides, "The guidance 7 ofinitial the Yes PPP on risk Executive The feasibility assessment study PPP Guidebook shall Yes and Regulations contain allocation provides, provides Article a preliminary (see "2. detailed 8 pp. of It shall the 51-55 analysis guidance PPP befor established Executive of on thevalue com Reg instance) A th Article 5(16) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP Yes Law the feasibility Pursuantstudy Article toNo 16 of is defined n/a as the PPPaLaw: <...> No of set 2. technical, The process n/a economic, of initiating a PPP legal, project i environmen n/a No n/a Yes No Article 26 of n/a provides: the PPP Decree Yes “A feasibility Article 26 of study of a partnership the prov PPP Decreeis as of the PPP Law Article 9(1) Yes provides Regulation 1152 Yes for a providesArticles a methodology risk assessment4, 7, Yes for and each of PPP 8 for Regulation risk Regulation project assessment 1152 1152 Yes <...> the in provide Articles supervisory A providesa financial comparative 14 a methodology and institution 15. viability The assessment. latter shall for assessment the assess compa Addit Article pr is and n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPP Law, art. 5, of the Investment Article 15-2Yes Law Yes The Methodology provides: on 2. PPP Before Issues Article 15-2 deciding approved Yes of the toInvestments by CPMA CPMA apply a public-private provides Order Law provides: No Yes basis a2019 partnership / for 2. CPMA 8-106 such Order on to Beforean deciding May carry assessment No8, out 2019 2014 tothe apply /on under 8-106 activities PUBLIC a publ "Se on Article 6.1.2 of the PPPn/a No Yes 2017-149 Decree (Decree from Article 7.2 2 of March No 2017, the PPP n/a elaborating Decree (Decree Yes on 2017-149Pursuant from 2 of the application tothe Article March PPP 2017, 9 Lawelaborating of with the rega PPP L Yes According to The the PPP Act, Section PPP Manual, Yes Procedure 11(a)(iii), “the According functions #1.2: to Completing Nothe of PPP the Act, the n/a Commission Section Project in 42 PPP Yes relation (2)(c)(ii), Screening to public-private According […] Matrix, at the minimum, to provides partnerships the PPP a Act, for a table Section shall to be feasibility No Sections PPP Guidelines, 3.1: All PPP n/a proposals Yes Section should be 2.1submitted Yes of the PPPdirectly Guidelines Section 2.1 to is the Yes of related relevant the PPP PPP Guidelines principles Guidelines, in toMinistries/agencies. is Adopting related Sections The toPPP typical 3.1: Appro Allin principlesP No Article 9.2 of n/arequires Yes the PPP Law the evaluation Pursuant to confirm toNoArticle theof that 9.2 operation n/a the PPP risk Law, Yesis the evaluation Pursuant transferred the toincludes to private article an 5 analysis partner when of the of the PPP L Section 5(2)(c)(iii) Pursuant toYes Sectionof the 6 ofYes the PPPA, Manual PPPthe feasibility defines Section 5(2)(a) study Yesthe term ofshall the PPPA demonstrate "risk" As indicated states and identifies Yes that that in section the the feasibility agreement theSections various 4.2.3 of study the types 5(1) shall shall of PPP transfer ofthe Manual, risks demonstrate PPPAappropria for states thos inherent in cot Yes Section VI of Section VIestablishes the PPP Guidelines of Yes the PPP that Guidelines Article 14establishes entitiesof should Yes the PPP identify, that PPP Law: entities "To describe, Guidelines determine should Yes and evaluate identify, the Section and Article viability describe, allocate IV 14 of of the of a proposed the evaluate PPP the project PPP Manual Law: PPP, and "To alloca the risks de as w pr Article 25(b) Pursuant toYes PPP Law, Order of Ministry the Yes public partner, Pursuant of Economy an No expert 143 toNo Section ongroup, approval 27(d) or n/a of the of Government the person Preliminary Yes designated Pursuant Matrix by them Resolution for to No. Repartition 476, Section compiles the Public a offeasibility 27(e) of Proper Gove Project n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Concessions Law No According to paragraph Yes Article 32,n/a According 2, point 3 of to the PPP Law, Yes Article the justification paragraph 32,The analysis Yes 2, points Rulebook onparticularly the4 Methodology and According of the toPPP for 5contains:Article 8) Value-For-Money identification Law, 32, theparagrap justifica and Yes According to The Articles 2(3) the PPP ofMinistry Yes of Law, prefeasibility Finance and economy According studies to Yes published “[…] 2(3) Articles The must of the take Ministry the into PPP "Guide Yes of account, Law, Finance to prefeasibility in Public-Private According and particular, studies Partnership economytothe Articles published complexity “[…] 2(3) Contracts must the of of the takethe "G (P in P No n/a Under PPP Regulations: No provides: Article 5(1)(d) n/a No The identification and n/a design of each and preparation Yes projectArticle of the 20 of the PPP Law provide technical n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 11.3 of the PP Yes Module 3 of Module the PSC Contains the 3 of need Yes the to PSC Contains conduct The entirety a Risk the need Analysis, Yes of the conduct as The to PPC well serves entirety as a Risk a asmethodology aAnalysis, Yes basis of the PPC foras a comparative Under well for serves asModule a as conducting methodology a basis assessment such 3 of for the an a comparati analysis PPC, whereas for the condu f Fu No According to n/a Section the PPP Guide, 4.7, “the invitation Yes Accordingfor to Yes EOI the draws PSC uponGuide PPP Policy, much Section provides Yes of 5.2.3, "additional such the work already According a methodology quantitative, done to the in Business Detailed the or Case value Bu G for n/a No n/a Yes Article 12, PPP No Law then/a Noand selection identification n/a of PPP projects requires, int No Article 24 of n/a the PPP Law PPP contracts provides:Yes shall Article 24give provides: Yes rise toPPPs Section contracts a prior C ofYes shall evaluation, the guidelines carried give rise Article outrefer to a 24 by the to prior ofcontracting the the evaluation, PPP Lawauthority juridical structure provide carried o No Part 3 of the contains a Yes PPP Policyn/a According Supplementary Note on to NoSection Risk Project n/a 9 of and the PPP Policy with Yes the Federal Paragraph Project Government 4 of the Development ofwith the ICRCparagraph PPP PPP Proc proce No 12 of the Article 6, Item Feasibility Yes n/a Study Regulation: Article Risk 6 of the identification, No n/a Feasibility Study risk management, Decree Yes provides Article for a6value-for-money allocation, of valuation, the Feasibility and mitigatio Studyas study D No According to n/a the PPP Act, Yes "without Section 4(2), According prejudice to Nothe to PPP the Act, n/a generality Section of theYes powers 4(2)(b), conferred "without According prejudice byto subsection toPPP the generality (1)(d),Secti the Policy, theo of the PPP Law: Article 27.3Yes Risk Manual for distribution Yes the Evaluation, Article Assignment proposal.27Itof must Yes the include PPP Assessment and Manual an Law. Eligibility initial forproposal ofthe and Yes Risks Preparation approval approved for Article theofof by distribution PPP 27.5 the Resolution Value of the of projects. for PPP the Those No. Money Law: ER-02-L1- project risks Susta Ana of the Section 8.1.4 Pursuant toNo n/a Yes of the PPP Policy, the According analytical toframework No n/a which Section 8.1.4 of the should PPP Yes accompany Pursuant Policy, the the Concept to Section analytical Note framework 8.1.4 andwhich of the whichshP w Yes Article 35 of The PPP-Unit Decree 4183/2020 Yeswebsite within section provides Article "Structuring 35 different of Decree and guidelines Yes 4183/2020 Guidelines preliminaryfor studies evaluation within provided Yes section for the (including by PPP Article PPP-Unit: "Structuring risk Projects 35 http://www.stp.gov.py/ of assessment) Decree andpublic from preliminary 4183/2020 initiative" of PPP stu pr w of the PPP Regulations Article 44.2Yes Yes Ministerial Resolution requires inNo. The the167-2016-EF/15 Yes Report Evaluation arerequired to Directorial the include: guidelines Resolution Yes Article by"(…) for 5. Preliminary 44.2 the004-2016-EF/68.01, allocation Article of the 44.2 Risk PPPofAnalysis Regulations of risks theinwhich of PPP PPP the Regulation to contract approv incorp projec Yes Section 4.3.1 Policy of PPPGB Basic project Circular Yes evaluation Section procedures No. 01A-2016 indicates 4.4 Yes of for PPPGB development for Policy risk Section analysis Circular projects, 4.4 theYes ofNo. following: PPPGB including 01A-2016 Policy iii. Section PPPs, Assessing provides Circular 4.3 areofbased No. for the PPPGB risk the 01A-2016 onValue Policy analysis the ICC for provid Circu toGu Me Yes Article 3a of Public the PPP Act Sector specifically Yes mentions Comparator risk The division PSC and risk is explicitly Yes as one of analysis - mentioned risk the There keyis elements a assessment incomparator Article Yes for 3aassessing of methodology PPP MFDRP theand PPP with Guidelines risk theAct. aeffectiveness tool analysis Articlein 3a - point an supporting states: of econom 3.8.5 analy 1. B poten Article 6 (1) Pursuant toNo (l) of the PPP n/a Pursuant YesLaw, prior to the launch toNo Article 6/1 procurement of the (a) of the PPP n/a Yes process Law, prior the Pursuant itemized to to and the launch Article of detailed the 6 (1) (h) identific of the procureme of the PPP Law Article 7(8) No No n/a provides ContractingNo that "The n/a Entity shalln/a develop, inYes coordination Article with 7 of Project the Law provides the PPPCommittee, a Article 19 of Pursuant toYes Appendix the PPP 1 GEO: Yes of GD No. The grounding 867/2016 Pursuant study toNo Article should contains "The 19 highlight n/a ofpreliminary the PPP the GEO: following Yes matrix for main Pursuant the elements, The grounding study distribution to Article should which of project justify, 23 of the highlight risks from PPP the -a Yespreparation Guidelines for and assessment Guidelines Yespreparation for Theand of Feasibility PPPassessment Guideline Study Yes Reports of Feasibility also details have been the Guidelines Study for procedure, Yes drafted preparation Reports Guidelines MINECOFIN have bythe content andbeen assessment for on drafted : http://www.mineco the comparative of byFeasibility MINECOF preparation and as a No According to n/a the PPP Handbook section Yes 2. BUSINESS According to Nothe PPP PLAN/CASE, a business Handbook n/a section No 2. plan/case typically BUSINESS n/aincludes PLAN/CASE, a business the following: 5. [...] pla Yes Manual The Privatization The(pp. Privatization 112-113) Yes provides: When Manual Section (pp. planning 97-106) 12: Yes provides Risk for Analysis a successful The guidance Privatization and PPPon Yes Adjusted project, riskManual PSC: identification, "whether Risks Financial form privatization providesallocation, andetailed integral viability assessment guidance and is partassessm the most of is on everp Yes Article 21 of A detailed the PPP Law provides document Yes that the evaluation Article called 21 the of Matrix PPP No of the projects of PPP Law n/a Typical shall provides Risks include hasYes been that a comparative the developed assessment Articleand analysis 36consists of is available the of PPP different of aat: comparativ http://w Decree prov option Yes According to Theart. the PPP Law, Value-for-Money 27, for Yesa PPP project According without Methodology to Yes contains the a concession aThe PPP Law, separate Chapter element, Value-for-Money section Yes III, "aPart PPP devoted 1, project Methodology Section According to description 1.1, to proposal art. contains the shall 27, PPP offor contain," the the Law, a PPP risk require Chapte anal proj amo Section 27 n/a Pursuant toNo Yes the PPPPursuant of the PPP Act, Unit is toto ensure No Section that n/a of the 27each PPP Act, projectYes entails among the appropriate activities the Section required 28 oftransfer the PPPof Act to risk: stipulat be unde (g) co No The PPP Handbook n/a encourages, Yes SectionPursuant under 2.1.14, a to risk No section 2.3.2 n/a assessment by of the stating PPP No Handbook, that n/a Public an optimal riskagencies allocation will adopt based on Be arisk Yes According to According the Procedure for Preparation to Yes the Procedure According and for Preparation to Implementation Yes the PPP ofand PPPs, According Implementation section Policy, Part 3, to Yes section thethe 1.4, of PPP3.1, control Policy, PPPs, According “a Part prerequisite process PartA, 3, to section the Stage for this Procedure for 1, section 3.1, any stage “a PPP prere for 1.4, inve Pt (ident No According to n/a Act, Article the Concessions According Yes 25(1), to "a feasibility No study the forn/a Policy the in Using concession a PPP Yes Model, shall <…> According draw Article upto 3(2), a "projects the register shall of risks Concessions eva Act be in t of the Procurement Section 2.2 No n/a Manual No outlines n/a Noprocurement the project Noand complex n/a for large n/a project and provides that suc No According to n/a Manual, the Concessions Yes Section According 4.3.3, Box to 4, NoItem the 7, "the n/a Concessions pre – Manual, Feasibility Yes Section According 1.5.1(1), "achieving or Preliminary study to the shall Concessions Value include Ma Mo for but Yes According to Module section 16.4.1 of the 4 of Treasury Yes manual Treasury the PPPRegulation, (p.23) Regulation, toYes determine prescribesModule whether section to construct 16.4.1.(c) 4aof proposed the the Yes indicates PPP risk-adjusted PPP Manual A that, project identifies among public financialis viability in sector the other steps best orcomparator to a interests bankabili follow aspects, fo a fe No Article 247.2 n/a of the LCSP Yes states that regarding According public works to Noconcessions: article n/a 247 the of 2. The LCSP, feasibility Yes the feasibility Article study report 247.2 shall must contain of the at include Law 9/2017 least a "descr the r follo n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Guidelines on PP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 14 of the PPP Act provides n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 7 ofn/a Pursuant toNo Yes the PPP Law: 1. The contracting Pursuant authority toNo Resolution No. undertake shalln/a Yes 81:27. After a preliminary receiving Pursuant all theto above feasibility study Section required of 58 of Resolut each presen docum No Section 13 of n/a the PPP Regulations Yes provides: 13.-(1) Section After 13 of No the approval the PPP Regulations n/a of the pre feasibility provides: Yes study, Section 13.-(1) After the 13 contracting the of the PPP authority approval of the sha pre Regulations section 22 (5) Pursuant toNo Yes n/aof the PPP Pursuant Act,"When proposing toNo Section the PPP project, 22 (6), the n/a the procuring host Yes agency Pursuant mustmust authority to submit include Section a project a report 22appraisal on alte (2) and r (6 No According to n/a Article 6(2) No of the PPP n/a Regulation, the PPP Project No Cycle n/a consists of Yes According the initial stage, to Articlestage, the feasibility the 8 of the pro PPP No Article 20 of n/a the PPP Law Yes of 2021 provides that Article the"[…] of Nothe PPP 18 Before Law giving n/a itsprovides No that opinion on "[o]nly the preliminary n/a projects evaluation and included in validating a portfolio o n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Policy, n/a Section Yes 1, “<…> the Government’s According PPP Policy, to the decision ente to Secti No According to n/a Article 4 of Yes Decree No.2016-772 (Decree Article 3 of No.No2016-772 the n/a of 20 decree No. 2016-772 June 2016, Yes of June 20, about the 2016 conditions Article 5provides of Decree and "The procedures No. 2016-772 procuring a fo No Article For BOT projects, 5 of the BOT n/a YesImplementation For BOT projects, Decree No provides n/a Article that 4 of the theBOT President Yes Law No. Turkey 3996 requires ofArticle of the 4may determine BOT that Law procuring No.contr the the 3996 No According to n/a of the Section 22(2)(b) PPP Act, the Yes According feasibility to NoSection study 22(2)(c)&(d) would n/abe assessed of Yes in PPP the Act, terms of the According the assessed projected to Section feasibility impact onstudy 22(2)(f) of t" the Article 11 of Pursuant toYes the PPP Annex 1 of Law: Order Yes1. The 232/2011 Pursuant No. analysis of contains the toYes effectiveness Article risk a11 of Order identification the ofPPP “On public-private Law: approval Yesmatrix 1. The of partnership analysis that the Pursuant describes Methodology to of the implementation Article effectiveness and evaluates of11 the ofPPP the of vario Effic PPP pub shall b Yes Dubai PPP Article 6 of the The Dubai Law provides, PPP Yes Guidelines "When selecting section Amongst the 3.8. Partnership Yes functions Risk Assessment of Projects, The Dubai government on the Yes page PPPfollowing Guidelines entities 37 provides, Article must as Section per 5 be Article The of taken 3.9, the management 10into Value Dubai ofaccount: the for PPPDubai Money, of Law3.PP ou risk i Th Yes According to the GreenAnnex Book (page 5 of the Yes 85), 'to be Green Book Assessment successful, titled Risk partnership Yes is conducted and uncertainty The arrangements using methodology treats theYes Infrastructure the need is generally toThe following be thoughtfully and Green subjects: conducted Projects BookRisk designed.' describes Authority using management the appro AInfras how th key § 33.2-1803(C) Pursuant toYes The VDOT (5) of P3 the Yes Risk Management Virginia Pursuant Code, theGuidelines to responsible Yes Section 2.2.2.1 (3.1.2) Methodology publicof identifies entity the Yes may for PPTA steps determine Manual the for exercise Appendix the Screening and Guidelines is provided that D of the development phase, the titled further PPTA which Manual under and/o are "Public t Se Yes According to The Ministry the PPP Regulatory Decree Yes of Finance article has 18, on once Pursuant its to website Yes the the eligibility PPPsupport Law, favorable The Ministry material previously report Yes of to andthe by Finance methodologic beginning the Pursuing Ministry has its onof the guidelines the of website PPP Finance procurement support that Law,and previously work the proce mate as Pla n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 16 of the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a (e) of the PPP Article 19.2Yes Law states Appendix Yes I andregarding II, FormArticle contents No. 01, PPP 14.3of YesPROJECT a feasibility (a) of the PPP PROFESSIONAL Appendix study Law provides: I and YesRESEARCH report for II, "Pre-feasibility Form a PPPNo. project: REPORT 01, Article 14.3 PPP study "e) of (dd) PROJECT [...] Decree report of the No. project-related PROFESSIO shall PPP 35:conta Item Law p According toNo n/a the PPP Amendment Act, SectionAccording Yes 4, which amends to No theAmendment the PPP n/a Section Act, 5 of Yes the PPP Section Act, 4, "(5)(1)(f)(iii) which amends According "the to the PPPthe functions Section Amendmen of o 5th the Zimbabwe Section 4 ofYes Yes and The Investment Development Section Guidelines, Chapter 4 ofAgency No 5 provides the Act n/a Zimbabwe№ 10/2019 Investment some guidance Yes [Chapter and on how 14:37] According to perform provides, Development Agency to theregarding Investment risk Act №feasibili 10/201 analysis ass Guid n/a n/a n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a According to the PPP Law, Yes Theart. Methodology 8(3)(8), Yes as part of According on PPP obtaining Assessments, to Yes athe Part PPP Law, V The mandatory provides opinion art. Methodology aondetailed Yes 8(3)(9),the as effectiveness onguidance part of PPP According obtaining Assessments, onand how toacomparative the mandatory to Part perform PPP Law, V provides opinion advanta an art.asse 8(3 Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q9#2_5 Q9#3_5_4 Q9#4_6 Q9#1_6_5 Q9#2_6 Q9#3_6_4 Q9#4_7 Q9#1_7_5 Q9#2_7 If yes, methodology? Is there a specific 9.6. please Procurement elaborateRelevant Strategy legal/regulatory Is there (i.e.,aquick If yes, provision assessment specific please 9.7. methodology? elaborate to Market Relevant sounding/ plan and legal/regulatory better assessment. strategize Is there a specific the 9.7.1 provision Including methodology? tendering the po process i No n/a Yes No Article 30 of the PPP Law n/a that:(1) Then/a provides No No shall include the following pha Project Cycle No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 19(3) of the PPP Law, the Pursuant toNo No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes The NSW Treasury NSW Office of Financial PPP Guidelines YesManagement Section Policy in National5PPP provide Yes &Guidelines Guidelines for both Paper the Business Volume 1 No TPP"Procurement 07-4Case "Commercial and Options Procurement Analysis" Policy Strat Frame No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the Law on Concessions, §17, "p No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes The PPP Screening According Manual, to No Screening the Condition n/a The PPP Screening 6: Yes Manual, Financially ViableCriteria provides According certain 9.1 to Yes "Is the sufficient guidance PPP Screening time onavailable the issuefor Manual, det dev ofSect Yes No Chapter 2 of the Instructions n/a for Evaluating No n/a PPP Yes Project Proposals approved Article 13 by the No of MoE the Instructions Resolution outlines on meth the Requirem No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 39 of the Concession Law provides fo No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No note section 6.4 provides: the The PPP guide No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Policy, Annexure 3, Sec No n/a Yes The New Public No Procurement n/a Law (Law No 14.133/2021) n/a Noin paragraph 1 of article 18: "§ states Yes Annex No. 1 Pursuant toNo n/a of the Ordinance No n/a financialNo for the n/a elements and economic Noof the concession:1. Financial a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the Annex of Sub Decree No. 72 No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes for Costing, The Guidelines 2016, provide Procurement strategy Yes a comprehensive assessment Chapter 3 of Yes is guide described the Supply to assessing The under Manual Federal a contains project's Yes Implementing Chapter 3 -detailed Procurement financial Guidelines recommendation viability. Strategy provid The Gu of t No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes guides There are several that DNP Article No 2.2.1.1.2.1.1 and Ministry of the n/a ofPPP Regulations Finance have developed Yes (Decree Articles 1082 as11 of those Yes to and 14matters 2015) ofinclude PPP Law in among parallel establish to the the the is studia No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 2 of Decree No. n/a 2009-161 of No n/aon the organization 20 May 2009 No and functioning of th No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 15 of the PPP Regulations. Preparator No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Article 5 ofn/a Pursuant toNo No the PPP Regulation, financial n/a feasibility No analysis n/a No shall be included in the Public Sector Comp Yes Yes The PPP Preparation According Manual.The Feasibility to Yes the PPP Study The Methodology. PPP Preparation Preparation Yes Manual, Stage Manual, According Stage to 3, "already Yes 3. the in aPublic Procurement feasibility Act, §1 study, a contract Yes Yes A detailed guidance Section 39 is provided in of the No Guidance the Public Procurement on Public Yes n/a Construction Act provides Section (Section that : "Before 3) 39(1) and Yes of the in launching Section Public Procurement procurement 1aof Law the Standar No No No comments n/a No Yes No comments article 4.1 of the PPP Law (Law N Pursuant toNo No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No The General Resolutionn/a for the Presentation No n/aApproval and Yes of PPP Projects Articles contains Noa56 53 and of the Guide. PPP Regulations Article dea 8.1 of the guid No n/a Yes Yes Article 20 of Article the PPP Law provides 20 of Yes for special the contracting Article PPP Law states29 of No methods the that: PPP “PPP projects depending Executive referred on the topurpo unde Regulations s Yes Noof "Methodology Section 7.2.2. n/a forNo Evaluation n/a of PPP projects" to the financial No refers n/a No modeling to be included as p No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Procurement Directive Section 9(1) requires No n/a Yes Section 65 n/a Pursuant toNo Yes of the Act on Public Contracts Pursuant toNo and Section 65 ofBefore Concessions, the the Act Public C on procure No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No of the Public Acquisition Cod Article R2111-1 No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Article 8 ofPursuant Pursuant toYes toNo Resolution Article No. 191:14 F) of n/a Resolution Availability Yes No. and Sustainability 426:2.Pursuant If theAnalysis project Article toNo - The meets9(3B) initial the public of Resolution and private identification of th No. 1p No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No(b) of the PPP Act, 2020 (Act 1 Section 38 (2) No n/a Yes Article 4(2) No of the PPP Law n/a provides No n/a work orNo <...> for each service included in the List of Pro Yes No Ministerial Accord n/a contains 214-2017 No the protocol n/a for theNo preparation of technical n/a No studies for PPP projects. This p No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes The inputs to Thefinancial the detailed PPP Toolkit No analysis according Module 2 provides n/a to the No for PPP importance n/ain Module theToolkit No of both 2 would "Choosing include best-suited thethe pr following: - Yes No The methodology usedn/a to analyze these No aspects n/a Yes is provided in Attachment According Chapter Yes to the III part LKPPBRegulation (7)(e) of the Bappena 29/2018, C No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Article 2.3.1 of the PPPn/a No Guidelines:No "PPP Procurement n/a Yes Assessment. The Article NDFA will 2.8.2 of Yes provide the PPP financial, insurance Guidelines: and Commun Yes through the This is doneNo n/a Guides to No using the PPP n/aMethod No n/a PPP projects: in implementing No http://govmultisite.xyz/p Yes No The PPP Guidelines mention n/a in Article No 5.3(d) analysis n/a on financial Yes Pursuant feasibility, which toYes Article 66 of includes analysis an the Public the flow ofContracts No n/a Yes According to Yes the Procurement The Procurement Yes Handbook, Handbook, According Volume 2, Volume Appendix to No 2, I, the Appendix PPP Policy, "a Procurement I,Section provides Plan 7,a deta iden "the P No n/a Yes No of the Process Section 4-1(2) Yes stipulates n/a Guidelines Section that 2-3(2) No of the authority a procuring shall make Process Guideline ac provi No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes of the PPP regulation provides th Article 4(C) No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to Order No. 725, Appendix 2, the No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to Section 12 of the PPP Regulatio Yes No An economic n/a analysis measures No the economic n/a efficiency of No n/a a project by No computing benefit-cost ratio (B/C ratio), ne No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 23 of the PPP Law: 1. Befo Pursuant toNo Yes Yes The PPP Guidebook The PPP provides "4.2.2.4 in Executive Yes Financial Regulations TheAssessment": PPPprovides Guidebook Yes In Article provides in this stage Article 9 about in of 9 p. the of the Yes Comprehensive 61: PPP "4.2.3 Comprehensive Executive Management Regulations Feasibility and Procu Feasibility pro St Study No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No for the n/a A methodology financial viability No assessment n/a may be n/a Article 22 No found under No of Regulation 1152:22. In prep No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Law, art. 5, "the projec Yes No CPMA Order No 2015 /n/a 8-221 on Aug. No 24, 2015 MARKET INVESTIGATION n/a Yes CPMA AND Order Yes No. 2015/8-221 PRIVATE INITIATIVE PRINCIPAL on PRO August 24, 2 No n/a Yes No Article 8.2 of the PPP Decree n/a (Decree n/a No 2017-149 No 2017, elaborating on the app from 2 March Yes Yes Procedure The PPP Manual, #2.8: to According Yes PPPthe Project PPP Manual, Financial The PPP Manual, Feasibility Yes Procedure Procedure Analysis #3.1:According Developing #3.1: provides to Developing Yesthe a detailed the PPP Policy, theguidance Implementation Implementation Section Plan on7.2, for how the to P “all No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes provides for Market Soundi The PPP Manual Yes No Numeral PPP Guidelines 6 fraction No n/a II a) and PPP n/a Manual (Annex No n/a Model) 2 Financial No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Methodology Financial Viability provides According No to the Concessions such n/a a methodology. art. 9.5, "the Law, No state administrative n/a No central body in charge No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to Article 32, paragraph 2, point 16 Yes No : https://www.finances.gov.ma/Docs/depp/2018/Guide%20PPP%2026-10-2017%20vDef.pdf The PPP guide n/a No n/a No n/a No refers No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 11.3 of the PPP Policy, the Pursuant toNo Yes No 3 of the n/a Under Module Yes PPC, the following model The required isPPC Yestoto applies beall prepared: large The PPC governmental describes Yes Action the projects 3D Calculating needfor and the infrastructure net cash of method valc No n/a Yes According to No n/a Section the PPP Policy, 5.17, "a number Yes According of actions to Yes the PPP Guide, required complete to Section a Det 4.2, "in No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Section D of the feasability n/a study guidelines No 0 Yes analysis, requires a market which Article 24 includes No of an analysis the PPP of the offer Law provides: and Partnersh No n/a Yes No Procedures The Procurement Yesprovides n/a Manual Section in Section 18(c) 29 No provides: of This the Public Manual provide Procurement Act No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No 7 of the Feasibility Study Decr Article 6, Item No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Policy, Section G, "in or No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to section 8.2.4 of the PPP Policy, Yes No The PPP-Unit n/a web site provides different No guidelines n/a for evaluation No n/a (including No viability) of PPP projects : - I financial Yes Yes Directorial Resolution Article 47 of No 005-2016-EF/68.01, the PPP which n/aapproves Regulations Yes the Guidelines requires the establishment Article for theYes 48.4 development of the of strategies PPP Regulations offor the the developm establishe formulation Yes of PPPGB Policy Section 4.3 Yes Section Circular 4.1 Yes of PPPGB No. 01A-2016 Resolution Section provides No. 5 ofYes PPPGB :2018-03-03 b) In Resolution terms dated Section of the No. 4.5 March procedures, of 2018-03-03 Yes 22, 2018, PPPGB the Policy dated financial provides Circular Marchthe No. 22, appo 01A- 201 appraisal No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes MFDRP's PPP Guidelines focuses Point 3.6 ofYes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 12/2 of the PPP Law, prio Pursuant toNo No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Per the ANAP Manual: The ANAP has created Yes strategy contracting Pursuant a document/manual is a document toYes Article that for conducting is part 139 of the ofPublic the a procuremen planning s Procure Yes Yespreparation Guidelines for and 3.3.1.1 Section Yes of the assessment ofPPP Feasibility Section Guideline 3.3.1.1 Yes Study provides of Reports the PPP Pursuant have thatGuideline thebeen contracting toNo article drafted provides autority by 13 that MINECOFIN of the the PPP shall contracting Plan : http://w Law: for pr Prior t a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Under II. PLANNING AND PREPARATION of th Yes No Manual The Privatization n/a in Part Twelve provides No Yes for Money, n/aunder Value During financial the business No case viability and bankability assess development stage No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes The Value-for-Money Methodology According to Nothe PPP Law, describes n/a in detail Chapter on No III, Part how 1, Section to perform n/a a financial 1.1, No art. 27, for a analysis. viability PPP project without No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes section 3.2.2 of the PPP Handbo Pursuant toYes Yes Yes According to According the Procedure to Yes for Preparation the Procedure and According for Preparation to Yes the Procedure Implementation PPPs, ofand According Implementation Part for Preparation A,to Stage Yes the Procedure 1, of and PPPs, Implementation section 1.4, section for Preparation the2.4, controlof if a p a pr Yes No The Methodology n/a for Preparing No Investment Documents n/a No contains n/a detailedNo a more guidance. No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to n/a Manual, the Concessions Yes SectionAccording 7.1.1, "a key to Yes initial the task for the Concessions Concession Manual, m Sectio Yes Yes According to the PPP Manual, According Module to Yes 4,PPP the Part Manual, 7, According initialModule to Yes the 4,PPP a procurment Manual, value-for-moneyAccording test gives Module plan to Yes indications must the the 4,PPPbeManual, procurement prepared about how Module as to part assess 4, plan mus of a the No n/a Yes No of LCSPn/a Article 116.4.a) Yes procuring mandates the Article authority 115 of No tothe LCSP justify regulates the selected procurem preliminary No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 14 of the PPP Act provides that "[…] t No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Section 59 n/a Pursuant toNo Yes of Resolution No. 81, corporate Pursuantpreparation toNo Section 59 a PPP ofof projectNo. Resolution may in 81, No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No(1) of the PPP Regulations 202 Regulation 36 No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Noof the PPP Act: When proposin Section 22 (6) No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Policy, Section 5, “to en No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No ) of the n/a Section 22(2)(c Yes that the PPP Act provides Paragraph feasibility 5.3 No of the study PPPinclude shall an assessme Policy provides tha Yes No assessment Financial viability Nobe performed n/a should n/a in line Yes with Order Pursuant “On approval toYes Resolution No. 384, The of the Methodology the PPP ofprocedu No n/a Yes Yes Article 10 of the PPP Law Deciding states "For onYes the project the The purposes procurement PPP of this Guidelines, No strategy Law, section and roadmap a Government3.6. Entity Market is part Soun will: p 1. o Yes Yes Section 6.10 of the Green In the Book GreenYes Book, provides that thethe The 'commercial methodology Yes dimension' affordability options of is The described (outlined should Green above Book above), Yesin provides always be section accordance considered guidance 3.14, withwhen the page onprovisi 11, the devel im spe Yes Appendix D of the PPTA No n/a Manual and NoGuidelines n/a Yes provides Guidance on Pursuant toNo APPENDIXD Project Identification of the and PPTA Manual Screening provide No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the Decree on Examination of t No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No II, Formn/a Appendix I and No. 01, PPP No n/a PROJECT PROFESSIONAL YesRESEARCH Article REPORT 19.2of Yes (h) of theNo. Decree Law PPP35: statesD. Section V.5 of regardi No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes According to InvestmentAccording Guidelines, to Investment YesSection 80, According Guidelines, "the Pre-Feasibility to No the Section PPA,80, Section "the Study should 26(1), Pre-Feasibility include "beforea n/a n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes No The Methodology n/a on PPP Assessments, n/a Part IIIn/a provides a No n/a detailed guidance n/a to perform an assessment of on how Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q9#3_7_4 Q9#4_8 Q9#1_8_5 Q9#2_8 Q9#3_8_4 Q9#4_9 Q9#1_9_5 Q9#2_9 Q9#3_9_4 9.7.2 If yes, please Specifically elaborate designed Relevant legal/regulatory Is there to identify a specific If yes, themethodology? please solutions provision9.8. elaborate Environmental and technology Relevant legal/regulatory available Is there impact as assessment a specific well If yes, as the methodology? please opportunities provision elaborate for innov n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 3(8) Yes of the PPP Law The defines Feasibility Administrative Studies as: Guidelines fo n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 4(2)DCM of DCM 912, No.No. dated November 575/2013, 1 the contr n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Environmental Yes Decree No. Environmental Jumada 07-145 of 2Decree El Oula No. 07-141 n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes Article 11.1(d) of the PPPimpact Environmental assessmen Law, the award o n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes article 13 The of PPP Law, prior General to the call Act, Environmental L for te n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Chapter 2 Section Pursuant toNo n/a 2 3) (f) of Decision No. 12 n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 3.4 Yes of the NSWSection 4 of the provides, PPP Guidelines "Enviro National PPP Gui n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the Law on Certain projects Concessions, must be §56(2), "a cont (2)evaluate n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 2.1 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the BOT to Articles Rules, the sector 4.8 orga and 4.9 o No The PPP Screening n/a Screening Manual, No Condition n/a 7: Marketable Yes provides certain to According Yes the PPP guidance on Guidelines, the Bangladesh The Section issue of a PPP Environment 14.1(c), project "to marke tes Con n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 16 of Yes the Instructions on399-3 Law No. On State Ecologica the Requirements for th n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Law of 22 May Yes 2008 onArticle the assessment 5 of Law of the of22 effects May 2008ofo n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 12 of PPP Law require Articlefour 90 of the Law studies on for environm any PPP1. F n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 4 ofSection the Sarajevo IX (Article 53 to PPP Law, Article in 65 the cou n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to the EIA Act, The EIA Act Section 4(1), provides <...> no such a meth person sh n/a Yes No Procurement The New Public n/a Law (Law Yes 14.133/2021) The PPPstates LawYes establishesThe in paragraph that methodology 1 of thearticle previous for 18: "§the 1 The Environ issuance of an preli n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Environmental Yes Impact Assessment The Ordinance On EU as per Terms And TheDirectives a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Art.21 PPP law Yes provides that “Public-private Decree partnership No. 2015-1187/PRES/TRA n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes article 12 of Decree the PPP the 7th of Law, October 2010 a partnership b cont n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to of Sub Decree No. 72 on Environ the Annexn/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Environment Yes Decree No. 2013/0171/PM Articles laying 9 of Decree down te No. 2013/01 the Procurement Section 3 ofNo No Guide also n/a Analysis n/a addresses Yes The Canadian market sounding, Yes and sets Environmental the objective UnderAssessment of Canadian the Act Environment 2012to: this assessment -O (http n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 80 of Decree N°630/PR/PM/MEERH/20 the environmental Law (Law No. 014/PR/98 n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Art. 10 of the Yes Law Nº 19.300 of General Environmental Environmental impact assessmenB n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Guiding Opinions of the National A PPP proponent, Developm where required No Colombia Compra n/a provides Eficiente Noguidelines n/a for the State Yesentities to create Article their Yesown 2.2.2.1.5.5 of market The the National PPP assessment Regulations Authority strategies: (Decree 1082 httpso on Enviro n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 18 of Decree No. Article 14/019 of02 18of August Decree 2014 No. layino 14/019 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 15 of Yes the PPP Regulations. Preparatory Chapter II of actions the General an Regulat n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Art. 10 paragraph Yes 2 of Decree PPP Decree No.of 96-894 November 2018-358 819 of Mar n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 37, paragraph Yes of the Environmental 4 Pursuant of the Envi to Article 76 Protection No The PPP Preparation Manual, n/a Stages No n/a Feasibility 2 and 3. The YesStudy Methodology. According to Yes the EIA Act, The EIA Act Section §4(1)(a) and 2,provides (c), the a detailed m Noon Publicn/a The Guidance No section 4 Construction, n/a provides aYes detailed guidance on to According Yes performing section 1(1) a The market the on ofLaw analysis. LawEIA onprovides EIA, The"the apurpos issue of the detaile n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes article 15 of PPP Law Decree (Law No. 2017-186 of 2 n 2011-029/PR/MHUEAT n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 41 of Yes (General Law 64-00Law (General Environment 64-00Environmental Law) en n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 53 of n/a the PPP Regulations provides for the need o n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The Environmental Protection The Ministry ofState Law 4of amended 1994for b the Envi n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 32 of Yes PPP Law state of Environment Law that procuremen to start the (Decree 233 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the EIA Act, Chapter to According Subchapter 2, the 1, § 3(1 EIA Act, Chapter n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 17 (2) Yes (c) of PPPThe Environmental proclamation Impact states Assess in undertaki n/a Yes Section 65 n/a Pursuant toNo of the Act on Yes Public Contracts andAssessment Act on the Yes Concessions, The ofbefore Act on the Environmental the procurement Environmental Impact (252/20 Im proce n/a n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article L122-1 Yesof the environmental code The provisions the methodol andprovides for Im n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 30 of Yes the environmental Law Article 32 No.environmental of the L 007/2014 relate n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 11 of The Environmental Resolution Assessment No. 426, C if the proje n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPA, Part TheIV, §97(3), "in making Environmental Impact Assess the awa n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 4 (2) Yes of Act 1039 requires The that the Assessment Environmental R contracting a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 22 of Yes the PPP Law Law No. 4014 provides of 1. <...> Environmenta 2011 on the Env n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 37 of Yes the PPP Law requires Chapter articles 21 to III, conducting 37, of G a econom n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes article 11 of Pursuant the PPPto article Law: needs this 11 analysi of the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 56 of Environmental Management and Decree onn/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes PPPs are subject Yes to theThe environmental impact Regulation of assessme the National Sy n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Annex I through Yes Annex Article III of Governmental Decree 6 through Article No. 11 of 3 Go n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Infrastructure Yes Environmental projects will impacts onsocial often have significant a the pr No According to n/a to the the Attachment NoBappenas n/a Regulation № Yes According 4, Chapter to Yes III, B, 6 (b), the "economic art. 23 (4)(d) and commercial According to the of the Bappenas Attachment studies" Regulatio to a that t n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Environmental Yes impact assessments are enabled The Code of Practice by Note 23/12/1997 n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes Article 10-12 According Law of Iraqito of our Protection and contributors, th No Article 3.3 of n/a the PPP Guidelines: No "Optional Market n/a Consultation. Yes EU procurement TheRegulation Yes of 29(4) Directives theIn EUaccordance Concession with 2017 do not preclude national provides: market and con "IE n/a No n/a No n/a Yes This is regulated Yes under This is elaborated the Planning in the Planning Law 5725-1965. The Yes No. 14Pursuant ANAC Guideline toYes Article on "Indications on 66 preliminary of ANAC the Public market Yes Contracts Guideline No. 14 Code: consultations" Article on "Indications "1. 23Before Yes on starting preliminary Article (http://www.anticorruzione.it/portal/public/cla a tender 23 market (6) procedure, consultations" of the the admini Public (h Contra n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Policy, The EIA Guidelines Section provide 7, "the such a PPP criteria n/a No n/a No n/a Yes An environmental Yes impact The Environmental assessment Impact pursuant the En to Assess n/a No n/a No n/a Yes report is prepared A feasibilityNo n/a by the contracting author n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The environmental impact Chapter 6 of Law assessment to be isNo. conducte 212, "Enviro n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 32 (2)(c) Yes of the PART PPP Act requires VI – a contracting INTEGRATED ENVIRON au n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Environmental Yes A detailed Impact methodology Assessment is provid Act of 2009 unde n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 5 ofYes Directive One Thestates: The feasibility Environmental Impact Assess study wi No Article 13 of n/a the PPP Executive Regulations No n/a "TheYes provides, Article Authority may announce 7 of the Yesthe PPP Executive The for Request Implementing Regulations Expression of Regulations provides, for (N Interest"The n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Annex 1 of Regulation Resolution No. 60 of<...> 160, an asse the EIA on t n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 26 of Yes the PPP Decree provides: Article “A feasibility 5-32 of the Environmentastud n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Law on Yes Environmental Law on Environmental The Impact, Impac Assessment of Octob n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Guide, Section Decrees dated 24/5/2012 8213devoted o to the PPP No CPMA Order 8-221 on Aug. No 2015 /n/a No 24, 2015 n/a MARKET INVESTIGATION Yes AND Article 3 PRIVATE of Law Yes on PRINCIPAL The Manual INITIATIVE Environmental Impact for Environmental PROJECT Assessment COMM fo Im n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 7.2 of Yes the PPP Decree Pursuant to article (Decree 13 of the 2017-149 from 2M envi No Procedure The PPP Manual, No n/a #1.2: Completing the n/a Project PPP Yes Screening Matrix,to According Yes provides the Environment forThe a table Management to be filled Environment Management out Act to№ 19 o make s A n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No "Environmental Section 34A(2) n/a Quality, Prescribed Activ n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 9. 1. Yes of the PPP Law Decree requires the evaluation n°2018-0991/p-rm to of de Dec Market Sounding, To realize a No No 5.2 of the n/a section n/a PPP manual Yes to :§IV requires Part of the Yes Investigate environment whether Sections protection 16 scheme a similar andact 18 of 2002 exists therelates for whi Act prot n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 14 of Yes the PPP Law: Article determine "To 25 the of the PPP feasibility o Regulations n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 25 of Yes the PPP Law establishes The that the feasibility Law on Environmental Impac n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the Environmental Protection The Law on Law of Mong the Environmental Im n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to Article 32,The paragraph EIA Law contains 2, the point 16 detailed of the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Law No. 12-03 Yeson impact The Guideon studies Public-Private to the environment pr Partn n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes As per article 17.1 (g) of Chapter II of PPP Law the is there the responsibi Environmental I n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes Environment TheProtection Act, Environment 2020 section Protection 2 Rule No The PPC describes n/a and method the need n/a No of conducting Yes consultations. a market An environmental ItYes describes impact A detailed market assessment consultation methodology (milieueffectrappo as: A for the E method specific methodology There is no No n/a No on how to perform n/a a market Yes sounding assessment According Yes to the designed Resource The Management Resourcefor specifically Management PPP Actprojects. of 1991, ActSe o Ho n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 12(4) Yes of the PPPDecree 45-94 (Rules Law provides of Permit that selection An proc n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 24 of n/a the PPP Law provides: Partnership contract n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 2 ofYes the Environmental Impact Assessment The Environmental Act p Impact Assess n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 16 of Yes the PPP Law The methodology provides forproposal that PPP pre environmen n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Policy, Section J, The Pakistan Step 3, "the PPP Environmental P Prot n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 27.7 Yes of the PPP Law Executive Decree provides: 123 of 2009 Preliminary est environ n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Section 50 Division 3 of the Environment of the Environment Ac Act:(1) Wher n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 35 of Decree 4183/2020 The PPP-Unit within the web section site "Struc provides d Yes Directorial Resolution Article 44.2No of the PPP 005-2016-EF/68.01, Regulations n/aapproves which Yes establishes the Guidelines that The for thethe Evaluation Yes Evaluationdevelopment Report Report required Theofmust theby Formulation include Article Evaluation a Report 44.2 3. Technical must of the and inclu PP Structa of PPPGB Policy Section 4.4 No No n/a Circular No. 01A-2016: n/a The financial Yes model review PPPGB and Policy Yes Circular the VfMNo. outcomes Within the that 01A-2016environmental requires the project an environm Apprai will be MFDRP's PPP Point 3.6 ofYes Step Guidelines 3 under No contains Page 90 inav n/a thorough 1.0 of the methodology MFDRP Guidelines Yes Thefor assessment market on Yes PPP sounding, is Preparation required Section starting the IV, by(p.with 105 Chapter Article rules in version 46 2 on the of 2.0) memo the stat Act o n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Articles 6/1 Pursuant toYes In (e) accordance with and 12/3 of the PPP Law, national prio and E n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No 30/2002 Article 1 of Law Promulgating the Law on Envir n/a Decision No. Pursuant toYes 395/2016 Pursuant toYes Article Article 139 Pursuant of under 18(1), the Procurement to the Yes conditions Decision No. Law: Annex of 395/2016 Article (1) No. 1 Before139 Yes Article of initiating of Lawthe 18(1), No. the Public Section 292/2018, award under Procurement procedure, ofregarding 2 theLaw conditions no. Law, the the 292/2018 the of contract evaluat Article contr (re n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes article 13 of The the PPP Law: PriorLaw environmental tender to aNo. 04/2n n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 4 (3) Yes of the Planning and Urban The Planning Urban Managem andManagement (E n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Each PPP project Yes is unique. Where required The and determined determination to carry o n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 36 of n/a provides that the prelimina the PPP Decree n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Law, Law on Environmental Article projectAs 27, for a PPPImpact w n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Section 23 A the Environment ofmethodology be found un mayProtection Ag No Section 3.2.2 n/a of the PPP HandbookNo provides that n/aGPEs should n/a the market No sound out proposed PPP approach, so as to No on theirn/a No According to n/a for Preparation the Procedure No and n/a Yes of PPPs, Implementation According Part A,to Stage Yes the Methodological The Methodological 1, section 1.4, the Document control process Document on a Feasibi t for o n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the Concessions DecreeAct, Article on EIA 3(2), "when provides im a method n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 2.2 Yes of the Procurement Manual outlines The Environment the pro Act of 1998 pro No Manual, The Concessions n/a Sections No 6.3 to 6.5 provide n/a a detailed Yes guidance on how According to No to the Concessions conduct n/a a public Manual, consultation Section 4.3.3, Box process. No Module 4 (p. PPP Manual 12) of then/a No requires to n/a assess each solution'sAn Yes environmental option using Yes the following impact Theassessment considerations: is required Environmental Impact - Is there to Assess a ca be p n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 247.2 Yes regarding Law 21/2013 public of Environmental works concessions A require n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the Guidelines The Environmental Act on PPPs, Section and the 257(ii), a “th n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 14 of n/a the PPP Act provides that "[…] the project c n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the Concessions Act, Chapter Code The Environmental "a cont 4, §3,(Ds 200 n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The facilities mentioned The in the appendix Federal for officeof Environme the Environm n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 7 ofThe the Law Law: PPP on 1. The contracting Environmental Impaca n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The need for Yes The methodology an environmental for the Environ impact assessment for al n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The requirement Yes for anThe environmental methodology is provided impact und assessme n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Decree Law Article 1 of the n/a No. 5/2011 on Environmenta n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 38 of Yes the Environmental Details are Law (Law No. provided Decreetre by2008-05 N n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Act No. 16 of 2003 issuing Thethe Environmental Environmental Impact Impact Ass Assess n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes The Environmental the PPP Policy, Management Section 4, “<...> the aim of t n/a No n/a No n/a Yes PPP Law ( La Article 7 of No No. 2015-49 dated 27 Novemb n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The Environmental Impact Articles 8, 9, 10, (EIA) Assessment procedure 11, 12, a 13 and 14 n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The National Yes The National Environmental 153 of 1995 (NEMA Act, CapEnvironmental Act, Order of the Pursuant toNo MEDTU dated n/a No 14.12.2021 n/a No. 1067, Yes the analysis Pursuant todemand of the Article 11 Yes should of Ukraine contain the has PPP Law: a detailed forecast 1. The analysis environme of of t the leve n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Dubai PPP Article 6 of the n/aLaw provides, "When selectin Yes is described The methodology The Green above Book Yes provides and moreThe detailed guidance methodology inYes on thetheisimportance Green The Book briefly process - follow described of market Yes of the and Environmental assessment. further long-list On and detailed top Impact of short-list This thein comes mentioned the Assessment Green in the appraisal Book Town form proces in the f a -o n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Key Tasks Yesduring the The methodology Project is provided Development inc Phaseund n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 16 of Yes the PPP Law, Decree 349/005, regarding Regulation the required of En assessm n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a the Law on Environmental Expertise, Article n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Environmental Yes The Environmental Protection Impact and Conservation Asses Act [CA No II, Formn/a Appendix I and No No. 01, PPP n/a PROJECT PROFESSIONAL YesRESEARCH Article REPORT Yes (d) 14.3of Decree of the No. PPP Article 35: Law 29 provides: of the Section D.VI.8 Law "Pre-feasibility of onForm Environm 01, A n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According toYes the PPP Amendment Act, Section The Environmental 9, which Act and the E n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Investment Yes Guidelines, Section The Environmental 20, "as Management n/a No n/a n/a n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 12 of PPPEnvironmental A the proponent, where required Impact Asse n/a No n/a n/a n/a Yes Yes Certain types The of activities will Lawbeon EIA provides required the to carry out an deta Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q9#4_10 Q9#1_10_5Q9#2_10 Q9#3_10_4Q9#4_11 Q9#1_11_5Q9#2_11 Q9#3_11_4Q9#4_12 Relevant 9.8.1. Consultation legal/regulatory Is there process witha affected specific If yes, provision please communities 9.9. elaborate Social methodology? explicitly impact Relevantincluded legal/regulatory Is there assessmentin the a specific environmental If yes, provision methodology? please elaborate impact 9.9.1 assessment Consultation process with a Yes Yes The Administrative The Administrative Guidelines for the YesPreparation Guidelines Article of Environmental for the 3(8) of the No Preparation PPPImpact Law n/a of Assessments Environmental defines Feasibility No provides: Impact Studies 5 as: Public A strategic, Disclosu Assessments pr Yes 7 of DCM No. Pages 6 andYes Pages 912 6 state: 7During andYes of DCMconsultations No. Pursuant 912 state: Yes Article During towith other 6(3) consultations institutions of DCM DCM No.No. 912 on with Yescontains issues 575/2013, other to the be the institutions addressed details feasibility of onwhat issues in study the sht E Yes Yes Article 10 of Article 10 the Environmental Decree of No Decree the No. n/a No. of 07-145 07-145 May Noof May 19, 19, 2007 determining n/a 2007 determining No the field of application, the contentca field of application, Yes Yes Whenever an environmental Articlelicense 16 ofYes is required, Presidential According Decree it must 117/20 be to Yes article obtained22under of 10 Presidential April of Presidential 2020 the specific provides Yes Decree Decreeno. for rules of the 117/20 the 117/20 public general of of consultatio 22 22 April enviro April 20 202 Yes No Article 19 of n/a the General Environmental Yes Act, Law According No. 25,675, Yes to determines Article 13 The of PPP General the right Law, prior Environmental Yes to the of every citizen call Act, for totendering Law be 25675, to consulted No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Yes NSW Environmental Yes and Planning Approval Item (EPA) process 3 of Appendix under the Yes Environmental 1 of Guidel the NSW PPP Plannin Yes Yes According to The the EIA Act, §13(2), EIA Act Yes provides "the environmental for According impact to Yes the instructions the report EIA and for Act, steps Certain projects §1(1)(1)(a) to be social listed followed Yesaspects and the to"the in(d), column engage are captured goalwith 1of ofthe as the thepart Annex affec enviroo Yes No According to Article 4.10 n/a of the Environmental Yes Impact Assessment Pursuant Article 2.1 toNo Law: of n/athe BOT the Rules: Customer No shall the sector conduct public hearing organization sub No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPA, art. The Bangladesh 31, No Environment “no condition Conservationin shall be incorporated A Yes Article 12 of Pursuant toNo Law No. 399-3: n/a Yes 1. Local Paragraphs Councils of 12-18 Yes of the Deputies, Paragraphs local Instructions executive Yes 12-18and for Evaluating of administrative the Instructions PPP Project bodies for Eval in Prop Yes No Art. 7 of Law 2008 on the of 22 Mayn/a Noassessment n/a No of certain of the effects No n/a plans and programs on the environment Yes Yeswith art.In In compliance 89 of the environmental Yeswith art.Article compliance 89law, of the theof 12 impact No PPP Law environmental assessment require n/a law,four study the studies Noguide impact assessment for elaborated any PPP1. byFeasibility theguide study Minist e st Yes Article 61 of Pursuant toNo n/a Law No. 33/03, No in then/a process of No n/a EIA, theNo evaluating the competent ministry informs and Yes Yes According to The the EIA Act, Section EIA Act 7(1), Yes provides such The asocial “an applicantmethodology. shallimpact take Yes allassessment measures The EIAisAct performed Yes provides necessary to seek as such part the methodology. views a of of the peo the environme Yes Yes CONAMA Resolution CONAMA No. Resolution 9/1987 deals Yes specifically No. Underwith article 9/1987 deals No 10, public consultations specifically VI, of n/a the PPP asLaw, with required Yes before public consultations for launching environmental any as PPP permits proje required for Yes Article 87(1), Pursuant toYes The item Ordinance 2 ofNo theOn The Terms n/a And Environmental Protection Conditions No ActFor (hereinafter n/a No Implementation "EPA") Of a discussion with affecte The Environmental Im Yes Yes Chapter 2 of Law on Environment Art. 27 of Decree (Law Yes No. 006-2013) No. Art.21 PPP 20151187/PRES/TRANS/PM/MERH/MATD/MATD/MME/MS/MARHA details law No providesn/a that “Public-private the environmental Yes impact assessment, partnership requiring projectsa s ar Yes Nocontent of As part of the n/a No the assessment, Art. n/a 16 of the Decree 7th October No of then/a No2010 bearing measures for the No n/a No n/a Yes Article 10(4) No Law, regarding of the PPPn/a No Project Approval states: If the Yes 2013/0171/PM Decree No. Yes laying Decree Yes 2013/0171/PM No.down termsDecree and laying conditions No.down Yes 2013/0171/PM terms of Decree and laying conditions No. the realization of down Yes 2013/0171/PM of terms social and the realization environmental and laying conditions of down social ofterm the impacan No n/a No n/a Yes NoEnvironmental The Canadian Yes Act 2012 provides within t n/a Assessment Yes Yes Article 27 to 32 of EIA Decree DecreeN°630/PR/PM/MEERH/2010 N°630/PR/PM/MEERH/2010 Yes No relating relating Article 8 of the to PPP ordinance to n/a the theregulation provides: No of regulation of the Environmental Environmental use of a public-private ImpactAss Impact Assp Yes establish an Law 20,500 Yes obligation Regarding Yes and the procedure procedure Also ofof Law prior 20,500, covered consultation by the Yes themechanism following The process environmental is ofa carried Yes Law link toout a 20,500 assessment guide byreferred the MOP. process in Additiona and in inclu http://www.conc the Yes Yes According to of the Environmental article 11 Article Yes 17 The EIS of a Impact construction ArticleAssessment 14 of project the Guiding No Law, shall n/a The Opinions include the of Nofollowing institutions theresponsible MOF, contents: NDRCfor and (1) theOutline People preparing th Yes Yes According to of Law article 39 The 1682 national Yes of authority 2013, consultation Article on 2.2.2.1.5.5 No process environmental ofis licensing the required n/a PPP (ANLA) Regulation Yes provides to be (Decree performed a guideline during 1082 offor 2015), the structuri the am prep Yes Yes Article 50 to Article 50 to No 55 of the environmental 55 Decree environmental n/a of the (Decree 14/019 No.No Decree of 02 (Decree n/a No. August No 2014 14/019 laying of down the operating 02 August ru 2014 laying No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Article 41 of n/a the General Regulation Yes on Environmental Impact Article 15 Yes of the Assessment PPP Regulations. Chapter Procedures Preparatory Yes II of the General (EIA) provides actions Regulation and for other on need the pre Envir No n/a No n/a Yes Art. 10 paragraph No PPP DecreeYes 2 of n/a No. 2018-358 of March 29, 2018 Yes Yes The Environmental Articles Act Protection 163prescribes No and 164 ofN/a the the process Environmental of Noconsultation n/a with Protection affected Act contain No communities the methodology in Title IX. for Ac the Yes Yes According to The the EIA Act, EIA Act §6(1), "a party Yes provides thataintends The EIAto detailed methodology carry Yes out includes thea social project on The aspects EIA how(notifier) the Act concerned provides so that Yesshallprovisions submit a public detailed notification applicable methodology a shall to of t be engage Yes EIA, sections The Law on Yes 35-37, The is devoted Law on Yes EIA, sections to describing The 35-37, social the devoted Yesprocess isaspects are to analyzed of describing The consultation on Law as part Yes EIA the with process provides of an the Environmental public of a consultation detailed and authoritie Impact with th guidance Yes Yes Public participation is addressed Public participation byYes articlesis 15addressed Pursuant to 17 of the by toYes article articles Environmental 15 of 15Articles to PPP 17 Law of16 the assessment (Law and NoEnvironmental No. 17Decree Decree 2017-186 (Decree n 2011-029/PR/M assessment of 29 No. May Decr 201 2011-0 Yes Yes Article 38 of (General Law 64-00Title the Yes IV of Environmental Compilation According Law) of regulations states Yes to that the and definitions in order procedures Law to 64-00 provided (General regarding Yesby prevent, article Environmental for control and of environmental mitigate 16 Law) the auth Law 64-00 pos (Ge and No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes According to Environmental Section 6.4.3.1 on Public Yes Consultation ImpactsEnvironmental Assessment of the Yes Environmental ImpactsThe Guidelines Section Assessment Impacts Ministry 6.4.3.2 Yes Assessment Guidelines of State for on the adopts Methodology Guidelines, the Environment a definition "The of Publ inv fo Eg Yes No Article 25 of n/a the Environmental Law Yes includes aAccording with Yes provision to rules article 32.c) for Further requires public consultation. a developed Yes social in impact evaluation, anfor the "Methodology anaE No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes According to The the EIA Act, Chapter EIA Act, Yes 2, Chapter Subchapter 2,Social Subchapter 1, §16(1),Yes impact1, “the assessment Articles decision-maker The §16 isto EIA performed Act §18will provide Yes provides organize as part a methodology a instructions of public the EIA. display on According the for of public an cond Yes No The Environmental n/a Assessment Impact Article 17 Yes Proclamation (No. (2) No 299 (c) of 2002) proclamation PPPn/a in article provides No in Trans-Regional states 6: Impac undertaking a feasibi Yes the Act on Pursuant Pursuant toYes the Assessment toYes Section 17 Section of the EIA of Environmental 2 of Act: Impact Yes the EIA The (8252/2017) Acts: The liaison For authority Act the on Section purposes the Yes shall Environmental ensure 17, of Subsection this that the Act:Impact("EIA") 1) 1 necessary the environme coordin o Yes Yes Code provides Environmental for a Procedure is Yes Public detailed Inquiry Pursuant by in order Article toNo to L123-3 article consult and 2 seq. of n/a Decree with ofaffected the 2013-1211 Environmental No datedCode. communities onDecember 23 2013 potential impac Yes No Art. 38 of the n/a Law (Law environmental No No. 007/2014 n/a No to the protection related n/a environment) provides that any ofNo Yes Article 6 ofChapter Pursuant toYes 4 of Yes the Environmental the Environmental Assessment PursuantCode, toNo Article Access Code the main 13(6) provides n/aof the guidelines stages of EIA PPPNo are: Law, the on a) the Public scoping participation preparation of the pub procedurein t Yes Yes According to The Environmental the Environmental Yes Assessment Impact Impact The Assessment social Act (UVP, Yes hereafter, Act aspects (UVP) are Theand "EIA analyzed Environmental the as Act"), Yes Administrative part of the §18, "(1) EIA, Impact a competent thus Procedures Assessmentauthori Act Actof provisions (U pr Yes Yes The Environmental The Environmental Assessment Yes Regulations Assessment of This 1999 regulated Regulation Yes isprovide the forunder ofrequirement 1999 The the Environmental methodology provides Yes of the consulting isImpact provided methodology affected Assessment under for communiti the this unde Envi Regul Yes Yes Article Law Law 4014/2011 19 on No. Environmental 4014 Noof 2011Licensing n/a on the Environmental Public No Consultation n/a provides Licensing Nothe and of Works following: Activities, 5. Timely informa Regulation o Yes No Article 38 of n/aApproach the PPP Law: Yes to the communities. Article 38 of Yes the PPP When theLaw: characteristics Chapter Approach III, Yes to of the21 articles PPP communities. toproject 37 of the demand Governme When it, t the Yes article 11 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the PPPto Law: Yes article needs this 11 of Pursuant the analysis Law: PPPto Yes must article this be11 accompanied of needs Regulation the analysis PPP Law: by A/2013/473/MEEF/CAB/SGG must Yes this an beneeds analysis accompanied of analysis the social must by an and anal be of ecM a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Article 58 to n/a 61 of the Environmental No Impact Regulations n/a No govern n/a public No on the environmental impac participation No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes effects should The secondary The Public be included Consultation Yes in theshall Social assessment. ordinarily Impact YesAssessments Public two Section components are primarily 4 of have consultation is Yes the often Social governed a part Impact comprising of:- the ofby Act, the (a) social Right prescribes a and to he public Fa en Yes No According to the Bappenas n/a Regulation Yes № 4, art. According to Nothe 26, "a public partner Regulation n/a responsibleYes for on PPPs, Chapter a PPP project X, Part(PJPK) II, art. shall carr 21 (d), " No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Article Article 1.5 "Stakeholders 1.5 in the PPP "Stakeholders Yes Procurement Article the 1.5 PPP "Stakeholders inProcess" of Procurement Yes PPP Guidelines:"PPP Article inProcess" the PPP 1.5 "Stakeholders Yes of Procurement projects PPP Guidelines: involve inProcess" the the PPP "The coming of Procurem Departm PPP tog G Yes Yes The Planning Law provides The under Planning "Public No hearing n/aof and Building Regulations objections No further n/a elaborate (Amendment 1995)" on No thatconsultations: such https://ww "107. The objector and th Yes Yes Article 24 of Decree LegislativeThe no.Yes 152/2006 EIA represents one (i.e., According of the the Italian to NoArticle supporting Environmental tools 22 n/a (1) to of the Code), public decisions, Yes Public provides Contracts aimed for,Code: as previously to Contracting a part est of the e Yes Yes According to Accordingsection the EIA Guidelines, Yes to the EIA 3.2.7, Guidelines, According "civil society, to Yes the which section 3.2.7, PPPincludes Policy, The "Annex EIA Section Guidelines II shows Yes 7,community-based citizens, various "the provide PPP public criteria suchconsultation are a methodolo standard and m non-go Yes Yes Public consultation, A thorough both by holding No methodology and forby a meetingn/a the accepting consultation No process n/a from opinions outlined No is all interested in the EIA Law: persons Article 3-4 regarding th No n/a No n/a Yes A feasibilityNo report is prepared n/a No contracting authority with the by the No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Consultation Regulation with affected 17(2) Yes of communities as the explicitly Section EIA Regulations 32 (2)(c) Yes in included of the andthe onwards environmental Regulation PPP Act provide requires Yes 18 of a methodology: the a contracting impact EIA assessment Regulations (2) authority are In seeking regulat 2003 c toel Yes Yes The details of the consultation The procedure process No and delineated n/a are consequences under of No Chapter the n/a consultation III of the process Environmental No are discussed in Assessment Impact Chapter III o Yes Article 20 of Pursuant toYes the Environmental Pursuant toYes Article 20 Impact of Section the Assessment 5 ofNo Directive Law: Environmental Impact One 1. n/a states: The main The No Assessment conclusions feasibility Law:1.andTherecommendation main study conclusion will contain, w Yes No The PPP Guidebook in pp. n/a48-49 provides: Yes The PPP "4.2.2.3 Guidebook Project No Due Diligence provides n/a under At this Yes the stage of requirements the Feasibility conduct toStudy "co proce Yes Regulation Pursuant Pursuant toYes No. 60 ofto the Yes Section 3 of EIA, the main Pursuant Regulation principles toYes No.for 60 Section of 1(2) the conducting Regulation ofEIA: Regulation an 15.EIA Consultations No. Yes 60 No. are: publicity; 60 -of the of EIA with the-contains EIA: taking theThe public purpos detaile into acco are Yes No Article 7 of Decree n/a No.112/PM Yes on Environmental Article Impact Assessment Yes 26 of Article (2010), the PPP Decree provides: 5-32 regarding of the Yes feasibility Environmental “A Rights andstudy duties Impact ofof a the Ass on partn Yes Article 3 ofThe Pursuant toYes Law onYes Environmental the methodology Socio- for conducting Impact economical a No public Assessment, calculations n/aconsultations consultation are is set No required with forth inthe Chapters by PPP public financial III are andand V of eco requiredth Yes № 8633 of The The Decree Yes 2012 sets out Decree №the Yes 8633 EIA of Decree 2012 provides 8213 procedure. Yes The dated article such24/5/2012 a7methodology, Decrees of this Decree 8213 on Yes among dated Strategic provides Environmental 24/5/2012 others. for the process on Strategic to be Assessme Yes Yes on Environmental Article 2 of Law Yes for Environmental The ManualImpact Assessment Section 9.4 Impact for Yes of Planned Assessment CPMA Order Economic According No in Lithuania Activity 2015/8-221 to Nothe Market https://am.lrv.lt/uploads/a No. I-1495 on August Analysis provides, 24,Methodolo 2015 MAR <...> 5. S Yes Yes Article 15 of Environmental Article Law of Yes 15Decree Environmental (Decree Article No. 99-954 7.2. Law Step Noof2: Decree 15 (Decree Feasibility December n/aNo. study: 1999 No 99-954as Aof Feasibility amended 15 December Study by Decree aimsas 1999 toamen No. 99- dem Yes Yes According to The EIA Guidelines the EIA Guidelines, Yes Appendix provide A, A.3, TheS-26(1), such aImpact Social Yes "UponAssessment receiving The methodology. Additionally, Environment the is environmental performed Yes the PPP as part Manual, impact Management of the Act assessment Procedure EIA № as 19 sta of#r No n/a No n/a Yes Section 34A(2) No "Environmental n/a No Prescribed Activities" of the Quality, Yes No 23 of Decree Articles 16 and n/a No. 2018-0991/p-rm Yes of 5 Article 31of December Decree No 2018 n/a relating Yes n°2018-0991/p-rmto the of December study and the environmen 31, 2018 relatin No n/a No n/a Yes EIA includes No n/a of the social, an assessment No economic and cultural effe Yes Yes Article 40 of TheMinistry the REIE: The Yes will carry Consultation procedure out Article within 14 of a public Yes the theenvironmental PPP Law: consultationThis in "To relationship specific impact Yes aspect determineto the the evaluation is further feasibility Environmental is carried regulated of aout Impact in asAr proposeit Yes The EIA Law establishes No n/a the exhaustive Yes list of activities Section 24 of No that shall Government be subject to public No No. n/a Resolution consultations. 476 indicates If the that the PPP fea proj Yes Yes According to Regulation the Law on on the Environmental Yesthe Procedure Impact The social to Ensure aspects Yes Public Assessment are being (hereafter, Participation The Law analyzed "Law onon the during YesasEnvironmental part EIA"), Conducting art. of 18.1, the environmental Impact an state "the Asses cent Environm i Yes Yes According to The the EIA Law, Part EIA I, Article Law Yes provides 2, "Environmental detailed According guidance Yes to the EIA on Assessment Impact Law, theThe consultation Part EIAI, is Law, Article a Yes procedure which 3, "the process includes with impact that the the includes assessment concerned social prepara pu id impac Yes No Art. 9 of Law on impact studies No. 12-03n/a No on the n/aenvironment n/a No provides that each project submitted to the environ No Yes Yes According to Article article 15.1 of the15 Environmental of Yes the Environmental Impact Assessment Impact According Yes to Assessment article 11 Regulation, Chapter (items Regulation, IIapproved j and Yes of the h) the ofEnvironmental approved byEnvironmental Decree byno. Impact 54/15, Decree no. Asse reg Impact54 Yes No Environment n/a Protection Act, 2076 Yes (2019) section According to Yes Environment (5), in preparing an The environmental Protection Environment YesAct, Protection 2020 study report, section Rules, the2 (t), 2020 under proponentpros Yes Yes for public The requirement Apartconsultations from No the right is provided the affected of n/a No under parties Sectionto provide n/aof the 7.24 their Environmental No Management view on draft Act im environmental of No n/a No n/a Yes Yes of the Resource The provisions The Resource Management NoManagement 1991 Act ofAct 1991 of as prov they rel Yes No Article 15 of 45-94 (Rules of Decree n/a Yes of Permit And Article 12(4) Yes of the Evaluation of Environmental PPPDecree Law provides Impact) Yes 45-94 (Rules that states: selection of Permit MARENA process (Ministry of a PPP And Evaluatio Yes No environmental Art 3 e) of the n/a law provides Yes Art. : to 7 of the comply with No PPP the principle Decree provides n/a of participation, for Noan social impact assessment according a to which eve No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Public consultations n/a are Yes part of environmental Public compliance. YesArticle are consultations of 91The part the Ministry Law of No on environmental ofEnvironment Environment compliance. provides and Spatial 1) The Plan Article 9 Yes Yes According to The the Pakistan Pakistan Yes Environmental Environmental Protection According Protection AgencyYes to (Review the PPP Policy, of AgencyThe (Review IEE Guidelines and EIA) ofYes Section J,Regulations IEE for and "thethe following EIA) Preparation of 2000 issues Regulations (hereafter and will of Revie be a 2000 Yes Yes Article 24 of Law No. 6 Law of 2002 No. (transparency 6 ofYes 2002 (transparency law) Article states 27.1that Yes law) of the requires both PPP Law thethat state states: No. alland projects 6 of General the Yes 2002 federal that (transparency social have government analysis. an impact law) must in require Itmust all in priva Yes Section 54 Pursuant Pursuant toYes toYes Section Act: of the Environment of 54 Pursuant (4) the The Director toNo Section Environmentmay8.1.4 for Act: n/a (4) the ofThe purposes the PPPYes Policy, of Director may assessing the for theapurposes proposed analytical of activ ass framework Yes No 294/93, Article 8 of Law Enviromental n/a Yes Impact Law Article states: 35 ofYes Decree The Administrative 4183/2020 The country Authority within possesses Yes shall the section make an Enviromental available toImpa "Structuring the and Yes Yes Consultation Public of affected communities participation Yes will be onimplemented the environmental The NoasReport Evaluation part impact ofrequired n/a theassessment by Yes Article is regulated environmental assessments 44.2 (10) in (c) accordance of that theare PPP w Re dev Yes Yes No. 2016-06-02 PPPGB Resolution Section 5 ofYes dated PPPGB Resolution June 21, 2016 PPPGB Circular No. onYes 2016-06-02 theNo. 10-2016 Section dated Guidelines on on June Public 5.1 public of 21, YesPPPGB consultation 2016 Circular on the Consultation and and Guidelines Engagement engagement No. on on 10-2016 P Yes Yes Section IV, Chapter Section 3 of onChapter the ActIV, Yes Making 3 Available of MFDRP the ActPPP onYes Making Guidelines Information about Available Table under Environment Information point 10 of Yes the 3.1MFDRP detail about and ItsaProtection, PPP "stakeholder the Environment Public analysi Guidelines Par a provi Yes No. 152-B / Decree-LawNo 2017, which n/a Yesalters the legal regime Article Yes 1A of forPublic the the assessment In Contracts accordance Code Yes of with thestates: environmental national 2 - Contracting EU-level and impact ofleg pu entitie No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Law No. 292 Section 3 ofYes is related Section 3 ofNo to Law No. the 292 n/a Information is related andNo to public participation n/a the Information and in No the public environmental impact participation enviro in the assess Yes No 63: : Rights Section 3 Article Yes n/a and obligations the PPP ofThe population Guide, No section of the Environmental 2.2.3 provides n/a thatprovides; No Law In environment the feasibility study shall Yes No Section 11 of the Planning n/a and Urban YesManagement Section 4 (3) Yes (Environmental of the Planning Impact The Planning and Assessment) Urban Yes Urban Regulations Management andManagement 2007 regards (Envir (Environment No n/a No n/a Yes Yes As part of the Business Where Case documents, required No andthe Privatization determined by the proje Manual p Yes No Article 38 of n/a the Environmental Code Yesspecifically mentions Article No 36 of the consultations PPP Decree n/a with the No providesaffected that the communities evaluatio preliminary as part of Yes Yes According to The the Law on procedure Environmental Yes for Impact gathering Assessment a public According No to the (hereafter, insight, PPP Law, holding n/aChapter a presentation "EIA"), No III, Part Article 10, "a 1, Section or competent1.1, authority Article a discussion 27, s is regul Yes the THIRD SCHEDULE Pursuant toNo n/a No to the Environment n/a No Protection n/a Act, an environmental Agency No impact assessmen No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes TheImpact The Act on Environmental Environmental Yes The Act on Assessment, Part Impact Methodological III, theYes section devoted Document Assessment, Art.Methodological The I,to Part on thea Yes III, participation Feasibility the section Document of Study, devoted the Part communitie on B, a Feasibili to the pa section No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the Concessions The Methodology No Act, Article for Preparing 3(2), Investment D "when implementing Yes No According to n/a the Environment Act of Yes According 1998, Section "the Yes 24(1),to theDirector Environment The onEnvironment being Act satisfied of Yes1998, that Act Section of 1998 an environmental 2,provides ""environmen such im No n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a Manual, the Concessions No Section 4.3.3, Box 4, Item 9, " Yes Yesof the National Section 2(4)(f) Environmental Yes for public The requirements Management The PPP consultations Manual Yes Actrequires statesModule that are setkey out "the stakeholders, in 2 the participation of the Public Yes PPPincluding Participation Manual of all (page organized Guidelines 14) indica interested and labo Yes Yes Art 247.3 and Law 21/2013 4 LCSP provides: Yes 3. Theof procuring Environmental According Assessment in authority shall No particular submit provides n/a to the Annex forVI the Yes of procedures feasibilityLaw study 21/2013 for public of stages and consultation to cond Environmenta Yes Yes According to the Environmental The Environmental Act, No Act Section n/a 23BB(2), and the"a applicable project No approving n/a agency regulations No provide shall such a methodology. on receipt of an initial env No n/a No n/a Yes According to No (c) of the Investment Article 10 n/a No Act, "the concerned m Yes Yes According to The Environmental the Environmental Code Yes(Ds 2000:61), Code According (Ds Part 2000:61) to I, Chapter the Yes provides Concessions 6, The Section a detailed Environmental Act, 5, "if Yes guidance the county Chapter 4,on Code §3, administrative how (Ds "a contracting to carry out 2000:61) board auth co provid Yes office for Environment The FederalNo No comments Yes has published Article 3 d.of numerousYesthe guidelines SwissArticles Consultation it has 4-9 Yes of Procedure callled Swiss "EIA: Consultation Implementation Act of 18Procedure Aid"200 March an Yes Article 24 of Pursuant toNo the Law on n/a Yes Environmental Pursuant ImpactArticle Assessment toYes The 18 of the ofLaw 2017: Environmental on Yes Environmental 1. Authorized Impact state Impact Assessment develops Law bodyAssessme Yes Yes under Section This is required 17 of Yes the EMA The methodology mayRegulations. be Section found under 15 17 No of the .-(Sections 1) PPP During n/a 17the andprocess 27 Regulations provides: No of the of conducting 15. Without EMA an prejudice environmen Regulations. to 17 .-( 1) No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Article 11 of the Environmental n/a Yes Law provides, Licensing of Article 11 "Public No the Environmental n/a 1)Licensing Consultation Yes It is Law provides, incumbent "Public Con on the Assessment Yes Yes Art. 41 of the Environmental According Impact Yes to Article Assessment 28 Decree of the Decree No. 2017-040 Yes 2017-040 Environmental laying laying Decree Article down down 24 of No. 2017-040 the Yes theod procedure procedure Decree laying No. for down 2017-040 for environmental the proced laying a environmental No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Act No. 16 of 2003 issuing Thethe Environmental Environmental No Impact Impact Assessment Assessment Ac Regu Yes Yes According to The Environmental the Environmental Yes Management Management According Act № 3 ofAct to Yes 2000 the № PPP 3 of Policy, 2000 [Chapter The35:05] Environmental [Chapter Section (hereafter, Yes 35:05] 4, Management “<...> the "EMA"), aim of (hereafter, art. "EMA"), this Act 35(5), PPP №3 Poli "an of art. No n/a No n/a Yes Article 7 of No PPP Law 2015-49 n/a ( Law No. 2015-49 dated 27 Novembe No Yes Yes EIA Regulation Annex 5 of the Ministrydetermines of Environment No n/a specifically and Urbanization affected No places; has n/a atherefore, guideline No the for EIA EIA assessment. https://webd studies conducted pursua Yes No Section 12 of n/a the Environmental Impact Yes Assessment Regulations Section 5 ofYes the Environmental S.I. No. Sections 13/199813-16 Yes Impact (https://nema.go.ug/sites/all/th of Assessment the Environmental Impact Regulations prov Yes Article 7 ofPursuant Pursuant toYes toYes Article 7 the Environmental ofPursuant Impact the Assessment Environmental toYes Article 11 Impact Law: of 1. Public the Order Assessment PPP of discussion Law: No the 1. Law, MEDTU The on the dated <...> analysis environmental the 14.12.2021 of the effectiv authorizedimpa ter No. 1 No n/a No n/a Yes Article 10.1. No Law provides of the PPPn/a Nothat it is mandatory to "prepar Yes to influence, The chance Yes Thefor Applicant Yes example,is the responsible design, Thelayout, for correctly or Yes Planning location Act of advertising 2008 of Guidance (Guidance a theon proposed Yes how on Nationally Significant pre-application to application put together Infrastructure under a Statemen sectio Proje consultation Yes Yes Public participation is mentioned Pursuant to under Yes Section same the1.6The of the section social PPTAimpact (1.6) Yes Manual of assessment and the VDOT PPTA Guidelines, Manual GOVERNANCE is one Yesand the of the methodology Guidelines objects DOCUMENTas of the the for P3the environm Public Public Invol consuE Yes No is a requirement A public hearing n/a Yes established by Article Article of 16 16 of the Yes Decree PPP Law, Decree regarding 349/005349/005, (Regulation Yes the required Regulation of Environmental of Environment assessments, state Impac No n/a No n/a Yes According to No of the PPP Law, Article 16 n/a Yes <...> in order to take into ac Yes Yes The Environmental The Environmental Protection Yes Act providesRegulations in Section Social impact to the 18: Yes assessments Act provide "Environmental The are details Impact Environmental considered about Yes Assessment" theImpact consultation part that: of the Assessment (4) environmenta process An musin EIARegu Yes (a) of the PPP Article 14.3 Yes Pursuant Law provides: toYes Article 33.3 "Pre-feasibility Article of the14.3 2020Yes (a) Environment study report and of (d) shall Section the Protection contain PPP D.I.5 Lawthe Yes Law, of Form provides: following contents 01,"Pre-feasibility Annex main of consultation subject II attached stud mattt Yes According to Yes the EIA Regulations, The EIA Regulations Section Yes 8(2), Social provide "to ensure such issuesthat methodology, are public aYes views analyzedTheasfor Environmental part are example, of Yes theinto taken in the Act EIA.account This and section stipulated during is the EIA Regulatio 10(2). the the inprep Yes According to the Environmental No n/a Yes Management According Act, Section Yes to the Investment 100(3)(c), "in Provisions considering Guidelines, of Yesthe Environmental Sectionor whether not 20, "astothe approve project Managemen a Yes According to Section 60 No of EIA assessment n/a Yes procedures, According to Yes the EIA shall Artilce 34consider According of the EIAtheProcedure, Yes to Artilce views, concerns, 34 of Project the EIA perception theand Procedure, Proponent Yes According to the Law on No n/a EIA, art. 14(1), No "the state n/a n/a environmental n/a for facilities expertise No referred to in the Articles 1 Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q9#1_12_5Q9#2_12 Q9#3_12_4Q10 Q10.yes_A Q10.yes_B Q10.yes_C Q10.yes_D Q10_1_TEXT Is there a specific If yes, Relevant legal/regulatory methodology? please provision elaborate 10. Does the If procuring yes, please authority provide 10. the include 10. If yes, specify relevant Fiscal which theAffordability assessments legal/regulatory 10. of Risk the assessments identification 10. in the assessment; Comparative provisions: request are and included forassessment; proposals in the requ allocation; and/ n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No 7 of DCM No. Pages 6 andYes 912 Pages andYes 7During 6 state: of DCMconsultations No. Article 9129 (2)with Yes of state: DCM other During 575 consultations institutions Yes states: Thewith Yes on submission issues other to No be institutions ofaddressed the feasibility on issues in the EIA to be study eIn-dept is addres done a n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes Article 16 of Article Presidential 10 117/20 Decree No of Decree of 22 n/a Aprilas 51/04, wellon 2020 No as the Article Environmental No 16 Impact No Decree of Presidential Assessment No 117/20 provides for the of 22 April public 2020, co provid No Article 19 of n/a the General Environmental Yes Act, Law Article No. 13 ofYes the 25,675, determines PPP law Yes states that Yes the right of every the convening citizen Yes authority must issue, to be consulted rende and prior t n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes Yes Section 6.7.2 Yes of the NSW Yes Yes provide PPP Guidelines Yes that the results and key assum Yes Certain social Certain aspects are social captured as No aspects part of are n/a the EIA process. captured as part No Hence, of the No provisions of No the EIA process. Hence, applicable No provisions EIA regulations in part of of the applicable EIAthr n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No According to of the Regulation Article 31 n/a Yes on Preparation, (1) Article 21 the Yes the PPP ofdevelopment Yes Law stipulates: of proposal Yes "Tender Yes documents documents may contain shall include consu "public the fo n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 61 of No No in theNo Law No. 33/03, process of evaluating the EIA, th Yes assessment The social impact The EIAisAct performed Yes providesas According part such a of methodology. theto environmental No No impact the PPP Policy, assessment. No Section 51, "the RFP No Therefore, is comprised generallyprovisions of gene of the EIA Yes The PPP Law Convention establishes Yes that the public No. 169/1989), noticeArticle and promulgated the contract 10 Yes of the PPP drafts in Brazil Law must established Yes thesubmitted by be Decree Yesthe No. information to5,051/2004 public No consultation thatestablishes as aguidelines condition the contracting of th n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No 20151187/PRES/TRANS/PM/MERH/MATD/MATD/MME/MS/MARHA/MRA/MICA/MHU/MHU/MIDT/MCT Decree No. No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 24 of No No the PPP Decree, bid package shall include at the No cond onleast n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No 2013/0171/PM Decree No. No No termsn/a n/a laying down and conditions No of the realization No No of environmental impact studies pr social andNo No The Environmental n/a Assessment Impact No Act under n/a Section 24 No providesNo participation" for "public No Noin the environmental assessme n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes Also covered During the by the mechanism ofenvironmental No Law 20,500. Articles n/a 4 and assessmentNo process, 26 to 31 Noof Law Nº No 19,300 participation of communities of General No is contemplated Environmental for EIAs, Basis and D n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No Article 2.2.2.1.5.5 n/a of the PPP Regulation Yes (Decree According 2015), Yes 1082 ofto Article amended 2.2.2.1.4.6 Yes by Decree of the 438Regulations YesPPP Yes provides of 2021, (Decree the 1082 need 2015) ofof th identi n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No Article 41 of n/a the General No Regulation on Environmental n/a No Assessment Impact No (EIA) provides No Procedures No for the need of public co No Decree no 96-894 n/a of September 1996 determines 8,No n/a the rules No and procedures No No applicable No to environmental impact study of de n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes the social The EIA includes EIA Act No The aspects provides so that provisions a detailed n/a methodology No to the applicable No onEIA how the also concerned apply No for thepublic No social shall impact engaged with beassessment. durin Thus, a Yes are analyzed The social aspects onpart The Law as No EIA, of sections an Environmental n/a NoImpact 35-37, is devoted to Assessment describing No as No the process stated in the of No Law on EIA, with consultation the1(2), section acco public an n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes Article 38 of (General Law 64-00Title the Yes IV of Environmental Compilation Art. Law) of 55.5states and Yes55.6 that and regulations of in order Law procedures No340-06 states: regarding Yes control to prevent, tender No The for and environmental mitigate specifications the authorizations will contain possible impactw i n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes According to Environmental Section 6.4.3.1 on Public Yes Consultation ImpactsPursuant Assessment of the toNo Article Guidelines 28 of No EnvironmentalSection the Impacts PPP6.4.3.2 Executive Assessment No Regulations, on the No Methodology Guidelines, the"The Administrative of Public Consultat involvement o Aut No Article 25 of n/a Environmental the Salvadorian No Law n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes Social impact The assessment performed isEIA Act,No Chapter as part 2,n/a of the EIA. No Subchapter 1, Articlesto According No §16 the to §18 EIA provide No Act, Chapter instructions 2, No on Division §16(1), 1,the “the public decision consultatio n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No the Act on Pursuant Pursuant toYes toNo the Assessment Section of Environmental 17 n/a of the EIA Act: NoThe liaison Impact (8252/2017) Noauthority Section No shall17, Subsection No ensure that the 1 necessary the coordinating autho opinions on n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes are analyzed The social aspects as part The Environmental No of the Impact EIA, n/a Assessment No Actof thus provisions (UVP) the No applicable Administrative and the No Nothat regulations Procedures govern aAct public consultati provide such Yes under The This is regulated methodology No the Environmental isImpact provided n/a Assessment No under theRegulations Environmental No of 1999, No"Matters Impact Assessment No to be Regulations addressed in environmenta of 1999, "Matt n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No Article 38 of n/aApproach the PPP Law: No n/a to the communities. When No the characteristics No No No of the PPP project demand it, the procurin No n/a No of March Regulation A/2013/473/MEEF/CAB/SGG No n/a 11, 2013 related to approval of No No Noenvironmental and social impa the study of n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes According to Section Section 5 of the Social 5 ofYes the Social Impact ActImpact As and per Clause Act directs Yes Chapter 4 of the 1.2.3 of the appropriate National No Model RFP, Yes government Resettlement the Feasibility & to No ensure Rehabilitation Report that prepared Policy a public 2007, by hearing pub the Pri No According to n/a on PPPs, the Regulation Yes Chapter X, The Attachment Part No II, art. 21 (d), to the "identification No LKPP Regulation of an29/2018, Yes No Chapter infrastructure provision II, A, 5 shall (e) (1) be carried lists dow n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes Article Article 1.5 "Stakeholders 1.5 in the PPP "Stakeholders No Procurement n/a the PPP No inProcess" of Procurement PPP Guidelines:"PPP No Process"Noprojects of involve No the PPP Guidelines: "The coming Department of together Fina and in n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No According to (1) of the Public Article 22 n/a Yes Contracts Articles Code: Contracting 165Yes and 183 ofauthorities Yes the Public Contracts and Yes contracting Yes as Code, well as entities publish, Articlein 14 of Presid their prof Yes According to As explained the PPP Policy, No Appendix in 1, the Q10.9, the n/a provisions criterion Noof is "project the viable" EIA NoGuidelines as shall includes No one apply of the No tosub-criteria is that assessment the social impact "socially sus n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes ParagraphYes Yes 1, MNE 18 of Appendix Order #725/2015, on the basis Yes Yes of the Regulation Section 32 (2)(c) 17(2) No of PPP Act requires a contracting then/a EIA Regulations No and authority to consider onwards No the social, No a methodology: provide economic No and(2) environmental In seeking the views of impact o n/a No n/a Yes Article 10(5) No Act provides of the PPPNo No where the competent authority p that "[…] No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No The PPP Guidebook n/a "4.2.2.3 provides: No Project Due n/a Diligence No No of the Feasibility At this stage No No process, all legal, land, site, te Study Regulation Pursuant Pursuant toYes the No. 60 ofto Section NoEIA, the 3 of main n/a RegulationNo No. principles 60 for conducting of the No EIA:an Consultations No 15.EIA No with are:- publicity; - taking the public account into are public carried out No Article 7 of Decree n/a No.112/PM Yes on Environmental Article Impact Yes of the PPP Decree 31.4Assessment Yes (2010),provides regarding No that "The Yes Rights tender and duties documents of the ones who shall are includ n/a No n/a Yes Article 21 of No Noprovides No the PPP Law No of the assessments in the te for the inclusion Yes Social aspects are analyzed The Decree as part No of №an EIAof 8633 asn/a 2012 stated provides NoDecree in the such a 8213 methodology, No dated 24/5/2012 No on NoStrategic Environmental Assess among others. n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 31 of No Yes Law, the the Concession No tendering documents for conc n/a No n/a Yes Article 8.3 of Yes the decree 2017-149 Yes Yes NoPublic person establishes the c indicates: the Yes Because the Theassessment social impact Yes is performed EIA Guidelines provide According such as part ato methodology. Yes of the the PPP Manual, Yes EIA, provisions Additionally, Procedure Yes applicable #3.5: the PPPYes Preparing Manual, to EIA consultation Procedure & Issuing #2.11: Request process also fora Condu E n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No 23 of Decree Articles 16 and No n/a No. 2018-0991/p-rm n/a of 31 December No No relating No 2018 No to the study and the environmental and soc n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes (i) Articles 34 (i) In to 40 of the Executive general, No the procedure Order n/a is (ii) Public Consultation the following: No to - No The Interested Indigenous communities No Party shall No (independently from thebefore submit the evaluation Social It n/a No n/a Yes Section 4 ofYes Government NoResolution No. 476 contains Yes No a list of terms with defini No The social aspects are being n/a analyzed Yesas part of According to Yes the environmental the Standard impact No RfQ assessment. No Document, Therefore, Section No 2.1, at the pre-qualification provisions of the environm s Yes According to The the EIA Law, EIA I, Part Law, Article Yes which 2, "Environmental According includes to Yes Impact the the social impact Concessions Assessment analysis, No provides is a Law, No Article procedure detailed 21(3)(2), that No guidance as includeson part ofpreparation an the open procedur of stud consultation n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes According to Article j15 article 11 (items of andYes h) the the Environmental According ofEnvironmental to NoArticle Impact Impact Assessment 12.2 Assessment Noof the Regulation, PPP Regulation, No approved approved No the Regulations, bylaunching Decree by Decree of54/15, no. no. 54/15, the regard public th ten No Environment n/a Protection Act, 2076 No (2019) section n/a(5), in preparing No environmental an No No the proponent shall hold, a No study report, n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No Article 15 of n/a (Rules of Decree 45-94 Yes of Permit And Article 24 of Yes PPP Evaluation ofRegulation Environmental Yes states No the tendering Impact) Yes states: MARENA documents shall contain (Ministry (4) p of Environm n/a No n/a No No No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes According to The Pakistan the PPP Policy, No Section J, Environmental n/a Protection "the following No issues willAgency be addressed No (Review PPP No inof IEE and EIA) No transactions: Regulations <...> Ensuring <...> of 2000 public su provide he Yes Article 24 of of 2002 Law No. 6 Law 6 of No. (transparency No 2002 (transparency n/a states law) that No requires law) both the No that alland state No the federal projects that have No government must an impact allow interest in private the part Section 8.2.4 Pursuant toNo n/a No of the PPP Policy, an n/a Outline Business No Case prepared No No for No will include the following ana NEC approval No 294/93, Article 8 of Law Enviromental n/a Yes Impact Law According states:to NoDecree The Administrative 4183 No the tendering Yes documents Authority shall make No available must include to the public and s engineering t No provisions The regulatory Noconsultation n/ato conduct n/a with affected No No communities stated in Prior areNo No Consultation Law (approved Yes No. 2016-06-02 PPPGB Resolution PPPGB Resolution No dated June No. 2018-12-02 21, 2016 onNo n/a dated the Guidelines December No on Public 14, 2018 NoConsultation provide No thatand PPPEngagement for projects with PPP Pro displacem Guidelines Table MFDRP PPPYes point under10 of No the 3.1MFDRP detail aPPP "stakeholder n/a Guidelines No analysis," provides Noan example which includes Noof stakeholder determining No analysis the impact provides andon the f all stakehold No. 152-B / Decree-LawNo 2017, which n/a Yesalters thePursuant legal regime Article toNo 14assessment for the (4) Noof the PPP of Yes the environmental Law, No if the launching impact of the of public PPP and pri project is a n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a Yes Articles 19 -Yes 24 of PPP GEO Yes 39/2018 provide the Yes Yesfollowing main elements:Pursu n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No Section 11 of n/a and Urban the Planning No Management n/a (Environmental No No Assessment) Impact No No Regulations 2007 regards public cons n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No N/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes According to the Methodological According Document to Yes on According the Methodological a Feasibility Document to Yes Study, the Public Part on Yesa B, Procurement Feasibility sectionYes 2.3, Act, Study, "<...> §101 Part In Yesorder (5), B, section forto the beover-the-limit feasible, 2.3, "<...> In the projec conce order to n/a No n/a Yes No According to the Concessions No No Act, Article No 43(1), "technical and functional requir No assessment The social impact is performed n/a (SIA)No n/aas part of No No the environmental No assessment impact No (EIA) within the meaning of n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes the Concessions Yes Section Yes Yes Manual, 8.1.1, "<…> the bidding documen Yes analysis The social impact The issocial part of impact the environmental Yes analysis According is part impact to No of theanalysis. the PPP Manual, No environmental Therefore, Module impact No 5, analysis. StageNo provisions 2,Therefore, applicable Part 2, Step to the 1, section EIA apply provisions 1.2, togen th applicabl No4 LCSP provides: Art 247.3 and n/a Yesprocuring 3. The Article authority 250 LCSP shall that No regulates submit No the feasibility theNo studyof content No the for public tender consultation documents and for includ one mo n/a No n/a Yes According to No No on PPPs, the Guidelines No and (iv), "<…> the RFP woul NoSection 234(i) n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes Provisions of The Environmental the Environmental Code No (Ds 2000:61) Code n/a 2000:61) No (Dsinclude the provides social No impact a detailed No guidance analysis on as well. Nohow to carry According outEnvironmental to the consultation p 9 of Swiss Consultation Articles 4 toYes 9 Articles 4 toNoProcedure of Swiss Consultation n/a Act refer to NoProcedure the methodology: No Act refer to No Participation; the methodology: Initiation; No Procedure; Form Participation; and d Initiation; Article 24 of Pursuant toNo the Law on n/a Yes Environmental Pursuant toYes Impact Assessment Article 14 (2) Yesof 2017: of 1. the PPPYes Authorized Law, the contracting Yes state bodyauthority procedures developsshall submit n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No Article 11 of n/a the Environmental No Licensing n/a Law provides, "Public No Consultation No No 1) It is No incumbent on the Assessment Committee Yes Article 28 of Article the Decree No. 2017-040 28 of No laying the down Decree No. the n/a 2017-040 procedure No laying down for environmental No the procedure No and for social No environmental and social impact assessments impact provides n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes are also The social aspects The analyzed Environmental No of n/a the environmental as partManagement Act No№ 3 impact of 2000 No assessment [Chapter No as stated 35:05] No (hereafter, in the Certificate "EMA"), art. Environme of 28 provides n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No No Sections 5 & n/a 12 of the Environmental No Impact Assessment n/a RegulationsNo No in terms of No shall apply No the public consultation process i n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Section 13 Yes of Order No. 384 (Procedures), Yes Yes contest documents inclu n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No Yes The Applicant Guidance is responsible on No for correctly how to put n/a together advertising a the proposed No StatementNo of Community application under No Consultation section No 48 of (SOCC) the Planning Act at is set out thisThis 2008. link Yes VDOT GOVERNANCE DOCUMENT The consultation Public No Involvement process's n/a methodology NoPolicy Manual is provided Manual No for Public No in in detail Participation both the No VDOT In Transportation DOCUME GOVERNANCEProjects p No is a requirement A public hearing n/a No established n/a by Article 16 of Decree 349/005 No No No (Regulation Environmental Impact Assessme ofNo No According to of the PPP Law, Article 16 n/a order to Yes <...> inArticle 22take of No into the PPP account Law Noprovides Yes for the the interests ofinformation the population, No should be included that consumers, users of Yes The Environmental Protection The Environmental Act while No applying Regulations n/ato social No impacts to the Act applying provides No toin Section No social impacts 18: "Environmental provide No about the detailsImpact consulta Assessment (a) of the PPP Article 14.3 Yes Law provides: Pursuant toNo Article "Pre-feasibility 33.3n/a of the 2020 NoEnvironment study report shall No Protection containNo Law, the Contents following No main of consultation subject matters: [...]the during i a) [. Social issues are analyzed Yes The EIA as part Regulations of Nothe EIA. Public n/a consultations provide such aNomethodology, process is part No for of No example, the in EIA the No section process stated in the EIA Regula as10(2). Provisions ofNo n/a regulations the EIA-related n/a social No also include Noaspects andNomeasure No No the social impact. Therefore, provisions of th According to Section 60 No of EIA assessment n/a No procedures, n/a n/a the n/a EIA shall consider views, concerns, then/a n/a and perceptions of stakeho n/a n/a n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Law, Yes “the tender Yesart. 21(1)(1), Yes documentation must conta Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q10.1 Q10.yes_E Q10.yes_F Q10.yes_G Q10.yes_H Q10.yes_I Q10.yes_J Q10.yes_k Q10.yes_10_TEXT 10. 10. Financial Procurement viability; 10. Market strategy 10. sounding for Market sounding private 10. Environmental sector for 10. technological interest; impact Social impact 10. assessment; Any solutions; other Please specify assessment; 10.1. Are the assessments publish No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No Yes Yes No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No Yes Yes No n/a No Yes Yes No Yes No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes Technical studies No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No No No comments No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No Yes No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No No No Yes Yes No n/a Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes Yes No According to the Attachment to the LKPP Reg No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No Yes No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes Yes No No No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No Yes No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes Yes No No No No No No n/a No Yes No No No Yes No No n/a No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No Yes No further details Yes No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No Yes Yes No n/a No Yes No No No Yes Yes No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No Yes Yes No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No Yes Yes No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes Yes Yes No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes Yes Yes Yes No n/a Yes No No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No Yes Yes No n/a No Yes Yes Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes Yes No No No Yes No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No Yes No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes Yes No Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No Yes No According to article 22 of the PPP Law, <...> t No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a Yes No No No No No No No n/a No n/a 0 n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a No Yes 0 No No No No No n/a Yes Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q10.1_4_TEXT Q10.1_3_TEXT Q10.1.yes_A Q10.1.yes_B Q10.1.yes_C Q10.1.yes_D Q10.1.yes_F Q10.1.yes_E Q10.1.yes_G specify If yes, please the provide website: 10.1. the relevant If yes,legal/regulatory 10.1 specify Fiscal which Affordability 10.1 ofprovisions: Risk the identification assessments 10.1 assessment; are 10.1 andpublished Comparative allocation; Financial assessment; 10.1 online: viability; Socio-economic 10.1 Market Procurement sounding strategyanalysis for private n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No https://www.argentina.gob.ar/jefatura/ppp According to of the PPP Law Article 29 Yes Yes the PPP Unit has to Yes Yes implement No No a website where No parties can access and mak interested n/a n/a No No No No No No No On Section 6.2.7 the of therelevant NSWNoPPP Guidelines procuring No authority's provides, No website, No including: "The results and key No http://www.rms.nsw.gov.au/ No of the PSC assumptions No or SBM may be disclosed to s https://www.umweltbundesamt.at/umweltsituation/uvpsup/uvpoesterreich1/uvpdatenbank/uvpgenehmigung/; According to No the EIA Act, No section 7, §43(1), “the No No Federal Minister No No for Sustainability No has to prepare the EIA docum and Tourism www.economy.gov.az According to No Article 4.10 No of the EnvironmentalNo Impact Assessment No Nothe Customer Law: No No shall conduct public hearings in accorda n/a n/a No No No No No No No Official According to the Regulation website No of the on tender Tender, No tender organizer No documentation No is divided No into preliminary, No http://pppbelarus.by/news/351.html No preparatory, and final tender docum n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No Federal Law Pursuant toProcuring Yes No. 12,527 authority Yes website; of 2011 http://portal.imprensanacional.gov.br/ (Article Yes 8, paragraphs No 1, IV Yes and 2), which Nothe access to public informatio Yes regulates Article 49(2) Pursuant toNacional Yes Concession of the Concession Register: Yes Law, Yes https://nkr.government.bg/ when organizing No conducting Public Procurement and Yes No the concessionaire Register: No designation procedure, https://www2.aop.bg t http n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No https://www.canada.ca/en/impact-assessment-agency.html The publication NoEIA is required of a draft No No under section 25 No of the Environmental No No Assessment Impact No Act:Public notice in certai n/a n/a No No No No No No No www.seia.cl Article 28 Law No 19,300 General No Environmental Law: No ArticleNo No 28 refers to No of certain the publication No aspects of the environmenta article 5 in No Notice of the NoMinistry of Pursuant tohttp://www.cpppf.org/index.html No Finance on No No Issuing the No Interim Measures the Administration of Informatio forNo https://community.secop.gov.co/Public/Tendering/ContractNoticeManagement/Index?currentLanguage=es-CO& Article 2.2.1.1.1.7.1 Yes of Decree Yes 1082 of 2015 that Yes the publication requires Yes No No of the tender Yes and since those tender do documents n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No https://investcroatia.gov.hr/en/ppp/ppp-projects/ Article 91 of No the Environmental No Protection ActNo states that No No impact assessment environmental No (EIA) decisions must be published No Information According to the EIA Act, No system §16(1), the for No EIA: communication https://portal.cenia.cz/eiasea/view/eia100_cr No No and disclosure No principles the information forNo No gathered during the EIA pro EIA, sections The Law on Some No information 35-37, is is available No devotedon tothe describing NoDigital Environmental the Noprocess of No consultation Yes with Administration website: the public No and authorities as well as https://dma.mst.dk/seneste-o n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No http://www.proesa.gob.sv/inversiones/centro-de-documentacion# Article 105 of "the PPP-Unit PPP Law:Yes No will create Nothe public No No registry of No partnership public private No projects, in which all projects n/a n/a No No No No No No No No According to No the EIA Act Chapter 2 No SubchapterNo 1 §21, “anNo No impact No environmental report is published and the resu assessmentNo n/a n/a No No No No No No No Section 23 Pursuant toPublished No ofthe on thewebsite EIA Act: Noof the The liaison FocalNoPoint authority. will review NoJoint website the No of Finland's adequacy No and quality environmental ofNo the EIA report and then(in administration Finnis draw ar n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No The According to Federal the No Environmental UVP portal: Impact No Assessment No Act (UVP, No hereafter, No"EIA Act"), https://www.uvp-portal.de/vorhaben. No No§19(2)(1), "in the course of the [public] pa n/a n/a No No No No No No No http://aepo.ypeka.gr/ Article 19a of No the Environmental No Assessment Impact No (hereinafter No Regulation") "EIANo No No requires environmental decisions and asse n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No of the General No Financial No Rules, 2017 Rule 161 (ii)https://www.pppinindia.gov.in/home Noprovides: http://www.finmin.nic.in/ No The organisation No https://eprocure.gov.in/cppp/ Noalso postNo should the complete bidding document n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No TED: Article 73 of https://ted.europa.eu/TED/browse/browseByMap.do; the Public Yes Contracts Law Yesis related Yes Yes to the publication Yes of notices. Procuring As part No of this law authority's Yes website it states (depending on the are that the notices projp https://www.nepa.gov.jm/new/services_products/applications/eias/index.php Provisions of No the EIA Guidelines shall Noapply to the No social impact No assessment No as well. No No According to the EIA Guidelines, Section 2 Ministry Article 3-4 (1) EIA of the of No Law statesNo Environment as website; follows:https://www.env.go.jp/en/ No preparing When No on primary No a document No No environmental impact consideration, t n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No Section 59 No of the Environmental Pursuant tohttp://www.nema.go.ke/ No No Management No No Act, the Co-Ordination environmental No No impact assessment must be are no specific Yes provisions No of the PPP YesActand While therehttp://pimac.kdi.re.kr/info/info_list.jsp that http://pimac.kdi.re.kr/info/restudy_list.jsp would No Yesthis, TheNo require No Act on Disclosure of Information by Public A n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No Regulation No No. 60 of the Pursuant tohttps://www.oneplanetnetwork.org/organisations/ministry-natural-resources-ecology-and-technical-supervision- NoEIA:19. From No the dayNo of publication No of public No of the notice No discussions, the relevant local n/a n/a No No No No No No No Section Pursuant toThe 20 No website of of the the entity Law Nothat on is required No Impact Environmental to conduct No the assessment No the final Assessment, No orimpact another assessment duly No authorized person's statement needs to be p website № 8633 of Environment: The Decree Ministry 2012 sets out No Nohttp://www.moe.gov.lb/%d8%a7%d9%84%d9%85%d8%b4%d8%a7%d8%b1%d9%8a%d the EIA procedure. No No As No 12 of the per the article No public and the affected comm No Decree, the No n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No www.compranet.funcionpublica.gob.mx Article 14 of Yesrequires Yes the PPP Law that information Yes resulting Yes from the Yes No No required assessments to be publish online. Article 11 n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No Website According to Law, the EIAof a Yes contracting Part II, Article No 20, “the authority. The No competent e-Government NoauthorityNo shall, portal: within No https://www.euprava.me/ five working No days from the Official date of receipt Gazette Monten n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No https://op.europa.eu/en/web/forum_official_gazettes/netherlands-oj This is required No 19 of the by Chapter NoEnvironmental No Management No Law titled "Public No No No access to environmental information".Art n/a n/a No No No No No No No http://www.snip.gob.ni/Portada/App; The assessments Yes are published inside Yesthe Statement No www.nicaraguacompra.gob.ni of Terms Yes and Conditions No No bid according of the No to article 24 (4) of the PPP n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No Ministry Article 90 of of Environment No the Environmental Protection No and Physical LawNo prescribes PlanningNo the needat website toNo http://www.moepp.gov.mk/?page_id=1140&lang=en publish the Noenvironmental No impact assessment online:P EIA According to reports the Guidelines No are usually for thepublished Preparation No No by and provincial Review Environment No NoProtection of Environmental No Reports Agencies, of November No for example: Punjab:1.4, 1997,-Section "full pu https://epd https://enterector.gob.pa/ Article 85 of Nostates: "Mechanisms the PPP Law No No for transparency No No access and citizen No No All the information that res to information. n/a n/a No No No No No No No https://www.stp.gov.py/v1/direccion-general-de-proyectos-de-participacion-publico-privada/ Article 29 of Yes Decree 4183/2020 No obligation states Yesto publish: Nopre-feasibility No Yes and feasibility No and contracts studies, and their mod https://www.contrat https://www.senace.gob.pe/atencion-al-ciudadano/consulta-ciudadana-de-proyectos/ For the environmental assessment, No Nopublic consultations No Noimplemented are of the environmental No as partNo No assessments that are n/a n/a No No No No No No No Public The publication the environmental No ofInformation No impact Bulletin: https://www.bip.gov.pl/ assessment No No is Nothe Act on required by No No Making Available Information about Enviro n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No http://www.e-licitatie.ro/pub Article 70 of Yes Law provides the Concession Yes the following: Yes Yes (1) Yes entities The contracting Yeselectronic means, through SEA Noprovide, by n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a No No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No https://www.uvo.gov.sk/ According to Procurement the PublicNo No The Act, §148 EIA No reports (1), "the can Public be Noaccessed here: No https://www.enviroportal.sk/sk/eia. Procurement No Office No (hereafter, "Office") shall publish in electro n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No https://contrataciondelestado.es/wps/portal/plataforma Article 247 LCSP Yes requires No to submit No study toNo the feasibility a public information Yes (or procuring period Yes and article authority contractors' Yes profile) 138 of the LCSP and article n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No Article 14 of Nothe EIA Regulations: No Pursuant tohttps://www.csb.gov.tr/turkce/index.php (1) No The EIA Report, No Nohas beenNo which No finalized by the Commission, s reviewed and https://www.nema.go.ug/services/eias The National No Act, Cap Environmental No (NEMA No153 of 1995 http://www.nemaug.org/environment_impact_assesment.php (CAP No 153) provides No No in Sections No 20 & 21, "20. Environmental impact s Article 11(5) Yesof the PPP Yes Pursuant tohttp://www.me.gov.ua/?lang=uk-UA Law:The analysis Yes Yes of the Yes of potential effectiveness Yes or negative) must be made No PPP (positive n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No https://www.p3virginia.org/projects/ The publication No No impact assessment of the environmental No on NoVDOT's P3 No No Office's website No is required by Section 1.6 of the PPTA http://ppp.mef.gub.uy/17716/16/areas/project-portfolio.html Article 4 of the PPP Law requires that Yes Yes No all actions carried out Yes Yes within the No framework No of PPP projects, with the limitations establ n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a No No No No No No No http://www.zema.org.zm/index.php/publications/eia-reports/ According to No the EIA Regulations, No Section 26(1), No No brief, environmental "any project No impact statement, No No terms of reference, publi n/a n/a No No No No No No No n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a 0 n/a The According to official the website PPP Law, Yesart. 9(10), of an Yesauthorized “based on the Yesbody, results which Yes ofwill varyYes from project a consideration to project. of a proposal No 0for In the implementation case of ais if an assessment inclu projec Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q10.1.yes_IQ10.1.yes_JQ10.1.yes_K Q10.1.yes_H Q11 Q10.1.yes_10_TEXT Q11_4_TEXT Q11_3_TEXT Q11.1 10.1 10.1 Market Environmental sounding 10.1 for technological Social impact impact 10.1 assessment; solutions; Any other Please specify assessment; 11. Are tender/bidding If yes, please please documents provide the 11.1. made provide the Do relevant available website: thelegal/regulatory tender documents online? in provi No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes Article 24(6) Yesof PPP Law, the contract notice Pursuant tohttp://app.gov.al/contract-notice/ No No No No n/a Yes www.algeriatenders.com Article 203 and No Public Acquisition Code No. 1 204 of the No No No No n/a Yes https://compraspublicas.minfin.gov.ao/ Article 67 of Procurement Law requires the te the Public No No Yes Yes No n/a Yes https://www.argentina.gob.ar/jefatura/ppp Article 12.9, Decree 118/2017 requires the pr Annex I of No No No No No n/a Yes Article 27(1) Yesof the Procurement https://pro Pursuant tohttps://www.mineconomy.am/en Law <...>, t No Yes Yes No n/a Yes According to The 6.3NSW of the Yes NSW PPP Guidelines, Government eTendering system: ht responsible No Yes Yes No n/a Yes According to The the Law on No dedicated portal: https://www.data.gv.a Concessions, Part 1, Chapter 3, No Yes No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes http://www.belavtostrada.by/ppp According to Yes on Tender, tender documen the Regulation No No No n/a n/a Yes article 45 of Nothe Concession Law, authorities Pursuant tohttps://my.publicprocurement.be/ and Offic No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes Article 17 (1) Yesof the Sarajevo PPP Law, The p Pursuant tohttp://vlada.ks.gov.ba/ No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes No No No n/a Yes Federal Pursuant toTender documents Law Yes are usually No. 12,527 published of 2011 8, p (Article on t No Yes No No n/a Yes Pursuant tohttps://nkr.government.bg/ Article 39 (2) Yesof the Concession Law, in organ https://www2.ao No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes article Pursuant toWhile creating 8 al.No 3 of the the PPP Decree, Agency’s tender website, doc publica No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No Yes Yes n/a n/a Yes Section 10.7.38 Documents of the Federal Yes pertaining the public Contracting callsprovide Policy and re No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes article 9 in Yes Notice of the Ministry of Finance Pursuant tohttp://www.cpppf.org/index.html No Yes Yes No n/a Yes https://community.secop.gov.co/Public/Ten Article 2.2.1.1.1.7.1 Yes PPP Regulations (Decree 1082 of the No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes http://www.armp.cg/en-us/documents/regu According to of the Public Procurement Code, Article 78 No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes https://eojn.nn.hr/Oglasnik/ According to Yes Act, Article 21, <...> “biddin the Concession No Yes Yes No n/a Yes A the According to profile Public of Yes Procurement a Act, §180(5), contracting authority for in the th Pub No Yes Yes No n/a Yes The According to the text EU of Concessions No concession the notice Directive, or of Title Chapt II, these No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes https://dgapp.gob.do/categorias/licitaciones Article 16 of Yes the PPP Regulations states: "Of the records No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes Article 105.A http://www.proesa.gob.sv; Yes of PPP Law: will create the p "the PPP-Unithttps://www.com No No No No No No n/a n/a No No Yes Yes No n/a Yes According to Public the PublicYes Procurement procurement Act,https://riigihan register: Chapter 11, §2 No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No Yes Yes No n/a Yes According to www.hankintailmoitukset.fi/en Yes the EU Concessions Title II, Chapt Directive,https://ted.eu No No No No n/a Yes http://www.boamp.fr/recherche/avancee According to Yes of the Public Procurement Article R.2132-2 an No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a Yes Article 12^1 Yes of the Public Procurement Law: Pursuant towww.tenders.procurement.gov.ge No Yes Yes No n/a Yes According to - the the portal Concessions "service.bund.de Yes Verwaltung Ordinance,-§17(1), On "a cont No No No No n/a Yes http://ppp.mofep.gov.gh/ Section 39(2)(c) Yes Act, regarding Request for qu of the PPP No Yes No No n/a Yes Article 34 of Publications the Concessions Yes Service Law the EU and, ofrequires on a natio the tender do No No No No n/a Yes Article 46 of www.guatecompras.gt, Yes the PPP Law https://anadie.gob.g establishes that the tender do No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes According to TED: the http://ted.europa.eu EU Concessions Yes Directive, Title Hungary II, Chapt Public Pr No Yes No No n/a Yes Rule 159 of https://www.pppinindia.gov.in/home the General Yes Financial Rules 2017 provides th http:// No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes According to The the National Yes Tenders Law: Article Tenders 23 on https://www database: "Documenta No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a Yes www.etenders.gov.ie Regulation 33 of the EU Concessions 2017, provides: "(1 No No No No No n/a Yes https://mof.gov.il/AG/Pages/AccountantGen Section 17 (a) Yes of the Mandatory Tenders Regulation pro Yes Yes Yes No n/a Yes The standard TED: https://ted.europa.eu/TED/browse/bro document publication of the EU apply: Pub Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes According to Government the PPP Policy, of Jamaica Yes 10.0.1, Section Public "<…> the PP Procurement No Yes No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes Contracting Regulation 36 of the PPP Yes authority's Regulations states as website, follows: National (1 Tre No Yes No No n/a Yes Article 10 of Yes the PPP Law, the procuring auth Pursuant tohttp://pimac.kdi.re.kr/notice/notification_lis No No No No n/a Yes Article 43 of Yes the PPP Law:1. The Public Auth Pursuant towww.pppkosova.org No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes Article 12 of Yes the PPP Law:www.ppp.gov.kg Pursuant towww.mineconom.gov.kg; 1. At the stage of q No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes https://www.iub.gov.lv/lv/iubsearch/ Article 34 of Yes on the Award of Concession EU 2014/23/EU No Yes Yes No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes Article 30 of Yes the Concessions Law, the conce Pursuant tohttps://pirkimai.eviesiejipirkimai.lt/login.asp No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes https://www.pppc.mw/procurement/advert According to Yes the PPP Act, Section 45:"45.__(1) An adver No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes Article 11 of www.compranet.funcionpublica.gob.mx; Yes the PPP Law htt establishes that the Ministry o No No No No n/a Yes http://www.app.gov.md/ro/press-release-typ The publication Yes of tender documents is required by regu No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes https://mia.gov.me/ According to paragraph 1 of the PPP Law stipu Article 49,Yes No No No No n/a Yes https://www.marchespublics.gov.ma/index. Article 12 of Yes provides : the advertising n the PPP Decree No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes Section 14 of Public the Public Procurement Procurement Yes Act, regarding Monitoring Invi Office https: No Yes No No n/a Yes www.tenderned.nl Online access documents is guaranteed by Art to tenderNo No No No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes Article 17 of http://www.snip.gob.ni/Portada/App; Yes the PPP Regulations www. states all tendering pro No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No Yes No No n/a Yes Pursuant tohttps://www.bjn.gov.mk/en Article 42 of Yes the PP Law, the contracting aut https://www.e-n No Yes Yes No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes https://enterector.gob.pa/ Article 39 of Yes affirms that the consultation Law 22 of 2006 No No No No n/a No n/a Yes No further comments No Yes Yes No n/a Yes https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/ Article 29 of Yes "Public Registry of Public-P Decree 4183/20: No Yes No No n/a Yes http://www.proyectosapp.pe/ Article 54 of Yes the PPP Regulations states that when the la No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes Article 24 (1) Yesof the Concession Law, the con Pursuant tohttp://searchbzp.uzp.gov.pl/Search.aspx No No No No n/a Yes Pursuant towww.base.gov.pt/; Articles 130, Yes https://dre.pt/ 131 and Contract 132 of Publicand www No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes Yes No No n/a Yes Article 21 of Yes Order No. 395 (implementing r Pursuant tohttp://www.e-licitatie.ro/pub No No No No n/a Yes https://rdb.rw/ According to Yes section 6.6 and 7 of the PPP guidelines on T No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes Article Article 41 of the PPP 41Decree of Yes provides the PPP that Decree tender that provides te docum No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes https://www.uvo.gov.sk/ According to Procurementhttps://crdvo.uvo.go the PublicYes Act, Art. I, Part II, C No No No No n/a Yes The According to the web-site Concessions Yes will be indicated Act, in the "from Article 41(1), tender n th No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes https://contrataciondelestado.es/wps/porta All documents published on the contracting auth shall be No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a Yes The According to the website Concessions No will be provided Act, in 8, Chapter §9, "a cont a contract no No No No No n/a Yes article 8 of No Pursuant towww.simap.ch the PP Ordinance, publications a No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes https://www.taneps.go.tz/epps/home.do Section 63 of No the Public Procurement Act provides: proc No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a Yes www.finance.gov.to Section 40(2) Yes Procurement Regulations pro of the Public No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes No No n/a Yes According to http://www.resmigazete.gov.tr/default.aspx No Article 6 of the BOT Implementation Decrea No Yes Yes No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a Yes The According to Article website 15 Yes depends (3) on the of the PPP procuring Law, autho an announce No No No No n/a Yes of 2020 on Yes Contracts and Warehouse Manag Law No. 12 https://esupply.dubai.gov.ae/esupply/web/i No No No No n/a Yes Regulation 34 Procuring of the CCR authorities No2016 states: "Electronic will make availab the tender d No Yes No No n/a Yes The Draft RfQ Specific and RfQ project Yes to are be published websites online pursua at https://www.p3v No Yes Yes No n/a Yes http://ppp.mef.gub.uy/17716/16/areas/proj Article 21 of Yes requires the publication of the PPP Decree No No No No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a Yes https://ctb.gov.vu/ Section of the No Tenders Act provides, "(2) Th Government No No No No n/a Yes http://muasamcong.mpi.gov.vn/ Article 9 of the PPP Law, which deal with transparency a Yes No Yes Yes No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a n/a 0 0 No n/a n/a No No Yes No 0 0 Yes According to the PPP Law, Yes art. 21(4), "in case of an open https://torgi.gov.ru/lotSearch1.html?bidKind Boolean Boolean Boolean Q12 Q11.1_1_TEXT Q12_4_TEXT Q12_3_TEXT Q13.1 Q13.1_4_TEXT Q13.1_3_TEXT Q13.2 Q13.2_3_TEXT 12. If yes, please Have standardized provide If yes, the relevant please PPP legal/regulatory and model provide specify and contracts 13. the provide relevant provisions: Does and/or aIf the government-supported procuring yes, legal/regulatory transaction please authority/responsible specify and provide documents provisions: the 13.2. website role the Obtaining been relevant of the where government If developed? procuring yes, legal/regulatory the the please possession mentioned authority: entity specify have of standards the provisions: required a role role in of la art Article 13 of Yes the PPP Law Standardized provides Article that: 7 of transaction The Central the Nodocuments PPP Partnership Law provides: n/a (１ areAuthority available n/a ) The at: shall Central have Yesthe Partnership following (1) The http://ppp.mof.gov.af/ Authority powers Entity and shall shallfacilitate develop8. functions: Tou the S Article 24(2) Pursuant toYes of PPP Law Pursuant https://www.app.gov.al/legislation/public-procurement/standard-tender-documents/ and Article toNo Article 26 of DCMn/a 12(3) (c) of PPPYes 575/2013 Law, the request the Concession Yes for proposal If the should Republic Treatment contain Agency of Albania (ATRAKO) a draft PPP incon is the o co n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes The procuring authority shall sub n/a No n/a n/a Yes Securing the According necessary topermits. article 11.1 No (d) of the PPP Law, the launchin n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes Article The government (procuring 5.b Annex No authority n/aand I of Decree Ministry establishes 118/2017 that of Environment Yes According to The Resolution documents 1241 Chapter Decree 2, areNo. approved part Yes 243 (1d), of the the by Minister PPP Thedraft decree N.of project 43 contract Finance The of proposal theis project Minister and tosubmitted be Economy Yes proposal included of Finance, adopted submitted for1. in the the Inand government's proposal on cases Economy for 09.02.2001. provided thethat government's adopted the for by approval procuring a onby 09. ap PPPth Yes Section 6.7.1 NSW of the NSW PPP PPP Guidelines Guidelines, NSW PPPrequires Section Yes template 6.7.1, Guidelines, Section Environmental provides project 6.7.1. "social Section documents provides impact infrastructure 4.1.2 to that assessments be of Yes "social included the National PPP infrastructure are projects in the The procuring procured PPP RFP in Guidelines NSW PPP authority by for allprojects the are social Volume NSW to has infrastru in Gover adoptNSW 7th p powe n/a No n/a n/a Yes The authority According to No within the the meaning EIA Act, of n/a§5(1), the EIA"a Act. project In general, the for applicant proa No According to n/a Article 5.9.5 n/a of the BOT Yes Rules: 5.9. The contest The a set of iscontractAccording documents should contain: to Yes includes Article information 2.3.13 the The of contract the about BOT following: should (…) licenses Rules, 5.9.5. the and Antender permit examp contain infor Yes According to the PPP Guidelines, Certain standardized Section According 26.1(a), to No contracts the "<...> PPP the were Guidelines, n/a draft developed, Contract n/a PPPSection including 5.2, shall "the Yes the PPP Public also Authority be Private annexed Land acquisition Partnership may to the beInvitation and <…> Program developing, resettlemen for Bid Ope m (I No Article 24 (3) n/a of the Regulation n/a on Preparation states thatn/a No "proposal documents n/a Yes include: shall (…) the draft Pursuant of public-private to Article 25 of the PPPp n/a No n/a No comments No n/a n/a No n/a Art.33 of the Pursuant toNo n/aPPP Law : n/a The tender dossier shall Yes Conduct include the aAccording draft environmental contract to Yes Article as well studies 12as Granting of and the PPPobtain supporting La, the the land anyrecourse require tender necessary to permit docume PPP co for t Article 17 (2) Pursuant toNo n/a(a) of then/a Sarajevo PPP YesLaw, theObtains tender documents permit based thePursuant toNo will include Article on EIA. the 65 of n/a proposal Law No. of 33/03: The contract. the PPP competent No According to n/a IX Standardized the PPA, Part n/a Bidding No packages n/a n/a processes, and Bidding n/a the Authority shall develop a No Article 56(1) No According to VI and Article Article 10,n/a Yes n/a11 of the PPP Law, the Obtaining procuring the This environmental is regulated authority has the No under permits obligation n/a Article before to include 10 entering (VII) of the a the draft PPP procurem Law: of the c Ar Article 78(1) Pursuant toNo n/a n/a of the Concession Yes Law, depending The onGrantor the subject Pursuant of the toYes is supposed Article to provide concession 127 The and of theGrantor the relevant the typeis of Concession assistance supposed procedure Law:(1) for the provi toWhen C de Article 42 of Pursuant toYes On the the Public PPP Decree, Order Acquisition No. the 2017-266/MINEFID/SG/DGCOOP bid NoRegulatoryshall authority package n/a include n/a website: at least on http://www.arcop.bf/dossiers-type/ Yes the following: the Grant's “the allocation, organization specific limited rights' and functioning purpose of the as owner conw n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes When the contract includes occu n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes Granting limited owner's right on No of the Contracting Section 12.4.2 n/a n/a provides, Policies No "12.4.2 n/a As stated in n/a No article 4.2, n/a Government Construction Co the Standard No Article 16.I.c n/a of the Implementing n/a Decree provides Yes that the Facilitating the Article obtention tender documents of 80shall Yes the of include the permit. a Granting draft contract environmental Law the right (Law detailing No. of 014/PR/98 the right occupation documents n/a The tender No are the contract, themselvesn/a No along with the regulatory n/a n/a framework Yes The and responsibility the for theand winner's technical fina exprop article 15 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Guidelines, n/a draft of then/a a No n/a PPP contract shall be included Yes Therequest in the for relevant proposals. Further governments shall s Yes For public financed Standardized initiative PPP projects Paragraph model article 7, No contract Article 30.2 of for2Concession the Law n/a 1150 Law 80 of of n/a 2007, Cuarta 1993 asGeneracion modified Yes (Public by(5G) article Procurement In particular highways: Law 4 of -the applicable for Law https://www.ani.go transportation 1882 as of stated in t 2018by Article 40 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law, n/a the bidding No documents consist Granting theArticle of plot three 55 of parts: of Yes land the necessary instructions PPP Law toprovides: Make given available the PPPtoproject. for candidates land, the proper setting access roado execu n/a Yes The ARMP: Pursuant http://www.armp.cg/en-us/documents/documentation/standarddocuments.aspx toNo Art. 21 of the n/aPublic Procurement n/a Code, drafting No n/a model documents for conces No According to of the PPP Regulations article 12 n/a n/a No the tender documents n/a will includeNo n/a n/a a draft of the PPP contract. No According to n/a Article 21.1 of the Public n/a Procurement No Code:n/a The request n/a No published for proposals n/aby the procuring authority sho Article 22 of Pursuant toNo the Concession n/a No n/a Act on the contents n/aof tender documentation, n/a n/a No a draft agreement is to be included in Yes According to Procurement the PublicSample The Concession Act, Sample §174(1), Contract Concession No within "a contracting n/a Contract the PPP Manual isn/a part of authority shall (https://www.mfcr.cz/cs/legislativa/metodiky/200 theproceed No PPP Manual in accordance and can be n/a accessed with in that doc the provisions ou n/a Yes The Danish (1) the Standard No PPP Model Competition for Construction: n/a and Consumer n/a Authority No has prepared n/a PPP standard models inten https://www.kfst.dk/udbud/offentlig-privat-samarbejde/ Yes Article 11 of https://unite-ppp-djibouti.com/modeles/ the PPP tender procedure Art. 4, Decree Decree (Decree No No. n/a No. 2018-178, 2018-176/PR/MEFI datedn/a 14 May 2018 Yeson the organization establishing Granting PPP procurement the and right procedures) of occupation functioning th ofadd No Under Article 27 of Law 340-06, as n/a n/a No amended, contracts executed n/a n/aprocuring by the No must be consistent with the draf authority n/a No Article 55, section n/a c), of n/a the PPP Regulations - Executive No n/a 1190,n/a Decree No "[...] In general, provides that n/a the administrative bases No Article 24(d) Law states n/a of the PPPn/a No documents that the tender n/a to be prepared n/a the Administrative byYes According to the PPP Authority Law and the in coordination No Article 41 of n/a "minimum PPP Law states: n/a content Noof tendering n/a documents: No of the contract" n/a (…) j) draft n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No According to Procurement the Publicn/a n/aAct, Chapter No 2, Division n/a 2, Subdivision No n/a 1, §77(4)(4), n/a otherwise provided for in thi "unless n/a Yes documentsNo TransactionTransaction documents available at: n/a have http://www.ppa.gov.et/index.php?option=com_joomdoc&view= developed No been n/a n/a and made available at the website of the FDR Section 68 n/a Pursuant toNo n/a Contracts (1) of the Public The procuring Yes and Concessions Act, Pursuant the authority toYes Section applies invitation 22a forIf to tender, the of the the project contract EIA Act: is located environmentalThe notice, permit needsthe on for is invita suc the private No of the Public Article R2111-8 n/a Code No n/a Acquisition n/a the buyer proviodes that n/aformulates Yes The contracting the technical authority specifications: is by 1° Either re most n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes When the project requires an occ Article 21(4) Pursuant toNo n/a n/a No. 426, of Resolution the Bidding Yes Transfer Document, of land Pursuant in agreement toYes and/or issuance with Article 28the of (1) Transfer permits of the of Agency,and shall PPP Law, land licenses be and/or subject approved provided to by the issuance th fo Yes According to The (non-mandatory) the Concessions Ordinance, According §16, standardized to"the the tender Yes introduction Assistance PPP documents for the in contracts According include granting PPP were developed any to the contract Yes document the permits for Standard the forand The several federal that Contract licenses. land a concession's sectors, highway would for usually Highways, in area particular: grantor under have prov the to (1)bP Sectio No(e) of the Section 44 (2) n/a PPP Act provides n/a that No the Request for Proposal n/a n/adocuments Yes The contracting should include authority a draft PPP may Agreement as ind Article 36 of Pursuant toNo the Concessions n/a tender documents n/a Law, Yes The procuring include Article authority the draft 20 Yes of the reimburses concession PPP Law The contract provides, the SPV ifwith it Procuring<…> incurs Authorities annexes. all permits additional 3.guaran requ The te co No Article 41 of n/a the PPP Law n/a establishes that the Yes tender documents Before signing "shall Article the 65 contract, contain the Yes of the project PPP the private Law: Declare Before partner specifications of signing collective and shall the obtain contract, substantial municip utility th and p n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes Where the PPP Contract involves n/a Yes Article 14.4 The CNMP website: Yes https://cnmp.gouv.ht/ requires the The procuring Pursuant authority procuring to to authorityYes article facilitates use standardized 6.2.3 the The of obtention contracting the standard ofauthority documents the clauses for permits. for provide public pro conc No Article 15 of n/a the General n/a Regulations of the PPP Yes Law, indicate The PPP the Article sheet that Superior 13 Council of subsection terms Nohas to coordinate and 2 n/a of the PPP conditions in efforts Law the request establishes with allfor thethat secre propoC No According to of the Public Article 57 n/a n/a Procurement No Act:(1) The n/a contracting Noshall make n/a authority public the procurement docum n/a Yes As per Clause Both 1.2.3 of the Model standard RFP, Model the RFQ bidding Yes contracts published and documents transaction by Applicable include the Ministry documents permits, Schedule theof draft Finance have as concession E required, to Yes been the Notification Model relating agreement. The developed. Concession No. Site Model 24(1)/PF-II/2006 to of environmental Clause the RFQ Agreement 2.7.2 published Projectprovides isprotectio dated to states by be the 18 fu t pr Yes According to Ministry the Attachment the to of Transportation Regulation LKPP Regulation of Yesthe and29/2018, the A Minister Toll public of Road Chapter Energy Agency According II, and partner A, responsible (BPJT) Mineral 5 (e)(1)(m), to Yes have the Resources Attachment for afor standard aaPPP A public № project 10 one-stage form toof partner the 2017 that tender (PJPK) Bappenas can responsible "About the shall beinformatio used compile Regulatio Principle as foraa a No Article 14 of n/a the Tenders n/a under "Bidding Law provides Yes documents" The relevant a) All government The Privatedocuments bidding Sector Yesentity Participation facilitates shall The relevant be submitted Order the issuance government provides equally of such inentity to perm all a Articlef n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes Whileagreement Standard project No draft: a regulatory basis n/a https://www.ndfa.ie/wp-content/uploads/2015/03/Updated_Temp per se does not seem No n/a n/a the country has developed s to be provided, Yes Section 17 (b) of the Mandatory https://mof.gov.il/en/InternationalAffairs/InfrastructuresAndProjects/Pages/PPP_GeneralInformation Tenders Section 17 (b) Yesof the Regulation provides Mandatory Thethat: procuring (b) Tenders According The authority Tender Regulation to Yes Documents facilitates the Planning provides the The shall that: private procuring Law: Notice (b) partner's The include, inter authority of Tender preparation alia, application helps all the Documen fac of s fo Yes Article 181 of The the Public standard Contracts Article Code contract 213, has Yes para provides been the 2 ofapproved the rules for Italian PPP Without byCode operations: the According National prejudice of Public to "[c]ontracting the to Yes Contracts Article provisions 14listing If of Anticorruptionauthorities contained the Law Authority land the N.241-1990: missions isin shall notregional in award (ANAC)of the 5.the in Without availabilit resolutio contract ItalianpA legislation No According to n/a the Procurement n/a Handbook, Volume No 2, Appendix n/a 7, Section No n/a A7.3, "Bidding n/a Documents include the following sect Yes The (Procurement) The PFI Process Promotion The Section Guideline, Guidelines Office No 4-1(7) makes for recommends it n/a available to Contracts-Notes on attach on n/a its website PFIa draft Yes the Project Implementation Guideline PPP contract Therelating procuring to the Contracts to Contracts authority tender are available may (Conside documents. gran No Article 24(B) n/a of the Regulation provides n/a that the NoTechnicaln/a Committee shall prepare, n/a n/a to the request for proposals d No in addition Article 37 (2) Pursuant toYes A standard-form (4) of theAccording PPP Law, PPP contract to the NoArticle procuring is20 set n/a (7) authority ofin out the Order PPP shall n/aLaw, of include Acting the Yes tasks Ministry a draft of of of thethe The National central state PPP contract authorized Economy partnerin No. body isthe obliged: request 724, includes to tr fo date No of then/a Section 50 (2)(d) n/a that tender PPP Act provides No documents n/a include basic shalln/a the project agreement including Noterms of n/a Article 71 of Pursuant toYes Standard the PPPPPP Basic This model is regulated Plans, the contract No competent by Article and PPP n/aauthority 40 Request of thefor may PPP n/a Proposals Basic prepare Plans, Yeshave a draft which beenMOLIT, under concession updated as 6. a agreement, requires procuring and uploaded PIMAC authority including betwee to preit Yes Article 48 of PPP the PPP Law outlines Kosovathe Pursuant Website to contents - section Yes Article of theon 17 PPP of The standardized Agreement. the contract PPP Law, Pursuant can some documents: specify to ofYes Article the the http://www.pppkosova.org/?cid=1,103 functions assistance 48 of The the contract of the that PPPPPPC the Law, can Contracting include: specify the Agreement 2.2. the Author assis sh issua Yes Article 22 of Annex BRegulations the PPP Executive (p. Article 224): http://www.kapp.gov.kw/Library/Files/Uploaded%20Files/arabic/KuwaitPPPProjectG 22 provides, of Nothe PPP Executive "The project's n/a Regulations procurement n/a Yes documents provides The shall that:The Public Higher mainly Entity Committee in collaboration include the followin shall have Article 13(1) Pursuant toNo n/aof the Law n/a on PPP, <...> No at the stage of selecting Government can n/a the provide winner Nosupport tender, n/a of the in obtaining the authorized licenses, permits, body for o ap provides that Article 31.3 No n/a n/a documents "The tender Yes shall include: Coordinate […] 3.According with A partnership otherto Yes Article agreement relevant sector 84(6) Theform." authorities procuring of Per article the Investments authority to issue 35Law of enterpris will and the PPP in assis Noof the PPP Article 33(11) Law provides, n/a No concession n/a <...> a draft n/a n/a contract shall be annexed Yes Providing to the the land Regulations. the case In and of a tc allowing No According to n/a art. 7(7)(c), the PPP Law, No committee, n/a "the project n/a n/a assisted by the working Yes team, A shall prepare procuring a draft entity either pro can tender doc Article 3 ofThe Pursuant toYes Concessions Developing the Partnership Law, Concession No (Concession) standard Agreement documents Documents n/a serves (which n/a falls into as the are the model used scope Yes contract, of as theThe mandate tenderavailable documents) procuring given at https://www.pppli include to the CPMA authority draftby asecurescoa article 8.3 of Pursuant toNo n/a n/a (Decree the PPP Decree When Yes 2017-149 fromthe 2 March PPP Article 2017, 37 of contract Yes involves elaborating the PPP the Law When onoccupation provides: application thethe state PPPof the contract operations of public includes the domai PPP Lawo carr No According to n/a the PPP Manual, n/a #3.13: Procedure YesIssuing DRAFT The procuring Section authority 33 PPP Contract(s) of toYes Pre-Qualified assist the PPP Act A procuring provide: Short-Listed in obtaining the Without required authority Private prejudice environmen Bidders or to fo the Gove n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No Article 12. II. n/a contractn/a 3. of the PPP No requires the n/a project contract and n/a its annexes Yes When to be included thetender in the requires occup projectdocuments. Section 2 of Pursuant toNo PPPA, "request n/a No n/a for proposal" means n/a the specific No n/a terms of n/a the project requirements, the procedures f Yes According to section Article 45 The (V) Article Federal of Government the PPP 92 ofYes the Law the PPP have launched tender Law In some referencing the cases documents Impulse Article the shall PPP content 45, procuring include: paragraph Projects Yes ofauthority "The the Strategy. VI PPP draft Itof contract the may depends contract, The Public-Private beStrategy onresponsible and the with article project has the Partnership 11 four rights forrequiri granti obje and wil and Article 25(d) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Government The Law: Resolution need theto necessary comply No. 476, Yes with documentation provides Assistance standardized instructions According in for obtaining documents theon tender Yes the toissuing Article permits. isfor required standardized the 10 of Assigning selection the by PPP Section the of Law, PPP the required contracts 113 (1) private of TheGovernmen land public and partner to tran pa th Yes According to - Annex the Concessions 3 to Law, According art. the 13.7.6, Government to"the Yes the tender Concessions Decree The№ regulatory 103 Law, of documentation According art. 4 May authorities 11.4, shall 2012 "the to include Yes the Standard Government andthe Concessions a procuring following The RfQ regulatory shall Law, Document: authority information: approve art.authorities 21.1.8, https://www.lega are the<…> <…> obliged "unless and (13.7. stand to a ot No According to paragraph n/a Article 41,No Yes 2 of the PPP According Law stipulates that an to The theEIA EIA integral part Law, Law, Yes Part of Part II, the Article tender II, Article The public 10. documentation 10, "the partner competentobliged is is public to e theauthori Yes Article 13.I.3 of the PPPhttps://www.finances.gov.ma/Docs/depp/2018/Clausier%20type%20-%20Contrat%20PPP%20VF%202 Decree provides The National that the No consultation Commissionn/aDecree file must No. n/a 2-14-867 include No of the "[…] 28 November draft n/a 2015 on the public-private National cont partnership Com No According to n/a of Decree Article 47.2(p) n/a no. 5/2016: No 2. The Bidding n/a n/a Documents No must Model Contract. include a n/a No Section 45 of n/a the Public n/aRules, 2064 Procurement Government Yes (2007) indicates the Section Documents of Nepal (by 8(k) of to Yes the ways be PPP included of the Government Act: "8. in tender Board) shall Functions, ofdocuments, Nepal grant duties or shall and includ make cause to po n/a Yes DBFM Standard The DBFM Agreement and Yes DBFMO For for Public Standard Works all permits version Pursuant concerning 5.0: Agreements have Yes tohttps://www.rijksoverheid.nl/onderwerpen/ Article areas been 18.3 covered prepared Providing of the by by the DBFM access the Natura Government to required 2000 Standard conser land of N Agreeme Yes According to the PPP Guide, https://treasury.govt.nz/publications/guide/standard-form-public-private-partnership-ppp-project-agr Section According 5.5, "theto Yes the RFP isUpdated a fundamental The procuring Procurement document According entity Rules, to shall tothe Yes Rule the obtain procurement 64(1)(e), PPP the Therequired "agencies Guide, Section process, procuring environmental considering 3.3, entity as "prior it describes shall to obtain appro the the the Ex proc Noof PPP Regulation Article 24(23) n/a n/a that the states Notendering n/a documentsn/a No shall contain n/a a contract proposal. article 33 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law n/a n/a tender dossier : (...) TheNo n/a shall include n/a a draft Yes Granting contract and the right supporting of occupation documents indicati n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes Ministry of Works and Housing Yes Article 21 of Samples the PPP Law can provides Pursuant that be downloaded the Commission toNo Article 40shall from the n/a of the (…) Ministry PPP prepare Law, of Economy's n/a theGovernment the No website: tender documentation, ofn/a the http://archive.economy.gov.mk/ including Republic the draft of North contr Macedoni Yes According to Standard the PPP Act, Section Form 13(2)(c), According of Bidding to Yes the "without Documents PPP prejudice A procuring for to Policy, Section Procurement the generality According authority G, "Standard of to of shall Yes Works subsection theprovide Standard PPPon Concession BOT Procuring assistance (1), Bidding Basis the Agreements/contracts implementing issued authority in Form obtaining by the forshall BOT, Pakistan agency, the provide nece Part E b" 1in No PPP Regulations: Article 8 of the n/a n/a 2. Feasibility Phase The Yes analysis and contracting approval Article to24 implement public entity Yes of the PPP shall the Regulations. The PPP contracting project. identify needs Based theAdministrative public for on entity theactions approv permits, lic shal Nothe PPP Policy Point 9.2.4 of that all bidding n/a statesn/a No documents n/a shouldn/a contain an Information No Memorandum, or its equivalent n/a Yes Article 48 of The web Decree 4183/20: "Tender page While documents of the there Secretary No is no and of draft Technical n/a express contract. provision Planning n/a The in the tender provides regulatory No documents models framework, of n/a for contracts thethe bidding/tender of different web the sectors, page of and draft Secre of the PPP Regulations Article 54.1No n/a establishesNo n/a n/a contract that the initial n/a version (Versión Yes Inicial Article 30.3 of-VIC) de Contrato must PPP law be inclu states tha (b) of the BOT Section 4.1 Yes Law IRR provides: Transaction documents Section 2 of "The Yes Executive and contract Order Agency/LGU Assistance clauses concerned No. 8, are in Under the available shall powers the securing prepare BOT the Yes on and environmental Law, the functions the following the bid/tender Support government the of webpage: permits inPPP documents, obtaining may Center, or http://ppp.gov.p the provide the securing as which follows: any land or of fo shalt of the Concession Article 2(1) Yes LawDocumentation Reference Article 16a defines 'concession of NoPPP Act documents,' on the PPP states n/a Platform thatwhich the n/a website: includes http://www.ppp.gov.pl/Publikacje/Strony/Dok minister competent Noa non-exhaustive n/a for regional list that speaks of is development any do resp Article 12 (2) Pursuant toNo n/a PPP Law, the (e) of then/a Noteam in charge n/a of appraising n/a and structuring No the PPP project must elaborate n/a No PPP Law Article 9 of the provides :"The n/a Yes Authority n/a Contracting The shall Licensing prepare, Article Authorities 17(3) in Yes of shall coordination the issue PPP The Law licenses with the provides Project Contracting for the that committee, Authority Projects indicat must the p the Partnershs Article 20(1) Pursuant toYes The of GD No. (c)National Pursuant Agency 395/2016, to for Yes Government Article Public Procurement 22(1) Conduct Decision (c) of developed GD theNo. Pursuant EIA No. 1/2018 to drafts Yes on 394/2016, Article the for and 6some of approval Article Expropriator Law classic No. 19(3) of the 292/2018: public general (c) inof the procurement GDand (1) No. nameThe special 867/201 and enviro and onco article 19 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a No n/aThe Contracting Authority n/a releases n/a the bidding Yes documents to the Granting shortlisted the land bidders.Th n/a Yes Section K.5.4. NoBidding documents n/a (1) n/a https://www.mof.gov.ws/services/procurement/standard-tender-document-templates/ of the Treasury No n/a Instructions procuring states that aand en http://w No for eachn/a RFPs launched n/a the draft project include Yes Identifying contract and relevantthe Article schedules. party of Yes Article the PSP 11responsible 80 Law for of The issuing provides the Implementing PSP the Lawthat enables necessary “[w]ithout expropriatio licenses, prejud Regulations o No Article 60 of n/a PPP Decree provides that n/a the draft No n/a is to be n/a PPP contract the bidding attached toNo documents. n/a Yes According to A draft the PPP Law, direct Article The 20, agreement "the Practitioners Nois provided procedure for selecting Guide for n/ain the a Schedule PPP private n/a and Concessions 2 of the Nois partner either Act in a Practitioners n/a public Serbia, Guide. Schedules A term sheet procurement procedure 1 and 2. nego for d Section 39 n/a Pursuant toNo n/a … (3) The of the PPP Act: Yesrequest for Assistance submission According in of expressions to obtaining Yes the Section permits of interest Obtaining 4 of PPPthe theshall Act: include land (1) at least A PPP the fol Agreem section 3.2.23 Pursuant toNo n/a Handbook, n/a of the PPP No in addition n/a to the information n/a No to n/a be included in the Notice of Proposed Proc No According to Procurement the Publicn/a n/a I, Part II, Chapter Act, Art. No n/a 1, §42 n/a (11), "the Yes tender documentation shall It depends on type the<...> of PPP a contain d pro No According to n/a Act, Article the Concessions Yes n/a 42(1), "the [concession According (tender)] to According the documentation to Nothe PPP Act, Part PPP Act, Article n/aArticle 5, shall 19, "a contain19, <...> public "a public partner the partner draft shallsh conces a of the Procurement Section 4.1 No n/a Manual n/a provides, No "o Draft n/a Contract: The No should n/a draft contract be published along with the bid n/a No According to n/a143(1)(d), the PPA, art. n/a No "the concession bid documents n/a n/a at a minimum shall, No n/a the following: <…> (d) Gener include Yes According to The following the PPP Manual, Module According website 5, (pages provides Yes to the 32-33): PPP "an Manual, for A Standardized procuring RfP document "theAccording authority National PPPmust provisions: Treasury has to include Yes the a direct https://www.gtac.gov.za/Publications has PPP a draft standaridized responsibility a A dedicated procuring PPP agreement PPP authority provisions, for Unit performing that has allows Part whicha direc has A, any se fot n/a No n/a n/a Yes When necessary According the procuring Yes to 142 article authority The of thewill General prepare concessionaire Regulations and has submittoth right the p "o No According to n/a on PPPs, the Guidelines n/aSection 244(v)(a), No n/a the RFP n/a "<…> No shall consist n/a components <…> (v) Contra of the following n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Supreme Council for Public-P n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes A contracting authority shall prov n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Article 15 (2) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP n/a Law, the content Yes The of the request agreement Pursuant for shall provide toYes proposals shallfor Article include 29 all of contracting the amatters a list PPP which Law, of the authority The bidding Parties deem document or other agreement sh necg n/a Yes Section 88 of Yes https://www.ppra.go.tz/phocadownload/PPP_Documents/PPP_Agreement_Final_August_2021.pdf the PPP Regulations Facilitating 2020, the The obtaining PPP ActNo regarding under ofthe permits procurement n/a by the Sections 10 (environmental private contract, partner permit provides: ris 88.- n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 49 of the PPP No ) of the n/a Section 13(1)(c n/a Public Procurement No Regulations provides n/a the Procurement thatn/a No in the Contracting Agency is resp Unit n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 15 of decree provides Article7 that of the the 2016-772 http://www.igppp.tn/fr/node/466 No restricted Government Full n/a tender PPP Decree Contract documents n/a No. template will Yes 2016-1185 include can of be 14in found October Granting particular: here: the 2016, - http://www.igppp.tn tender rights setting rules, the- when organiz draft it's pubp n/a No n/a n/a Yes Government As per Article authority No needs 5/6 of to the n/a Public obtain environmental Procurement permit befor Law, in the No of the n/a Section 10 (3)(f) n/a provides PPP Regulations Yesthat the invitation The approving to NEMA bid and (CAP the Yes authority153) bidding or physical applies documents The andrelevant Physical planning shall committee minister Planning include— shall may(f)grant declar a cop Authority No According to of Resolution Article 13 n/a No. 384, competitive n/a Yes The documentation procuring According includes: to Yes authority, as (a) thethe Law Instructions of IfUkraine a land for constructionlot "On applicants; employer, is required Environmental (b) toConditio shall procur Imp implem No Article 18 of PPP Law provides, the Dubai n/a n/a No "A Government n/a Entity will prepare n/a Tender documents the No n/a of the Partnership Projec n/a Yes The last standard The existing form No of Project/Concession model andn/a standards, Agreements n/a until the discontinuation No for PPPs applicable n/a in England of the use (Wales of PFI, were and part ofN Section 4.3.1 Pursuant toYes of the Forms are4.3.1 available TheDraft at: mandate RfP, No http://www.p3virginia.org/ppta-resources/ of the may VDOT VDOT's n/a choose P3 Office issue ton/a allows the it RFPto in Yespublish draft This format standardized includes: Obtaining to Short-Listed the P3 PPP Task land documents. for Order Proposers thetemplat The( private No Article 19 of n/a the PPP Regulatory n/a indicates Decree procuring entity No that then/a n/a shall elaborate Yes Projects the draft contract developed along under with PPPbS athe No According to of the PPP Law, Article 22 n/a Yes n/a <...> an A public integral part of thepartner tender According to a PPP to Yes Article is obliged, documentation 14 is A the ofpublic the draft among partner PPPPPP others, Law, agreement. a is topublic obliged assistpartner privat ato pro n/a Yes Tender of The CentralSection the YesGovernment Board issued standardized The procuring Tendersprocurement Act The Environmental provides, No authority would documents "(2) The Protection conduct n/a Minister, including: the environmental Act provides the Director Request infor General Section impact Tenders of a 14 Yes According to Appendix Article 49.2(g) of Decree VIStandardized of No. the Decree 35, regarding No PPP 35 model provides Preparation, contract n/a is appraisal n/a guided standardized PPPunder and model Yes Appendix approval contract, of Provincial bidding VIalong of the with People's documents, Decree 35. Committees Circular 09/2021/ for projects Yes According to https://www.mofnp.gov.zm/?page_id=3396 the PPP Act, The PPP "the Section 22(5)(c), ActNo provides: invitation“5. to submit n/a functions n/a (1) The expressionsof of the Yes Department interest A contracting for are to— [...] participation authority in (e) thedevelop pre selectio must tec pro n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No According to n/aart. 21(1)(1), the PPP Law, Yes documentation n/a "the tender Assistancemust in According obtaining contain Yes to<…> the any necessary (1) PPP decision A contracting a Law, art. on 15(10), permits the issued authority implementation "during by themust governm pro conclusioof Boolean Boolean Boolean Q13.3 Q13.2_4_TEXT Q13.3_3_TEXT Q13.3_4_TEXT Q14 Q15_A Q15_B Q15_1_TEXT Q15_2_TEXT the relevant and provide13.3. If yes, legal/regulatory Obtaining theplease required and specify provide provisions: the right of 14. the role Please relevant way.of the provide 15. procuring legal/regulatory Which anyof If additional authority: the yes,following please provisions: information 15. The options bid specify and If or evaluation best provide comments yes, describes please the committee on relevant the the provide required answers the members legal/regu relevan to t qual Yes The PPP Law in Article 39 (1)provides The Entity The that: PPP shall (1)facilitate The Law Entity in Article the comments shall utilization 39 Nofacilitate provides: of the the n/a (1)relevant The Entity No project utilization shall of the site, facilitate relevant n/a and project the utilization provide site, all necessary and ofprovide suppo all the relevan Article 37 of Pursuant toYes Procuring the PPP Law: authority Pursuant 1. In facilitates toComments the Article event if that 37 of theYes aprocuring PPP private Law: 1. Pursuant authority concession/public-private In the event to isNo the Article owner that 18 a private of of n/a PPP contract theconcession/public-private Law, immovable involves the members the use ofof property. the In prob c ca YesNo. 90-30 Art. 65 of Law of 1 December Granting Art. the right 65 1990 of of way. on n/aStates’ Law Land No No. 90-30 of provides 1 December n/a that1990 on YesStates’ the manager aPursuant public ofLand provides service to article that or the manager concession 160 of of the Pub n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a No Article 19 of n/aprovidesn/a the PPP Law the "Provision Comments of land parcels:" No n/a 1. In No for byn/a cases provided a PPP contract, a public partner the National Section 8 ofYes ThePPP procuring Guidelines Section Volume authority 8 ofn/a the has 7 Provides, powerNoto National PPP 8.1 takeOwnership temporary n/a (a) Guidelines Volume orSubject permanent Yes7 Provides, possession/ NSW8.2 to 8.1(b), PPP government Construction Guidelines acquisition willlicense generally provide of landin be an 8.2.1SG n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes According to the Law on Concess No According to Article 2.3.13 n/a of the BOT n/a Rules, the Comments Yes will include: tender notice According licenses to No and permits Article of the 5.4n/a required BOT Rules, by the Law the of the Re compositio Yes According to the PPP Screening The rightManual, ofAccording way shall Figure to n/a be 2-16 the provided PPA, Typical to Yes art.Risk a 28(1), Allocation “the private According partner private Matrix upon to partner Nothe shows a duly PPP or the Guidelines, land amade n/a project acquisition notification. Section company and40.1, resettlement or any "the its o r of Evalu Article 25 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Pursuant Article Law: 1. In25 accordance to Comment Article of the PPP 25 with of No Law:the an 1.agreement In PPPaccordance Law: n/a1.on public-private with Noan agreement In accordance with partnerships, n/a an on agreementa public on public-private public-private partnershi partner is e n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a section 6.2.4. Pursuant toYes of the the Granting Pursuant right of Guidance Note, way ton/a section 6.2.4. the PPP Yesof Unit the Guidance assists Article the public 3Note, ofauthorities the Nothe PPP Law PPP Unit inn/a acquiring defines assists a procurement the public lands authorities whereas section Commis n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes Article 13 of Pursuant toNo the Sarajevo Concession Law:1) n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes There are no requirements regar Article 16 of Pursuant toYes the The Grantor Concession Pursuant is supposed Law: Comments Article to to(1) Inprovide the 16 of Yes case the the of relevant a construction Pursuant assistance Concession Law: concession to(1) No Article to the Inthe80 Concessionaire, to case of the n/aof the object a Concession of where construction concession, Law: necessary, concession (1) the The gran bu to pro Yes Article 78 of the PPP Decree Granting provides theArticle right thatof 78 the ofcontracting way Decree the PPP 0 authority, No provides in n/a that the Yes accordance with the Article contracting authority, terms of 40the of inthe accordance PPP Decree with public-private prov th partn article 39 of Pursuant toYes the PPP When the Law: contract Article When includes 39 the of the partnership occupation PPP 0 Law Yes contract of the Pursuant provides: involves when domain, public theto occupation partnership No article it implies 13ofn/a of contract the the authorization public PPPinvolves Law, domain, anof occupation ad it hoc occupation shall commis beof fo det n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a section 17 Granting Pursuant toYes the of PPP Law (Law right No. Pursuantof 2006/012 way ton/awhen of section itsDecember 17 of public No Law land No.29, 2006/012, n/a when Yes the 2006, enacting general According thecontract occupies regulations to section a public of 22 (3) estate, of the Partnership it n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a Yes Article 35 of Grantingprovides: the PPP ordinance Article the right the of 35way. public of authority the PPP ordinance 0 No may provides: make n/athe the public No site project available n/a may authority to the make private partner. the project It ma site av Yes According to of the Article 15 The Concessions According responsibility for Law, the to Comments Article should expropriations it be 15 of required Yes Concessions therests with The to expropriate evaluation theLaw, Ministry No assets committee should of Public itand/or be n/a needs Works rights to requiredand to for expropriate beit the composed is he construction by must pro whoassets related to land, For permitsYes The relevant article For 22 governments permits of Measures Comments related shall for to simplify the Yes land, Administration article the formalities 22 of of Pursuant Measures Concession to where No article a concessionaire forfor 7 ofInfrastructure the Interim n/a Administration Measures needs and of tofor Public Concession handle the Admin plannfo Utilities, Yes Article 20 of On2013 Law 1682 of Article top of the previous 38 Law Comments provision 1682/2013No for n/a enables land, the Law No n/a the procurement entities of national level t Yes Article 55 of Make the PPP Law available provides:Article for land, the 55 access proper of theexecution roads, PPP 0 Lawnetworks, Noprovides: of the contract installations n/a for the proper and No andexecution facilities subject to then/a available laws of the incontract utility force Democratic and subject inequipment Re to and n/a No n/a n/a n/a Yes articles 1 and Pursuant toNo n/a2 of the Decree No. 2009-161 n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a comments Yes NoDecree No. Art. 21 of PPP n/a2018-358 of March 29, 2018 r n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes No Article 16 of n/a Act provides details on the the Concession n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes According to the Public Procurem n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a article 52 of Pursuant toYes Granting the PPPthe Law, Pursuant right when to of way the n/a article contract implies Yes 52 of occupation the PPP According Law, when of the the to Nocontract public Art. 3 of domain, the implies n/a PPPitProcedure occupation constitutesof anthe authorizat Decree ( PPP D public d n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes According to article 16 of the PPP n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes Article 65 of the PPP Regulations No Article 17 of n/a the PPP Law provides,n/a "“the procedures n/a Yes for contracting Article for a PPP29Project of No reflected the PPP n/a Law provides under Article that "A committee (20) sh of the PPP L n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes Article 42 of No n/a PPP Law: "Committee of evaluation. The te n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes According to article 28 (2) of the No Act on the Redemption of Immoveable n/a n/a Property Comments and Special No Rights (603/1977, n/a No as and Highways Act (503/2005, as amended) n/a Yes Art. L2213-10 Granting of the Public the Acquisition Art. right Code of way provides: L2213-10 of theWhen Public 0 No the Acquisition n/a Code partnership provides: No entails contract when n/a occupation of the public the partnership domain contract entai Yes According to of the the Article 67 When Ordinance According PPPproject requires to (Ordinance Article n/a 67No. No of the an occupation 009/PR/2016 PPP of the Ordinance No of 11 public (Ordinance February Land, No the conclusion 2016 No. n/a009/PR/2016 on Public-Private of the contractPartnership of 11 February implies an2 Article 28 (1) Pursuant toYes of the of Transfer PPPland Pursuant Law, subject and/or toComments Article issuance to the 28(1) ofYes permits of the PPP limitations and outlined Pursuant Law, licenses subject in Georgian to provided No Article to the 18(5) for legislation limitations n/a byof the the and/or legislation PPP set forth Law, the Public in an of Georgian Georgia authorized and Priva in leg ca b Yes According to TheContract the Standard way for Highways, would right ofAccording to Comments the Section Standard usually No 11.1, have toContract be "a client n/a for provided to [aHighways, contracting a private No Section party. authority] 11.1,undertakes n/a contracting "a client [a to con provide aauth Yes Section 64 of Theregarding the PPP Act, procuring Section Acquisition authority 65 of Comments of the may rights PPP assist related No the Act, regarding private to project party easements, n/a site, to enjoy provides Yes provides: the right that: Section "Subject to "(1) enter 43 to whereupon, of the the thetransit nature payment PPP Act, through ofof a regard appro partn Yes Article 23(1) of the PPPThe LawProcuring provides Article for Authorities 23(1) expropriation Comments ofguarantee the PPP declared Yesthat Law by they the Pursuant have provides Minister for exclusive expropriation toNo Article of Development ownership 67 declared of n/a the rights and Concessions byInvestment the or exclusive Minister Law, whenever use of special Develop rightco o la Yes Article 66 of Declare the PPP Law: Declare of collective of Article collective ofComments utility theand 66utility PPPand public Law: public Yes interest Declare interest of Article thecollective the required 49 required of utility the No PPP expropriations expropriations and Law: public n/a for Bidsinterest will for thebe theevaluated the PPP projects. PPPrequired projects. by The anThe AN e expr Yes Article 26 of Procuring the PPP Law the provides: Where Article right26 of theway. n/a of the Contract PPP Noprovides: PPP Law involves the n/a Where theYes PPPof occupation the public Pursuant Contract involves domain, tothe Part shall I, chapter be deemed itoccupation of sec 3, the article 6.2.2 Pursuant toYes of the standard Granting Pursuant the rightclauses of way. to article for concession 0 Yes 6.2.2 the of the contracting Pursuant standard clauses to authority No article for concession of n/a the PP 8provides, as the Law, necessary, contracting a bid opening authority the comm land p and n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes According to Article 27(3) of the P Yes Article 10 of Concession the ModelThe right ofModel way Agreement provided n/a read is Concession and with Agreement Schedule No by granted inthe 'A' Article n/a Procuring states 10 that states No Authority the Site that the of (NHAI n/a right the Project in ofthis way is isto case) provided be to provided the Private and granP and No According to the Bappenas n/a Regulation n/a № 4, art. Comments Yes 10 (6), "at the implementation According to phase Nothe LKPP Regulation n/a of a PPP a public partner project ,29/2018, respo art. 7, "the P Sector Participation The Private Yes The relevant Order The government Private Sector provides inentity Article Participation facilitates 07Yes - The investor Order the issuance provides is obliged Article 5 of ofthe No such to in Article Tenders cooperate permit. 7n/a Law - The with provides investorunder is obliged the project "Bidding to coop company in Com n/a No n/a n/a n/a Yes No According to n/a of the Government Contract Article 6 (1-2) n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a Yes63 of the As per Section Planning The procuring Law, As per theSection authority Planning Comments helps 63agency of facilitate the Planning Yes the shall have private Law, Section a role the partner's in 8 relevant ofNo the "(2) the application Mandatory Planning delineation n/aagency Tenders for of obtaining new shall roads have Regulation the and required a role provides thein righ ens diver Article 31 (4) Pursuant toYes Theofresponsible the Public Pursuant Contracts person Article ofCode, ton/a the procuring 31 the (4) official Yesof the authority responsible Public Articles is the 77 of Contracts one and No theresponsible 78 Code: procedure of "[b]esides the n/a Public (RUP) for securing those Contracts shall tasks propose the Code specifically the provide required righ call pf o n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes According to the PPP Policy, Secti Yes by Article This is regulated The69 procuring of the This PFI authority Law is regulated "Lending n/a mayby grant Article of No a right 69 of ofthe use administrative n/a PFI property". of the "Lending Yes Lawrequired (Lending land of of No to administrative administrative the specific private qualifications property". partner property) (Lending Article are regu n/a No n/a n/a comments Yes No are two Primarily, there committees of bid evaluation w n/a Article 17 (2) Pursuant toYes Theofstate the PPP partner Pursuant Law, is obliged theto state Comments Article partner to 17 (2) No isof transfer to the a PPP obliged: private n/a to transfer partner Law, the state No tothe a private rights n/a partner to partner is the obliged: PPP theobject rights to on transfer to the toobject terms a privat o p n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes Section 54 of the PPP Act provide Article 18 of Pursuant toYes MOLIT, the PPP as Law, aPursuant procuringto land is to authority n/a Article be acquired isof 18 No entitled the using PPPthe toLaw, acquire n/a expropriation land is use or No to be the acquired land for n/a procedure using allowed the purpose thefor expropriation public of public entities proced or in infrastru Article 48 of Pursuant toYes The the contract PPP Law, Pursuant the can specify Agreement toComments Article the assistance shall 48 No of specify thethat PPP the the Law, n/a matters Contracting the Agreement considered Yes shall Authority appropriate Pursuant can specify the to provide byArticle matters the to the 19 Parties, Private considered (2.3) includin of Partn the a Yes PPP Law Article 3 of the The provides, Higher Committee Article "The Higher 3 of the shall Committee PPP have Law 0 the shall provides, No have n/a "The the following competency to Higher approve Yes Committee competences: Article requestsshall for6. the have 3 Approving of allocation the PPP following Executive ofrequests the compet land Reg fo neces n/a No n/a Government Comments can provide support in Yes obtaining According to Nothe Regulations licenses, permits, n/a on the Tender Committee f approvals. Yes According to The Article 84(6) of procuring the Investments According to authority Law Comments will Article and assist 84(6) in in Yes concurrence obtaining of the Investments the with Article required establishing 33 of Law Nothe certificates, and a in PPP one-stop-shop Decree concurrence n/alicenses provides with for or permits that investors, establishing "A necessary there tender com a s on No Section 78 of the PPP Law n/aprovidesn/a for the registering Comments No private partner of the n/a in the Yes Land Register for24 Article the ofduration the PPP of Law provide the PPP a Yes According to In case the PPP Law, art. 13(1), expropriation According "contrary tonecessary, is the to any PPP other 0 Law, Yes the art. right text, the 13(2), toPublic According use"<...> the Entity the expropriated to No shall the PPP have expropriated Law, land the n/a art. right shall6,to be properties "<...> put givenat after shallthe be to a the disposal registered private par of Council Yesof the Investments Article 15-2(5) Law In case Obtaining the required provides, of making Comments right <...> ofwhen way. No available forland, carrying asn/a out the activity previously mentioned, Yes The stipulated thequalifications right in the ofgeneral ofgovernment thebe way would includ member a article 37 of Pursuant toYes the PPPthe Granting Law Pursuant right (PPP Law of ton/a article 2015-039 occupation:37 when of on Yes thethe PPP February PPP Law Pursuant 3, contract (PPP 2016), Law to when includes article 2015-039 No the28 occupation PPP of on n/a the contract February PPP ofInstitutional public 3, 2016), includes property, occupation when framework it the impP of Yes Section 33 of The the PPP Act provide: procuring Section Without authority prejudice 33 of Comments assist the PPP to providing in Act the Norights provide: the of the Without right n/a Parties of way prejudice toor agree Yes assist to such the to obtain terms According rights and such ofto thethe right. Parties conditions PPP Act, to ofagree the PP su Section n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes No (JKAS) terms PPP Committee n/a and conditions Financial su article 26 I.When Pursuant toYes PPP of thethe project Pursuant Law, when requires the ton/a article occupation project 26 I.No requires of the of the occupation PPP n/a Law, when procuring of authority's Yes the project domain, procuring Pursuant requires authority's theto contract article occupation domain, 6 implies II. the of the of the contra autho procu PPP n/a No n/a n/a n/a Yes the PPA provides Section 8 ofNo n/a :(1) There is established a Yes Article 45, paragraph VI Itof depends the PPPon Law: theThe Article project 45,tender paragraph Comments and documents will VINo ofdetailed be will the PPPprovide in n/a Law: theThe contracts. for tender II. No documents realprocuring TheThe estate, n/a will assets authority provide might for II. and rights be Theinreal cha necessary Article 8 ofObtaining Pursuant toYes the Concessions the Pursuant required Law, the toComments land Article contracting rights 8 offor Yes thethe Concessions concessionaire. Pursuant authority Law, assigns the to the Noland contracting to Article the 27 n/a (1) concessionaire. of authority the PPP assigns Law, in the the8 Article private- states: land to t Yes According to The regulatory the Concessions art.authorities 21.1.8, Law,According toComments "unless the and Concessions otherwise a No procuring Law, provided authority n/a art. 21.1.8, by are the obliged "unless law and Yes otherwise to provide anAccording agreement, assistance provided to a the by concession Concession in obtaining the law agreem and Proc the a No According to No of the PPP Article 81(3) n/aLaw <...> Comments if the state Yes is the owner of immovable According No to Article property paragraph that is required 37,n/a 1 of the for PPP the executi Law, mem n/a No n/a n/a n/a Yes No Article 10 of n/a states that: the competent a the PPP decree n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes The bid evaluation No n/a committee in Mozambique must inte Yesof PPP Policy: Article 11.9(1) Government Government Article of Nepal 11.9(1) of Nepal Comments shallof make shall PPP make Policy: available Yes available theSection Government required the required of 147 Nepal No land of to the land shall procuring to a Public make a n/a procuring available authority Procurement authority the Rules for required PPP provides projects for land PPP fo to pro Articles 4.2Providing Pursuant toYes access and 5.1 of Pursuant the DBFM to required to Standard n/a Articles land Agreement, 4.2No and 5.1 of thethe Procuring n/a No DBFM Standard Authority Agreement, needs n/a to provide access to the Procuring the lan Authority Yes According to The procuring the PPP Guide, Section According 3.3, entity shall to n/a "prior to the consider the Expression PPP Yes Guide, obtaining Section of Interest the3.3, required According "prior (EOI) to No stage, to the the right PPP ofit Expression way is Guide, n/a also prior assumed Section to ofthe Interest Expression that (EOI) 6.26, "the the procuring overall stage, of Intere ev it n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes No According to of the PPP Regulation, the evalua Article 32 n/a Yes Article 20 of Granting the PPP Law the provides: The Article right contracting of 20way. of n/a the PPP Law party may Noprovides: obtain n/a from the contracting Yes party the competent may Article obtain authority 7aof right from the ofthe PPP Law competent provides occupation of ta the Federal Section 3 ofYes Highways The Ministry Act, Section of Cap. 13 WorksF13, of and Comments LFN, Housing the 2004 ICRC No provides: Act provides Power n/a that "everyYes contractor to acquire Part to land for whom Federal 1, Article highway any3.2 concession (1) of the The PPP Federa has be Polic n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes Article 20 of No n/a the PPP Law stipulates: "the Commission (.. Yes According to TheBidding the Standard Form way shall right ofAccording for BOT, either to n/aSection the Standard be 43.13, No Bidding provided “the by a Bidder procuring n/a Form for shall authority BOT,provide NoPart 1directly statement "General n/a or Conditions all of additional the necessary Concession of land require assistanc Yes Article 24 of the PPP Regulations. The contracting Administrative Article public entity Comments 24 of the actions PPP shallrequired identify No Regulations. the to develop Administrative n/a needs for thepermits, Yes PPP project. licenses actions Article In the and/or required 37.10 feasibility to develop approvals of the the PPP to analysis PPP Law bephase, issue state proje n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes No group isn/a A PPP Steering established under Section 41 of n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes No Article 54 of n/a Law: "Evaluation Committe Decree 4183/20 of the PPP Law: Article 30.3Yes the Article public 30.3 Article of PPP partner 30 law Comments states of the is in PPP charge that Law No to obtain the the n/anecessary public partner No is in charge areasto for project. n/a theMinisterial obtain areas for proj necessary Resolution 16 Yes Section 13.3 (c) of the BOT Obtaining Law IRR the states rightthat: Obtainingof right way Comments Subject is ofmainly way Yes existing the function tomainly laws, the function Section policies, of theof 3.1 government the rules No of theand BOT government, regulations, Law n/a IRR unlessthe the provides: Government alignment "The Head is may of th provp n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a of the PPP n/a Article 7 (4)No n/a Law provides that : "The n/a Contracting NoEntity shall n/a in coordination develop, No n/a with the Project Committee, Article 34 (1)(a) Pursuant toYes Transfer of the thePPP right GEO, Pursuant of to way the Comments Article to the public34(1) partner private No (b) of may partner. the transfer n/a PPP GEO, the Yes forthe public benefit partner of Pursuant the may PPPto company transfer for bythe direct Article 126(2) benefi of traN GD Yes of the PPP Section 3.3.1.1 Theguideline PPP guideline Section provides 3.3.1.1 on provides Comments issues of onthe issues relating PPP Norelating guideline to project n/a toprovides project land: land: For on Noasset issuesbased relating n/a For asset service to project based service delivery land: delivery PPP projects For asset PPP ba projt n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes NoBid Evaluation Section K.2.4. n/a Committees of the Treasury Yes Article 38 of The the PSP Law provides PSP Lawthat enables "1. Article 38 [e]xpropriation ofn/a the PSP Law expropriation and and Noprovides temporary temporary n/a that takeover "1. takeover [e]xpropriation of Yes realestate ofreal Article and are estate temporary are 67 permitted, of Thetakeover Implementing permitted. of real ifnecessary R foe n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 42 of the PPP Decree esta n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes No The PPP Law, doesn't contain any requirement Article 30n/a the PPP Act Section 7 ofYes Obtaining provides the that: Section right 8 (1) A ofof contracting way n/a the PPP Act Yes states the authority Pursuant following: shall to make available "A No Section to 48 the contracting n/a of private authority the PPP partner Act, or other or, (2) as An evaluation appropria public autho n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes No (Establish Section 3.2.40 the Evaluation Team) of the PP n/a No According to 129/1996 Coll. the Act №n/a Comments n/a of the National Council No of the n/a Slovak Republic Yes on Certain Measures According to Public to the Procurem Accelerate the P n/a Yes According If a private party to Comments the is unable toPPP secure Act, No Article the 19, n/a necessary"a rights, public Yes partner a contracting According shall authority assist toshall a private the PPP party assist to a private Act, Article a PPP inp n/a No n/a n/a n/a Yes No Financial The Procurement n/a instructions (Chapter 7 Suppl n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPA, art. 62(1), " Yes According to the PPP standardized A procuringAccording provisions, authority to shall section the Comments provide PPP 3.5, standardized "in thePPPs No ofn/a rightfor way provisions, the performance associated Yes Part A, with section of the According an required 3.5, "into institutional PPPs land the function, for PPP the delivery Manual, performa any of Mo Consea Yes Article 257 of states the LCSP The concessionaire that the Article concessionaire hasof 257 right Comments theto LCSP has "obtain right states Yes from to that "use the Article thepublic administration concessionaire 326 properties NoLCSP of the (bienes has establishes execution n/a right detodominio some "use of the public characteristics público" properties and procedures for of to fo th (b" n/a No n/a n/a n/a Yes No According to n/a on PPPs, Section 234(i), “the the Guidelines Yes According to If of Article 7(e) a contracting the PPP According of theto Actauthority n/a responsibilities Article needs 7(g) acquire of of to Yes thethe a land Supreme PPP Law, Article necessary the 19.1 Council Supreme offor No thefor the PPP Council Public-Private Act n/a provides implementation for Public-Private Partnership that of a "aPPP Bidproject include: Committ an Partnershi " Yes According to the Road Law A contracting (1971: 948), According authorityto §7, "if n/a the shall the Road provide state No a road isLaw the (1971: right holder 948), n/a of way. §7, "if within an the area No with state isa n/a adetailed planwithin road holder wherean area the with municip n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Article 31 (3) Pursuant toYes The the PPP Pursuant ofagreement shall Law, a contracting provide toComments Article for 29all ofNo matters the PPP authority or which Law: other n/aThe governmental agreement Parties deem No necessary, shall bodies, n/a in provide but accordance for definitely all matters include with thethe provi which fo Pa n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes Section 36 n/a Pursuant toNo of the PPP Act, a host agency sha n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes According to Article 5(2) of the PP Yes Article 49 of Law statesIf that the“[…] project public-private involves inPursuant to public Article n/a domain's 24 of No partnershipthe occupation, contracts, PPP Law, n/aassets If the a contract are No distinguished contract implies involves n/a public aninto authorization return assets, domain's to occupy trade-in occupation, ita for n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes According to NoSection 10 of the Public Procurement Regu n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a Yes Article 25 of No 2015-49 PPP Law No. Article ( Law No. comments 25 of 2015-49 n/a PPP Law dated Yes (Law27No. November 2015-49 According 2015to datedrelated No 27 Article toArticle contracts November 25 of n/a2015 related between the PPP toLaw, the contracts public approval and betw t o n/a Yes According A right of way to Comments or a construction the Article right Yes 40 of the may BOT Article be established Implementation 23 of on No behalf the Decree, ofn/a Health the PPPproject Regulations a rightcompany of way statesathat orby thethe Minc construc YesAct is not While the PPP explicit The Minister in In this connection mayrespect, by statutory Comments according with road instrument to No projects, Section declare according 3n/a of the an area Land toYes Section bounded Acquisition by 2 of According the Act imaginary of 1965 RoadstoAct lines PPP (Chapter 1949 parallel Act (Chapter Section 226) to issue and 19( 35d Article 8 (1) Pursuant toYes a land Ifof the PPP lot Pursuant is Law, required in case toComments to Article the implement public-private Yes 8 (1) athe of PPP partnership Pursuant public-private Law, inpartnership, case requires toNo the theResolution the the public-private acquisition n/a public 384:partnership (1) of partner the a private tender shall requires transfer, partner commissio acc of the n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a No n/a Yes The public authority Obtaining can condemnation The exercise the right public of way Comments to for obtain the authority can private No land exercise orpartner condemnation n/a for the No estates to obtain private partner n/a any pursuant in land interests to § 33.2-1814 PPTAor estates fo Yes According to Projects article 59 of the PPP developed Law, According regarding to under Comments article expropriations, a PPP59 of Yes Scheme the are PPP for public the Law, Article purposes regarding projects, 8 of the No ofexpropriations, the PPPas and provisions Law such n/a establishes for one theof article the responsible that purposes 32 for ofeach for ofConstit the the obtai PPP pr pr Yes According to ofpublic Article 31 A the PPP partner Law, According the is obliged to Comments land plot Article to provide on which 14 of the Yes the PPP right object Law, Article of way a public of 24 a associated PPP of Nois partner thelocated PPP with to Law n/a a the andPPP specifies (or) land contract required theis which is membership necessary obliged, for a PPPfor proje crite amongth n/a No n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 56 of Provincial the PPP Law states: Preparation People's Article 56 of of Committees Comments the building PPPshall sites: Yes Law states: assume Provincial Preparation the Article People's prime33 responsibility of of NoDecree building Committees35sites: n/a provides: for, Provincial and shall assume cooperate "1 . An the People's expert prime withCommitt group compete responco According to the PPP Act, Yes A contracting Section 46(1), According authority "a contracting Comments toshall the PPP either authority Act, provide Yes Section orthe other 47, The right "aPPP public contracting ofAct wayNodoesn't itself authority, authority or contain under assist n/a or a the any concessionaire other terms provisions public of anyregarding relevant in obtainin authority, the law und n/a No n/a n/a Comments Yes According to No n/a 18(1), "for each procurem the PPA, Section n/a No n/a n/a Comments No n/a Yes Section 14(a) of the Tender Rules According toNo n/a art. 12(2)(4), the PPP Law, n/a "a [PPP] Comments agreement n/a the following Noshall include No essential n/a terms <...> (4) an obligation o Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q15_C Q16 Q15_3_TEXT Q16_1_TEXT Q16.1 Q17_A Q16.1_1_TEXT Q17_B Q17_1_TEXT evaluation 15. The bid If committee 16. yes, please elaborate Does the members If and procuring yes, provide are please 16.1. authority examples: specify notIf required yes, issue theIf ismeans yes, the to anplease public have invitation of 17. any publication procurement specify Are specific for bids/ theIf and foreignqualifications. website: yes, tender notice companies provide please notice 17. the published provide Requirement subject relevant for online? the the toPPP legal/regulatory any to relevant project? ofhave the legal/regu an offic pr followin Yes Yes provisions The regulatory do not While no specific require Yes provisions http://www.ppu.gov.af/Beta/English/More/CADA.aspx are found bid evaluation committees No in the to PPP n/a meet Law, theNo Public certain requirements. Procurement This The LawNational in Artic would be d No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 24(6) http://app.gov.al/njoftimi-i-kontrat%C3%ABs-s%C3%AB-shpallur/ of the PPP NoLaw and Article n/a 26(3) Noof DCM No. 575/2013, the contra No n/a Yes According to Yes Art. 25 of A the Concession notice No Decree is published on n/a (the procuring Decree No No. 18-199 authority of 20 Dhou Elhttp://aac website: Kaâda 14 Yes Yes The bid evaluation Articles members committee 67 and Yes 117 are not of Angolan required the Public Official Procurement No to meet Gazette: specific Law n/ahttp://www.imprensanacional.gov.ao/ qualifications. state that No the However, public procurement noti the PPP Law in and Yes Yes According to Decree 118/2017 Article 12.8, (Annex, Yes Annex, of Decree Article 12.24) 118/2017 Websitethe of procuring PPP No Unit: authority that n/a aftershall the No setshttps://www.argentina.gob.ar/jefatura/ppp expiration appoint Bid Evaluation of Commis the 30-day term fr Yes Article 26 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the Procurement toYes Article 27 (1) Law, an https://www.mineconomy.am/en of evaluation the Procurement No commission n/a the Law, is formed tender https://procurement.minfin.am/ No by announcement and a decree of the invitation Executive No n/a Yes Yes The National PPP Guidelines The notice is No in Section published 3.5 of Volume in the relevant n/a No procuring 2 provide private sector that theauthority's sho website No n/a Yes According to Yes the Law on According to Nothe Concessions, §22(2), Law onn/a “a procuring No Concessions, authority §33(1), has to announce "a procuring the in authority No n/a Yes Article 5.6 of Pursuant toYes the are There BOT examples Rules, No in of tender n/a announcements accordance with Nothe conditions on the website.in indicated par Such No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Guidelines, Some of the No websites, Section 18.1,where n/a “the Contracting No tender notices Authority are published shall advertise include: - al Yes Article 17 of Pursuant toYes the PPP Article 22 Law: of Yes the To organize Official 1.Regulation onand website Tender conduct No stipulates of the the tender tender, the state No bid evaluation n/athatorganizer. partner One example creates committee would shall be the a commissiop Yes Yes Members of Pursuant the bidding committee toYes article are usuallyOn 42 of the the chosen Concession e-procurement within No the Law, procuring n/a platform: a concession authorities https://enot.publicprocurement.be No noticeand is published external experts. No n/a Yes Yes According to article 17 Dedicated of the PPP website Law, No the http://www.marches-publics.bj/ n/a : procedure No award of partnership for the contrac Official webs No n/a Yes Article 17 (1) Pursuant toYes of the Public Procurement Sarajevo No Portal: PPP Law, n/a https://www.ejn.gov.ba/ the private No partner selection procedure Sarajevo Canton Yes Yes According to According to the PPA Regulations, Yes the PPA Section 40(1), Regulations, Public "the accounting Section Yes Procurement 28(3), officer Regulatory According “a shall pre-qualification appoint Authority to NoSection an (PPRA) evaluation process 76 PPA, ofwebsite, shall committee "except abe section as w openot No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 21 of The Official the Gazette PublicNo Procurement of the n/aLaw (Law Federal Executive No 8.666/1993), uses any the public bid web following mu No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 72 of The the Concession No national concessions Law:(1) n/aThe decision register No in to the case open concessions: ofthe shall a procedurehttps:/ No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 28 of On the the General PPP Law, No the Directorate selection n/a of public of private theNoprocurement partner and is made through financial com No n/a Yes According to Yes article 28 The of the PPP PPP Law, Decree No publicity requires n/aof calls the for public No procurement tenders are made accordingly notice t to be publis Yes Nobeen established No rules have n/a in the No PPP Law. n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes section 17 of Pursuant toYes The PPP PPP Decree Unit No (Decree www.ppp-cameroun.cm website: n/a 2008/0115/PM No. No of January 24, 2008 regu Yes Section 10.5 Pursuant toYes "Selection" Section Yes 10.7.36 of of the Contracting the Official Contracting Federal Policy No , there Government Policy Procurement are n/aprovides, particular Website that, No forof requirements procurements Canada: as to thecovered specific https://buya No n/a Yes Yes Article 16 of the PPP ordinance https://dgmarket.fr/NoticeList/local provides: No n/a the selection the https://www.j360.info/en/tende of No private partner shall be carrie No n/a Yes Yes According to Web article 14.2 of the of the Concessions PPP Unit: Regulations: No n/a Calls No for bids will be published at https://concesiones.mop.gob.cl/Paginas/defa No n/a Yes Yes article 14 PPP guidelines, and 17: Ministry ofaFinance No procurement designated n/anotice should No be published government on ainformati procurement special m Yes Yes According to Numeral 3,of Article 2.2.1.1.2.2.3. Yes Article Decree 1082/2015, 30, Colombia Law Compra aNo 80 of 1993 bid(Public evaluation (Colombia Procurement n/a committee No Law): is not procurement The portal): mandatory. noticehttp://www.colo for Even if a bi the bidding No Yes There are no Articles regulatory requirement 25 and Yesfor 33the bid Public of the evaluation PPP Law Procurement provide Nocommittee Regulation n/a that, toameet as principle, Authority specific No thewebsite: public-private http://www.arm qualifications. partnershi No n/a Yes According to Yes Article 78 Public Public No of the Procurement Procurement Regulation n/a Code, the Nosigning Authority's of the service website: delegatio http://www.arm Yes Yes No legal requirements other Article 17 of than Yes not the having PPP Regulations conflicts Official Gazette: of mandates interest. No https://www.imprentanacional.go.cr/gaceta/ tender n/a process Nowith publication as in accordan No n/a Yes Yes Art. 13 of the PPP Decree https://marchespublics.ci No. 2018-358 No of Marchn/a 29, 2018 Norelating to Public Private Partne No n/a Yes Article 21 of Pursuant toYes the Concession No Act, the https://eojn.nn.hr/Oglasnik/ n/a (national tender No tender notice publication is to be (together publishedwebsite); No n/a Yes Yes According to Procurement the PublicA profile of No a contracting Act, §180(1), n/a authority No in the Public "a contracting Procurement authority Inform shall commence Yes Public Procurement Neither theYes According to Yes Law the norEU the Concessions According EU Directive, to No Concessionsthe Directive EU art. Concessions n/a contain 31(4), provisions Directive, No "contracting art. about authorities 33(2), the required concession aand quali n contract No n/a Yes Article 22.1 Yes of the PPP Law Pursuant toNo articles provides that with 6 and n/a the of the awarding Noof the negotiated 7exception procedure, procedure PPP ( Decree a No n/a Yes Yes Article 39 of Government the PPP Law provides:No Competitive Procurement's n/a website: selection process No of the successful bidder: http://www.comprasdominica No n/a Yes Article 61 of Yes the PPP Regulations https://www.appecuador.gob.ec/ No "[...] The states: No phase begins with the call for n/acontracting No n/a Yes Yes Article 26 of The website the PPP Executive Regulation: No of the PPPn/a Unit: "The https://pppcentralunit.mof.gov.eg No Authority may not publish Administrative No n/a Yes Yes Article 36 of Website PPP Regulation: "Depending of PROESA: No the n/acomplexity, No the nature and magnitude of t onwww.proesa.gob.sv Yes No framework The regulatory No n/a does not require the n/a No committee bid evaluation No to have any specific qualificat n/a members Yes legal requirement There is no Yes for the According Yes to the existence PublicAccording or to a composition Procurement No to Act, the Public §74, of Procurement "to an evaluation n/a NoAct, commence committee. an Chapter open procedure, 1, However, Division any 7, §45 de restricte No n/a Yes Article 35 of Yes the Procurement Public Procurement No Proclamation&provides, Property n/a Administration "1) No Invitation to bid Agency's shall be advertise website: ht Yes Yes The Public Contracts Sections and 58, Concessions Yes 60Act anddoes (within not impose 61 Tenders Electronic No Chapter specific 7) Daily ofqualifications the n/a Public (TED), procurement No a Contracts on the bid andevaluation portal Concessions of the Europea Act set f committee Yes Yes According to Prior Art. L1411-5 the general Yes in of advertising, code accordance ofwould It be with No local public published Article authorities: L. onn/a 2131-1 Bid the evaluation of the european NoPublic websites committees Procurement (http://www.boam Code: of local “In autho Yes Yes No provision regulates Pursuant the qualifications toNo article 18 of the of n/a theevaluation bid PPP Ordinance No committee (Ordinance n/a members No No. 009/PR/2016 of 11 February 20 No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 19 of www.tenders.procurement.gov.ge Resolution NoNo. 426:1.n/a For the purpose No of announcing the selection Yes explicit provision There is no Yes for the According to Yes the requirement Concessions - the to form Ordinance, portal No "service.bund.de a separate §19(1), evaluation n/a"a concession team No orgrantor - Verwaltung Online a committee, shall " is theneither centralized announce cer its i No n/a Yes Yes Section 39 of the PPP Act, Ministry of Finance's Yes regarding RequestPPP for Section qualification, Portal: 44 of Nothe http://ppp.mofep.gov.gh/ provides: Public Procurement contra "39. (1) The Law pr No n/a Yes The PPP Law Yes in Article 9(2)(b) sets No Government the Procurement principles n/a Portal that areof to No Greece: www.eprocurement.go be upheld with regards to PPP No n/a Yes Yes According to of the PPP Article 45 ANADIE's website: Law No ANADIE https://anadie.gob.gt//; must publish n/a State Contracting No the procurement twoPr noticeand t No n/a Yes Yes Article 13 of Onprovides the PPP Law the Public No that Procurement n/a agency's PPP procurement rules No are based website: on the principles http://www.armpguin No n/a Yes Article 69 of Yes the PP Law indicates On the the National No concessions Commission n/a are on Public No to subject Procurement's article 39 of the samecnm website: Law Yes Yescommittees Bid evaluation are Article not 16 of Yes regulated the PPP Regulatory The PPP neither Superintendence's by the NoPPP Decree establishes Law nor n/a its that Regulation. the websiteNo notice (SAAP): However, of https://sapp.gob.hn/ bid public evaluation tender an or pubc No n/a Yes Yes According to EU of Article 37(6) (TED): the Public http://ted.europa.eu No Procurement n/a Act <...>, No contracting National authorities Website (Public shall Procuremen Yes Yesevaluation Generally, bid committees Rule theare 159 of Yes General constituted The Financial CentralRules, No Public of concerned 2017 Procurement ministers requires n/a all Portal and No the high Ministries/Departments ofranking Government of India facili administrative offic of th No n/a Yes According to Yes the Attachment A public the NoLKPP tonotice willRegulation be published n/a 29/2018, No on Chapter a website ofII, the relevant B (1), Respo the Procure No n/a Yes Yes Private Sector Article 2 of the The National Participation NoTenders database: n/aprovides Order No that - the investor shall be selec https://www.parsnamaddata.com/ No n/a Yes Yes According to Republic Article 4 (3)(a) of the of No Public Iraq Ministry n/a of Planning: Contracts Notender Law, the notice shall be publishe https://mop.gov.iq/ Yes Yes While it is expected Regulation that members30Yes of of the evaluation EU Irish Government's committee Concession No state 2017 will electronic asbe follows: n/acompetent "Concession Noandplatform: tendering comprised notices: www.etenders.ie of 30. personnel (1) A contr wi No n/a Yes Yes Section 15 (a) of the Mandatory Accountant Tenders No General website: n/a provides Regulation No that, "Where a Ministry has e https://mof.gov.il/AG/Pages/Account No n/a Yes Yes According to The Articles 71, 72Procuring and 73No ofAuthority's n/a the Public website.ANAC: No Contracts the public procurement n Code,https://www.anticorruzion No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Policy, The legal Section No6.0.1(3), "the requirement for n/aan Project onlineTeam publication No will <…> only issue exists RfPthe the for co <…>" No n/a Yes Yes Article 8, Paragraph 1 of The Act requires PFInotice No is published to select online n/a theby private each No different operator procuring authority by invitation. Accor No n/a Yes Yes According to Articles 14(B) The and website No 17(A) the ofof the procuring PPP n/a entity No Regulation, publication and the PPP Unit. is made The PPP by Unit' the Pub Yes Yes Generally, legislation Pursuant of Kazakhstan toYes Article does not 36 provide Website of any varies the PPP No Law, specific depending <...>requirements information procuring for No n/aon theon the members holding a tender authority of (i.e., the bid tender (auction) to ide evaluor No n/a Yes Yes Section 46 (1) of the PPP The procuring Act provides No authority's that a contracting n/awebsite, No e.g. Ministry authority shall, of Transport, on Infrast the approval of Yes Yes According to Article 13 According (2) of the Act to Yeson PPP Article 70 inWebsites Infrastructure, (4) ofNo of 2016 competent PPP the Basic competent Plan, n/a authority, pursuant e.g. NotoMinistry Article authority shall designate 10 ofof Transport: one of http:// the Decree, the the No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 43 of www.pppkosova.org the PPP Law: No 1. The Public No shall submit to the PPP Depar n/a Authority No n/a Yes of the PPP Law Article 8(2) Yes KAPPprovides, website: No http://www.kapp.gov.kw/en/Home "The n/a shall announce Authority No the projects approved No n/a Yes Article 12 of Pursuant toYes www.mineconom.gov.kg; the PPP Law: No 1. At then/awww.ppp.gov.kg stage No of qualification selection, the authoriz No n/a Yes No Article 29 of the PPP Decree n/a provides n/a Office No No that "[...]The of Public-Private Partnership shal No n/a Yes Yes Article 19(1) Law provides, of the PPPProcurementNoMonitoring <...> then/a Bureau; www.iub.gov.lv; Concession Procedure Commission No Electron Tenders shall pro No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Law, Theart. High Council No 7(1), "the for process n/a Privatization for the selection and No PPP of website: http://www.hcp the Private Partner sha No n/a Yes Yes Article 23 of the Concessions https://cvpp.eviesiejipirkimai.lt/notice; Law regulates No communication alln/a between No also the procuring auth on https://ted.europa.e No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes article 17 of PPP the PPP Law, Unit's No every website (to competitive be n/acreated)dialogue but also is No on the procuring preceded author by a notice e No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Act, One of the 45: Section No"45.__(1) places wheren/a An tender notices No are advertisement for posted a PPP is project procure the PPP Comm No n/a Yes Yes PPP Malaysia's Government Procurement Unit Website: No Regime www.ukas.gov.my, n/a in section state 4.3 state that in ensuring No MyPROCUREMENT fairn portal: ht No n/a Yes Yes Article 16 of Onsets the PPP Law the the WAEMU principle No website n/a http://www.uemoa.int/fr/appels-doffres of publication, article 7 and 8 of the PPP Decree No No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes section 16 http://publicprocurement.govmu.org/Pages/default.aspx (1) of the PPA, No where the n/a No open advertised bidding method is used, t Yes bid evaluation There is no Yes tender Yes Thecommittee, notice the published: Compranet isprocuring (i) on No authority (public the evaluates procuring procurement n/a the bids. portal): No authority's The website; PPP https://compranet.haciend Law (ii) doesonnot thespecifical Federal O No n/a Yes Article 5 (2) Pursuant toYes of the Monitor: Official PPPNo Law, http://monitorul.md/ the public n/a partner shall No provide ; Public Property publishing Agency: news re htt No n/a Yes According to Yes the Concessions The tender notices art. 12.2, Law,No are"the n/a usually published No on announcement contracting ofathe authority tender may be pub No n/a Yes According to Yes article 49,According paragraphto No 1 the of the Concessions PPPn/a Law stipulates Article Law, No that21(2), the public for the open proced invitation for No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 3 al.The 2 ofpublic procurement the PPPNo Law and Articles n/a notice11 and No 12 of the is published PPPpublic on the procurem Decree, the pro No n/a Yes Yes Article 33 of Decree No. http://www.concursos.co.mz 05/2016 provides No that n/a the procuring No authority issues a public proc No n/a Yes section 7(3) Pursuant toYes of the Public Pursuant toNo section Procurement 14 n/a (2) ofAct, Public the a No Procurement Public Act, the notice Entity shall establish a proc Yes Yes Act does The Procurement not set Pursuant any toYes Article specific 2.62 qualifications of the The Procurement official No Government for bidAct: evaluation n/a of The contracting committee No tender 1 Netherlands authority members. portalwhich at Inwww.tend intends case law, No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Guide, Section No The Government4.11, Electronic "then/a procuring entity No Tenders is required Service https://www.ge (GETS): to publish the in No n/a Yes Yes Article 21 of the PPP Regulation http://pronicaragua.gob.ni/en/; details No the content n/a of the No notice and provides it shall be pu http://www.nicaraguacompra.gob. No n/a Yes No Article 32 of the PPP Law n/a provides No n/a : the pre-qualification No procedure shall be conducted by No n/a Yes the ICRC Act Section 4 ofYes provides Bureau of Public that No upon Procurement n/a approval of aNo project website: or contract, the Federal www.bpp.gov.ng No n/a Yes Article 42 of Pursuant toYes the PP Online System Law, Nothe contracting n/a of Public authority No https://e-nabavki.gov.mk/Pu Procurement: shall make the tender docum Yes explicit regulation There is no Yes According related to Yes the a bid evaluation to Public Procurement The Public Procurement committee Yes Rules, 2004, or According Regulatory commission. to Section No 12(2), Authority's the Public "All procurement website: https://ww Procurement Rules, 2 opportu No n/a Yes Article 37.1Yes of the PPP Law Website of the states: No "Due governing noticen/abody shall made Norector): be(ente through publication in the ele https://enterector.gob No n/a Yes Section 68 n/a Pursuant toNo of the Procurement No n/a Act: No (5)Procurements undertaken by the Commi No n/a Yes Yes Article 22 of National PPP Law: "Article 22 Information - No Call. The call n/afor interested System No Procurement: on Public https://www. parties to participate in the c Yes Yes PPP Law Article 7 of the According foresee the to Yes article establishment of the ofPPP 54 Proinversion Special Regulations, Nowebsite: Committees http://www.proyectosapp.pe/default.aspx the request n/a No to support for the proposals ("convocatoria") activities of the relevantm No n/a Yes Section 5.2 Yes of the BOT Law www.ppp.gov.ph IRR: The Yes Headand of the the Executive Agency/LGU concerned NoAgency/LGU's concerned Order No. 65 or shall, the website, Foreign after obtaini availa ifInvest Yes Yes are silent The regulations when it Pursuant to Yes comes Article to ofThe 5 the qualifications the PPP Act No (...), e-Procurementofthe the platform bid n/aevaluation public https://ezamowienia.gov.pl/pl/ entity, No following committee the (komisja przetargow publication The of Bu the a Yes the Article Pursuant Pursuant toYes toYes Article 67 (3) of Public Contracts 131TED of Code Public (Tenders Contracts 18, the NoElectronic bid evaluation Code n/a Daily), 18, thecommittee notice the online No shall version members be published of PPP of the in contrac the Of 'Supplemen Yes Yes PPP Law Article 6 of the provides Article the 8 ofthat: Yes PPP "A committee LawItprovides: is usually"The shallpublished be formed No Contracting on n/a for each the procuring Project No shall, Authority authority's on ain case-by-case coordination website. with This bas basis, the web No n/a Yes Article 7 ofSEAP Pursuant toYes the Public (Electronic Procurement No Procurement n/a Law: (1) The No contracting System): authority has an o https://www.e-licitatie.ro/p Yes Yes The bid evaluation committee Pursuant is to usually article Yes 16 of composed www.rdb.rw the of PPP Law, No The Contracting representatives from the n/a Authority Government No requests for expressions authorities that overo No n/a Yes of the Treasury Section A.1 Yes Instructions Ministry of Finance's No regarding tender n/a Advertisement No advertisement page: and https://www.mof Notification provides No n/a Yes Article 71 of Yes The Implementing The means of Nopublication Regulations of n/a the include the PSP Law sets No website out the of process for issuing the procuring autho No n/a Yes Yes Article 57 of Senegal PPP Decree provides Government for No the issuance n/a of a public Procurement Portal: No https://www.marchespu procurement notice of the PP No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Law, Website of22, Article the No"the contracting procedure n/a authority No will depend of awarding on the a PPP public transaction contract with No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Section 37 Procuring of the Public authorities' No websites Procurement n/a Act, 37. also(1) the No Public website procurement of National Public shall u be P No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes section 3.2.22 Government No Electronic of the PPP Handbook, n/a Business (GeBiz) a Tender Notice No (incorporating portal Notice of P https://www.gebiz.g No n/a Yes Yes According to Procurement the PublicOnline Bulleting NoAct, of §26 the Public (1), forProcurement n/a No Office: non-exceptional https://www.uvo concessions, "the co No n/a Yes According to Yes the Concessions According Article No Act,to the Concessions 28, "a n/a Act, Article procedure for the No 33, selection of a concession "the notices referred t No n/a Yes Section 4.2 Yes of the Procurement The Ministry Noof Finance Manual provides, n/a & TreasuryNo website, "The Tender section devoted Advertisement togive must be pub No n/a Yes Yes According to Certain the PPA, art. 144(1), tender “upon No notices approval n/a available are No of the concession at the global bid documents, the Pr tender websites, su No n/a Yes According to Yes the Treasury The government No section Regulation, of South 16 n/aAfrica’s A.6.3, eTenderPublication No the accounting authority portal: must ensu http:/ No n/a Yes Yes Article 134 of the LCSP Public (Previous Procurement announcement) No n/a states Portal: that No the procuring authority can p https://contrataciondelestado.es/wps/p No n/a Yes According to Yes the Guidelines The websiteNo will on PPPs, Section vary depending 249, n/a "the Secretary, onNo a project. Taking Ministry of into Finance account and P th No n/a Yes According to Yes Article 20 Some of theof the PPP No Act, websites, "[t]he where n/a tender No announcement notices of the are invitation to compete published include:- Yes Public Procurement Neither theYes According to Act Yes the nor Concessions the Concessions According Act Chapter No Act,to the contain Concessions 8, §1, any n/a"a provisions Act, Chapter No regarding contracting 10, §1, authority qualifications "a or contracting or me aut a contracting e Yes Yes Nothing is provided Pursuant in the Law. toYes article 18 of www.simap.ch Noeach contract the PP Law, No to a separate call for tenders. n/a is subject Yes Article 19 (1) Pursuant toYes According of the PPP to Yes Section Law, a contracting www.ppp.tjNo 79 authority of Resolution No. 81, shall the n/a announcement establish No an evaluation of the tender willto committee be pub evalu Yes Yes The law does Section not address the qualifications 15 (1) Yes Act of PPPof the states Tanzania bid evaluation that National Noall PPPcommittee projects n/a should e-Procurement members. System No (TANePS) be procured at:open in an and com https://www No n/a Yes Since there Yes is no notification The notice enforced No be will under published the n/aPPP on the act No and website the notification of the relevant procurin under the pre No n/a Yes Yeswith Article In Accordance www.mof.gov.tl; 6(2) of the No PPP Law, n/a Article 61 No of the Procurement Regime prov www.cna.gov.tl/en/current-tenders/ Yes Yes Article 22 of the PPP Regulation Pursuant provides toYes Articlethat https://www.j360.info/en/tenders/afrique/togo/ an ad 25 and 33hoc of the commission No is n/a PPP Law as in charge well as Article No of evaluating PPP without 16 of thebids menti Decree provid No n/a Yes Yes ) of the Section Section 38(1)(c 38(1)(c No ) of the Public Procurement Regulations n/a Public Procurement No provides, Regulations "(1) provides, The notice "( of invitati Yes PPP-related The existingNo regulations n/a No n/a specificYes don't contain details about According the membership No to orart. the PPA, 28(1), "a procuring qualifications of the m No n/a Yes Pertaining to Yes Article 10On of Decree No. No 2016-772 the concerned procuring n/a of 20 June No2016, authority's official about the conditions website and (depending No n/a Yes Yes According to of the Article 25 The records Health No of theRegulation PPP n/aGazette Official regarding No are available tenderhttps://www the openonline. procureme No n/a Yes Yes According to Section 31 of the PPP Websites ofNo Act, the procuring direct invitation n/a authorities, tender toNo or call including for expression (Ministry of i of Works No n/a Yes Yes for potential The information http://www.kmu.gov.ua/ bidders No about the n/a tender should No be posted on http://www.dzo.com.ua/ the website of https://prozorro. Yes Yes Article 11 of the Dubai Article PPP Law provides, 15 Yes of the Dubai "a. An Article PPP Law15 internal of committee No provides, the Dubai "Subject named n/a PPP Law paragraph provides, tothe No (c) "Subject "PartnershipofCommittee" Article to paragraph (14) of will be (c) this fo Lao Yes Yes does not The framework require specific Regulations 31 and Yes qualifications 33 of Regulationthat CCR 2016 No state: 34 the of the bid "Concession CCR evaluation n/a 2016 —(1) committee NoContracting notices 31(1) members Contracting authorities must meet. and util authoritieH Yes Yes No specific provisions. Pursuant In practice, tothe Yes section committee The 4.2.1 is of the PPP comprised Department Implementation No of technical of n/a Virginia's Manual Department and No financial experts, Guidelinesof experts, Transportation for the and PPTA, a procu we the R No n/a Yes According to Yes Articles 15 and 21 of the Government NoPublic PPP Regulatory n/a Decree, Procurement No when website: the procuring entity in https://www.comprasest No n/a Yes According to Yes Article 21 The of the PPP Law, tender No notifications the procedure n/a are published both for No one on both and two-stage the tenderso official website Yes Yes According to Section Section 11a of the8Government ofYes the Government Tenders The website Act, No "(2) Tenders the ofAct In addition provides Central n/a Tender that: to (2) No Board: subsection The Minister, (1), https://ctb.gov.vu/index.p the Director the functions Gene of the Ce No n/a Yes Article 9 of the Yes PPP Law: "Transparency Ministry No and and of Planning disclosure n/a Investment No National Bidding of information System about PPP (Vietn investmen No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Act, The publication Section Yes means 22(4), According "the invitation and the website for to submission No Public the will varyProcurement of depending expressionsAct, on a tra of Sec int No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPA, Section The publication 37, "aNoprocuring means n/a and entity the website shall invite No will bids-(a) vary depending through the public on a tra No n/a Yes Yes Regarding construction Ministry tendering, of Transport's No for purchaseswebsite: n/a https://www.motc.gov.mm No exceeding MMK 100 Million ( and services Yes Yes According to According the PPP Law, to art. 22(1), Yes the "to PPP Law, The conduct a official tender, art. 19(4)(1), No website a public "a tender partner of n/aRussian the held in is createsYes Federation accordance a tender commission. for posting with informatio The num a decision on t Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q17_C Q17_2_TEXT Q17_D Q17_3_TEXT Q17_4_TEXT Q17_E Q18 Q17_5_TEXT Q18_3_TEXT 17. If yes, please Requirement provide If yes, the relevant to please form legal/regulatory 17.aRequirement joint venture provide If yes, the relevant provisions: to with please have legal/regulatory 17. specify prior domestic Threshold experience and firm(s) If yes, provide provisions: to for please be public in the allowed 18. tenders country relevant Doesto specify and to the bid to If legal/regulatory beyes, bid provide in procuring open the in please public for the the authority public foreign provide relevant tender. provisions: tender. participation grant legal/regu the the p relevan n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 31, Section 2 of the 2015 P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 22 (4) of The P n/a Yes No According to the Art. 38 n/a of the Public No Procurement For the achievement n/a code, No n/a of its objectives, the co n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Public Procurem n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 8, Article 12, Annex I of D n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 20(2) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Law on Concess n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The period of time for submission n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPP Guidelines, paragraph n/a Pursuant toNo 22 of the PPP 4 of Article No n/a No company Law, if foreign n/a is recognized Yes as the winner of Pursuant paragraph tothe process, bidding 26 of theit n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 47 of the Con n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to article 33 of the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 40 (1) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPA Regulations n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Specifically to PPP, Resolution no n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 93 of the Con n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 32 and 42 of the PPP Decr n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 8 of the PPP Decree requi n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Articles 17 and artic n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The minimum period of time for n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes If the procurement of the PPP pr n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The minimum legal period is not n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 34 of the PPP Law provide n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 78 of the Pub n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 42 of the General Procure n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 12 of the PPP Decree state n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 42 of the Concession Act e n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Public Procurem n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the EU Concessions n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 6 of the PPP awarding pro n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 49 in its paragraph II of th n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Article 36 of PPP Law establis n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Public Procurem n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Procurement Proclamation Articl n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Section 120 of the Pu n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article R.2161-14 of the Public Ac n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 19 of Resoluti n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Concessions Ord n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 44 (2) (i) and (l) indicates n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 43(3) of the C n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 46 of the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 13 of the PPP Law provide n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to article 69 of the PP L n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 16 of the General Regulat n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 8 of the Conc n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Rule 161 (v) of the General Finan n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 15 of the Tenders Law pro n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 39(3, 4) EU Concession 20 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Ministry of Finance Internal Orde n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Simplifications Decree (Decre n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Procurement Ha n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 38 (2) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to article 70 (2) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 26 (2) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 23 of the PPP Executive Re n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 12(2) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 11(2) of the Procurement n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 39 of the PPP Law provide n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPP Law, art. 7( n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Applications to participate in the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 22 of the PPP Decree (Dec n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to article 12 II. of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 26(2) of the PPR provides n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The PPP Law on article 51 establi n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 18 of the Con n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Concessions Law n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Concessions Law n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 12(4) of the PPP Decree se n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 53 (1) of the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to section 14 (4) of the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 2a.36 located n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPP Guide, Secti n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to article 30 of the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes For prequalification, article 32 of n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 25 (2) of the Public Procu n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes In an open procedure, the minim n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Public Procurem n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 37.1 of the PPP Law states n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 46 of Decree 4183/20: "Pu n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes This is usually Norequired n/a where there No n/a requirement is a nationality Yes under Section Philippine 5.3 of the law. BOT For Law IRR: example, T the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 31(3) of the C n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to article 63(1) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes This period must be specified in t n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Articles 54 (open ten n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to section K.5.3 of the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 79 paragraph 5 of the Imp n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 26 of Yes the PPP Law provides Article PPP“[…]Public-privat 60 ofthat Decree provides n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPP Law, art. 20 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 24 of the Public Procurem n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 22 of the GPR establishes n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Public Procurem n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Concessions Act n/a No n/a No No No No Yes Section 4.2 of the Procurement M n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPA, art. 73, "in n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Treasury Regula n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to article 136 of the LC n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Guidelines on P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 20.4 of the PPP Act provid n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Concessions Act n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to article 19 of the PP O n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Section 80 of Resolut n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Public Procurement Regulations p n/a No n/a No No No No Yes Clause 6 of the Details of Invitatio n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 20 of the PPP Decree prov n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 39(3) of the Public Procu n/a No n/a No No No No No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 10 of Decree No. 2016-77 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 25 of the Hea n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to section 24 of resolu n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Regulation 39 of the CCR 2016 pr n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Section 4.2.1 of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 21 of Decree No. 17/012: n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 21 of the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 31.6 of Decree 35/2021/N n/a Yes According toNo Procurement the Publicn/a NoAct, Section n/a 39 (6), ifYes an open international According to the PPP bidding Act, Section method is use n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Procurement Re n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Section 10 (b) of the No According to n/aart, 3(5), the PPP Law, No"a private partner n/a Russian legal is a No n/aentity withYes which a [PPP] agreement According to thehas PPP Law, been art. 23 conclud Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q19#1_1_AQ19#1_1_BQ19#2_1_1Q19#1_2_AQ19#1_2_BQ19#2_2_1Q19#1_3_AQ19#1_3_B Q18_4_TEXT 19. and the time calendar inWhat Default are days: the procurement Relevant procedures 19.2. Competitive available Default legal/regulatory and/or provision tendering/bidding Relevant set as default legal/regulatory 19.3. withMulti-stage for PPPDefault pre-qualification contracts? provision tendering/bidding 19.1. stageOpen (Restricted (with ten sh competit 30 No No n/a No Yes of the PPP Law Article 3(9) No No defines the Partnership Tend 30 Yes No Article 22(3) Pursuant toYes No of the PPP Pursuant Law, in the toNo award 22 Article (3) Noof the PPP concessions/partne of private-public Law, in the award o n/a Yes No According to Yes Art. 42 of No the Presidential Decree, According to Yes tenders Art. 8 of the No Concession (national and / or Decree International) ( Decree N ma 20 Yes No Article 14.1Yes of the PPP Law No refers to Article 14.1No the Publicof Procurement the PPP Law No Law on to refers the this PublicArticles matter. Procurem5( 60 No Yes No Article 12 of PPP Law states No the selection n/a Yes of the No contractor must be through a public tende 40 Yes No Article 18 (2) Pursuant toYes Pursuant toLaw: Noof the Procurement Article No "Tender 19 of Nothe Procurements types Law: are open and 1. The closed. c Clos n/a No No n/a No Yes (Short-list Bidders) Section 4.5 No Yes of National PPP Guideline 30 Yes No According to Yes the Law on No According Concessions, §22(1),to "a No procuring the Law onNo authority Concessions, may§22(1), "a procuri freely design the 63 Yes No Yes authority The competent Depending Nocan choose open tendering on No the investment No allproject between specifications, the companies-candidates as 42 Yes No According to Yes the PPP Guidelines, No According Section 21.2, to No "the PPP Guidelines, No the bidding process for Section PPP Projects 21.2, "the bidd can eit 42 No No n/a Yes No Article 19 of Pursuant toNo Nothe PPP Law:1. The competition 30 Yes No Pursuant toYes art. 38 of the NoConcession Pursuant toNo Law, the adjudicator art. 38 of the No freely organizes Concession the Law, bid the protest i adjudicato 63 No No n/a No Yes Yes Article 18 of No that the award procedure fo PPP Law states 45 Yes No Yes An open procedure No of the available is one A restricted procedures No procedure No is one for PPPs. of the available Pursuant procedure to Article 25 of th 42 No Yes Yes According to the PPA Regulations, No According Section to No 55(1),the "except as Noprovided PPA, Section 52:(1) for procuring Ain entity m these Regulation 100 No Yes Yes Article 10 of No PPP Law establishes According "the procurement to Yes article a public-private of 12 of the PPP Law No the competitive partnership p will be p 30 Yes No Pursuant toYes Article 52 of No Pursuant the Concession to Law: (1) No Article 53(2) No A concessionaire of the for Concession concessions the com Law,above th 45 No No n/a No Yes Yes Article 29 of No provides that “the selection the PPP Decree 90 No No n/a Yes No No Article 17 of Noindicates: the procurement of the PPP Law n/a No Yes No Article 18 of the PPP Law Noprovides:n/a No of Private "the selection NoPartner for the solicited projec 20 No No n/a Yes No Law 2006-012: Article 9 ofNo Yes (1) The selection of the contr 15 Yes No the Government Section 7 ofYes No Contracting FederalRegulation Contracting Yes provides, Policy No 10.7.20 provides, "A contracting "Pre-qualific authority sha n/a No No n/a No Yes Yes Article 16 of No the PPP ordinance provides: The selection o n/a Yes No According to Yes Article 3. b) No Article 6 bis of the Concessions Law, No of the selection No of the the Concessions establishes Lawbid is made awardeethat the 20 Yes No The Ministry Yes of Finance's Article NoNotice on Issuing 5 the of PPP Yes Administrative No Measures Procurement for 2014 and Government article 13 of theP 14 Yes No Article 2 of Law Yes 1150/2007 No states that Article one of 10 of the No available the No PPPs Lawpossibilities states thatfor forthe PPP projectsof selection re 45 No No n/a No Yes Yes Article 25 of Noprovides: the public-private pa the PPP Law 45 No No n/a No Yes Article 79 of Pursuant toYes Nothe Public Procurement Code: a 21 Yes No Article 17 of Yes the PPP Regulations No According refers to the toGeneral article 53 No Public No of the Procurement Law that regula General Procurement Law 45 No Yes Yes 14 of Decree Articles 13 and Art. 16 and No No. 2018-358 Yes of March 17 of Decree 29, 2018 NoNo. 2018-358 relating of March to Public 29,Par Private 201 30 Yes No Yes Article 85 of the Public No Procurement Article 85 of No Act: Publicthe Procurement Procurement Public No Act Procedures lists the within meani thevarious 30 Yes No According to Yes the PublicNo Procurement Act, §174(1), According No to the"a PublicNo Procurement contracting Act, authority shall §174(1), "a co proceed in 30 Yes No Yes According to No of the Public section 55(2) According Procurement to No Act, section 55(2) No "the ofprocurement process must the Public Procurement Ac 60 Yes No article 20.1No Pursuant toYes of the PPP Article Law (the of No 21PPP Law the PPP No. 2017-186 Yes Law (the PPP of Law 29 May No. 2017 on pub 2017-186 of 45 Yes No Yes Article 16.1) No that allows of Law 340-06 for15 Article open (3) No tendering. of No Law 340-06 It states: statesOpen that an administrativ tender: It is the n/a No Yes Article 12 of Yes the PPP Law Nostates that the selection Article No 64 of theof PPP Regulations the No private partner (Executive made throu will beDecree 1190 n/a No Yes Yes Article 19 of Noprovides,Article the PPP Law "The PPP 20 of project No contact the PPP Noparagraph Law selection is 2 subject (1) indicates to the prin that 14 No Yes Article 39 of Yes PPP Law: "the No tendering processes, Article No 35 of PPP without exception, No tendering Law:"the will process be public can and inter have an n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No 30 Yes No Yes According to the PublicNo Procurement According to No Act, §48(1), the "the PublicNo Procurement contracting authority Act, or §48(1), entity is req “the co 45 Yes No Article 19 of No Yes the PPP Proclamation provides: Article 19 of Except Yes the PPP Proclamation No as otherwise provided provides: for under Except as Pr this o 30 Yes No Yes According to Section 118 No(specifically According to No applicableSection to Concessions) 118 Noof the the Act ofPublic on Public Contracts Contr and Con 30 Yes No Article L2124-2 Yes of the Public No Acquisition Article L2124-2 Code No provides of the forNo an open Public Acquisition or restricted Code call for ten provides f n/a No No n/a Yes No No Article 20 of No provides that procurement p the Ordinance 30 No Yes Article 17 of Pursuant toNo Nothe PPP Law: n/a1. The selection Yes concessionaire shall be carried o of aNo 30 Yes No Yes According to No the Concessions According Ordinance, §12(1), to Yes "a Concessions the No grantor concession may §12(1), Ordinance, "a conc freely structure 42 No Yes Yes Section 38 of the PPP Act Noprovides Section procurement Yes that the38(4) of the PPP process No for public Act provides that the public private priv partner 30 Yes No Yes Article 11 of the PPP Law Nostates that Article 11 of No the procurement the PPP procedures Nostates may Law the that be procurement either pr Open proc 60 No Yes Yes Article 40 et PPP Law regulate seq. of theNo Article 60 theof tendering Nothe PPP Law Noprovides process for the required prequalificatio them to always b 63 No No n/a No Yes Yes Article 14 of Nospecifies: PPPs can be passed ( the PPP Law 45 No No n/a No Yes article 119 No Pursuant toYes of the PP Decree, public service c 15 No No n/a No Yes Article 22 of No No the PPP Regulations states: Prior to the sub 60 Yes No Yes According to Section 81No of the Public Procurement According Yes to Article Act:8 An No 1.of the open Concession procedure is 1. Act: The publi a one-stage 45 Yes No Yes According to No Rule 158 of Procurement the General FinancialYes Rules, of a PPP includes Noin cases Except covered under a shortlisting Rule 15 of bidders a n/a No No n/a No Yes Yes According to No the LKPP Regulation 29/2018, art. 12 (1), "i 30 Yes No Article 11 of Yes the Tenders No Article Law provides: c) 12 In big ofNo procurement, the No Tenders Law one of the following provides method on- Prequalificatio n/a Yes No According to Yes article 3 of No According the instructions on execution to Yes article of public 3 ofNo the instructions contracts (2014), on the executio the procu 30 Yes No of PPP Guidelines Section 9.2 Yes No Article states: Procurement: 26 of No The projects No 2016: EU Regulations should (1)be When procured in anpu awarding o 40 Yes No Yes Tenders The Mandatory No The Regulation in Section Mandatory No 17B Tenders No provides that, "The in Regulation Section Tenders 17B provid Committee 30 Yes No Yes According to Article 59 No (1) of the Italian According Public toContracts article 61 No Code: No (1) of"1. the Public In the award Contracts of public Code : co 30 Yes No According to Yes the Procurement No According Handbook, Volume to Nothe2, Procurement Section No 1.1.3.1(A), Handbook, Volume 2,opti "the following Sec n/a Yes No Yes (ii) of the Section 4-1-(11) No Process Guideline Selective Bidding set No with prequalification No for the selection the methods of theunder is allowed privat n/a No No n/a No Yes No process The procurement No by default is the restricted ten 60 Yes No Article 31(1) Pursuant toNo No of the PPP n/a Yes partner Law, the private Noshall be identified by the follow n/a No No n/a No Yes No Section 45 of Nostates as follows: "45. Restricte the PPP Act 90 No Yes Open competitive Yes tendering No is the Pursuant toNo Article general default procedure 76 of No according the toPlans, PPP Basic article(1) 10If of the the co 20 Yes No Article 33 (1) Pursuant toNo Yes Pursuant of the Public Procurement toNo Article 26 of Law, unless Nothe PPP a provision Law:1. After the PPPC of Articles 34 h 90 No No n/a No Yes Yes Article 14 of No the PPP Executive Regulations under "Invita 30 No No n/a No Yes Article 11 of Pursuant toNo Nothe PPP Law, <...> 1. the selecti 45 No Yes Yes Article 10 of the Procurement No provides, Law Article of 16 "Procurement Yes the Procurement No methods provides: Lawmay "The follow: case ƒPublic o bid 30 Yes No Yes Article 17(1) of the PPPNo Law enumerates Articlethe different No 17(1) of the PPP modes Law No of enumerates procurement, the<...> in orde different m 30 No No n/a No Yes No According to No art. 7(2), "the process for sele the PPP Law, 30 Yes No No Article 47 of the Concessions Yes Law provides The main procedure No that the granting forNo awarding concessions authority includes publishes the concea 40 Yes No Article 16 of Yes the PPP Law No(Law 2015-039 16February Articleon of Yes the PPP 3,Law No(Law 2016) 2015-039 indicates on February 3 procedures pr to 3, n/a No No n/a No Yes No provides The PPP Manual No a description of the full PPP pr n/a No Yes Section 2.2 No (d) of Malaysia's No Government n/a Procurement No No provides as a procurement Regime 45 No No n/a No Yes article 13 of Pursuant toYes Nothe PPP Law : I- A public-private 30 Yes No section 15 of Pursuant toNo Yes Pursuant the PPA: (1) Subject toto Yes section subsection No 15 of (2), the the PPA: (1) Subject choice to subsect of procurement 28 Yes No Chapter four Yes of the PPP No According Law and Chapter to four No Section subsection Two Noofof V Article the Regulation 68 of the of the PPP Regul PPP Law 30 Yes No Yes Section 33 of Government No Resolution No 476 Section 144provides, No of Government No award "The procedure Resolution shall No 476 be cho provides 60 No No n/a No Yes Yes Procedure The Concession No establishes that a pre-qualific 30 Yes No Yes According to Public Procurement No According Law, 51, No Article to Public public procurement No Procurement Law, procedures Article 51, are: 1) op public p 40 Yes No According to Yes Article 4 of No According toNo PPP Law, public-privateArticle partnership No 4 of contracts PPP shall be awarded Law, public-private un partner 21 No Yes According to Yes Article 13(1) No of the PPP Law: The According toYes general Article legal No 13(2) of the PPP regime for the Law and Articleof contracting P 13( 45 No No n/a No Yes Yes Section 11.7 Policy outlines a step-by-step te of the PPPNo 30 Yes No of the Public Article 2.26 Yes No Article Procurement Act2.27 delineates No of the Public No Procurement the procedure Act delineates for open the tendering:Th 112 No No n/a No Yes No According to No Figure 1, Sections 4 and 5, p the PPP Guide, 120 Yes No Article 17 of Yes the PPP Regulations No Article states that 24(5) tendering No of the PPPNo Regulation processes statesand are public internation that a pre-qua 45 No No n/a No No n/a No Yes 42 No Yes Yes Section 24 of No that: "Except the PPA states Section as 23(1) provided No Public of the by No Procurement this Act provides: Act, all procurements W of good 30 Yes No Article 15 of Pursuant toYes Nothe PPP Law: Pursuant toNo “(…) TheArticle public 15 partner of Nothe PPP carry shall �(…) Law: out The the public p procedure 30 No Yes Yes According to NoSection 13(2)(d), the PPP Act, According"without to Yes the PublicNo Procurement prejudice Rules, 2004, to the generality Sectio of subsecti 42 Yes No Yes Article 28 of Noprovides:Article the PPP Law 31 of "The selection Yes theof PPP the bidders Nostates: Law "Prequalification. shall The c be carried out throug n/a No Yes Pursuant toNo Section 68 Yes of the Procurement toNo Section PursuantAct, (1)Except 58 No of as the Procurement provided Act: for in this (1)The part, Co open 90 No Yes Yes Article 20 of No 20 - Types PPP Law: Article of Article 42 procurement of NoDecree 4183/20: No "Pre-qualification procedures. ofoffero The selectionof the p n/a Yes No YesLaw defines Article 34 PPP Articles No that in the "Transaction" 52.2 No phase, and 67 No of the Proinversion PPP Regulations expressly the will determine int 60 Yes No Pursuant toYes Section 2.6No of the BOT Rule Law IRR, the No 5 of Projects BOT may Law IRR Noimplemented be throughof refer to qualification bidde public b 30 Yes No Article 29 of Pursuant toYes No Article Law: the Concessions 29.1(1) No 1. The of the Concession No contracting Law provides authority for a limit may conduct ac 30 Yes No Article 16 of Pursuant toYes No Pursuant Public Contracts Code toNo Article 18:In the 16 of NoPublic case of contracts Contracts whose 18:In the Codeobject co 0 Yes No Article 8 of the Yes PPP Law: No Article 8 "The Contracting of the Authority Yes PPP shall, Law:No in"The coordination Contracting with the Compete Authority shal 30 Yes No Yes According to Article 51 No (1) of the Concession Pursuant toNo Article Law: open76tender of Nothe is initiated Public by sending Procurement for in Law, pu n/a No No n/a Yes No Yes18 of theNo Article 16 and PPP Law mentions a request for 45 No Yes Yes According to No Open Competitive section K.3.2. According to Tender No Method section No Selective K.3.4. Bidding of the Treasury Method of Instructions: 60 Yes No of the PSP Law Article 12.1 No Yes provides Article that "[t]heof PSP 12.1 Yesthe project PSP Law No provides is to that "[t]he be tendered PSPan through op proj 30 No Yes Pursuant toYes Article 28 of No contracting PPP Law, Article No 28 ofauthorities the PPP Lawmay lists Yes use competitive one of thetendering pro following as a 60 Yes No Yes According to the PPP Law, No art. 20, "the According to No procedure the for PPP Law, No Article selecting a private 20, "the partner procedure for is either a 42 Yes No Section 39 Yes Pursuant toNo Pursuant (4) of the PPP Act, the toprocuring Yes Section 39 authority of the PPP No may or only Act, not request may those bidder 25 No No n/a No Yes the PPP Handbook Pursuant toNo No (section 3.2), the procure 30 Yes No Yes According to Procurement the PublicNo According Act, §102(1)(a), to Yes the Public No Procurement for the Act,concessions over-the-limit for §102(1)(b), (w 30 Yes No Yes According to the PublicNo Procurement According to No Act, Article the 39(1)(a), PublicNoProcurement "a authority contractingAct, 39(1)(b Articlemay, in 30 No Yes Procurement Yes No Financial Instructions (Chapter Both the Procurement 7 No Supply Chain No Management) Financial Instructions provide, and"P7 Pro the22 C 45 No Yes According to Yes the Concessions No According Manual, Section to No 9.1.1, "the No Concessions the Concessions Manual, Section bidding 9.1.1, "<… proceedings 21 Yes No The ModuleYes 5 of the PPP No According Manual states to No that "the the National Introduction Treasury No considers to the Moduleit 5 toof be best the PPp 30 Yes No Yes Article 131 of establishesArticle the LCSP No the "ordinary" 131 of Nothe methodsestablishes of procurement LCSP No are both metho the "ordinary" open 90 No No n/a No Yes No According to No on PPPs, Section 240, “the C the Guidelines 60 Yes No of the PPP Act Article 21.1 Yes Article No provides that "Partnership 21.1 Yes of the PPP Projects No provides Act offered shall be that to competiti "Partnership Pr 30 Yes No According to Yes the Concessions No According Act, Chapter 6, to §1, No "a Concessions the contracting No authority Act, Chapter or an §1, "ashall 6,entity cont 40 No Yes article 13 of Pursuant toYes Nothe PP Law, Pursuant toNo article the procuring authority 13 of No can the PPprocure Law, the through procuring open or autho 28 No No n/a No Yes Article 10 of Pursuant toNo Nothe PPP Law,1. The contracting 90 Yes No This is provided Yes under Section No According 15 of to the PPP Act: Yes Section 15.-(l) All 370 public Noof the private Publicpartnership Procurement Reg projec 60 No Yes Yes Section 32 of Norequires Clause the PPP Act the selection 8 of No Details of Invitation of private entity through No open competitive Notice Notification state n/a Yes No Article 11(3) Yes PPP Law stipulates No Article that the procedure 11(3) Yes Law stipulates No in the PPP described that previous the procedure desc paragraph m 45 No Yes Article 25 of Yes the PPP Law Nodefines open competitive Pursuant toYes Article tendering 25 of No asPPP the Law, "the restricted competitive tenderp bidding 45 No Yes Section 30 of Yesthe Public Procurement No Section Regulations 32(1) Yes the Public No ofprovides, "(1) Procurement Public procurement of goo Regulations pro n/a No No n/a No Yes No The PPA, art. No a list of the qualification req 29(1) provides 20 No No n/a No Yes According to No No Article 8 of the Decree No. 2016-772 of 20 45 No Yes Yes 16 of the Articles 13 and No According to BOT Implementation No Decree Articleprovide 16 No of the BOT that Implementation open tender among all Decr n/a Yes No No Section 31 of the PPP Act Yes Section 4 of sets the guidelines on No the the open PPP No Regulations tenderingprovides: procedure and (1) provide A Contrac 60 No No n/a No Yes clause 1 of No Pursuant toNo Article 14 of the PPP Law, a priva n/a No No n/a No Yes No Article 15 of PPP Law provides, "Subject to pa the Dubai No 30 Yes No Yes Regulation 30 No2016 provides of the CCR Regulation, that the No 30contracting of the CCR No 2016 provides authority that shall or utility have t the contra 30 Yes No Section 4.1Yes Pursuant toNo Pursuant of the PPTA Manual to and No Section 4.1No ofwhile Guidelines, competitive the PPTA and Guidelin Manual bidding with 90 Yes No According to Yes article 19 No of the PPP Law the procuring According No to article authority 19 No of the PPP may use Law any the procuring aut competitive me 30 No No n/a No Yes No According to of the PPP Law, <…> a two-stage Article 21 No n/a No Yes According to Yes the Tender No According Regulations in Section to Nothe Tender 3(2) No all tenders Regulations shall be called in Section 3,open on by tendea 90 No Yes Article 37 of Yes the PPP Law Article Nostates: Open bidding 3 of the Yes 1. Open bidding PPP Law Noregarding is an approach Interpretation provide to selecting in 42 No Yes According toYes the PublicNo Procurement Act, Section According toNothe 38(2), "subject NoSection PPP Act, to this 21, Act, "a contracting a procuring en auth 40 No No n/a No Yes According to the PPA, Section Yes No 30(1)(e), "subject to this A 30 No Yes In general, the No Tender Rules No provides No procedure. n/afor an open No Section 48 (c) of the Tender R 30 Yes No According toYes the PPP Law, No art. 19(3), "a tender According toNo may the PPP be open No(any Law, persons art. 19(3), "amay tender submit may an o be ap Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q19#2_3_1Q19#1_4_AQ19#1_4_BQ19#2_4_1Q19#1_5_AQ19#1_5_BQ19#2_5_1Q19#1_6_AQ19#1_6_B 19.4. Competitive Default Relevant legal/regulatory dialogue: Relevant provision Available legal/regulatory 19.5. Best and Default provision Final Offer (BAFO): Relevant Available 19.6. DirectDefault negotiation: legal/regulatory provision Available n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No No According to No Concession Art. 8 of the n/a Decree (No Decree No. No n/aDhou El Kaâda 18-199 of 20 corresponding to August 2, 2018 Yes 1439No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No Yes Annex of Article 12.2(a), No According Decree 118, sets thisto No procedure No of the article 14when PPP the specific Law, n/a when the No complexity characteristics theor of No PPP amount project, the project of such high as the justi n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No (Short-list Bidders) Section 4.5 Yes No of National The competitive PPPYes Guidelines dialogue Volume No 2 "Practitioners' Under falls within the "interactive 5.4.2No ofGuide" Volume tender No 2 of process" - expressions the National of meaning. interest PPP Section are submi 6.7 Guidelines, n/a Yes No No According to the Law on No n/a §22(1), "a Concessions, Yesprocuring authority may freely design the No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a No No n/a Yes No No According to No the PPP Guidelines, Sections 24.2 and 24.3 n/a Yes No Pursuant toNo Article 19 of No n/a1. The competition the PPP Law: No No be two-stage or three-stage. may n/a Yes No Pursuant otNo art. 38 of the NoConcession adjudicatorNo n/aLaw, the No freely organizes the bid protest i No Art.19 of the No PPP Law provides: n/a Public-privateNo partnership No are primarily contracts n/a awarded by Yes Nocall of open international bids n/a Yes No Pursuant toNo Article 14 (3) Noof the Procurement n/a Yes When the Law: No value of procurement, in case n/a Yes No Yes According to Section 52 of the PPAAccording No (1), a procuring to Yes PPA, Section theentity No conduct may A procuring entity 52:(1) procurement by me m Yes Article 12 of No that "(...) PPP Law states Article The10 competition of Nothe PPPforNo Law, the as amended n/a by contracting of the public-private New Yes Publicpartnerships No Procurement Lawcomply shall with the (Law 14.133/2 n/a Yes No Article 52 of Pursuant toNo Nothe Concession n/a Law:(1) Yes No A concessionaire for concessions above th No Article 29 of No provides the PPP Decree No n/athat “the selection of No n/a the private Yes be made partner shall Noby competitive bidding through n/a Yes No No Article 17 of the PPP Law Noindicates: n/a Yes the procurement partnership contract is made thro of a No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No Law 2006-012: Article 9 ofNo selection ofNo No (1) The n/a the contracting No partner n/a Yes undergoes No steps:- The preselection;- The the following Yes Federal Contracting No 10.7.22 Pursuant Policy provides,to "Two-step No Section 9.60.30 No (f)(including proposal of the n/aSupply price Manual, competition). Yes NoThis method competitive dialogue is takes used when, ow place in P No Article 16 of No the PPP ordinance n/a The selection provides: No of No the private n/a Yes partner shall be carried out by competitive bidding at na No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No Article 4 ofNo Pursuant toYes Pursuant PPP Procurement 2014, toNo article the methods PPPfor 4 of No Procurement Procurement n/a 2014, under the Yes PPP methods Projects No forinclude procurement under PPP open tendering, P inv n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 39 of Pursuant toNo No n/a the selection the PPP Law: No of the No n/a can also private partner Yes No be done in two steps. The pre-qualified ca Article 79 of Pursuant toNo No Procurement the Publicn/a No Code: q pre-qualification No Yes n/a of candidates No is mandatory for Public Delegation co n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No Yes Article 10 of No provides: the PPP Decree The invitation Pursuant toNo Articles to18 tender and 19 No may be n/a open Decree No. or restricted, Yes 2018-358 March ofin one or No 29, two 2018 phases, and relating shall to be P Public t n/a Yes No No Art 85 of the No Public Procurement Act n/a Yes lists the various No procurement methods available to pr n/a Yes No No According to the PublicNo Procurement n/a Yes "a contracting Act, §174(1), No authority shall proceed in n/a Yes No No According to section 55(4) No of the Public Yes n/a Procurement "the procurement process must Act, No Yes PPP Law Art.20.2 of the (the PPP Law No Art.20.3. No. 2017-186 provides No of 29 No that, by way May 2017 of on exception, n/a the Yes public-private Contracting partnerships) No Authority statesmay theeither thatuse the c two-stage n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No No Article 23 of the PPP Law Noprovides n/a Yes that the administrative authority with the PPP central un No n/a Yes No No Article 36 of PPP Law:"Competitive No dialogue. (…) n/a No authority can use a process No the procuring n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No No According to the PublicNo Procurement n/a Yes"the contracting Act, §48(3), No authority or entity has t the tender No After listing Yes Article 33 methods in Chapter Seven of No ofProcurement the No Proclamation the PPP Proclamation n/a address as Yescompetitive previously displayed, No dialogue. Article Article 58 ofprovides: 37 this Procl n/a Yes No No According to Section 118 No n/a Contracts of the Public Yes No and Concessions Act: In awarding the conc n/a Yes No Article L.2124-4 No of the Public No Acquisition n/a CodeNo No provides for the competitive dialogue is a pr n/a Yes No No Article 20 of the Ordinance No provides n/a No that procurement No procedures for PPPs include: open t Article 20^3 Pursuant toNo Noof the Public n/aProcurement No Law:1.No Two-stage n/a No state procurement Noprocurement object defined b of the Yes According to No the Concessions Ordinance, According §12(2), to Nothe Concessions "procurement No process Ordinance, n/acan §12(1), Yes"a concession be carried out in one or No grantor moremay stages <…>", freely amon structure Yes Section 36 of the Public Procurement No Section Law provides 44(2)(k) No of the for PPP No the option Act provides: n/a "(2) The of multi-stage Yes request bidding: (1) No A for procurement entity shall proposal documents engag shall inc n/a Yes No No According to Article 13 No of the PPP Law, n/a <...> in the case of Yes No"Particularly Complex Contracts n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No No Article 14 of Nospecifies:n/a the PPP Law No PPPs can be passed (i) No either by invitation n/a Yes to tender; No (ii) or by the Direct Negotiation whic article 119 No Pursuant toNo n/a public of the PP Decree, Noservice concessions No n/a are through an tenderedYes open tendering with prequalific No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No Yes According to No Article 118 According of the Public Procurement to No Act: Article 1. No 90 The of the tenderer Public n/a shall act in Procurement accordance Yes No Act:1. Competitive with this Part dialogue is a for the publicof award pr the General Rule 164 of No No n/a 2017 relates Financial Rules, No to two-stage No n/a (Obtain bidding No No bids in two stages with receipt of financial b Yes According to No the LKPP Regulation 29/2018, A competitive art. No dialogue 17, No option "auctions (tenders) is called n/a <…> consist an Yes optimization of:(a) adialogue One-stage No auction; or in Indonesia (b) a and possibl isTwo-sta n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No No Instructions Article 3 of the n/a of Public No on execution No Contracts No (2014) provides n/a Yes in its No for open tendering with te third paragraph n/a Yes No No Article 3.1 of the PPP Guidelines: No n/a revised Yes "The No Directives introduce a new procedure descri n/a No No n/a Yes No of the Mandatory Section 17ENo No Tenders Regulation provid n/a Yes No No According to Article 59 No of the Public n/a Code, 2. Contracting Contracts Yes No authorities shall use th n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No Article 29-3No Paragraph 4 No n/a of Public Accounting Yes and Section Act No 4-1-(11)(i-2) of the Process G n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No Article 42: 1. Pursuant toYes No Pursuant The competition for tothe No Order definition No No. 725: a private of12. n/a In order partner to attract Yesbusiness using No entities two-stage procedures to the planning is carried out of in the c PP n/a Yes No No Section 52 of the PPP Act No provides: n/a Yes dialogue "Competitive No(1) A contracting authority may, n/a Yes No No Competitive dialogue isNo an option under No n/a Article 2016 Basic Plans:Article 147, 201 147 of theNo n/a Yes No No According to Article 30 No (4) of the PPP Yes n/aLaw, when two-stage procedure, the follow using theNo Yes Article 34 of No the PPP Executive Article 34 Regulations provides, of Yes the PPP Executive "The Higher Committee No Article 42 Regulations may, provides, of No based the "The PPP Executive on the No Higher recommendation Regulations Committee may,of the based provides, "Th o Auth n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No No Article 17 of No the Procurement Law n/a provides, "For No large complex No n/a plants Yes projects and high value Nofor which the project executing n/a Yes No No Article 17(2) of the PPPNo Law provides n/afor the competitive Yes No dialogue <...> the competitive dia n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No No Article 56 of the Concessions No Law provides n/a possibility No theYes of conducting competitive dialog Yes procedure Open tendering Article No is detailed 16 of by article No 22 of the PPP Law the PPP No(Law Law2015-039 which n/a provides Yes a two-step on February No 3, 2016) selection indicates in the case of PPPs 3 procedures pr toof n/a Yes No According to Yes the PPP Manual, No According Procedure #3.10: to Yes the Drafting &No Issuing PPP Manual, the PPP Request Procedure for Qua #3.10: Drafting n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No article 13 of Pursuant toNo No n/a the PPP Law No : I- A public-private partnership No n/a awarded Yes open No through competitive tendering preceded n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No Pursuant toNo Section 178 No n/a Resolution of Government No No No 476, the public partner shall apply t No According to No the Concessions Law,n/a art. 16.1, "depending No Nothe type and on Yes n/a sector of No item, a tender may be condu a concession n/a Yes No No According to Public Procurement No n/aArticle 51, Law No Nopublic procurement procedures are 6) com n/a Yes No No According to Article 4 of No n/a no. 86-12 PPP Law (Law No Yesof 24 December 2014 ), public-private par No According to of the PPP Regulations, Article 16 No n/a Noa two steps No is used for Yes proceduren/a No projects with technical complexity [...].The co No Section 11.7 No Policy indicates: (2) of the PPP n/a RFQ No No be made and RFP can either in one n/a No depending on the PPP procu Yesor two stages n/a Yes No of the Public Article 2.28 No No Procurement n/a Act delineates Yes No the procedure for competitive dialogu n/a Yes No No According to the Procurement No n/a Rules, Yes Rule 31(b), No process is permitted and can a multi-step n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No No conclusion Article 29: The n/a No of a partnership contract No shall be Nosubject to n/a Yes of competitive the obligation No tendering and advertising n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No Article 53 of Pursuant toNo Nothe PP Law: n/a No The contracting No may conduct a competitive authority Yes procurement The multi-stage No According method is possible to No if a the pre-qualification Public Procurement No n/a stage is followed Rules, Yes Section 2004, by a two-stage No 42(d), "a procuring procurement method agency a may u No the projects Available when n/a by international No are financed No No organizations n/a the provision based onNo No of articles 7 and 8 of Law 22/2 n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No No Article 44 of the PPP Law Noand 62 of PPP Regulation n/a No introduce the possibility to in No expressly n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No Article 29(2) Pursuant toNo No of the Concessions n/a Yes Law: No 1. The contracting authority may conduct n/a Yes No Pursuant toNo Article 16 of No n/a Code Public Contracts 18:In the case Yes No of contracts whose object co No PPP Law: Article 8 of the No n/a "The Contracting Authority No shall, in Nocoordination Yes n/a with the No Competent Department, announce the Pro n/a Yes No Pursuant toNo Article 57 of No n/a Law, the the Concession No dialogue procedure is conduc Yescompetitive No Article 20 of Noindicates: the PPP Law Where theNo n/a Contracting No n/a to use Authority elects a two-stage Yes Nocompetitive procurement proc n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No of the PSP Law Article 12.1 No No provides n/a that "[t]he Yes No PSP project is to be tendered According through to Yes Article 95 No an open the Implementing ofcompetitive Regulation, tendering process, Yes Article 28 of Noprovides Article the PPP Law that, under 28 of Nothe PPP circumstances, ordinary LawNoprovides n/a that thecompetitive Yes bidding maydialogue be conducted No is one in of two stages preceded the derogatory procu n/a Yes No No According to the PPP Law, No Article 20, n/a Yes for selecting "the procedure No a private partner is eithe Section 45 No Pursuant toNo n/a (1) A contracting of the PPP Act: No authority, No n/a in conjunction with the Unit, Yes Nomay use a two-stage bidding p n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No Yes According to Procurement the PublicNo According Act, §102(1)(e), to Nothe Public No for the Procurement over-the-limit n/aAct, §102(1)(d), Yes (whose concessions for the No value over-the-limit is equal to or higher tha concessions (w n/a Yes No No According to the PPP Act, NoArticle 46(1), Yes of the No n/a "regardless form and an arrangement of a PP n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a No No n/a Yes No No According to No the PPP Manual, Module 5, Stage 2, follow n/a Yes No Articles 172No to 176 LCSP No n/acompetitive regulate the No Yes dialogue procedure. n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No of the PPP Act Article 21.1 Yes Article No provides that "Partnership 21.1 No of the PPP Act No provides Projects shall be n/a that offered "Partnership competition to Yes No through Projects shall be one of the to offered competiti following m n/a Yes No No According to the Concessions No n/a Act, Chapter Yes 6, §1, No authority or an entity shall "a contracting n/a Yes No Noauthority The procuring Nocan make a n/a Yes competitive for complex tasks or services of a dialogue No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No Yesof a multi-stage The possibility No Competitive (two-stage) bidding No dialogue is delineated allowed isNo under undern/a Section Section 154158 of the Yes of the Public No Public Procurement Regulations: Procurement 154 Regulations t n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No of PPP LawNo Article 11.4Yes Article stipulates that there 11.5 will No ofbe multi-stage the PPP Law No addresses tendering n/athis and that Yes issue and the states shortlisting No "5.final that, of candidatescircumst In exceptional will be m Yes Article 25 of No providesArticle the PPP Law that PPPs 25 of can No the be procured PPP Law Nomentions through n/a a multi-stage the Yes procedure. competitive dialogue No as Article a possibility. PPP 9 of the It Decree d is defined a No Section 31 of the Public Procurement No n/aRegulations No provides, No n/a "(1) Competitive Yes may be No bidding held in two stages in the followin n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No No According to Article 8 of No n/a Decree No. of 20 June 2016, 2016-772Yes No about the conditions and p n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No No Section 35 of the PPP Act Noprovides, n/a Yes "a procuring shall use the competitive dialogu authorityNo n/a Yes No No Competitive dialogue isNo available only Yesof the PPP n/a in the case Noin the form of concession.Purs n/a No No n/a Yes No Yes Section 4.2.4, No of the PPP Guidelines, Bid Evaluation, expl n/a Yes No Regulation 30 Noof the CCR No2016 provides n/a that the Yes No authority or utility shall have t contracting n/a No No n/a Yes No Section 4.3.3 Pursuant toNo Noof the PPTA Manual and Guide n/a Yes No No According to article 19 No of the PPP Law No n/a the procuring No may use any competitive me authority n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No n/a No No n/a No No n/a Yes No Yes under No This is regulated Article 31 of Article the Public 38 ofProcurement Nothe PPP Law Noprovides: Law:Article n/a "Competitive Yesnegotiation 31. The two-phase No Competitive method dossiers1. The with twonegotiation tw appro n/a Yes No According to Yes the PPP Amendment No According Act, Section to Yes 9the PPPamends which Amendment No the Section Act, Section 27 of the PPP A 9 which a No tendering The multi-stage n/a No will result No if following a pre-qualifications No n/a a procuring stage No Yes entity choses a two-stage method as de n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No n/a No No Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q19#2_6_1Q19#1_7_AQ19#1_7_BQ19#2_7_1Q19.8 Q20 Q19.8_1_TEXT Q21 Q20_1_TEXT 19.7. Other.Default Please, Relevant legal/regulatory provision specify: Relevant legal/regulatory 19.8. If direct Available If yes, negotiation provision please 20.is Doeither thethe provide If an tender yes, relevant available please documents 21. or provide Do default detail thethe legal/regulatory tender option, the relevant procedure documents does provisions: legal/regu the of regu una th No Article 10 of Noprovides n/a the PPP Law YesEconomic that: The High While Council the has Yes PPP Law the following has According not addressed powers toand the Yes functions applicable such circumstances, in general Private rules, Public the Ar P rules Article 33(2) Pursuant toNo No n/a Procurement of the Public Pursuant Yes Law, the negotiated toYes Article 32 of procedure, the without Public Pursuant toprior Yes Article Procurement 24(2)may notice, Law: of be the1. PPP used Where for the Law, the all t Art. 18 to 21 Pursuant toNo n/a No. 18-199 Noof the Decree Yes of 20 According Dhou El Kaâda to Yes Articles 18 Art. to 21 27 of 1439 corresponding of the the Yes Decree Concession to No. August 2, 18-199 2018 Decree relating provides: of to th 20 Dhou th No Article 22 of Procurement the Public No n/aLaw allows Yes for directAccording negotiationYes to article 27 (called of Simplified As the foreseen Public Contracting in Procurement Yes in 45 Article theet country). Law, seq.whatever of the Public the Additiona n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 12 of PPP Law sets that the general pr Article 23 of Pursuant toYes Nothe Procurement Pursuant Law Article <...> 1.21 toYes A purchase of Pursuant the Procurement toYes may be made Article 23 Law: of from 1. Pursuant the Aone closed Procurement toYes Article tender person 27 Law: isthe if:1) used of1. the product, A if purchase the procuremen work, may Procurement bse orLa n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to Figure 3.1 of the NSW PPP Table Yes According to No the Law on Concessions, According §22(1),to Yes "athe procuring Law on authority According Concessions, to may Yes thefreely Law on §22(1), design “a According Concessions, procuring the procedure Yes to authority the §22(3), Lawformay "by on the Concessions, way freely choice of design derogation of thethe con §55(5) Article 2.5.3 of the BOTNo No n/a Rules states Yes that direct negotiations Pursuant ("direct to Yes Article 2 ofare attraction") theone BOT Pursuantof Order: the to Article Yes 2.8.5.6 available At least of methods. the (3) candidate 3 BOT Rules: Com Furthermorc n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Guidelines, Section 26. n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Article 22 of the Regulation on Te Pursuant toYes n/a Yes No art. 38 of the Pursuant otNo n/aConcession YesLaw, the Pursuant adjudicator toYes freely Art. organizes 38. the bid protest of the Concession Law: i No Article 18 of No that the PPP Law states Article award procedure 18 Yes of PPP Law for states PPPs that Art.20are: of the the - International Yes PPP award Lawprocedure provides: Pursuant bid - direct to for exceptionally, Yes PPPs article negotiation 27-of are: International a - unsolicited public-private the PPP Law,bid propos the -part dire pr Article 14 (3) Pursuant toNo n/a Noof the Procurement Yes When the Law: Pursuant value to ofYes procurement, Article Pursuant 24 of the in Procurement case toYes Article of works,53 Law: amounts ofContract the Procurement onexceeds to or pK public La Yes According to No the PPA, Section Section 52 <...> 52 (1), A procuring of Yes entity the PPA provides According may conduct that: to Yes theA (1) procurement PPA procuring Regulations, According entity by means to Section Yes may theconduct PPA of: 66(1), (g) Regulations, procurement <...> the request fordirect Section proposals byproc 55 me No cases (e.g., In exceptional n/aemergency, No war, public Yes small value In exceptional extensions Yescases (e.g., Pursuant to contractswar, or when public toYes Article emergency, 40 is bidding the ofnotsmall viable Public value Procurem due to lac exten Article 18(1) Pursuant toYes No of Public Procurement Pursuant toYes Article Act, the procedures Pursuant 18(1) of the Public to under Article Yes this Procurement 182 law Pursuant ofshall Act the Public be: to , the <...> Yes Article procedures 13.78 direct of the Procurement negotiation. under Act: Concession (1) this The Furthe contra Act sha Law No Article 55 of No provides the PPP Decree Yes to the n/athat “[s]ubject Article approval 55 of Yes of thePPP the Council Decree Pursuant of Ministers provides toYes Article or the that “[s]ubject 32deliberative of the PPP to the Decree body of : th approvaTh No Article 17 of Noindicates: the PPP Law n/a the procurement Yes partnership of a Article No 17 ofcontract the PPP is Lawmade indicates n/a Yes through: : the open procurement with tendering of a pre-qu a partnersh No Article 18 of Noprovides:n/a the PPP Law "the selection Yes of Private Article Partner for No 20 of the the PPP solicited Law n/a projects states: No may "The Implementing be implemented through Agency co may pu No Article 13 (2) of decree No n 2014/2343/PM, n/a Prime Minister The No Yes the circumstances n/a could when Pursuant toYes so section require, the 19 of PMD PPP may, Decree No. after co2 the Government Section 6 ofNo n/a Regulation No Contracts Yes provides, There "a contracting Yes authority are multiple This may restrictions is required to enter Yesinto directpursuant negotiations, a contract to Section without as follows: soliciti Seco 10.7.41 No Article 14 of No the PPP Ordinance provides: n/a “The Yes public authority According be Yes shall to authorized Article 14 According ofto the directly PPPto Yes negotiate Article 105 Ordinance: a The public-private of public the Public authority partne Procurs n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 17 of the Concessions Regulations est article 4 of No Pursuant toNo n/a 2014, PPP Procurement Yes the methods Article for Procurement Yes 31 of under Government Article Procurement PPP of PPP Yes Procurement 9 Projects include, Law provides inter 2014: alia, the competit contents circumstan No 1150/2007 Article 2 of Law n/a 4 regulates No on its section Yes the cases Article on of Law Yes direct 2 which negotiation According 1150/2007 on its to (contratacion section Yes Article 4 regulates 2.2.1.1.2.1.3 the directa) is of cases possible. Decree on w1 No Article 44 provides exceptionally, thatNo Yes n/a the Contracting Authority Article may also Yes have 44 provides recourse thatPursuant exceptionally, toto the Article Yes the Contracting direct negotiation 35 of the PPP Authority in Law, thethe follow pre ma art. 79 of the Pursuant toNo n/a NoPublic Procurement Code, Yes exceptionally, Pursuantthe toYes authority art. may 79 of the According Public also have to Yes Article use direct Procurement 41 Code, ofnegotiation the exceptionally, Procurement in accot C No According to second paragraph article 17 No Yes n/a of the PPP Regulation, According the to Yes article 17 procuring second authority Article 52 paragraph can ofYes promote the Public direct of the PPP Procurement negotiation Regulation, Regulat the mech No Article 20 of No provides the PPP Decree Yes n/a that “The direct negotiation Article 20procedure of Yes No. Article Decree may be used: 12 of 2018-358 - Yes of when Decree there March 29, No.is2018-358 2018 an urgent relating need, of to Pub Marchdu Yes Procurement Article 85 Public No Public Procurement Act: Article Yes 85 of the Public Procedures Article Procurement 131 within Yes of the the Act Public meaning provides Pursuant Procurement for: of to 3.this competitive Yes Article Part Actof17 contains the of negotiated thestrict Act are Concessions <...> restrictions procedureLaw 6. nego No According to the PublicYes Procurement According Act, §174(1), Yes to the"a Public contracting According Procurement to Yes the Act, authority shall Public §174(1), proceed According Procurement "a contracting accordance Yes in to Act, the Public §176(1), authority with Procurement "<…> the shall provisions aproceed Act, §1 ou in contractin Yes According to section 55(6) No of the Public According Procurement Yes to sections Act55(3), “the According procurement 55(5), toand section Yes process 55(7) of 80According of themust Public the be Public toProcurement carried the YesProcurement EUout Concessions according Act, Act, "the Directive, "A procurem contractin to t one of a No Art.20.3. provides by way of exception, that,No n/a Yes the Contracting Pursuant toYes article Authority 26 of may use direct Pursuant the negotiation PPP to Law article (the Yes 11 PPP underof Law the theconditions PPP2017-186 No. provid awarding pr of n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Paragraph III of article 47 of the PPP Regulati n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to article 12 of the PPP Law, the p No Article 20 of Nosets forth the PPP Law the exceptional n/a Yes procuring Article methods 20 of the Yes PPP that Law can be Article as resorted 24 of Yes to amended which the paragraph PPP include Law states, 2 (2) direct "The negotiatio admin provides the n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Law: "Competition: tender p Article 8 of PPP n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes According to Procurement the PublicNo According Act, §49(1), toYes the"aPublic contracting According Procurement authority Yes to Act, the Public or entity §48(2), According Procurement has "the contracting the right Yes to Act, theto Public use §49(1), authority aProcurement negotiated "a contracting procedur Act, or entity aut has th §3 No Article 39 provides: No Conditions for n/a use of Direct Yes Negotiations: 1/ The for Conditions Yesuse PPP Directorate of Direct Article General Negotiations: Yes 36 of mayProcurement the engage 1/ The in PPP direct Proclamation negotiatio Directorate Ge (on Concessions) Section 119Yes No According of the to Yes Public Contracts Section and Concessions Section 118 Public of the119 (on ActContracts Yes Concessions) states: Pursuant A contracting and of Concessions toYes theSection Public entityAct: Contracts 68 may ofIn award the awarding and a contract Concession Public the conc di Contract n/a Yes No the Public Acquisition L 2124.3 of Yes Article L2122-1 Code Yes of the Public Articles provides for the Acquisition R2132-1 negociation Yes andCodeR. provides: procedure. 2132-2 of the The theproced Public buyer [ n/a Yes No Article 20 of No n/a the PPP Ordinance Yes (Ordinance No. Pursuant 009/PR/2016 Article toYes of 1118February of the PPP Ordinance 2016 on Publi n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Article 18(1) of the PPP Law, the Pursuant toYes Yes According to No the Concessions According Ordinance, §20(1), to Yes the Concessions According "publishing concession to Yes of aOrdinance, the Concessions §12(1), notice According can "a concession Ordinance, be waived Yes to grantor if §20(1), the Concessions the construction may "publishing Ordinance, freely structure or servic of co a§13 No Section 40 of the Public Procurement No Yes for direct n/aLaw provides Section negotiation 40 of Yes the Public under Section theProcurement term44 'single-source (2) Yesof Lawthe provides procurement': PPP Actaprovides limited set (1) that Ath of c p Article 32 of Pursuant toYes No Procurement the PublicArticle Yes 29 of the Law Public <...>, Procurement "Direct negotiations" Pursuant Article Law provides toYes 32 of are Pursuant the not Public the option toYes Article discretionary. Procurement of conducting 38(4) "Negotiated of Law the the <...>, "Negotiate procedure "Direct n Concessions n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 41 of the PPP Law regulates the mand No Article 14 of Noprovides n/a the PPP Law Yes that PPPs can be passed Article (i) either 14 of Yes by invitation the PPP Law to Article provides tender; 13 of Yes (ii) that the PPPs PPP or Law can by the Direct provides be passed Negotiation by the that PPPDp w n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Article 122 of the PP Decree According provides toYes article 42 of that the the PP Law, delegating the ten authority n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes PPP Law establishes that the Article 6 of the Yes According to No of the Public Article 98(1) Procurement Innovation Yes Act <...>, partnership: According According the negotiated toYes to Article Section 9895 According of of the procedurethe Public without Public toYes the Procurement Procurement publication EU Concessions Act: of Law, aThe contract Directive, contractin <...> not the A in n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes the General Financial Rules 2017 Rule 144 of Yes No According to No the LKPP Regulation n/a 29/2018, art. Yes 12 (1), "implementation Yes According to of the the LKPPprocurement Regulation The Attachment 29/2018, Yes process shall art. to the 20 LKPP include: (1), Regulation (a) a pre-qu 29/2 "selection of No Article 29 of No the Tenders n/a under "Cases Law provides Yes in which Article bidding 29 of isthe Yesnot necessary" Article Tenders LawIn provides 14 the offollowing theunder Yes cases "Cases Tenders Lawbidding in provides which biddin under is not ne No Instructions Article 3 of the n/a of Public No on execution Yes Contracts Article provides 3 of the in its Yes fifth paragraph Article Instructions on4. execution 3(b) for YesDirect of the Public Public Contracts Contracts ofnegotiation. Law provide req The procuri Yes According to of EU Regulations article 32 No Pursuant 2016, toYes regarding According Regulation use 31 of ofthe theEU to negotiated Yes article Regulations 32procedure Regulation of EU 2016, Regulations there without 36 Yes of is also 2016, EU Concession the prior publication, regarding possibility 2017: use (1) of states Innov Athe of con n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Section 15 (c) of the Mandatory Tenders Reg Yes Article 63 of the Public No Contracts Code Pursuant providesArticle that direct toYes 65 (1) Article negotiation of the of Yes the may 63Public Public be used Contracts Article Contracts Code: in the 71The of Code following Yes the contracting Public cases: providesContracts that authorities "(a) direct where Codeand no states ten the negotiat No According to No the Procurement n/a Handbook, Volume Yes 2, Section 1.1.4, "procurement According Yes to the Procurement According by Direct Handbook, to Contracting Yes the Procurement means Volume only 2, Section Handbook, one contr Vo 1.1.4, " No Act does Article 8 of PFI No direct negotiation, not forbid n/a Yes based According on Article to Yes Article 29-3 99 Article of the4Cabinet Paragraph 5of of the Yes the Order PFI Act on Accounts under Act Budgets, Paragraph and the Settlem Article 2-3 p 99,99 n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The pre-qualification invitation, published in Article 44 of Pursuant toNo No n/a1. The determination the PPP Law: Yes Pursuant of a private toYes Article 44 on partner Pursuant of the PPP basis to Law: Yes Article of 1. The direct37(2) negotiations determination of the PPP is carried of a priv Law, o the No Section 38 of Nostates that: the PPP Act n/a Yes authority "A contracting Section may, 38 Yes consultation inof Section the PPP Actwith states the 50(2) that: Directorate, Yes "Athe of PPPuse Act contracting direct provides authority procureme may, that tei n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 69 (3) of the PPP Basic Plans lists infor Article 40 of Pursuant toNo No n/a1. Upon Yes the PPP Law: the PPPC, approval byPursuant tothe Yes Article 40Authority Public Pursuant of the PPPis to Law: authorized Yes Article 31 to 1. Upon approval of negotiate the PPPby Law: an the1. PPPC The agreem n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 23 of the PPP Executive Regulations p Article 11(3), Pursuant toNo n/a No<...> If the Yes investment amount is Pursuant more than Article one billion toYes Pursuant soms, 11(3), <...>(Approx. If to theParagraph investment Yes 8 of 88,534.75amount USD) Regulation the is more PPP proj No. 39 tha No Article 10 of No the Procurement provides, "Procurement Law n/a Yes Article methods may Yes 13 of Procurement the follow:Article [...] Direct 31 Law ofYes states the PPP that contracting." Decree "bidding Additionally, states: "Tender through dire article No Article 17(6) Law allowsn/a of the PPPNo Yes for direct negotiation in Article specific 17(6)Yes of the PPPChapter circumstances <...> Law the allows VII. negotiated for General Yes issues direct negotiation procedure related shall in tospecific apply the i con n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to PPP Law, art. 7(1), "the process No Article 54 of NoLaw:The awarding Concessions n/a Yes authority may Article a concession award54 of Concessions Yes without Pursuant Law the provides tendering to Article Yes No a limited procedure 30 catalogue of thewithout Law on of Conc obse situati No Article 24 of Noprovides n/a the PPP Law Yesdirect negotiation. details on the Article 24 of ItYes can the be PPP Law Pursuant used in (PPP theLaw following toYes 2015-039 article 20 of on(i) cases: PPP February public Decree 3,(Decree 2016) security p or No Direct negotiation No is available according n/a to section Yes 52 of the Direct Act:"52.__(1) Yes is available PPPnegotiation Where According a under PPPto project Yes the PPP the hasManual, been following circumstances, approved Procedure in #3. ac acc n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes of the Malaysia's Government Pr Section 7.1 No No Article 14 of No providesn/a the PPP Law Yes that a private-public can Article be concluded Yes 8. II of the PPP Law through Pursuant a provides directto negotiated article that direct Yes 8 of procedure the negociation PPP Decree, withoutthe prio procedup n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes the PPPA defines "request for pr Section 2 ofYes No Article 64 of Noregulate the the PPP Law Yes n/a circumstances on which Article invitation 64 of the Yes PPP to only Law three Articles regulate bidders the Yes 44 and circumstances 45 or direct of the negotiation on which PPP Law is possibl invit establish t n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Article 47(5) of Government Res Pursuant toYes No According to No the Concessions Law, n/a art. 17.1, "aYes concession may be granted According Yes to through the Concessions According a direct Law,agreement Yes art. to the17.1, Concessions "a inconcession Law, art, may the following 12.1.7 be g cases: n/a Yes No No According to n/a Public Procurement Law YesArticle 51 Article 41, paragraph paragraph 1, points 1 Yes of the PPP Law stipul (3),(4),(5),(7),"competi No According to No Article 4 of n/a Yes PPP Law, public-private partnership Article contractsYes shall 7 of PPP Law awarded Article bestates that, 13 under of Yes the the unless PPP special competitive Decree permission dialogue states that is proc the t granted No According to (3,4) of the n/a article 13 No duly substantiated PPP Law, inYes According situations to Yes article 13 as and (3)aof last Article 44 theresort PPP of Yes Decree subject Law, No. in to duly 5/2016 the substantiated establishes prior situ express at No Section 29 of Noprovides:n/a the PPP Act “Project may Yesbe implemented Section 29 through Yes of PPP Act Pursuant the Negotiations: provides: (1) toNotwithstanding section “Project Yes 13may (2) be of anything the implemented Public Procu th contain Yes is allowed Direct negotiation the Public No underArticles Yes Procurement 2.30 and 2.31 of Direct the Act,Public Article Yes Procurement 2.32,is negotiation under allowed Pursuant specific Lawunder provide to Yes the thefor relevant Public circumstances, a competition Procurement Public which Procurement usually Act inclu und procedure No According to No the Procurement n/a Rules, Rule 15(9)(c), Yes “valid exemptions According to Yes the Procurement from advertising Rules, open According toYes <...> the [include]: Rule 15(9)(c), PPP Guide,c. “valid Only Sectionexemption one supplie 4.7, at th n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 24 of the PPP Regulation details the c No conclusion Article 29: The n/a No of a partnership Yes shall be contract Article subject 44:to A contract the obligation Yes Article governed of competitive 32 by the Yes of provisions the PPP tendering Law provides: of this and advertising Act may (...) be The No Section 42 of the Public Procurement No n/aAct permits Yes the direct Section negotiation Yes 42 of procedure the PublicSection Procurement in certain 26 ofinstances Yes Act the Public permits such Procurement the as where direct the Actcon pro negotia n/a Yes No Pursuant toNo Article 15 of n/a Yes The public the PPP Law: Pursuant partner toshall Yes Article 81 out carry the of the procedures PP for Law: The con No According to NoSection 20, the PPP Act, Yes n/a"the implementing agency According may Yes enter to intoAct, the PPP aAccording negotiated Section to 20, Yes the "subject Public to procurement of the Procurement a rules public private Rules, and regul2 n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes of the PPP law dealing with defin Article 4.15 Yes n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Section 49 of the Procurement A Pursuant toYes n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 45 of the Decree 4183/20 provides th n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 47 of the PPP Regulations sets forth t Section 2.6No Pursuant toNo Law IRR, Projects of the BOT n/a Pursuant Yes may be implemented toYes Section 2.6Rules through the 5BOT to ofpublic bidding 8Yes Law of theorBOT IRR, Projects law direct negotiation. IRR may andbe implem The di section 4 Yes Article 20 of No Law identifies the Concession special Negotiations with Yes circumstances the publication The Concession under Yes are allowed Law direct which lists Article under the negotiations Article 2 of the Yes specific conditions Concessions may 29.1 (3) take of the under place. Concessions which Law, concessions it isLaw Furthermorepo Article 16 of Pursuant toYes No Pursuant Public Contracts Code toYes 18:In the Article case 16(1)(g) Article of of contracts Public 25 Yes of Public Contracts whose Contracts object Pursuant Code Code 18, covers there to 18 Yes Article services lays is the 40 outpossibility and which the41 are possibilities of Public of orPartnersh areContr for likely d Yes PPP Law: Article 8 of the No Article 8 "The Contracting of the Yes PPP Authority shall, Law:Article in coordination "The 65 of Yes thewith Contracting Tenders Authority the Article Competent Regulations, shall, in NoDepartment, 9 of the still coordination PPPapplicable, Law provides: announce with provides "The the the Contr that: Pro Compete Article 69(4) Pursuant toYes No of the Public Article Procurement 69 paragraph Yes Law, by (2) Pursuant and exception toYes Article Articlesfrom 95-103 the 64 ofof provisions Pursuant the the Concession to Public ofProcurement Yes paragraph Article Law: 150(1) (1), (1) Law By of theexception provide the contracting Public that Procu from au th No The PPP Law Nodirect negotiation provides for n/a Yes for PPPs thatPursuant are either to Yes Article the 25 result of of Pursuant unsollicited the PPPto Yes article Law : Circumstances 16 of proposals orthe on PPP under the Law, which The ad Contractingp Yes According to No LimitedAccording section K.3.6. to Yes section Bidding Method of the K.3.5. According Treasury Instructions: to No Restricted Bidding section K.3.6. Method (2) n/aUnder ofthis Limited Yes Bidding the method: Treasury Method (a) Instructions: ofprocuring the (1) Rest enti the Treasury of the PSP Law Article 12.1 Yes Limited No provides that "[t]he Competition Yes PSP project per asArticle is to Article be 107 tendered Yes 12.1 of of the the Implementing through Article PSP Law an74and Regulation of Yes open Article the competitive Implementing 104 of the of PSP the Implementing Regulations Law which tendering sta s process, Yes is allowed Direct negotiation Competitive No in specific Yes bidding circumstances under which Direct Article is different 28Yes of than the negotiation allowed isPPP competitive Pursuant Law and in specific to Article dialogue Yes Article 8760 and of of the regulated PPP PPP circumstances Decree, Decree. specifies in Articles These thein A ten Yes According to the PPP Law, No Article 20, According "the procedure Yes to the PPP for Law, selecting For Article a PPP project 20, Yes"the a private without partner procedure According is a either concession for selecting a Yes to theelement, PPP public a private procurement Law,according Article partner procedure 20, is "the to eithe the Pu d pro No Direct negotiation No undern/a is allowed Yes special circumstances The enumerated Yes under five special Section instances Pursuant in53 which oftoYes direct Section the Act: PPP negotiation 4853. (8) Subject of the is allowed to theProcu Public app are n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Section 3.2.23 of the PPP Handb Pursuant toYes Yes According to Procurement the PublicNo Act, §29(f), According Yes to the "procurement PublicAccording Procurement to Yes the Act, procedures for Public §102(1)(c) the According Procurement over-the-limit and toYes the (f), the contracts Public Act, other §81, Procurement "a available direct negotiation include <…>Act, (f) dir procureme§4 Yes According to the PublicNo Procurement According Act, Article Yes to the 39(1)(f), PublicAccording "a Procurement contracting to the Yesauthority Public Act, Article According Procurement may, 39(1)(d) in the and Yes to the manner Act, (e), Concessions "aand Article contracting 46(1), under Act, the "aArticle contractin conditio 42( authority m No According to No the Procurement Manual, n/a Section Yes 2.6, “the Requesting Officer Yes According to will first the Procurement Section check Manual, 4.1 Yes of the whetherSection Procurement the goods, 2.6, “the works Manual or servic prov Requesting No According to No the Concessions n/a Section Yes Manual, 9.1.1, "<…>According in justified tocases the Concessions Yes methods otherAccording Manual, given to Yes thein Concessions Table9.1.2, Section 7 below "Table Manual, may is Sectio 7be use a su n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes PPP Manual, Module 5 provides that the RFQ Yes Article 168 of No negotiate LCSP regulate procedures Articles 177Yes to 182 without establishes publicity Article the 168 LCSP Yes and procedure restricts regulateArticle it to of thespecific limited Innovation 132 LCSP Yes cases. Partnerships, circumstances states the following: on which new "Princi the pr procedure in n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to the Guidelines on PPPs, Section of the PPP Act Article 21.1 No No provides n/a that "Partnership No n/a shall be Projects Yes offered to Article competition 20.2Yes through of the PPP one Actof provides that the the following m Yes According to No the Concessions Act, Chapter According §1, Yes 6, to the "a Concessions contracting According Act,to Chapter Yes the authority or an Concessions 6,entity §1, According "ashall contracting Act,to be Chapter Yes free the Concessions to 6, organize authority §12, "a orthe Act, contracting an entity Chapter shall procedure 6, aut f NoPP ordinnance Art. 36 of the n/afor a direct No provide Yes negotiation Art. procedure: 36 of the YesPP ordinnance (...) Pursuant 2 The adjudicator provide toYes article may for aalso direct 16 award of the negotiation PP a Ordinance, proce contract th dire Article 23 of Pursuant toNo No n/a where agreements the PPP Law, Yes are Pursuant negotiated Article toYes 22 of without using Pursuant the PPP a tender, to Law, Yes Article a contracting 10 (3) subject of the to approval authority PPP ofLaw, shall: the the Cou Yes Single-source No is regulated procurement Section under 155Yes of the Public Sections 160The Procurement (procedure) special Yes conditions and Regulations (single Section 161 makingallows source single 39(1)(e) Yessource procurement for of the procurement "RequestPPP for Regulations of works) possible proposal with of thes provin No Section 34 of Nostates that the PPP Act n/athe selection No may not be made by n/a Yesbidding ifClause the host agency, Yes ofthe 4 Details Invitation Responsible Notice Notificat Minister a No Article 12 of Nostates that: the PPP Law Yes n/aExceptions to competititve Article 12 tenders Yes of PPPbe themay LawAccording considered states that: Yes to Article in the case Exceptions 62 of to the procurement Procurement proc competititve R ten No Article 25 of Nostates that the PPP Law n/aPPP projects Yes may be Article procured ofNo the PPP 25 through direct Law n/aidentifiesNo agreement which the conditions is defined under which as the the P procedu No Section 34 of No the Regulations allows n/a for direct Yes sourcing/negotiation of Section 34in athe Yesnumber Regulations of Section scenarios, 23 of Yes allows for including: thedirect Public sourcing/negotiation Procurement (a) Regula when no suitable b n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to No Article 8 of n/a Decree No. 2016-772Yes of 20 June According 2016, about to the Article Yes 51 Articole of Decree conditions and 16 procedures No. Yes of PPP 2016-772 for the Decree ( 20 of Decree award June No. 2016, of 2016 ab public- No Article 12 of No n/aDecree provides the BOT implementation Yes that, According the following Yes to procedures Article 22 The of the following are Public Yes Procurement articles available: provide c) bargaining Law: that method. "the method the Furth tende No Section 33 of Noprovides n/a the PPP Act Yes for direct negotiation in Section circumstances Yes 33 of provided the PPP Act Section for provides 4 ofYes under the the for direct PPP PPP Regulations regulations negotiationand in circumst on appr provides: (4 Article 14(1) Pursuant toNo No n/a of the PPP Yes Law, if only one applicant Pursuant submits Article an application toYes According 21 of the for Concession participation to Yes Section in Law, the 13the of procuring competition, Resolution authorit No. 38 the No Article 14 of PPP Law provides, the Dubai No n/a Yesprocess of "a. The Article selecting 14 ofathe Project Yes Dubai Article PPP Law Partner will (18) provides, Yes ofsubject be "c.to the Dubai Notwithstanding the PPP Law provides, principles the of "T p ope Yes Regulation 31 No2016 requires of the CCR Regulation competitive 30 Yesof the CCR tender Regulation in 2016 provides 31 Yes paragraphs of(1) the thatCCR to (5) the Regulation 2016 but contracting requires they Yes 37 do of authority notcompetitive CCR apply 2016or in states: the utility tender cases (4)in shall The have parag cot regulate n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 19 of Decree No. 17/012 establishes t No According to of the PPP Law, Article 25 No Yes may According n/a <...> "parties conclude ato PPP Yes Article 25 According of the agreement PPPto withoutLaw, Yes a Article direct tender22 negotiations onofthe thebasis PPP Law, of are <...> limite direct nt No According to No the Tender n/a Regulations in Section Yes 3(4), tender processes According Yes to the Tender other thanAccording open Regulations to Nothe in Section tendering may Tender include 3(4), Regulations, tender process the selective not tende of the PPP Law: Article 39.1 Yes No "Investor Article appointment 40.1 Yes of the PPP The approach Law: Article "Investor to appointing 39.1 of the Yes selection PPP Law: Article taking investors Investor 49 shall place of Decree be Yesin employed certain appointment 35/2021/ND-CP: special in Thethecases approach following 1. "Prepa In to casa ca According to the PPP Amendment No No n/a SectionYes Act, 9 which amends According the Section Yes to 25 of the PPP According Amendment the PPP Act, to Act, Yesamong the PPPothers, Act, Section 9 which Section "(35) 22(5)(d), a contracti amends the"t The Zimbabwe No and Development No Investment n/a Agency No n/a Act № 10/2019 Yes[Chapter 14:37] According statesto Yes inthe section Procurement 3 (c):"3. (1) Subject to S Regulations, t n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a n/a Yes According to the PPP Law, art. 21(1), "the ten Yes Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q21.1 Q21_1_TEXT Q22 Q21.1_1_TEXT Q22_1_TEXT Q22.1 Q22.1_4_TEXT Q22.1_3_TEXT Q22.2 21.1. If yes, please Are there provide If yes, the any relevant please parameters/limits legal/regulatory 22. provide Can potential the If yes, to relevant provisions: bidders/tenderers please the qualification legal/regulatory 22.1. provide the If yes, If requirements can submit yes, relevant the provisions: please bidders questions legal/regulatory and provide toelaborate also ensure tosuggest the clarify 22.2. relevant on thatprovisions: If the innovations they yes, public kind do legal/regulatory is there not of procurement innovations unduly toaimprove timeframe restrict provi tha the no rules in theArticle The generalYes Procurement Public53 of Yes the PPP Law n/a Article 20 provides that: Noprovide: (1) The (1) n/aBidding documents relevant n/a shall and Entity arrange Norequest the Tender for proposal, Process in a ma which sh Article 31(2) Pursuant toYes of the Public Pursuant Article toYes Procurement 20 of Pursuant the Law, Public to No inProcurement restricted Article 42 (1) n/a procedures, (3) Law, of contracting then/a the contracting Public authorities Yes authority Procurement Law, shall avoid potential (CA) any criteria, shall publishr tenderer No Art. 12 of the n/a Concession No Decree provides that n/a the call forYes tenders takes 11 and Art.place two article in Art. 11 stages 12 and and No article of Concession 12 thethat the of 1st the stage Decree consists provide Concession of Decr Yes Articles 118.1 Article (i) and 120 120.2 of the Yes Public of Procurement the Public Articles Law 51 provides and No 72.2 Procurement Law(b) that provides n/a of the the Public thatn/a qualification the Procurement public criteria contracting Yesmust Law be provide entity disclosed cannot that interested in set the qua procu 118, AnnexAccording Decree No. Yes to Yes I, Section 12.5, article 12.19 and Section 12.5 12.35 of Decree 11, indicate Yes article 188/2017, 12, Annex that the Article technical tender I 14 of specifications of Decree documents No the restrictions 118, PPP Law states must Yes and provides conditions contain that are in place interested that themust when regarding selection parties be the develop compl proced the sco and Article 24 (2) Pursuant toYes of the Procurement Pursuant Article 6 ofPursuant toYes Law, the Procurement the to prequalification Article No 29(1) Law: n/a 4. of Criteria announcement the Procurement n/a for is published eligibility Yes Law, and qualification the in participant of a the online participant entitled toa isnewsletter No mentioned The previously Yes n/a Figure 3.1 Section of the NSW 4.3 Yes PPP Guidelines of Volume and2 Section of the National Section 4.1.1 6.6 of of Thethe Responsible the PPP NSWGuidelines No PPP Guidelines National PPP Agency, provides Guidelines in consultation provides that Volume a briefing under 2" with Yes According to According the Law on Concessions, to Yes the Law on §28(3), According “aConcessions, contracting to Yesauthority §46(1), the Law on“a According shall Concessions, contracting to state An inthe the authority innovative §40(1), Law notice on"if YesConcessions, to a shall solution request award determine with a is concession made §67(3), exceptionally the in"if awhat timely an offer documents hig prom Article 5.6 of Pursuant toNo n/athe BOT Rules: Yes Competition Pursuant toNo Articleshall conditions 5.14n/a be of preparedRules: and announced the BOTn/a Prior Yes to submitting by the Competition Comm bids, a company m No According to n/a the PPP Guidelines, Section Yes 22.2(b), According “the RFQNo to the PPP Stage of Guidelines, the n/a process n/a 30.1, bidding Section shallNo “a include Pre-Application Meeting, prequalification shor and Pre- Article 23 of Pursuant toNo n/a the Regulation Yes on Tender, Pursuant competition the toNo Articles 17committee n/a to 19 of the conducts Regulation n/a No a preliminary on tender:17. selection Participants of the of bidders in of the concession Art. 48. § 1.Yes Art. 48.Law of the Yes provides: Concession Pursuant The Law adjudicators provides toYes article fix that in criteria 45 of the Pursuant the concession must toThe be Concession art. notice non-discriminatory tender 55 Law, the procuring No ofthe procedure conditions Concession authorities allows and for Law, proportionate the for notwithstand selection or innovative compete of tos c No According to of the PPP Law, article 27 n/a No the pre-qualification n/a Yes Art. notice and its35 consultation of the No comments PPP Law provides No rules, if applicable, : In the contain among two steps oth open Article 26 (2) Pursuant toNo n/a Yes of the Procurement Pursuant Law, the restricted toYes Article procedure Pursuant 56 of shall toThe be Article the Procurement conducted bidding 53 Law: ofdocumentation (1) the Yes the Procurement inInterested following candidates/bidder shall manner: Law: (1) The a) a include st co pub No According to n/a the PPA Regulations, Section Yes According 28(5), to No "a pre-qualification the PPA Regulations, notice n/a shall Section contain34(1), n/a a statement No“bidding of documents the scope of the stipu shall proc No Pursuant the n/a Concession Yes18, V, and Law, Article Article the Public 39 of Procurement the Public Within Yes Law the (Law Procurementpublic There 8.666/1993), Lawconsultation are (Lawnot No 8.666/1993) restrictions Article 40,establishes VI, procedure regarding the on qualification thethe that bidding inno for Yes According to Articles 60 to 63 of to Pursuant the Yes Article Concession Pursuant 62 of Law, the Concession the tocontracting Article Yes Law: 79 (1) of entity Pursuant the TheConcessions may grantor todetermine, Variants Article shallLaw: 78 determine of with are1. athe YesAny possibility regard Concession person as conditions to the mayLaw: bidders, for (1)participa Depend request clarifi selecti Article 32 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Decree, n/a Yes the pre-selection Article 34 of Yes notice the PPPshall Decree Article contain 35 inter and Article provides: alia Applicants 49 of 35 the theYes the PPP and may criteria 49Decree of submit theadopted PPP state requests Decree forthe that state for procu clari tha pre-selec article 30 of Pursuant toYes According the PPP Law: to Yes The partnership Articles 23 Pursuant and 27 of contract tothe article No shall 29 of Decree on n/a bethe awarded PPPs, PPPthe n/a to ad Decree, the hocselected committee No to related candidate restricted proceedsprocedure, on the to the basis pre-qua of the the te n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No NoDecree enumerates Art. 20 of the n/a the requirements No n/a supporting No n/a of the n/a bidder’s application No in the case where they are ne and Section 10.7.1 Pursuant toYes CETA the Federal Yes ofArticle 19.7 and Contracting CFTA The Federal Policy, Article 507 Contracting No set out "Equal opportunity n/a the Policies limitations n/a Section in for tocontractors. all 10.8.22 establishing No provide, In conditions accordance "Forwarding participatio for with the of po Tend No Article 19 of n/a the PPP Law provides:Yes the conditions Article pre-qualification, for18 No of the PPP Ordinance n/a provides n/a admission, association that bidders Noof tenderers can submit publication and questions c toar of the Concessions Article 6.bisYes RegardingLaw pre-qualification, Yes indicates the pre-evaluation Article Article 18 ofYes 6 the of of bisConcession Concessions bidders Article Regulations 6 bis will be Law Improvements, of based provides Concessions on Yes the permitsthat and "uniform, additions Law, the regulates interested and bidding or objective "Questions parties terms: adjustments andshall reaso and Bidd to b c Yes 2014, PPP Procurement Article The 6: pre-qualification Ministry Yes of Finance's Article Notice criteria of 22on shall the Further No Measures be published Advancing n/a for Government on the the n/a Public-Private special media. Yes Partnership Article Procurement of 14 PPP in ofProjects the Notice Public provid of Services Yes initiative For public finance PPP projects According to Yes Article articleof 2.2.2.1.4.6. the PPPto 12 According Law, Yes article numeral 8 of all PPP3Article processes of the law the PPP 80.6 1150 must Technical Regulations of the ofcomply 2007 Public No or (Decree economic with Procurement and Articles the1082/2015) principle alternatives 2.2.1.1.1.7.1 Lawof that objective establishes and and exce 2.2 allows s b Article 35 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a Article 37 of Yes the pre-qualification Yes the notice PPP Law Pursuant shall provides contain to atthat Article leastthe theContracting 0 39 of No following the PPP information: Authority Law: the shall a descriptio respond selection of t No According to of the Public Article 46 n/a NoProcurement n/a Law, the Yes calls for tender of60 Article of The public the procurement bidder Public may No Procurement projects which propose, Code in addition provides: amounts to the are (1)b No Article 53 of Procurement the Public n/a YesLaw establishes Article 60 of that the No theprequalification Public n/a Procurement criteria n/a will beYes Regulationsstated provides in the for the possibility tender documents. to No Article 12 of n/a Decree No. 2018-358 Yes of March 29, Article relating 2018 12 of Yes Decree to Public No.Article 2018-358 Private 21Partnerships of The ofthe March tender Public 29,No documents Procurement 2018 relating contracts include Code provides to that Public the (Decree possibility Private the No. call foP 2 Yes Article 42 of Article the Concession Act 143 stipulates of Yesthe Public types the Article Procurement of 40 ofYes theAct information Concession states that Pursuant must Act that be any states tolimiting The included Article that object of the in 48 prospective of of Yes the provisions procurement, tender the Concession bidders documents. regarding technical Act, upon public must be This specific done recei inclu proc Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording to Yes the Public Act, §180(6), According Procurement “a contracting to Yes the Act, Public authority According Procurement §6(1), may to also "a contracting Variants the Act, specify authority Public §180(5), mayYes in Procurement be the must for permitted. the tender comply concession documents Act, Additionally, with §102(1), award the princip "ifan pro the qualifica Yes According to According Directive, the EU Concessions to Yes the EU art. Concessions According Directive, to 31(2), “concession Yes the EU art. notices Concessions According shall 3(1), “contracting contain Directive, to Variant the EU the authorities bids art. Concessions information Yes 34(3), may be "provided permitted. Directive, andreferred contracting that to An art. in it innovativ entities 41(3), has Annex been s V "th article 21.4n/a Pursuant toNo Law, when the of the PPP Yes number Pursuant of toYes Article candidates 11 of According satisfying the to Innovations, the Art.20.2 PPP awardingselection procedure of technical the No PPPDecree Law criteria variants. included (the (PPP PPP Decree in Law the No. No.2 pre-qu2 Yes Paragraph III It is of article 47 ofexpressly the PPP Yesestablished Regulations: Paragraph in The Article IINo terms3, ofand subsections article response n/a 54 of2the times and PPP n/a of 8 of Regulations the Law No. 340-06, Yes different states: actions the thePrinciples tender documents included inof the phasew "Equalit No Article 55(e) Regulations of the PPPn/a Yes (ExecutiveArticle Decree 1190), 66 No of theregarding PPP Regulations n/a (Executive n/a the tender documents, Decree No provides 1190) provides in general, that "[...]that "The ad No Article 31 of n/a the PPP Executive Regulations Yes According states to No "The prequalification article 21 of n/a the PPP Law, committee composed n/a the Administrative No by the competent authority Authority at t in coordina No Article 35 of n/a the stage PPP Law: "(for Yes Article 35 of of prequalification) a Yes PPP tendering Article documents Law: "the 36 of Level shall tenderingthe documents PPP be of service Law Noprovides made will and and will allow technical contain for the (prequalified) the possibility the requirem standards pa of b n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording to Yes the Public Act, According §45(3)3)8), Procurement “ <…> to Yesthe Act, the Public contracting §98(1), According Procurement "the authority to contracting Variants the Act, Public or entity authority may §46(1), Yes Procurement submits "the be or permitted. contracting entity to the Act, may public authority verify procurem §46(3), theor su "clarifi No Article 21 of n/a the PPP Proclamation Yes details: Prequalification Section 16.12.1. No of the criteria: 1/n/a Procurement In order ton/a qualify Directive No provides, for the pre-selection "As provided proceedings, int in article 3 Article 83 of Pursuant toYes the Public Pursuant toYes Article Contracts and According 83 of the Concessions Public to Contracts the Act, Yes EU Concessions the and Section Concessions 38Directive, of contracting Innovation the authority Public Act,art. The Partnership Yes may Contracts 34(3), lay contracting "provided down and the Concessions that authority requirements itmay has Act lay a been d Yes According to Articleof Article R2142-1 L. the 2142-1 Yes Public the According of Acquisition Public Acquisition Code to Yes : TheDecree Articleconditions R2151-4 Pursuant provides of for the to participation The Article that Public procuring when R2151-8 Acquisition Yes the in authorities the buyer of procurement the Code decides Public : may the Acquisition to time authorise proceedings set limit minimum the Cod for r No Article 22 of n/a the PPP Ordinance No (Ordinance No. n/a 009/PR/2016 No of 11 February n/a n/a 2016 No on Public-Private Partnerships) requires th Article 19(9) Pursuant toYes of Resolution Pursuant Article toYes No.19 426, of Pursuant Resolution toNoArticle qualificationNo. requirements 426: 19(2) 9)n/a of the forPPP a public-private n/a Law, Qualification requirements the documentation Yes partnership project of the concessiona shall for a public-private be det partners Yes According to According the Concessions Ordinance, to Yes §25(1), According the Concessions "a concession Ordinance, to Yes the Concessions §25(2), According grantor shall "theOrdinance, specify eligibility to Innovative thetheConcessions [qualification] §18, eligibility solution Yes "a concession Ordinance, with criteria exceptionally grantor must [qualification] §31(2), criteria be shall non-disc “if in provi a high bid f acc No Section 39 of n/astates: "(3) the PPP Act YesThe minimum Section qualifications No 41 of the PPPrequired Act n/a of a bidder provides:n/a "Prequalification for a public Yes private proceedings 41. (1) The partnership con projec Article 39 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the Concessions toYes ArticleLaw, 38(3) <...> of the While the neither Concessions tender Yes documents the PPP Law Law, Pursuant a nor must limiting to the The list Concessions Article of the tender types prequalification 45(3) of Yes participants innovations of the Law explicitly Concessions criteria is are possible not in an allows Law, explicitly for as objective long the pro en as bidders No According to of the PPP Law article 60 n/a Yes " the prequalification According toNo guidelines article 61 n/a ofshall the PPP define n/a Lawthe "interested objectives Yes parties may submit necessar and requirements consultat No Article 13 of n/a the PPP Law that PPP procurement provides No n/a No rules are based n/a n/a on the principles No of competitive bidding, competitio No Article 70 of the PP Law makes provision n/a prequalification Yes for a Article 89.2Yes of the ofPP candidates Articleprovides Decree in case 75 Variants of the of that PP a concession additional areYes allowed. Decree states information of public that variants service on the facility. are possi tende A No Article 22 of n/a the PPP Regulatory Decree, Yes establishes According thattoNo the the Article selectionn/a 21 process of the General n/a will include Provisions a Yes prequalification of the PPP Law "Inquiries stage, which will Yes According to the EU Concessions According Directive, to Yes Article 65 According of the Article 31(2), Public to "concession Yes Procurement Article 56 Section notices of the Act (1), shall 95 of PublicInnovation the contain Procurement eligibility the the Public Partnerships Yes Public information criteria Act:Procurement Any 1.defined are referred economic by the Act allowed tocontract operato in discusse in Hung Anne the General Rule 173 of Yes Financial Rule 144 of Yes the General Rules, 2017 inter Rule Financial 173 alia requires Rules No provides clauses that (iv) the n/a and (x) the bidding of fundamental the documents n/a General principles Financial Yes shouldRules, of provide public 2017procurement. the eligibility provides crite thatEvt Yes According to According the Attachment to the to Yes LKPP the LKPP Regulation According Regulation 29/2018, to 29/2018, Yes theChapter Chapter LKPP According II, B,IV, Regulation 4 (f), Part to 29/2018, "qualification the III, The new §1, Attachment art. things/provisions No art. 14 13 document (1)(c), (2), to "in theone preparation LKPP shall of and/or Regulation consist the important of stages of qualif of 29/ the f th No Article 14 of n/a the Tenders Law provides Yes under "Bidding Article 17 of Nothe Tenders documents" a) All n/a Law bidding under n/a documents "Clarification" shall No provides: be submitted case a bidder a) In equally to all af No Article 4.3(b) n/a Contracts of the Public YesLaw requires Article factors No on of 4(3)(b) which the Public evaluation n/a Contracts will n/a Law be provide conducted No that to be the tender Note: included. shall p noticeAccord Yes According to RegulationDirective, the EU Concessions 7 Yes of EU Concession art. Regulation 31(2), "concession 33 2017 Yes states: of thenotices EU (1) A Regulation Concession contracting shall contain 41 Innovative of 2017 authority EU the establishes: Concession solution Yes information and a contracting (5) with 2017 referred an Provided provides exceptional entity to that as in it Annex shall follow has level tre V be Yes Section 15 (c) of the Mandatory Section 17 Tenders (a) Yesof the Regulation Mandatory Section provides 15 Tenders (c) Noof the Regulation that, Mandatory "Inn/a a notice alsoTenders provides of n/a the holding Regulation that, No of"(b) a public provides The Tender tenderDocuments the that, a notice sha "Infollowing m o Yes According to Article article 61 (1) of the 30 Public of Yes Public Article Contracts the Contracts Code: 74 "1. (4) Code Yes of restricted In the Public providesPursuant that procedures, Contracts to1. "WhenArticle Code Contracting awarding any 45 provides economic Yes of the contracts authorities that Directive operator inquiries andmay 2014/24/EU may, concessions, authorize - which submithave the a or on req Pu r cb Yes According to According the Procurement Handbook, to Yes Volume According the Procurement 2, Appendix Handbook, to Yes Procurement the 7, Section Volume According 2, A7.3(d), Handbook, to Section Variant the "Bidding 1.3.4, Procurement Volume (alternative) "pre-qualification Documents No 2, Appendix Handbook, bids include may should 8,be the Volume Section following not 2, be A8.3, allowed. uss App Yes Article 5, Paragraph 2-2Section of the PFI 4-1Law Yes ②-1-2 and3④ requires that -1-(7) of the ofcriteria the Process No Policy Basic for Guidelines selection Regarding n/a must PFI states n/a be and that 4-1 specified the(8) qualification No in the of detail Procurement in requirements the Implementation Process Gu should No Article 16 of n/a the PPP Regulations provides Yes "[i]n the thatArticle 19(B)(2) Pre-Qualification No of the PPP n/a Regulation Invitation, n/athe Steering suggestsNo that Committee potential bidders can subm shall determine t Article 32 of Pursuant toYes the PPP Article 32 of Law Yes (1) the PPP to participate law Pursuant in specifically toNo a Article tender sets out or 37 the (4) n/a direct qualification of the negotiations PPP n/a requirements Law, a for potential Yes the selection private which are partner of ageneral private hasin partner the rig natur No According to of the PPP Yes section 47n/a Section Act,"(1) A private 50(2) partyYes intending of the PPPUnder to respond Act Regulation to The providesathat request innovations 38 tender ofNo the for qualification PPP enumerated documents Regulations, prepared under by thecontractin law by contr inclu asection 46 Article 76 (2) Pursuant toNo n/a Yes of the PPP Pursuant Basic Plans, (2) If the toYes Article competent of authority the PPPintends Basic Bidders 122 Additionally, according Plan to are conduct :(1) to permitted YesThe the Article competent 12 prequalification a wide (8) ofrange the PPP of discre Act, exam authority b shall Article 26 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the PPPto Law: Yes Article 27 of 1. After Pursuant the the PPPC has Law, PPPtoNo Article approved to be33 pre-selected, of n/a and the authorized interested n/a 1. PPP Law: the The project Public No and biddersAuthority must themeet start of the may, the on eligibility its tenderin own ci No Article 14 of the Executive n/a Regulations Yes provides, Article announcement No "The32(2) of the PPPn/a of Executive the invitation n/a for qualification Regulations No provides, "The shall Investors include the follow may sub Section 8 (3) Pursuant toNo n/a Yes No. 39:Pursuant of Regulation a) the procedure toYes Section for8 (2) According of Regulation submitting to andn/a Article receiving No. 39, 13 applications of the Yes rules the PPPof Law, for theparticipation tender should qualified in co th particip Yes Article 31 of Article the PPP Decree 30 of No states: the "Tender Documents n/a provides: PPP Decree No The tender "Principles n/a Governing documents n/aPartnership shall No include:1. ATendering detailed plan of the tender A public-private p par Yes Article 33(3) law provides of the PPPArticle 37 of Yes the forDirective Article 2014/23/EU the drafting 18(8) of regulations, Yes of the of thewhich PPP Article Law are European provides 51(8) to Parliament address The the offor kinds the PPP inof and possibility detail Yes Law innovation of the provides the Council following of submitting are for not of <...> 26 the specified possibility February questions if the cont in 2o Yes According to According the PPP Law, art. 7(3), to Yes "the the PPP Law, According project committee art. 7(1), to Yesthe shall "the PPP process provide Law, According art. the for the 7(7)(b), parties selection to As part the"the interested PPP of of project the the Law, Nomadatory Private art. incommittee, being 7(9),prequalified "the consultation Partner project assisted shall be with commit process by subjec the the Yes Article 41(5) Concessions of Law on Article 41 of Yes the andConcessions Pursuant Article 47 ofLaw Public to explicitly Yes Article 31(2)(19) states, Pursuant Procurement <...> Law of the state the ton/a Concessions minimum that the Article 52 of Yes qualification qualification the Law, Concessions the way information to Law, submit requirements innovative of the setqu by parti article 17 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a Yes the tender Pursuant noticeto No article 15 indicates prequalification of n/a the PPP Decree criteria n/a which (Decree No 2017-149) is also mentioned related to article byopen ten1 Yes According to According the PPP Manual, Procedure to Yes #3.10: the PPP According Manual, Drafting Procedure to &Yes Issuing the PPPthe Manual, According #3.11: Receiving PPP Request Procedure to The &the for Evaluating submitted PPP Qualification #3.15: Manual, No PPP Receiving innovative Qualifications Procedure (RFQ) & Documents, Responding designs, & Announci technolog #3.17: to "anBidd RF Evaluat n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No Article 8 IV. Pursuant toNo 3. of the PPP n/a No Decree, the n/a pre-qualification Yes Pursuant criteria be article included are toTechnical13variants - No 2in of the theand tender PPP legal Law documents. : Afinancial and arr public-priva No According to n/a section 8 of the PPP Manual, Yes REOI mayto the Pursuant No comprise section 8.3.5.3 then/a following of the components: n/a Manual, PPP Nothe 5. Evaluation Contracting criteria.Additionna Authority sets a Yes According to Article subsection 47 of V of Article Yes the 68 of the PPP Article Public-Private Regulations, 50 Partnerships Yes of the PPP the procuring Law Article establishes prohibits entity 48 of Any the the may the innovation procuring PPP possibility establish YesIn Law: authority may of some a prequalification submitting be cases proposed. fromthe including questions authority requ phase in m for Section 153 Pursuant toYes Government Article Yes 28 of the Resolution Concessions Pursuant No.Law 476, provides to within Articlethe No 57 that of framework n/a qualification Government n/a of criteria Resolution standard Yes must documents No not 476, any of pre-qualification, unduly restrict competit interested econo t Yes According to ThereProcedure, the Concession explicit is no Yes art. statement 5.1.1, According in this "the to No the regard. commission Standard However, shall n/a RfQ Document, then/a prepare the preliminary Section Standard RfQ NoDocument 3.4.1, tender bidder provides shall "adocuments detailed a in accord submit Yes According to According the Concessions to Law, Article Yes the Concessions 38(3), According Law, for the to No Article Article two-stage 38(4), procedure, 95 n/a paragraph1 “the pre-qualification “the n/a of Competent Public Procurement criteria No must Authority Law:" shall be set, set The in in an the objecti publi bidder has Yes Article 17 of Article the PPP Decree provides 17 of Yes that the PPPprequalification Decree Article provides 20(3) Noofthat and attribution the PPP prequalification n/a Decree permits n/a criteria areany and mentionned candidate attribution No criteria in to submit the must tender questions bedocuments objective, n to th No According to of Decree no. Article 47 n/a Yes5/2016, the Article 49 of Bidding Documents NoDecree no. n/a must 5/2016, (applicable n/a specify the qualification byYes way ofrequirements. Additional Article 14 of the PPP Reg Noa bidder, n/a In the case of Yes criteria the qualification According set forthto in Nothe bidding section 16. n/a (1) documents n/a or where of the Public Procurement No prequalification Act, where any bidder, proceedings havb Article 2.90 Pursuant toYes of the The Proportionality Procurement Yes Act, Questions Guide (Gids the qualification Proportionaliteit), and Yesclarifications criteria Article which are are2.83 set allowed out This provides of the in can under a manner be Public mandatory Yes related Article Procurement that either 2.53 guidance is clear ofto the Law contractual for and Public allows unambiguo the applicat Procure for aspe Va Yes According to According the PPP Guide, Section to Yes 4.7,PPP the at the Guide, According Expression Section No to the 4.8, of PPP “the Interest Guide, invitation n/a (EOI) Section stage, for n/a the 5.6, "in order Expression "it is toNo inform important of Interest and that potential (EOI)a provide should basis respond not for s No Article 24(5) n/a establishes Yes that the procurementArticle process27 of Nothe could include PPP Regulation a n/a pre qualification n/a bidders enables NoIn phase. to such formulate case, the tenderto questions the docum No Article 32 of n/a the PPP Law (...) The pre-qualification provides:No n/a Yes notice shall Article 34 of contain at In the theleast PPP first the LawNo following provides: stage, candidates information subject shall to:- the a descrip submit to t derog Noof the Public Section 23 (1) n/a Procurement Yes Act provides Section 23(4) that No of the the procuring Public n/a Procurement entity shall n/a set out Act provides the Yes precise thatcriteria upon which en "The procurement it Article 81 of Pursuant toYes the PP Article 97(2) Law: Yes of thetender The Pursuant PP Lawdocumentation statesto explicitly Yes Articleshall that 81 of Article contain while the PPthe the 81 of Law: number The the following ThePP PP Law contracting Law, of potential as Yes does a minimum:- not underauthority paragraph bidders explicitly shall ifmay required, state 4, includes be bethe limited, obliged type the m the Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording to Yes the Public Rules, According 2004, Procurement Section to16(1), the Rules, Yes Standard "the 2004, According procuring Section Biddingto agency Alternative Form 32, the Standard for "save engaging BOT, as Yes proposals Section Bidding otherwise in pre-qualification are IB.14.1, Form provided, possible for prospective no "aBOT, ifshall they procurin Section are ann of the PPP law Article 4.15 No with definitions n/a dealing Yes Article already 33 of Noindicates: the PPP Lawn/a Bidding establishes: Documents. n/a"Period of Yes Set of consultations requirements unilaterally and dem homologatio Section 58 n/a Pursuant toNo Yes of the Procurement Act: Pursuant (6) A procurement Section 54 toNo n/a method of theauthorized Procurement n/a by theNo Commission Act: (1)At any time under prior this Act dead to the may Yes Article 43 of Decree 4183/20: Article"Content 42 of Yes theof the call Decree 4183/20 Article for pre-qualification 49 of provides Yes Decreethat Article and 4183/20: the Contracting the 49 "Consultation of The BookDecree of kind Authority 4183/20. of bidding and Yes innovations terms clarification. must Consultation and guarantee allowed conditions Procedures transparent areof and clarificat not the for pre re liste Yes 54.1 of the Articles 52 and PPP Regulations According Yes to the PPPstates Regulations: Articles that52, theNo 54.1.b. tender 52.2 Theand documents OPIP n/a 91may of themust PPP n/a at include in least Regulation the Tender contain Noestablishes (a) the applicable Documents the tender criteria that (Bases), rul mecha of the BOT Law Section 5.4 Yes prescribes Section of the 5.4 Yes theBOT Pre-qualification Law Pursuant IRR establishes toNo requirements Section the 6.2n/a pre-qualification of the of potential IRR, bidders. BOTn/a a bidder No Legal Ifrequirements. is in requirements, doubt We will asprovide to the meaning a quick Experience Article 21 of Pursuant toYes the Concessions Pursuant toYes ArticleLaw, 33.2the of the concession Pursuant toYes Concession Article notice 25(1) Law,Article (...) of the (which the is 37 part qualification of Concession The the ofdefinition the Concessions concession Law, criteria Yes of innovative the Law defined bidder orallows tender may by the for solutions request documents) variants: contracting the is open 3. pro m I Article 164Article Pursuant toYes (1) (h) 165 and of Yes (4)the of PublicPursuant PPP LawContracts sets forth toCode Yes Article 18, a set 50 of when parameters (1) Regulation of using Public a and 41 restricted Innovative Contracts of limits Directive to procedure Code solution Yes be2014/23/EU followed 18, with the with clarifications when exceptionally pre-qualification, provides as necessa high specifying thef t follow n/a Yes Yes Article 12 of the PPP Law Article provides No that 31 of the "[s]election Regulations n/a of successful 22aof 2016 n/a provides, bidder Yes "Submission shall be subject to the is of tender deem princip Article 51 of Pursuant toYes the Concession Pursuant toYes Article Law 75 (applicable Pursuant (3) to to of the Concession Yes Article open tender): Law, Pursuant 160(1) of the (1) the qualification The Public to1. contracting Article Contracting Procurement 45 andof Yes entity the authorities EU selection has Law 24 the and criteria Public may obligation Article must Procurement authorize 70(8) torelated be of orth rD indica Article 16 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a Yes The advertisement According to Yes requesting section 3.3.2.1 for expressions Article 20 of of theVariants PPP theof PPP guideline and Law Yes interest innovations. indicates: on in connection queries Where andwith theaContracti issue PPP proj clarificat Yes According to According section K.4.5. to Yes Permittedsection Qualification K.4.5. According criteria to No Permitted paragraph of Qualification the Treasury n/a 3.20Instructions, criteria of then/a Guidelines of the Treasury (3) No for The procuring Government Instructions, entity Procurement shall (2) clearly GW st Qualificatio Yes According to Per Article 2 of the Article Implementing Yes 2 Regulations, of the Implementing Accordingthe to Regulations, Yes contracting Article of the 64 Article (procuring) the contracting Implementing 64 ofArticle the authority Implementing 80 Regulations of Nois the (procuring) obligated authority Implementing Regulations the tois apply Tendering obligated regulation requires thePlan principl to the sha of app No Article 55 of n/a PPP Decree No provides information n/a about pre-qualification No criteria that n/a is available n/a Noto all bidders with legal, technic Yes According to According the PPP Law, to Article 20, Yes the "the procedure PPP According Law, Article for selecting 6, to Yes the "a PPP principle a private Law, According ofArticle equal partner to and 20, For the is "the fair either PPP the treatment procedure PPP Law, Yes a public projects Article includes for procurement without selecting 20, "the theaprocedure prohibition concession a private procedure part of eld for Section 42 n/a Pursuant toNo Yes (1) A contracting of the PPP Act: Section 47authority, of No the PPP conjunction n/a inAct establishes n/a with the that: (1) Unit, A No shall evaluate contracting the qualificatio authority, in conjunc Yesof the PPP Section 3.2.12 Handbook Pursuant toYes Section provides 14 that of the the GPR, According"Invite to Yes there section are3.2.31 limitations The PPP Expressions of the Interest" Handbook, to PPP The howHandbook, PPP Notice theunder Manual qualification should No the sections provides first include procedure type for 3.2.33 information of an information exchange and 3.2.34, may beon use of th e pr Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording to Yes the Public Act, According §102(6), Procurement for the toover-the-limit the Act, Yes Public §10 According (2), Procurement one ofto the If the concessions aAct, basic contracting (whose Public §48, obligations value Procurement "the Yes authority contracting is equal of the explicitly Act, to contracting or authority higher §47(1), allows "the than autho shall for cow E Yes According to According the Concessions Act,to Article Yes the Concessions According 42(1), "the [tender] Act,to Article Yes the Public 6, "a According concession documentation Procurement shall to Thethe contain Act, grantor variant Concessions Article inat aYes bids least 61(4), may tender the Act, process "if be information Article aallowed. contracting must 49(4), An ensure required original author "if tha b a gran Yes According to According the Procurement to Yes theSection Manual, Procurement Section 4.8, “some Manual, 4.3 No Tenders of Section the may n/a Procurement 4.8, include "<…> Manual n/a care must provides, specific beYes taken Eligibility "Tenderers Requirements, to ensure will that such at Eligibility times exclR asrequ Yes According to According the Concessions Manual, to Yes the PPA, art. Section 10.4.2, 17(3), According "the "any to Yes the requirement PPA, request for art. According pre-qualification 20(1), established to "aAlternatives Procuring the pursuant PPA, shall art. Entity No be to to76(2)(i), announced the shall this technical at "the the Articleand bidding or shall earliest publicized contractual be possible set fort we documen s Yes According to This process the PPP Manual, Module Yes is regulated 5, StagePPP through 1, Manual, Step1, the Yes Module RFQ number document According states 5of the pre-qualified must thatto "as Variant the enable part PPPbids bidders bidders. ofManual, the No mayto Thus, be bid process, present Module allowed. according the 3, section it isappropriate advisable to the 5.1.3, PPP toin M h a Yes92 of theArticle Article 74 and LCSP: The 74 and specification Yesss. LCSP;According Article of the 122 to minimum Yes LCSP, article and economic Article This 138.3 ofpossibility and the 116LCSP: LCSP. financial Variant has 3. According solvency The to bids becontracting Yes already are admissible and to these technical foreseen bodies provisions if established or shall in professiona the and provide tender relate a in t Yes on PPPsAccording The Guidelines to doesn't provide Yes the any PublicAccording Procurement guidance on to what Yes the Guidelines, Guidelines shouldAccording beSection contained on PPPs, to 3.12.1(f), Material in the Section the Guidelines EoI changes "pre-qualification 247, Noif a“the on toPPPs, RFP are decision was will Section shall allowed have made not instruction to 247,be subject have “<...> used a of the PPP Act Article 20.2No n/a provides Yes that the tender Pursuant toYes Article invitation shall 23.1 include of the While the PPPoption The “[…]allAct thePPP "the details to the Act Governmental related bidders does not No to to the specify suggest Entity partnership the may, innovations kind through proje of t inno Yes According to According the Concessions Act,to Chapter Yes the Concessions According 6, §2, Act, "<...> The to Chapter Yes award the Concessions criteria 7, §1, According "technical according Act,to Chapter Variant and the toConcessions the functional bids 10, Yes §11, Chapter mayrequirements "a be Act, 13, contracting allowed. Chapter §1 shallAn be must 13, authority stated §3, be"a innovative repo in con or s an No PP Ordinance Annex 4 of the n/a applicable Yes for both Pursuant open and article restricted toYes 16 of procedures Art. the22 PPof Ordinance, Variants requires the PP ordinance if on theNo the bids qualification authority provide are allowed has for criteria variants: provided through to be 1aThe inclu cand the te com Article 10 (5) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant Section Law, the toYes 78Pre-qualification Pursuant of t Resolution Article toNo tender No. 81,of 18 tender n/a documents the PPP documentation n/a shall Law: A contracting Yes should 1. contain the following not authority information: contain: 1) requiremen may, own at its a) Th No Section 39(1) n/a of the PPP Regulations Yes "39.-(1) UponNo provides:Clarifications approval are explicitly n/a of the allowed n/a under feasibility study, Section Yes a contracting 42 of the PPP Regulations: authority "Cla shall, sub No 1. Section 33 n/a of PPP Act No states that, the PPP committee n/a No issue then/a may n/a notification No the characteristics of private e to prescribed No Article 51 of n/a the Procurement Regime Yes provides: In 1. the the prequalification Noof pre-qualification, Incontext n/a procedure, n/a Article pre-qualification the53 No of the Procurement documents Regime provid shall be n/a Yes No Article 28 of the PPP Law n/a provides Yes Article that contracting 12 of authorities The thecompetitive may PPP Regulation only No imposeregulates on candidates dialogue procurement allows conditio for variants No Section 26(2) n/a Procurement of the Public Section Yes Regulations provides, 41(1) Yes "The of the contracting Section Public 42 entity of Procurement The the Procurement Procurement Regulations shall Yes state clearly Regulations provides, Regulations the qualification "Clarifications allows provides: for crite Alt of inno No According to n/a29(1), "aNo the PPA, art. procuring entity n/a shall ensure No n/a that suppliers n/a and No (a) have the legal capacity to contractors— No Article 14 b) of PPP Decree n/a states that Yes the tender According to Yes documentsArticle should14provide Pertaining (c) of Decree references to NoArticles No. comments 2016-772 such 14as No(d) conditions of and 16 20 June (d) of2016, of participation, Decree about No. 20 thea Yes Laws and regulations According applicable Yes PPPs toto Article usually 63According of provide the Highway to NoArticle generalPPP criteria 30(4) Regulation, n/a of the for during Health n/a the PPP participants to preparation, assess Regulation, Yes whetherexecution theycan bidders are and request appropriatcla finalizati No Section 23(2) n/a of the PPP Act provides Yesthat the Section minimum qualifications 5 of the PPP Regulations No n/a requiredpermits of n/a a prospective a bidder No for a project bidder shallto be specified request in t clarific paragraphsPursuant Pursuant toYes 13, 15, 17, toYes and Resolution 18 of Resolution 384, to participate Pursuant to No. Yes Section 384, in 25the pre-qualification Pursuant of pre-qualification Resolution ton/a criteria 384, a Section stage, 26 legal shall Yes of Resolution an be applicant included entity 384, in interested must the the inmeet participatin state tender partn at leas docu Yes Article 15 of PPP Law the Dubai Article provides, (14) of the Dubai Yes "Subject Dubai PPP Law toDoF paragraph provides, PPP No Guidelines, ofn/a (c)"a. The Article page process (14) 63,of of n/a provides this selecting context Law,No aaGovernment Project for the bid Partner Entity clarification will be subjec must, pro prior Yes Regulation 37 Regulations of the CCR 2016 states: Yes 8, 37 Limitation Regulation & 38 of of candidates CCR 201634.5 Yes regulate orthe of tenderers this CCR Regulation matter 2016 (2) establishes: The in41 Innovative several of contracting CCR 2016 (5) solution Yes aspects. Provided authority provides In particular, withthat as or an follows exceptional it has utility Regulation may been regarding requ level 38t limit Section 4.2.1 Pursuant toNo n/a YesManual and of the PPTA Potential Guidelines, bidders Yes evaluation are allowed A value to engineering submit criteria The as well regulation questions as assessment the Nomethodology to clarify is required the specifically to addresses procurement evaluate for all value them pr e projec No In general, Article of the PPP Yes 19 d)n/a Decree establishes Article 21 that No of PPP Law the tendern/a documents states: Presentation n/a must contain of the No offers- of indication Thethe offers main factors must inc Yes According to of the PPP Article 22 Article Law, Yes 23 of thethe PPPtender Law According documentation states toNo <...> tender article 14 must criteria n/a of reflect theshould PPP Law, n/a be <...> requirements clear <...> a private Nonot and to discriminatory. documents, partner confirming Theto, is obliged amot applica n/a No n/a Yes Section 4 ofNo the Tenders n/a n/a Regulations No "(3)If a person inquires abou provide that: Yes Article 38 of Decree 35 stipulates Yes 0as follows: “2.Article Contents 39.2(c) of a No of Decree dossier n/a of 35: “In case invitationn/a the to prequalification pre-qualification No documents A dossier have to to of invitation b According toNo n/a the PPP Act, Yes Section 22(6)(a), "theAccording pre-selection to Yesthe PPP Amendment bidding documents According to Act, Alternative the shall Section Procurement include (variant) No which 9at Regulation, least bids amends the following may be Section the allowed. informati Section 30 o 89(1) According to the Procurement Yes According Regulations, to Yes the PPA, Section According Section 81(1), 28(3), to Yes "the"procuring the notice PPA, Section According published entities shall to by 41(1), Alternative the "a anot procuring PPA, contracting impose Section Yes (variant) entity eligibility authority bids 46(3)(c), shall [pre-qualification] might inrespond "at terms the be ofallowed. opening promptly sectiono c n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No According to the PPP Law, Yes art. 21(1)(3), According Yes to the "the PPP Law, tender According documentation art. to No 21(3), "the the PPP tender Law, must n/adocumentation art. contain 21(5), n/a "a public <...> (3)shall requirements Yes partner not contain andto a thethe requirements professional tender commission fo an Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q22.2_4_TEXT Q22.2_3_TEXT Q22.3 Q22.3_1_TEXT Q22.4 Q23 Q22.4_1_TEXT Q23.1 Q23_1_TEXT and If yes, please provide indicate the 22.3. the timeframe: relevant If yes, If yes, legal/regulatory please 22.4. notwithstanding provide If confidential yes, theIf does yes, provisions: relevant the please information legal/regulatory 23. provide procuring Besides pertaining authority the If questions yes, relevant please provisions: extend to the and legal/regulatory 23.1. specify bidders, the clarifications, yes, Ifproposal and does notwithstanding provide the provisions: can submission procuring the theprocurin deadl conf au relevan n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 20 (4) of the Procurement Article 20 of No Lawthe and Public 33 ofProcurement the Procurement n/a NoLaw provides: Rules require (4) Bidders can re disclosing q Pursuant A bidder may to request clarification Yes Article 42 (1) within Pursuant five of the to Public days Yes Article Procurement before Pursuant the 42 (1) (3) deadline of Law: theProspective Article Public to submit toYes Procurement 42(2/1) Pursuant their bidder ofbids. may theto Law, Public The Yes Article request contracting Procurement 42(3) potential clarification tenderers of authority theLaw, Public of in may tender shall Procur any requre ca d n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According Until the end of the second to Yes article third of 51.1 According the of the submission to Yes Public Article Procurement period. 51.4 Articles of the Law, 51 Public the and No procuring 72 of the Procurement n/a Public authority Law, Procurement No questions has until the and Lawclarifications provide end second of thethat inter shalltb According At least four to days prior Yes to Decree No. the deadline According 118/2017 for the tosubmissions (Annex Section Yes I, 12, Section Pursuant of Article bids. 12.12), 12, toNo Annex clarifying article 12.12 I of n/a Decree circulars of Decree must No 118, 118/2017, the beprocuring communicated authority Annex at procurin I, the can issu least fou Pursuant The clarification of the toYes respondent Article 29(1) shall of the Pursuant be Procurement provided toYes Articlein 29(2) Law, writing Pursuant of the the within Procurement participant toNo Article two calendar 29(5) is Law, entitled n/a of days theto notice Procurement an No following explanation onthe theday contents Law, on ofin the which case of invitation the of the enquir reque to change n/a n/a Yes No Section 16.1 of the National n/a PPP Guidelines Yes Contributors Practitioners' Yes Guide havestates that: provided "PPP that projects the m "interac According Six days before to the bid Yes submission the Law ondeadline. According Concessions, to Yes the Law on §40(1), "if According Concessions, a request to Nois the made §40(1), Lawin onn/a a Concessions, "if a request timely No manner, is made §43(1), thein contracting a timely "in manner, authority the event theo of a corr Article 5.14 9 Pursuant toNo of the BOTNo n/a Rules: Prior n/a to submitting n/a No bids, a company Noapply to the Competition Com may n/a n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Guidelines, According Section to Yes the PPP Guidelines, 30.3,According "the Contracting Section to Yes the PPP 30.4, Guidelines, "themay Authority Contracting also Section Auth 18. issue, if n/a n/a Yes the Regulation Pursuant toYes of the Pursuant toTender: No the Regulation n/a of the Tender: 18. Clarification Nothe provisions of of the of 16. Introduction change prelimina n/a n/a Yes Pursuant toYes article 45 of Article the concession No 59 of Law, the PPC Law procuring n/a authorities No stipulates that the or contracting competent servicessh authority p n/a n/a No n/a Yes Art. 35 of the No n/a PPP Law provides: No the result of the exchanges shall be Pursuant Within three tonot days and Yes Article later than 56 Pursuant (2) five of the days Procurement toYes Article the before 56 (2) Law, expiry Pursuant of the Public the toNo of contracting Article time Procurement limit 56 authority (3) n/a for the of the Law, shall submission Procurement No the prepare contracting ofarequests Law, written authority if the forcontracting participat shall answer, and t pr n/a n/a Yes Yes According to the PPA Regulations, According toYes the PPA Section Regulations, According 34(3), "any addendum to Section Yes to 34(5), the PPA a bidding Regulations, "any extension document Section ofsh a 31 n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 40.VIII of the Public Article Procurement Yes 21 of Law (Law the Public Article Procurement 8.666/1993) 39 of Nothe Law establishes (Law Law on8.666/1993) Public that theestablis procure Procurement Pursuant Within 4 working toof days Yes Article receipt 79(3) Pursuant of of the the request, Concessions toYes Article but not later of Pursuant 79Law, the within than Concession 6 to four days No Article working before Law: 79 (3) of n/a days theWithin deadline the from Concession 4the No working receipt for Law: receipt days (4) of of the of Where receipt request clarification of applications but thenot or te req Article 10 days of the 34 of receipt Yes of thePPP the request. Decree Article 34 of No provides that the PPP Decree “[a]pplicants n/a provides may Yessubmit that “[a]pplicants Pursuant requests for to may Yes articles submit clarification 47requests of to the the contracting forDecree, PPP th au clarificatio n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No General rules on transparency n/a fairness of the and No process would apply according to n/a bidding No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article At least 10 days 18 of before Yes the Concessions submit Regulation: date toArticle 18.2 offers Yes of The the Concessions Ministry under the Asbidding mentioned of Public Regulation terms. No Works in 23.4 state above, n/a (MOP) the shall following: if the No respond Ministry "The toof the responses questions Public Works as well at (MOP)'s as th least 1 According Within 7 working daysto after Yes article 53 Article of the receiving a query Government 20 of (9 Yes Regulation calendar Article days) on the31(2) Procurement Implementation Law, Yes of Regulation the purchaser Pursuant ofon theshall Government to the Yes article Implementation give replies 11Procurement ofwithin theof PPP7 working the Governme Law prov day Procuremen n/a n/a Yes of the Public Article 30.4Yes Article Procurement 30 of Yes Public theLaw (80 Procurement of 1993): Article 30 of within Yes the Law the (80term Publicof Procurement 1993) of the numeral Law4any tender, co (80 n/a n/a Yes Article 37 of No n/athe Contracting the PPP Law: Yes Authority Articleshall 36 ofYes the PPPwithin respond Law provides the time that a con limit set n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No 7 Yes Article 60 of Procurement the Public Article Yes 60 of the Regulations Public Article Procurement states 60 inYes of the Regulations its Public third paragraph: It Procurement isfurther possible regulates the to clarifications No conduct that Regulations aif conference at states the as request in its with second a consequence t ofth n/a n/a Yes Article 68.3 Yes of the public Article 68.4 No of the procurement provides Public n/aprocurement that No Codeto if, in response provides a candidate's written that “If, during Article With no delay, not but40 ofYes later the Concession Article than six Act days 40 (4 states days of Yes for thethat Concession low-value the Article provisions Act public of 42states No regarding procurement) thethat the public n/a Concessions provisions before procurement Act provides No the regarding deadline shall forpublic an apply extension for bid procurement mutatis submission. of mutan de the sh (four in the At least fiveAccording to Yes case the Public of a shortened Procurement According to deadline) Yes the Act, §180(5), working PublicAccording Procurement for days before to the No concession the Act, Public the bid §180(5), n/a award Procurement submission forprocedures the Nodeadline. concession Act, §180(5), “§96award This to §100 corresponds for the procedures shall concessio apply to "§a m According No later than before Yes six days to the EU the Concessions According expiry Directive, to of the Yes deadline the EU art. for According 34(3), Concessions submitting "provided Directive, to Noan section application that art. 93(4) it n/a 34(3), hasor of the a been "provided bid. Public requested No Procurement thatin itgood time, Act, requested has been the “A contr contra n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article No later than 75% 20, of the paragraph Yes deadline for I of According Law submitting 340-06 toNo Paragraph proposals. n/a provides: Participants III of Article Yes 55 may Law Article 340-06 of request clarification 53 the Yes consultation of Lawfrom 340-06 states thephase bidding consists that, entity rega of th previou n/a n/a Yes Article 66 of No n/a the PPP Regulations Yes (Executive Decree Article 62 of 1190) Nothe PPP Regulations provides (Executive D that "The administrativ n/a n/a Yes According to Yes article 21 of According Law, the PPP to Article Yes the Administrative 53 According of the PPPto Executive NoArticle 50 Authority inof Regulations coordination, the Executive "Before with the th Regu n/a n/a Yes Article 40 of Yes the PPP Regulations (regarding No Art. 41 of the PPP Regulations consultations n/a No and clarifications mentions: of tendering "If the contracting do instituti n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According Three working days, but to Yes the at least six PublicAccording Procurement (four in the to Yes the Act, casePublic of §46(1), According Procurement emergency) "the contracting days to No Act, the before Public §46(1), authority the n/a Procurement bid "theor submission contracting entity NoAct, makes §138(1), authority deadline. clarifications "When or entity pertainin make creating, n/a n/a Yes Yes of the Section Section 16.12.1. Procurement 16.12.4 Yes Directive PPP provides, of the Procurement Proclamation "As No provided addresses Directive in article provides, questions "Where 39 of the a Pr Pu only i Pursuant Not later than toor, six days Yes Section in the56 case of the of the Public Pursuant to accelerated Yes Section Contracts procedure, 56 of and Pursuant the Concessions to not No Public Section Contracts later Act:56 In thann/a of and the four the case days Public of Concessions NoContracts a Act: In restrictedand the procedure, Concessions case of a restrict the Act: cont According Within 6 days to before the Yes Article deadline for Art.the R.2132-63 of of bid's the theYes submission. Public PublicAcquisition Article R2151-4 Procurement Code Code, Yes provides: [Extension the additional procuring of time Articles R.2151-3 information authorities Yes limit for andon receipt R.2151-4 shall the respect tender of tenders] the further princi Articl (1 ) documen in n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No 1 day Article 8(1)n/a Pursuant toNo of Decree No. Yes 12, prior According to the award Yes to of the Article 12^1 tender Pursuant (9)status of the “announced� Article toNo Public Procurement 21 (3) of to Resolution the electronic Law, after te No.th4 According At least six days to before the the Yes bid Concessions According Ordinance, submissions to No deadline. the Concessions §18), n/a "a concession No grantor Ordinance, "a shall §18, n/aconcession provide No grantor all shall provide companies all comp participating in a Section Within a period 41 of at least of Yes 7 days the before PPP Act Section provides: the 41deadline Yes "Prequalification of the PPP forAct submission. This provides: is stipulated proceedings Yes "Prequalification by 41. Section Section (1) 53 The proceedings contracting 42 of the of Yes the Public PPP 41. authority Act (1) states: The Procurement shall contracting "Prequalific respond Law.Submto au Article At least six days before 67(2) Yes the o of the bid submission Public According Procurement to Yes Article deadline. Law 11 Pursuant provides of the Joint toYes that Article Ministerial if requested 45 of While Decision in Concessions the theNo PPP Yes 117384/2017 Law sufficient time, Law, and the the Concessions contracting (GG procuring Β 3821/31.10 author Law do n Article Any clarification 61 of regarding Yes the the tender PPP law. According It documents states: toArticle article No must61. 61 finish n/a of the Consultations 15 PPP daysLaw, Yes before and clarifications. thethe "both Article bid requests presentation. 103 Those of No and the interested PPP the responses Regulations in a tender shall regarding of avail be allian n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article days Within 5 calendar from of the 89.2Yes the PP bid Decree Article. submission provides 89.2 of No the deadline. thatPP additional Decree n/a providesNo thatmay information n/a be requested additional information No by bidders may be on the tender requested by bi doc Article At least 15 days 21 of before the thebid Yes General submission Article Bylaw deadline ofof 21 Nothe the PPP PPP Law: Regulatory n/a Decree Inquiries No to Specification n/a that the establishes Sheet the No answers and to the inquiries suggestions andof to the draft m According Not later than to 6 days before Yes Article the56(2) According of date closing the Public for to Yesthe Procurement submission Article 56(5) According of the Act: of tenders. to The Yes Public Article additional Procurement 52(4) According information Act: of the to Public The Yes Articles contracting Procurement should 56(5) be provided and authority Act, the 56(6) within of shall contra the apr P re Yes 15 According to Para Clause 2.8.1 of2.9 the(i) Model Yes of the RFP Model about Ruleclarifications, RFQ and para Yes of 173(iii)(b) 2.8"the the (i) General of Authority Rule the173 Model Financial shall Yes RFP Clauses Rules, provide (x) of the endeavour2017 that to General respond the Authority Financial provides, "In to caw resp n/a n/a Yes Yes According to the LKPP Regulation According to 29/2018, Yes the Attachment According art. to the 14 (1)(c), to one Yes LKPP the the Regulation ofLKPP stages Regulation of 29/2018, the 29/2018, pre-qualif Chapa n/a n/a Yes No Article 17 of the Tenders n/a No Law under n/a provides: "Clarification" No b) The clarification and replies n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Regulation No later than 34 Yesof the six days before tender theEURegulations Concession deadline. Yes 33(5) 2017of EUAccording Concession establishes: Provided No (5)to 2017: articleProvided 47(3) that n/a of it has EU that been Regulations has itNorequested been2016, requested in a contracting good time, in good time auth contra n/a n/a Yes Section 24AYes of the Mandatory Ministry Tenders Yes Regulation of Finance Section Internal requires Order 14Aissued Yes of that theprocuring Mandatory Instruction authorities 7.4.3.1 Tenders Regul on the publi Pursuant No later than before six daystoYes Article the 74deadline Article (4) 74 of theto Public (4) submit Yes the bids. Public of Contracts Pursuant Code, Contracts toYes Article “[p]rovided Code 79 provides that of Pursuant the it has Public been that disclosure to Article Contracts Yes requested 165 of Code: this (3) inof information 3.Contracting the time, good Cont is au do Publicaddit n/a n/a Yes According to No n/a the Procurement Yes Handbook, Volume According 2, Appendix Yes to the 8, Procurement Section A8.3, Handbook, "<…> the r Vo n/a n/a Yes No of the Process Section 4-1-(8) Yes (provided, n/a Guideline Frequently however, Asked No that the procuring Question authority Section w of the PF n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 23(a) of the PPPArticle Regulation 23(c)provides of the PPP Yes that Article Regulation the PPP 23(A) Yes stipulates of theTechnical Project PPPthat Regulation the Committee PPP Projecttha Te stateswill Article 37 (4) 3 Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toYes Article Law, within Pursuant 37(4) of three the days within toYes Article three from 37(5) days the moment offrom Pursuant the PPP the of toNo Article Law, date of registration the 37(6) registration tender of of such the organizer aof request, PPP the Law, reque has the th t n/a n/a No n/a Yes Yes The PPP Regulations Section provide for 50(2)(j) anYes extension of the of the PPP deadline Act pursua provides that Article At least four weeks before 122 Yes of the bid PPP Basic Pursuant Plans submission to deadline. provides No Article 122(1) for n/a a time of PPP of the NoBasic four weeks before n/a Plans, (1)the Thedeadline No for authority competent shall endeavo the submission of a pro n/a n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 33 of Pursuant the PPPtoNo Article Law: 1. The 33 of Public n/a the PPP Law: No 2. Authority Any may, on change its own initiative shall be immeor n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 32(2) Executive of the PPPArticle 33 of Regulations No the PPP Executive provides, n/a "The No Investors Regulations may submit provides: inquirie The Authority m 5 Yes According to Article 13 of the PPP Law, According the Public to Yes Article Partner 13 According of has the the Law right to on Noto PPP, Article accept the 13 n/a of or amended reject the Lawchanges request on No PPP, for tointhe the proposals event of request for for change proposa aparticipa n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 18(8) Within five working Yes days of (seven the PPP calendar Law provides, Article 18(8) days) Yes but of <...> the not flater PPPthe Article Law tenderer than provides, six days 39(9)has No of <...> the requested (eight f the PPP calendar n/a Law tenderer additional provides days) has No information for before requested extending additional regarding the deadline the deadline for the informa requ the su for n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Pursuant 6 days before toYes the deadline Article for 33 bidof Pursuant the Lawto on submission.Yes Article Concessions 34 of the and Article Directive 33(5) Article Yes of36 Concessions of the 2014/23/EU Pursuant Public of LawProcurement to the provides European Yes Article forLaw. Parliament the 31(2) and extension "<...> (19)the andto the ofthe the Con ofbidding m dC n/a n/a Yes Pursuant toNo article 15 of n/a the PPP Decree n/a relatedNo No 2017-149 to open tendering, complement n/a n/a Yes No According to the PPP Manual, n/a No Procedure n/a #3.15: & Responding to Bidders’ Questi ReceivingYes n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No 0 No n/a No n/a n/a Yes provides: If Art. Art. 8.3.5.2 Yes the 8.3.5.2 Contracting Yes provides: If Section thereceives Authority Contracting 8.3.5.2 Yes any Authority question Of receives guide the PPPfrom a note bidder any quest after provid days (ten 14 calendarArticle business Yes 48 of the PPP days Law Article and article prior to the 45 and Yes date 70 50ofset thefor Article PPP establishsubmitting that Regulations. clarification 48 Yes of the offers) PPP Thewill modifications Article Law and be provided article 50 of the must Yes in PPP 70 of clarification be thenotified LawPPP establishes Regulations meetings. to bidders theprov at pos Accole The No later than timeframe 7 days Yes isthe before deadline delineated According under for the No to Section submission Section 59 58 n/a of ofGovernment Government of Resolution n/a 476: bids. No Resolution No 476, 58. No thepublic The partnerhas publicpartner an obliga is obliged to n/a n/a Yes Yes According to the Standard According RfQ Document, to Yes the Concessions According Section Law, 3.4.2, to "<…> Yes art. thethe Standard chairman 13.8, RfQof "the eligible Document, the persons CommisSe m No n/a Yes No According to Article 95,n/a paragraph No n/a No 2 of Public Procurement Law: "Depending on the type o n/a n/a Yes Article 20(3) Yes of the PPPArticle Decree obliges 13 No of thethe PPPprocuring n/a provides Decree No that authority to the disclose competent authority questions and cl According Responses should to Yes articlewithin be provided of Decree 49 According the second no. to No 5/2016, third 49 article the n/a of Decree of clarifications deadline no. Noset 5/2016, for the necessary n/a for submission clarifications the proper Nonecessary of proposals. for theand understanding interpreta proper unders n/a n/a Yes section 16 n/a Pursuant toNo Yes of the Public Procurement Pursuant Act, the toYes Public 13 Article of the Entity Public shall to comm haveProcurem This no later than days 10 is before Yes under regulated bid submission Disclosure Article 2.54 ofof any Yes additional the Pursuant Procurement information Act: toNo Art 2.54 1A regarding of n/a the Public the contracting authority tender Procurement No that shallis communicated Law:further provide informa to a bid 1A contracting a n/a n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Guide, According to No Section the 5.6,Procurement "responses n/a to questions NoRule 39(1), Rules, be agency should"an may unl timely and, ma n/a n/a Yes No According to of the PPP Regulations, Article 27 n/a Yes Article the clarifications 26 of Yes the PPP Regulations made allows pre- by the procuring aut n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Section Within a period of at 23(5) most Yes working of7the Public Section days Procurement 23(6) (9 calendar Noof thedays) Act provides: n/a Procurement Public The Yes response Act requires byPara. the procuring that 3.2 Part "The of Yes 1 entity response of the shall PPPbePolicy to given any acknowle withintha request a Article Not later than 81(6) six days Yes before of thethe PP bid Law Article states 81(6) the Yes submissionoffollowing: deadline, the PP Law Article The or four states answers 86(3) days the Yes offollowing: and in the the the PP simplified The modifications LawThe states so-called answers open theprocedure "technical Yesfollowing: and andsupplements the modifications dialogue," with In order publication to the used to to enable tende the for of a a t o According No later than to Yes the 21 days prior to Standard According the Bid Bidding to Submission Yes Form the Standard for BOT, Date. Section Bidding According to IB.14.2, Yes Form for the Standard "the BOT, According Employer Section BiddingIB.14.2, will Yes Form to therespond Standard for "<...> BOT,in written Section Bidding writing IB.15.1, to Form copiesany of for "at thB req Yes 7 Article 52 of Article Law 22 of 2006 (Public 33 of Yes Procurement the PPP Law Article establishes Law)33 provides: of Yes in its the PPP second Law "[...] Article Notwithstanding establishes: paragraph: 33 of Yes the"In PPP "[... the ]In theforegoing, case Law event establishes: the that, any contracting either query "Period as or pua n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 15 days prior 49 of Yes the openning Decree of the 4183/20: Article 49 offers. of "[…] Yes Both Decree answers the4183/20: Article to 49 "Consultation the of Yes Decree queries4183/20: and made Article by44 "[…]Both theof Yes bidders Decree clarification. […]Both theas 4183/20: answers well theas to any answers "Consultation the clarificatio to the q queries m n/a n/a Yes No According to article 54 n/a and 91 of PPP n/acomments No Regulation, No and questions are published b n/a n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Section 6.2n/a of the IRR, Yes If a bidder is in doubt Pursuant toas Yes Section to the meaning 6.3 of the BOT of data anyIRR: orpr For r Based Not later than on Article six days Yes 25 before the of bid Pursuant the Concession toYes submission Article deadline. Law,25 if the Article of the Article request Concession 37 135for Yes of the of providing the Concessions Law, Public the Pursuant additional Procurement procuring Lawtorequires Yes Article information authority Law136(1) the provides contracting ishas obliged of been thePublic the to following: received authority provide Procu b 2 Article No later than 34.5 six days Yes of thethe before EU tender Concession Pursuant deadline. to 2017 Yes Article 50 (4) Pursuant (Directive 2014/23/EU) of Public toNo Contracts Article establishes: (1 n/a to 3) 64 Code 18, 3. ofProvided Public clarifications No Contracts that and corrections Code it has been 18requested theto subm the The Article 55 of thetimeframe Regulations Yes to22 address 2016 questions of Article provides 55 of No and that the Tenders clarifications within n/athe two-phase would No Regulation provides be up tendering to n/a that thewithin bid procedure, submission the No two-phase "The date. receiver Article tendering of bid 31 procedu of the Te docum Pursuant In the case of concessions, toYes Article at least 15 of the 160 Pursuant days Public before toYes Procurement the deadline Article160 Pursuant (3) Law: of the to submit (1) to Public No Article Anybids. interested 153 n/a Procurement of the economic Law, Public No the Procurement operator contracting hasauthority/contra the (1) Law, The right requ to cont working days Whin three According to Yes section from the According day of 3.3.2.1 of the thereceipt No to section PPP 3.3.2.1 n/aonof guideline queries theYes PPP guideline and According issue on queries to Yes clarifications: section and Theissue Contracting 3.3.2.1 of the Authority PPPThe clarifications: (C C guide n/a n/a Yes Yes According to paragraphAccording 3.21 of the toGuidelines paragraphAccording Yes 3.21 for Government of the toGuidelines paragraph Yes for Procurement 3.21 Government ofGWGS, the Guideline Proc Any a n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 116 of the Implementing Article 74regulation of Yes the Implementing Articles of the PSP Law 122 Regulations Yes - requires 124 of states that the Implementing Information the minimum Regul on exa req n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No No Article 83 of the PPP Decree of 2021 provide According Within three days from to Yes the theday PPPof Law, receipt According Article of such to Yes 20,the "the request. PPP Law, procedure According Article for selecting 20, to Nothe "the PPPa private Law, n/aArticle procedure for selecting 20, Nois partner "the either procedure a private partner a public procurement for is eithe selecting a n/a n/a Yes Section 47 of No n/a the PPP Act Yes establishes that: (2) Section A contracting 49 of No authority the Procurement Public and Act pro the Unit shall ind n/a n/a Yes Yesof the PPP Section 3.2.32 Pursuant Handbook toYes Sections requires the Section 3.2.36 and GPE 3.2.12 (Government 3.2.37 Yes(d) of of the Procuring PPP the PPP Handbook, Handbook Entity) to prov whenere According At least six (four to - in theYes case the Public of emergency) Procurement According to Yes daysthe Act, before Public the §48,According Procurement "the deadline contracting tofor the Yes Act, bid Public authority submission. §48, Procurement such According shall reply without Yes tothe to a Act, request Public delay §21(4) provide for (b), Procurement clarifications "the an contractin Act,from §2 explanati in an emergency Six (or four According Yes to the Public situation) According Procurement to days before Yes the Act,Public the Article deadline According Procurement 61(4), for"if the toNo athe bid Act, contracting Public submissions. Article n/a Procurement authority 61(4), "ifNo a contracting Act, Article receives the request authority 74(3)(b), in"in a timely order receives Section Within 3 calendar 4.3 Yes days receipt of the Procurement of Section the request. Manual 4.3 of the No Procurement provides, n/a "<...>Manual Requests Yes provides, for Clarification Section 4.2 No "In order should of the to ensure Procurement be made transparency later and no Manual prov than 7 fair n/a n/a Yes Yes According to the PPA, art. According 20(2), "Bidder’s/applicant’s to Yes the PPA, art. According 20(3), "a requests to Yes Procuring the for PPA, art. Entity 146, may, clarification, "where as whereneces well nec as a n/a n/a Yes According to No n/a the PPP Manual, Yes 5, StagePPP Module 3, section Manual:Yes 5, clarification Module 5, states "meetings that as part of should b Article No later than 6 days138.3 before Yes of LCSP: the deadline. According Bidders to may Yes request article information Article 138.3 of the 136 up LCSP: No to of LCSP: 12 The days contracting n/a before the Contracting authority No deadline authorities may shall for include submission extendin the the initial of bids.d tenderT n/a n/a Yes Yes According to the Guidelines According on PPPs, to YesSection the 247, Guidelines According "<...> on PPPs, the to the YesSection Project Guidelines Committee 248, "if on PPPs, in consulta Section necessary and n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According At least six days to beforeYes the the Concessions bid According submissions Act, deadline. to Chapter Yes the Concessions §11, "aAct, contracting 10,According Chapter No to the Public 10, authority §11, n/a Procurement "a or anNo entity contracting Act, Chapter shall, authority11, or at the Section request an entity of sh ap 8(2), n/a n/a Yes article 16 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PP Ordinance, No n/aauthority if the Nohas provided a candidate impor Pursuant not later than 7 calendar toYes Article days prior Pursuant 18 of to the the PPPto Law: No Article 2. for deadline 18 A contracting submission (2) n/a authority of the PPP of No proposals Law,shall the contracting n/a indicate in the No authority of the record shall selection indicate proced in the rec Section Within seven 42 days working Yes of from the PPPreceiving Regulations: Section the 42 of Yes question "Clarification the PPP Regulations: Section of applications "Clarification Yes 13 of thefor PublicSection Procurement of applications 40(2) Yes pre-qualification:of Regulations 42.-(1) the for pre-qualification: PPP A contracting Regulations stipulates authority that: 42.-(2) "13 provide n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No According to Article 53(3) n/aof the Procurement Yes Regime Article 63 theYes of reply the Procurement to any request Regime provid that may be n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Section No later than 2 days41(2) prior Yes tothe of deadline theProcurement Sectionfor 41(3) submission Regulations Yes of Section provides bids of the Public or Procurement 41(5) that proposals. No the of the Regulations contracting Public n/a Procurement entity No provides, shall "Responses Regulations respond promptly provides to and requests "If for in nec w n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes According to Yes Article 14According (c) of Decree No to Article22 No. 2016-772 of n/a of 20 Decree June No. No2016-772 2016, about of 20the conditions June 2016, aboa According As per the Highway to PPPYes Regulation Article 11 Article - at of the least Highway 11 15 of Nodays thePPP Highway before Regulation, n/a PPP the bid Regulation the submission administration No anddeadline. Article n/a shall 30(4) AsbeNo of per authorized the theHealth to Health PPP PPP make Regulation Regulation any kind-of at sta n/a n/a Yes Yes Section 12(3) of the PPP Section Regulationsthe 5 ofYes PPP Regulations provides Section that a Contracting 13 of Nothe PPP provides:Authority (5)Regulations For the is purposes required provides of is to t su Pursuant within 7 working to days from Yes Section the 25 dayof of Pursuant Resolution appeal topublication Yes Section 25 tender 384, the of Resolution commission According No to Section 384:All must such 26n/a of provide appeals Resolution anNo regarding explanation 384, the the provision public and publish partner of it clarific has th onth n/a n/a Yes Yes DoF PPP Guidelines, The Page 63, Dubai under Yes PPP Manual the Article on p.152 bid clarification 16provides process of Yes the Dubai that it PPP "[t]he is statedLaw that Government provides, "a. E "If the resp Regulation No later than 6 days before 34.5 Yes of the tender the CCR Regulation 2016 submission establishes: 34.5 Yes of the(5) CCR Regulation deadline. 2016, 3) Provided No 41 that During of it CCRthe has2016 been n/a concession requested No provides contract as in follows award good regarding time, procedure, contracting the award aut cont n/a n/a Yes Appendix Fn/a Pursuant toNo Yes of the PPTA Manual and Appendix Guidelines, F Yes of all the PPTA Manual information and Guidelin incorporated in n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to Article 22 According of the PPPto Law, NoArticle a public <...>21 PPP Law, of the partner, one-s in agre n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Article 39 ofYes Decree 35Article stipulates 39.3asoffollows: Yes Decree “2.35 Article stipulates Distribution, 39 of Yes Decree as follows: modification 35,“3. regarding Extension and clarification of the Notices oft n/a n/a Yes According to Yes the Procurement According to Yes the Procurement Regulation, According Section 89 Regulation, (1), to"Athe Yes Procurement Section 89 Procurement Unit (2), Regulation, "" A procu shall, whereSe According No later than of the end to Yes the third Procurement According quarter of Regulations, the to Yesbidding the PPA, Section period Section According 41(1), 20(2), Yes to"the the "a procuring procuring PPA, Sectionentity entity According41(4), shall to shall the Yes"arespond respond procuring PPA, Section promptly promptly entity 41(2), may and in "for accorda modify in writ the n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According Five days before the deadline to Yes the PPP submitting According for Law, art. 21(5), applications to Yes the PPP "<...> clarifications Law, for According participation art. 21(5), to ofNothe the "<...> provisions PPP in aclarifications tender. Law, n/a art. 21(6), of the of tender n/a the public documentation partner "a provisions has of the tender shall the be doc se right Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q24 Q23.1_1_TEXT Q24_1_TEXT Q24_2_TEXT Q25 Q25.1 Q25_1_TEXT Q25.2 Q25.1_1_TEXT 24. If yes, please Does the provide the If procuring yes, relevant legal/regulatory If please provide authority no, please the require 25. elaborate: Does provisions: thethe relevantbidders legal/regulatory If procuring yes, please to prepare authority provide 25.1. Can provisions: andcriteria the evaluate submit If yes, other please athe relevant financial legal/regulatory 25.2. bids/tenders than provide price model If criteria the (non-price with strictly relevant other provisions: their than attributes) legal/regu and solely price in proposals a n/a No n/a Yes There are no The provisions that general requirerules financial Yes models Article in Article 22 31 of to the be of the presented Public Yes PPPProcurement Law provides with Law that: provid proposals. (1) Th No According to n/aof the DCM Article 50(9) No obligation 285/2021, Yes <...> for the the presentation Pursuant contracting toYes authority/entity Article of 55 (2) Pursuant a financial of the model shall is Public toincluded Yes not Article disclose Procurement 23 in of the tothe other relevant PPP Law, participants Law, legal the procu the cri prov n/a No n/a No financialYes model is demanded Accordinghowever No to Article pursuant 78 n/a of the to art. PP No Decree, 12 of the the Concession criteria for the choice Decree, th n/a No n/a Yes 60 of the Articles 59 and According Public Procurement to Yes article 82Law, of the Article determining Public 82.2(a) Yesof the documents PublicLaw, Procurement Procurement the to be bids of Law subm th n/a No n/a Yes It depends on the kind of According project and to Yesthe requirements Article of PPP Law 15 Accordingset to Yes the article forth in12 the contractofshould bidding Decree terms. 118/2017, be For e awarded n/a No n/a Article 6(3)Pursuant Pursuant toYes to and (4) of the Yes Article 34(1) Pursuant Procurement Law, of the Procurement to the Article Yesbidder (2) Law, 34mustof satisfy the thebids Procuremen are the evalu qualific Yes n/a Yes Yes According to Section Section 5.3.4 of the 6.7.5 National Yes of thePPP NSW PPP Guidelines Guidelines pro Volume 2 n/a No n/a PPP-related The existingYes According regulations to Yesdon't the Law on establish According Concessions, a requirement to Yes the §67(1), Lawto on submit "the Concessions, submitted a financial §55(7) bids sh mo n/a No n/a The applicable Yes regulations Pursuant do not toNo explicitly Article 5.16 require n/a of the BOTNo biddersRules: to provide The Chairman a financial of the Com model. No is made Such notification n/a A financial via uploading model Yes of the minutes is developed theAccording meetings byto aYes to the the PPP Data contracting Guidelines, room. According authority Thus,to according (or Yes the consultants SectionPPP 23.4, Guidelines, to"applications thehired PPP Guidelines, by Section shall it) the no at 24. n/a No n/a Yes The legal framework According does not reference to Yes a need paragraph 47 toof submit the Pursuant to Regulation Article a financial No of 22 on model the Tender, PPP with the proposals Law: 1. To d commit n/a No n/a Yes can be A financial model Art. part 46. of 1.Yes § the proposal but Art Concessions are there 55awarded of Concession is Yes legal noton theLaw: requirement. basis The of the award criteria crite are lin n/a No n/a Yes that inArt. Art. 22 provides case 37 ofof an unsolicited Yes the provides: Art. 37 PPP Law offer, the ofoffer the the NoPPP mustLaw include, public-private provides: partnership inter the alia, public-p cont the e n/a Yes Article 17 (2) Pursuant ton/a Yes(b) of thePursuant Sarajevoto PPP Yes Article In (1) Law, 17 Pursuant addition of theto Sarajevo tothe No Article criteria 18 of PPP Law, defined thethe Sarajevo under private Conces partn Paragra No According to n/a the PPA Regulations, The existing Section Yes 31(5), PPP-related "the Secretary According regulations to theYes to the do not PPA, Board shall require Section According prepare submitting 64(1), to Yes minutes the "In a PPA the for financial evaluation Regulations, all pre-bid model meetings Section together and 72 an w adjudica n/a No n/a Yes of a financial The presentation Accordingmodel to Yes along12 Article Pursuant of the proposals with PPP toLaw Yes Article is not the examination 12 of a requirement the PPPof Law, the the in allbi propot n/a Yes Article 88 of Pursuant ton/a the Concession Yes Pursuant Law: to Yes Article (1) 103 Pursuant The offer consists of the Concession of toYes Article a Law: 68(3) proposal (1) and ofThe a binding the Concession offer.(2) Commission s L articles 47 n/a Pursuant toNo Articles the of the PPP Decree, contracting and 51 of the 42, Yes Article authority PPP Decree 52 of can Yes organize do the require PPP The Decree a conference financial evaluation provides No information that criteria prior “[t]he to listed thetoevaluation submission bein included Articleof ofin the 52 the ofs prop n/a No n/a Yes framework The regulatory does not Pursuant toYes article require30 financial Article aof 29 the PPPmodel Law: of Yes theto PPP The partnership be Law included provides in contract : The awa shal proposals a n/a No n/a Under the PPP No Law there n/a No is no such n/aduring the requirement Nosubmission of the bids. n/a No No No financialYes model is required SECTION 14 by Yes the of PPP the PPP law.Pertaining to Nothe :article Decree provides Any public 10 oftender the PPP the(La tolaw co n/a No n/a Yes The law does not address Section the issue 10.7.27 of the Yes requirement of the As set out Contracting for in Yes Policy, Section which bidders 4.35 to submit stipulates: of the a Supply "The Manu financial mo pri n/a No n/a legal obligation There is no Yes According for the toprocuring Article 24 Yes According of the PPP authority toto Law: require NoArticle thebidders proposal 24 Article and to is prepare evaluated 28 of and in thep n/a No n/a Yes Regulatory provisions require According an economic to Yes Article 7 of According proposal the Concessions but to do Yes not make Law: Article "The 7 ofaConcessions specific bid for reference Law the an workt No According to of Measures article 13 n/a on issue This Questioning isYes not regulated to andPPP Complaining Procurement in Yesabout 2014, the regulatory framework. Government According article 12 However, Procurement, -Yes to the evaluation The Regulations a financial Directive group on the model should 94 Impleme may of Min con be No Article 30 of the Public n/a Procurement The regulatory Law Yes (80 of 1993) framework numeral According 4 contemplates does to not include Article 30 Yes such carrying In numeral accordance a requirement 6 of out a hearing Law Yes 80 with article in of order 1993 12.2 toof the proposals Law 1508t determine o m No Article 37 of n/athe Contracting the PPP Law: doesn't The lawAuthority Yes require shall respond Article it. within 30 Yes the that provides timeArticle the limit contract 30 of set No by the the is awarded PPP implementing Law to states the measures that the con qualified to can n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 41 According of the Procurement to Yes Code: Article 82 of the The According Public tender to YesProcurement documents Article 82 of the must Code: Public comprise The public th Procure n/a No n/a Yes framework The regulatory Article does of Yes 55not state the Public that Article Procurement the procuring 55 of the Yes authority Regulations Public Procurement will regulates require the Lawbidd pro evalu n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 21 of Article PPP Decree No. 2018-358 21 of NoPPP Decree of 29, 2018-358 MarchNo. of Ma 2018 relating to n/a Yes of the PPP Act Article 4(5) n/a Pursuant Yesstates that the PPP toContract Yes Article 47 of Pursuant shallthe contain Concession to Yes Article at Act, least the 48 the of following evaluation the appendixes: of bids Concession Act, n/a No n/a Yes The financial model is usually According prepared to Yes theat the preparation Public Procurement According to Yes stage the Public Act, §183(1), as part Procurement ofas the part of Act, the con feasibility st §1 n/a No n/a The existingYes PPP-related According regulations Yes to do not the EU Concessions require According the submission to Yes the EU art. Directive, Concessions of a 37(2), financial contracting model wit "a Directive, a n/a No n/a The PPP Law Yes only requires According to Yes it for unsolicited article 23.5 proposals: PPP (related to Noopen Law article 22 of tendering) the PPP Awarding Proce and article 24.6 Yes Article 20 paragraph II Paragraph of Law No.II 340-06 n/a of Article 56 Yes states of that Law the answers Article 340-06 mandates 54 to the Yes of the questions the PPPpresentation Paragraph Regulations formulated provides: of III No of financial inarticle thePresentation hearing conditions 54 of the be to will PPP of be reflected offers. Regulat evalua O n/a No n/a There's not No a specific regulation n/a Yes it depends because According on the to Yes specifications article 12 of the of PPP the call LAW, each and th n/a No n/a Yes No provisions explicitlyArticle require financial 72 Yes of the PPP models Executive Article to be24 Regulations of Yes the PPP presented with states, Lawproposals. provides: The Adm "[t]he committee n/a No n/a Yes be required While this may Article in the 43 of tender PPP Law: Yes to According award documents, there a to contract Yes is no article both such objective a 43 requirement and andarticle quantifiabl 44 th estab n/a No n/a requirement There is no No n/a towards including No n/a a financial No for bidders. model n/a No n/a legal obligation There is no Yes According to submit to Yesa financial the Procurement model. In PublicAccording to Yes practice, the Public Act, however, Chapter Procurement 4, Division it might Act,§14 2,be re Ch n/a No n/a Yes framework The regulatory According does not to Yes state that article 28 (2) Procurement theof procuring the PPP YesProclamation, authority Directive Section require regarding 16.8.2. the bidders evalua t provid n/a No n/a Yes The proposal needs to be Pursuant given in Yes toa form which Section 122 According of is the in correspondence to Yes Public Contracts Section 122 with and (Concessions) Concessions what ofAct th have been Art. 3 of the Public Acquisition No n/a There Code are no provides: Yes buyers legal and regulatory Article L. [procuring 2152-7 provisions Yes of shall authorities] the imposing Article Public respectAcquisition L.such 2152-7 the Yes principle an obligation, theof ofCode:Public “The equal butcontract treatment the submissio shall Acquisition of Co n/a No n/a Yeslaw mandates Nothing in the According the procuring to Yes article 42 Art. of the authority 43PPP to of the Ordinance NoPPP the require Ordinance bidders (Ordinance (Ordinance to prepare No. and No. 009/PR n/a Yes Article 21(6) Pursuant ton/a Yesof Resolution Pursuant No. 426, Article the proposal/application toYes Pursuant 19 (2) of Resolution toYes Article No.19(9) 426, of submitted by theResolution the Selection participant Comm No. 42 n/a No n/a Yes No such requirement. The According financial Yes to the Concessions model is usually According prepared Ordinance, to Yes the by §31(1), Concessions or on behalf "theOrdinance, award of a contract criteria §31 No Section 42 of n/a the PPP Act states: "Prequalification Even though Yes bids bidders’ are expected Section conference 48 to (3) Yes 42. demonstrate of[...] the(2) PPP Clarifications certain Section Act states 44 financial (2) Yes that sought (d) the criteria, of by Proposal the PPPand bidders Act Evaluation even or states prospectiv though that t c Pan Article 47(3) Pursuant toYes Article of the 15(2) Public n/a the PPPYes of Procurement Law, under Law <...> Pursuant "FinancialtoStanding," Yes Article 45(1) the consultation provides Article process of the shall 50Concessions ofbe <...> Yes the following conducted Law, Concessions the inascertainment accordance Law <...> concessions provides withfo dess n/a No n/a Yes framework The regulatory According does not to Yes state article 53 Articles that the of the procuring PPP 52 Law: No authority and "The 53 award of the PPP will of require Law tender thethat thestate wi bidd n/a No n/a Yes The law does Article not require a financial 13 of No model. the n/a PPP Law that PPP procurement rules are b provides No n/a No n/a Yesauthority The procuring Article does not 55 of require Yes the the PP bidders LawArticle requires 73 to prepare of the Nothe offers PP Law to submit and be provides: evaluated a financial accordin the mo award n/a No n/a articles of the Among the Yes According PPP regime to Yes Article 25 As of stated in Honduras, there the PPPbefore is Regulatory Nonot article Decree, 25 of the an obligation PPPs forPPP the shall bidder Law Re be No According to n/a and 56(6) Articles 56(5) of the There is no Public Yes such legal requirement. According Procurement to Yes Act:(5) Article The contracting 125 According of the authority to Yes Article Public shall 76 Procurement provide of the Act: Public the additional (1) Procure The succ No (x) of n/a Rule 173 Clauses the GeneralThis Financial is project Rules, Yes 2017 and specific requires Rule any 173that (xii) Yes the of the requirementsrecords General regarding Rule of such 173(xi) Financial a financial Yes of Rules, the General conference 2017 model shall be would provides Financial intimated be that Rules set out bids to ali pr Yes According to the LKPP Regulation The Attachment 29/2018, n/a to the art. LKPP 14 (1)(c), Yes Regulation one According 29/2018, of to the stages Yes the Chapter of theAccording II, Attachment pre-qualification A, 5to (e) the (1) to Yes LKPP the listsprocess down Attachment Regulation the includes information to 29/2018, the LKPP (c) Chap to Reg b "provis n/a No n/a Yes There are no provisions Article that require 19 of the financial Yes Tendersmodels Article Law provides to of 19 No be the presented under Tenderswith Law proposals. provides under "Technical/commercia n/a No n/a Yes No precise provisions have According to No been provided, Article nor 3(First) n/a have contributors of No confirmed the Government that Instructio Contracts this is don n/a No n/a Yes framework The regulatory Regulations does not Yes state 36 that of Eu Concession Regulation the procuring 2017 67(2) Yesauthority of the EU regulate will thisPublic matter. require Sector the bidd The Reg regu of the Mandatory Section 14ANo n/a No specific Tenders provisions Yes provides Regulation require Section that:(a) 20Aof Yes Tenders the financial models Mandatory Committee Section to beTenders 22 may of Yesdecide the presented Regulation with Mandatory toproposals. make provides a preliminary that: Tenders (d) re Regula T Article 165Pursuant Pursuant toYes (3) of theto Public n/a Article 181Yes (2) of Contracts Code: the Public For Pursuant concessions toYes Article Contracts Code, to 95 be awarded the (1) Article of contracting the 95 using Public of Yes therestricted Contracts a authorities Public Contracts procedure, Code, shall award the Codethe contra provid award cr call No According to n/a the Procurement Handbook, This is usually Yes Volume done 2, Appendix in practice, According 8, Section to yet no the Yes A8.3, legal Procurement requirement "if According the Procuring to exists Yes theEntity Handbook, in Procurement Volume this convenes 2, Appendix regard. a meeting 8, Vo Handbook, Se to n/a Yes (9) of Guidelines Section 4-1 n/a Yes Regarding Article Process 11 (Objective of PFI also Yes Article requires Evaluation) 11to of Paragraph No submit the PFI a2financial Act of provides the PFI model Act for the in orde proc provide Yes Article 23 of Among the the PPP Regulation provides: n/a criteria"A. It requested Yes is permissible for pre-qualification Article the(C) for 29 Yes PPP Project andof32 bidder ofArticle Technical the accordance inPPP Regulation Committee No of 24(A)(4) the with provide to Article PPP invite that 16(B) the Regulation the prequalifie oftechnic the stipula PP n/a No n/a Yes requirement No such express Pursuant exists toYes for either Article concession 108Pursuant (4) of Order toYes projects Article No. 725,or the 103 PPP of Commission, Order projects No. in gener when 725, con No Section 38 of n/a the PPP Regulations. Section (1) A contracting Yes 51(1) of the authority PPP Section Actmay requires alter 54 Yes (2) of a tender a bidder the PPP document Section who Actintends provides (1) No toof 55 based bid the that onfor "the the PPP a outcome proposal project Act provides to of evaluation a pre-bid that th complete n/a Yes of the Standard Section 1.2.n/a Pursuant Yes RFP BTO specifies, toYes Article the form (3) According 79 of of the the financial PPP to Yes Basic model Article 123 Plans, to be of presented. the the PPP Basiccrite evaluation Pla n/a No n/a of a requirement No mentionYes Pursuant to to submit Yes Article 29 of Pursuant themodel a financial PPPto Law, Yes with Article The thePublic proposal 35 of the Authority PPP within Law:the 1. The shall ma PPP n/a Yes n/a Article 35 of Yes the PPP Executive Regulations Article 37 of Yes the PPP provides, "The Executive Article proposal Regulations 35 of Yes the must mainly PPPprovides, Executive include "The Regulations the Competitp following: n/a No n/a clear requirement There is no Yes for Pursuant to bidders Yes Article to of Pursuant the PPP 12prepare and to Law: submit No Article 1. At12 a financial theofstage the PPP model of qualification Law: 1. At and th thei n/a No n/a Yes Provisions in Article 32 the Procurement Law of Yes the PPP and Decree Article Regulation such provides: 32 as of NoArticle the PPP "The selection Decree 15 of theprovides: latter of the most are toosu "The s b n/a No n/a Yes There are no explicit provisions Article 42(1) in the Yes the PPPArticle Law of regulatory framework provides, 51 of Yes the <...> PPP that the Law requires Concession specifies financial Procedur models that non-p n/a No n/a Yes No provisions According in the regulatory framework to Yes the PPP Law, According requireart. proposals 7(14), to Yes"the toPPP the be project accompanied Law, committee art. 7(12), shall financi by"the o pr Yes Article 33(6) on Concessions of the LawThe n/a provides Yesthat CPMA Methodological Documents if the Pursuant awarding includeauthority Article the Standard toYes of 52prepares The the documents. Concessions a meeting Yes InLaw Concessions Law, with lists SectiontheII multiple economic on "Definitions non-price evaluation criteri o operat n/a No n/a A financial model Yes is required Pursuant to be prepared article 22 by toYes of Article the procuring PPP 18.Law No (PPP authority SelectionLaw of applications 2015-039 and included oninFebrua in the case o No According to n/a the PPP Manual, Procedure According #3.8:Yes toPlanning the PPP & Manual, According Conducting to Yes an the Procedure PPP #2.8: Investors’ Act, According PPP Section Conference, Project 49(3), Yes to the"<…> PPP "The Financialonly Manual, Feasibility Evaluation publiclyAnalysis, Committee known#3. Procedure fin inf n/a Yes the PPP Guidelines As stated inn/a No n/a Para 3.1 Box 2:Yes Typical Information Pursuant Required toNo Treasury PPP Proposals forCircular -A No.5 of busin 2007, t 0 No n/a Yes Article 16 of the PPP Decree Pursuant demands toYes Articles bidders from14, 15 and Pursuant various Article toYes article financial 17 II. 19 of of the the informations, PPP PPP Law:amongs I- Publ Decree, the b No According to n/a 8.3.5.2.2 of the PPP Manual, The regulatory Yes there isframework a written Section record mentions ofYes the 37(9) offinancial a the PPA meetingSection proposal provides which 8.3.4.2 is distributed but that No not every of a financial the PPP to the bid shall guide participants model. be provides: evaluated The pre th Proa Yes Article 11 of According the PPP Law providesto n/a that the 74 article minutes Yes of theof PPP Regulations theAccording clarification to Yes the Article meeting 52 economic must PPP of the be Regulations PPP proposal publicly Law Yes will"In include: set available the forth evaluation "(ii) the in CompraNet. The criteria financial of proposa m that m n/a Yes n/a Section 28 of Yes Resolution Government Pursuant 476 contains toYes Article 29 (2) Pursuant of requiring a provision the PPP toYes Article Law, the bidders 29 (3) the of tothe submitted include PPP offers a techn Law, for are e Yes According to the Standard According RfP Document, to n/a the Standard Section Yes RfP 3.5,Document, at the According tender to stage, Yes the Section 3.10.3, Concession " <...>financial According Questions Procedure, to model submitted Yes the shall Section be Concessions during submitted 3.10.3, the Law, pre-evaluat as art. "the Comm 13.3, part of n/a No n/a Yes The such requirement could According be one to Yes the of Concessions the tender According conditions, Law,toYes Part theIV, but Section Concessions it is not 2, mandatory. Article Law, Part IV, Se 29(2), fo n/a No n/a Yes in the Article There is nothing Moroccan8 oflaws the Yes PPP Law Article provides indicating that8the ofthat the Yes procuring PPPcontract the authorities law would provides that require be the the ten awarde n/a Yes n/a Article 14(1), Yes paragraph b), of PPP According Regulations to(Decree Article 56 Yes According 16/2012) (1) of Decree imposes to YesNo. the 5/2016, Article 40 presentation (1) the of Decree proposals of a financi no. 5/20 of th Article 13 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PublicThe Procurement regulatory YesAct, Bidding framework Pursuant does Documents not toYes section state be 10. tothat The the Prepared: 4) of Public procuring the Public Private No (1) Prior authority Procurement Partnership to invitation require Act, and to the bids, Investmen bidders bid, pre-q the t Pu n/a Yes of the DBFM Pursuant to Schedule09Yes Pursuant Standard toYes Article 2.113 Agreement, bidders Theofevaluation the Procurement are Yes required Act, are criteriaby the set the procuring out contracting in Article authoa2 n/a Yes n/a According to Yes Table 1 the PPP Guide, According "Indicative to Yes the PPP RFP Guide, According Response Requirements" Section to Yes 6.12, the "the PPP Guide, RFP under theevaluation Section Area of 5.13, plan "th Responc No Article 26 of n/a the PPP Regulation mandates The regulatory to register Yes frameworkmeetings does this Article 37not of in minutes the state Yes that PPP and Regulations According the toprocuring to them No send states article authority to that all 37 the participants. of award the PPP require criteria Regulation the shallt bidders n/a No n/a Yes framework The regulatory Art. requires 36 of the Yes aPPP financial Pursuant offer to be Law provides :to the No presented Art. PPP of the by bidders 36contractPPP shall Law along be Thetheir PPP :conclude para. 2.3 of Pursuant toYes According Part 1 of the to n/a Paragraph Yes 4.3 PPP Policy, a record of PartSection of 1 of the any questions 32(1) PPP Yesof the and Policy "All Public answers Section of the Procurement pricing 32 at the of Yes the pre-bid Public information, Act provides conference Procurement including that should financin Act "For be pro the e m Yes Article 76, paragraph of the PP 3 Article 3, paragraph Law n/astates2, Item Yes the following: 6 of the Article The PPPcontracting 109,Yes paragraph Content states, authority "Attached 7 Article of shall the99(2) PPdeliver toLaw the Yes of the states contract thePP minutes the laware following: states the of the that, conducte The the following m ap eva Yes According to According the Standard Bidding toForm the Standard n/a for BOT, YesSection Bidding IB.21.3, According Form for BOT, to Yes the Section "minutes of the Public IB.44.1, Technical Procurement meeting, regarding including Yes criteria Rules, at thecopies 2004, the information very of Section the questions least can to30(1), be provi be "alr use No Article 33 of the PPP Law n/a establishes: No "Period provision Yes specific of consultations require Articlealways and36 of Yes the thePPP homologation. submission Law Article Prior establishes: to of athe financial 37.3 of Yes submission the “Evaluation PPP model. Law ofand proposals, qualification makes there o it provides n/a No n/a Yes No provisions in the law According that required No to that the PPPa Policy: financial n/a 9.2.2: The No be model PPP prepared Centre and andthe Project w submitted C No Article 44 of n/a Decree 4183/20: "Consultation The regulatory Yes framework procedure and Article reception does23not Yes of PPP state of Law: that proposals "Evaluation Article the forprocuring improvements, 24 of of No proposals. authority the PPP Law, additions will In regarding require the instance and adjustme award the of bidd an ev n/a Yes of the PPP Regulations Article 58.4n/a Yes According establishes to Yes Article that winner the57 of the Article of57.2 theRegulations PPP bidding of the PPP No process Regulations the most will have establishe to pres favorable b of the BOT Law Section 6.3 No n/a IRR: Nothing The regulatory stated Yes at framework Section the pre-bid does conference 8.1 not Yes of the shall BOT require the modify Law Section bidders IRR: any 8.1 The provisions toof prepare Yes evaluation the BOT or andterms of Law submit bids IRR: and [...] aconditions financial shall be unde The Agenm Article 136(2) Pursuant toNo There n/aof the Public Procurement is no Yes binding regulation Law Pursuant for the open in to this Article procedure Yesarea. 6(3) In the Pursuant of (...), non-binding theThe PPP to contracting Yes Act, Article guidelines, the6(3) body criteria of the MFDPR shall forPPP draw Act, evaluation recomme up the of cr info n/a No n/a Yes framework The regulatory Pursuant does not toYes state that Article Pursuant the 70 (1) ofprocuring Public toYes Article authority 74 Code Contracts (1) will of18, Public requireContracts the bidd proposals sho n/a No n/a Yes No regulatory provisions Article nor standard Yes PPP 9 of the Law practiceArticle has provides: been 41 of established Yes theContracting "The Tenders to Regulation require Authority provides shallm financial p n/a No n/a Yes In the classic public procurement Pursuant to procedures, Article 187 Pursuant Yes of least, at the Public the toYes Article bidders Procurement have 187 the of to Law: present Public (1) Without an offer Procurep No According to n/a of theNo section 3.3.2.1 financial PPP Yes guideline model on queries is required Pursuant issue and by the to Article Yes clarifications: PPP Law. 21 of The theThe PPP PPP guide, Law, Contracting No section The Contracting Authority 6.4.1 provides Authority (CA) a list shall rev acceo No According to 3.21 of theThe paragraphn/a legal framework Guidelines Yes for Government inAccording the country Procurement to does section Yes GWGS, notC.8 provide According regarding [...]that any toEvaluation the additional section No procuring C.8 information, and regarding Comparison authority clarificat require of Bi Evaluationt Yes Article 124 of the Implementing Article 92.1.d regulation n/aof the of the Implementing Yes PSP LawPer regulation requires Article 2 of when Yes of theholding PSP the Implementing Law Article conferences, 89 of as part of Yes the the the regulation Implementing evaluation Contracting of the PSP criteria regulation Law,shall theshall Authority of con n/a No n/a Yes The law does not address Article the issue 58 of of PPP Yes Decree bidders'Article submission provides 55 ofYes of PPP that athe financial Decree Bid Committee provides model. for the shall foll proc n/a No n/a Yes is notAccording A financial model explicitly required to Yes the PPP the According byLaw, Article law being 20, to Yes mentioned "the the procedure PPP as Law, Chapter exactly for selecting same III, title a Article n/a No n/a Yes Financial provisions arePursuant set to beto in Section the contract Yes of but the 51 This is are regulated PPPnot Act, Yes required under (1) Section A contracting at the outset 49 of the and PPP in in authority, t Yesof the PPP Section 3.2.35 Handbook: A financial model n/a GPEs required is mayYes holdby a tender Section Pursuant 2.2.16 toYes briefing of during the PPP Sectionthe 3.2.13 Pursuant Handbook: period of the toto PPP 2.2.16 No Section Handbook, explain In 19 thegeneral, ITT Tender and the the suppliers documentatio various financial who info expert Yes According to Procurement the PublicThe n/a ProcedureAct, for Preparation §25(2), Yes"if a candidate, andAccording Implementation to Yes the or tenderer ofan Public PPPs economic According Procurement suggests operator to that the Yes aPublic Act,financial §44(9) who Procurement intends (b), modeltois "the contractin develope Act, §4 participat n/a No n/a Yes "financial The exact term According model" is to not theused Yes anywhere Concessions According Act, in Part Yes the to the4, related Public ArticleProcurement 50(3), "a grantor regulations. Act, Art However m n/a No n/a No provisions Yes Section or practice 4.1 require such No of the particular n/afinancial Procurement Manual No proposals provides, presented. to be“o Evaluation Crite No According to n/a Manual, the Concessions Usually, Section financial 10.4.6.1, Yes model "<...> According is prepared if some toclarifications the Yes as part PPA,of According the art.sought 80(1), pre-feasibility may to Yes "following the lead Concessions to the study a change opening by a Concession inof Manual, any bids, clause Sectio Ent the Yes According to According the PPP Manual, Module to n/a 5, Manual, PPP 3, Module StageYes section 5, According 5,clarification the RFP toYes the must "meetings require PPP Manual, According should bidders Module be to tosubmit scheduled the Yes 5,PPP Step financial Manual, well 4, at in the models Module advance, pre-qualifica that 5, at allo shout n/a Yes numeral 1, Yes Article 250,n/a of the LCSPArticle establishes 145 et Yes that the seq. the of proposals Art. LCSP 145(3) must LCSP Yes defines contain criteria The application afor "economic-financial the evaluation of p of more tha o Yes According to the Guidelines According on PPPs, to the Guidelines 0 247, Section Yes "<...> on PPPs, the According SectionCommittee Project 271(iii), Yes to at the in the Guidelines According consultation evaluation on PPPs, to Yes of the Section with the Guidelines financing the 257, relevant "evaluation on plan PPPs, Ministry, stage, Section wil the of"thi n/a No n/a Yes modelAccording Usually financial is prepared to Yes Article as 25.2 part of a According feasibility of the PPP study. No to Act, the Article 25.2 project of the shall PPP Act, be the awarde n/a No n/a There is notYes such explicit According requirement Yes to inConcessions the the concessions- According Act,to Chapter or the Yesprocurement-related Public 12, §1, Procurement regulatio Act, aut "a contracting Ch n/a No n/a The regulation Yes does not Pursuant toYes require for article a financial 28 of Pursuant model. article No 21 of the PP Ordinance, PPauthority the indicates Law, other criteriatm n/a No n/a Article 15 (3) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the PPP toYes Article Law, a financial 20 of Pursuant the PPP proposal to Law: Yes Article required, 3. 20 (1) where Pre-selected of the bidder PPP the financia shallcrit Law, co No The minutes are provided n/ato each tenderer The PPP Regulations in 3 Yes days from talk Pursuant the about meeting toYes financial Section pursuant capability, 372 to Pursuant ofSection the however, Public 189 to Section Yes (4) financial of372 Procurement the models of Public Regulations, the Procurement are not Public men whi Procure n/a Yes of the Details Clause 5 (5)n/a Yesof Invitation Pursuant Notification toYes Clause 15 (4) Clause requires the of the potential 15Details (3) No of bidders of Invitation the Details to present ofNotification, Invitation business Noti th No Article 63(4) n/a of the Procurement Regime Financial provides, Yes "4. models areWhen not Article as the 86(1) result explicitly Yes of the of the mentionedProcurement Conference in Article the regulatory 86 (1) Regime Yes it of is necessary framework. provides the Procurement to that The amend bidders required Regime or chang est arede n/a No n/a Yes The Law does Article not provide any 22 regulation ofYes the PPP financial Article forDecree 25 provides models of No that the PPP to all be Law presented bids states are assessed that by the the by con biddea n/a No n/a Yes framework The Regulatory Section does not Yes 51(3) of the Public ptorvide that Section Procurement the 56(1) procuring Yesof the authority Regulations Procurement requires provides, Regulation the bidd "Foll n/a No n/a The PPP-related No regulations n/a don't contain No n/a an obligation submit a financial model. toNo n/a No n/a Yes The PPP Law Article 34 (Law No. 2015-49 dated of Yes27 November Decree Article No. 2015 2016-772 13 of Yes of related PPP Law to contracts 20 June 2016, No. 49-2015 about between ( Law the the No condi n/a No n/a Yes Procuring authorities are Articles required 37, Yes 38, to and 40the choose of According the bidder Public to Yes Procurement Article which provides 40 of the Public Lawmost provide profitable that t Procuremen n/a No n/a Yes No specific provisions require Sectionfinancial 25(1) Yes of modelsThe the PPPto Act be PPP presented Regulations No "for provides, with the provide proposals. purpose of evaluatin in Section 17: (1 n/a No n/a Yes According to section 25Article of Resolution 45 of Yes 384, a bid Resolution No. Article proposal 384 of shall Yes 45provides Resolution exclusively an exhaustive No. include 384 provides of evalua listthe an follow Yes Article 16 of the Dubai Dubai PPP Law DoF provides, n/a Guidelines PPP "a. AYes Government section 4.2.2. Article Entity 22may of Yes the hold DevelopmentDubai preliminary of the Article PPPRfP Law22 Document, meetings provides, of Yes with "The the Dubai Request prequalified PPP Partnership Law for RfP, provides, Financial Commit"Th Partners t n/a No n/a Yes framework The regulatory Regulations does not Yes expressly 37, Regulation 41 of CCR 38, andrequire the 41 Yes 2016 submission regulate of the CCR of2016 this a financial matter. —(1) Concess In part model w Appendix FThe Pursuant toYes provision of the PPTAn/a Manual and Yes of a financial Guidelines, model is Pursuant explicitly all information torequired Yes Section incorporated forNon-price the 4.3.3 offinancial theinto PPTA criteria the No proposal Manual bidding examples and byas Appendix Guidelines, aare result provided of G questio the to inpr the A n/a Yes n/a Article 34 of Yes the PPP Regulatory Decree Article requires 28 of Yes the the presentation PPP According Regulatory of Decree a No to article finalprovides Financial-Economical 22 of the that theLaw, PPP regard Plan offers mu n/a No n/a Yes The financial According model is prepared byto Yes public 21 aArticle According of the partner atPPP the toYes feasibility Article law, evaluation <...> 23study of the stage. PPP of tender However, Law, pro <...> c n/a No n/a Yes No specific provisions require Sectionfinancial of the 11AYes models Government Section to be presented 7Tenders ofNo the Tenders with Act provides proposals. Regulations that: (2) Cons onIn add Yes Article 39 of regarding Decree 35,Article Notices n/aof Decree 59.2(c) of invitation Yes 35/2021/ND-CP to prequalification, According to Yes describes distribution, the42 article financial-commercial of According the modification Law: PPP to article Yes requirements and 42 of Methods clarification the and PPP including: Law: of dossie standards for " "Met e According to the Procurement Yes AccordingRegulation, to n/a the PPP Amendment Section Yes 93 (5), Act, According "A Procurement Section Yes to9,the which Unit PPP amends shall Amendment According prepare the toAct, Yes minutes the sectionSection PPP 31ofAmendment ofa9, the prePPP which bidAct, amends conference Act, among Sectio the According toNo n/a the Procurement Regulations, Financial Section model Yes is prepared 23(c) and According (d), by "if,to before Yes a procuring the PPA, the authority end According Section of the at 47, bidding to the "following Yes the Pre-Feasibility period, PPA, the Section opening a procuring Study 50(3), of stage. bids, entity "in Thu the additc n/a No n/a Yes framework The regulatory Section does24notYes of the Tender state that According the Rules procuring toYes states authority that the section 24(a)-(h) procurement require ofthe Tender departm thebidders t n/a No n/a According to the Methodology Yes Accordingonto Yes PPPthe PPP Law, According Assessments, art.section 19(21), to the Yes "a 9.1,PPP decision "a Law, construction art. of a19(9)(1) of a comm tender financ and (3 Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q25.3 Q25.2_1_TEXT Q26_A Q25.3_1_TEXT Q26_1_TEXT Q26_B Q26_C Q26_2_TEXT Q26_4_TEXT 25.3. If yes, please When provide If price the yes, relevant is pleaselegal/regulatory 26. used asIn one provide theof case the Please the where relevant evaluation provisions: specify only legal/regulatory 26.and The criteria, oneprovide proposal Please does procuringthe provisions: the is authority provide submitted, procuring 26. The relevantthe considers legal/regulatory relevant which procuring authority Please sole oflegal/regulatory the authority provide proposal following provisions: the a cost valid does relevant options estimate? provisions: not as long award best legal asda No Article 53 of n/a the PPP Law provides No that:(1) Then/a relevant Entity n/a the Tender No shall arrange n/ain a manner that allows all bid No Process Article 23 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Law, No Article 23 (4) n/a the criteriaof for the the PPP evaluation Yes Law, if any Pursuant of the other bids legal relate to Article No regulating act to 22(3) the n/a most of the the favorable PPP Law, financial in order concessions offer to cont fort establishes n/a No n/a Yes No Art. 15 of the Concession n/a No Decree provides n/a for a specific procedure: after the fir Yes Article 85 of Procurement the Public According No to article Law establishes 23 n/a of the Public the that No Evaluation n/a Committee Procurement Law theYes procuring shall issue authority Pursuant to Report Article a Finalwill on provide 16.4 which a cost of the estim it PP con No According to article 15 n/a of the PPP law, No the project n/a must be awarded to Yes According the bid considered article No Section ton/a 35, be the Article most12, convenient toDecre Annex I of the p Article 34 (2) Pursuant toYes of the Procurement Pursuant Article 28 (1) toNo n/a Law, ofthe thefirst-placed Procurement Yes Law, Pursuant the contents participant to is determined: No Article of the n/a 1) 38(1) of the the invitation number Procurement should of bidders contain: Law, 9) negot with su the Yes Section 6.7.5 Section of the NSW PPP Guidelines 5.2 No of the provides PPPin NSWn/a the context Guidelines No provides of evaluation n/a that the No bids that "Value ofResponsible n/a Authority for money will develop a Shadow takes into accoun Yes According to According the Law on to Yes the Concessions, §2(14)(a) Law on Concessions, and (c), “Criteria According No to §12(4), the Public shall "the n/a Procurement mean: (a) the NoLaw, estimated value §149(2), ofn/a selection a criteria concession "a contract are the criteria award must procedure establish be calculated n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes In case less than 3 (three) propos Yes According to the PPP Guidelines, According Section to Yes the PPP Screening 24.2,According "QualityManual, and to No Cost the Secion Based PPP n/a 2.4, Guidelines, Selection Screening Section No (“QCBS�) 28.1, Method: n/a "IFB: Condition Output 4: In<...> the event the Driven, Proposal that only "the tender or Bid ( one B n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 22 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law:3. The winner of th n/a No Art 55 of Concession n/aThe criteria Law: n/a No are linked to the subject No matter of the concession n/a No do not confer a discretionary fre andn/a n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo article 28 of n/a No of June 28th, Law 2016-24 n/a 2017, when less than three n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 19 of Pursuant toNo the Sarajevo Concession Law:(1 n/a Yes For example, According when evaluation by to the No quality the and n/acost-based PPA Regulations, Section Noselection 30(2)(f), n/a is used, then "any Noaccording solicitation document n/a to the PPA Regulations, issued Section by the procuring Article 12, Paragraph Pursuant toYes to According 2 of Nothe the ArticleLaw, 40, paragraph PPP n/a No the bid evaluation 2 (II) of n/a based the on technique Public No Procurement criteria n/a Lawmust 8.666/1993), (Law be the estim justified, objective Article 68 of Pursuant toYes the Concession Pursuant Article toNo Law: 73 (1) (2) n/aof the The Concession Yesshall determine grantor Pursuant Law: (1) The asto notice award No Article criteria of concession 117 of n/a objective the Concession shall requirements Law: have the (1) related The G minimum c n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 29 of n/a the PPP Law : The awardPursuant provides Yes criteria mainly toNo article 5 of relate tothe n/a the PPP overall No quality Decree, theofnumber n/a the works, of candidates equipment or for intangib procuring n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 8 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law (Law No. 2006/012 n/a No As set out in n/a Section 4.35 of the Supply Yes Manual, Pursuant "All evaluation Section toNo 10.8.10 n/a criteria must of be No Contracting theclearly n/a specified Policy, in the "When only one solicitation valid bid document n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 25 of the Articles 23 and Concessions According No to Article Regulations 17 n/a of the Concessions provide for a very No Regulation, specific n/a theNo way bidding of documents n/a evaluating the technical shall include an aspects official such thatb Yes According to Article 29 of the PPP Procurement Yes 2014, Regulation Notice on article 12, Implementation the 2014, evaluation Noarticle 13 group of - the n/a In the Bidding should caseconduct Law Nowhere provides no premore n/a - qualification that than the3 proposals tenderee inquiries may, are and submi inde accord Yeswith article In accordance value The12.2 ofof the No PPP the Law, contract, n/a the factors defined Yes byestablished article 2.2.2.1.4.3 According by the procuring to of No the article PPP 24 authorities Regulations, n/a of Law to 80choose of 1993 must bethe and included article best in5 offer o m the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to Article 82 n/a of the Public No n/a Code: The Procurement According Yespublic service delegation to No contract Article of the 30 n/ashall Public be awarded on theLaw, Procurement ( basis No Article 42.-Minimum n/a structure. TheNo public bidding n/a procedure No will be developed n/a No by n/a regulation, and the following minimum crit n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 14 of n/a Decree No. 2018-358 of March 29, 2018 rel Article 48 of Pursuant toYes Article the Concession 42 of No Act, the n/a the Concessioncriteria Act contains Yes beamade must ofknown mandatory list Article of 40 toNo all the potential Concession elementsn/abidders of Act the tender states and bethat given the notice, aprovision set of m including t Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording No to the Act, Public §183(1), Procurement n/a of Act, as partYes §174(1), According the concession"a award contracting to No procedure, the authority Public Procurement n/a"the shall award proceed Act, §184(1), inshall criteria be "§122 set accordance Yes According to According Directive, the EU Concessions No to the EU art. Concessions n/a Directive, No 41(1), "Concessions art. shall n/a be awarded 31(1), No on the "contracting authorities basis n/a of objective criteria entities and contracting which c n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Art.21 of the n/a that the Contracting Autho PPP Law states n/a Yes No Paragraph of article 63:n/a The tenderNo documents n/a No and, subsequently, n/a the public-private partnership contr No Article 67 of n/a the PPP Regulations No (Executive Decree n/a 1190)No provides that No n/a"The delegating n/a entity shall determine the award fact Yes Article 24 of the PPP Law Article provides: 24 of The the PPP Yes Administrative Law Article 81 Authority, provides: No of the Administrative The PPP inExecutive coordination n/a Authority, No with the Regulations in provides, coordination n/a PPP Central "[a] Unit, with single shall the bidprepare PPP mayCentral be the acce No Article 43 of n/aIn order No the PPP Law: to award a n/a contract, objective, Yes Article 44and quantifiable No of PPP easily Law: The n/a evaluation comparable award committee factors must be shall du n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording No to the Act, Publicn/a Procurement Chapter YesAct, 2, 4, Subdivision Chapter §140(1), The regulatory 2, Division "In the Noprocurement 2, Subdivision n/a doesn’t framework documents 1, §77(4)(12), contain for a awarding specific "unless pro ac othe No Procurement Directive n/a Section 16.8.2. No provides, n/a Yes "Selection of a successful Procurement bidder No shall be carried Directive n/a Section out 16.19.2.9 in either of the following provides, "Whe Yes According to Section 122 Pursuant (Concessions) toNo Section 102 of the n/a Public of the Public YesContracts Contracts Pursuant and Concessions to and Concessions Act: No Section Code, When announcing 119 (on n/a theConcessions) contract the notice criterion of theof Public shall contai C econo No of the n/a Article L. 2152-7 No Public Acquisition n/a Code: Yes shall be “The contract According awarded to Nothe tenderer Article n/a or, where R.2142-17 Public Procuremen of theapplicable, to the t n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 19 (9) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of Resolution toNo Article No. 426, n/a 19(2) of qualification Resolution No requirements No. 426, n/a the application No for the n/a for a public-privatepurpose partnership of the project shall be de concessionaire s Yes According to According the Concessions Ordinance, to No §31(1), n/a"theOrdinance, the Concessions No criteria award §2(1), according n/a "a concession §152 toNo grantor Paragraph n/a shall3calculate of the [PPA] estimated the are con to be give No of the n/a Section 59(3)(b) No Public Procurement Law n/a provides that No (b) the lowest n/a No tender evaluated ascertained on the basis of crite n/a Yes Article 50(2) Pursuant Law of the Concessions the toNoprovides EU Concessions for n/athe objective Yes character Directive, Article Article of non-price 12(2) 31(1), "contracting No of the PPP authorities n/a criteria: <...> Law provides the award and<...> contracting criteria "Limits on entitie <...> can ma n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Nothe PPP Regulations: Article 128 of n/a the project will be aw n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo article 54 of n/a Nothe bidding the PP Law, n/acommittee makes sure the mi n/a Yes No According to article 6 of n/a the PPP Law, No the Specifications n/a No must state Sheet n/a the cost estimate of the proj Yes According to According Article 76(6) to NoArticle of the Public Procurement 78 n/a of the Act, assessment Yes Public According criteria Procurement Act:1. shall Where to No Article contracting conform to 75 of the n/a the following authorities Public Procurement assess the requirements: cost (a) Act (1 Yes Rule 173 (xii) Rule 168 of the General of Yes theRules Financial General provides According Financial thatRules No bids to received provides Rule 173 (xx) n/a should that: of thebe General All No evaluated the terms, Financial conditions, in n/a Rules, terms the 2017 ofstipulations conditions even when andalready only inform Yes The LKPP Regulation According 29/2018 provides to No detailed n/a guidance theaAttachment No to the Bappenas on what administrative n/a Regulation №No 4, Chapter and n/a technical III,requirements A (2)(b), "a PJPK shall contain shall a ensure n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 24 of the Tenders Law pro n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Regulation 41 of the EU Concession Directive 2014/23/EU, No 2017. —(1) n/a Concession Annex No V, section contracts 4, regarding n/a shall be awarded No on information be tothe n/a included basis of objective criteria in concession which notices Yes Section 22 of Section the Mandatory 22 of Yes Tenders the Regulation Mandatory Section provides Tenders No that: 23 of Regulation the Mandatory (b) The n/a Tenders provides Tenders No that, Regulation "(b) shall Committee n/a The provides Tenders include Committee in that, the "(a) Tendershall Docume Where only includ Article 95 (6) Pursuant toYes of the Public Pursuant Article toNo Contracts 181 n/a (2)Code: Public Yes Contracts of theprocurement According documents Code: the to No shall article contracting 183 n/a (10) establish the authorities of award the Public shallContracts award criteria, contra Cod coherently Yes According to According the Procurement Handbook, to No Volume n/a 2, Appendix the Procurement Handbook, No 8, Volume Section n/a 2, A8.12.5, No "the Appendix 7,evaluation Section n/a A7.3(c), for works of bids"Bidding contracts Documents n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No of the PPP Article 4(A)(3) Regulation n/a Nostates that n/a the following Article 35(A) Yes will be provided of the by the PPP Regulatio contracting party Article 103 n/a Pursuant toNo No of Order No. 725, for each n/a criterion, Yes Pursuant the following parameters toNo Article are40(4)in of setn/a the the PPP Law, tender if only one ten documentation: n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 13 of Pursuant toYes The the cost PPP Decree, No estimate which all the has criteria n/a been calculated Yes into account taken during For solicited by thetheNo VFMproject, study process procuring authority n/a isto pursuant provided need Article as bea to82 objective maximum (2) an of the PP Article 35 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant No Article Law: 1. The 35criteria of n/a the PPP Law: No 2. The for evaluating and criteria n/a comparing for evaluating technical Yes proposals Pursuant and to comparing shall Article financial include,(1) as of 39and comme the P approp No Article 37 of n/a the PPP Executive Regulations Yes Articleon provides of No 40evaluating the PPPoffers Executive n/a that,Regulations NoCompetition "The n/a Committee provides, "In case of shall submission ofth undertake o n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 12(3) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP Law <...> to conduct n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 51 of Article the PPP Law provides 20 (Notices, No under Section forms) n/a5 that of PPP No thethe criteria Law provides for n/a that: tender 1)No <...> The evaluation are template n/a to be objectively comparable for the notification or form No According to n/a art. 7(7)(a), the PPP Law, According Yes "the project committee, to No assisted the PPP n/a Law, art. by the 7(13), working No team, "in case According shall less thanprepare three to the proposals a draft tender PPP Law, art.doc were 7(1 su Yescriteria for The non-price tender to Pursuant No evaluation the EU Concessions must n/abe objective Directive, Yes and justifiable, According Article 31(1),as "contracting to warranted Nothe Article authorities by 51 Article n/a of the52 Concessions and of the Concessions Law, contracting onLa t entitie n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 23 of the PPP Law states t No According to n/a the PPP Manual, Procedure Yes #3.17: According Evaluating No to PPPPPP the Technical Manual, n/a Bids & No Announcing Procedure #3.11: n/a Technical ReceivingBid Results, “scoring & Evaluating PPP Qu e n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a article 19 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a n/a No I- Public-private partnerships No n/a are No the basisn/a awarded on of objective criteria that respect n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Articles 50 section Pursuant XV, 52, 54 of the toNo PPP PPPLaw on Laws establish n/a article 14 the Yes that procuring the Article evaluation authority can 54 be No of the by points, shall PPP provide Law n/a costs-benefits, an allows estimation the procuring of theother, among monetary but authority Article 106n/a Pursuant toNo No Resolution of Government n/a No. 476, No n/a the public Nonot use criteria partner shall n/a that are not related to the Yes According to According the Standard RfQ Document, to No Section n/a 4.6.2, the Concessions Law,at No art. the13.7.4, n/a "the tender pre-qualification No stage, documentation "<…> n/a a technical and technological shall include cap the following: Yes According to According the Concessions to Law, Part No theIV, Concessions Section n/a 2, Article Part Law, Yes IV, Section 29(2), the 2, open forAccording Article procedure, to No 21(3)(2), the "the as n/apart Concessionsvalue Law, ofof an points open Part IV,procedure, shall Section be set “th un 2, Art No Article 17 of n/a states the PPP Decree, Nothat othern/a criteria may No n/a consideration be taken into No n/a by the procuring authority insofar as t No Article 36(2) n/a 5/2016 No of the Decree establishes n/a that when criteria No n/a other than price is used it must No n/a be justified. n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 26(2) Pursuant toNo n/aof the Public Procurement Act Article 2.115 Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the Public toNo theProcurement EU Concessions n/a Act, the Nonon-price Directive, art. n/a 31(1), criteria used No for assessing "contracting authorities n/a theand value contracting for money 1Award entities w Yes According to According the PPP Guide, Section to No5.12, the "<…> PSC n/a Guide, the Section evaluation No "the affordability n/a 2.8,criteria No threshold and evaluation approach is n/a should be disclosed determined to parties by refe participating n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 42 of n/a the PPP Regulations states that in the case n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Art. 36 of the PPP Law provides : No Section 32 of the Publicn/a Procurement No Act provides: n/a (4) All relevant Yes According factors, in addition to No to price, Section n/a 111 that of the will Public Procurement, be considered Go for the No 6 of the Article 99, Item PP Law states n/a Yes that theArticle criteria 15-d of selecting forNo the PPPthe n/a Law outlines most No favorable the procedure. bid must n/a be provides that, in thepropo It non-discriminatory, case Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording No to Rules, the Standard 2004, n/a Bidding Form 29, “procuring SectionYes According for BOT, agencies Part III "Bidding to Noshall the formulate Data", n/aSection Procurement anCode, appropriate called Answer "Special to the Stipulat Freq evaluation c of the PPP Law Article 37.3 Yes states: Article The of the 37.2 No tender PPP Law n/a document establishes: Yesspecify will “The contracting that Article the58.13 public No criteria of with Law entity which n/a must the 22/2006 states prepare technical that thethe reference procuring proposal valu will a be n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Section 62 n/a of the Procurement No n/a Act: (1)Negotiations shall not be carr n/a Yes No Article 48 (i) 4183/20 states of Decree n/a n/a No that the procurement Yesdocuments Article 56 shall of Decree include official budg the 4183/20: "Co n/a Yes No value of n/a The reference projects areNo included in preliminary n/a No n/a studies (Multi-year PPP Investment Report of the BOT Law Section 8.1 No Yes n/a IRR: [...] The Agency/LGU Pursuant concerned Section toNo shall 9.1n/a evaluate of the BOT theLaw technical No IRR:Direct proposals n/a negotiation of the shall bidder resorted bein accorda Article 33(2) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the Concession toNo the EU Concessions Law, n/athe selection No criteria Directive, art. n/a 31(1), defined by the No contracting "contracting authorities n/a authority and contracting must be linked to th entities w Article 139According Pursuant toYes to Yes article Code of Public Contracts (7)18 17 According of all Public the tocriteria NoArticle need 18 n/a Contracts (5)to Codeofbe 18, the numerically PPP No the Law, when expressed estimated value n/aonlyof one inthe order applicant to besubmits contract objective should ap be a No out the general Article 12 sets n/a No applicable principles selection of n/a to the Yes Article the awarded 14 of No bidder. the Article PPP Lawn/aprovides: 12 provides: "The selection "The Prime Minister, Article 189 Pursuant Pursuant toYes toNo Article of the Public 9 ofn/a Procurement the Law: Public (1) Yes The contracting Procurement Law: authority (1) to Pursuant The No Article has 78(8) no right n/a contracting authority of the to use Public assessment calculates the factors Procurement Law, th estima n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 21 of n/a No Where a the PPP Law, competitive procurement proce n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The As per the Implementing cost estimate Yes theis Regulations, part evaluation Article of the of 83 proposals of VFM the Noanalysis Implementing is done (Article n/a in 53 phases ofNo the Regulations and Implementing appropriate of the n/a PSP regulation Law governance states of that: is required. the PSP "1. pro AllLawB Articles 55,n/a Pursuant toNo Nothe PPP Decree, 68 and 69 of n/a the evaluation No n/a of No the strictly n/acriteria may take place on the enumerated Yes According to According the PPP Law, Chapter toIII, the Yes Article PPP Law, 20, According Chapter "the procedure to No III, the PPP Article for Law, selecting 21, n/a Chapter "the calculation a private No III, art. of 20, partner an "the n/a estimated either avalue is procedurepublic forof selecting procurement a publica pri cont Section 49 n/a Pursuant toNo No all criteria of the PPP Act, n/aneed to be Noquantified n/a or given weights No n/a so as to make them objective:(f) the c n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No The PPP Handbook n/a situations when none of th addresses Yes According to the PublicAccording Procurement to YesAct, the Public §44(1), According Procurement "the contracting to No Act, the Public §44(3) authority n/a Procurement (b) and shall (c), No evaluate Act, Art. "the bids bids n/a I, shall based Partbe II, evaluated Chapter on objective §57 1,on award the (2), basis crite "the o Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording No to Act, the Concessions Article n/a Act, 84(5), Article Yes "the award criteria According 26(1), "themust valuebe No to the of a concession Publicn/a non-discriminatory, Procurement is the proportionate total Act, turnover Article and of the link 92(1), c " n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to According the Concessions to No Manual, the Section n/a 10.6.26(a) Concessions to No Manual, (c), Section n/a 8.2.1, Criteria "Prohibited 6: in TableNo "Sample Concession n/a Contents of a Concession Evaluation: Biddin The criteria for t Yes are usually Non-price criteria dependent According Yes to the PPP on the Manual, According prevailing anytoNo government the PPP findings about Manual, n/a policies. the project Module No example, For 5, Stagen/a revealed during the 1, Step1, Preferential the the feasibility pre-qualified studybidde Procurement Re stage Yes According to Articles Article 145.5.(b) of 100, the NoLCSP: 101, 102 (criteria) and n/a 116 LCSP must Yes be formulated state the that According objectively, cost of No the to Article with contract 150.3, fulln/a respect must second befor paragraph the principles included of the in the of equ LCSP tender/ No According to n/a on PPPs, the Guidelines NoSection 270, n/a “the main No criteria applied n/a No to the evaluation are:(i) the technical ca technical n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to of the PPP Act, the government e Article 26 n/a Yes According to According the Concessions Act,to Chapter No 13, n/a §1, "a Act, the Concessions Chapter No contracting authority 5, §2, n/a or value "the Noof a shall an entity concession award n/a a concession shall using as be estimated the con a awa n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 20 (1) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the PPP toYes Article Law, criteria According 20 (2) for of the evaluation to No PPP Section Law,of criteria 115 n/a technical of for evaluation proposals No of Resolution of the shall financial contain Board n/a proposals No. the 81, following shallinformation: if only contain one the bid was No under Section This is required n/a Nothe Public 372 of n/a Procurement No Regulations, No n/a which applies n/a to all evaluation criteria, including no n/a No n/a Yes Under Section No 40 of the n/a is at the discretion PPP Act, itNo n/a of the Selection Committ No According to (5) of the Procurement article 86 n/a No n/a Regime, regarding No n/a Assessment No and n/a Tender Procedures, it is comp Choice in the n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 25 of n/a the PPP Law provides that when only one p No According to Section 56(5) n/a of the Procurement No Regulations, n/a Yesnon-priceSection award criteria 44(1) No the Public ofshall n/a Procurement whenever Regulations possible be in quantifiedonl n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Pertaining to of Decree No. Article 60n/a No 2016-772 n/a of 20 June Yes According 2016, about to No the conditions Article and procedures 47 and 48 of the n/a for the Decree award No. 2016-7 of public Yes According to Article 40 According of Public Procurement to No Law: of Public Article 40 n/a “the <...>Procurement No economically n/a Law: <...> most advantageous No economically “the n/atender most determined solely isadvantageous tenderon n/a Yes No Section 19 of n/a the PPP Regulations provides: No n/a (1) No Committee The Evaluation n/a shall evaluate the financial b Yes According to The Section 29 tender No documentation of Resolution 384, the n/a governing consists, body, among Yes other Pursuant taking things, into account toof No Article conclusion athe 14 of n/a the based proposals PPP of the Law, oncommission, If upon the having results determ of ana an ann No Article 14 of PPP Law provides, the Dubai n/a Yes "a. The Article process of No 24 of selecting the Dubai n/a PPP a Project Law provides, No will Partner A "a.be n/a Tender subjectfor to a Partnership the of ope principles may be Yes Regulation 41 It has of the CCR 2016 be Yes included to—(1) Concession asAs part contracts a generalconcession shall of the No be awarded principle, n/a notice on Regulation regulated the 37 Noof the byof basis CCR objective n/a 2016 Article 31 of provides criteria the CCRthat 2016 which(3) comply that The refe wi num n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo section 4.3.3 n/a No Manual and of the PPTA n/a Guidelines, if at least one res n/a Yes No Article 18 of n/a the PPP Regulatory Decree No states n/a Noreport favorable that once the n/a to the eligibility of the pr No According to n/a Article 7 of No <...> competitiveness the PPP Law, n/a No and objectivity n/a in theYes selection of a private to According Article partner 21ensured are th of the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a article 42 of the PPP Law: No Methods n/a Yes for evaluation and standards According ofto bidding NoArticledocuments n/a 83.3 of Decree 1. Capability 35, in case and experien of prequa No According to n/a the PPP Amendment Act, Sectionn/a No 9, which amends No n/a 32 of the section No n/a the PPP Act, among others, "(32)(1) "a cont No According to n/a 50(4), the PPA, Section No n/a "criteria referred to in Nosubsection (3) [non-price n/a that are to be used in the evalua No criteria]n/a No Section 25 of the Tendern/aprovides for No a point system n/a to be Noused when evaluatingNo n/a n/a states that approximately 50 bidders, which Yes According to According the PPP Law, art. 19(11), to No "for the PPPeach Law,tender n/a art. 21(1)(1), criterion Yes "the provided According tender for documentation in the to No paragraph the PPP Law, must n/a 9 art. contain of this 19(2)(2) article, <…>to (1)(4), the following "a conclus a decision p on Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q26_D Q27 Q27.1 Q27_1_TEXT Q27.1_1_TEXT Q28 Q28.1 Q28_1_TEXT Q28.1_1_TEXT 27. Does 26. The regulatory the If procuring yes, please framework does27.1. authority not specify include If yes, publish theIf isany means yes, theprovisions. the contract of please contract 28. publication specify Does award award notice If theand procuring website: yes, notice? provide published pleaseauthority the 28.1. provide online? relevant If yes, the notify does If yes, relevant legal/regulatory all the please notification the bidders provide legal/regulatory provisions: individually the of the relevan provi resua Yes Yes Yes General provisions apply, http://www.ppp.mof.gov.af Yes and Article 84(2) of the General Public https://ageops.net/en/procurement-procedure/con rules Procurement Noin Article n/a 43 Rules of the provides Publicthat Procurement the procurin Law No Yes Article 58 (2) Pursuant toYes http://app.gov.al/njoftimi-i-lidhjes-së-kontratës of the Public Yes Procurement Pursuant towithin Law, Article Yes five 21 (2) days Pursuant the ofof Public to Article notification Procurement of 58(2) of the award, Law theP No Yes Art. 41 of the Pursuant toYes www.algeriatenders.com Concession YesDecree, According to Yes Article the contracting authority 82 Article of the shall65, Public publish paragraph Procurement the provisional 2 of Public DecrenP No Yes Articles 96 http://www.compraspublicas.minfin.gov.ao/ Pursuant toYes Yes and 97 of the Public Procurement Pursuant toYes Articles Law, award the 96&According and http://www.imprensanacional. 97 is of the notified to Article Public to theProcuremen tendered, 96.2 a of the P No Yes Yes According to Section 9,https://www.argentina.gob.ar/jefatura/ppp Article 12, Annex Yes I of Decree Decree118, Yes the Procuring 118/2017 (Annex According I, Authorityto12.31 Section Article shall publish and 12.27, 12.35 the also awa Annex No Yes Article 10(1) Pursuant toYes https://www.mineconomy.am/ of the Procurement Yes Pursuant Law, before https://procurement.minfin.am/ toYes concluding Article 10(1) Pursuant a contract,tothe Article client of the Procurement 10(2) shall Law, of befor the P publish Yes Yes Yes According to Website Section 6.4 of the National of the Yes relevant Section government 5.4 PPP Guidelines Yes Volume of agency/procurement Volume 2, "It2 Section the is National 5.4 and common practice authority, PPP Section forincluding 17 a public of Vol Guidelines staa No Yes Yes According to According the Law on to Concessions, Yes the §34(1), Law onAccording at the European to Yes Concessions,the §35(1), Union Law onlevel, According at the “following national to the Concessions, level §72(1), a Law of onAustria, "aConcess contrac completion "a of No No n/a No n/a Yes No The announcement n/a winner of the tender shall be of the No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes the Regulation Pursuant toYes The of notice Tender: No is published 51. The commission n/a on the public No for the competition, partner's website, within n/a e.g., the 10notice business days of the fi Yes Yes article 44 of Pursuant toYes the concession Yes Law, at https://eten.publicprocurement.be/; Pursuant most 48 days to article Yes after http://ted.europa.eu 8 of entering Pursuant Act of 17 to June into the article 2013 concession, 8 on of Act the of procu 17 motiv No Yes Yes According to Article 44 http://www.marches-publics.bj/ of PPP Law,Yes awarded contracts Article 39 http://www.gouv.bj published isof the PPP Law Yes inAccording the provides legal journal that to the within Article 39 tender of 30 days comm PPP a Law No Yes Article 70 (6) Pursuant toYes of the Public https://www.ejn.gov.ba/ Yes Procurement Pursuant and Law, thetoYes the Article contracting website of 70the (6) Pursuant contracting of the Public to Article authority shall authority Procurement 70 publish the (3) of Law the P de Yes Yes Yes According to the PPA Regulations, http://www.ppadb.co.bw/Pages/Tenders.aspx Section No n/a <...> "allNo 122(5), n/a shall be advertised by the p contract awards Yes Yes Article 109, Pursuant toYes paragraphNo http://portal.in.gov.br/ 1 of Public n/a Procurement and the Public No Authority Law 8.666/1993), (Lawn/a website the award notice m No Yes Article 192 https://nkr.government.bg/ Pursuant toYes Yes of the Concession Law:Pursuant (1) The https://www2.aop.bg/ toYes Article National Concessions 119 Pursuant of the Register Concession shall to Article 119 Law: contain (1) of the distin The Gr Con Yes Yes Yes Article 53 of Article the PPP Decree 59 of provides Yes the that PPP Decree Article “[t]he indicates: 53 of selectionYes committee theAfter PPP Decree the Article shall negotiations, rank 53 of the the provides that bidders the PPPpublic Decree according “[t]he author prov selectio No Yes article 25 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Decree, Yes articledetailed Pursuant 25 of results the PPPto Decree, are No article provided 25 of n/a to the detailed results candidates PPP Decree, are provided and published to result detailed on candi Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes prequalification Further the No Yes n/a report, the public Decree administration No. No 2008/0115/PM which isn/a of January owner 24, 2008 of the project regulatin appoints a No Yes Yes of the Contracting Section 10.7.31 https://buyandsell.gc.ca/ Yes Policy provides, "In order According Yes to Section to demonstrate 10.8.21 Pursuant the ofthe torequirement Section Federal 10.8.21 Contracting for of th acce Yes Yes No Article 28 of the PPP Law n/a provides:No at the end n/a No of the negotiations, n/a the public authority shall publish th Yes Yes Yes According to article 8 of www.concesiones.cl the Concessions Yes Law the tender Yes Thecontractdocuments awarding referred Economic describe how to by Article the offer and bidders bids 1 will will be res evaluatibe No Yes Yes 18 of PPP Articles 17 and http://www.ccgp.gov.cn/ Procurement Yes 2014 and article to Pursuant 21No article of the 45 of n/a Noticethe ofBidding the Ministry Law, after the dete of Finance on No Yes Yes According to Article 2.2.1.1.1.7.1. www.secop.gov.co; and Yes article www.colombiacompra.gov.co; Law 1150 of 2.2.2.1.8.3. Yes of2007, the PPP in its Regulations Law 1150 https://community.secop.g article 9, of establishes (Decree 2007, in 1082/2015) asarticle its mandato th 9, Yes Yes Yes As a general Depending principle, Article Yes 9 of on thethe PPP lawArticle provides implantation decree 43 that No of the transparency PPP of Law the n/a PPP provides Law, in the it would procedures that be published after for the aw o negotiation No Yes Yes According to Article 83 http://www.armp.cg/en-us/publications/tenders/decisions.aspx of the Public Yes According Procurement The Yes Code: to Article contracting 88 According of the procurement to Article authority must publish 88 Code: of the a noti The aw Pro Yes Yes Yes According to article 41.d) https://www.imprentanacional.go.cr/gaceta/ of the General No Public Procurement n/a award will be publish in "La Gaze No Law the n/a No Yes of PPP Decree Art. 24 al. 4Yes The CNP-PPP No. 2018-358 Yes website: https://ppp.gouv.ci Art. 75 of March of 29, 2018 the No relating Public to n/a Procurement Public Private Code Partnerships con provides that th No Yes Yes Article 40 of the Concession https://eojn.nn.hr/oglasnik/ Act states Yes that the provisions Pursuant regarding toYes Article 49(3) public Pursuant of the Concession to Article shall procurement 50(2) Act,apply <...> of the mu C the No Yes Yes According to Procurement the PublicA profile of Yes a contracting Act, §185, According "within authorityto 48 in days the Yes the Public from Public the Procurement Procurement conclusion According to the Act, of Information Public a§184(1), contract, Procurem Syste a co "§122 Yes Yes Yes According to The onlineDirective, the EU Concessions Yes publication art. would According usually 33(2), to Yes the a concession be EU done Concessions award According notice through Directive, to “shall a public the procurement EU be art. drawn40(1), up,po Concessions tr "th No No n/a No n/a Yes article 28 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law (PPP Law No. 2017 n/a Yes Yes of the PPP Regulations Article 20.1Yes https://dgapp.gob.do/banco-de-proyectos/ Yes provide: "Registration Yes and Article 102 of Decree publication 543-12 According provides of public-private to article that 102 the partnership of Decre procuring Yes Yes Yes Article 68 of the PPP Regulations www.appecuador.gob.ec (Executive Yes Article Decree 68 of 1190) provides Yes Executive "This Decree Article 68 1190 of will decision Executive provides be notified that Decreeto 11 thd "This No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Article 105.A of PPP Law: www.proesa.gob.sv "PROESAYes (the PPP-Unit) will44 Article create and No45 of the then/a public PPP registry Law establishes that the of public private res partn Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording to Yes the Act, Chapter Public Procurement 1, Division According Yes to the Act, 7,Public §45(1), According Procurement "unless Chapter 1, Division otherwise to the Act, 7,Public §45(1), Chapter provided "unless 1, Sub by Procurem No Yes Yes Article 34 (4) of the PPP http://www.ppa.gov.et Proclamation, Yes regarding Notification Article 34 (1) Yes ofof the PPP According Award Proclamation, and Signing to the of regarding PPP Proclamatio Contract, states t Notifica No Yes Pursuant toYes Section 127 TED of the Public Yes (Tenders Electronic Contracts Pursuant and Concessions Daily, toYes Section Supplement 127 Act: to The the Pursuant of Official the Public toJournal decision ofContracts the of Sectioncontracting 123 the ofEU) the and htt Pu en Con No Yes Yes of the http://www.boamp.fr/ Article R.2183-1 Public Acquisition Yes CodeArticle http://eur-lex.europa.eu/oj/direct-access.html?locale=fr requires R.2181-1 the Yes procuring of the Article Public authority R.2181-1 to publish Acquisition ofCode the the Public awardAcq n indicates Yes Yes Article 47 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Ordinance Yes Pursuant to (Ordinance No. No Article 009/PR/2016n/a 45 of theof PPP 11 Ordinance (Ordinance February 2016 on Publ Yes Yes Article 15(9) Pursuant toYes www.tenders.procurement.gov.ge. of the Public No Procurement No tender commission n/a Law, the n/a shall publish the contr Yes Yes Yes According to - the portal the Concessions Ordinance, Yes "service.bund.de According §21(1), - Verwaltung to Yes "a concession the Concessions grantor Online According shall " is Ordinance, send the centralized toathe contract Concessions §30(1), access award "witho not Ord poi Yes Yes Yes Section 75(2) of the PPP www.ppaghana.org Act requires Yes Section that the PPPO 48(8) and No the of contracting n/a the PPP authority Act provides shall that the Head ensure no thatof th No Yes Yes Article 31 of Contracting the Concessions Law provides Yes Authorities' for Pursuant websites: the tohttps://portal.eprocurement.gov.gr/webcente Yes publication Article of the 44 of Pursuant the Concessions contract to Article award notice Law: 44 no of 1.the TheCon later tha con No Yes Yes According to of the PPP Law article 54 www.guatecompras.com.gt; Yes the awarding Articlenotice 56 ofYes the mustPPP https://anadie.gob.gt/ beLaw published According requires to the into notify article website 54 the of awarding of ANADI the PPP Yes Yes article 81 of Pursuant toYes http://www.armpguinee.org the PP Code, Yes the procuring Articleauthority of the 23-6Yes PPP Article Decree publishes a notice 23-6 provides ofaward of that the PPP of the Decree public ser pr winning No Yes article 74 of Pursuant toYes cnmp.gouv.ht the PP Law, Yes Pursuant the procuring toNo authority article publishes 125 n/a of the an attribution PP regulations notice and section of the con Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes According to Article 37(2) http://kozbeszerzes.hu/ of the Public Yes Procurement According The Yes Act:to notice Article 9/A on According the of results the Concession to Article of theAct: procedure 9/A(1) the Co of The co pu No Yes Yes of the General Rule 173 (xviii) All public Financial procurement No Rules, n/a award 2017 notices provides No that are to the bename published n/a of the on the website successful of CPP bidder aw Yes Yes Yes According to A contract the Attachment to the award Yes LKPPnotice According is published Regulation to Yes 29/2018,the onChapter Attachment a website According II, C to the theto of(1)(l)(1), relevant LKPP the at Attachment the Regulation PJPK. selection29/ to t (te No Yes Yes According to the Tenders https://www.parsnamaddata.com/tender.html Law: Article No 23 on "Documentation n/a n/a No and Information" provides:a) The governm Yes Yes Yes According to Ministry Article 41(1) of theof Works Construction Yes Contracts Article Instructions, and 12(1)(d) YesIraq: Housing of each the http://www.imariskan.gov.iq/en Public Article Contracts 12(1)(d) contracting of Law authority the provides shall inform Public tha UN Con Yes Yes Yes Regulation 31 of the EUwww.etenders.gov.ie; Concession Yes 2017 establishes: Regulation (1) Not www.ojeu.eu Yes 40 of later the than EU Concession 48 days after Regulation 402017 ofthe the states EU Concessi award follow asof a co No Yes No Tenders The Mandatory n/a Regulation Yes provides in Section Section 2121 of Yes that: the Mandatory While Tenders not (a) Following completion explicit, Regulation where of examinati under Section No Yes According to Yes Article 72,The 73 and 98 of Yes awarding authority's the Public According Contracts website,to which Yes Code, article the 98 wouldaward (1) According include the in of notice Public to this is article case published Contracts 76 the Ministry inof (2) the the Code w" Yes Yes Yes According to the Procurement JamaicaHandbook, Information Yes Volume According 2, Service website: Appendix to No https://jis.gov.jm/government/procurem the Procurement 8, Section n/a A8.17, Handbook, "once a Volume has decision2, b App Yes Yes Yes Paragraph 1, of theis Article 11 There no PFI Act Yes centralized website. to publish requires 4-2 the the (3) of Each Yes Procurement result government on4-2 Process agency official the(3) of theor Gazette, Guidelines Procurement each local newspaper governm Proce requires t No No n/a No n/a Yes The biddersYes are notified Article of the30 of the PPP rejection Regulation of their s pre-qua No Yes Article 35 (3) Pursuant toYes Theofwebsite the PPPof NoLaw, the information relevant n/a organizer on the No of the procurement results n/a of the competition process (public for partn determinin Yes Yes Yes According to Section 69http://www.pppunit.go.ke (1) of the PPP Yes Act, "a contracting and in to According contracting authority No section 60(3)(a) authority n/a upon shall, of the the websites PPP execution of a proje Act, a contractin No Yes Nothe 2016 n/a Article 173 of Basic Plan provides Yes the publication forPursuant article toYes of the 81 (2) contract According of the award to Article PPP notice. Basic 81 Plans, Article (2) upon of 173 co the No Yes Article 3 (IV) Pursuant toYes www.pppkosova.org of Directive Yes Pursuant to No. 4, notification Article Contract ofYes 3 (IV) Award Pursuant or Cancellation to Article of Directive No. 4,3 the (IV) of Procurem of Direc Contract No No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 37 of n/a the PPP Executive Regulations provides, "Th No Yes Yes According to Article 13(7) www.ppp.gov.kg of the PPP NoLaw <...>,n/a No commission the competition n/a publishes information abo Yes No n/a No n/a Yes Article 15(2) Yes Article 15(2) of the Procurement of the Procurement Regulation provides, "R Yes Yes Yes Article 53 of the PPP Law https://www.iub.gov.lv/lv/iubsearch/pt/_pp/ provides Yes for the publication of of Article 53 Yes thethe contract PPP Law award Article notice: 53 of <...> provides, the (1)PPP (3) The Law Concession The provide Concess No Yes Yes According to the PPP Law, www.hcp.gov.lb art. 8, "<…> Yes the project According to Yes the committee shall PPP announce Law, According the art. 8, tooutcome the "<…> the PPP project Law, of thecomm bidd art. 8, No Yes award notices Concession Yes https://pirkimai.eviesiejipirkimai.lt/login.asp?B=ppo; are always Yes pursuantto providedPursuant toNo Article Article58(1) 29(1) n/aofthe of the http://ted.europa.eu/TED Concessions ConcessionsLaw, where Law, the aw No Yes No PPP Law Article 7 of the states that n/a obligation Article Yes of transparency 26 of No in the Decree procurement n/a 2017-149 requires process implies tha the procuring au No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Yes Article 23 of the PPP Decree Pursuant requires Article toYes an award 24 of Article notice the PPP 20 toof Decree, be Yes the PPP the published Law award Article within andnotice 20 15ofdays the Article 21 is published of PPP ofnotifying the LawPPP and onthe the Art w Decre Yes Yes Yes Section 40(7) of the PPA http://publicprocurement.govmu.org/pages/awards.aspx provides that Yes a publicSection 40(3) body shall No promptly of the PPA publish, n/a in such provides that manner a public as may in body ber No Yes article 55 of Pursuant toYes https://compranet.hacienda.gob.mx/web/login.html the PPP Law, Yes the procuring 11 and Yes55 Articleauthority will of provide theArticle PPP the Law requires of the PPP 55resolutionthe that Law procuring require includes Yes Yes Article 5(4)Official Pursuant toYes of the PPP Monitor Yes Law, of the meetings the Pursuant ofof Republic to the No Moldova Article 112 http://monitorul.gov.md/; n/a of Government private-partner selection commission Resolution Public are No 47 Prp Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes According to Website the Concessions Law, of a Yes Part contracting According authority. IV, Section to 2, Article Yes Official the 36(1),Gazette forAccording the of Concessionsopen Law, Montenegro: procedure, to theIV, Part Section http://www. "the Compe Concessions Law 2, Art Yes Yes of the PPP contract An abstract Yes http://www.sgg.gov.ma/ together Yes with According the https://www.marchespublics.gov.ma/ award to No notice Article are of n/a PPP Law, 8published in "the the Official public entity shal Bulletin an Yes Yes Yes Article 64(2) no.most of Decree As 5/2016 PPPs Yes foresees that Article awards are determined via 20 of shall direct Nothe PPP award, be Regulations n/a published at the inend the of press. the negotiation (Decree pro 16/2012) clear No Yes section 60 of Pursuant toYes https://www.bolpatra.gov.np/ppmo/searchOpportunity the Public Yes Procurement Act, after Pursuant section toYesa procurement 26 Pursuant (3) and contract to (4) section of has the Public been 26 (3) conclude and (4 Procurem Yes Yes Article 2.134 Pursuant toYes www.tenderned.nl of the Public Yes Procurement Pursuant Act, the to Article Yesannouncement 2.127 Pursuant ofPublic of the the to Article contract Procurement 2.130 award of the noti P Act, Yes Yes Yes According to The Government the Procurement Yes Rules, Rule Electronic According 45(1), Tenders "An to Yes agencythe Service must PPP (GETS): Guide, According publish https://www.gets.govt.nz/ Contract aSection to the 4.25, Award PPP Guide, Notice “following on the Secti No Yes Article 41 of Pursuant toYes the PPP Regulations Yes http://pronicaragua.gob.ni/en/; "Approval According of to Yes the http://www.nicaraguacompra.gob.ni/; Article Award", 41 According theresult ofthe Regulation, PPPto Article has to be40 besides of http://w the PPP published a pu No No n/a No n/a Yes Noprequalification Regarding the n/a stage : Art. 32 of the PPP No Yes Yes of Public Section 19(1)(j) www.bpp.gov.ng/ Procurement Yes Act mandates Sectionto 56 of No "Announce the PPM requires n/a and publicize thatthe the procuring award entity in the form No Yes Article 70 of Pursuant toYes https://www.e-nabavki.gov.mk/PublicAccess/Home.aspx#/home the LPP: The Yescontracting Article 113 of Yes authority shall the PP mandatorily Law Article states publish that the 113(4) ofathe contracting contract PP Law prov aut award No Yes Yes According to Procurement the PublicThe Public Procurement NoRules, 2004, n/a Regulatory Section No Authority's 35, n/a website: "procuring https://www.ppra.org agencies shall announce the r No Yes Yes Article 37.16 of the PPPhttps://enterector.gob.pa/ Law states: No of the evaluation The reportn/a No n/a committee, including the score obtain No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Article 62 of Decree 4183/20: https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/; "Adjudication Yes (Awarding Article 62of ofYes the Decree www.stp.gov.py contract). Article The 62 4183/20: "Adjudication Contracting of DecreeAuthority 4183/20: (Awarding"Ad shao Yes No n/a Yes http://www.proyectosapp.pe/default.aspx No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Section 11.4 of the BOTppp.gov.ph/ Law IRR: The Yes and implementing PBAC Section shall post the 11.2, agency's notice No website of award second paragraph, n/a and/or of bidding the BOTresults in the Law IRR: All Yes Yes Yes of the contract The publication The Public award Procurement Yes notice isPursuant required Bulletin to by Yes Article https://searchbzp.uzp.gov.pl/Search Article38 23(1) (1) According of the of Concessions the Concession to the EU Concessions Law, Law or/and (...), the e-P no pro No Yes Article 78 (1) Pursuant toYes of Public Yes Contracts www.base.gov.pt and http://ted.europa.eu/ Code Pursuant toYes 18, the award notice Article (1) 77Regulation Pursuant of should Public 33 be to Article of Contracts submitted the EU 77 Code (3) Concession for publis Publi of18, al No Yes Yes Article 45 of Article the Tenders 45 of Regulation Yes the provides, "The It Regulation Tenders decisions is the Yes standard provides, related practice to "The Article todecisions notify 45 ofall acceptance, theexclusion, related bidders. Tenders to award accepta Regulat Article o 45 No Yes Article 145 http://sicap-prod.e-licitatie.ro/pub Pursuant toYes (1) of the Public Yes Procurement Pursuant toYes Law, the contracting Article 215(1) Pursuant ofauthority the to Public Article Procurement shall submit 215(1) of forLaw pu the No Yes of the PPP Guide Section 6.6 Yes www.rdb.rw on Transparency Yes Article and 22 of public disclosure No the PPP Law n/aprovides provides for the : A disclosure partner who the of is c not Yes Yes Yes According to section C.11 https://www.mof.gov.ws/services/procurement/tender-awards/ regarding Yes Award of Contract Accordingofto the Yes section Guidelines According k.6.8 for (4) Government of the to section Treasuryk.6.8 Instruction (4) of t Procurement No Yes Article 31 of Pursuant toYes the PSPto Pursuant Law, Yes Article 31 of Article the PSP all information, 116 documents, Law, of Nothe all information, and n/a data related Implementing regulation documents, to PSPand of project data the shall PSP La rela Yes No n/a No n/a Yes Article 58 of Pursuant toNo PPP Decree, the Bid Committee n/a No Yes According to Yes the PPP Law, ForArticle 20, Yes a PPP project "the without According a concession procedure to Yes theelement, PPP for selecting a private Law, According according Chapter partner to III, to the is the either PPP Article Public Law, 20, a public Procur Chapte "the pr pro Yes Yes Yes Section 26 of the Public https://www.publicprocurement.gov.sl/index.php/contract-awards Procurement YesLaw mandates Section 27 publication the of Yes the Public of Section the notice 27 ofof Procurement the Law award. Public obligates provides the ItProcurem No Yes Yes Section 30 (1) of the GPR https://www.gebiz.gov.sg/ indicatesYes that a contracting According to Yes section authority 31 shall publish GPR, of the a GPR, notice section (1) 32.-(1) in Subject anA contracting to regula approved m No Yes Yes According to Procurement the PublicWithin Yes the profile Act, of Art. the According I, contracting Part to Yes the II, Chapter authority Public 1, §55(2), According on Procurement "the the contracting to the website of Act, Public the Art. authority I, Procurem Part Proc Public C II,sh No Yes Yes According to According the Concessions Act,to Article Yes the Concessions 32(1), According "the typesArticle Yes Act,to the of notices Concessions 33, "the include According notices <...> Act, Part, to athe referred notice Article Concessions to ofin 52(1), the the Arti Act "a award Yes Yes Section 4.12 Yes of the Procurement http://www.mof.gov.sb/ReportsNew/ProcurementTenders.aspx Yes provides, Manual According "The following to No information n/a the Section 4.12 of will the be Procurement Manu posted on the M Yes Yes Yes According to the PPA, art. Certain 24(1), contract No Procuring "the notices award n/a Entities are shall available No on publish, n/a within such websites two weeks - Global as:of decis awardTende No Yes Yes According to www.etenders.gov.za/ the Treasury Yes section At Regulation, 16A6.3(d), the pre-qualification the No awards arestage, n/a the PPP published the Government inManual, Module No Yes Yes Article 151.1 of the LCSP https://contrataciondelestado.es/wps/portal/plataforma regardingYes Resolution Article and notification 151 LCSP Yes states of the According that award states: the to article award 1. decision The151.2 resolution must be o of the Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No The contract award notice n/a publication Yes is provided under Article 25.4 the No of PPP Act without the PPP Act n/a states specifying that "subject to paragr the means of p Yes Yes Yes According to According the Concessions Act,to Chapter Yes the Public 8, §6, Procurement "a contracting According Yes to Act, the Concessions authority Chapter According 10, or Act, an entity §1, Chapter "a to the contracting that Concessions 10, has §12, awarde author Act "a co Yes Yes Pursuant toYes article 28 of www.simpa.ch the PP Ordinance, Yes thePursuant authority toNo article 23within publishes, of n/a the 30 PP days, the authority Law, the award. comm No Yes Article 25 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law: Yes1. The contracting Pursuant to Yes Section shall authority 136Pursuant of issue Resolution to Section a notification No. 81, 135 of minutes award (3) of Re o of Yes Yes Yes The Third Schedule Public of the PPPProcurement Regulations Yes Regulatory This isfor provides Authority the No required publication pursuant (PPRA):of to n/a the Section tender https://ppra.go.tz 61(1) award of the notice: and TANePS PPP Reg "TEN No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Yes According to In the Article 89(1) of the different Procurement Yes electronic Regime, portals According to of theYes award Article the relevant 7 of According the notice is Procurement published ministries, to Article including:http://ww in the Regime, 7(2) common of the the P lo p No Yes No Article 34 of n/a the PPP Law that "[t]he contracting provides Yes Article 30 of No authority the PPP Law n/a states shall publish that a notice of award afte the contracting aut No Yes Yes Section 64 of the Public www.finance.gov.to YesRegulations Procurement Section provides, 59(3) No "The of the Public n/a Procurement Regulations Central pro Unit shall prom Yes Yes Yes According to the PPA, art. Ministry 36(1),of Finance Yes thewebsite: "upon entry According into https://www.finance.gov.tt/category/awarded-co force to Nothe of aPPA, procurement art. n/a35(2), contract "a procuring <...>, entity a procurin shal No Yes Yes Article 16 of The the PPP Law No. publications 2015-49 Yes ( Law are made Article No. on 49 theof 2015-49 dated No website Decree 27 No. November of n/a 2016-772 the minister 2015 of concerned 20 related June to bycontract the 2016, pro abou Yes Yes Yes awards The procurement are generally Public announcements Yes published Although with in respect Official Yes the the BOT to Gazette thelaw awards does Although and not the are include the websites BOT published a specific law online of does theon procur not thein provisi Yes Yes No Section 24(2) of the PPP n/a Regulations Noprovides n/a No for the publication n/a of the contract award in at least 2 ne No Yes Yes According to of the Article 16 The website PPP Law: Yes where thethe Pursuant information results to of the Yes Section competitive is to be35 published According of bidResolution evaluation to Section depends toon No. 384: designate a35 public The of minute Resolu part a priv No No n/a No n/a Yes No Dubai PPP Manual n/a p. 164 provides, "Seventh: Contract A No Yes Yes Regulation 32 of the CCR Regulation 33 Yes 2016 establishes of the 32—(1) Regulation CCR Notestablishes 2016 40 Yes later than of the 48 33—(1) CCR days Regulation after Thestates: 2016 the 40award noticesof "Informing required the of CCR 2016 by candid regu st a concess No Yes Section 4.1.1 Pursuant toYes http://www.p3virginia.org/p3-projects/ of the PPTA YesManual and Guidelines, Pursuant toNo Section major 4.6n/a of the PPTA, business points all of the Comprehen non-successful p Yes Yes section 23 www.comprasestatales.gub.uy Pursuant toYes Yes the final of the PPP Law, According result of andthe Yes to the tender article http://ppp.mef.gub.uy/1201/2/areas/porta must Article 23 of be 32 registered the PPP of the Law, PPP inthe Regulatory the Project R D definitive No Yes Yes According to Article 21 According of the PPPto Law, No <...> Article 21 the n/a oftender commission the PPP Law, No <...> the publishes n/a tender information publishes commission about w the in Yes Yes Section 11AYes of the Government https://ctb.gov.vu/tenders/tenders-results Tenders Yes Act provides Sectionthat: 11ANoof (2)the Government n/a to subsection In addition (1),provides Tenders Act tha the functio No Yes Yes PPP Law, Article 9 of the www.muasamcong.mpi.gov.vn regarding Yes Transparency and disclosure Article 63 of Yes Decree 35/2021/ND-CP Article 63about of information states: PPP investments, of Decree Publication o 35/2021/ND Yes Yes According to the PPP Act, Yes An Section award notice 38(1), Yes would "subject usually to subsection Accordingbeto Yes the (3) published Procurement and on According except the website Regulation, for toathe contract of aPublic procuring Section Procurem 178 awardedauth( p Yes Yes According to the PPA, Section Yes 55(2), This will vary Yes "before depending According the expiry on of to the transaction No the the PPA, period Section of n/a and the bid identity validity, 55(2)(b),the of a procuring "before entit auth the expir Yes Yes According to section 37Publication Yes Yes of the of the Tender Rules, award aUnder notice Tender Committee, willYes sectionbe37placed of the established onTender the Section Under Rules, under relevant 37 the the ministry's Tender of the Tender various Comm procu websit R No Yes According to the PPP Law, Yes https://torgi.gov.ru/lotSearch1.html?bidKindId=6 art. 31(1), Yes "a tenderAccording commission,to the Yes PPP15 within Law, Such days explicit from art. the 31(2),requirement "a date tender commiss exists of signing apo Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q28.2 Q29 Q28.2_1_TEXT Q29_3_TEXT Q29_4_TEXT Q29.1 Q30 Q29.1_1_TEXT Q30_1_TEXT does 28.2. If yes, If please yes,the 29. provide procuring Is there authority the If a yes, relevant please provide standstill and (or legal/regulatory provide bidders/tenderers pause) the time the period 29.1. in relevant calendar provision: If afterwith yes, If the isyes, days: the legal/regulatory the contract please standstill option 30. award provide of Does provisions: holding and the period If the set before regulatory yes, relevant aout debriefing in the please the legal/regulatory signing framework provide notice meeting of of the the intention to restrict contra discus provi relevan m No No No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 10 Yes Furthermore, pursuant to Article 43 Pursuant of the PPP Article Law:1.24 toYes Any of Pursuant economic the PPPtooperator Article Law: 1. The 51 who contracting (1) has or P of the h No n/a Yes procurement Art. 42 of the Public10 Yes Decree Art.82 of the Yes Public provides: the Procurement action Article shall paragraph Decree 80 be specifies brought3within of the ten Pres that i ( No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 12.17, Annex of the Decre No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 10 10of Yes the Procurement Law: Pursuant Article toYes 2. The decision 10(2) Pursuant to conclude of the to Article Procurement a contract 38 (1) Law, shall thed ofthe P Yes and Sectionn/a Section 5.4 No n/a2 the National 17 of Volume No n/a PPP Guidelines provide Yes all biddersto that According Section must 6.8.1 of the be provided wit No n/a Yes 15 According to the Law on Yes Concessions, §73(1),to According Yes “athe procuring Law on According Concessions, authority may to the §72(1), not Law on"aConcess award a cont contrac No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a the PPP Guidelines, n/a 54.1,No Section "the Contracting n/a Authority Yes may, upon According toof request any the unsuccessful PPP Guidelines,S No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to the Regulations of th No n/a Yes Article 11 of Act of 17 15 June Yes 2013 on the motivation, According to Yes standard information Article 43 Europeananddocuments of legal remedies inLaw the Concession rela No n/a Yes 21 According to article 41 No of PPP Law n/a and art. 22 Yes of the PPP Commission Decree Art. 40 of the both PPP Law provide provides: No n/a Yes Article 72 (1) Pursuant to15 n/a Procurement Noof the Public Yes Law, Pursuant the contracting to Article 72 (5) of authority the shall P de Yes Yes According to According the Procurement Manual, to Section Section 14 No 12.9(1), 104(1) of the "in n/a PPA, the"a procuring No of transparency interests entity n/a shall, after and the publication openness, of an it is norm No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to the PPP Law, Article No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 120 15 Yes of the Concession Pursuant toYes Law, Article the contracting 116(2) Pursuant of authority the to Article signs122 Concessionthe Law, of contract theCon the de No n/a Yes Article 59 of the PPP 10 No provides Decree Yes n/athat “[t]he contracting Article authority shall 40 of the draw PPP up Law a reco provide No n/a Yes 20 Pursuant to article 6 of No the PPP Decree, is a period of n/a there No n/a20 days at least between the a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a of the Section 10.8.21 Federal Contracting n/a No Polices, n/a "Debriefings Yes Thebe should provided scope to unsuccessful of negotiations b with th No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 98 of the Public Procurem No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 21.8 of the Concessions R No n/a Yes 9 No Articles 17 to 19 of the n/a 2014 PPP Procurement Yes provide that PPP within 10 business (i)Procurement articles 2014, days 1 of t Yes No 1150 of Article 9 of Law 2007 establishes n/a during the same n/a that No n/a public Yes hearing where There isproject the is awarded no specific the pa legal provisio No n/a Yes 10 that after Article 43 states No negotiation, n/a the process Yes of concluding Pursuantthe contract to Articles follows 41 PPP of thethe No n/a Yes 15 Article 88 of the Public No Procurement n/a Yes the contracting Code provides: authority Article 81 of or Procurem the Public delegated No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 9 No Article 76.3 of the Public n/a Code provides Procurement Yes thatArt the Contracting 13 No. 2018-358 of Decree Authority o shallof No n/a Yes The standstill period is provided 15 Yes for The standstill under Yes Article 54 of the period is Article to Concession 404 be set (2(6)) out Act: in the (1) of intention the A concession Public to a Pr No n/a Yes 15 According to the PublicYes Procurement Act, §184(1), According Yes to the"§122 Publicto According Procurement to apply §127 shall Act, the Public §185, mutatis “within mutan Procurem No n/a Yes 10 According to section 173 Yes of the Public Procurement According Yes to section Act,171(4) "A According contracting of the Public to the authority EU Procurement may not A Concessions c No n/a Yes 15 The Manual on PPPs No Procedure adopted n/a by decree Yes N°2021-192/PR/MEFI provides Pursuant to article that 29.1 of PP thedisp No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 27 of Law 34 No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 31 of the PPP Law states, No n/a Yes 5PPP Law: "(the Article 44 of Yes award Under resolution) the recently will take Yes effect adopted Article in five 56 of days the(…) PPP Administrative during Procedural Law states L t that pe No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Public 14 Yes Procurement According to Yes Act, §141(7), the"When PublicAccording Procurement awarding a the Act, Public §45(3)(4), toconcession Procurem “ <… contract, No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 45 of the Procurement Pro No n/a Yes 14 According to Section 129 Yes of the Public Contracts According Yes to Section and Concessions 123 According of theAct: tofor Public Article Contracts procurement 37 (6)and abo Co of the No n/a Yes 16 The Public Acquisition Code Yes provides Pursuant toYes article for a standstill period R2181-3 Article of 11 of R.2152-13 the or Public 16 days.of Acquisition Pursuant the Public Cod to ar Ac No n/a Yes 15 According to articles 45No and 46 of the n/aPPP ordinance, No n/a the contract may not, under penalty No n/a Yes 5(1) Pursuant to Article 24 n/a No. 426 Noof Resolution Yes of 2018 titled Pursuant to Article "On the 24(2) approval of Resol of the rule Yes Yes According to the Concessions According Ordinance, §30(2), 15 §134(2), to the PPA, Yes"at the "a request contract According may of to Yes the the be parties concluded PPA,concerned §134(1), According "public at the to in the the earliest text contracting Concessions 15form calendar accor Ord da in autho No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Section 49(2) of the Public Privat No n/a Yes The standstill period15 is regulated Yes Pursuant by toof Article 2a Article YesDirective 2a of Pursuant 2007/66/ECto2007/66/EC Directive of the 38 Article European of of the the Par Eu Con No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 64 of the PPP Laws requir No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 131(6) According to Article10 Government Yes of the Public PublicYes Procurement Decree No. According 44/2015. Act: The tocontracting Article (XI. 131authority 2.) MvM of the Pu contains No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Rule 173 (xiv) of the General Fina No n/a Yes 0 Regulation According to the LKPP No n/a 29/2018, art. Yes 18 (3)(m), According toof "a selection the Attachment a business to tt entity No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 15 Article 2a (2) of Directive Yes Article 89/665/EEC 2a (2) states: AYes contract of Directive Regulation may 89/665/EEC not be concluded 36 (8) states: of the A contract EU Conce following th No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 32 Yes According to Article35 (9) of the Public Article Contracts Yes 46 of Code the European the Article Concession 183 may contract (10) Directive of not bePublic the referrin Con concluded No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to the Procurement Ha No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 36 of the PPP Regulation s No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 40 (10) of the No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Section 57(3) of the PPP Act prov No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Articles 84 and 127 of the PPP Ba No n/a Yes Pursuant to10 Article 26 (4.1) No of the Public n/a Procurement No n/a Law, the persons having signing auth No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 17 of the PPP Law provide No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 15 Article 54 of the PPP Law Yes provides Pursuant toYes Article for a standstill 2a of period Article 10 DIRECTIVE 52(2) days: of A the (1)2007/66/EC public PPP Law OF prov THE partner or No n/a Yes 10 No Article 24 of the Public Procurement n/a No (2) provides Law paragraph n/a that "[p]romptly after the No n/a Yes 15 Yes Pursuant to Article 60(7) of the Concessions Pursuant toYes Article Law, <...>58 the of Article the Concessions 53 of contract concession the Concessions Law, must the beLaw con stand No n/a Yes 20 Article 26 of the PPP No 2017-149 Decree n/a requires Yes the procuring contract is The authority to notify the other negotiated, after No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPP Manual, Pro No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 15 Article 22 of the PPP Decree Yes makes Article provision for 21 of the Yesa stand PPP Decree still Articlerequires 19 of period 15 of the the days PPP notification (between Decree re n is to Yes No Section 41 of n/a the PPA provides n/a that: A public body No shall promptly, n/a request of an on Yes unsuccessful Section bidder, 10 of the inform th PPPA indicates: No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to article 51 of the PPP No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to Section 39 of Annex No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 2.127 Pursuant to20 Yes of the Public Pursuant toYes Article Procurement Act: 2.130 1) Pursuant contracting A(1) of the to Article Public authority Procurement 37 (6)shall tak of the E Yes No According to the PPP Guide, n/a Section n/a 8.7, "following n/a of the No No conclusion n/a stage, all unsuccessful respo preferred bidder No n/a Yes Article 42 of 5the PPP Regulations No period of five days to establishes0aNo 0 allow the bidders appe No No No comments n/a n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 38 of the PPP Yes No Section 19(e) n/a Procurement of the Public No n/a Act provides for the n/adebrief of Yes on request. bid losersParagraph Furthermore, 56.3 accord of the Procureme No n/a Yes 10 Article 115 of the PP Law: No The contracting n/a No must n/a authority not sign the public procurement No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to the Public Procurem No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes The regulatory framework does n No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Section 12.1 of the BOT Law IRR: No n/a Yes 15of Pursuant to Article 41 Yes the Concession Pursuant to Law, Yes Article the contracting 2a of Pursuant authority to2007/66/EC Directive Article shall conclude 13 of of the thea con Eu PPP No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 104 15 Yes (1) (a) of DL Pursuant isYes 18 thereto a standstill Article 46 (2) Pursuant period (a) ofofto 10Article Directive days between 2014/23/EU, 99 of Public the Ca n No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes It is implied under the PPP Law th No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 59 16of Yes Law No. 101/2016 toYes Article 46(2) Pursuant (Remedies): (1) Pursuant For (a) of theDirective to Article purposes of 207 2014/23/EU, Article of the Pub 58 p a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to According section C.11 regarding to 14section Award k.6.8 of No (4) ofof Contract the the n/a Treasury Instructions, Yesfor Government Guidelines in the case According Procurement toof section contracts GWGS, awarded k.6.7 of t (1) par Yes Yes Manual The Privatization issued by Pursuant to Article NCP in 100.1 2018 14 No of the Implementing stipulates in Section 24: n/a Yes Regulations Notification Article addressing 103 of awarding the of Qualified Bidders Implementing the PPP that proR "Afte No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 95 of the PPP Decree prov Yes Yes According to the PPP Law, According Chapter to the III, Article PPP15 20, Yes Law, Article "the 20, procedure According "thefor procedure selecting to Nothe PPPa private for selecting n/aart. Law, 20, partner a private "the is procedure partner either isfor eithe a public pr sel No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Section 3.2.2 (f) of th No n/a Yes 15 Yes According to the Public Procurement According Act, §55(2), Yes to "the the Public contracting According Procurement to the Act, authorityPublic shall §55(2), without Procuremd "the co Yes Yes According to According the PPP Act, to the"immediately Article 58(3), Concessions 15 Yes Act, before Article According announcement the 53, "a Yes to the grantor Public may According Procurement of not award the conclude to the decision, Act, aConcessions Article the90(11), candid concession Act con No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to According the PPA, art. 25, "the to the PPA, 14Entity Procuring No 83(4), art. shall"the upon n/acontract request shall of any No not unsuccessful be n/a signed until at least bidder, 14 calendar inform the bidd No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 21 Yes Art. 153.3 LCSP provides: "If the contract Article is subject 151.2 LCSP Yes tostates the Article special that the challenge 153 notification of Act applicable 9/2017 must states to pr contt No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article14 28 No of the PPP Act, n/a “[a]fterNo n/a announcing the results of the competition, t No n/a Yes 15 According to the Concessions Yes Act, Chapter According 16, to§1, the Yes "if Concessions a contracting According Act,to Chapter the Concessions authority or 10, an§12, entity an is a Act No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 14 YesSection 61 This is provided for under This ofis the PPPYes Regulations: provided for under Pursuant "61.-(1) Sectionto61 Section of the Upon receipt 90 PPP of of the thePPP re Regulati No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 8 of the Proc No n/a Yes Article 23 of the PPP7Decree No provides n/a that theNo n/a contact shall be signed after a standstill per No n/a Yes 14of the Public Section 59(3) No Procurement n/a Regulations Yes provides, Section the case "In58(1) of contracts of the aw Public Procu No n/a Yes According to the PPA, 0 art. Yes35(3)(c),According to "the noticeNo referred the PPA,to art. in 35(2), n/a "a procuring subsection contain, (2) shallentity a shal No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 10 No According to the Article 41(3) of the n/a No Public Procurement n/a the contract cannot be signe Law, No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes In accordance with paragraphs 55 No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes DoF PPP Guidelines, page 52, und Yes of the CCR Regulation Article 40.2Yes 48 2016: (2) On of the request15 CCR from Yes 2016 states: Regulation the party (1) Where 47 Yes concerned, the regulation of the contracting CCR Regulation 47(1) 2016 applies, establishes 37(7) authority or the ofutility that the contracting the shall, CCR cont 2016 a as No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 14 Article 64 of the PPP Regulatory No n/a (Decree Decree Yes17/012) states According the that to article contract 49 of shall PPP thebe e No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 64 of Decree 35/2021/ND Yes Yes According to According the Procurement to the Public Regulation, Section 14 Yes Procurement 185 (3), According Act, Section [upon Yes entry theto 71 the Procurement into (2), force According "a of aRegulation, contract procuring toentity the PPP and shall Section Amendmen award the 178 ac( provisio No n/a Yes 14 Section According to the PPA, Yes 55(2), According "<…> the Yes to the PPA, contract shall Section According not be signed to the 55(2), until "before Procurement the at least 14 expiry o Re No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes 10 According to the PPP No art. 32(1), Law, n/a "<...> a [PPP] Yes agreement must be According to the signed PPP Law, art. within tim the 32 Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q31 Q31.1 Q31_1_TEXT Q31.1_3_TEXT Q31.1_4_TEXT Q31.2 Q31.3 Q31.2_1_TEXT Q31.3_3_TEXT If regulatory 31. Does the 31.1. yes, please specify If yes, framework andIf isyes, provide there allow for please a timeframe the complaint andrelevant provide elaborate review in31.2. legal/regulatory/standard the which the timeframe: relevant If decisions yes, If are mechanisms yes, legal/ decisions on please pertaining complaints 31.3. provide subject contractual If regulatorytoyes, provisions: are the the to is Ifissued? PPP appeal? yes, relevant the bidding/tendering please original provisions: legal/regulatory provide complaint the and/or relevan provi process?t Yes No The PPP Law provides under n/a "Complains n/a Assessment No n/a Committee" in Article Yes 16 that: The PPP (1) Law The provides Complains under "Com Committee Yes Article 63 (1) of the10 Pursuant toYes Pursuant Public toYes Procurement Article Law, 43(6) Pursuant any the PPP ofperson Yes Article tohaving Law, the or 43 Public (8) Pursuant of had having the Procurement PPP an to Article interest Law, 43(1) Commission in a the procurem of the P complainas Yes Yes Art. 42 of the 20provides Concession Decree Art. 42 of that the Yes Concession any Organic Decree candidate wholaw participated provides No 98-01 of May in n/a that 30, the Public call 1998 forService the competition Delegation relating orCo a to competen Yes Yes Articles 15.1 Article 20.1Yes and 16 of the Public5Procurement of Law the allow According unsuccessful Public to No Procurement article bidders Law 21 states of challenge ton/a that the challenges the Public Procurement award shall decision decid beLaw st wi Yes Yes Article 12(35) 126 of Decree Article No. 118/2017 provides 12(35) Yesof Decree that Article No. 118/2017 the awarding actNo 12(35) may ofprovides Decree be challenged n/a that118/2017 No. byawarding the provides the Bidders act who may that bethe are e c Yes Article 46 of the Procurement Pursuant toYes Law: 20 Pursuant Article 1. Everyone toYes 50 of Pursuant has the the Procurement right to Article Yes 46 to appeal Law: of Pursuant the 4. Procurement accordance to Article In actions (inaction) with 47 Law: of the 1. the and requir decis Proc Everyo Yes of the NSWn/a Section 4.6 No PPP Guidelines n/a provides Yes The NSW that the NSW Procurement Government Yes has established The Policy NSWFramework Procurement independent for Governme Policy review m Fra Yes Yes According to 42 the Law on According Concessions, §86(1),to "until Yes the Law on The Concessions, the awardappeal of a contract No can §92, beor lodged until "an application n/a with the revocation the Austrian for the of annulment High an Admini award, aot Yes Article 5.22 of the BOT Pursuant toYes Rules: The 90 Pursuant toYes consequences Article 52 of Pursuant of Law the to on a party's No Article Administrative failure of n/a 44 to sign the Proceedings: Law a contract on Administrative a violation or52.1. com of The Proc Yes Yes According to 42 the PPP Guidelines, According Section 50.1, to Yes "formal the PPP Act, The art. original complaints may 32(2), Yes complaint be lodged “in made The against the event that original to the a contracting complaint Contracting person orauthority organizati Authorit made c to a Yes Article 38-1 of the PPP Pursuant toYes Law:1. Participants 14 According to paragraph Yes of the Pursuant 1, Article competition 38-1 to Article No have of the 38-1 the PPP of right n/a the to Law, the PPPfile Law: term a complaint for 1. consideratio with th Participants o Yes Yes Articles 14-22 60 Art. of the Legal Protection Law 23 of of the 17No Law of June 17 2013 n/a June provide for 2013 provides No for five possible n/a different procedures to review delays: decision 60 days (annul Yes Yes Article 74 of 42 provides:Article the PPP Law contest74from of Yes the PPP Law Article provides: unsuccessful 74 of No bidders PPP contest are brought Law: the n/a from decision before unsuccessful the ofPublic the bidders Public are Procure brou Procuremen Yes Article 29 of Pursuant toYes 30 Pursuant the Sarajevo PPP Law: toYes Article (1) Provisions (1) of theto 208Pursuant Yes Law Article on Administrative 213Pursuant (1) of theto Procedure: Law Article Proceedings on Administrative 215 Where shall (1) of bethe ap the Yes Yes According to the PPP Regulation, 14Section According to Yes 77(1), "a the PPA Regulations, person According who is aggrieved to Section Yes by the PPP 78(6), any Regulation, According decision Section of toan in case of the original Board PPP 77(1), Regulation, complain "a or perso any of Yes Yes According to 5 Article Section 109 of the Public Procurement 109, Yes III §4ºLaw and(Law The petition 8.666/1993), Article No 41, §1º is of originally the decisions Public n/a Procurement regarding addressed to the theLaw evaluation first (Law decision of m 8.666p Yes Article 156 of the Concession Pursuant toYes Law: 60 Pursuant (1) Article toYes Any 175 decision Pursuant <...> The to Commission of the grantor Article 178 Yes under for Pursuant of Protection procedure to Article of Competition the Concession Law: 156 for the of (1)the The sha Con d designa Yes Yes Article 60 of the PPP Law provides 5 Article that “[d]isputes Yes 106 of thearising PPP Decree Article from decisions 107 of Yesthe provides that PPP takenthe during Decree Art. 1 the of provides the contracting procurement ARCOP authority decisions Decree should phase No. are iss render 2 Yes Yes mechanisms 10 Complaint review Pursuant in relation toto the Yes article tendering the process PPP Decree, 6 of According to No are article regulated the6procuring n/a by of Article the PPPauthority Decree, 6 of thewill when PPP Decree. the bidde answer A wit No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Art. 38 of the Pursuant toNo n/a n/adecree N° 2008/0115 No n/a / PM of the No 2008 specifying 24th January n/a the modalities of applica Yes Yes of the Contracting Section 12.1.14 Policy 90 The time provides limit No depends n/a on the more insight regarding complexity Yes international Pursuant of the case, trade including to the agreement-related whether hearin Procurement Inqc Yes Yes Article 194 of the Public Procurement 3 Article Code provides: 199 Yesof the (5) any Public Article tenderer30 who of Yes the Procurement PPP Code considers ordinance Article himself provides: provides: 30 of tointhe the be aggrieved PPP absence Candidate ordinance of in aten the p p de Yes main mechanisms There are 4No n/a for complaint n/a Yesreview regarding and the The Tribunal Yes tendering de Contratación Public process: Pública" 1. Appeal Purchasing or Tribunal "TCP" for reversal ("Tribu (r decision Yes Yes Article 52 of 9 According the Government Procurement Law to Yes article states thatAccording where 52 of any the Government to No provider Procurement believes n/a the Government that Procurement Law, its rights where Law, anyinterest and provid article Yes Nodecision can The awarding n/a before n/a be challenged Yesjudicial authorities Decisions regarding . The No mechanisms n/a available procurement are those resolving commo challenges p Yes Yes The PPP Law 21 complaint provides for review Article 108 mechanism. provides Yes Article Article that the 107 complaint 21 of of Yes this the is law PPP submitted Law Article provides provides 107 thatof within any that 8 this working candidate law the provides days or from ten managemen th Yes Yes Article 141 of 5 Procurement the Public 142 -5 Art Code provides: of Yes the PublicArticle Procurement 1-Candidates and 141 Yes of the tenderers CodePublic provides Article who Procurement consider that 142 -In 1the provides: Code themselves absence provides: of unfair a 1- de a Dispute Yes to 195 of the Articles 172Yes 56 General Procurement Article 191 of No the of the n/a Regulation General provide Procurement for Yes a complaint Regulation review Article 182 mechanisms of provides: Resolution. pertaining the of the General Yes Yes No. 2018-358 Art. 33 of Decree 10 Article 29, of March 145.4 2018 Yes of the relating Articles toProcurement Public 144 Public Yes to 147 PrivateCode Partnerships of the provides Pertaining Public that Procurement to Art. the regulatory contracts 145.1 states Code of that body regu Disp the Pu Yes Article 30, paragraph Pursuant toYes 301Pursuant of the PPP toYes Article Act: Legal 432, protection Pursuant paragraph toYes in 2 Article ofprocedure the the434, Public Pursuant of Procurement selection paragraph Article to 1 the of ofAct a30, private Public -The State Procur partn paragraph C Yes Yes According to Procurement the Public15 Act, §241(1), According to Yes the"objections PublicAccording Procurement to may be raised the Yes Act, Public §245(1), by aAccording Procurement private entity to the Act, who "a contracting Public §245(4), authority is inProcurem danger sha "if c ao Yes Yes According to 30Executive section 10(1) of the According to Order Yes section № 1080 According "The 12(2) the on of Act to Yes Actthe section on Danish the 8 Danish According Complaints of Act on to Board theComplaints section the Danish Board for 10(1) for Complai of Public Public Pro the Yes article 55 of the PPP Pursuant toYes 30Law Pursuant toYes (PPP Law article No. 2017-186 55 of Art.55.3 ofPPP the 29of May Law the Yes(PPP 2017), PPP Law bidders Article (PPP No. 2017-186 Law 55 of can No. the file of a2017-186 complaint PPP 29 law May and 2017), in29 of arti M fron Yes Yes Article 67 of 15 for Law 340-06 provides Article a complaint 67 of Yes Law 340-06 review Article provides 67 of mechanism. for No It Law a complaint 340-06 states: n/a Any claim provides review or for mechanism. challenge made It states: a complaint by the review Yes Yes Article 103 of 7 Article the Public Procurement Law,103 LeyYes Orgánica of del According the Public Procurement Sistemato Nacional No Law, the Ley de219 artile n/a Contratación Orgánica of the Organic del Pública Sistema ("Public NacionalPro Administratived Yes Yes According to 30 law: "A petition Article 39 of the PPP n/a shall be 0 No committee Yes formed chaired According toMinister by the ofof Article 39 the PPP Finance a Yes Yes Article 45 of 20 regulatesArticle the PPP Law 45 of the appeal Yes of the PPP the Law Based award states decision onthat the (recurso No general once admitted de n/a revision) (theto administrative admission the procedure samehas procuring to be and, p e indo No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to 30 According the Public Procurement to Act, §185(1), Yes the"a PublicAccording Procurement tenderer, to Yes the candidate Act, or Public §200(1), According Procurement economic operator "the Review to the Act, interested Public §200(4), Procurem in"the Committee mak parti Yes Yes According to 10 the PPP Proclamation, article 64 of Yes Article 31 (3) of regarding the PPP complaints, Directive, Article regarding No 31 (4) the of the complaints Review n/a PPP and Directive, of Complaints review regarding mechanism Review by prov of C the PPP D Yes Yes According to Public Section 126 of the30 Pursuant Contracts toYes Chapter and Concessions Section 3 Act: 6, According to No (2) the chapter of the contracting 7 n/a Act on Proceedings entity section 2 of shall the Act in be attached onMarket the to Co Proceedini Yes may apply 20 The biddersYes Concerning to the administrative court Yes onlyfor the pre-contractual Article review R. 551-6 by using Yes a summary specific of the recourse Code Article proceedings, ofR. called 551-6 see a of Administrative Pre-contractual Article the Code Justice: of Ad "F R. 551-5i Yes Yes According to of the PPP Ordinance article 70 30 According (Ordinance to Yes article 70No. of the 009/PR/2016 PPPto According No Ordinance article of 11 71 n/a of Ordinance the PPP (February 2016 Ordinance No. on 009/PR/2016 Public-Private of 1 (Ordinance P Yes Article 1 (3^3) of the Pursuant toYes Pursuant 28Public toYes Procurement Article Law, 23^1 Pursuant disputes (8) of therelated to Public Article Yes to Procurement 11 the ofcontractor Resolution Pursuant to selection Law, No. Article the437, Board 23(1) process the of decisio the shall (he maP Yes Yes According to 35 According the PPA, §155, “without to prejudice Yes to the PPA, §167(1), review by the supervisory "the According Yes to public the PPA, authorities, procurement §171(1), Accordingany tribunal toaward "immediate the PPA, shall of appeals <…> §155, take“with shall its d conces Yes Yes Section 67 of the Public Private60 Partnership Section 70(2)(a) Yes Act, 2020 of the (ActSection Public 1039)Private establishes 70(5) YesPartnership of the a Public Complaints Section Act, Private 80(1) Panel Partnership 2020 offor (Actthe 1039): the Public Act, The Procu 2020 bidding pr Com Yes Yes Article 60 of 20 provides the Concessions Law Article 367(1) for Yes the ofright the Public resolve Procurement toArticle disputes 372 Yes of the related Public Law provides Articles to the347-360 <...> concession Procurement Law independent of the states award Public Autho proce that th Pro Yes Yes Article 57 of 5 states: Appeal the PPP Law for Article 57reconsideration. of Yes the PPP Law states: The 106 Article [...] of No offender Once the ofPPP theLaw the n/a appeal states: adjudication for reconsideration Right decision may file has to challenge an be the Yes of the PPP 10 Article 36-1Yes Lawworking provides Article days for for 52the of complains Yes claims the before PPP Decree Article filedthe before Contracting provides 36.2 the Yes of Contracting the that Authority: PPP theLaw Article Contracting Authority, Applicants and36.2 Article of and Authority who 52 25 the PPP of working feel the should Law they PPPdays hav Dec pro and A Yes No Article 95 of the PP Law provides: the n/a n/a bidders Yes may, after an Article 95 to appeal Yes of the the contracting PP Law provides: authority, Article the 95 of the bidders contest PP Law the provides may, after decis Yes article 26 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law n/aGeneral Yes Regulation, Article 26 of the awardingNothe of PPP Law n/a a contract Regulation can be challenged establishes that the through C Yes (Public Procurement Chapter XXIYes Accordingof 60Remedies) to Yes the Article 164 Public Procurement Public Procurement According to Yes Article Act regulates 169 Act: Pursuant of this The 1.the Public area. Public to Article Procurement Procurement the Arb 145(2) ofAct: ( Yes No Rule 173 (iv) of the General n/a Financial n/a Yes "Suitable Rules provides, provision The regular No procedures should be n/akept for in the appeals to bidding the Supreme Cour document t Yes No According to n/a the LKPP Regulation n/a 29/2018, art. No "a selection 18 (3)(m), n/a of a business No n/aentity through a one-stage ten Yes Yes Article 25 of 21 the Tenders Article Law provides under 25 of "Complaint Yes the Tenders Article Law provides review 25 of Yes procedure": theunder Tenders a- Should "Complaint Lawany Article 25 of of review the provides theunder bidders Tenders procedure": "Complaint Law an have a- o pro Yes Yes of the29 In Chapter Seven Article Government Contracts 7 of the Yes Instructions Government The the Contracts "Settlement Noare ondecisions Instructions subject ofn/a Disputes", to provides tothat appealArticle the in 7 regular (First) each contra provid courts Yes No The relevant n/a review is a judicial review n/a to the High No Court of n/a No Ireland conducted accordance with Order 84A of the in n/a Yes No Section 21 of the Mandatory n/a Tenders n/aRegulation Yes (e)decisions provides:All No (1) A participant issued as maya result withinof n/a 30the days of the date scrutinizing of ha process Yes Yes According to article 211 (1) of the 30 Public According to Yes Contracts article Code: 211 Pursuant At the (1) ofinitiative thetoPublic Yes Article of Contracts the 100 contracting Pursuant of the Administrative to Code: At Article authority the initiative 100 orProcess one of the of orthe mo Co Ad Yes Yes According to 14 the Procurement According Handbook, Volume to Yes the Procurement 1, According Section Handbook, to 2.5, "anyYes contractor, the Procurement Volume who1,claims Section Handbook, According the toto 2.5.1(a), have Procurement suffered for compl Volume Sec Ha 1, loss Yes Yes The Japanese established Government has 14 Overview the of Nothe Government n/a Government Procurement Procurement Yes Challenge ThisSystem is regulated Complaint Procedure to support byavailable thegreater Order go th aton Yes Yes Article 34 of the PPP Regulation21 provides According that: to “A. Noarticle It is permissible 34(E) n/a PPP of the for any No of the bidders Regulations, n/a “[t]he ofHigh the PPP Project to Committee sub shall is Yes Article 57 (3) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP n/a Law, disputes No relatedn/a No to the procedure n/a for determining a private partner are Yes Section 75 of the PPP Pursuant toYes Section 28 Act, 75(6) Yes the Petition of Committee the PPP Section Actis states 75(7) an Yes that of the "The independentPPP Petition Pursuant entity from Committee to the Section Act provides that procuring shall a75 person of the entity: hear and PPP aggr Yes Yes by Article This is detailed According 1044-2 (Formal Objection) to No of the Article PPP n/a 44-2 Act: (3) ofArticle theNo PPP Act, 44-2. the (1) A time person n/a limit who hasdays is ten from suffered disa athe d Yes Article 46 of Pursuant toYes 15the PPP Law: Pursuant toYes Article 1. If a person participating 117 Pursuant of the in Public the toYes Article contract Procurement 46 award of the Pursuant Law: procedures PPP1. to Law: The Article PRB 3. set 46 Theshall out decision of the in issue PPP of this la its Yes Yes Article 32 of 21provides Article the PPP Law that:"1. A of 32 Grievance Yes the PPP Committee Law The provides Administrative Yes that: shall be"3. established Circuit The Grievance in the Article 32 a by of Court decision Committee theof PPP First Law of the shall Instance provide Counc issue a Yes Article 19 of the PPP Pursuant toYes 42Law Pursuant toNo Article <...>, disputes arising 42(1) n/a of the Administrative between the No parties to n/a Procedures the PPP agreement in connectia Law, the maximum Yes Yes Art 46 of Law 15 on Procurement Article Under Governmental 15 of Yes the Guideline Article Budget on 30/NA, no. 15.2 the Yes Implementation ofdated the Guideline 02Article November on of the the 15.2 2017, of Law Implementation the onaProcurement bidder can Guideline of onm tU Yes Article 29 of the PPP Pursuant toYes 30Law, Thethere is Yes PPP Law a Article complaint 30 Article (1) review provides mechanism 31 Yes of for the the PPPone-month regarding Law Article statesthe 28the of procurement the period: possibility The PPP Complaint to Law: file (1) The processanR Yes Yes According to 28 Article the PPP Law, art. 7(7)(b), 106 "the project (9) Yesofcommittee, As per the Public assisted the Article Yesby the Procurement 94 Law of working provides the Decree Article 106 that of team,10434 shall the committee prepare of 14/6/1975, Public a draf in c Procurem Yes Yes procedure for concessions The complaints 8 Pursuant toYes Article 74(3) procurement isPursuant set of out Concessions to the in No Article 72 Articles 73Law, and of n/a74 <...> the of 3 the Concessions The Concessions awarding Law, there Law.is Pur authoritth Yes No Article 49 of n/a the PPP Law addressing n/a Yes disputes related The to PPP Law No. projects No states 2004-036 n/a any that of the dispute 1st October arising2004 on or directly inoc the Yes Yes According to the Public Procurement 10 According Act № 8 Yes of to the 2003, PublicAccording section Procurement 37(1), to"subject the YesActPublic №to subsection of Procurement 2003, section 8 According (2), to the Act any 38(3), Public №bidder 8 of Procurem 2003, "the head that s cl Yes No Government The Malaysia's n/a n/a Procurement Regime No has a section system for n/a n/a titledNo appeals, reviews and remedies. T Yes art. 29 of the Pursuant toYes Pursuant 7 PPP Decree: toYes Bidders can art. complaint 29 of the According before PPP to the Yes Decree:Art. procuring Bidders 29 of According the can authority. PPP complaint Decree, Art. before toThis the complaint 29 of decision the theprocur PPP must D of No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 59 of n/a the Public-Private Partnerships n/a Yes Law establishes Pursuant the legal toNo article 59 of alternativesn/a available the PPP Law, to submit a complaint against the award Yes Yes review mechanism The complaints 20 Pursuant for the procurement toYes Article 39process of Pursuant the Concessions toYes ArticleLaw, of concessions42(13) isPursuant "Submission provided of the to under Article of the Chapter Concessions37 appeal", of Law,VI,"The the the Conc Settl Yes Yes According to 14 the Concessions art. 34.1, Law, The Concessions "complaints Yes Law doesn't According related to the to No excludethe granting or Concessions of n/a aan prohibit concession application Law, art.shall 34.1, of the "complaint be Public Pr submitted Yes Yes specific complaint There is a more review 30 For appeal the mechanism Yes mechanism under Forthe envisaged the appeal Yesby mechanism the Concessions Law Concessions For andthe envisaged a more appeal general Law,by mechanism according the complaint Concession to envisa there Yes Article 32 of the National Pursuant toYes Commission 21 Article Yes 32 of theon National Public TheProcurement biddersYes may Commission on Decree:The contest Public TheProcurement bidders the tendermay bidders may procedure Decree contest contest provides: inthe front the ten deco Yes Yes Article 20 of 14 the PPP Regulations (Decree Article 275 16/2012) of NoDecree 05/2016 allows for a period Article 276 states: of No Decree of 30 days 05/2016 n/a forof (Admission the Complaint) states: non-selected 1. Classification, bidders (Admission to p of Hier Yes No Section 11.2 Policy state: of the PPPn/a n/a Projects to No n/a be implemented No under n/a PPP (i)Government of Nepal, public enterp Yes No The Ministry of Economic n/aAffairs created n/a an independent Yes Pursuant toof Committee the YesProcurement explanatory Pursuant Experts notes Article ("Commissie to that follow 3 of the the van Institu Aan text o Yes Yes According to 28 According the Procurement Rules, to Yes Rule 47(1), the "a supplier GuideAccording tomay complain to Supplier Feedback the to Yes Procurement anand agency TheComplaints original Rules, if complain Rule issued it believes the 47,must by "ifthe a suppl be agency re Minha Yes Yes According to articles 4614 of the PPP Article Regulation, Yes 46 of bidders the PPPmay Regulation According file a review to Yes article against provides its in47 the of According last the resolution paragraph PPP to article ofthat award 47 once Regulation, if of orthe declar the PPP app Cont Yes Yes Article 51 of 30provides:Article the PPP Law Contest of 51arising Yes the from the Pursuant PPP Law provides: tender to procedures No Art. Contest arising 89 of Organization n/a from regarding the the awrad Act tender No. 2004-50 procedures shall of 2 be broug Yes Yes Section 54 of the Public21 Procurement Section 54 of Yes Act provides: the Public (1) A bidder Section Procurement may 54seek of Yesthe Act administrative provides: Public Procurement (2)review Section 54Aof complaint the for Act any Public provides: omission by a bidde (3) Th Procuremo Yes paragraph 1 of the PP Article 138, Yes Article 15 Law 167,Any states: Yes paragraph economic 6 Article operator of the PP Law 170 No of having the states: PP Law n/a The a legal interest states: State The Appeals in obtaining decision Commission a the of Stat public p on Yes Yes According to 10 According the Public Procurement to Rules, 2004, Yes the Section 48: Procurement "(1) The PublicAccording No toprocuring the Rules, 2004, agency Public Procurement n/a Section shall 48(3), constitute Rules, " The a GRC committ 2004, shal Sectio Yes Yes Article 153 of Law 22/2006 provides 7 According for complaints to Yes article that155 may Article Law of be 163. 22/2006, filed for Yes Exhaustion review the General of Article ofthe the 15.11 governmental Directorate General Directorate of 22 Lawof route. Public of for 2006 Con Pub (P Once Yes Section 75 21 Pursuant toYes PursuantAct: of the Procurement toNo Section (1)Subject 75 n/a to the of part, Yes thisProcurement a person Act: who Pursuant is aggrieved (3)On to Section receivingby the a75 decision complaint, Pro of the of t Yes Yes Article 25 of the PPP Law, regarding 21 Article appeals, 25 of Nothe PPPInterested provides: Law: n/aAppeals. parties NoInterested parties an appeal may filen/a mayagainst file anthe appeal agains decisions o Yes of the PPP Regulation Article 52.1No n/a n/a stablish that No n/a tender rules No this mechanisms must include n/a Yes Section 9.1 of the BOT Pursuant toYes Law IRR: to 63 Pursuant Any No Section 9.1n/a of bidder disqualified the BOTmay No Law IRR: Any appeal n/a thedisqualified disqualification bidder may of the appea concern Yes 579 of the Public Procurement Pursuant toYes Law, Yesthe under 15 This is stipulated parties Pursuant Article and participants toYes Article 515(1) in of the 579 the Public Pursuant ofappeal the Public proceedings to Article Procurement Procurement Law. 473 are ofentitled the Law,Put According Yes Yes review (by the procuring Administrative authority): 5 Article 274 (1) Yesof Articles PublicArticles Contracts 267 to184Code No 274et ofseq. Public 18;of Articles Contracts n/aAdministrative the Code 94 (1) and18. 102Judicial (3) (b) review Procedure the of Cod No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 8 of Law No. Pursuant toYes 15101/2016, Pursuantthe Article person24 toYes who of Pursuant Law considers No.toYes itself Article 101/2016: 29(1) injured of Pursuant The Law by an Council No.to 101/2016, act Article resolves of the contracting 8 of the on the decision Law mer au No. 1 Yes Article 22 of Pursuant toYes 15the PPP Law, Pursuant a bidder toNo who is 22 Article of not n/a satisfied the PPPwith Nothe Law, a partner competitive n/a who is not satisfiedprocedures procurement with the co Yes Yes According to 14 regarding section C.11 Section Award V of Contract Yes of of the the Guidelines Section Guidelines for V Government the ofNo for Guidelines Government Procurement, n/a for Government Procurement regardingGWGS, Award par inq Procuremen Yes Yes Article 39 of Article the PSP Law requires 39.8for Article of the setting 39.8Law PSP of up Yes the requires of PSP Law Asthe per a committee requires NCP's Article toYes Board the 39.7 hearNCP's appeals of ofDirectors the Article Board PSP against Law of 39 toDirectors of issue the the the tendering decisions the PSPrules toLaw issue of and governi mandat the awa co ru Yes Yes Article 123 of the PPP Decree 15-30 of 2021 Article states 126 of Yes that: PPP "[t]he appeal Article Decree of 2021 provided 126 provides of YesPPP forDecree by the "[t]he Article provisions of decision 2021 3 of provides of the ofthe PPP Article Law "[t]he 50 Dispute defines of decisio Resol Law t Yes Yes According to the PPP Law, art. 58, 20 "legal According to Yes protection the in Public the According Procurement procedure of Yes to awarding Law, the Public art.According a 158, Procurement public "the Republic to the Law, contract PPP shall art. Commission Law, be 159, art. "no58 ensuredf Yes review is given expressly The right toYes to all bidders 7 Pursuant Section toYes at all 64(3) stages The of of thethe Public Yes decisions procurement are Procurement subject While process to appeal Law, the under there pursuant Section is original complaint a deadline to the 63 of is of th de prov Yes Yes Proceedings Part III Challenge 45 of the Pursuant GPA regulates toNo Sections 12n/a and 18 of the complaints review the YesGPA, the system timeframe regarding Pursuant tothe Section for procurement procurement proc cha 8 of the GPA, Yes Yes Chapter IV of 7 According the Public Procurement to Act is devoted Yes the Public to theProcurement revision procedures. According Yes to the Act, Public §165 Particularly, Procurement (3), "the contracting According according to the Act, Public §165(5), authority toProcurem Publ the"the Procurement Section Awarding the is reviewe 7.2, Pro Step Yes Yes According to the PPA, art. 163(1), 5 "a According potential toor Yes the actual PPA, art. bidder According 164(4), that claims to "unless Yes theto PPA, the have complaint According suffered, art. to for or 164(5),is resolved the that a complaint PPA, is likely by art. to 164(5), made mutual a suffe Yes No According to n/a the PAJA, Section 5(1), n/a Yes "any person The judicial whose rights have been No review decision n/a materially and made adversely by theaffected by adm High Court with Yes Yes Article 44 et 7 Article seq. of LCSP regulates the special 57.1Yes procurement LCSP. The complain Article appeal. 59 of Yes mustLCSP be decided states Article in 5 that 45 business and the against 59day. of resolution Furthermor LCSP of that th cre Yes No According to the Publicn/a Procurement n/a No Section 8.3.1(a), Guidelines, n/a "the Yes to the Lineto Secretary According the Public Ministry Procurem shall within o Yes No According to of the PPP Act, Article 28 n/a n/a “[a]fterNo announcing n/a of the competition, the resultsNo n/a the government entity i Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Act, Chapter n/a §4, "following 16, Yes According an application to No for review n/a from the Concessions Act, a Chapter private16, entity "an ap §5, that co Yes No According to of the PP Law, article 27 n/a Yes of theAccording n/athe decisions bidding authority to No can article 27be n/a of challenged the PP Law,before the Federal the decisions of th Yes Article 79 of Pursuant toYes 3 the PublicIf Procurement the complaint YesLaw: Participants is submitted to of Pursuant the to Article procuring the Yes 81procurement of entity, the Public public the Pursuant procuring to Procurement Article proceedings of the 3 entity Public will shall re 1. hav Law: Yes Section 95 and 96 of Pursuant toYes 14 Pursuant the of Section to Section 96 Law, Public Procurement toYes the complaints PublicYes to Section Procurement are allowed regarding Act, the procurement the deadline for reaching No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes article 15 of Pursuant toYes 15 Pursuant the PPP Law, toYes an applicant article may of According the PPP 15request Law, to No a reviewarticle an of applicant an award 68 n/a of may or appeal Decree-Law request No. against a 32/2008, decisions review an27 of of t a Yes Yes Articles 56 to 7 Article the 61 of the PPP Law describe 58 of complaint Yes the PPP Law Article of 2021 mechanism.59 of provides Yes the PPP Law for the ofrelevant provides Article 59 of the timelines that: PPP "The regarding Law of prov decision Yes Yes Part 11 of the 17 Regulations Procurement Section allows 76 and for77 No of the n/a complaints Procurement by bidders Yes Regulations for any Section loss due 76(2) allow a breach toup of to the 7 days Procuremen of duty by for an a ind Yes Yes According to 28 the PPA, art. 41(1), "the According Office [of to Nothe PPA, art. n/a50(11), Procurement "the Regulation] Yes may decision on According its of the initiative, own to the Office under PPA, or shall subsection art. as a res 41(1), ( " Yes Yes The Article 16 60 The of PPP Law provides for Article bid contest 16 Yes PPP Law ofbeforeAccording theprovides Administrative to No Article for contest 6 and n/a40 bid Tribunal.before of thethe Law No.72-40 dated Administrative Tr Yes Yes Article 54 of 10 Pursuant the Public Procurement Law allows toYes Article candidates, 55 of the tenderers Public Pursuant Procurement Article toYesor potential 56 of Pursuant tenderers Law: the The Public to contracting Article Procurement who claim 56 ofauthorit the Law, that Pub th they Yes Yes of clear 21 In the absence PPP-specific Section rules, the general Yes 90 of the Public procurement Procurement Section rules 91 of Act IYes the would provides: Public apply Section in (2) this 91 On ProcurementB narrow receiving of the Actmanner. Public provides: Procur Secti (1) the compla Yes Yes The Code of 15 Procedure Administrative Pursuant provides toYes Article details277Pursuant and timelines of the Code tofor No Article onthe Administrative 287n/a of of review theadministrative Code Procedure, on Administrative offenses the and Pr administr Yes Yes Article 37(a) 30 Article of the Dubai PPP Law provides37(a) that No "[a]ny of affected n/a the Dubai PPPparty Law Yes provides: may submit a. Article a written Any 37(a) grievance affected of party the may Dubai to submit PPP the Law DOFa Yes No mechanisms The complaint n/a n/a are regulated in Regulations Yes Appeals 50 are to 64 of the No possible and CCR 2016. In n/a would particular, be regulated by the Regulation pro 52gen Yes Yes The Code of 10 Virginia addresses protest theThe Codetoof award Yes Virginia addresses The Code or decision award of tothe Yes timeframe Virginia under §The for allows 2.2-4360: the code fordecision of appeals § Virginia 2.2-4360. to onthe theProtest decision protestof establishes ot un Yes Yes Article 317 of 150 the Constitution provides Depending on Yes that all administrative the position Article acts, of 317including of Yes procuring theauthority Constitution theArticle decision 307 provides within the toof award the Administration, that constitution a bid, all administ can be es thc Yes Yes regulations do 15 The PPP-related provide for notAccording Yes toathe complaints LRU №According mechanism 445 to No “About the Appeals specific LRU № to n/a of 445 Individuals the “About PPP procurement and Appeals Legalof process. IndividuA Entities,� Yes of the Government Section 13DNo n/a Tenders n/a Act provides Yes The under Island Courts "Complaints Yes Review Act Cap Section Mechanism": 13D of (1) 167 providesthe for A tenderer Government the general mayjuT Yes The PPP Law contains article 96 which Yes deals 9 Article of 96 directly Yes the PPP with procedures Articles Law 96.1(c) states: Yes for "1. Procedures handling and 96.2(c) of forpetitions of settlement the to According PPPArticle arising Lawof petitions 96.1(c) from investo provide that abou of the Yes Yes According to 14 40, the PPP Act, Section "a bidder According toYes that the Public claims Procurement to have suffered, According Yes to Act, the Public Section or that According Procurement 100 (4)(c), may to the suffer, "unless loss Act,Public Section or injury an Procurem 100 due(6 applicat Yes Yes According to the PPA, Section 73(1), 5 According "a potential to the Yesor PPA, actual According bidder73(5), Section in procurement to Yes for a the PPA, complaint Section According proceedings 74(1), to the lodged with who "where the PPA, claims -(a) Section procuring to a have 74( procu e Yes No According to section 46n/a of the Tender n/a Rules, aNo bidder mayn/a No of grievance file a complaint n/a of valid grounds and evide Yes Yes According to 7 According the PPP Law, art. 9(12), to "a negative Yes the opinion of According an authorized FAS Administrative Yes to the Regulation, body Federal may According section be appealed Law 2.13, to the № 135-FZ “the in Resolution About the supervisory manner Protectio pr of th Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q32 Q31.3_4_TEXT Q32.1#1_1 Q32.1#4_1 Q32.1#2_1_1 Q32_1_TEXT Q32.1#1_2 Q32.1#4_2 Q32.1#3_1_1 the and identify32. Does approving the If procuring authority: yes, please 32. authority provide If yes, which publish the Available relevant of the online thePPP legal/regulatory Website following contract? elements Relevant provisions: does (notwithstanding legal/regulatory 32.2. the publication the The full Available protection PPP provision contract: online include? of commercially 32.1. Available A summary sensi (e.g. by Assessment Complaints No Committee n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes Pursuant The Public Procurement toNo Commission. Article 14 of No n/a1. The Concession/Public the PPP Law: n/a Yes Yes Private Partnership Registry shall be an n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes No According to (e) of the PPP article 18 No n/aRegulation n/a Yes the PPP contracts Yes concluded and their annexes must n/a Yes No According to article 29 No of the PPP Law, n/a the PPP Unit must Yes n/a a specific public and free interne implement Yes Yes Procurement Pursuant Complaint Investigator toYes Article 11 of the Procurement Yes Law: https://procurement.minfin.am/ Pursuant 1. The contracting toNo Article 11 of Nothe Procurement authority shall publish a Law: notice on co 1. The th Yes The NSW Procurement Board As and noted Yes inthe Section NSW8.1 Civil ofand Yes National www.tenderers.nsw.gov.au PPP Guidelines the Administrative Tribunal Section (NCAT). 8.2 andof expanded Yes or the NSW https://www.treasury.nsw.gov.au/in Yes on PPP Section 8.1 inGuidelines of the NSW provides PPP under " n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Panel constituted The ReviewNo n/a by the NoPPP Authority. No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes No According to No Article 6 of the Regulation n/a on State n/a Yes State Register Register, the No is maintained by entering i n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes Art. 7 of the PPP Unit Decree Yes Yes provides Ministry that the of finance PPP Art. ofwebsite: the 7 Unit shall No PPP https://www.finances.bj/accueil/ Unit Decree publish every year No provides a public thatreport on the PPP all Unit Council within AppellationYes Pursuant the Council toNo Article 21 of No of Ministers theof Sarajevo n/aPPP Bosnia Herzegovina n/a and Law: Yes partner Yes (1) The public shall submit the signed PPP Agree No n/a The Public Procurement No Regulatory Authority Board. No The Public n/a Procurement n/a No Tribunal. No n/a Yes Article 61, sole Yes paragraph, Yes of the Public Official Gazette: Article Procurementhttps://e-diariooficial.com/dou-diario-oficial-da-un 61, Law No (Law sole paragraph, 8.666/1993) No of the provides that every contr Public Procurement Law Yes Commission Pursuant for Protection of Competition toYes Article 124 Yes https://nkr.government.bg/ of the Concession (1) Within Law:Pursuant toNo one Article 124 No month of the from the Concession conclusion of the Law: Withi (1) conce Yes Article 71 of ARCOP: http://www.arcop.bf/ the PPP Decree Yes n/athat approved No provides Article PPP 71 of contracts Yes the PPP shall No be provides Decree published in accordance that w approved PPP n/a Yes Pursuant toYes article 7 of No the PPP Decree, n/a the Agency’s website Pursuant toNo article must include 7 of No the PPP maximum Decree, details about we the Agency’s the n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes Canadian International Trade Tribunal. Pursuant toYes Section Office 86 Yes of of Canada's the Procurement https://www.tc.gc.ca/en/transport-canada.html Access Ombudsman. to Information Pursuant toAct, No Section certain Competition86 Tribunal. No of information regarding Canada's Access contracts o to Information Yes appealArticle The non-judicial 40 of body responsible Yes the PPP forOrdinance No acquisition. public n/a provides: An extract Article of 40the No of the public-private PPP Ordinance No partnership provides: An extract contract of t is publi Yes Tribunal Public Purchasing ("Tribunal According No to article de Contratación 98 No of the Concessions n/a Pública") n/a Regulations: Yes the decree Once Yes awarding the concession con n/a Yes article 20 of Pursuant toNo NoPPP Procurement n/a n/athe project 2014, Yes Yesimplementation body shall publicize the P n/a Yes No is published The PPP contract No via Internet n/a n/a - Article on SECOP Yes of the PPP Regulation (Decr Yes2.2.1.1.1.7.1 No n/a The public procurement regulatingNo authority ( No ARMP) n/a n/a No No Yes n/a The Public Procurement Regulation Yes Authority.No n/a No Article 83 of Procurement Code provides: the the Public No No Comptroller n/a General Office No No n/a n/a No No Yes The National of Regulation Authority Article 24 of Yes PPP of Public Decree Contracts No. 2018-358 Yes https://ppp.gouv.ci of March Article 24 of 29, 2018 relating NoPPP Decree to Public No Private Partnerships No. 2018-358 contra of March 29, 201 Yes The State Commission for TheSupervision registerYes of public-private of Public Yes Procurement partnership https://investcroatia.gov.hr/en/ppp/registry/ Procedures. acts The is regulated registerNo of public-private under No16 of Article partnership the PPP Act: acts The (1)is Agen regulate Yes The Office for According the Protection to No of Competition. the PublicNo Procurement n/a n/a "a contracting Act, §174(1), Yes Yes shall proceed in accordance authority Complaints According The Danish Yes to Nosection Board for Public Procurement 175(1) No of the Public n/a n/a Procurement Yes Act, No of the contract, a contracting "For the term No The PPP Commission n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes Article 20 of Yes the PPP Regulations Yes http://www.comprasdominicana.gov.do/ provides: "Registration Article 20 of and No publication the PPP Regulations No of public-private and https://www.dgcp.go provides: partnership c "Registration n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No No The Petition n/a Committee No established by virtue of NoArticle 39 of the PPPn/a n/a Law. No No n/a Yes No Article 105.A of PPP Law: No"the PPP-Unit n/a will create Yes registry Yes n/a the public of public private partnership pro n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes According The Public Procurement Review Committee. to Yes the PublicNo n/a Information According Act that entered intoto force Nothe PublicNo Information 1 January 2001, § 4(1), Act that "in order to ens entered into n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes which is Council of State the supreme Article Yes Courts R.2196-1 of thefor Yes Public Acquisition Publication admistrative CodeArticle claims. on indicates the R.2196-1 contracting that Yes the procuring the No Public authority of authority'sAcquisition buyer profile. provides, Code Theindicates on its b State's o n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes Dispute Resolution Pursuant Board toYes Article (established by the 15^1 Public Yes (9) of the www.ppp.gov.ge Public Procurement Procurement Pursuant Law). Law, - however, toYes Article theittender 24(7) Yes should of beResolution noted that commission shall No. this 426, website the publish Com isco the u No A Public Procurement n/a Tribunal. No No n/a n/a No No No Public Procurement n/a Board No No n/a n/a No No Yes Independent for the Review Authority Pursuant Article toNo of Prejudicial 59 of No Complaints n/a (AEPP). the Concessions access to the Law, n/a Yes No multiple other categories of c contract and n/a Yes No Article 30 of the PPP Law Noand Articles n/a151 andn/a Yes Regulations, 152 of the PPP No indicate that the contracts Resolutionn/a The DisputeNo and Sanction NoCommittee No (CRDS), which n/a is a body No n/a of the ARMP. No ResolutionPursuant The DisputeYes toYes Committee which is article 3 of sa the non-judicial Yes https://cnmp.gouv.ht/ appeal Ethics Charter, the body. Pursuant names oftoNo article private 3 of No partners the and Ethics value of contracts, Charter, theof the names co n/a Yes No Article 93 of the Regulation No of the PPP n/a Law.- Publication n/a Yes of Yes information .- Once signed the Agreement Yes Public Procurement According Arbitration to No Committee Article 43 n/a of the Public Procurement n/a Yes contracting n/a Act:(1) The Yes authority shall publish in the n/a Yes for the PPP No The Toolkit No Cell provides n/a for the publication n/a the PPP agreement ofYes Yes as it is important for ma n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No No Appeals Committee n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes No The Freedom of Information No Law 5758-1998 n/a n/a provides No publication for the Yes of information in which PPP c No Council of State n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes The National According Contracts’ to Yes Commission the (NCC) PPP Policy, Yes Section summary A 10.0.1, According of the "<…> PPP the concessions to Yes Unit thewill PPP adopt Policy, Yes the agreement Section following for the 10.0.1, further practices developm "<…> on dis the PP Yes Procurement The Government Article 15, Challenge Paragraph Yes Review 3 No Board of PFI Act states n/a that when Article concluding No a business 15, Paragraph 3 No of PFI contract, Act states that when concl an administrator of n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes Article 169 No Pursuant toNo n/a of Order No. 725:For republican n/a Yes PPP to enter data into the register of projects,Yes Yes Petition Committee Yes Section 69 of Noprovides n/a the PPP Act that (1) a contracting Section 69authority of No shall, the PPP Act Noprovides on the execution that (1) a of a project a contracting n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes Review The Procurement Body. toNo Pursuant Article 14 (1) Noof the PPP n/a Law, notwithstanding n/a paragraph 2 Yes of Article 7 of this Law, the Pub Yes No Grievance Committee n/a to be adopted Noby the Higher No Committee n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No No Finance Unit n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes Review Commission The Complaint No Article 68 of within the PPP Law the Procurement Noprovides:n/a (3) Monitoring n/a Not later than Bureau. within Yes Yes 10 working days from the day when the pu YesCommittee The Objection According to Yes the Law № 28 dated 10/2/2017 Yes (hereafter, www.hcp.gov.lb According "Access to No to Information the Law №No28 dated Law"), 10/2/2017 (hereafter, art. 1, "every pe n/a Yes Article 86 (9) Pursuant toYes Yesof the Public https://cvpp.eviesiejipirkimai.lt/Notice Pursuant Procurement Law to<...> No Article contracting the86 Noof the authority (9) must publish Public Procurement Lawin n/a Yes article 26 of Pursuant toNo Nothe PPP Decree n/a (Decree Yes n/a2017-149 No 2017, elaborating on the app from 2 March No of Public Office of Director No n/a Procurement No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No settlementPursuant The disputeYes toYes body of the Article Public 23 Acquisition of Nothe PPP Decree, n/a the Regulatory Authority award Pursuant noticeArticle toNo 23 of No is published the andPPP includes Decree, winning thethe award not bidde n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Article 11 of the PPP Law Yes requires to publish "data Article https://compranet.hacienda.gob.mx/web/login.html regarding 11 of Yes the PPP the PPP Law No contracts requires to publish and "data regar their modifications No The National n/a Agency for the Solution Noof the Appeals. No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes No According to No the Law on Glass Account, n/a art. 6.5.9 Yes "the State n/aand 6.5.10, YesCentral Administrative Body Re Yes mechanism For the appeal envisaged According Yes to the by Concessions the Concessions Yes Law,Law, Part the III, Article Concession Pursuant 15(1), http://www.komisijazakoncesije.me/registar-koncesija; Commission to "concession Article 90of No contracts of Montenegro. the PPPshall No Law,be For Public-Private registered appealinPar me the thehttps://mia No The National n/afor Public Commission NoProcurement No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes Paragraph 1 of article 24 Yes Noof the PPP n/a Paragraph Regulations 1 (Decree 16/2012) No of article 24 andNoArticle of the PPP 23 of Regulations (Decree the PPP Law (No. 1 n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No No Commission Experts of Tender n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes Possible reviewing According authorities to include: No the the Auditor-General; › PPP No Section Guide, n/a 8.8, › the Ombudsman; n/asuccessfully "having Yes › theconcluded State Services Yesthe procurement and› thethe Commission;process, Co Yes The Minister of Finance andContracts PPP Public No Credit and its amendments No n/a approved by have to ben/a Law according Yes No to article 23 of the PPP Law n/a Yes Yes Art. 38 of the PPP Law provides No n/a : An the 38 extract ofArt. partnership of the NoPPP Law provides contract Noshall be : An published in the Offici extract of partn Yes Procurement Bureau of Public No is mainly This publication Nodone on the n/a ICRC PPP n/a Disclosure Portal: https://ppp.icrc.gov.ng/ Yes Yes and is based n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Act, NoSection 24, n/a“the public n/aprivate partnership Yes No agreement shall be a public docum Yes General Directorate Public Procurement of Article No 41 of the PPP Law Noestablishes: n/a“PPP Contracts. n/a contracts are PPPYes Yespublic law. The PPP contracts, No Authority to n/a Pre-commit Committee Noestablished Nounder the n/a PFMA n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 15 of No PPP Law: "Transparency. n/aThe Public-Private n/a Yes Partnership Yes Unit must submit an annu Project n/a Yes No The signed version of the NoPPP contract n/a must be submittedYes n/a Yes of Finance (MEF) in order to to the Ministry n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes The National The signed Appeal Chamber agreement (Krajowa No Izba Odwoławcza). itself No is not published n/a n/a but Yes is available No for third parties who wish to become acqu n/a Yes Article 33 (g) Pursuant toNo Noof the PPP n/a Law, contracts n/a and its annexes are Yes Yespublished/made available on U n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No No is reviewed The initial appeal No n/a by the National Council No n/a Complaints. for Solving n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes Article 39 of Article the PSP Law mandate 31 of Yes the PSP Law complaint to Yes an requires independent According NCP to establish committee to Pursuant Article a registry to be to31 Yes of Article formed the for PSP of 31 of projects Law, Yes attheall PSP least information, which five Law, will experts all information, include with documents, the a comp dec do Yes Dispute Resolution Article 98 of Committee PPP Decree Yes Yes provides that UNAPPP wbesite Article the terms which of the 98partnership of No PPP is Decree yet to be contract Yes created provides are that the terms published of the on the web p Yes The Republic According Commission for the to Protection Nothe PPP Law, n/a of Rights Chapter in the X, Area n/a art. 74, of Public "public n/a Procurement. contracts Yes shall be recorded in the Register of Pub Yes No Procurement n/a Review Panel No No n/a n/a No No No Procurement The Government n/a No Adjudication Tribunal No n/a n/a No No Yes Public Procurement According to Office. Nothe PublicNo Procurement n/a I, Part II, Chapter Act, Art. n/a Yes "the contracting authority Yes I, §64(1)(c), Yes The National Review Commission According to (the Nothe Access National n/a to Audit Committee). Public n/a Information Act of 2003Yes n/a Yes of the Republic of Slovenia (Official Gazette No The Solomon n/a Islands Ombudsman.No No n/a n/a No No No Procurement The Independent n/a Review No Panel. No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yesissued by The complaint the bidder Article 154 LCSP No is resolvedNo by a special that mandates then/a publication entity the n/a administrative of the contract onlineYes Yes tribunal at public of most 15contracts days after its signatu ("Tribunal Co No Appeal The Procurement n/aBoard at No the Presidential No Secretariat. n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No No State Body The Authorized No n/a on Procurement No n/a n/a No No No Public Procurement n/a Authority Appeals No No n/a n/a No No n/a Yes Yes 1. According to Section Yes 9 of the Official https://ppp.sepo.go.th/ 1. According Information No Act, B.E. to Section 2540 No (1997), 9 of state the Official agency shall make Act, Information avai n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No No Public Procurement n/a Regulatory No Authority (ARCOP) No n/a n/a No No No Independent n/a Expext appointed by the No Procurement No Division n/a n/a No No Yes The Office of There Procurement Regulation. is no Yes obligation to No n/a publish a contract. According However, a notice to No PPA, the of art. award No contains 36(1), "upon certain entry into thecontract fo deta n/a Yes Yes Article 63 of the PPP Decree Yes No. 2016-772 http://www.igppp.tn/ Article ( Decree No. 63 2016-772 of No Decree the PPPof NoJune 20 No. 2016, 2016-772 Decree about(the No. condition No Public Procurement n/a Authority No No n/a n/a No No Yes Public Procurement Section and Disposal 47(3) of Yes Public of theAssets No PPP Appeals Act requires n/a Tribunal all PPP agreements to No Section 47(3) bethe of PPP published No Act requires on all PPP the website the Ministr ofagreements n/a Yes Nothe Resolution Article 153 of No of then/a Cabinet ofn/a Yes the procedure Ministers, "On No for conducting a concessio No of Finance The Department No(DoF) n/a of Dubai No n/a n/a No No n/a No n/a No No n/a n/a No No Yes Disinterested Pursuant person or panel; depending toYes sectionon 4.11 Yes the procedure. of the PPTA https://www.p3virginia.org/categories/current/ Manual and Pursuant toYes section Guidelines, the once4.11No contract of the PPTA Manualand is finalized decisi andaGuidel Yes Contentious According Administrative Courtto (Tribunal No Article 4 de No oflo the Contencioso PPP Law, n/aall acts and n/a agreements Administrativo), a jurisdictional Yes made under Yes the framework tribunal of this Law that is independent ofs n/a Yes Yes According to Article 20 Yes of the PPP Law, The official website Article 20 <...> informationofof about the No the PPP PPP development PPP projects, Nostates Law including,"among <...> agency information is https://www. on pub others, No Expertn/a An Independent No and Central Tenders Board No n/a n/a No No Yes Petition Settlement ArticleBoard Advisory 9 of the Yes PPP Law regarding transparency Yes Article muasamcong.mpi.gov.vn and disclosure 9 of the No PPP Law No regarding of information about transparency and disc PPP investments p The ZambiaYes AccordingAuthority Public Procurement to the PPP Act, Yes YesSection 38(2), The website "a notice According will depend issued under No to the on transaction subsection PPP No Section Act, and (2) [notice the 38(2), identity "acontract of of a procur notice awar issued panel appointed The review No n/a by theNo Procurement No Regulatory n/aAuthority of Zimbabwe. n/a No No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a Antimonopoly The FederalYes Service. According to the PPP Law, Yes Yesart. 11(2)(3), The website "the following According will dependto Nothe on the PPP information identity shall Law, Nobe art. published of an authorized 11(2)(3), on “the the body official following th in at we Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q32.1#3_2_1 Q32.1#2_2_1 Q32.1#3_3_1 Q32.1#1_3 Q32.1#4_3 Q32.1#2_3_1 Q32.1#1_4 Q32.1#4_4 Q32.1#2_4_1 Website 32.3. All of the Relevant legal/regulatory Available provision contract’s online Website Relevant annexes and appendixes: legal/regulatory 32.4. Available Any subsequent Available (e.g. by provision online amendment request Websiteor in made to the gazette) the official PPP con n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Pursuant toYes Article 14 of http://www.atrako.gov.al/?page_id=112 Yes the PPP Law http://www.atrako.gov.al/?page_id=112 and DCM No. 211to Pursuant dated No Article 16.03.2016, No 14 of the PPP "OnLaw creation n/aand DCM and administration 16.03 No.211 dated of ele n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a According Website of the to PPP Tecnhical Yes article Commission (e) of the 18 Yes PPP (“Comissão Website Regulation Técnica of the According PPP das the PPP Tecnhical Parcerias to contracts Noarticle Commission Público 18 concluded No (e) of Privadas�) (“Comissão the PPP n/a and Regulation their annexes Técnica the must PPP das be contracts publishe Parcerias Púc According to Yes article 29 Yes https://www.argentina.gob.ar/jefatura/ppp of the PPP Law, https://www.argentina.gob.ar/jefatura/ppp the PPP According Unit must toNo implement article 29 No of a specific Law, n/a the the PPPpublic andPPP free Internet Unit implemen mustconsultati n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a As noted in Yes Section www.tenderers.nsw.gov.au 8.1 Yes or https://www.treasury.nsw.gov.au/index.php/projects-initiatives/public-private-partnerships/a of the National www.tenderers.nsw.gov.au PPP Guidelines As notedand in Yes Section expanded or https://www.treasury.nsw.gov.au/index.php/pr 8.1 Yes on of the National www.tenderers.nsw.gov.au in Section PPP 8.1 of the Guidelines NSW PPP Guidelines and or ht expande n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Yes According to Article 6 of No n/a on State the Regulation Register,to According the Yes Article State6Register No of the Regulation is maintained n/a on State by entering information Register, the State R n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Pursuant toYes http://mp.ks.gov.ba/en Yes Article 21 of the Sarajevo http://mp.ks.gov.ba/en PPP Law: (1) The public Pursuant Article toYes partner 21 of Yes shall thesubmit http://mp.ks.gov.ba/en the Sarajevo PPP signed Law:PPP (1) The public partne Agreement with n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Yes No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a Pursuant toYes Article 124 Yes https://nkr.government.bg/ of the Concession Law: (1) Within one mont n/a No Article 71 of the PPP Decree No provides n/athat approved n/a PPP contracts No No be published shall n/a in accordance with article 47 n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Article 98 Concessions Yes Regulation: Yes https://concesiones.mop.gob.cl/Paginas/default.aspx https://concesiones.mop.gob.cl/Paginas/default.aspx Once the decree Articleof 98award Concessions Yes of the concession Regulation: Yes https://concesiones.mop.gob.cl/ Once the contract, will decree be public all relevant of award of the Pursuant toYes article 9 in Yes Notice of the www.cpppc.org:8086/pppcentral/map/toPPPList.dowww.cpppc.org:8086/pppcentral/map/toPPPList.do Ministry of Pursuant FinancetoYes on Issuing Article 7(2) thein Interim Yes NoticeMeasures of www.cpppc.org:8086/pppcentra the Ministry for theofAdministration Finance on Issui of Article 2.2.1.1.1.7.1 Yes of Decree Yes https://community.secop.gov.co/Public/Tendering/ContractNoticeManagement/Index?currentLanguage=es-CO&Page=login& 1082/2015 https://community.secop.gov.co/Public/Tendering/ContractNoticeManagemen states Article that 2.2.1.1.1.7.1 the procuring Yes of authority Decree Yes shall https://community.secop.gov.co publish 1082/2015 states all the that the procuring administrative ac n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a Yes Yes http://investcroatia.gov.hr/en/ppp/registry/ The registerYes of public-private http://investcroatia.gov.hr/en/pp Yes partnership acts is regulated under Art a contracting A profile of According Yes to authority the Procurement PublicYes in the Public A profile Procurement Act, §174(1), a contracting Information "a contracting of According Yes to the authority System: Public authority Procurement inhttp://www.isvz.cz/ISVZ/Podpora/ISVZ.asp Yes Public theshall A profile proceed Procurement Act, §174(1), in ofaccordance a contracting Information "a contracting authori with Syste the p au n/a Yes According to section 175(1) No of the Public n/a Procurement According to No Act, section "For the175(1) term No of thecontract, ofthe Public n/a Procurement a contracting Act, "For the authority s n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Yes Yes http://www.comprasdominicana n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Article 105-A Yes of the http://www.proesa.gob.sv/ PPPYes Law or http://dapp.gob.sv/ http://www.proesa.gob.sv/ Article 105-A Yes of the PPPYes Law Yes or http://dapp.gob.sv/ n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No Yes The Public Procurement Register n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No are administrative Public contracts No documentsn/a n/a subject to the Yes right of Yes access established by Book A publication the onIII the Code on ofcontracting n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Pursuant toYes www.ppp.gov.ge Article 30 of Yes the PPP Law: www.ppp.gov.ge Pursuant toYes 1. The Public-PrivateArticle Partnership 30 of Yes the PPPis Agency Law: www.ppp.gov.ge obliged 1. The establish and Partners toPublic-Private manage n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Article 59 of Pursuant toYes Nothe Concessions n/a Law, Pursuant access totoYes Article the contract 59 of and No multiple the Concessions n/a other Law, categories toconcession-r accessof the contrac n/a No Article 30 of the PPP Law Noand Articles n/a151 andn/a 152 of the PPP No indicate No Regulations, n/athat the contracts must be reg n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Yes Yes https://cnmp.gouv.ht/ Article 93 of Yes the website The PPP Superintendence's No General Regulation (SAAP): https://sapp.gob.hn/ n/a of the PPP Article 93 Law that and of regulates Yes Procurement the General the Yes publication Regulation portion of Theof thePPP the transparency PPP obligations Superintendence's Law of PPP that contracts. regulates portal webs of Fu t Hon Pursuant toNo Article 43 of No https://kereso-core.kozbeszerzes.hu/ the Publicn/a Procurement No Act:(1) The Yesauthority Yescontracting shall publish in the public electr kba.kozbeszerzes.hu The Toolkit Full PPP contracts Yes for the PPP are published onCell No www.pppinindia.gov.in. provides Full forPPP thecontracts publication The See Toolkit and for of instance: all No for thethe PPP there https://www.pppinindia.gov.in/documents/201 annexes agreement PPP No Cell provides areas published n/a it for is important publication theon for maintaining of the PPP www.pppinindia.gov.tha n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a The Freedom No of Information Yes Law 5758-1998 https://www.mr.gov.il/OfficesTenders/Pages/SearchOfficeTenders.aspx https://www.mr.gov.il/OfficesTenders/Pages/SearchOfficeTenders.aspx provides The Freedom Noand for theof publication Information http://govmultisite.xyz/projects/ No ofLaw 5758-1998 n/a information in which provides https://www.nta.c PPPfor contracts the public wo n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a According For the projects to procured Yes the byPPP National Yes Section the Policy, Road For 10.0.1, Operating the projects "<…> and the According procured Constructing PPP No Unit to by thewill PPP the Company Policy, National No the adopt Section Limited Road following 10.0.1, Operating (NROCC) n/a practices "<…> the andsigned on the Constructing disclosure PPP Unit will <…> Com agreement a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Pursuant toNo Article 169 No of Order No. n/a https://kzppp.kz/en/%D0%BE-%D1%86%D0%B5%D0%BD%D1%82%D1%80%D0%B5-%D0%B3%D1%87%D0%BF 725:For republican n/a Yes PPP to enter data projects,Yes into the register of concluded P https://kzppp.kz/en/%D0%BE-%D n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Pursuant toYes www.pppkosova.org Yes Article 14 (1) of the PPP www.pppkosova.org Law, notwithstanding Pursuant toNo paragraph Article 14 (1) 2 No ofArticle of the PPP7 n/a of Law, notwithstanding this Authority Law, the Public paragraph n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Article 68(3) Noof the PPP https://www.eis.gov.lv/EIS/ NoLaw provides n/a <...> notn/a Yes 10 working later than within from the day when the public-pr Yes days https://www.eis.gov.lv/EIS/ n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Yes Yes https://cvpp.eviesiejipirkimai.lt/N n/a article 26 of Pursuant toNo Nothe PPP Decree n/a (Decree n/a2017-149 No No 2017, elaborating from 2 March n/a on the application of t n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Yes Article 11 of No Article 70 the PPP Law. n/a paragraph XXVIII 11 Article of Yes of thethe General PPP Law. No Article Law 70 n/a of Transparency paragraph andXXVIII Access the ofto Genera Informati n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a According The previously to No concludedthe concession Law on No contracts Glass n/a in different Account, n/a sectors art. 6.5.9 and 6.5.10, can Yes be found "the Yes onCentral State the website Administrative Amendments of the National to the Body Development previously co Responsible f n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Yes Yes http://www.komisijazakoncesije. n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a According PPP contracts to are usually Yes the published Yes on the PPP Guide, Section websites PPP 8.8, contracts "having of the According relevant are successfully usually authority, toNothe published concluded PPP Guide, No who on acted the the Section as websites a procurement n/a procuring 8.8, of "having process, theentity. relevant successfully For theexample, authority, procuring concluw e th n/a No and its amendments PPP Contracts No n/a have to ben/a approved by Law according Yes n/a 23 of the PPP Law and article No to article n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a This publication No is mainly Nodone on the n/a ICRC PPP http://www.ppp.icrc.gov.ng/project/165/katampe-district-phase-ii n/a Disclosure http://www.ppp.icrc.gov.ng/project/209/warri-new-termin Portal: https://ppp.icrc.gov.ng/ No No n/a and is based on Section n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Act, Section 24, n/a“the public private to According No partnership the PPP Act, agreement NoSection 24, n/a"the shall be a public public private partnership document. Any in Article 41 of Yes the PPP Law https://enterector.gob.pa/ Yes establishes: https://enterector.gob.pa/ “PPP Contracts. Article 41 PPP of Yes contracts the PPP Law are Yespublic law. https://enterector.gob.pa/ establishes: “PPP The PPP Contracts. contracts, once PPP they a contracts n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Article 15 of Yes PPP Law: "Transparency. https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/Yes The Public-Private Article 15 of http://app.gov.py/ Partnership Yes PPP Law: Project "Transparency. Yes Unit http://app.gov.py/ must submit The an annual Public-Private report to Partnership The signed version Yes https://www.proyectosapp.pe/ Yes of the PPP contract https://www.proyectosapp.pe/ must be The submitted signed version Yes to the MEF of the No inPPP contract order be included ton/a must be in submitted the National Regis to the M n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No Act on Access Article 6 of the No to Public n/a Information n/a provides No a non-exhaustive No n/a list of categories of public informat Pursuant toYes http://www.utap.pt/ Yes Article 33 (g) of the PPP http://www.utap.pt/ Law, contracts Pursuant its and to Article annexes Yes 33are (g) Yesof the PPP http://www.utap.pt/ Law, contracts' published/made available on annexes UTAP's webs and ap n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Article The platform 31 of (registry) Yes has thenot PSP Law been Yes established requires NCP The platform to establish yet. Article (registry) a registry 31 of Yes has the for not PSPbeen Law PSP Yes projects established requires which NCP Theyet. will platform to include establishaa (registry) complete, registry hasfor up-to- not be PSP Article 98 of NoPPP Decree Noprovides that https://www.economie.gouv.sn/fr/articles/03-11-2022/lunite-nationale-dappui-aux-partenariats-public-prive-unappp n/a the terms n/aof the partnership No No contract n/a are published on the website of the r According to Yes the PPP Law, http://portal.ujn.gov.rs/Default.aspx YesChapter http://portal.ujn.gov.rs/Default.aspx X, art. 74, "public According toYes theshall contracts PPP Law, be Yes Chapterin recorded X,the http://portal.ujn.gov.rs/Default.a art.Register 74, "public of Public Contracts contracts shall n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a According Within the profile to of the Yes the contracting PublicYes authority Within Procurement the the onAct, Art. website profile According I, Part of II, the of Chapter the to Public Yes the contrcating Public Procurement I, §64Yes (1)(c), Procurement authority Office: "the on Within contracting Act, the https://www.uvo.gov.sk/ Art. web-site the profile I,authority Part ofII, of Chapter the theshall Public contract publis https I, Pro §6 According to The public procurement portal: the Rules Yes Yes https://www.enarocanje.si/ on Record-Keeping The public forprocurement PPPs, art. 2(3), According Yes to the"aRules portal: public https://www.enarocanje.si/ Yes onpartner must Theforward public Record-Keeping PPPs, to the forprocurement Article Ministry 2(3), portal: [of Fi "ahp n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Article 154.1 Procuring Authority's Yes LCSP profile and that No mandates the https://contrataciondelestado.es/wps/portal/plataforma n/apublication Articles of the contract Yes 8.1.a) and 12 itself of Law 19/2013 Yes on transparency, access to pu https://contrataciondelestado.es n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No n/a n/a n/a No No comments No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a Yes No n/a According to No Nothe Official Section 9 of n/aInformation Act, B.E. 2540 (19 n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Article 153No Pursuant toNo n/a of the of the Resolution n/a Cabinet of No No the procedure Ministers "On n/a for conducting a concessi n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Virginia Freedom Pursuant toYes No of Information n/a Pursuant Act (FOIA),to § Yes 2.2-3704: Virginia Freedom Public No recordsn/a to be open of Information Actto (FOIA), § 2.2-3704: inspection; proce According to Yes Article 4 of Yes the PPP Law, http://ppp.mef.gub.uy/1201/2/areas/portafolio-de-proyectos.html http://ppp.mef.gub.uy/1201/2/areas/portafolio-de-proyectos.html all acts and According to Yes agreements made Article 4 of under Yes the framework the PPP http://ppp.mef.gub.uy/1201/2/a Law, of all acts and this Law shall abide agreements made b n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a Yes Yes muasamcong.mpi.gov.vn n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a No No n/a n/a No No n/a Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q33 Q32.1#3_4_1 Q34 Q34.1#1_1 Q34.1#2_1_1 Q34_1_TEXT Q34.1#1_3 Q34.1#1_2 Q34.1#2_2_1 33. Please provide 34.provision Relevant legal/regulatory any Does the If additional yes, please procuring 34.1 information authority provide If yes, the orRelevant or which contract relevant comments of the legal/regulatory management legal/regulatory Participation following on the answers tools Relevant authority of provisions the provisions: does tomembers legal/regulatory the it establish Elaboration include question(s) of(check athe system ofPPP above provisions aall PPP contract that to and contract manage apply)? indicate manag the maEs n/a n/a Yes No The PPP Law provides under n/a "Management No PartnershipNo of n/a Contract" in Article 38 that:(1) T n/a Comments Yes Article 107(1) Pursuant toNo No 285/2021, n/aof DCM No. Noimplementation of the contrac n/aduring the n/a n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Art. 82 of the Pursuant toNo Art. Concession Decree, 82 of the n/a theConcession No Decree, contracting the authority contracting shall the im monitorautho n/a Comments Yes No Chapter III of the PPP Law n/aentitled No "Supervision, n/a Noand Change of Partnerships," a Monitoring n/a Comments Yes According to Yes Article 21 According of PPP Law No the to article regulation 21 n/a of PPP the No andLaw, the fulfillment control of PPP contracts of the execution of the Pi n/a Comments No n/a No n/a No n/a No of the NSWYes Section 8.1 n/a Broadly PPP Guidelines alsooutlined provides, Yes in"Any National material Section 4.3.5PPP of variation(s) YesGuidelines, the to Section National Volume PPP the contract Guidelines 7.12Yes of Practitioner's should the NSW also PPP Overview Guide, be Guidelines and disclosed expanded Section withi 7,u requi8 n/a Comments No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Comments Yes Article 2.3.7No of the BOTn/a Rules includes No among the No n/a terms to be developed regarding the inve n/a n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Act, According "the No art. 23, to the contracting PPP Guidelines, n/a authority No12.1, art. shall execute "on receipt the of PPP contract the In-Prin Comments According to No Article 6 of the Regulation n/a on State NoRegister, the n/a State Register No n/a is maintained entering information in it:on pub byNo n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Art.61 of the Yes PPP Law requires, Art.61 offor thethe PPP No proper Law requires, n/a functioning the of the forNo proper contract, functioning of themo for a regular con Article 21 of Pursuant toComments the Sarajevo Yes According PPP Law: to NoArticle (1) 22 n/a (1) partner The public of the Sarajevo No shall submit PPPn/a the signed Law, No PPP pursuant toAgreement the provisions all withof addenda the Regul n/a Comments Yes Yes Sections The PPP Policy, According 5.9 to 5.12, to Yes provide the Policy, According PPP some guidance Section to Yes 5.10, for PPP the the "<…> Contract Policy, the Section Management 5.10, Institution "<… must Comments Article 61, sole Yes of the Public paragraph, Procurement Article 15 of Yes the PPP Law Pursuant Law establishes (Law toNo the 8.666/1993) that Article the provides n/a 67 offor the competent mandatory ministry aPublic No Procurement orpublication regulatory Lawagency (Law of 8.666 mu summar Article 124 Yes Pursuant toComments Pursuant of the Concession toYes Law: Article (1) Within 131 According one of the month Concession No from to Article the Law: 24 conclusion of (1)the n/a Ordinance When of executing No the concession forthe monitoring, concession manageme contract, the offic contract, n/a n/a Yes Article 88 of Yes the PPPP Decree 9 of the No PPP Article specifies the decree management n/a provides and No control that onceprocedures the contract for has been the PP n/a n/a Yes No A PPP management team n/amust be No by the procuring establishedn/a No authority in order to comp n/a Comments Yes Yes 40: "The PPP Law Article According Implementing to Yes Article 3 of Agency shall Decision According be responsible to of NoMEF No. Article of 3 for 5, Decision in the coordinating of MEFthe management,Nom n/a n/a Yes Yeswith the Section In accordance No section 34 of the Decree PPP Decree: n/a No. 2008/0115/PM No notification (1) After of the : (1) After contract, i notification n/a Comments Yes Section 3 of Pursuant toYes The the Treasury No Business Case Board Guide, ofn/a Canada Secretariat's Section "Managing 5No Policy the on the Managem Investment" spec n/a n/a Yes No Article 38 of n/a the PPP ordinance: the No n/a public authorities No shall monitor the execution of the pu Comments Article 98 of Yes Regulation. the Concessions Article 29 of Yes the Concession Articles Law and 38, No 39 Articles and 40 of n/a 38 to 44 the Concessions of the YesConcession Regulation create and Regulations reg regula article 10 of Pursuant toComments in Notice of Yes The Notice the Ministry of Nothe Ministry n/aon of Finance Finance No of Issuing the on Interim n/a Measures The Guidelines No for PPP for the Operations, article Administration Inform of23: the Comments Article 2.2.1.1.1.7.1 Yes of Decree 1082/2015 Article 33 (2) Yes states of that the PPP the Article Law establishes 33 authority procuring No of the PPP that obliged in isLaw. n/a PPP In Colombian to publish No the contracts, regulatory all the auditing administrative must be contra framework, impl acts f n/a n/a Yes No Article 17 of the PPP Law n/a provides No n/a that the institutional No framework of the public-private pa n/a n/a Yes Yes 2009-161 (1) Decree No. of (1) Decree 20 MayYes 2009 No. on the 2009-161 of Decree organization 20 No. May 2009-161 2009 Yes on and the functioning of 20 organization May of 2009 the public and on fu the n/a Comments Yes No Article 11 of n/a the PPP Regulations states No that the procuring n/a authority will oversee the execu No n/a n/a Yes Art. 27 of Decree Yes No. 2018-358 Article 25 of March No of the PPP 29,Decree 2018 n/a relating No provides Public tothat "PPP Private contracts are drafte Partnerships co of public-private The registerComments Pursuant Yes partnership toYes acts Article is regulated 17 of Article under 81 Article the PPP Act, ofNo the 16 a monitoring Concession of then/a PPP system Act (1) Act: No The is created Agency prescribes thefor establishment constitutes and PPP project ofkeep a co implem Comments According to Procurement the PublicYes TheAct, Public §174(1), Procurement No "a contracting Act doesn’t n/a No authority contain shall proceed n/a provisionsin about accordance No a contract with the provisions management. ou Cert n/a n/a Yes Standard PPP Yes Model for Section 4 ofNo theSection Construction, Standard n/a 4, PPP Model providesYes detailed for Construction guidance on the recomm states: “It is re n/a n/a Yes Yes At national/central Pursuant level, article 6 toYes article of 9 of the PPP Pursuant the(PPP Law LawLaw No. toNo article 2017-186 (PPP 9 ofNo. Law of 29 the 2017-186 PPP May Law, each of 29 2017 M p onpro Comments Article 20 of Yes the PPP Regulations Article 12 provides: "Registration of Yes Decree 434-20, Article and the 12PPP of publication No Decree Regulations, of public-private n/a states: 434-20, PPP "Subdirectorate No thepartnership Regulations, contracts. states: of Management The General a "SubdirectD n/a Comments Yes Yes PPP Law Article 9 of the establishes Article No 72 of the in general PPP Regulations that the procuring n/a Yes authority (Executive is the responsib Decree 1190) provides t n/a n/a Yes Yes PPP Law Article 5 of the Article states, of the No 5 "The PPP Law contracting n/a provides, " No(...), If administrative authority the PPP contract along with the ot assigns t Comments Article 105.A Yes of PPP Law: "the PPP-Unit Article will create 21-29Yes of the the PPP public Article Law establishes 60 of registry Yes of the PPP public the Law private creation Article provides partnership of a 28 ofYes managing for thethe PPP projects, appointment Law authority in which for establishes of the aall contrac theproje gover par n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Comments According to Procurement the PublicNo n/a No in the Act, §83(7)(2), n/a case whenNo n/a a public procurement No procedure is terminated prematu n/a Comments Yes Yes Article 14 of the PPP Proclamation Article 14 of Yes the PPP Proclamation establishes Article a Project 14 Management of No establishes the PPP Proclamation Team a within Project establishe the Con Manageme n/a Comments No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a provides Article R2196-1 that the buyer Yes Pursuant profile toNomust be, Article free, n/a direct L.2234-2 of theand No Public giveAcquisition n/a access complete No Code, the to essential buyer has control data over exe for public con n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 30 of Pursuant toComments the PPP Law: Yes 1. Theto Pursuant Public-Private Yes Article 31 of Pursuant the PPPto Law: No Partnership Agency 1. A 31 Article public isof n/a obliged the partner PPP establish shall No 1. toLaw: A public and ensure the manage partner monitoring database ashall ensur of the n/a Comments Yes No The Standard Contract for n/aHighways No n/a provides for to manage and monitor a contra a systemYes n/a Comments Yes Yes Section 31 of Section the PPP Act confers 33 primary (1) Yes(d) and (e) Per responsibility ofSection the PPP for No 33(1)(a) the provides Act the PPP that management Act, the ofstates Public each asInv af phase Comments Article 59 of Yes Law specifically the Concession mentions Article 17(2)Yes of the PPP amendments Each Law Procurement provides No as <...> one ofAuthority "Content then/a typesestablishes of of information Partnership No a contract Contract." available management in the The conces te Partnersh n/a Comments Yes Article 78-93 Yes of the PPP According to No Law, regulated Article the 78 implementation of the PPP Law, n/a the contract, Noof both, establishing a Directory in Ad-hoc and n/a n/a Yes No According to article 2 of n/a the PPP Law: n/a No The Administration and Control of Major Projects an No article 3 of Yes Pursuant ton/a Article 9the the Ethics Charter, Yes names of the PP Law of private Article indicates 9 of implementation the No and partners PP Law value n/a indicates monitoring of implementation No is contracts, the done contractual by the monitoring ministerial is done timelines ofsi or Comments Article 93 of Yes the General The Regulation of PPP the PPP Law Yes Law in its article that The21PPP regulates creates Law the information/publication Nothe in Public-Private its n/a article 21 creates Partnerships Nothe obligations Public-Private ofSuperintendence (PPP) PPP contracts. Partnerships Comments According to of the Public Article 43 No n/a Procurement No Act:(1) The n/a contracting n/a No authority No in the public electronic contra shall publish n/a n/a Yes Yes The Planning Commission Rule (now NITI 135(2) of NoAayong) the General in n/a 2012 had issued Yes Financial Rules, certain 2017 Guidelines : Ministry or Depar for crea n/a Comments Yes Yes According to the Attachment According to theNo to Bappenas the Attachment n/a Regulation to the Yes № 4, Chapter Bappenas Regulation IVA, A (3), № 4, Chap The Cont n/a n/a Yes Yes The Roads Contruction The ByLaw provides Roads Contruction No in Article n/a ByLaw provides 28- The temporary No in Article or final 28- The temporary delivery of the n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Comments Yes Yes Article 2.2 of Appraisal Article Guidelines: 2.2 of "Unless NoAppraisal it already n/a Guidelines requires Yes exists (e.g. for that ongoing capital program the management st n/a Comments Yes According to Yes Government According to DecisionNo 3012 Government of 03.09.2017 n/aDecision 3012 the Multi-annual onNo Infrastructure of 03.09.2017 on the MultiD n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 30 of the Public The Contracts project No manager Code sets out (RUP) n/a theidentified general principle Yesin Articles that 31, the execution 101 of w and 111 of n/a Comments Yes Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Executive No to the Summary, PPP Policy, n/a "Ministries, No Agencies Executive Summary, "Ministries, and Agenci Departments (M n/a n/a Yes No Step 6 of the Process Guidelines n/a No regulates n/a No implementation and monitoring in general assig n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 11 (B) of the PPP Article 11 (B) RegulationNoprovides of the PPP that n/a Regulation Yes : "[…] The Public Authority provides that : "[…] shall The Public form A a PP Article 169Yes Pursuant toComments Pursuant of Order No. 725, in to case No Article 46 of n/athe PPP of amendments and Law No additions to n/a the procedure the concluded for PPP No implementation PPP agreement, information monitoring an n/a Comments Yes Yes Section 73(1) of the PPP Section Act states 73(2) asof No the PPP follows: A n/a Act provides No contracting that "the authority that project parties is party proje to ashall, n/a n/a Yes According to Yes Article 49 Pursuant (1) 7 of the PPP Article toNo Basic 23 Plans, (3) n/a duties Yes of the PPP Basic of the Plans, Competent Authority the competent aut n/a Comments Yes Article 19 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Law Yes Article on the (2.4) Pursuant of the 19responsibilities toPPP Yes Article of the Law on 19contracting (2.3) the responsibilities authority: of the of o PPP Law 1. n/a n/a Yes No PPP Law Article 6 of the n/a provides that competent Yes No KAPP is n/a with functions pertaining to the i n/a Comments Yes Article 14(9) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP No n/aagreement Law, the PPP No must contain <...> the proced n/a Comments Yes Yes Article 41 of the PPP Decree Article of 2020 41 No of the provides n/a PPP Decree in paragraphs of 2020 Noprovides 7 and 8 that "In the implemen in paragraphs 7 that " Comments Article 68 of Noprovides:n/a the PPP Law No (3) Not later than within n/a Nodays from 10 working the day when n/a No the public-private partnersh n/a n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Law, According "the No art. 11,to thePublic PPP Law, n/aart. Entity shall 11(1)(a), be Noin charge "immediately following the of the monitoring the Article 86(9) Pursuant toComments Yesof Public Procurement The Concession Yes Law, <...> Law under Sections the Article contracting 1.2. Yes 60 lists and 1.4. contemporary of authority Section PPP must 1.3.1 publish subject Yes Projects Implementation of the inmatter the PPP Projects Central to be Portal defined and Implementa Managem ofin Publ the n/a n/a Yes Institutionally, Yesarticle 9.1.1 Institutionally, of the PPP Yesarticle Decree 9.1.1 2017-149 Institutionally, of therequires PPP Yesarticle Decree public 2017-149 the9.1.1 ofentity therequires PPP to Decre set the up n/a Comments Yes Yes Procedure The PPP Manual, #5.1:to According No Designing the PPP the Manual, n/a PPP Contract No Performance Procedure Monitoring #5.1: Designing the PPP Co Pla n/a Comments Yes Pursuant toNo section 3.4n/a of the PPP No guidelines :n/a No The relevant Ministries are responsible for t n/a n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Art. 5 of the n/a PPP Law: The initiating authority No project n/a No is responsible for identify n/a n/a Yes Section 4 (1) Yes (a) of the PPPA According to No provides: section a contracting 2.16 n/a(a) authority No Manual, of a PPP thecontracting shall forthe purposes of this autho Comments Article 11 of YesArticle 70 the PPP Law. Articles paragraph 125-127 No XXVIII the of of n/a the PPP General Law establish No of Transparency Law n/a the oversight and system No for PPP Access projects and to Information attribu requires n/a Comments Yes Pursuant toYes Article 22(1) The the PPPNoLaw, of Regulation regarding the public n/a monitoring No partner contracts annual performs checks andpar for public-private m Comments According to Yes the Law on According Glass Account, to art. 6.5.9 Yes the and 6.5.10, According "the Concessions State Law, No to art. the Central 25.1, Model Administrative n/a Agreement, "the No following Section entities Body Responsible shall 4.1, "a concessionaire forthe monitor imple Finance a w Comments According to the Concessions Yes Law,According Part III, Article to Yes the15(2), Article “all According 89 of the to changes relating No PPP Law, the Concessions to the the status n/aconcluded Law, andNo Article dynamics49, of concession"(1) the contracts the Competent shall execution of PP be e Au n/a n/a Yes No Article 12 of the PPP Law n/a provides No n/a that the PPP No stipulate the modalities of m contract shall n/a Comments Yes No According to Article 5(3) n/a of the PPP Law, the procuring No n/a No authority (for the sector at stake) is n/a Comments Yes Yes According to According section 111 (1) of the toPublic section Yes 111 Section Procurement (1) of 12.4 the Rules, Public of the Yes a public Procurement PPP policy: entity shall (1) Rules, Everya pub do the fo n/a n/a Yes No DBFM Standard Article 8 of the n/a Agreement No n/a sets No Assurance system for the co up the Quality n/a n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Policy, According to No Section 5.41, the Standard "effective n/a PPP Contract, No Section management 15.1(b), "on of outsourced or prio service con Comments PPP Contracts Yes and its amendments According have to beYes toapproved Article 32by According ofLaw the according Law, No PPPto Article the to article Ministry 32 n/a of the 23of of PPPtheLaw, Yes PPP Finance will Law the Ministry be and responsible of Finance articles 54 and to will 55b inspe n/a n/a Yes No Art. 13 of the PPP Law provides n/a No that n/aprecise the the contract No periodicity and mode of contr n/a Comments Yes and 12 of the Sections 10 Yes The Nigeria No Public Infrastructure Concession Private n/aPartnerships No Manual Regulatory provides Commission provide Actthat th In orde n/a Comments Yes Article 53 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law: No "The concession n/a No and the public partner shall grantor n/a n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Act, According 13(2)(g), No Section to the PPPA "without Act, n/a Section Yes 13(2)(g), prejudice to the“without generality of subsectio prejudice to th Comments Article 41 of Yes the PPP Law Article establishes: “PPP14.10 Contracts. Yes of the PPP PPP contracts Law establishes: Article are No 14.10 of public the "Functions PPP law. n/a Law Theof PPP the contracts, No establishes: contracting "Functions once public ofentity. they are contracti the The co perfected n/a Comments Yes Section 73 Pursuant Pursuant toYes toNo Section 73 of the Procurement Act: n/a of the Procurement (1)All No arising contracts (1)Allprocurements Act:from u contracts arisin Comments Article 15 of Yes Section PPP Law: "Transparency. III "Contract Yes The Public-PrivateExecution" Partnership Article 79 (Articles Project No of 78 Unit the Decree to n/a must 100) 4183/2020: submit of No an Project Decree annual 4183/20 superintendent report specifies to the some Theproc Co Executi Comments Article 139 of Yes the PPP Regulations:Article Besides the 6.2 Yes ofsigned the PPP PPP Law contract, Article establishes 6.2 the of Yes the that PPP National "Entities Law Articles Registry establishes in charge of No 16.3PPP and that ofContracts 17 managing "Entities of the also PPP a inproject charge contains Regulations: or ofthe a manc po n/a Comments Yes Yes Section 12 of The:national the BOT Law No Coordination government and Monitoring n/a agency PPP of Projects. Yes - The Coordinating manual volume Co 3 (contract ma n/a Comments Yes Yes developed In 2021, MFDRP According a newto volume Yes Section the According of2.1.1PPP of the guidelines PPP to Yes Section Guidelines 2.1.1IV devoted to of(“PPP the PPP managem Guideli Manageme Article 33 (h) Pursuant toComments Yes Each of PPP Law, contract Yes subsequent management amendments Each authority to contracts Yes contract implements and Each their management its authority contract annexes ownNomeasures are implements published management of contract its authority unless ownmanageme they implem inclu measures n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Comments Yes Article 41 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant GEO: Yes Article the44 of Pursuant the public PPPto partner GEO: has No Article thePublic (1) right 44 the of to authorities monitor PPP GEO: intendin (1) and Pub cont n/a Comments Yes of the PPP Guidelines Section 6.3 Yes No of the PPP Section 6.3provides forGuidelines n/a the establishment provides Yes for of the establishment a Contract Managemenof n/a Comments Yes Yes According to According section 1 "Project Governance" to Yes section 1of According the PPP "Project Governance" Handbook, to Nosection 1of "Project the PPP the PPP Steering Handbook, Comm Governance" n/a Article 31 of Yes the PSP Law requires NCP Procedure to establish NoContract for n/a a registry Management for PSP projects Nois setwhichin will outn/a Implementing Theinclude Yesa complete, Regulations up-to-date, and of the a PSP n/a n/a Yes According to Yes Articles 119-122 Article of 119 of No the PPP the Decree, n/aa partnership PPP Decree provides No that contract a Monitoring Committe Monitoring Comm Comments According to YesChapter According the PPP Law, X, art. 74, to "public Nothe PPP Law, n/aChapter contracts shall be No VIII, recorded in art. 61, "the n/a the Government, Register Yesof Public through a special Contracts act, sha (hereinafte n/a n/a Yes No Section 23 of the PPP Act n/a 23. The PPP provides:No Unit and, No n/a where appropriate, the statutory n/a Comments Yes Yes Part 4 of the PPP Handbook Section is related Yesof 4.1.15 managing to PPP Handbook Section a PPP 4.1.15 relationship: Nocontract - "A manager of PPP Handbook the purpose (or - "A of contrac this s contract Comments According to Procurement the PublicYes TheAct, Procedure Art. No forII, I, Part Chapter n/a I, §64 Preparation andNo (1)(c), Implementation "then/a contractingYes of PPPs describes, authority shall among publish others, the within e its Comments According to on Record-Keeping the Rules Yes for According toNo PPPs, the PPP Act, n/a Article 4(1), Article "a public 135(1), No partner n/a is obliged "a public No partnerto has provide the right and the duty information to any about mo n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes According to Yes the PPA, art. According "the No 159(1), to the Negotiation Concessions n/a Team shall Yes Section Manual, 11.2.1, conclude "after theman post--contract con n/a Comments Yes Yes According to PPP the Treasury Regulation, Manual, Module Yes 6 According states art. 16.7.1, "the that accounting to the Yes the project PPP Manual, officer's officer Module main respons or accounting "a P 6, aut information Among the Comments to published Yes regarding Several Yes articles public in the contract Article LCSP should 62 of No regulates the include execution LCSP anyn/a modification of the contract establishes person aNo them of and responsible assig accordingfor to the tothe thecontr refer procuring a n/a n/a Yes Yes According to the Guidelines The Contract on PPPs,Management Yes Project Section 223, "<…> Guide, Committee the Yes Procedure [Project] № Committee CA 02 appointed in"Formation terms will <…> o of S.b2 n/a n/a Yes While the PPP No Act doesn/a not explicitly Noprovide a system to manage n/a No the PPP contract, the Go n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Comments Yes Pursuant toNo Article 44 of n/a No a contracting the PPP Law, No shall be responsible for ensu n/a authority n/a Comments Yes Yes Section 98 of Pursuant to2020, the PPP Regulations Section No regarding 24 n/a of the PPP Regulations, Yes and monitoring evaluation of project, the accounting pr office n/a Comments Yes Yes43 of the Under Section Under PPP Act, Section No 43 upon of the signing n/a of PPP the PPP Act, contract, upon Yes signing the of the PPP contract, Responsible Ministet n/a Comments Yes Yes According to According Article 5(2) of the PPP to Yes Article 5(2) Regulation, the of the PPP AccordingPPP Project to NoArticle Assessment 5(2) the Regulation, of the PPP Team Project PPP Regulatio Asse member n/a n/a Yes No According to Articles 51n/a and 52 of the of 2021 specifies No PPP Lawn/a No a mechanism of control an n/a Comments No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Comments Yes Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Section No to the 6, "the PPPGovernment Policy, n/a Section No7.3, will develop "<...> and when the PPP transa implement all PP n/a comments Yes Yes Article 22 of the Presidential ArticleDecree 8 of Government Yes No. 2022-451 Decree of 5 Article May of No.Yes 6, 2016-1185 2022, Decree n.establishing 2016-1185 of 14 October the organiz about the o 2016 n/a Comments Yes Yes According to of the BOT Article 25 According No to implementation Accordingn/a to Article Decree,Yes 75 the of the Administration Regulation, Highway PPP may superv n/a Comments Yes Yes According to According Section 15 of the PPP to Yes Section Act, contracting According "the 15 of the PPP authority to NoSection Act, that "the 16(d) contracting intends of theto authority PPP Act,aam enter p th n/a Comments Yes Article 21 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law: No 1. The public No n/a partner, other public authorities, local a n/a comment Yes Yes Article 34 of the Dubai Article PPP Law 34 of No provides, the Dubai "Without n/a PPP Law provides, No to the prejudice functions "Without of the Financ prejudice to the n/a Comments Yes Yes PPP Projects were negotiated Sectionbased 20.1.3 Yes ofthe on PF2Standardization Contracts Section 20.4.1 provides Noof PF2 guidance ofPFI Contracts Contracts on or implementing provides: Ak Standardiza Virginia Freedom Pursuant toComments 23 U.S. Code Yes of Information No Act§(FOIA), 106 - Project 2.2-3704: § n/a Public No and approval records oversight n/a g.1 to be open (A)In Yes to general.-The inspection; procedure for of US Secretary reqT Comments According to Yes Article 4 of According the PPP Law, and all acts to Yes the agreements85 of made articleArticle 67 and the under No68 PPP Regulatory the of the framework PPP n/a Regulatory ofYes Decree, thisprocuring the Law Decree shall establish abide bythe Authority may possib perf certain ge n/a Comments No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The Government Yes Tenders The Standard Act No provides Works in Section RfT furthermore n/a No provides 4 on "Execution (pp. 32-33):Contracts of Government 5.2.2. Co Comments Article 65 of Yes Decree 35/2021/ND-CP: Article Contract 59 ofsigning the PPP Yes and Law: disclosure Management Article 86 ofNo the of PPPPPP and project supervision n/acontract Law: "Oversight of Noquality carried information: of out [...] by State 3 . In case construction works thean regulatorya n/a Comments Yes According toYes the PPP Act, According 62, Section toNo the "contracting Publicn/a ProcurementNoshall authority be responsible Act, Section 76(1), "a procurin for ensurin n/a Comment Yes No According section 34 ofn/a the Zimbabwe n/a and Development No Investment No Agency Act № 10/201 n/a Comments No n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a Comments Yes According toYes According the PPP Law, art. 14(1), to the Yes PPP Law, "control According overart. execution 14(1), to Yes theofPPP a [PPP] "control over Law, agreement art. execution shall of a be 14(1), "contro [P Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q34.1#1_4 Q34.1#2_4_1 Q34.1#2_3_1 Q34.2_A Q34.1#1_5 Q34.1#2_5_1 Q34.2_B Q34.2_1_TEXT Q34.2_2_TEXT Establishment Relevant Relevant legal/regulatory provisions of personnel legal/regulatory Establishment training Relevant provisions of a risk programslegal/regulatory 34.2 mitigation (i.e., Which training If of initial mechanism yes, provisions the please following andwhich The continued specify PPP options considers contract and If training yes, best provide the management please describes throughout evolving theprovide relevant the nature team the required thecourse of relevan membe risks qua o legal/regu n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Art. 211 of n/a Pursuant toNo No the Public Procurement n/a Decree : Civil Yes servantsAccording to and public Article responsible officials f 211 of the Pu n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 21 of n/a Decree 118/2017 stablish the requirements n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes National PPP Guidelines, Appendix Volume H 2Yes Practitioner's Section H.6.13 National Guide, of the PPP National Yes Section Guidelines, 7.2 PPP Section Guidelines, andVolume Appendix 4.4 2No of Practitioner's Hthe Volume Section NSW 2 Practitioner's n/a H.6.2 PPPGuide, Guidelines - "InSection a well-managed Guide, provides 7.4provides, provides, PPP that "In "C p the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No N/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a Section the PPP Policy, 5.11, "further, Yes According the Institution to Nothe PPP Policy, n/a must putAnnexure in place YesknowledgeAccording 3, Section and 92, “<…> succession toperformance the PPP management Policy, Sect manage n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to of the Ordinance for monitoring, Article 24 n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a Article 3 of Decision of MEF No. 5, in coord n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Regulation n/a The ServiceNo Yes (Reglamento de Servicio i. Article de la Obras), 30 No of the Concessions which isn/a regulated Regulation in Noarticles 39 sets forth n/a letterminimum m), 40 letter capital requirem f) and 57 of t n/a Yes No According to Notice on n/a Regulating No PPP Contract n/a No published Management, n/a on December 30, 2014, articl n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 5 subsection 4 of Law 115 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to The Public No Article 23:n/a Procurement n/a Yes Unit monitors Management the Art. 4 ofthe No performance Decree No. n/aof contracts 2009-161 of 20 and May public 2009 on th service n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 81 of the Con n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a NoModel for Standard PPP Construction, n/a No Section n/a 4, providesNo detailed guidance n/a Norecommended on the n/a procedures to be followed n/a Yes Art.6 of theNo PPP awarding n/aprocedure Yes Pursuant Decree (Decree No. to2018-176/PR/MEFI No article 9 of n/a Law the PPPof May (PPP 2018 Law No. 2017- ) states that n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 71 of n/a the PPP Regulations No (Executive n/a 1190)No Decree provides for n/a strategy for Yes Article 72 of the contract management and contract PPP mana Regulations n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article (6) of n/a the PPP Executive Regulations provides, "Sh No According to of the PPP Law, article 88 n/a Article 10 Yes the procuring authority of Yes PPP will establishes Article the Lawapprove the 24 of No service the obligation PPP manual Law n/aestablishes of the procuring prepared byspecific the authority private criteria tofor ov partn n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes of the Procurement Section 5(8)No n/a No Directive discusses n/a the competencies Yes Section procuring of the 5 authority gene of the Procurement Dir n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a Contract the Standard Yes for Highways, The§1.1.6, Standard No "a Contract project contract for n/aHighways, have shallNo§55the is devoted following n/a to contract the issue of the required components, wh n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 31 of the PPP Act confers n/a No n/a Yes Article 17(2) No Law provides of the PPPn/a n/a of Partnership Contract. The No<...> Content n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 78 of n/a the PPP Law states that the Directory ad-ho n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 14.3 of the Ethics Chart st n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 22 of n/a the PPP Law states that in order to be Supe n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a YesPost- Award Guidelines for Contract Guidelines Yes Management for Post- Award PartContract for 11 PPP Concessions 12 Management andYes Post-Award (Section for PPP of the Post-Award 4.1.1) Contract No Concessions Contract TheManagement contract Management (Section n/a 3.6.) Manual Manual managementprovide: requires plan (part must 2): that Afte hat Identifyin No According to the Attachment n/a to the No Regulation № Bappenas n/a n/a No4, Chapter IVA, B(1)(a)(3)(a), Yes the Control Team Bappenas has the Regulation No. duty Attac 4, and a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Roads Contruction ByLaw pro n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No created a The NDFA has Contract Template n/a Yes for The PPP NDFA has No agreements, contract n/a which created publically available includes Yes sections and extensive of Article 2.2 standard guidelines of the Appraisal clauses docume and on the o Guide n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a manager identified The project No n/a No 148 of in Article the Implementing n/a No Regulations n/a Yes also undertake would Article 31 the oftask the Public Contracts of verification of n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a Section the PPP Policy, No "in summary, the main responsib 4.0.2.6(c),n/a n/a Yes Step 6 (4) of Yes the Process The Risk Allocation Guideline No provideGuidelines that, n/a serve Noprecisely in connection with the this n/aimplementation of a PFI projec purpose. They delineate the of the PPP Regulation Article 3(B) No n/a Yes stipulates that: The"The 2022 Fiscal Yes Unit Commitments shall Article prepare guidelines 10(B) AndNo of manuals the PPPn/a Contingent Liabilities Regulations for the PPP Operational Project’s providesphases and the that and St Proce n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 46 (1) n/a No of the PPP n/a contract should contain:15) d Law, the PPP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 23 of Pursuant toYes The the activities PPP Basic Yes Plans, listed forguidelines Pursuant PIMAC underneed to Article No to be Article3139 prepared (Principles n/a (Activities for for the No of Public properand Mitigation inspection n/a and Private Allocation of performance of Risks) Infrastructure Investme of as wel the P Directive 2:n/a Pursuant toNo No Article 2: Creation n/a Management of Project No Teams n/a 1. Any public Yes authority Pursuant has whichto entered Article into 4 of an agr Directive No PPP Law Article 6 of the provides that n/a No KAPP is n/a competent No with functions Noto the implementation n/a pertaining n/a of the PPP project n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 41 of the PPP Decree of 20 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/aart. 11(1)(a), "immediately fol the PPP Law, Table 1 of the Section 1.1 No n/aPPP Projects Yes Implementation Section 3.6 and of Management No the PPP Projects n/a Guidelines Implementation Yes provides Sections thatManagement and 1.2. the contract and 1.4. management Guidelines pr of the PPP Article 9.1.1 of Decree 2017-149: No n/a Yesteam develops, The Article 29 in of dialogue No 2017-149 n/a decreewith the holder, requires Yes a plan the of PPP Article contract piloting of the 9.1.1 to of include Contract Decree 2017-149 in terms clauses o relat n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the PPP Manual, Pro n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 4 (1) (a) of the PPPA prov n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 4 of Pursuant toNo the Regulation regarding the mo n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a Law, No the Concessions concessionaire shall have an oblig art. 26.5, a n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Art. 12 of the PPP law provides n/a No mandatory n/a provisions on insurances and garant n/a No n/a Yes According to No of the PPP Law, Article 15 n/a n/a No (General Principles on Risk Prevention a No According to n/a section 111 Public Procurement (1) of theNo n/a Rules, No a public n/a entity shall do the following Yes acts, as of The Members the Monitoring required, while im n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Part 3 of Schedule 9 of the DBFM n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to According the Standard PPP Contract, to No Section n/a the Standard PPP Contract, 70.2, to the commen “(a) prior Schedule 7, Sec No Article 33 of n/a the PPP Law Nothe obligation establishes No a manual n/a to develop n/a of the services Yes PPP of the Law regulation contract, refers containing to the a descript n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Public Private The Nigeria No n/aPartnerships Manual provides n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to n/a Bidding Yes the Standard According Form for BOT, Part 1 "General to Yes Conditions the PPP According Act, Section of Concession to 15(2)(k), Nothe Standard Contract", n/a Bidding Section Form “notwithstanding anything 3.2.1, for BOT,containe Part "the II " rules n/a No n/a Yes Manual for No the Evaluation, n/a Assignment n/a No and Assessment of Risks, approved by R n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Directorial Resolution No n/a No 005-2016-EF/68.01, n/aapproved the Guidelines for th which No PPPGB Policy n/a07-2015:No Circular No. n/a Framework PPP Monitoring n/a No and Protocols requires Yes to prepare andto Pursuant section 4.2 implement contract a of the PPm Yes According to According Section 1.8.5 to Yes of the PPPSection Guidelines 2.1 According of IVthe (“PPPto PPPNoGuidelines Section 1.3 management�), n/a IV of the PPP (“PPP No Guidelines Contract Management management�), IVmembers n/a(“PPP management�), of Manual can the PPP be the a PPP ma Project Te n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant to Article 44 of the PPP No PPP Law Article 9 of the indicates: The n/a n/a No responsibilities of Contracting No Authority are n/a Yesthe following: 6º prepare a plan for PPP ag n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to section 1 "Project G Nothe Implementing Article 128 of n/a Yes Regulations of Article the PSP Law 128 No of provides the Implementing that: n/a “[t]he Regulations No Concerned Entity n/a of the PSP shall Law provides develop that:“[t]he contract man n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Articles 119-122 of t No n/a The PPP Implementation No Decree presents such n/a a guideline. No n/a to the Thus, according No n/a PPP Implementation Decree, art. 1, "this re n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Yes The PPP Handbook PPP does not Handbook, expressly No establish 4.1.15: a risk mitigation Sectionn/a mechanism, The contract managemenb No for Preparation The Procedure n/a andYes Implementation Methodological of PPPs Noreferences n/a document the Approach PPP Project Noto Risk Management n/a Management and Implementation in Coa PPP Projects was n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to the Concessions According Manual, to Yes the Section Concessions According 11.4.1,Manual, "contract Yes to Section the management According 11.4.5(4), Concessions Manual, planning to "the Nothe exact Section Concessions should operating n/a 11.2.1, start Manual, at "<…> procedures an early Contract Section for stage 11.3.1, during contract Managem th “in Yes PPP Manual, sates that to Module 6 According the Yes the project officer's According PPP Manual, one Module to Yes of the6,PPP the main the Manual, project According responsibilities officer Module No to the andin 6, while the PPP relation Manual, PPP n/a the agreement to risk managing Module management management 6,the PPP [the project plan agreem will team off e n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Contract Management The Contract Guide provides Yes Management According such a guidance. Guide, toProcedure the Thus, Yes Contract according №According CA Management 06to“Orientation the to Nothe Contract Guide, Contract Management n/a Procedure Management Training № on Contract Guide, CA 07Managemen Section "Commence Guide, 1(2) Procedu n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Section 27 n/a Pursuant toNo No n/a of the PPP Regulations, Yes may prepare the PPP Centre Pursuant operational toNo Sectionguidelines of the PPP 24 n/a manuals for proper and Regulations, fu the accou No 44 (1) and Under Sections No n/a(4) of the PPP Act, an/a supervisory Yes Pursuant committee shall have toNo the Section 43 n/a ofpowers following the PPPand Act, duties: (1) to moni upon signing the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According to Article 5 (2) of the P n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 7 of Decree Article 23provides n.2016-1185 No of that:n/a the Presidential The unit Decree of Yes No. 2022-451 studies, Article of 12 assistance and Mayof No6, Government 2022,is training responsible establishing n/aDecree the No. for: organization - providing assista 2016-1185 and of O 14 po Yes According to of the BOTto Article 18 According No implementation Article 18 n/a of the Decree: No(1) The Implementation n/a Decree: BOT implementation (2) Yes contract The implementation is According preparedto Article contract according to 10includes of the spec BOT th Im n/a Yes No ) provides Section 11(2)(c functions ofn/a n/athat the No the Unit is Yes to provide capacity According to section building 15(2) to and of the advise co n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No PPP Guidelines, Page 80 of the n/a section Yes 5.2.3 titled Dubai The Risk PPP Manual describes Management on pp. 22 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a 23 U.S. Code Pursuant toNo n/a § 106 - Project Yes approval Theand Risk No PPPoversight Management (h) Major n/a Guidelines Projects.- No(2)ProjectPPP management and then/a Risk Register plan.-A address the pro project ma No According to of PPP Regulatory Article 66 n/a No Decree n/athe Contracting No n/a Administration must perform No n/abi-yearly reports regarding co n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According toNo n/a the Procurement Regulation, Section 213 (2 n/a No n/a Yes According toNo n/a 86(1), the PPA, Section No"where inn/aany procurement a successful bi n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a No on PPP n/a The Resolution provides a detailed Monitoring Yes Accordingguidance to No on how the PPP n/ato Law, art. perform 12(2)(9), No a PPP contract n/a "a [PPP] agreement monitoring shall by include thepar a public fol Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q34.2_C Q35 Q34.2_3_TEXT Q35_1_TEXT Q35.1 Q35.2 Q35.1_1_TEXT Q36 Q35.2_1_TEXT If yes, management The PPP contract 35. please elaborate Doesteam the If and yes, members provide please procuring 35.1. or are examples: provide contract If yes, not the required If is management yes, relevant the please PPP to meet contract legal/regulatory 35.2. provide authority any If yes, specific construction If theis establish yes, relevant the qualifications. please PPPperformance a provisions: contract legal/regulatory 36. monitoring specify Doesconstruction theand procuring website: information provisions: evaluation performanc or made contrac syste av No n/a Yes No The PPP Law provides under n/a "Monitoring No n/a and Evaluation" in Article 44 that: (1) The Entity a Yes No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 71 (1) n/aDCM. No. No n/a 914/2014, implementation of the contract, During theYes No n/a Yes No Art. 48 of the Concession n/a No Decree provides n/a that service delegation contract must any public Yes No n/a Yes No Chapter III of the PPP Law n/aentitled No n/a "Supervision Yes of Partnerships," and addr and Monitoring No n/a Yes No According to section d, n/a Article 9 of No n/a PPP Law the Yes must establish the mechanism PPP contract No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Section 8.7 No of the National n/a PPP Guidelines No n/a "For many provides, Yes projects, it may be useful fo No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 3.10 n/a of the BOTNo authorized Yes Rules: The n/a body shall conduct monitoring w Yes Yes According to There is no the PPP Guidelines, art. No construction n/a 12.2, "the Project specific Director monitoring No should n/a be appointed system in place. YesThere by the is Contracting Authority a vague statement th No n/a Yes Article 31 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the PPPto Law: Yes Article 31state 1. The It the of will partner PPP be available Law: Yes is obliged 1. The the to post on state partner website on its of isthe obliged pub official w No n/a Yes Regulation of NoJanuary 14, n/a No for the 2013 provides procuringYes n/a authority receiving the works. Se Yes Yes Art.61 of the PPP Law provides Art.62 ofthat the NoPPP a Law provides: regular n/a monitoring Inof No addition ton/a the control the performance of the Yes exercised obligations of State by the or other a the public-priva No n/a Yes No According to Article 22 n/a (1) of the Sarajevo No Law, pursuant PPPn/a Yesto the provisions of the Regul No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Yes There are no specific rules Theestablishing PPP LawNo any qualifications n/a determines the PPP agreement that No the PPP must n/a define contract Yes management the objective team criteria for assessin members need No n/a Yes According to Yes Article 21,Pursuant to1, Paragraph Yes Article Point131(3) 4 of https://nkr.government.bg/Information the the Concession ofOMMCC, Law, the grantor Yesthe Privatization shall e and Post-Priv Yes Yes requires The PPP decree follow-up Article 9 of the No andPPP control n/a bodies decree for No provides the that contractthe implementation once n/a Yes contract is signed, to be designated, the and contracting the autho Yes Yes PPP Unit Article 5 of the Pursuant Decree includes toNo articlein 37 of then/a principal the PPP Law, missions No the contract n/aAgency of the shall include assistance Yes provisions to the government on related to the p No n/a Yes Article 40 of Pursuant toNo n/athe Law on No n/a Partnerships, Public-Private Yes the Implementing Agency Yes Yes There are no Pursuant regulations with regard toNo Section qualifications to the36 of the Decree n/a No required of n/a the PPP No. 2008/0115, at contract the Yes of each year, executive. endmanagement the public co Yes Yes There are no Section regulations with regard 12.6 No to of the the qualifications n/a Contracting Policy No required of n/a provides, "12.6.1 the PPP contract The Yes management and team management membe administratio No n/a Yes Article 37 of Yes the PPP ordinance Article 38 of No provides the PPP : When ordinance n/a provides Yes that a public-private the public partnership authorities contract entru Yes Yes Concessions RegulationArticles indicates 39only and Yes duties and This 41 of the Concessions faculties. information YesRegulations. may be requested The Fiscal Yes by https://concesiones.mop.gob.cl/Paginas/def Inspector any interested party has the by mea authority to No n/a Yes Article 26 of Yes the NoticeArticle of the 31 of Yes theof Ministry Notice Finance www.cpppc.org of the Ministry on The Guidelines Yes of Finance for PPP on The Guidelines Operations re No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 83 and n/a 84 of Law No1474 of 2011 Yes n/a the contracting entity must permanentl No n/a Yes No According to Article 19n/a of the PPP No n/a agency Yes Law, the public (UC-PPP) will monitor, on behalf No n/a Yes No According to Article 23:n/a The Public No n/a Procurement Yes Unit monitors the performan Management No n/a Yes No According to article 11 n/a of the PPP Regulation, No n/a procuring the Yesauthorities must supervise the Yes Yes framework The regulatory Pursuant does not toNo Art. 27 ofany provide n/a Decree information No. 2018-358 No on the qualification of n/a March 29, 2018 Yes of the relating to Public management Private Par team No n/a Yes Article 18 (1) Pursuant toYes Article of the 18PPP No of Act, the Right the public on n/a partner Yes Information Access shall within Actthe (OG 25/2013, term 85/2 of 6 mont No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Yes Although the PPP Model Standard Section 4 ofNo for the Standard n/aPPP Construction requires Model Nofor formation n/a of states: theConstruction a project Yes"In management the construction team, it does phase, it i No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo article 38 of n/a the PPP Law, contract sets No the PPP n/a Yesthe performance objectives th Yes Yes Article 12 of Decree 434-20, Article the 12PPP of Decree NoRegulations, 434-20, n/a states: the PPPNoRegulations, n/a states: "Subdirectorate of Management "Subdirectorate Yes and Supervision. The Su of Management a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No PPP Law Article 5 of the n/a provides, "(...), No the contracting n/a Yes Administrative Authority along with No n/a Yes Yes Article 60 of PPP Law: "During Article 60 the construction Yes of the PPP Law: www.proesa.gob.sv phase The updated of the Yesproject, and log of the the the project contracting procuring mustState be a autho No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 14 (2) of the PPP n/a No states: “The Proclamation management team shall, on beh n/a projectYes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Article L.2234-2 Pursuant toYes Article ofR.2196-1 the Yes Public the A Public ofProcurement publication Acquisition Code, Yes will theCode buyer be made indicates has oncontrol contractin thethat the pr over ex No n/a Yes No Art. 56 of the PPP ordinance n/a statesNo n/amonitoring that a regular Yes of the performance of the co Yes information There is no Yes regarding Pursuant tothe Yes Article management Pursuant 31 of requirements the PPPto Law: Yes Article 1. A 16 in of the www.ppp.gov.ge public the partner respective PPP Law, shall Yes information ensure the monitoring regulation. of the on public-private No n/a Yes No The Standard Contract for n/aHighways No n/a contains separate Yes that are devoted exclusively sections No n/a Yes Yes Section 27 (i) of the PPP Section Act sets out No 75(1) of overseeing the PPP n/a the in Act, regard monitoring Yes to and acess evaluation of public to information, pr state Yes Yes framework The regulatory Article provides 17(2) Nonothe of PPPn/a specific Law regulation No about provides <...>their "Content n/a qualifications. Yes of Partnership Contract." The Partnersh No n/a Yes Yes Article 79 of the PPP Law Article provides Yes for 79 of the the PPP appointment https://anadie.gob.gt/ Law and establishes Yes functions that the Inspector will be in of the Inspector ch duri No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo the standard n/a No clauses of n/athe procuring concessions, Yes authority monitors the wor No n/a Yes Yes In the case of PPP projects Pursuant toYes included in the 95 article National of http://sapp.gob.hn. the Public GeneralYes Investment Regulationexample of the PPP For Program, tracking Law, the monthly of an No n/a Yes No According to Article 142 n/a No Procurement of the Public Contracting authorities shall doc n/a Act:(1)Yes No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo clause 14.1n/a of the Model n/aagreement, No Concession Yes during the Construction Perio No n/a Yes The Attachment No to the n/a Bappenas Regulation No № 4,ChapterYes n/a IVA, C (1)(d) stipulates that in the No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No According to Article 14(7) n/aof the Investment No n/a the National Law, No Commission for Investment No n/a Yes No According to Schedule 14(1) n/a "Reports n/a No during Construction Period" of the Contract Templat Yes Yes Yes do not provide The provisions According specific to NoGovernment criteria n/a to be Decision met by3012 Nothe contract of 03.09.2017 n/amanagement onYes the Multi-annual team members.Infrastructure D No n/a Yes Article 30 of Yes the Public Article Contracts Code Yes 53 of Decree-Law sets out https://dati.anticorruzione.it/superset/dashb No.general the Yes 77/2021principle ("Simplification that the - bis Decree-L execution of w Yes Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Section Yes to the 4.0.2.6(c), PPP Policy, According "<...> the to Contract SectionNo4.0.2.6(c), the PPPManagement Policy, n/a "in summary, Team Yes Section the (or 10.0.1, main Contract "<…> responsibilities PPP Unit in theManager ofthe th will a No n/a Yes The private No partner is required n/a No PFI contract in the Yes a report on the progress and n/a to provide No n/a Yes The Contracting No Authority n/ashall submit No periodical Yes n/areports to the PPP Unit - the latter shall s Yes Yes There are no Annex 4 of Order specific requirements to the No No. team 725members n/a a list of documents containsNo n/a Yessubmitted throughout the life to be Yes Yes of theSection Regulation 56(5) 73(1) No PPP Regulations of the provide n/a PPP that Act states the Public No as follows: A n/a Privatecontracting Partnerships Yes authority Unit (now the that party to a proje is Directorate) sh Yes Yes Article 23 of According the PPP Basic Plans requires to No the Article 49 n/a procuring (1.7) of the authority No PPP Basic Plans, n/a the to operate a committee competent Yes authority for is responsible the evaluation of per No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 48 of n/a No the PPPn/a the PPP Law, shall contain: the right of the Co agreementYes No n/a Yes No Article 27 of the PPP Executive n/a No Regulations n/a "TheYes provides, PPP Agreement must set the bas No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No Article 49 of the PPP Decree, n/a regarding n/a No "Overall Yes for Project Monitoring, Ins Responsibilities No n/a Yes Yes Article 12 of the PPP Law The provides Freedomfor Noofthe Information n/a Law of establishment of Yes 1996 a monitoring providessystem of contrac under Section 10 No n/a Yes No The PPP Law, art. 11(1)n/a is devoted No n/a of a contract to the description Yes management and monit No n/a Yes Chapter X (Articles Yes According 26-28) to of the Partnership Yes the Order Agreement No 1K-112regulates Yes of the Minister www.ppplietuva.lt of Finance the "Control dated of Perform No n/a Yes No According to the articlen/a 32 of the Decree No n/a the public 2017-149, Yes person sends every year a re No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Manual, n/a No Procedure MonitoringYes #5.2:n/a PPP Performance During the Con No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo article 29 of n/a the PPP Law, n/a No adressing Yes and publications:1- The con checks, reports No n/a Yes No Section 4 (1) (a) of the PPPA n/a provides: n/a authority No a contracting Yes shall for the purposes of this No n/a Yes Article 125 of Yes According the PPP Law to providesYes that the Article "Supervision 14 of the http://www.transparenciapresupuestaria.go of construction PPP Yes Law: "In works addition, the Ministr execution shal No n/a Yes Article 22 (1) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP No n/a partner Law, the public Yesperforms annual checks and m Yes No According to n/a the Model Agreement, No n/a at the implementation Section 4.28, No Yes n/a stage, "a Concessionaire shall always hav Yes No Law doesn't The Concessions No n/a define the competencies n/a the Competent of No Yes n/a Authority. No n/a Yes No According to Article 18 n/a of the PPP Law, No the contracting n/a Yes authority controls the implementat No n/a Yes No Article 27 of the PPP Regulations n/a No mandates n/a the Authority to track compliance of Procuring Yes No n/a Yes Section 9 ofNo the PPP and n/a the Investment n/a No Act. provides a Monitoring and Facilitation Com for Yes No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 8.1 (Management n/a n/a No System)of the DBFM Standard Agreement:(a) The Con Yes No n/a Yes The monitoring No system n/a is the sameNo for both construction n/a Yes operational periods.Thus, acc and No n/a Yes No According to Article 61 n/a of the PPP Regulations, No n/a Yes the project inspector/auditor is entitled to s No n/a Yes No Article 13 to 15 of the PPP n/a Law indicates n/a of procuring No the rights Yes authorities pertaining mon No n/a Yes No Section 12 of the ICRC Act n/a provides No n/a procuring that the relevant Yes entity shall supervise the pr No n/a Yes No Article 53 of the PPP Law: n/aThe grantor public partner No and then/a Yes shall continuously and regula No n/a Yes No According to the Standard n/a Bidding No Form for BOT, n/a Yes Part 1 "General Conditions of Concession Yes Yes Article 14.10 of the PPP Law establishes: Article 14.10 Yes of the "Functions PPP Law establishes: Article 11 of of theYes contracting the PPP "Functions https://enterector.gob.pa/ Law provides: ofentity. public theYes “Functions contracting The contracting of public the governing entity. entities public The co bod Yes Section 73 Pursuant Pursuant toYes of the Procurement toNo Section 73 Act: of(1)All n/a the Procurement contracts No arisingn/a Act:from (1)Allprocurements contracts Yes arising from procurements undertaken by the Comu Yes Yes Article 79 of Article the Decree 83 of 4183/20: Project Yes Decree 4183/20: According "Construction superintendent Yes The to Articles Contracting 121 Phase: http://app.gov.py/; andThis 122phase of YesDecree Authority shall shall https://www.contratacio appoint 4183/20, be regulated as long by the a Project as the pro Superi Yes Yes According to article 7 of Article the PPP 6 of the Yes PPP Law Regulations, in Article the case 6.1 of establishes that the Yes PPP Ministries, among Law INFOBRAS the establishes the functions (https://apps.contraloria.gob.pe/c Yesthat Committee offor the the Private granting Investment granting authority authority ("en mo Prom No n/a Yes PPPGB Resolution Yes No. 2015-09-01: Section 2.4 Yes PPP of the Monitoring BOT Law https://ppp.gov.ph/list-of-projects/ IRR Framework requires Yes the andposting Protocols of Priority indicates the Proje No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 8 ofn/a the PPP Act, No n/a authority the procuring Yes is entitled to monitor the priva Yes Yes are no specific Although there Portuguese legal No law regulates n/a requirments some regarding aspects Nothe qualification monitoring of the n/a of of itsYes members, construction the composition of th works, namely A No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No Clause 17 of Government n/aDecisionNo provides details No. 1/2018n/a Yes on this matter. More specifi No n/a Yes No Article 50 of ministerialn/a instructions No n/a of 16/04/2014 no 612/08.11 Yes setting up modalities for d No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Procedure for Contract Article Management 31 of Yes is set the Law PSPoutArticle inrequires The31 Implementing ofNCP Yes theto PSP establish Regulations Law requires a registry NCP of the for toPSP est PSP No n/a Yes No Article 44 of the PPP Law n/a provides No that the contracting specifically n/a Yes authority shall control a No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Law, n/a ChapterNo 63, "a public VIII, Articlen/a Yespartner is obliged to continuou No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Section 27 n/a of the PPP Act, No the Unit shall... "(j) Yes n/a ensure continued monitoring an No n/a Yes No functions The monitoring n/aduring the No n/a phase are construction Yesdelineated in detail under Sect No n/a Yes The Procedure No for Preparation n/a Implementation andNo Yes n/a of PPPs describes, among others, the e No n/a Yes The monitoring No and control n/a functions No are not phase-specific n/a Yes and there is no distinction of c No n/a Yes Section 6.3 No of the Procurement n/a No provides, Manual Yes of the stage of completion n/a “Certification No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Manual, n/a No 6, Section Module n/a Yes 7 "Key Challenges and Tasks of the PPP Ag Yes Yes does not Article 62 LCSP Article require 256 any No of the LCSP type of specific n/a states qualification once the that,No for construction the n/a contract Yes works are finished and before the responsible. No n/a Yes No The Contract Management n/a Guide, Sections No to 5.6 detail 5.4n/a Yesthe procedures to be taken dur No n/a Yes No Article 16 of the PPP Act n/a provides that n/aparty shall No the public Yes monitor the implementation o No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No No No comments n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Section 151 n/a of Resolution n/a No No. 81, monitoring Yes fulfillment of obligations of p the No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No According to Articles 51 and 52 of the n/a of 2021 specifies No PPP Lawn/a Yes a mechanism of control an No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes PPP and procurement-related The existingNo n/a No regulations n/a No provide for don’t No n/athe membership or qualifications of the m No n/a Yes Both ArticleNo 31 and 32 of n/a No 2015-49n/a the Law No. Yes dated 27 November 2015 r (Law n. 2015-49 No n/a Yes No Article 25 of the BOT Implementation n/a n/a No Decree provides Yes that: (1) The procuring authority sha No n/a Yes No Section 16(g) of the PPP n/a No that the n/a Act provides team would, "oversee the mana PPP projectYes No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 21 of n/a the PPP Law n/a46 of the No and Article Concession Law, a public partne Yes No n/a Yes No Article 34 of the Dubai n/a PPP Law provides, No n/a prejudice "Without Yes to the functions of the Financ Yes Yes Members of Sectionmanagement the PPP contract Yes 7.2.4 of Standardization team Theare not ofYes required PF2 Contracts Government's to The transparency have sets Government's any policy specific out a procuring Yes requires qualifications. transparency authority's Departments, Examples policy requi fromex obligation No n/a Yes This is provided Yes for under Pursuant to Section § Yes Virginia 33.2-1808 Freedom of the of PPTA. https://www.p3virginia.org/categories/curre Information Yes Comprehensive Act (FOIA), § 2.2-3704: agreement. A. P Yes Yes According to articles 39PPP - 41Regulatory of the No PPPDecree n/a articles Law, the Procuring 66 to No Authority shall n/a perform 68. The Ministry of Finance Yes the control issued of the contract. Guidelines Hop for the No n/a Yes There are no Yes specific M&E There are general Yes stage-related construction provisions Thererequiring are provisions Yes the general in provisions disclosure the PPP-related requiring of information the di regulati No n/a Yes No the Government Whereas neither n/a Tenders No nor its Regulations Actn/a No address the monitoring a Yes Yes framework The regulatory does Article 59not ofNocontain the Law: n/a PPP any provision Management No regarding the n/aqualifications and supervision Yes of quality of the construction works of management Ar team.an No n/a Yes According to No the Procurement n/a No Regulation, n/a 215 (1)(a), Section Yes "a contract shall state that th No n/a Yes According to Nothe PPA, Section n/a 84(1), No "where the procurement n/a Yes requirement consists of <...> n/a n/a Yes Investment No n/a Law, Chapter 9, SectionNo51 requires foreign investors n/a Yes to submit a progress repo Yes specific legal There is no Yes According provision Yes detailing to the PPPthe Law, According qualification art. 14(2), Yes to "a requirements the PPP Law, public The partner art. website to14(5), shall theYes will monitor "the depend members compliance of on results aof project who perfoming aby public a privat a con managempar Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q36.1#1_1 Q36.1#2_1_1 Q36_1_TEXT Q36.1#1_3 Q36.1#2_3_1 Q36.1#1_2 Q36.1#2_2_1 Q36.1#1_4 Q36.1#2_4_1 36.1. If yes, please If yes, provide theRelevant which relevantthe legal/regulatory Performance of legal/regulatory following Relevant tools is provisions provisions: does assessed legal/regulatory it The include procuring against output/ (check Relevant provisions orall contract Key thatperformance The apply)? legal/regulatory management private Payments Relevant partner indicators provisions are authority must legal/regulatory linked (KPI) provide canto abate set in performanc the theprovisio procur tende (reduce Yes Article 15 of the PPP Law The provides generalNo rules that: The in the Entity n/a Public the Yes following Law has Procurement The under general functions and "Payments" Yes rules powers: in Article 10. inArticle Article To 39 monitor 52(2) of 32the provide of and Public evaluate the PPP that: Procurement Law (1)implem prov The e Article 12 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a Pursuant Yes the procuring authority toNo Article monitors n/a 107(3) of DCM the 285/2021: Yes implementation To of Pursuant the PPP ensure that to Article contract the quality 12 by (2) of selecte the(e) of th work No According to n/a Article 156 of Public Procurement No Decree No. n/a 15-247: Public Yes Article procurement 147,Yes paragraph contracts Art. 3 48 of Public concluded of the Procurement Concession by the contractin Decree Decree p Yes Chapter III of According the PPP Law entitled No to "Supervision article 10.11 n/a(i) of and theYes PPP Regulation Monitoring According of Partnerships," their is to and duty No addresses to 10.11 article inspect n/a(i) implementation reversible of the PPPassets, mechanisms with the Regulation p their No According to Article 9 of Yes section d, n/a PPP Law the Article PPP contract No 9.e of must the PPPestablish Law n/arequires No that the tender the mechanisms n/a for monitoring documents the include among o compliance o n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes system is The evaluation broadly Section outlined 12.1Yes of Volume in Section Section 2 of the7.3 National 4.3.5 of the PPP Yes National Guidelines PPP Guidelines Practitioner's No Overview n/a Guideand provides: Practitioners' Guide expanded "In Volume upon 2 provid in general Par term No Evaluation of n/a the project No implementation is conducted n/a the procuring by No n/a No authority n/a to the art. 18 of the Budget itself (according No The Ministry of Economy, n/aas the competent No n/a authority the purpose for No n/a of evaluation Yes and control over Please note thethat performance as per Article of an a 3.1 No According to n/aart. 18(3), the PPP Act, No "the contracting n/a No shall submit authority No to the PPP n/a reports n/aAuthority on the progress and Article 31 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a No 1. The state n/a partnerNo is obliged to n/a No post on its n/a on the global computer netw official website NoJanuary 14 Regulation of 2013 indicates n/a No in its article n/a 39 that Nothe procuring No can monitor n/a authority n/a or have monitored the prep Yes Art.62 of the Pursuant to PPP Law provides: InYes addition Art.47 ofto the the PPP control Law, Pursuant toYes any exercised Art.47 PPP the by ofcontract Pursuant the PPPState necessarily Law, toYes any or Art.47 other PPP includes authorities of the The contract PPP clauses PPPLaw, Law necessarily under relative any provides PPP the regulations to includes contract for thedifferen clause nec remunin Article 32 (1) Pursuant toNo n/a No of the Sarajevo n/a Concession Law,No the competent No n/a Ministry n/a shall continuously supervise the activities o Yes According to According the PPP Policy, Section to Yes the 5.12, "for PPP Policy, According PPP projects, Annexure to Yes the 3,PPP contract Section Policy, management According 92,Annexure “performance to Yes the must 3,PPP the address management Policy, chart According three showing Annexure to key during the PPP elements, 3,PPP Project Section thePolicy, namely Cycle 92,Anne “<.. delivery at < ph article 5, VII, Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toYes Section Law, the 6th, The PPP contract paragraph Concession Yes should 1, of the Law include provides PPP Under Law thethat the article objective PPP a Yes6, agreement §1º concession criteria of the The contract PPP tomay Concession evaluate Law, provide must theLaw the contain performance that performance provides payments the crite of of tha Yes According to Pursuant Articles 18, 21, and to 25 Article of the 32(3) Yes OMMCC According of the and Articles to No Concession Article 39,Law, 40, n/aand 122(2) state-regulated 3.,42 10., ofYes the 23. 19., Concessions prices of the According ofConcessions the Act, the services to Article Ministers, Law provided 131 the concessi ofby the mun the the Co No Article 88 of n/a specifies the PPPP Decree Yes the management Article 88 of and No control the procedures n/a specifies PPPP Decree Yes for the thePPP management contract. Article As and 88 of the such, control PPPP it provides procedure Decree spe tha Yes Article 43 of Article the PPP Law requires 7 of an the Yesannual report PPP Law provides to Article 36.14 be: prepared Yes The of the remuneration by PPPArticle Law the private requires 7 ofof the the Yes partner, co-contracting clauses PPP Law and related Pursuant provides article to 44 partyto provisions : shall The article requires be43 remuneration carried in periodical case of the out of PPP of noa ac Article 40 of Pursuant toNo the Law on n/a NoPublic-Private n/a Partnerships, No n/a the Implementing Yes Pursuant Agency shall be responsible to Article for 40 of the manag the Law Section 36 Pursuant Pursuant toYes toYes (new) of thethe Decree article No.Pursuant 5 2008/0115/PM, of the PPP toYes the lawarticle (Law at the 5 Pursuant No.end of 2006/012 the ofPPP toYes each law of theyear, December article (Law theNo. Pursuant public 5 of 2006/012 29, the 2006, PPP contractor to Section law of enacting December (Law and 36his the No. of the contrac 2006/0 genera 29,PPP 20 No According to Section 5.1 n/a of the Contracting No n/a "5.1.1 It Policy, Yes is the responsibility Section 12.7.11 ofNo departments n/a and agencies of the Contracting toprovides, Policy "Con ensure that ad Yes Article 38 of Article 42 the PPP ordinance provides of Yes the PPP Ordinance that Article the public 38 authorities of Yes the PPP provides: theordinance: shall public-private Article monitorof 42the Yes the the public execution PPP partnership authorities Ordinance Article contract of the shall 38provides: public-private ofshall the monitor specify the PPP ordinance the public-priv partners the executi term p No Article 29 of n/a Law and the Concession YesArticles 38 According to 44 of to No the Concession article 29 n/a of the Regulations Concessions Yes regulate Law: "The the supervision Article bidding 43 of the documents Concessions of the Concessi Reg shall e Yes articlesPPP PPP Guidelines, Operation 23 to 31. The YesNotice Guidelines, of Pursuant the Ministry articleto 26: Yes article A project of 25 of FinancePursuant implementing the on The Guidelines toYes Notice of the article organization 26 Ministry for of According PPP theof shall, Notice Operations, Finance to according of Thethe on Notice articles The Ministry toGuideline a 23, of project the of 24M a Fin Yes Article 33 of Article PPP Law. In Colombian 5 of the Yes regulatory PPP Law Article framework, and Article 3 of PPP Yes 2.2.2.1.2.2 implementation Law and of Section theof Article PPP the 2.2.2.1.2.5 2 of Yes Regulations PPP Title contract of 2 the PPP (Decree PPP isRegulations supervised Regulations ofAccording 1082 to Article of(Decree by 2015) two (Decree 2.2.2.1.2.6 establish authorit 1082 1082/o of Yes According to Article 19Article of the 98 PPP Yes Law, of the the PPPpublic Law Article states agency provides Yes 16that (UC-PPP) the remuneration that will The the monitor, procuring public-private is necessarily on Nobehalf authority of partnership linked n/a the canContracting tocontract the abate payment achievement Authority, setsfor out the of the perf per im non-perf No According to of the Decree Article 23 n/a YesNo. 2009-161 According of 20to NoArticle May 2009 23 onofthe n/a Decree theorganization NoNo. 2009-161 and functioning n/a of 20 May of the public 2009 procure on the orga No Article 11 of n/a the PPP Regulations states No that the n/a procuring authority will No the execution n/aoversee No n/aof its responsibilities by the pr Art. 27 of Decree Pursuant toYes 5 of2018-358 Article No. Yes Decree No. of Article March 5 2018-358 of 29,of 2018 Decree Yes March No. relating 29,Article 2018-358 2018 to Public 5 of of relating Private Decree Yes March Partnerships No. to Public 29,According 2018-358 2018 Private Partnerships contracts of relating to March Art. to Public 27 : Without 29, of contracts 2018 Private preju Decree No Pa st rela Article 18 (1) Pursuant toNo n/a No of the PPP Act, the public n/a partner No n/a shall within the term Yes of 6 months from the Pursuant todate Article of registration 82(3) of the C of Yes According The Public Procurement to Yes Act doesn’t the contain PPP provisions According Manual, about to Part Yes B, thea PPP Section contract Manual, 14, According “for management. each to Part No B, service the PPP Section Certain provided, Manual, 14, n/a "for Part each there guidance B, is service is provided Section a quality 14, inmonitor the “forPPP provided, th ea the Standard Section 4 ofNo n/aPPP Model Nofor Construction n/a No "It is recommended states: n/a Yes that the organization Section 4 of of a PPP the project Standard during PPP Mo article 42 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law n/a Yes(PPP LawPursuant No. 2017-186 toNo article 38May of 29 n/a of the 2017 PPP on No public-private Law (PPP Law n/a No. partnerships), 29 May 2017 2017-186 of contract in shall o Yes Article 72 of According provides: the PPP Regulations No to Article "Powers 60 n/a of Law and responsibilities Yes paragraph 340-06, of II,the According in cases supervisor to No whereduring Article the 60 ofconcession n/aLaw the340-06, operation entails paragraph the delivery stage. II, in ca During t No Article 71 of n/a the PPP Regulations Yes (Executive Decree Art. 18 of the 1190) provides NoPPP Regulations that n/a delegating No "The(Executive entity n/a Decree is 1190): responsible for "Service the developm levels and indi No PPP Law Article 5 of the provides, "(...) n/a Yes The contracting Article 5 of Administrative No PPP Law the Authority n/a provides, "(...) along Yes The contracting with In accordance other concerned Administrative with authorities Authority Article regul 13 of t No76 of then/a Article 21 and YesOFAPP is PPP Law: The Article the executive 77 of No body PPP explicitly n/a Lawresponsible to establishes Yes technically obligation audit the theArticle project 31 literal to oversee e operation. of the the PPP perform Spe Law n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Section 30.1 n/a of the Procurement Yes Directive provides, Section 30.1 Noof "Public the Procurement bodies have n/a to ensure Directive Yes that the performance According provides, to of "Publicarticle bodies a procurement 53 have of the to ens co PPP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes of the Public Article L.2234-1 ArticleAcquisition L. 2213-8 Yes of the Article Code indicates Public Acquisition L 2213-8 that Yesthe contract of Code the Public Article provides: holder Acquisition R2213-3 Yes "The has to of remuneration Code establish the Public According indicates Procurement an of that the to Article annual the contractor report holder's Code R.2234-1 to enable proviod remu of shall tt be No Art. 56 of the n/a statesNo PPP ordinance n/amonitoring that a regular n/a No of the performanceYes of the contract Pursuant to Article holder’s 55 of is obligations the PPP mand Article 31 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a n/a No 1. A public partner shall No ensure n/a the monitoring Pursuant to Yes of the fulfillment the obligations ofArticle PPP 31 of theassum Yes The Standard According Contract for Highways to Yes contains the Standard separate Several Contract provisions sections for Highways, Yes that of the are According Standard devoted §45.1.2, to exclusively Yes Contract "in the Standard for addition to Several Highways to contract Contract the provisions installment management establish for Highways, of payment the during such a§45.2, requir des Standarc No Section 27 (i) n/a of the PPP Yes Act sets out overseeing Sec 44monitoring the No (2) (c) (iii) requires and evaluation n/athat as of Nopublic part of a private request n/a partnerships for proposal from commence documents, it s Yes Article 17 of According the PPP Law providesto Yes <...> "Content standardized According of Annex Partnership to Yes 6, Payment standardized Contract." Mechanism, Article Annex The 17 Partnership of 6,the Nothe Payment Monthly PPP Law Contracts Mechanism, n/a provides Unitaryand Payment <...> there Ancillary isin a respect detailed Agreemen "Content of lisa of Part 80 and 81 establishes Articles 79, No n/a Yesresponsibilities the Article 105 of the of No the PPP Law Direction n/a of Supervision regulation Yesestablish relating Article the compliance the 82 of the of requirement to PPPstandards formulate Law andofse s art No According to n/a article 2 of the PPP Law: No The Administration n/a and Controln/a No No of Major Projects Public Procurement (ACGPMP) d and n/a article 16 of Pursuant toNo the standard n/a n/a No clauses of concessions, No the methods No n/a of assessment the operation are determined in of n/a No The PPP Law n/a in its article No 21 creates the PPP Superintendence n/a n/a No (SAAPs), No ascribed to n/a Audit Court , from which it w the Superior Yes According to According Section 142 to Yes Article of the Public Procurement 142 According of the Act: (1) to No Public Contracting Procurement Article 142 n/a of authorities Act: the Public (1)No Contracting shall Procurement document n/a authorities Act: the particulars (1) shall document relating Contracting the to t authoriti No Contract The Post-Award n/aManagement Yes Manual Part 8 of 5 in Part the lays Yes Post-Award down the scope light of of In Contract the activities Management Yes structuring to As be Guidelines: per ofundertaken the Clause revenue Inby 19.1 each model the of the of Contract these of Model the pa M C pr Yes to the For The Attachment the government-pays Bappenas Yes Regulation № 4, PPP Chapter projects, According to Yes IV, theC Attachment according (1)(a) According is devoted to the to the Regulation to to Yes the Bappenas description MOF onReg According Regulation PPPs, of 260/2016, the art. management to № 11the (2)(b), art. 4, Attachment IVA, 6(2), Cof(2)(b),"Th "aan "returnPPP impl on to Agit No n/a The Roads Construction Yes Article ByLaw provides: The 29-Roads During Construction the operating No ByLaw n/a period, provides: the No affairs related n/a Article to 41- In the the performance operation and of civil pr cons n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Part 7 "Relationship n/a and Yesof the Contract Monitoring" of Part Note 2 Template Yes15 specifies of the Contract Notereports 4 of Part Template: (Article Yes15 of the 20) The and According Contract payment Template:(b) to records (Article Schedule mechanism21) 14(2) is required If at PPP"Rep Co the h No According to n/aDecisionNo Government n/a 3012 of 03.09.2017 onNo the Multi-annual No n/a Infrastructure n/a Development Program in Israel, an Yes Article 30 of Contractsto the Public Pursuant Code Yes Article sets out 180 (3) the Pursuant ofgeneral theto Public Yes principle Section Contracts 2.4that According b) of Code: the ANAC execution to in Nothe article public-private of Guidelines 180 works, n/a (4) 9: No. of services performance the partnership andContracts Public risk concession, agreement, , that Codego is t t No According to n/a Section the PPP Policy, No4.0.2.6(c),n/a "in summary, No the mainn/a No of the Contract responsibilities n/a Management Team inclu No Guideline The Monitoring Yes n/ahas been developedPerformance by the PFI Promotion No Office n/a is assessed of the against evaluation Yes Cabinet criteria Office The private set in the partner regulating in tender detail must document provide the differ No Article 41(O) of the PPP RegulationYes n/a provides "[t]he Article partnership 41(B) Noof the PPPn/a Regulation contract must include Yes provides the basic Article clauses "[t]he 42(J) that partnership of the govern contract PPPthe must partne in Regulatio 23, 25 and 26 Articles 22, Yes of the Article 46(1) PPP Yes of the Law PPP set out Article Law the competencies 46(1) states that Yes of the thePPP PPP and Law contract Article authorized states 46(1) should No that of state the the contain: body PPP PPP n/a contract on Law19) state states criteria property should that the for assessing contain: management PPP contract 19) thecrit fu No Section 73(1) of the PPP n/a Act states No as follows:A contracting n/a Noauthority n/a that is party to a project Yes Section agreement 82 of shall, the PPP Act provide together with No According to of the PPP Act Article 24 n/a n/a No No on the Management and Operation n/a of Infrastructure Yes According Facilities, to Article Land 51 (1) of the or infrastructure fa Article 19 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law n/a n/a Noof the contracting No on the responsibilities n/a authority: Yes Pursuant 1. The Contracting to Article Authority 19 of the PPP shall en Yes PPP Law Article 6 of the provides Article KAPP's Yes 41 of the PPP competencies Law Article provides, of No"The theinclude 35which Project PPP Lawn/a to, Company provides, No shall "The "6. Set out not Partnership start approaches n/areceiving to Agreement follow any up and shall evaluate include monetary the amouth Article 14 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a No The PPPn/a agreementNo must contain No clauses: n/athe following n/a9) procedure for monitoring an No Article 49 of n/a provides the PPP Decree Yesthat "Agencies Article and 51 of relevant No Decree n/a have the PPPparties provides: the Yes responsibility Article to 52 monitor, "Responsibilities of ofProject the PPP inspect Decree and prov Executing Age eval No12 of then/a Articles 9 and No for means PPP Law provide No n/a of monitoring then/a performance Yes Article implementation of PPP contract Law prov 12(5) of the PPP after cons No The PPP Law, is devoted to art. 11(2) n/a Yes According the description of ato contract Yes the PPP Law, According art. 10(6), management and Yes to the "<...> monitoring PPP Law, theAccording Partnership during art. 10(14), to operational Agreement the"<...> PPP the phase. shall Partner Law, incl Thu art. 10 No Agreement The Partnership Yes n/a provides for establishing The Partnership a monitoring Yes (Concession) and The evaluation Agreement Yes system Partnership (Concession) Annex in Chapter each 3 (Mechanism individual X (Article Agreement of contract 27.1) Annex Monitoring of (Chapter 3the (Mech an Pa Yes According to of the PPP article 32 Article 36 of Decree Yes the PPP (Decree Article Decree (Decree 31 of 2017-149), Yes Decree 2017-149 the public Article from person 2017-149 2 36 is March of sends Yes the related2017, PPP every to the elaborating year Decree Article yearly a(Decree report 31 andof onperiodical PPP to the 2017-149 the Decree application PPP from Unit reports (Decree and of 2pre t M Yes According to According the PPP Manual, Procedure to Yes #5.2: the PPP Manual, According Monitoring Procedure to Yes PPP the Performance #1.2: PPP According Completing Manual, During to Procedure Yes the the the PPP #5.1: Project Construction Manual, Section Designing PPP Screening 33 Procedure and the ofthe the PPPOperational/Ser PPP Matrix, #1.2: Contract Acta procuri provide Perfo Completi n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 29 of Art. the PPP Law requires 2 of the the Yes PPP Law provides Article procuring authority 24 that of to for the Yes ensure public PPP Law execution payment Pursuant partnerships(and to requires ofthe Yes article thecontract contract. 24 (b) toof Article That therefore include the 34PPP ofclause the control not Law: happens PPP concessions) related ForLaw at public require to the the pay th en No of the PPP Section 8.5.18 n/a Yes Manual provides for According performance to No Monitoring: section n/a 2.18 of Since the the No PPP Manual, private party the n/awill key to paid be the based on managem successful output p No of the n/a Articles 125-127 No PPP Law establish the oversight n/a Yes for PPP system CLAUSES projects. OF PPP CONTRACTS Yes AND PPP Law 95 SECTIONS Fractions V ON RELEVA and VI th Article 22(1) Pursuant toNo n/a Yes public partner PPP Law, the Pursuant performs toNo Section 123 annual checks of Government n/a andYes monitors Resolution the Pursuant PPP's 476, to "The Section performance, public 231 partner includingGo a of the mu No According to n/a the Model No Agreement, n/a Section 4.8, "a concessionaire No n/a is required to Yes adhere to <…> According the Standard Rules for theLaw to the Concessions Pe No According to n/a Law, No the Concessions Article 49, "(1) n/a the Competent No n/a shall No Authority n/a monitor and control the execution of contrac Yes According to of the PPP Article 18 Article 19 of Law, Yes the the Law According provides PPPpublic entity controls to Yes that thethe Article 18 public-private implementation Article of the PPP 19 of Law, Yes partnership the the of PPP public Law the Article contract contract provides entity 18(5) and provides controls that of the the way thethe for PPP public-privat the provisions implemen Law prov private No Article 27(2) Regulations of the PPPn/a provides: It Yes According is in particular to NoArticle responsibility the 7 of n/a the PPP Regulations, of Yesthe Regulatory According The Authority regulatory to Article authority to ensure 9 of is therespon PPP compl No Section 15 "Monitoring and Evaluation" n/a No of then/a PPP Policy No requires (1)n/a Noand evaluation a monitoring n/a processes to be establishe Yes DBFM Standard Article 8 of the Agreement 2.2 Obligations Yes of the sets Client Article the up Article 8.2 Quality of Yes 2.2 theAssurance of the Standard DBFM Standard system Article 3 DBFMO of Agreement Schedule Yes for the Agreement 2(Performance of Pursuant thestates contract. DBFM Moretospecifically: that: Article Standard Management The 8.3 Agreemen (Inspectio Pursuant Client System must:t Yes system According The monitoring is the same to Yes for the Standard both construction According PPP Contract, to and Yes the operational Section According Standard PPP periods. 49.3(c), Contract, to “payment Yes Thus, the Standard according ofAccording the Schedule PPP 13 Monthly to“Performance the Contract, toStandard the Unitary Section Payment, PPP Standard Regime�, 49.1(a) Contra PPP Co “p a related to monitoring All matters No n/a and Yesoversight According of the PPPNo to contract article 62(5) implementation n/a No and 63 of are the PPP regulated Regulation n/a in detail by project the PPP VII of t Chapterinspect Yes Article 13 to Article 15 of the PPP Law 8 indicates of the Yes PPP Law the rights Article provides: of8 of The the No co-contracting PPP procuring Lawn/a authorities provides: pertaining party The Yes co-contracting monitoring shall Article and 14 party be remunerated control ofwithin the shall of be PPPthe implementat Law remunerate framework provide No Section 12 of n/aprovides the ICRC Act Nothat the relevant n/a procuring shall supervise No entity n/a n/a in respect of which a concess No the project No Article 53 of n/aThe concession the PPP Law: No grantor n/a and theNo public partner No n/a shall continuously n/aregularly supervise the implem and No According to n/a Bidding No the Standard n/a Form for BOT, Part 1 "General Yes According Conditions to Yes of Concession the Standard Contract", According Biddingto Form Section the 3.6.1, Standard for BOT, "the Biddin Com Part 1 Yes Article 73 of Article the PPP Law establishes 65 of Yes in its the PPP second Regulations, Article paragraph: 73 of regarding Yes the"It PPP the Law will Article be states: PPP thecontractor's responsibility 65 "Service of the PPP Yes non-compliance of levels Regulations, Article the andcontracting 75 of penalties. regarding and thepublic The application PPPbidding the Law PPP entity establis of docu to con co in Section 73 n/a Pursuant toNo No of the Procurement n/a Act: (1)All contracts No arisingn/a No from procurements n/a undertaken by the Commission sha No Article 93 of n/a "Supervision Decree 4183/20: Yes during Article the94 operation No of phase Decree n/a 4183/20: The Contracting "Supervision Yes Authority Article of the will service 78 be Decree levels responsible In the supervis 4183/20: the t for"(...) T Yes Article 35 of Article the PPP Law establishes 3.3 of Yesthat the the PPP Regulations Contractual Service Levels indicates Yes Execution (Niveles that phase de Article one Servicio) includes of 115.2. the No are of the waysregulated the follow toPPP generate n/a up Regulations in and several value oversight for establishes money of the instances inis the that contra by PPP the est No Section 14.1 Law IRR: The of the BOTn/a Yes Section PPP Center shall 12.10 be responsible Yes Pursuant for of the BOT theIRR, Law toregarding Yes coordination Article 12.12 and Review monitoring of the of Project According to section BOT Law of Construction, projects IRR: 6.2 Theimplem of theOp PP Projec Article 8 ofAccording Pursuant toYes to No the PPP Act, Article the public of entity 7.2n/a the PPP shallYes Act, have the the right According to current remuneration of to Yes Article the control private of 7.2 of project partner the PPP Pursuant to implementation shall Act, Article the8(3) remuneration primarily depend of thethe by PP Nomanagement Each contract No implements n/a authority n/a its own Yes measures of Pursuant contracttoYes Article 329According management since of Public there Contracts to isn't a set Article 414 Code of b)rules of the 18, or Pub Yes Article 75 of Article the Tenders Regulation 78 of Yes provides, the "The Tenders Article Regulation governmental 82 of Yes the provides, authority "The Article Tenders Government shall 79 of Regulation No inspect the Tenders provides, Authority the "The n/a completed Regulation shall pay contractor materials, provides, the is obliged works price ofto "Thethe contr or insp co se Yes Article 41 of Article the PPP GEO: The32 public of Yes partner the has PPP GEO Article states the 32 right of Yes thatthe to the monitor PPP public-private GEOand Article states control 32partnership that of Nohow the the PPP the public-private GEO contract private n/astates partner regulates partnership that the and/or at public-private contract thethe least follo reg projectp No Article 50 of instructions ministerialn/a Yes no 612/08.11 Article 50 of No of 16/04/2014 ministerial setting n/a instructions No up modalities no 612/08.11 for drafting, n/a of 16/04/2014 negotiating, setting up mo requesting fo n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Procedure for Management Contract Article 128 of Yesis set the outArticle in The128 Implementing Implementing Regultaion of Yesthe Implementing Regulations provides Article the 128 Regulations following: of Yesthe PSP Implementing "The sets Law TheConcerned in private out that Regulations the Articles partner 127-133. Entity Concerned isshall sets Article out develo Entity obligatedtha t 128 Yes Article 44 of Article the PPP Law provides 44 of Yes specifically the PPP Lawthat provides:"In the Article 44 contracting of Yes the addition PPP authority Article Lawto the44 shall control of provides:"In Yes control the addition operations PPPall Lawaspects to Article provides:"In that the43may ofof control PPP the beaddition projects operations mentioned PPP Lawtoprovide that the in the co includingm No According to n/aChapter Yes the PPP Law, 63, "a public VIII, Article According toYes the partner PPP is According obliged toto ImplementationYes the Decree, continuously PPP Implementation According Article monitor6, the to report "a work Decree, the of on PPP Law, athe Article private realiza 6, p Chapte Section 27 n/a Pursuant toNo No the Unit of the PPP Act, shall... "(j) No n/a ensure continued n/a monitoring Yes Pursuant to of and evaluations PPP Agreements Section 4 of the PPPb Section 4.1.6 Pursuant toYes ofis This the regulated PPPYes Handbook,Sections under Section performance 4.2.6 2.4.19 Yes and the PPP ofmonitoring 2.4.20 This Handbook: are is the of regulated specific PPP Yes Managing activities Handbook: under Pursuant Sections service within 2.4.19 2.4.21 the to delivery In Section structuring management and means 4.2.6 2.4.22 ensuring of the paym of the the P Yes for Preparation The Procedure and According to Yes Implementation the Procedure for According of Preparation PPPs to Yesdescribes, the and Procedure According among Implementation for Preparation to Yes others, the the Procedure ofand existing PPPs, According Part for situation Preparation B,to section the Implementation atProcedure the of 7.1PPPs, stage and "Monitorin Impleme Part of for PPB P No and control The monitoring n/a functions Yesare not phase-specific The agreed No obligations and there(performance is no distinction n/a Yestargets of controls or According KPIs) available in the PPP for to the PPP contract construction Act, Articleo will be Yes Manual, The Procurement Section According to6.5 the No describes Procurement n/a Manual, No process. the Payment Section n/a 6.5, "onceNo n/a an officer is satisfied that goods/works/serv Yes According to the Concessions According Manual, to Yes the Section Concessions According 11.8.1, Manual, to Yes the "during Section the Concessions According 1.6.1(d), operationalManual, phase "some to Nothe Section of of athe concession key n/a Concessions 11.4.6(1)(a), features/characteristics Manual, project, Section thethe "with focus developm 11.7.3(c), ofof the co Yes According to According the Treasury Regulation, to Yes art. the PPP16.7.1, Manual, According "theModule accounting to Yes the the officer procurement 5,section 16.7.1 or accounting Accordingofto the Yes documents the Treasury PPP authority According Regulation, must Manual,of clearly Module theto institution the the set 5, accounting out PPP the Manual, the procureme that is offic part paymenMo Yes Article 261 of regulates the LCSP Article 102(6) the YesLCSP allows According prerogativespayments of the to procuring Yes article to be linked 259.5: authority According to The performance: Administration to during No article 259.5: Contracts, n/a may the implementation The include Administration whenof in their athe PPPbidding including may nature and docum inclu pu the Yes The Contract Management According Guide,to Sections Yes 6.1, the Contract According 6.2 Management and 8.3.1 to Yes detail the Contract the Guide, Section According procedures Management 8.3.2, to No related the"the Contract Guide, Contractor to n/a the Section Management contract should 8.3.1, "performance submit Guide, performance his Section Statem moni8 mo No Article 16 of n/a the PPP Act Yes the public provides that According party shall to NoArticle 34the monitor of the n/a implementation PPP Act, Yes a PPP of Article a PPP contract contract must 30 of the specify inPPP all its Law the followin provide aspects. n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 44 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a n/a authority No a contracting responsible No shall ben/a Yes for ensuring the proper Pursuant implementation, to Article ma 29 of the PPP Yes Performance This monitoring andis evaluation stipulated Yes under This Section is required by is stipulated 23 theYes (2) PPP under thein ofAct PPP This Section Section Act: is stipulated 23: 23 (2) The Yes (2) "23.-( of under the I) All purpose PPPpublic The of Section Act: private private (2) 23 monitoring The (2) party purpose under of the is to partnership sub-section PPP self-monito of monito project Act: (2) Section 44 n/a Pursuant toNo No a supervisory of the PPP Act, n/a committee No shall n/a have the following No n/a and duties: (1) to monitor an powers No According to n/a Article 5(1) No of the PPP Regulation, n/a task forces No n/a may be or committees No monitoring or supervising PPP pr set up for n/a Yes According to Articles 51 and 52 Article 9 of of the the Yes PPP Law PPP Law of provides According 2021 provides to that Yes payments for Article 43aArticle of mechanism in thePPP PPP 9 of contracts Law the Yes of control provides PPP Law are and According linked provides that monitoring "The to performance: to that public-private Article payments of the 51PPP of "The the partne in PPP hold PPP c contra n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 31, 32 Article and 33 of PPP law 62 of No. Yes PPP Decree 49-2015 (Law states No. Article 62 that 2015-49 of Yes The Decree PPP dated partnership Article 27 states November 62that of contract Yes PPP The 2015 must Decree partnership state related Article states essentially contract 31 to that contracts al 1The of the must partnership following PPP state between Law 49-201 essent : the (...) con p No According to n/a (m) andNo Articles 18(1) 25 of the BOT n/a Implementation Yes According Decree, to No the PPP Articles contract of n/a a PPP 18(2) (e) of Project the BOT Implementatio should include pr No According to Section 16(e) n/a of the PPP No Act, amongst n/a the functions No n/a of the established YesPPP project According is to teams to "monitor Section the 28(2) the ofimp Article 21 of Pursuant toYes the The PPP law "On Law Yes PPP" Article The and(Article 1) 47 law of andthe Law "On Concession PPP" Yes"On( Concession" Article Pursuant Law, 1) and (to a final Law Article Yes Article assessment "On Concession" provide 1)43 of Pursuant the of the Concession for the (to PPPArticle Article dependence (concession) 1) Law: 21(2) define The of 1. of implem perfor the the fee Pf No Article 34 of PPP Law provides, the Dubai n/a Yes "Without Article 26 of Yes prejudice the to the functions Dubai PPP Law Article 26 of provides the Yes of the Financial Dubai that PPP Article PPP contracts Law Audit Department, provides 32 of the shall Dubai that include, PPP PPP contra "6. Law a Governme p Th Yes Section 20.2 of PF2 Guidance According and to standard Sectioncontracts Yes 19.12.6 According of -recommends Standardization to Yes Section 19.12.6 substantial of PF2 of Standardization a According to Contracts: Yes element Section Authorities 19.12.6 of According monitoring of PF2 of should Standardization Contracts: to bySection the primarily Authorities 20.4.3 of Contractor, conside PF2 of sub sh thC No for under This is provided No n/aSection § of the PPTA. 33.2-1808 n/a NoComprehensive n/a agreement. Yes A. Prior This developing tois and/or provided for operatin under Section Yes Decree Article PPP Regulatory articles 66 17 of to Yes68.PPP the TheLaw: Ministry Article The 17 Public-Private of of Yes the PPP Finance issued Law: Participation Article Guidelines The 17 Public-Private ofYes Contracts the for PPP the presentation Participation must Law: According The necessarily to of Public-Private Contracts article Control include, 41 and Participatio must and of Monito neces the PPP notw No There are no n/a post-construction specific M&E No n/a stage-relatedNo provisions n/a No in the PPP-related n/a regulations. Still, there are general pr n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a According to Article 66 n/a No No on supervision of the PPP Law n/a No of public of quality n/a products Yes and services: "1. the As for PPPPPP projects project of nationa enterprises m According to the Procurement No n/a No Regulation, Section n/a 214 (1),No" A contract manager shall n/a n/a No be responsible for—(a) monitoring the p explicit disctinction There is no Yes Accordingfor tothe the Yes monitoring PPA, Section According framework 82(2)(a) to Yes thedepending PPA, and Section (b),According "a procurement on 82(2)(a) theto phase. Notheand PPA, contract Any (b), Section division "amay n/a procurement 88 among provide (a) tophases (c), contract for the "where is procuring may a pro pr arbitrary Law, Chapter Investment No n/a9, SectionNo 51 requires foreign investors n/a No to submit n/a a progress Yes report In accordance to the Myanmar with Investment Investment CoR According to the PPP Law, No Yes n/a art. 14(2), "a public According partner shall to No monitor the compliance n/a on PPP Resolution by Yes Monitoring, a privateAccording section partner 15(d), to the with the(e) Resolution terms and (f), of a"at [PPP on P th Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q36.1#1_6 Q36.1#2_6_1 Q36.1#1_5 Q36.1#2_5_1 Q36.1#2_7_TEXT Q36.1#1_7 Q36.1#1_7_TEXT Q37 Q37_3_TEXT Relevant The procuring legal/regulatory The or contract management PPP contract Relevant provisions performance legal/regulatory Themust authority PPPinformation contract periodically If yes, provisions please must performance gather Relevant specify beinformation available information the legal/regulatory 37. website: Is tothere on the must the public If an performance provisions be yes, economic/technical (e.g. available please by provide of online. request theits or PPP regulator incontra the an name of Yes No Article 15 of n/a the PPP Law provides No that:The Entity n/a has the n/a No following functions n/a and powers:10. To monitor and eval No n/a Yes No According to Article 86 n/a of the DCMn/a Publication n/a 285/2021, No of the signed contract notice <...> Yes No Art. 48 of the n/a Concession No Decree provides that n/a service delegation any public n/a No n/a must include information rel contract Yes of the PPP Law Article 17.1Yes provide Pursuant article that PPP toYes 17 agreements of Website the PPP Regulations, of the Pursuant musttechnical indicate toregarding No article committee the entity of n/a which the 17transparency, (CTPPP) PPP is responsible Regulations, the technical regarding to commi oversee Yes No Article 22 of the PPP Law n/a provides No that the General of the contract n/a Audit n/a n/a in each annual action plan a No shall include No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/aart. 18(3), the PPP Act, No "the contracting n/a n/a shall submit authority No n/ato the PPP Authority on the pr reports No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 31 of http://pppbelarus.by/projects/ongoing/ the PPP Law: Pursuant 1. Theto state No Article partner 31 of isthe No PPP Law: obliged to post 1. The on its official state partnew No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 66 of n/a PPP Law provides thatNo Public partner a regular basis, n/a hold onn/a n/awith the private sector to und No meetings Yes Article 32 (1) Pursuant toNo n/a No of the Sarajevo Concession n/a Law, n/a No Ministry the competent shall continuously supervise the n/a Yes No According to n/a the Procurement Manual, No Section n/a n/aContractNo 12.3(7), “the n/a set up a system whereby date Manager shall Yes Yes The PPP Law (art. 15) provides Article 14, that §Yes the 5º and Ministries § 6º http://www.planejamento.gov.br/assuntos/parcerias-publico-privad the PPP of and Article Regulatory Law provides 14, Agencies 5ºthat §Yes and shall the § 6º Taking annual of the send tothe reports the PPPcase Board Lawsubmitted study provides of the into that to accoun the th Investme Yes the following Pursuant toYes Pursuant Articles to Yes ofArticle the Concession 131(3) https://nkr.government.bg/ the Concession of Law: Pursuantto Pursuant Law, toNo Article Article the Concessions 131(3) 131(1) grantor n/a of shall the of the Concession ensure ConcessionLaw Law, <...> publicity thethe for gr Wh Yes No Article 88 of n/a specifies the PPPP Decree No the management n/a n/a control procedures and No for the PPP contract. As such, it p n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 40 of Pursuant toNo n/a the Law on No n/a Partnerships, Public-Private Implementing n/a "the No n/aAgency shall be responsible fo Yes Section 36 n/a Pursuant toNo No of the PPP Decree (Decree n/a No. 2008/0115/PM n/a of Januaryn/a No 24, 2008 regulating the Law No. No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to of the article 29 This Concessions Yes may information Law: be http://www.concesiones.cl/proyectos/Paginas/proyectos_operacio requested "The This by bidding documents information any interested No shall may explicitly be n/a party by means requested indicate of by any the procedure interested levels est pa of servic Yes Yes Article 26 of of the Ministry the NoticePursuant article toYes of Finance 8 of http://www.cpppf.org/index.html Notice on The of the Guidelines Pursuant Ministry tofor of No article PPP Operations 8 of Finance onNotice n/a Issuing requires of the the Interim a project Measures Ministry implemf of Finance Yes No According to of PPP Law,No Article 24 n/a the public resources n/a n/aall otherNo and n/a funds of the project shall be administered th No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 18 of n/a the Procurement Code No n/a The Public provides that: No Regulatory n/a Procurement n/a Authority carries out techn No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No According to Art. 27 of n/a Decree No. No 2018-358 of n/a 2018 relating March 29,n/a Private Partnerships contracts: P No to Publicn/a Yes YesAct provides Article 17 PPP for the Yes periodic The publication of PPP monitoring performance http://investcroatia.gov.hr/ implementation information of The publication Nois of required ofPPP PPPperformance Noby Article projects 18 by the information paragraph competent 6 minis is of th requi No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 72 of n/a the PPP Regulations provides: No n/a and responsibilities "Powers n/a n/a Noof the supervisor during the operation sta No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Yes In general, according toAccording article 82 to of Yesthe PPP Article 89 Law The of the webpage the PPP OFAPP Law, According of (contract the OFAPP supervisory to No (the Article contract 89 management authority n/a of management authority) the must PPP Law, carry have the authority) the out supervisory studies right once re toaba No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes article L.2234-2 Pursuant toNo n/a of the No Public Procurement n/a n/a the buyer Code, Yeshas control The Transport over Regulatory the execution Author of the cont Yes Article 56 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Ordinance, n/a No an/a follow-up of the holder's n/a n/a Noobligations must be realized regularly. Yes Article 31 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Law: Yes Article 1. A public www.ppp.gov.ge 16 of partner the shall PPP Law, Information Information ensure No the on public-private on public-private n/a of the monitoring partnership fulfillment partnership projects, of projects, the oblig as wa Yes obligation in There is no No n/a the Standard No Contractn/a for Highways, Noan option n/a but rather that a contracting authority can n/a Yes No Section 66 of n/a provides the PPP Policy Nothat: A Contracting n/a n/a Authority Nois party to that a PPP Agreement/Concession is n/a Yes No According to of PPP Law No Article 83 n/a 4635/2019 n/a <...>, project n/a No implementation be systematically monitored. Bo is ton/a Yes Yes Article 87 of Article the PPP Law 86 of establishes Yes the that ANADIE PPP https://anadie.gob.gt/ Law must periodically Article establishes the publication 86 of verify Nothe that of the PPP the n/a Law service Reports establishes standards of the theDirection publication of Sup are met. of t No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to of the PPP Article 23 Article Law, Yes 95 of the SAAP PPP Regulatory has http://sapp.gob.hn the following Article Decree.- Advertising 95 of attributions:"... Yes the PPP for 8) compliance Superintendence To require Regulatory with Decree.- fromcontracts service of Advertising provider Public - Priva .- for The a No n/a Yes Yes Annex 16 (Information https://kereso-core.kozbeszerzes.hu/ concerning According the performance to NoArticle of the of 43n/a contract) the or https://ekr.gov.hu/portal/k Public to Government ProcurementDecre Act:(1 Yes Yes Chapter 13.5 of the Post-Award The Planning Contract No Management n/aGuidelines Commission n/a Manual(now lays NITI NoAayong) down on detailed n/a guidelines Institutional require the for toMechanism Mo autho Yes No According to the Attachment n/a to the No Regulation № Bappenas n/a n/a4, Chapter Yes In the toll roads IVA, Part C(2)(b)(2), sector, for the the Toll R management o Yes No Article 57 of Construction the Roads n/a NoByLaw provides: n/a Ministry should The n/a n/a No prepare and release annual report on th No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No According to Schedule 14(2) n/a "Reports No during Service n/a Period" No n/aof the Contract n/a Within 5 Business Days aft Template, No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes manager identified The project No n/a No 101(3) in Article n/a of the Public n/a Contracts Yes ANAC Code would - http://www.anticorruzion periodically verify the owners Yes Yes According to According the PPP Policy, Section to No6.0.1(4), the "the n/a Public PPP Policy, Section Investment n/a 10.0.1, "<…> Yes the PPP The Management Secretariat UnitPublic will adopt Investment (PIMSec) the following continues pra Managem Yes Guideline, Section Monitoring Yes According 2-3to establishes No periodical the Monitoring No Guideline, monitoring n/a Section and 6-2(2), No PPP information n/a contract gathering duties for informat performance the proc Yes No of the PPP Article 7(B)(7) n/a Law provies No that the n/a PPP Unit shall: No n/a "receivd n/a on PPP Projects from Cont periodic reports Yes Article 25(6) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant p.169 toYes Law, the of MNE local https://kzppp.kz/projects executive Order Pursuant No. body 725, the monitors toconclusion p. 169 the No and contracts of MNE n/a monitoring Orderof No. public-private observations 725, partne areo information Yes Noof the PPP Section 73 (1) n/a Act provides No that:(1) n/a A contracting n/a that is a party authorityNo n/a to a project agreement shall, Yes No According to n/a Article 51-2 (1) of theNo PPP Act, the n/a competent authority No n/a n/a shall submit a report on the conditions of op Yes Article 48 (2) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP No n/a contractn/a Law, the PPP should contain: agreementNo n/a 2:11. the obligation of the Pr Yes No Article 33 of n/a the PPP Law provides,No "The Minister n/a of Finance No to the Council n/ashall present n/a of Ministers an annual re No n/a Yes Decree No.www.ppp.gov.kg; Pursuant toYes purpose 307:3. The Pursuant www.mineconom.gov.kg of toNo maintaining Decree No.n/a the Register 307: is a complete, 4. The register time is compiled a Yes No Article 51 of n/a provides: the PPP Decree No "Responsibilities n/a Project Executing ofn/a No n/a Project executing agencies ar Agencies Yes Yes Article 12 of The the PPP Law Freedom provides No for of Information reports n/athe on Law performance of n/a 1996 provides contracts, of No Section n/a underfor which 10 the procuring that authority public institutions Yes No According to n/a art. 11(2)(c), the PPP Law, No "the project n/a management n/a No for the Operational office n/a Phase shall present th Yes No Article 27.1. n/a of the Partnership Agreement No n/a <...> 27.1. provides, No partner n/a The Private n/ashall provide the Public partne Yes No Article 34 of n/a the PPP Law obliges the Nopublic authority n/a n/a into a PPP entering n/a No contract to carry out an evaluation of pe Yes Noof the PPP Section 65 (2) Act, regarding n/a No Duty to n/a monitor and implementati n/aoversee No n/a on of a PPP contract, provides: No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No A report is prepared the end of each at n/a No phase of n/a n/a by the procuring the contract No n/a authority (Article 29 of the PPP Law Yes No of the PPP Section 8.5.18 n/a No Manual provides for n/a Performance n/a No Since the Monitoring: private party will be paid based n/a Yes Yes According to According article 128 PPP Yes bis of theto the Regulations: Articlehttp://finanzaspublicas.hacienda.gob.mx/es/Finanzas_Publicas/Info 14 ofAgencies According the PPP and federal Law: "In to No addition, the Article entities the n/a that 14 of Ministry have the PPP of Finance Law: "Inand addition, public-private Public partner Yes Article 22(1) Pursuant toNo n/a No of the PPP Law and Sections n/a and 227 of No 124 n/a n/a Resolution No. 476, the pub the Government Yes No According to n/a the Model No Agreement, Section 4.3, n/a n/a by a contracting "an [appointed No authority] Independent Engineer n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 27 (2) n/a of the PPP No Regulations (Decree No. n/a16/2012) provide that n/a n/a NoIt is in particular the responsibility of the R Yes No According to n/a section 111 (1) of theNo Public Procurement n/a n/a a public Rules, No n/a entity shall do the following acts, as require Yes Article 8.3 (Inspections) Pursuant toNo n/a Noof the DBFMO n/a Standard No (a) The Contracting n/aAgreement: n/a Authority may at any Yes No According to n/a PPP Contract, the Standard No Section n/a n/a Crown may 20.2(a), “the n/a No elect at any time to undertake its own p Yes Article 62 of Pursuant toYes PPP The Integral Regulations, Yes Management the http://www.snip.gob.ni/Portada/App Information project The Integral System inspector No inspects covers Management fulfilment n/a all of ofInformation norms Public Private stipulated System Partnership covers by con al theProje Yes No Article 13 of n/a the PPP Law provides No : In addition to the control n/a No n/a exercised n/aor by other competent author by the State No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Article 63 of the PPP Regulations Article 11 of establishes Yes in the PPP Lawhttps://enterector.gob.pa/ its provides: last paragraph: Article “Functions 11 "Control of No of the PPP areas the Law and n/a governing provides: mechanisms. body. The “Functions [...] The governing the body gov w of contrac No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 120 of Article 122 Decree 4183/20 of Yes provides: Decree Reporting http://app.gov.py/; by the 4183/20: Article Contracting 122 "Transparency https://www.contrataciones.gov.py/ of No and Authority Publication Decree to n/a the 4183/20: of Public-private the "Transparency information and regarding Publi Partnership Yes No Articles 58.5 and 118 of n/a PPP Regulations refer to theArticle sectoral Yes that https://www.ositran.gob.pe/nosotros/ositran-en-cifras.html 10regulatory - Resolution Yes 024-2011-CD-OSITRAN OSITRAN (https://www.ositran.g mechanisms - OSITRAN and subsidiary establis Yes Yes Section 12.10 Section of the BOT Law IRR, 2.4 regarding Yes of the BOT Law ppp.gov.ph IRR: Review Project Section of Concerned Construction, 2.4 Agencies/LGUs of the BOT No Law n/a areIRR: Operation tasked and Concerned Maintenance: to prepare their The infra Age Agencies/LGU Yes Articles 16b Pursuant toNo and 16c ofNo n/a the PPP Act, n/a n/a the public No to provide entity is obliged n/a the minister competent for Yes Article 35 (2) Pursuant toYes (n) of the Pursuant Articles PPP Law, toYes 35 one andof36 UTAP's of the Pursuant http://www.utap.pt/ functions PPP Law, toNo is Articles to collect, UTAP 35 n/a and provides such process 36 ofinformation and the centralize PPP Law, onthe its webs UTAP pro econ No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 50 of instructions ministerialn/a Nono 612/08.11 n/a of 16/04/2014 n/a No up modalities setting n/a for drafting, negotiating, re No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Yes out that Article 128 sets Article the Concerned 31 of Yes Entity the PSP LawThe shall requires websiteNCP As developisaper yet contract to Article to establish beNomanagement 31 a of created. registry then/a PSPand for Law, PSP monitoring all information, projects which plan and docum will inc furth Yes Nothe PPP Decree Article 121 of No that the n/a provides n/a Monitoring n/a No Committee annual reports which are sent to prepares n/a Yes No According to n/a the PPP Implementation No Decree, n/a Article 4(1) n/a and (2), "supervision No n/a of the implementation of a public c No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Section 4.1.21 Pursuant toNo n/a of the PPP No Handbook, n/athe GPE n/a No that during should ensure n/a the procurement phase, the s Yes No According to Procurement the Publicn/a NoAct, §12(1), n/aa "register n/a No is an information of references n/a system of the public a Yes Yes According to According the PPP Act, Article 135(2), to No "<...> the PPP n/a a public Act, Article partner 72, n/a"a privateNo party written may request to a PPP n/areports shall inform, about in the performanc accordance w No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a the PPP Manual, Module No 6, the project n/a officer should ensure n/a n/a No that the necessary mechanisms are imp No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No According to the Contract n/aManagement No Guide, n/a n/a and (vi),No Section 8.1(v) Contract administration function "following n/a Yes Article 30 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Act, No the Project n/aCompany shall submit n/a reports to the contracting author Noperiodic n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 29 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a No the agreement n/a provide for shalln/a No which parties deem necessary, b all mattersn/a Yes Section 97 n/a Pursuant toNo No of the PPP Regulations,n/a the accounting is responsible n/a officer No n/afor collecting data on the priva Yes No to gather The obligation information n/a Nois impliedn/a in Section 44 n/a No of the PPP the supervisory committee shall Act, sincen/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 51 of n/a the PPP Law states that No n/a authority the procuring Nopowers aiming n/ahave audit n/a at monitoring the impleme No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No According to Article 31 n/a of the PPP Law No (Law n.n/a 2015-49 dated No n/a 27 November related to contracts between th 2015n/a Yes No According to Article 25 n/a of the BOT No Implementation n/a Decree, n/a No administration the relevant n/a supervises, or alternativel Yes No According to n/a Section 16(1)(h), the PPP No project n/a team would "submit toNo n/a n/a or such other reports on th the Unit, annual Yes of the implementation Monitoring No n/a No of contracts n/a concludedn/a No within the framework n/a of public-private partnership is ca Yes No Article 10 of PPP Law outlines the Dubai n/a No the functions n/a n/a of government entities, which No n/a include, "12. Prepare quarte Yes No Section 20.2 of PF2 Guidance n/a and standard Yes The Government's contracts -recommends https://www.gov.uk/government/collections/major-pro transparency a No substantial n/a element policy requires of monitoring Departments, from by the Co Yes Yes 23 U.S.C. § 129(a)(3)(B) requires to Pursuant a public Yes Virginia authority https://www.p3virginia.org/categories/current/ Freedom of Information with Pursuant to jurisdiction over Act No Virginia (FOIA), a toll Freedom §n/a 2.2-3704:Public facility conduct toof Information or records have Actto an indep be op (FOIA), Yes Yes According to of the PPPto article 39 According Yes Law, Article the Contracting 4 of http://ppp.mef.gub.uy/1201/2/areas/portafolio-de-proyectos.html the PPPAdministration According Law, and No all acts to Article shall agreements monitor 4 of n/a the the PPP compliance made Law, under all the acts framework and with agreem the cont Yes No According to the articlen/a 14 of the PPP No Law, "a public n/a partner n/a No to," among has the right n/a others, "request and receive No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 94 of n/a the PPP Law provides:No Responsibilities n/a of competent n/a No authorities: 7. Publicize information about P [...]n/a Yes According toNo n/a the Procurement Regulation, No n/a 214(1)(a), Section No manager n/a "a contract shall be responsible for— (a) m n/a Yes According toNo n/a Guidelines, the Investment No Section n/a n/a 150, "monitoring No to project is central n/a management. It is, therefor No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to the Resolution Yes According on PPP to Monitoring, the PPP Law, Yes Thesection art. website 14(5), 6,According "monitoring will "the dependto No resultsthe on of ofthe PPP who perfoming implementation a Law, n/a public a control art.party 14(5), to"the over ofaaPPP [PPP] results compliance agreement agreeme o of perf Q37.1_A Q37_4_TEXT Q37.1_B Q37.1_1_TEXT Q37.1_2_TEXT Q37.1_C Q37.1_C Q37.1_3_TEXT Q37.1_4_TEXT 37.1 If and the relevant yes, does legal/regulatory If yes, the please provisions 37.1 provide economic Managerial regulator establishing the If yes, relevant have autonomy please its legal/regulatory 37.1 (check provide mandate: (freedom all that Tariffthe setting If yes, relevant to apply): provisions: determine please authority. Political legal/regulatory 37.1 provide theautonomy use the DisputeIf resolution of yes, relevant its provisions: please (for budget legal/regulatory authority. provide example, and organization through the relevan inde o provi n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No According to Art. 213 of the Publ n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Each independent regulatory Regulatory agency agencies Yes have: is regulated Regulatory by (i) stability a specific agencies Yesof thehave law. directors, Regulatory managerial Recently, i.e., Law agencies Yes 13.848/2019 impossibility autonomy, generally Regulatory of was according dismissal, issued define agencies to tothe except provision establish maximum generally for commo serious in limit ha the l n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The authority The juridical was founded by LawYesNo. status given The 2009-1503 byjuridical -national 8/12/2009 YesLawand status given n. reorganized The 2009-1503 byAuthority national - 8/12/2009 through Yes Law has new n. Lawisn/a powers No. an independent 2015-990 2009-1503 applicable - 8/12/2009 of public August to the is body 6, motorw an 2015 wit indep n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Article 82 of n/a the PPP Law No General Regulation establishes n/a No the supervising that n/a No attribution n/a for the SAPP to verify complia allows n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a in the toll roads Specifically,No there is a Toll n/a sectorNo n/aRoad Regulatory Yes According Agency to (BPJT), Yes which the Regulation n/a that is a body of the has Minister the authority to Wo of Public pe n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Article 213n/a Pursuant toNo No Contracts (1) of the Public No supervision n/a Code: The n/a and control No of public Pursuant contracts Article to and 210 their of the Pub regulation s No According to n/a Section the PPP Policy, No6.0.1(4), "the n/a Public Investment No n/a No Management n/a Secretariat (PIMSec) continues to monitor n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a FrameworkArticle Law 27332,Yes Law on 2 the of Law Yes Regulatory 27332 onAgencies the nature Article of 2 of Law Yes Private of27332: regulatory Article the Investment The Regulatory 3.1 agencies: in(b) Yes Public of Bodies the The Services, Regulatory Laware Article 27332 decentralized establishes 3.1 that (e) Bodies establish of and the public are Law regulates decentraliz that bodies 27332 regul a m at n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a n/a Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q38 Q39 Q38_1_TEXT Q39_1_TEXT Q39.1_A Q39.1_B Q39.1_1_TEXT Q39.1_C Q39.1_2_TEXT If yes, 38. Are foreign please 39. companies provide Does restricted the the If regulatory relevant from yes, please repatriating legal/regulatory 39.1 framework provide If yes, the theIf(including income yes, which relevant provisions: of please the resulting legal/regulatory/standard 39.1 standard following provide Changes from contractual circumstances Ifthe the of yes, relevant operation ownership/contract please clauses) legal/regulatory/standard 39.1 are contractual of In provide a specifically expressly other PPP the project? cases, assignment, relevant provisions: regulate regulated? flexibility legal/regu change contra at any to c (ch No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 32 of the PPP Law n/a Yes and Article 23 of DCM Pursuant No. 575/2013 toNo Article 32 (1) the contains of the laws PPP that regula Law, the No n/a Yes Law No. 16-09 No of August n/a No promotion 3, 2016 about No n/a of investments, is applicable to public in No n/a Yes articles 239 Pursuant toNo and 373 of n/a Yes the Public According Procurement to No Law, the article private 373 Public Procure of the partner may n No n/a Yes Yes r) and Article 9, sections Article t) of the 9.t)PPP of Yes Law, the regulate PPP Law Article regulates changes 9.t) of No PPP in the the Law assignment ownership regulates or structure. the assignm change a to As No n/a Yes Article 15(3) Pursuant toNo n/aof PPP Law No n/a <...> where Yes applicant is a consortium of the successful No n/a Yes of Volume 3 Sections 29 Yes National and 28 PPP of Yes Volume Guidelines National 7 of Volume the National PPP 3 on Guidelines No Commercial PPP Guidelines Volume Principles regulate 3 on for any Comm ch Soc No n/a Yes No According to n/a the Law on Concessions, Yes §108(1),According "substantial to No changes the to a Law on concession contra Concessions, §108(1 No n/a Yes During the term No of the n/a agreement No investor can assign its rights n/a No and obligations (totally or p No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 34 of n/a the PPP Law: n/a No 1. Change Nopartner in obligations under an of a private No n/a Yes of the PPC n/a Article 38/3No Yes Regulation Implementation Article authorizes 43 of Nothea change of private 2014/23/EU partner Directive on Coo No n/a Yes No According to of the PPP Law, article 68 n/a Yes the contract According may to set No out the article of the PPPunder 68conditions whic Law, the c No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 23 (1) n/a Yes Concession of the Sarajevo Pursuant Law, toNo Article the contract (b) of 23 (3)may the not be transfer Sarajevo No n/a Yes The PPP Policy, No Annexure n/a2, Section No n/a a clause 35 establishes Noin a Summary of Standardized C No n/a Yes No control n/a Changes in the Yes of special purpose vehicle As expressly is subject Nothe Granting established Authority's by the article 3 ofto PP prio No n/a Yes Article 143(1) Pursuant toNo Yes n/aof the Concession Law, Pursuant the concessionaire Article 143shall toNo notify of the the granto Concession Law No n/a Yes Article 81 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Decree, n/a Yes “[u]nless Pursuant otherwise toNo Article 81 of in provided the PPP Decree, Article “[u 79 above, No n/a Yes Article 35 of No n/a the PPP Law The project provides:Yes Article company 35 of Nothe can PPPtransfer only the partnership Law provides: The proje No n/a Yes No According to Article 28 n/a of the PPP Law: No "The assignment n/a Yes of rights and obligations of the Pri No n/a Yes No According to section 5 of n/a No the Law 2006/012, n/a the must include provisions regardin contract No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 32 of the PPP Ordinance n/a No provides n/a contract that the Noshall contain provisions on the c No n/a Yes YesArticle 65 Article 30 and According of the Concessions to Yes article 30.5 Article of the Regulation65 Concessions restrict of Nothe Concession changes of control Regulations Regulations: during "The stat th conce No n/a Yes No Article 4(10) of The Ministry n/a of Finance's n/a No Notice No and Promoting Asset Securit on Regulating No n/a Yes Public Procurement No n/a are intuito contracts According Yes personae, therefore, to No once Article celebrated, 41 of 1993, of Law 80 they Pu canno No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 10 of the PPP Regulations n/a No to the General refer n/a No Procurement Law regarding assignm No n/a Yes No According to Art. 25 (q)n/a of Decree No. n/a No 2018-358 29, 2018 relating to Public Privat of MarchNo No n/a Yes Article 66 of Pursuant toNo the Concession n/a Yes Act, aPursuant transfer of toNo the Article 66 of the concession to a third party Concession fo Act, No n/a Yes No According to Procurement the Publicn/a YesAct, §174(1), According "a contracting No to authority the Public shall proceed Procurement in Act, §1 No n/a Yes According to No n/a the EU Concessions Yes Directive, art. According 43(1)(d)(ii) No to and the (iii), EU Concessions "concessions may be m Directive, T No n/a Yes Yes Article 44 of Any the PPP Law relates transfer toYes of the PPP contract The cession, third article of PPP, 45 party to No cession to which ofthe if authorized,shares. can, PPP The any inis Partner case, given upih No n/a Yes Yes Articles 10.4, New members 10.7 and 19.10 of theNo Model of the Contract n/a for a PPP shareholding composition No are only tender process: allowed if t https://dgap No n/a Yes No According to article 30 n/a of the PPP Regulations No (Executive Decree n/a No 1190), the transfers of sha No n/a Yes Article 36 of Yes the PPP Law Article 36 "The states, ofNo the project PPP Law n/a states "The company may Noproject not be dissolved, company may not struc its legal be d No n/a Yes Yes Article 46 of Art. 56 PPP Law: "The bidder PPP Yes who Law: has been Article Without awarded detriment 30 (d) No the of the to PPP provisions Law: contract, shall The agreed be private forced upon par to a c No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to the Publicn/a Procurement Yes According Act, §123(1)(5) to (7), to No "the the Public contracting Procurement authority or§1 Act, en No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes of the Public Section 136No n/a and Concessions ContractsYes Pursuant Actto includes Sectionprovisions No Public 136 of theon Contra changes in No n/a Yes Article R.2194-6 Pursuant toNo Public Procurement n/a of theYes Pursuant Code, toNo Article R.2194-6, change the new of economic owner operato No n/a Yes No Article 59 of the PPP Ordinance n/a Yes a written requires Article consent 59 of Noof the the PPPprocuring Ordinance requires authority aw befor No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 26 of n/a Yes1. A public-private the PPP Law: Pursuant to partnership No Article 26 of the PPP Law: agreement may includ 3. A ne No n/a Yes No The Standard n/aHighways, Contract for Yes§59 dealsAccording with the issue No to ofPPA, the §132(1)(4), "material the shareholder structurec No n/a Yes Section 73(4)and No (5) of n/a the PPP Act, No 1039) states 2020 (Act n/a Nothat:(4) A majority shareholder No n/a Yes Article 28 of No n/a the PPP Law Yes highlights the circumstances Article 51 ofofNo the Concessions changes made to the Law private partn provides th No n/a Yes Article 145 of Yes According to the PPP Regulations provides NoArticle 145 for n/a the of the PPPNoRegulations inclusion the contract in the contract should of provisions re No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 32 of the PPP Regulatory n/a Yes regulates Decree Article the32 assignment ofNo the PPP Regulatory (cession) of a PPP: The Decree p regu No n/a Yes Noexisting PPP In the case of Yes n/a contracts, the then-applicable According to Act No CXXIX Article of 2003 139 of the on Public Public Publi Procur No n/a Yes Yes The Model Concession Equity Agreement No restricts structure of the a change n/a privatein the No partner shareholding is regulated as per sector pattern spe of the SPV No n/a Yes According to Yes the art. 32 According Regulation No (4) of theto the art. 32 on n/a (4) PPPs, "transfer of the Regulation No of shares on PPPs, in an implementi "transfer of s No n/a Yes No Article 11 of the Private n/a Sector Participation No n/a provides Order Nothat - The investor is authorize No n/a Yes According to No of the Investments Article 23 n/a Yes LawAccording (previously No to Article 10(3) Article in 2008), Article 23 (previously 10o the Iraqi No n/a Yes Yes Contract Template includes Section section Yes 49.2 of Contract 49 "ChangePursuant Template: in Ownership". toNo private A 43 Article partner commonly of EU Concession "will accepted 2017 cont procure th No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes of the Public Article 175 (1d) According Contracts to Yes Code Article regulates Article 184(3) of the 175 the Public No different (1) (2) of (D)Contracts changes theCode, Public that Contracts can the occur change No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes of the Guideline Section 6-2 Yes Section relating 6-2 Yes ofto Contracts the Theprovides Guidelinepublic relating authority No for to Share Contracts Transfer must provides consent of the to for the Share cha Appoin No n/a Yes Article 42 of Yes the PPP Regulation Article 42states No of thethat PPPthe Regulation n/a mandatory Noprovisions states mandatory that theto provision be stipulated for in No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 54(3) n/a Yes of the PPP Law, without According the consent to NoItem 138public of the model of theand private thePPP con No n/a Yes No of then/a Section 68(3)-(7) Yes as follows: PPP Act states Section "(3) The 68(3)-(7) No directors of PPP of the Act states a project as foll company s No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 27 of n/a Yes the PPP Act :(1) Management Article 26(2) andNooperation of the PPP rights Basic Plans shall be consid states: (2 No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Article 24 of the PPP Law Article provides, 24 of "The the PPP Yes Law Article Project Company provides, 24 of No"The the or PPP theProject consortium Law Company provides, company "Inthe or may coo case No n/a Yes No According to Article 15 n/a of the PPP Law, n/a No <...> the the tender in order to implemen winner ofNo No n/a Yes No Article 48 of the Law on n/a Investment No n/a provides: Assignment of rights or transfer of business a Yes No n/a Yes Article 74 of Yes the PPP Law Article 74 of regulates Nosituations the PPP Lawn/a provides where the ownership No for a limitation structure of thechanges regarding private No n/a Yes According to Yes the PPP Law, According to No art. 9(2), "regarding the PPP Law, n/a PPP Projects art. No 9(2), "regarding undertaken by Projects PPP the State or pub underta No n/a Yes No Article 60 of n/a Law provides the Concessions Yes a list Article of compulsory of the 29.3 No Partnership clauses included in th to be Agreement pr No n/a Yes Yes Articles 29 (3) and (18) Articles of the PPP 29 (3) Yesand (18) Decree (Decree Articles of the 2017-149 PPP 29 (3) Decree and (18) Nofrom 2 March (Decree of the 2017-149 2017, PPP Decree from(D 2 elaboratin No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Guidelines on As per Shareholders Concessionaire Guidelines No onChanges Concessionaire n/a : 1. Purpose No of the Guidelines Shareholders is to:8: Changes Para C i. st No n/a Yes No Article 36 of the PPP law n/a forbids any No n/a change of of the contract without the proc ownershipNo No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Article 105 of Nothe PPP Regulation n/a Yes regulate the Article possibility 105.II of No change of in the the PPP structureestablish Regulations of PPP, No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to n/a Law, Yes the Concessions art. 27.1.1 and According 27.1.4,to "a No Concessionaire the Law, Concessions is art. 32.2, prohibited: < No n/a Yes According to No n/a Law, Yes the Concessions According Part VI, Article 52(1), "a to Nothe Concessions Concession Contract Law,can Part be assi VI, Ar No n/a Yes In accordance No with the n/a article 12 of the PPP Law, Yes Paragraph the substitution, 2 of Article No 21 the transfer of the PPP the pro andLaw con No n/a Yes Article 21(6) No Law provides of the PPPn/a transfer Yesthat any Article 21(6) of the No PPP Law and of contractual Article and 42 of pos statutory PPP No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes The DBFM Standard No n/a Agreement Yes that the provides Pursuant transfer toNo or issuing Article of aof 2.163a the Public share Procu in the capit No n/a Yes Yes The Standard PPP Contract, According Section to 91 the Yes devoted isStandard According PPP to the Contract, toNo the issue of Standard Section the change 91.1(a), PPPin ownership. “a Change Contract, Sec No n/a Yes No Article 25 of n/a the PPP Law requires the Yes approval According from theto NoArticle 25 of Department Public of the PPP Law, the a Investment No n/a Yes Yes Article 49 of the PPP Law Article provides 49 of : the ThePPP Yes Law Article partnership provides contract 49 of No : the The partnership concluded isPPP on Law provides contract the :basis is part The of th conc No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Article 42 of No n/athe contract the PPP Law: Article 42 Yes for establishing aof public-private No provides that the PPP Lawpartnership may be the c No n/a Yes According to Yes the Standard According Bidding No Form to the Standard for BOT, n/a Bidding43.10.1, Section Form for No as BOT, partPart 1 "General of the Co information No n/a Yes No Article 83 of the PPP Law n/a Yes states: "Transfer of the Article PPP83 of Nothe PPP contract. The Law company requires that the su holding P No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Article 29 of Article the PPP Law: The 65 private of Yes Decree 4183/20: Article participant may 65 "A voluntarily of NoDecreeassign company for 4183/20: specific the public-private purposes "A company fo (...) No n/a Yes Nothe PPP Regulations Article 109 of n/a provides the Yes Article rules 109 for PPP Nothe of PPP Regulations contract assignment or transf provide th No n/a Yes Yes Section 11.6 of the BOTPursuant Law IRR,to regarding Section 12.20 Yes Section of the Withdrawal/Substitution 11.6 BOT No Law of BOT of the IRR: Subject Law a Member: IRR, to regarding approv theThe W Pro No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Art. 46.1 (4) n/a Yes of the Concession Law, Pursuant it is prohibited toNo Article amendof to46.1(4) the the Concession concession a No n/a Yes to 323 of Public Articles 316No Yes Code 18 n/a Contracts Article contain 318/No 2 (b) rules the 3 onand (b); Article 319/2, of assignment/subcontra No n/a Yes A specific company No n/a shall Yes be created for the implementation A specific company Noof theshall be created project. forof Article 24 the im the No n/a Yes Article 40 of Pursuant toNo the PPP GEO: n/a Yes (1) Upon Pursuant termination toNo Article of the public-private 105 partnersh of the Concession Law No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Articles 14.3 and 25.1 of n/a No regulate n/a the PSP Law of ownership structure and the a the transferYes No n/a Yes Article 42 of No n/a26 and 27 the PPP Law, of the PPP Yes Article Decree of No 42regulate the PPP theLaw transfer of ownership provides that the c No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Section 12 of the PPP Act n/a (1) A controlling provides:No Noin a private partner's company n/a interest No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to Procurement the Publicn/a YesAct, §18(1)(d)(2) According to andNothe Public"a §18(1)(e), contract, a framew Procurement Act, Art No n/a Yes According to No n/a the PPP Act, Yes 138(1), Part VII, Article Provisions "a private related No tochanges partyto in the a PPP must ownersh inform a pu No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes According to According the Exchange to Control Yes Regulations, the Trasury According 1961, Regulation, art. to10(1)(c), the section Yes PPP"no 16.8.2, Standardized For person the shall, relevant No Provisions, a situation except when treasury there with section is will permission 83.3.3, approve "gene grante a realization ma a of No n/a Yes Article 214 of Yesthe LCSPArticle regulates 214assignment Yesthe LCSP of Article and/or regulates transfer 214assignment of No the of the LCSPand/or Work regulates Concession transfer assignmen cont of the No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to n/a Act, Chapter the Concessions Yes 14, According §13, "a concession to Nothe Concessions Act, contract may be changed Chapter 14 No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Article 34 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a Yes1. The rights Pursuant and obligations toNo Article 34 the ofof a private the PPP Law: 1. The partner No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Clause 3 (3)No of the Characteristics n/a No of n/a to Contract Amendment No Announcement: Amendment No n/a Yes According to No n/a Annex II of Yes the PPP Act, the PPP agreement According to shall No address, Article the 39 ofL) Public the to pledg right Contrac No n/a Yes No Article 43 of n/a the PPP Law provides Yes that: "The public-private Article 43 of Yespartnership the contract shall PPP Law provides "The that: inclu No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes According to No n/a Law No. 2015-49 Yes of November 27, Article 2015 28 public-private onof PPP Law No.sector No contracts 49-2015 20 (Law n.and No n/a Yes No Article 27 of n/a YesDecree provides the BOT Implementation The PPP Legislation that No generally the project states company that may the assig No n/a Yes After defining Nothe private n/a No party as a n/a company, special purpose No Section 20(2) of the PPP Act No n/a Yes No According to n/aof the Concession Article 25(6) Yes Law, In accordanceof reorganization "in case No 10 with paragraphof of concessio the the Proc No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Regulation 43 of the CCR Section 2016 6 ofYes that regulates modification Regulation Standardization of PF2 43 No Contracts ofof the the CCR allows 2016 Concessionfor that contracts, regulates reg a "lock-in" ( No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to the Article 76 of the PPP n/a According Yes Regulatory Decree, tothe Article No contractor 76 of the shall PPP Law: "The request the P No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Article 54 of the PPP Law: Article Transfer 54 ofof the Yes PPP Law: shares, contributed Article Transfer 54 of No of the shares, capitalPPP portions, Law: contributed rights and Transfer of shares, obliga capital por No n/a Yes According toNo n/a the PPP Act, Yes "except Section 50(1), According as otherwise to Nothe PPP Act,in provided section Section forty-nine 50(2), "an No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes In accordance No with Section n/a 191 of the No Investment YesMyanmar Investment Commis n/a Rules, the No n/a Yes According toNo n/aart. 13(11), the PPP Law, According Yes "a transfer of the rights to No and the PPP Law, art. 13(12), obligations "a tran of a private p Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q40 Q39.1_3_TEXT Q40.1 Q40_1_TEXT Q40_2_A Q40_2_1_TEXT Q40.1_1_TEXT Q40_2_1_ Q40_2_1__3_TEXT 40. If yes, please Does the provide If regulatory the yes, relevant please legal/regulatory/standard 40.1. provide If yes, frameworkthe is If(including yes, relevant an approval legal/regulatory/standard 40.2. standard please contractual from provide If yes, a the government If which yes, relevant contractual provisions: please of the clauses) legal/regulatory/standard 40.2.1. authority, provide following contractual If yes, the other If expressly circumstances yes, is relevant there regulate than please a provisions: the legal/regulatory/stand threshold provide the procuring contractual aremodification specifically the forauthorit relevan which provis reg a or n/a Yes Yes Article 41 of Article the PPP Law under 10"Amendments" of Yes the PPP Law provides provides Article that: Yes 41 of the(1) that: The PPP The High LawParties under Economic Article shall 41"Amendments" of the determine Council PPP hasthe Law provide under the follo amen " n/a Yes Yes Article 31 of Pursuant the PPP Law regulates toYes Article the modification 23 of Pursuant DCMof No. to575/3013, the Articles Yes PPP/Concession 31(4) any Pursuant amendment and 31(5) to Articles of the contract. Modifications or transfer PPP 31(4) and Law: the to 31 of4. C n/a Yes Art. 58 of the Pursuant toNo YesDecree, Pursuant n/aConcession toNo the delegating Art. authority 58 of themay n/a use the conclusion Concession Decree, the delega of ame n/a Yes Yes According to Article 19 Article of the PPP 19.2Law, No of the PPP the PPP Law n/a may provides Nothat the be modified service/entity n/a or renegotiated; to that represents this the end a negotia n/a Yes No Article 9.i) of PPP Law, and n/a ArticlesYes 9.8, Annex Article 9.i) of I of Decree 118/2017, Yes PPP Law, states and Article Articles 9.i)PPP the of PPP 9.8, Agreement Annex Law, and Decre Article I ofshall co Article 15(3) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of PPP Law toYes Article <...> where Pursuant 17 of thePPP the successful to Law, Article Yes amendments applicant 17 of Pursuant PPP is made a Law, consortium toamendments No to Article 17 of legal of the conditions n/a the madePPP ofto persons, PPP Law, the the conditions amendments structure contracts: 1. of The ofmad equ con PPP n/a Yes According to Yes Section 19 of the National Section of the 2.1 Yes PPP National Guidelines Volume PPP Guidelines No 3, Practitioners' "Government n/a may initiate Guide that "if th states Modificati n/a Yes Yes According to According the Law on to Concessions, Yes the §108(1), art. 58 “substantial (3) of theto According Yes the Federal changes Law Budget to According on a concession Law and tothe Concessions, the contract §108(1), directive Law onduring Concess of the its "substan M n/a Yes Article 3.1.30 Pursuant toNo n/aof the BOT NoRules, the n/a No should include BOT contract n/a the terms and conditions n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Act, Not a formal art. No 12(e), approval, “the contracting n/a but an opinion No ofshall authority obtain the PPP n/aAuthority the opinion shall be and assistance sought. Thus n/a Yes Article 30 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law: No 1. An agreement n/a public-private onNo n/apartnership may be amended n/a Yes No Article 43 of the 2014/23/EU n/a Directive Yes on Concession Art. 62 of the Yes Royal contracts provides Decree Article for of 43 allowed 25 June of the 2017 modification: 2014/23/EU Dire Tho on the awar n/a Yes Yes Article 56 to Pursuant 60 of PPP Law addresses toYes article contract According 60 of PPP law provides: article Yes Non amendments. 55substantial of Changes the Art.57 PPP of contract Law the the relatingPPP to amendments the modification lawscope of the ma provides: ( ar n/a Yes Article 18 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the Sarajevo toNo Article Law(5) PPP 18 n/a of the Any Sarajevo No PPP Law: amendments n/a to (1) the concluded Prior PPP Agreements to the Decision on the p n/a Yes Yes The PPA Regulations, Section According 95 deals to Nothe PPA with the Regulations, n/a issue of contract Yes amendments, Section According 95(2), "a contract and to the Section amendment 96 - with shallth PPA Regulations b n/a Yes Yes Article 57 of Procurement the Public In the case of YesLaw (LawArticle extension of the57 term, of No 8.666/1993),the approval paragraph Public n/a Procurement 1a for provides 'qualification that Lawa for change (Law 8.666/19 in the extension' n/a Yes Article 137 Pursuant Pursuant toYes toYes Article Law: of the Concession 141 Pursuant (1) of the TheConcession toYes Article Law: concession contract 138 (2) Pursuant of the The mayGrantor to be Concession Article amended shall 137 Law: either when: (1) of the send 1. Con When t n/a Yes No Article 53 of the PPP Law n/a provides No public-private that « [t]hen/a n/a contract may be amended or No partnership n/a Yes article 36.15 Pursuant toYes of the Article PPP 37: The Yes Law, the contract Pursuant stipulations public-private toYes of ashall include article 37 clauses partnership Article of PPP the related 37 Law: ofcontract the to renegotiation the PPPstipulations Law may provide onlyacc o be Yes According to Article article 22 (3) of the 30 PPP of Yes Law: the PPPWithin Law Article provides: 14 (fourteen) Yes 30 of "The the PPP working PPPLaw Contract Article days30 provides: after shall of "The Nothe specify thePPP establishment PPP the Law Contract n/a conditions provides: shall and"The for specify registration PPP the the contract Contract conditio of the ameS sh n/a Yes Section 5 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law No(Law No.n/a 2006/012 of No n/a December 29, 2006, enacting the general r n/a Yes No level, Section On the Federal n/a 12.9.1 No n/a of the Contracting No provide,n/a Policy "Even though the Contracts Dire n/a Yes Article 40 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP ordinance: No n/a The may be extended duration No n/a only where the private par n/a Yes Yes Article 19 of the Concessions According Law to Yes articles and Articles 19, Articles 69 and 20 and 72 68, 20 Yes 69 ofbis the and the 70 Concessions of ofConcessions According the Concessions Regulation to Law Article andprovide Regulations. 19 article and 69 Articl for of A ma n/a Yes The Notice Pursuant Pursuant toYes of the Ministry toNo article 28 in n/a of FinanceThe on The Guidelines No Notice of the Ministry for n/aPPP Finance on article ofOperations, 28(1) o The Guideline n/a Yes Yes According to article 7 of According the PPP Law Yes to article no changes 26 According of PPP in the Law, to Yes ifarticle scope or duration there 7 is of to According be are the PPP any allowed change Law to article noin during changes the 13 and payment in the first the 18 ofts n/a Yes Yes Article 51 of Article the PPP Law provides: 51 of Yes the the duration PPP Law may provides: Article 46 be of extended, Nothe duration the Law PPP on the may n/a provides: basis be extended, a reasoned ofthe on the opinion basis public-private pa n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No According to article 14 n/a of the PPP Regulations, Yes modification According Yes to article of the12 contract According of the are regulated to article General Procurement 12 by of the Gene the Gen Law n/a Yes article 28 of Pursuant toYes the Art. 29 PPP of Decree the Yes PPPNo. 2018-358 Pursuant Decree of provides toMarch No article that any29 amendment 29, 2018 n/a of therelating PPP Decree, isto subject Public PPP Private contracts to Parm the form n/a Yes Yes Article 19 of the PPP Act Article outlines the Yes 19 of the mechanism PPP Act Article of amendments 19 of outlines Yes the mechanism the PPPto Act thecalls of Article contract amendments changes 63 of initiated theinConcession a scope toby the of contra Act a con either p pa n/a Yes Yes According to Procurement the PublicAccording Yes to the Act, PublicAccording Procurement §174(1), to Yes the "a contracting Act, Public §186(1), authority Procurement "a shall conclusion According to proceed the Act, Public of inaaccordance contract Procurem §174(1), b "a co n/a Yes No The EU Concessions Directive, n/a Yes and (2) art. 43(1) provide a According toYes detailed the EU Concessions of situations listAccording Directive, to the in which EU art. Concessions contract a 43(4)(c), n/a Yes article 43 of Pursuant toYes the PPP to Pursuant Law, Yes article the PPP Pursuant specifies 43 of to Law, the PPPtheNo article conditions any 43 modification ofin the n/a PPPof which it Law, can thethe PPP be modifications will have to proceeded to b n/a Yes Yes Article 75 of Law 47-20, Article the PPP of Yes 75Law,the and PPP Law: article Article 73 "Modification of73 the of Yes Decree the PPP contracts. Regulations: of No. 434-20, Article Any the 31.2"Of modification of PPP Law the modification 340-06ofregard Regulations reg the a P n/a Yes Yes Article 71 of the PPP Regulations Article 58 of (Executive No Decree n/a 1190) the PPP Regulations provides: No provides that n/a"(c) "Binding Modifications and and change definitive report on sus n/a Yes Yes PPP Law Article 7 of the Article provides, 7 of "The No PPP the Law Administrative n/a provides "The No Administrative Authority is entitled n/a toAuthority amend the conditions is entitled of to am n/a Yes Yes Article 64 of PPP Law regulates Articles 63 conditions and Yes 64 of PPP for Articles contractual Law establishes 63 and Yes modifications. the 64 of requirement Articles the PPP Law63 establish and of approval the from PPP Law 64 ofconditions fo the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No According to the Publicn/a Procurement Yes According Act §141(7), "whento awarding Yes the Public a concession Procurement According to contract, the Act, Public theProcurem contracti Chapter 2, Div n/a Yes No Section 29.4 n/a of the Procurement Directive No n/a "Where provides, n/a No it is called for, the contract may be amen n/a Yes of the Public Section 136No n/aContractsYes and Concessions Pursuant includes Actto Sectionprovisions Yes 136 Pursuant of theon Public changes to Contracts in Section 136 theof and procure Con the Pu n/a Yes Articles L 2194-1 Pursuant toNo n/a and R.2194-1 Yes R. 2194-7 et seq. Public Yes of theof the Public Acquisition Articles Acquisition R. 2194-8 Code, Code modifications provides of the Public are thatpo an A n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 22 of Pursuant the PPPtoYes Article Law: 1. Parties 22 of Pursuant the PPP shall have to Law: No the Article 1. right Parties 22to of n/a shall the PPP make an amendment Law: have the1. right Parties to make to a public shall an hav n/a Yes No According to n/a the PPA, §154(3), "as Yes for other matters, the to According Yes following the PPA, provisions §132(1)(3), According to "material shall the apply PPA, for§132(3)(2), the award changes to a n/a Yes Yes According to Sections 61(1)(2)(3) According of to NoSections the 61(1)(2)(3) n/a PPP Act, 2020 (Act of Nothe PPP 1039): Act, (1) A n/a contracting 2020 (Act 1039): (1) A authority or private contract n/a Yes No Article 51 of the Concessions n/a Law regulates Yes Article 51(1) modifications to Yes ofthe theconcession Concession Article 51(2) Law addresses of the contract during Concessions its changes life. in L n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 18 of the PPP Law Article provides No that 45 of the any PPP modification Decree n/a provides No of that amendments n/a contractual obligations, are subject deadlines or the to the pr opin n/a Yes Pursuant toYes article 80 of Pursuant the PP Law article and article toYes 80 of Pursuant 20 theof PP Law, its implementing to article Yesmodifications 80 of Pursuant thehave PP Law to toarticle regulations provide and be authorized article 80that of 20 contra theby PP of th L its n/a Yes Yes Budget The 2017 General AnyProvisions contract No stipulate n/a that modification must any modification No first have theof approval n/a and investment contract entity, of the regulatory includ n/a Yes Yes According to Article 141 Inof case Public theof Yes the procurement Procurement According Act:1) to procedures Yes The Article initiated 141 provisions According of byof the certain this to chapter PublicArticle Procurement shall contracting 141apply of authorit Act: the Pu to t 1 n/a Yes Yes General Rule 225(xiv)(a), Financial Rule 225(xiv)(b) Yes Rules, of2017 Rule provides 225(xiv)(a), the General that No the Financial General Rules, terms n/a of Financial a PPP 2017 provides contract, Rules, that 2017 when provides mater including the n/a Yes No is no detailed In general, there n/a guidance No on the n/a No issue of modifying n/a agreement after it was signed a PPP n/a Yes No Article 56 of the Roads n/a Construction No n/a indirectly Bylaw although n/a No so about contract amendments, provide n/a Yes No of the Government Article 9(Fifth) n/a No Contracts Instructions n/a No provide n/a circumstances for modifying the dura n/a Yes Noof the EU Regulation 43 n/a Concession Yes 2017 states as follows: Article of 29.3Yes "Modification the Contract Regulation of concession 43 of Template provides the contracts EU a Concessi proced duri n/a Yes No Tenders The Mandatory n/a RegulationNo provides inn/a on functions Section 8ANo of the Tenders Committee that n/a n/a Yes Article 175 (1) Yesof the Public Pursuant Contracts article toYes Code 165 regulates (6) and175(1) Article article the Yesof 182(3) different the Public changes of Pursuant theContracts Public that tocan Contracts Article occur Code 175 provides during (4) of Code, for the the ea n/a Yes Yes According to According the PPP Policy, Section to Yes 8.0, PPP the Policy, According "change in Section the contract to No8.0.1, the environment "<…> n/a Procurement a formal Handbook, is inevitable, and well-structured Volume the given 2, ap lo Sec n/a Yes No of the Contract Provision 2-1-2 n/a Guidelines No n/a deals Nochanges, n/a with design change of design. Furthermore, t n/a Yes Yes Article 16 of There the PPP Law are which provides three Yes cases: that-:Article "a. The Approval Council 16 the Higher ofYes PPP of Ministers Law Article Committee provides: 16(B) may, is "A. of uponrequested the The the PPP recommend Law as per Council state of MA n/a Yes Article 49(1) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP No n/a Law, PPP Contract No may n/a by the mutual agreement of t be amended n/a Yes Yes Section 72 of the PPP Act Section provides: 72 of No the (1) A party PPP Act n/a to provides: (1) agreement a projectNo A party n/a to intending a project to make any amendme agreement intending n/a Yes Yes in Article This is regulated According 15 of the to NoArticle PPP Act60 (1) n/a ofThe the PPP Basic No Plans concessionaire shall regarding n/aprepare a detailed implement amendments to the Con n/a Yes Yes responsibilities One of the main According to of No the Article PPPC is, 17 of n/a pursuant the PPP to NoArticle Law, 17n/a the PPPC (2.10) has to of the PPPand review approve Law, reviewing n/a Yes Article 35 of Yes the PPP Law The Higher Committee provides,No "The Partnership n/a must approve Agreement No such amendments shall n/a include the according followingto particula inArticle 36 n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 48 of Article the Law on Investment 25 (c) Noof the Procurement provides: n/a Regulation AssignmentNo of rights or provides n/a transfer of No that contracts business according shall n/a contain, "the conditions to a concession for t agreeme n/a Yes Yes Article 63 of the PPP Law Article regulates Yes 64 of the the regime PPP Law Article provides for concession 63(2) Yes for of the PPP the necessity PPP contract Article Law defines amendments: 63(5) of of changes obtaining theapproval PPP (1) toAthe concess Law prov scop for PP n/a Yes No According to the PPP Law, n/a art. 10(9), No"<...> then/a Partnership No n/a Agreement shall include the following: <...> n/a Yes Yes Article 60 of Pursuant the Concessions to Law provides Yes Article 37 of Article a list of compulsory the 62 of Yes Resolution the Concessions on clauses PPPPursuant to be <...> Law If during to included regulates Article the in period 62modification the concessio of of Con the part n/a Yes Yes Article 34 of Pursuant the PPP Decree which toYes article addresses Pursuant theamendments 9 ofthe toNo PPP Law and to article article 34 then/a of 34 Decree PPPof Contract Decree 2017-149, and 2017-149, a modificatio states modific that the n/a Yes No According to the PPP Manual, n/a Yes #5.4:According Procedure to No How to manage the PPP request n/ato revise Manual, Procedure & renegotiate #4.1: How PPP to P co n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 35 of Pursuant the PPP Law is related toYes article to contract Pursuant 35 of the PPPto Law, Yes modification. article an approval 35 of Pursuant the required isPPP Law, to article important from of the 35the modific unit in c PPP n/a Yes No Section 46(2) of the PPA n/a provides that Yes any amendment to Yes the Section 8.5.22 of contract, the PPP Section other Guide than adresses 46(3) of the changes change PPA which in Serv do n further p n/a Yes Articles 117Yes to 120 of the Article PPP 122 Yes and Law of the Articles PPP Regulations: Article 117 to 122 117 Yes "When of the of the PPP PPP amendments Article Law for allow 117 the to of Regulation modification athe public-private PPP allow regulate to for the par mo th incre n/a Yes Article 33(1) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP Yes Law, if during Pursuant toYes Article the active period35of ofthe thepublic-private Concessions Pursuant to ArticleLaw, partnership 35 of any the modico Con n/a Yes No Law, art. The Concessions n/a22 is devoted No to then/a issue of duration n/a No of a concession contract and extension n/a Yes Yes According to Article Law, the Concessions 71 ofNo Part the VI, PPP Lawn/a Articledoes 43(2)(15) stipulate not No that and (16), n/a “the explicit Concession Contract permission shall co or consent n/a Yes No Article 23 of the PPP Law n/a specifically Noaddresses amendments, n/a n/a be initiated by any party to t No which may n/a Yes No Article 21 (4) of the PPP n/a Law provides No that then/a No amendment n/a or revision of the main contract follows the n/a Yes Section 53 n/a Pursuant toNo Yes of the Public According Procurement Act, Unless to No otherwise section of provide 53n/a the Public forProcurement in procurement Act, u co n/a Yes Article 13 (1) Pursuant toNo n/aof the DBFM Yes Standard This is regulated Agreement, under Yesthe Parties Pursuant Article can only to change Article 2.163g of the 2.163e this Public inProc conn Agreeme n/a Yes No The Standard PPP Contract, n/a Part 12 No n/a "Changes", No Sections 39 with the issue of a contract chan to 48 dealn/a n/a Yes Yes Article 54 of Articles 54 the PPP Regulation and establishes Yes 55 of the According unilateral PPP Regulation toagreement the art. Yes 55 indicate According modification ofthat the PPP the toRegulation, the of the art.PPP Ministry of 55Finance the of contract amou the h PP n/a Yes Yes Article 45 of Art the PPP Law provides 46 of the Yes : contract Article provides46that of PPP LawcomplementaryNothe any to a amendment PPP Law n/a partnership provides is contract previously : (...) Modifications authorized may be concludb m n/a Yes Yes 2.6 of the Part 3, Section According ICRC National to NoSection Policy 88.3 on n/aof the PPPs Procurement 2008Noprovides as n/a Procedures Manual: PPP follows; "Because Bureau The contract n/a Yes No Article 41 of n/aThe contracts the PPP Law: Yes regulated Article by41 of this Law the may Yes PPP Law be amended “Amendments Article by 41 of the concluding PPP to the Law an andanne Art Contract n/a Yes No According to the Standard n/a Bidding No Form for BOT, n/aPart 1 "General No n/a Conditions of Concession Contract", n/a Yes The PPP Law Yes contains an Contracts must Yes be entire chapter dedicated approved Articles by46, the theYes 47, topic, General titled: 48 of Comptroller the Chapter Articles PPP Regulation VIII 46,(Contraloría - Modification 47, 48deal of the with General) PPP of chang Reg o Contr n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 32 of Article 97 of PPP Law: "Unilateral modification Yes Decree 4183/204: Article of the97 "Unilateral of Yes Decree contract formodification 4183/20: the Article development 97 of of the Decree of "Unilateralcontract modification public-private 4183/20: Before"Up t of n/a Yes Yesof PPP contracts Renegotiation toregulated In order is Yes modify the inPPP Article 136 55 of of Yes contract, different thePPP the PPPLaw Regulations opinions Article and 136should of establishes articles 134 be the PPP to obtained: 138 Regulation that ofin(i) cas the A n/a Yes Yes Section 12.11 Section of the BOT Law IRR, 12.11 regarding Yes contract Section of the BOT Law IRR, variation: 12.11 regarding Yesof the A contract BOT contract Section Lawvariation variation: 12.11 IRR, regarding of may[…] be the BOT Upon contract approved due Law var di IRRb n/a Yes Article 46 of Pursuant toNo n/a the Concession Yes Law, It Pursuant toYes is forbidden to make Article 46 of any Article changes the 46 of to the Concessionthe Concessions Law, contractual It shallLaw pr be n/a Yes Article 20 of Yes the PPP Law The negotiation contains specific Yes committee rules Pursuant submits governing toYes article the theissue 313 of reportPursuant of on unilateral the thePublic tomodifications Article Contracts negotiation 313 process (1) Code of the with (d) and 18,P n/a Yes No Article 17 of n/a the PPP Law: "The PPPYes Contract shall include, Article 80 ofin Yes the particular, TendersArticle Regulation the 80 of the following: provides, ... Tenders 5- Selling Regulat "Upon rec price n/a Yes Article 36 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Yes GEO, Article the 17(3) public-private Articles PPP of the100 Yes to GEO, partnership 109any of the modification contract Pursuant can to Article Concession ofLaw be the modified 102 discuss public-private the thisCon ofonly iss in n/a Yes of the PPP guidelines Section 6.5 Yes Section 6.5allows No provides that n/a post-agreement the contracting negociation. No authority Section n/a 6.5 shall inform provides RDBthat the the in case con n/a Yes No Section B.12 n/a Price Adjustment Provisions No n/a of the No Guidelines n/a Procurement GWGS provid for Government Yes Articles 14.3 Articles and 25.1 of the PSP8.3, Law21.1 Yes and 22 regulate Articles the of transfer the 8.3, PSPYes Law of ownership 21.1 and 22 regulate Article of the structure themodification 130.1.d PSPNoand ofrequires Law The theand assignment Implementing n/a extension an approval of of the Regulations the ofPPP the PPPcontract. Ministry contract.Ac of of the P Ar n/a Yes Yes Article 117 of Pursuant the PPP Decree toYes provides Article the117 conditions od PPP Article of Decree, 118 provides modifications Yes any for amendment Article aof new theaward partnership 118 of the during procedure implementation PPP contract when Decree pro th duri n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Law, According Chapter toIV, Yes the Article PPP Law, According 50, "at Article the request 50, to Yes the "if changes PPP of aLaw, public The to PPP aor public Law, a private Chapter IV, contract Chapter Article partner IV, are 50,Article or made "at ba athea n/a Yes No According to Section 15n/a of the PPPNo Act, (1) ... an/a No shall set PPP Agreement n/aout the extent to which a priva n/a Yes No of the PPP Section 4.1.20 n/aHandbook No n/a contracts provides that n/a Noshould be capable of change. However, fo n/a Yes Yes The Public Procurement The Act, Art. I,Yes conclusionPartfrom I, §18 regulates According the situations toYes the Public Public Procurement of Act, an According Procurement §18 (1)(d)(2) amendment Act, of to the and Public aArt. contract, §18 Procurem I, (1)(e) Parta is § I,fra n/a Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Act, Article Yes 60(1), According to Yes the "a concession contract Concessions According may be amended Act, Article to the Concessions 60(1), during conce "aits Act term n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Manual, No Section n/a No the development 11.4.6(3), "with n/a of the [Contract Mana n/a Yes Yes Amendments According to to a PPP Agreement Yes may theonly section be executed 16.8.2 ofto According the No bythe the Treasury accounting PPP n/a Regulation, officer Standardized Provisions, the or accounting section autho prior written 50 app n/a Yes et seq. 255Under Articles 203Yes some and 262 regulate Yes circumstances Articles the203-297 modification of contract Yes of approval from the forArticles other LCSP workcontain concessions. entities 205 of is the procedures required. LCSP Articles regulates and 203-2 con Accord n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes Article 36 of Article the PPP Act provides 36 of that the"(1) No PPP Act No n/a amendment provides that No shall be "(1) made No n/a amendment to the terms shallset made be out to the in the P n/a Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Act, Chapter Yes §8, "a concession 14,According Yes to the Concessions contract According may Act, to be changed Chapter the Concessions 14, without lau Act §14(3), "a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Article 38 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law: No 1. An Agreement n/a Noset out the shall n/aextent to which a private partn n/a Yes stipulates under The PPP ActYes The PPP Sections ActNo stipulates under n/a 7A and 20 thatSections contract No 7A and 20 n/athat shall amendments contract be approved amendments sha by the P n/a Yes Yes47 of the Under Section PPP Act,to Pursuant inYes Section the case where 46 of the anPPP According investment to Act, NoClause contract 3 case In the n/a of the the Characteristics amendment amendment necessary, is of Amendme the th PPP co n/a Yes No According to Annex II Point n/a (u) to the No PPP Law, n/a Nominimum amongst the requirements of the PPP agreem n/a Yes Article 43 of According the PPP Law providesto Yes that: "The Article 44public-private Article of the PPP 44 paragraph Law, No a modification 4 of n/a partnership the contract of contract PPP shall No provides Law include can n/a be that essential conducted “[a]ny modification without clauses, a competi of the c in compliance n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No Article 62 of PPP Decree n/a No. 2016-772 No (Decree No. 2016-772 n/a n/a 2016, about the conditions an No of 20 June n/a Yes Yes Article 18(1) of the BOTAccording implementation to Yes Article 12 According Decree the Highway to of provides No that Article PPP regulation Regulation, 12 of the n/a Highway of amendments projects PPP may should be prepare be in Regulation, p n/a Yes Yes According to Section 26(8) According of the PPP to No Act, "the Section n/a 26(8) [PPP] of the agreement No Act,shall PPP "the only [PPP] n/a be agreement or varied amended shall be a only with n/a Yes Article 17 (4) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP NoLaw: "a public-private n/a No n/a partnership contract may be amended or te n/a Yes No Article 30 of the Dubai n/a PPP Law provides, No Partnership "Then/a No n/a Committee may, after obtaining approval fr n/a Yes Noof the CCR Regulation 43 n/a 2016 states: Yes "Modification of concession Regulation Yes 43 of the CCR contracts Regulation 2016 during 43 of states: their "Modification theterm CCR 2016 43—(1)re of c n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes The PPP Law Yes has a chapter According to Yes specifically Article dedicated 47 Article of the PPP 47 Modification to the Law Yes of theand PPPArticle Law Article andregulates 71 Cession to 73 47 of the of the ofthe possibility PPP the Contract. PPP LawDecree regulat incl ofIt a is n/a Yes Yes According to Article 29 According of the PPPto Law, No <...>29 Article the n/a ofPPP PPP Law: No - Amendment, theagreement n/a may be amended, modification, or terminat supplemented, or te n/a Yes No Tenders The Government n/a No in Section Act provides n/a4 under "Execution Yes The of Government Government Tenders Act Contracts": Eve (1) pro n/a Yes Yes Article 50 of Article the PPP Law: 50 of Modification Yes the or PPP Law: Article revision of 50 PPPof Modification No contracts the or PPP 1. Law: n/a Modification revision Modification of PPP contracts of a or revision PPP With of 3.project con PP resp n/a Yes According to the PPP Act, Yes According Section to 54(1), No "without the Public n/a Procurement prejudiceNo to section Act, Section n/a sixty 77three, (1), "An agreement shall anamendment or vas n/a Yes Yes 81 deals The PPA, Section with the According toYes issue the Investment of a variation Accordingof to procurement Yesthe PPA, Guidelines, Section Section According contract: 138, 81(2), "if the "(1) to "the total theAny PPA, parties project variation Section to a of costpro a 81( No with Section In accordance No Investment n/a 191 of the n/a Rules, the No Myanmar Investment n/a No n/a prior approval is required if Commission's n/a Yes According toYesthe PPP Law, According toYes art. 13(2),the "a [PPP] PPP Law, Theart. PPP13(6), agreementLaw,No mayart. "a be change 13(3) amended to in(6) n/a theregulate essential with the consent a terms change of of of athe a publi es [PPP] Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q40_2_B Q40_2_2_TEXT Q40_2_1__4_TEXT Q40_2_D Q40_2_4_TEXT Q40_2_C Q40_2_3_TEXT Q40_2_E Q40_2_5_TEXT A change inIf and please elaborate: yes, the risk please allocation A provide change the of inIf the yes, contract. relevant financial legal/regulatory/ A provide please and/or change economic in the the If yes, relevant duration standard please balance legal/regulatory/standard A provide ofcontractual the change of the contract. in the contract the If yes, relevant provisions: agreed please legal/regulatory/stand price provide or tariff the relevan contractual provis or annu No not process The Entity shall Yes in price n/a any increase Article that41 exceed Yes of 15 the PPP % of Article the Law under value 42 of Yes the PPP "Amendments" totalLaw payment Article provides provides by 41 of that: the that: the Entity (1) PPP (1) The An Law and/ Parties under or may Entity sh " tota Yes 20% threshold Article 32(4) Pursuant toNo n/aand (5) ofNo the PPP Law, n/a No the contracting n/a shall request prior approva Authority n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes article 138 Pursuant of Presidential article toYes Decree 138 Pursuant nº of Presidential toan 15-247, article amendment Decree 136 nº Preside can be of 15-247 n/a No n/a Yes No Article 19 of n/aWhen, during the PPP Law: Yes the execution Article 18 of the of partnership the contr PPP Law states t Nofor the value The threshold Yes is 20%Section n/a of a change of the value 7, article Yes of a 9, PPP contract. Article Annex Decree I of 4.d) Yes of the 118/2017 PPP Lawsets states Article 9.6 the the terms of the PPPDecree to preserve 118/201 Agreement sh the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes Yes Yes No or 10% n/a Euro 5,548,000 YescontractAccording of the original value. to the Law on Yes According Concessions, to No §108(1), the n/a Law on "substantial Concessions, §107, "a changes a conces tocontracti n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Art. 67. A modification may be made n/a Yes Art. without a new68 of the NoRoyal Decree procurement n/a of 25 procedure when June Yes the 2017 onArticle amount ofawarding the 43 of this modification the and general is less 2014/23/EU Dire tha rules No The non-substantial n/a modification Yes not change does the Art. 56 of overall the Yes PPP Law forbids nature of the contract Article forof 55 substantial No theand PPP law then/a possible provides modification increase : changes whichin can made be the constit to the price do n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No 15% of the Not more than price for a single n/a original No n/a amendment No n/a for a series and 25% According to the PPA Regulations Yes of amendments. n/a Yes Article 10 of Yes the Concession Article 10 provides Law of Yes the Concession thatThe the PPP Law Law provides initial Yes establishes economicthat balance Article the that initial of 9, the the PPP economic contract paragraph contracts 2, balance must ofmust the beof con alw Cont Yes The value of Pursuant the amendment is below toYes Article the 136 Pursuant of thethreshold, European toYes Concession Article below Law: 123(4) (1) 10of A Pursuant percent concession the to Concession No Article of thecontract value 34Law, of n/a the may ofin the Concession case be concession, of modified a breach Law: only andof does (1) in the Any the eco no coca n/a No n/a Yes Article 53 of Yes Pursuant the PPP Law provides toNo that Article 46 of « [t]he public-private the PPP Law,partnership n/a contra the duration of th 20 No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 41 of the PPP Law Article states: of the 30 "The PPP PPP Law provide Contract shal n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 40 of Pursuant toNo the PPP ordinance: The duratio n/a 0.15 No n/a No n/a Yes According to Yes article 70 Article 71 of the Concessions of the Concession Reg Regulations: 1. n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a 0.2 No n/a Yes Article 5 and Yes 27 of Law According 80 of 1993 No to establishes article 7 of n/a that PPP Law no shall the contractors have changes in the the ris n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 51 of n/a the PPP Law provides: the duration may be n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Nofor the value The threshold Yes is 50%According n/a of a change toNo of the original article value ofn/a 14 a PPP. of No the PPP Regulations a change in the economic balanc n/a n/a No n/a Yes Art.26 of the Yes PPP Decree provides: Pursuant article toNo the contract 28 of n/amay the provide PPP Decree, for PPP revision clause contracts m YesamountsArticle The threshold to 10% 7 of ofthe the Yesinitial concession PPP Regulation Article 19 builds contract ofYes the PPP value. upon Act theArticle definition calls changes 7 of of No the PPP in economic Regulation n/a substantial changes balance builds from contract the the aupon a Act "substa and PPPdefinition Nofor the value The threshold n/a of a change Yes is the lower According of theNo to EUR the Public 5 548 n/a 000 ProcurementofAct, or 10%No original n/a value the §174(1), of a concession. "a contracting authority shal Nois 50% ofn/a The threshold Yes the original contract value According if a concession to Nothe EUwas n/a Concessions awarded Directive, by No art. a grantor for 43(4)(b), n/a the pursuit “in any of an event […] a activity mo not l n/a No n/a No n/a Yes article 40.2. Pursuant toNo of the PPP Law, only the additio n/a No According to n/a article 31.2 of Law 340-06 No the procuring n/a Yes entity Article can modify, reduce 49 paragraph or No I of increase n/a up Law to twenty 340-06five states that the percent dura (25%) o n/a Yes No Article 71 of n/a the PPP Regulations (Executive No n/a 1190)No Decree n/aModifications and changes, in provides: "(c) n/a No n/a Yes No PPP Law Article 7 of the n/a provides, "The Yes Administrative of the PPP Article 7Authority entitled isLaw to a provides 0.2 No n/a Yes Articles 63 and Yes 64 of the Articles PPP Law and Yes 64 ofconditions 63 establish the Articles PPP Lawforestablish 63 changes and 64 ofconditions in the the net PPP pr fo Law n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No for the value The thresholds Yes are the n/a of a change EUR 5 382 According No to the 000Public and 10% Procurement n/a NoAct,value of the original n/a of a concession. §123(2)(2), “a modification is conside n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No The value of n/a the change Yes referred to Pursuant in paragraph shall be toless Yes Section 10Pursuant than136 of the per Public cent to ofNo Section the Contracts 136 value n/a of and the of the original Concessions Publicservice Contracts Act: or supply and The Con co contra Yesmay be amended Thee contract 2194-7 Yes of the Article R. however, theArticle amount Public R.of 2194-7 the Acquisition Yes amendment ofCode theR. provides 2194-7 must Public Acquisition of be that Yesbelow an the Public amendment Code 10% Acquisition provides R. 2194-7 of theisamount of substantial, that the an Code Public provides of amendment theAcquisitio in particula thatco initial an is n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 28 of Pursuant ResolutionArticle No. 426: toYes 221. of Pursuant the In the PPP cases to Law: Yes Article provided 2. The 22(1) amendments for Pursuant inthe of Law to Article thePPP Law, toand be parties made Paragraph 22(1)to shall of publ 2 ha athe P of Nofor the value The threshold Yes is the lower n/a of a change According of the toEUR Nothe PPA, 5,548,000 §132(1)(2), n/a or 10% No of the original "material changes n/a value to a public of contract during a concession. n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Nofor which The threshold amendments n/a Article Yes are allowed amounts 51(4) Yes of up Concessions tothe Article to 10% 17Law of theof original Yes the regulates PPP Law Article substantive provides contract value. 51(1) <...> changes of the Concessions to the Content conce L of Partn n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 42 of Yes the PPP Decree provides Article No 42 of the that PPP PPP n/acontract a Decree provides canthat be extended if the the contract m No cannot The modification be of more n/a Yes than 30%Pursuant of the initial toYes article Pursuant value.80 of the PP Law toYes article and article 20-2 of 20the of its PursuantPP to implementing regulations, article 18 of regulatio PP regul modificat n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No for works 10% of the value Yes n/a concessions. According to No n/a 141 of the Article 141(6) n/a No Public Procurement Act:6) Apart from the n/a No n/a Yes Rule 225(xiv)(b), No General n/a Rules, 2017: Financial No the financial and other effects i n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes The Roads Construction Bylaw pr n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No of the Government Article 9(Fifth) n/a Contracts Instruction No Any increase n/anot exceed in value may Yes 10% of the Article value 43of ofthe EU original Yes Concession Article concession 2017 43 of provides NoEU Concession (9) that contract. n/a a2017 newprovides (9) that a is award procedure ne new n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No If the modification n/a 10% ofYes is under the value of Articles the initial No concession, 165(6) and 182(3) n/a then of a new the No Public procedure Contracts n/a is not needed. Code provide for the renegot n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Provision 2-2-7 Yes of the Guideline 4-4Agreement Provisionfor regulate of the Guideline for Yes Article 16(B) Law states of the PPPArticle No that 41(N) of the a new PPPtendering Regulations n/a Noprovides process is required that n/a thein PPP Yes the event that contract Article should amendment(s) address 41(F) of risk or the change(s) PPP Regulatio allocation to t struc n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 48 (3) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP Law, the period of v n/a Yes Yes Section 72 (2) (iii) of the Section PPP Act 72 (2) No(i) and provides: (ii) [...] n/a (2) of An PPPNo Act provide: theamendment, n/a variation [...] (2) or An waiver to a project amendment, agre variatio n/a No n/a Yes Yes pursuant This is regulated Article to Article 60 (1) 60 of (1) Yes PPP theof the Article Basic PPP Plans Basic 60 Plans of the (1) PPP (1)explicitly if mentions Basic it Pla ' is inten n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 9 (2) Pursuant toNo of the PPP Law, upon approval o n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 36 of n/a provides, this Law further Yes "The Public Article Entity 36 of this may Law further amend prov the terms n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 25 of the Procurement Re Yes Article 63(5) Law provides of the PPPArticle 63(2) Yes offor the PPP two Article thresholds Law classifies 63(2) that Yes ofchanges the PPPa require to Article Law new the concession risk 60 of provides allocation Yes the thatagreement: PPP Law changes ofArticle the regulates contract to 63 one theof economic set the the as bymaterial PPP changes theLaw equilibrium Cabinet in changes regulate theand du n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yesfor individual The threshold amendments Article 62 of Yes the Concessions is upPursuant to 10Lawto percent prohibits Yes Article 62 of the initial of modifications Pursuant theagreement Concessions toof Yes Article thevalue contract Law, 62 of and Price amendments the that the revision Concessions total would clauses that sum materially of Law, would are the changes amendm express lead alterto th t n/a Yes Yes Article 29 of Pursuant decree 2017-149 requires toYes article PPP the34 Article of Decree contract 292017-149, of to Noincludea decree clauses modification n/a related 2017-149 requires cannot to:the 6. the PPPconditions contract modify the es n/a Yes No According to the PPP Manual, n/a Yes #4.1:According Procedure to Yes How to Prepare, the PPP Conduct, Manual, According and Manage to the PPP Procedure #4.2: Contract Manual, Reviewin Ne Pro n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Modification n/a are possible of the contract Article Yes if price increase 35 of Yes the is PPP 30% below Law Article forbids of the 25initial modification of the No price. PPP Law n/a when allows change inbalance theaeconomic of th the duration No to the contract An amendment n/a No that will increase n/athe contract No value by n/a No more than n/a 25 percent shall require fresh procurement the first 2 years 20 % duringYes of the According toYes contract. article 117 According "No After the modification first to Yesarticle two shall 117 years modification Article involve of the121 risk PPP of Yes Law, transfer can theexceed PPPfrom Law Article Section the 5,one establish regulates 20 119 party percent ofthe the to the the possibility PPP restoration but they other Lawrequire in regula of of ex term YesamountsPursuant The threshold to to 10% of Yes Article the initial 35 of Pursuant the Concessions contract toYes ArticleLaw, value. 35 of Pursuant a the change Concessions inNo to the risk Article 35 allocation Law,of n/a a the change amounts in the economic Concessions a substantial toLaw, contra thebalanc n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a Law, art. 22.3, "in the even the Concessions n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 23 of the PPP Law n/a Noaddresses specifically these circumstances, which ma n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 39 (1) PPP Regulations provides that th (a) of the n/a n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to Section 56 of the Public Procurement Act, ( n/a No over 10% An amendment Yes contract n/aof the initial Pursuant value requires toYes Article 2.163g, a new tender Pursuant para process. 3b toNo Article of the Public n/a Procurement 2.163g, para 3b of the Act, Public a new contr Procure n/a Yes No According to n/a PPP Contract, the Standard n/a No Section 40.2, “the Yes party sending the Change According Standard to theNotice PPP must Co spec Nofor the value The threshold No is 25%n/a n/a of a change of the original No contract n/a budget. No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Article 46 of the PPP Law n/a : (...) Modifications provides No n/a may not be substantial. F n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Clause 88.3Yes of the Procurement Procedure Clause 88.3 Manual prov of the Procurement P No Article 41 of n/a the PPP Law provides Yes that in the event Article of a change 119 Nothe PP of in the Law n/a essential explicitly No addresses terms of thean/a contract, change in the economic which provide were notbalance n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a Bidding Form for BOT, Part 1 " the Standard Yesfor the value The threshold of a Regulations The PPP Yes modificationhave is Theunder PPP 20% of Regulations the Section Yes value of 2of a deal Chapter Article PPP contract. 65 VIII of specifically the Yes theGeneral PPP with contractual Law: Articles regime "Term.46, for balance The risk 47,PPP 48 allocation of andcontract compensatio the PPP and will con Reg h n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Unilateral modification of the contract: n/a Article 97 Yes The maximum amount of No of these Decree n/anew "Unilateral 4183/20: investments Yes modification may Article 95 ofof not exceedthe Decree 15% contract. (fifteen 4183/20: percen "Ta Before t costs surpass If additionalYes 15%134.1 Article of the Yes of the PPP original Article investment Regulations 134.1 amount Yes establishes of the PPP of the Article Regulations that project, any 52 of contract No athe newPPP establishes tendering modification Law n/aand process that the article should parties 38 is possible. aim of could the toPPP agree preserve to Regu Yes A cap on the variation allowable Section 12.11 during Yes BOT Section Law of the entire IRR, contract, 12.11 regarding Yeswhich of the shall contract BOT not Section Lawexceed IRR, variation: 12.11 Yesten regarding of the A contract BOT percent contract Section Law (10%) IRR, variation: 12.11 variation ofregarding the of may original A be contract the BOT contract approved Project Lawvaria IRR var b C Noamountsn/a The threshold to 10% of the Yesinitial contract Pursuant value. Article 46(6) toNo n/a2 of the Concession Yes Article Law, 46(1) - The of the Concession modification La of a conce Yes According to Pursuant Article 313 to (1) (d) of Public Yes Article 282 Pursuant of Public Contracts CodetoContracts 18, Yes Article 282 Code modifications Pursuant of18, Public of - Restoration to Contracts 1 the contract Yes Article 282 Code motivated ofAccording (3)18: theof financial 1 Public - byFinancial to a Contracts change Article balance rebalance of of 300Code circumsta of PPP 18 con of t P Public No Upon recommendation of the committee, n/a Yes the Article head may, 22 of Nothe for public PPP Law interest, n/a provides No that amend quantities "[t]he Partnership n/a or volume of the concluded Agreement a may beco Yes Can not be changed more than by Pursuant Yes Article to10% as per 106the Pursuant of the Concession toYes Article Concession Law.Law: 106 Pursuant (2) of the A modification toNo ArticleLaw: Concession 105(1) of concession (2) (c) a n/a A modification of the contract ofduring a concessio Concession the Law, va the n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes No Section B.12 Price Adjustment n/a No Provisions n/a of the Guidelines for Government Pro n/a No n/a No n/a Yes and 22 of the Articles 8.3 No n/aPSP Law, as well as Article 131 Noamountsn/a The threshold Yesinitial contract to 25% of the Article value. 118 of Nothe PPP Decree No for a new n/a provides n/atender procedure when the m Yes According to According the PPP Law, to ChapterYes IV, the PPP Law, Article According 50, Chapter "if to changes Yes IV, theArticle to a public PPP 50, Law, According contract "if Chapterto Yes are IV, changesthe to Article made PPP a public at 50, According the Law, contract "if Chapter request changes are IV, to of the to Article made aPPP a financier public at 50, Law, the "at contrac Chapte <...> requ the s n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Section 15 Pursuant of the PPP toYes Section Act, one of 15the The of the extension PPP cases Yes which of inAct, (1) the the ... PPP PPP According Agreement Agreement acontract to be may Section isamended shall regulated 15 setof is outthe when the PP under n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No A concession n/a be amended contract may Yes during According the term to of No contract the Publicn/a Procurement without Yes launching Act, Art. I, new Part a According procurement I, §18(1)(c), to the Public "a procedure, substantial if t Procurem Nois 50% ofn/a The threshold Yes the original According contract value to if a concession Yes the Concessions wasAccording awarded to Article No Act,by the a grantor PPP 60(1), Act, n/a for Article "a concession the 71(3), pursuit ofcontract "a an activity may duration not be of a lP n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes No According to n/a the section No Treasury 16.8.2 of the n/a Regulation, Yes According the relevant will treasuryto the PPP Standardize approve a materia 0.1 No n/a Yes According to Yes article 262 Article LCSP, of the270 Yes of any the LCSP modification Article foresees affecting the 270 ofmodification the the LCSP economic of the foreseesbt n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 36 of the PPP Act provides Nofor the value The threshold n/a of a change Yes is the lower According of theNo toEUR the Concessions 5 548 n/a 000 and 10% Act, Noof the14, Chapter n/a §9, value of a concession. original n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes Article 38 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant PPP Law: to Yes 1. An Agreement Article 41 of Pursuant the shall PPPto set Article Law,out thethe duration 38 extent of PPP to of th w Law n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No regulated This is explicitly n/aby Section 13 of the PPP Act:" n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Characteristics Yes of Amendment to Contract Characteristics Announceme of Amendment to n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a (u) to the Annex II Point n/a No PPP Law, amongst the minimum requirem n/a Yes According to Yes Article 44 According of the PPPto NoArticle Law, a modification 44 n/a of thr PPP of contract No provides Law be can n/a that conducted "A public-private without a competi partnersh n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No comments n/a No n/a Yes Article 17 alYes 2 of the PPP Article 2.6 49-2015 law No. provides of Decree that, No. 2016-11 n/a No n/a Yes No with the n/a In accordance calculation Yes method setIn out accordance with in Annex-1 theHealth of the PPP calculatio n/a Yes Yes According to Sectionany Section 26(9)(c), 26(9)(a) amendment No & (b) of to n/a the the PPP PPP Act Yes agreement Section should requires that 26(9)(a) the preserve project continues & "the continued (b) of to PPP the prov n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a 10 percent.No n/a Yes Regulation 43 Yes Regulation of the CCR Yes 2016: (9)43 A modification of the CCR Regulation 2016: of a concession (9)43.1 of the contract CCR of A modification duri a co 2016, n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No with the n/a In accordance Yes the 20% PPP Law, above According threshold toin NoArticle the unilateral 48 n/a of themodification PPP Law No a change n/a or the 50% in theor economic 30% whichever is appli and financial b n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a price of the If the in theNo original terms n/a n/a No exceeds 10%, than Yes a new tendering The Government No process Tenders n/a is required. Act provides in Section 4 unde n/a No n/a Yes Article 50 ofYes the PPP Law: "Modification Article Yes 50 of the PPPor revision Law: Article of50 PPP "Modification of contracts the PPP or revision 1. Modifica Law: of PP "Modif n/a No n/a Yes According to Yesthe PPP Act, According 54(1)(a), Yes Section to the PPP "without Act, According Section to 57, prejudicethe "the to PPP section duration sixty Act, art. at of54, a material n/a If there wasNo Yes change in acontract's nature According to No or scoprthe if there or PPA, n/a Section was a material Yes 80(4), "whereprice the Thetime PPA, deviation Section foror performance a price 80deviation dealsunder withinth a p e n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a No n/a Yes According to Yesthe PPP Law, Theart. PPP13(6), Yes Law, "a change art. to 13(3) According in(6) the essential to the regulate PPP terms a change Law, of ofathe [PPP art. es 12 Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q40.3 Q41_A Q40.3_1_TEXT Q41_1_TEXT Q41_B Q41_C Q41_2_TEXT Q41_D Q41_3_TEXT If yes, 40.3. Can the please 41. procuring/contract provide Does the the management If regulatory relevant yes, please legal/regulatory/standard 41.2. framework authority provide Material the modify If(including yes, relevant Adverse please a PPP legal/regulatory/standard 41.3. standard Government contract provide contractual Change contractual unilaterally? If yes, the in relevant provisions: the Action please Law. clauses) legal/regulatory/standard 41.4. provide contractual expressly Refinancing. the relevant provisions: address legal/regu contra the follo No n/a Yes No Article 43 of the PPP Law n/a provides No parties may that:(1) Then/a Noterminate a Partnership Contra Yes Yes According to Pursuant Article 31(2) PPP of the toNo Article Law, changes n/a 31(3) ofthe (b)to Yes PPP Law,which thecontract, modifications Pursuant are not toNo essential, to the 31(3) Article can (c) be contract of may done the beby conclude PPP Law, the Co No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo art. 48 of the n/a NoDecree addressing concession n/a Nomandatory content of the conc the Yes No According to n/a Article 18.1 of the PPP No n/a party No Law, the public n/a issue aNo may unilaterally request to reestablish the financ Yes Yes Article 9.i) of Article PPP Law, and 9.b) Yes Articlesof 9.8, PPP Law,Article Annex of Decree Istates the of 9.b No bid 118/2017, PPP specifications Law states states n/a the thebid and PPP Nospecifications Agreement tender documentsshall and shall tender regulate contain a cla th docum Yes Article17 of Pursuant toNo n/a PPP law<...>, No a PPP contract n/a shall No procedure No include then/a and conditions for unilaterally am Yes of Volume 2 Section 7.4 Yes of the National Sections 21 Yes of Volume PPP Guidelines 3 and 20 of Yes Volume provides 7 of that According Government the National to Yes initiated PPP Guidelines Section 20 of the modifications apply National to arePPP likel NSW iG No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No shall include The agreement n/a the provisions No n/a regarding No force majeure cases ( Article 3.1.17 o No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Act, n/aart. 26(3)(r), n/a No "without Noscope of sub-sections (1) and ( limiting the No n/a Yes Article 36(5) Pursuant toNo n/a Yes of the PPP Law, a private Pursuant partner, Article toNo 33 of the duly fulfilling obligations itsPPP und Law, If duri No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes article 54 of Pursuant toYes Art.72 the PPP of the Law: Yes each PPP Lawparty provides Section to the 7 : the public-private of the No Guidance public-private partnership note partnership requires cont the contrac No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 27 (1) n/a No of the Sarajevo n/a Law, No Concession when it is impossible for a party No n/a Yes The PPP Policy, Yes Annexure The PPP 2, Policy, No Section 21Annexure establishes n/a2, a clause Section 22 Yes in a establishes Summary of Standardized a clause C in a Sum Yes Article 58 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the Public toYes Procurement Article 5, "III" Article of Law 5.III (Law the PPPof Yes 8.666/1993), Law, the PPP PPP Law Article contracts the expressly public 5, III, must Yes of authority the provides contain PPPthat Law may provisions provides modify the contract contract that the PPPregarding No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 123 Pursuant of the Concession toYes Article Law: (1) of the 123 Pursuant TheConcession economic toNo Articlebalance 123 (1) Law: of The of the the Concession economic bal Law concession No n/a Yes No Article 45 of n/a the PPP Law indicates Yes that the PPP Article contract shall No Decree 84 PPP provides include thatregulating a provision “[t]he co Yes article 36.15 Pursuant toNo of the PPP n/a NoLaw, the contract n/a No shall n/a related include clauses to renegotiation according to a Yes No n/a Yes Article 30 of No n/a the PPP Law "The PPP Contract provides:Yes Article 30 shall of No specify the Lawconditions PPP the for the provides: "The PPPc Yes Section 5 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law n/a No(Law No.n/a 2006/012 of No n/a December enacting the general regulations 29, 2006, No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 43 of the PPP Ordinance n/a No : Then/a provides No may terminate the public-p public authority Yes Yes According to of the are article 19 There several Concessions Yes provisions LawArticle the Ministry in19 of the Concessions the Noof Public Concession Works n/a LawLaw may and Regulation No modify the establishes that referred characteristics "Theto forceof maje concession h the No n/a Yes Yes The Notice of the Ministry Article of Finance 2(3) Yes of NDRC Guiding on The Article Guidelines Opinions 36 of for YesPPP and the Operations, article 3(1) "Measures for article of the MOF Administ Guidi 24: In c Yes Yes Article 16 of Law Law 80/1993 sets 95 of 1890, Yes forth that Civil theCode, Article Law procuring2780 authority ofof No Law 1993 80 of allowed 1993, n/a 42 is(article and to inmodify case particular No law, theestablish refer contract to Force unilaterally the Majeure right onl a to res No n/a Yes Yes Article 58 of the PPP Law Article provides 58 of that the PPP Yes Law Article PPP contracts provides 15 may No that of the be terminated, PPP PPP contracts Law provides: in particular may be termin in th without p No n/a Yes No According to Article 117 n/a of the Procurement No n/a WhereNo Code: the amount referred to in the pr Yes Yes According to article 12 Regulated of the General in No Procurement article n/a 11 of General Law (referred Public No Procurement by article n/a 14 ofNo Law that the PPP specifies regulations) the of the rights the c procuri No n/a Yes Yes Article 25 (m) of the PPP Article Decree: 25 (m) Yes PPP contracts of the PPP Incontain, Decree: accordance inter PPP No with alia,Article as a shall contracts 26 of minimum, contain, theclauses PPPinter Dec a o No n/a Yes Article 4(4) Yes of the PPP Act Article states ofNo the 72 that the Concession contract n/a should Yes regulate Act provides for force the possibility majeure, <...> PPP of the co Yes Yes According to the PublicThe Procurement Public Procurement The Act YesAct, §100(1), Public “a is silent Procurement Yes on this contracting matter. The Act authority Public is However, may silent reserve Yes oncertain this inmatter. Procurementthe guidance Act tender is However, is documenta silent oncertain this m provided i No n/a Yes No According to n/a section 2 of the Standard Yes PPP Model According for Construction No to "the PPP the Standard Model for PPPcontract the in Con No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo article 39 of n/a the PPP Law, contracts set No the PPP n/a Noconditions within which the risk Yes Yes Article 72 of Law 47-20, Article the PPP of Yes 63Law,Law and 47-20 Article establishes article 75 of32 Decree No ofthat the No. Law in order 340-06 n/a 434-20, to be the considers PPP No considered Regulations actsvalid, or failure regulate the to comply theshall contract of cth possib No n/a Yes Yes Article 44 of the PPP Regulations Article 15 of (Executive Yes the PPP Decree Article Law 1190) 15 of establishes No states: the thePPP legal Law security establish "Suspension and of the the interven legal PPP co No n/a Yes No According to n/a Article 8 of the PPP Law, Yes "In caseAccording of the occurrence to NoArticle of of the PPP Law, 8unforeseen "In cas circumstan Yes Yes Article 63 of PPP Law regulates Articles 69 theYes right and 70of ofthe the Article PPP Law 61 of procuring regulate authority Yes the PPPconditions Law toArticle require establish for 61 oftermination No conditions the PPP variations inLaw the for incontract case establish the private of force and condition estab maje partne No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Section 49 of the Procurement Part of the Directive Yes provides, definition Article of force 49.1 majeure 55force of Nothein PPP Section majeureProclamation, results 49.2(a) from the an occu Proc ofregarding No n/a Yes Section 136 Pursuant toNo n/a of the Public NoContracts and Concessions n/a No Act: a contract and a fram Yes Article L2194-2 Pursuant toYes Article of L. the Public Yes of 2195-2 Acquisition the No Public specific Acquisition Code, Yes whenCode: the provisions under No procuring “The specific buyer the relevant entity provisions No[procuring unilaterally legal under framework entity] the makes relevant but a modific sever terminate th leg No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 63 of Article 63 of No the Ordinance, the PPP Force n/a majeure establishes Ordinance No fortermination is cause in case of d termination. No n/a Yes Article 30(9) Pursuant toNo n/a(d) of Resolution No 426, the contract, No. n/a No together with the principle No n/a Yes No The Standard Contract n/a for Highways, Yes According §27 deals with the issue to the Yes Standard of force majeure Contract and a third- for Highw No n/a Yes Clause 14 of No n/a the Third Schedule the PPP ActClause of Yes states 14 that ofat the No minimum, Third Schedule a PPP contract shal of the PPP A No n/a Yes Article 17(1) Yes of the PPPStandard Contractual Yes<...> Content Law provides Provisions: Standard of Partnership Contractual COMPENSATION Yes Provisions: EVENTS Contract. Partnershi 1.1 The1.1 PPO's Change No n/a Yes Article 3 of the No PPP Law defines Force n/a Article Yes Majeure and then 70 of considers the PPP it No Law regulates a cause the right for contract te No n/a Yes No Article 42 of the PPP Decree n/a provides Article Yesthat a PPP contract 42 of can Nothe PPP be Decree if extended the contract provides that ais No n/a Yes No Article 87 of the PP Lawn/a defines force n/a No majeure, No article 87-1 indicates the principal circumst No n/a Yes Yes PPP Law Article 9 of the Article states8.3.17 that extraordinary of Coalianza's Yes Article risks Operative 8.3.17 attributable No Manual states that to of non-foreseen amongst Acquisitionstender states the causes Yes Section 141(1) Pursuant toNo n/a of the Public No Procurement n/a <...>, the provisions Act No n/a this subtitle shall apply to any co of No No n/a Yes Yes is regulated Force Majeure Material in detail Adverse Yes government under A Change Chapter VI actions of in theLaw Model Yes are scenario contemplated Concession is usually andcovered addresu Agreement No n/a Yes No According to the Regulation n/a on PPPs, n/a a PPP agreement No art. 32 (2)(q), No (contract) shall conta No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a of the Article 12(Third) NoInvestments Law, the investor No n/a Yes of the Contract Article 36.1Yes Article Template 34 "Termination Yesregulatesfor contract Article Authority 30 "Change change YesDefault" in Law" due ofForce to the of the Contract Majeure Contract circu TempTe No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Article 106Article Pursuant toYes the and (12) of158 No Public 159 of the n/a Implementation Contracts if the contracting Code: Yes Pursuant Regulationauthority and toNo Article is required Article 107 (c) 106 of the (1) to of increase Public Contrac or de the Public C No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Policy, n/a Section No the contract 8.0, "<…>n/a Nomechanisms will typically includ No n/a Yes Yes Different provisions in the Provision Contract Yes 3-6 of the Contract GuidelinesProvision (For example, Guidelines 2-1-2 No provision ofrecognizes 2-2-9, material the Contract 3-6, Guidelines 5-3 govern di and 6 No n/a Yes Article 41(N) Noof the PPP RegulationYes n/a sets out the Article minimum 41(N) contract Noof the PPP terms Regulation that thesets cont PPP out t Yes of the PPP Pursuant Pursuant 46Yes Law, the PPP toYes Article contract should Pursuant 48(3) (1) of contain: the toYes Article PPP Law, 20) exceptional 48(3) the Pursuant period (2) of the cases of toNo PPP validity Item unilateral 159 of Law, of the ofthethe period contract refusal Model of validity PPP of to public- cont executeo No n/a Yes No Section 70(1) n/a of the PPP Act provides, Yes "(1) TheSection parties 70(1) to a No of the PPP project Act provides, agreement this Th under "(1) A No n/a Yes Force Majeure Instances ofYes are This is regulated dealt Nowith in Article under Article n/a 47 39 the Yes of(3) PPP of theAct PPP Decree and (Grounds Article for 39 of the No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 12 (3) of the PPP Law, up Pursuant toNo Yes Yes Article 35 of the PPP Law Article provides, 35 of "The the PPP Yes Partnership Law The PPP provides, Agreement Guidebook Yes "The Partnership shall (pp.Article include 231-235) Agreement 35 the of in Yes following the Annex shall PPP Law B on ininclude particular: provides, the Recommended the7."The Regulat Part following No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No Article 25 of the Procurement n/a No Regulation n/a that contracts provides No shall contain, "the conditi No n/a Yes No 62 of the Articles 63 and n/a PPP Law provide No n/a regulations No regarding force majeure:Article 63(3 Yes No Such right is based on the n/acardinal No rule used inn/a administrative n/a No contracts the administration can modify th whereby No No n/a Yes Yes Law under The Concessions Article Article 21 of 62 the Yes Partnership Article provides for the Agreement 41.2.5 possibility Yesof the of Partnership changing details the cases the Agreement concessio of exempt Yes Yesof the PPP Article 29 (26) Article Decree 47 of Yes the PPP states that Law the Pursuant contract indicatesYes force toshall article provide majeure 29 of the Pursuant asconditions PPP a cause Decree toYes article for (Decree termination. 29 (6) under which of 2017-149), PPP the Pursuant Decree Public the2017 to con a Entit No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Manual, According Procedure Yes to #2.12: the PPP Manual, According PPP Project Procedure to YesRisk the PPP #2.12: Identification, Manual, PPP Project a procuring Risk #2. Procedure Ide No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Yes Article 24 of the PPP Law Article requires force No 34 III. Of the majeure PPP n/a to be Law dealt indicates No with the private in the contract rights partner and in c indica No n/a Yes No Section 46(1) PPA provides (g) of the n/a Yesthat a procurement Change in law No is regulated contract by section shall include 8.5.23 the modalit No n/a Yes Yes According to article 92 Article of the PPP 19 of Law Yes the PPP Law Force Article Majeure regulates 19 must Yes of the be right the regulated PPP Law to the regulates by the PPP theContra right reestablishment No n/a Yes Yes According to Chapter 1 Pursuant of Annex to No Section 2 of the Yes 28 Pursuant Government of the Annex toNo Resolution Article of Order 33 paragraph No.143, No the 476,in the (1)PPP of case cont the P of No n/a Yes Yes According to the Concessions According Law, toart. the Yes Concessions 21.1.23, According "unless Law, otherwise Yes art. to the22.2.2, Concessions provided "an Authorized in Law, theart. lawEntity and i 23.2.2 No n/a Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Law, No n/a 43(2)(15) Part VI, Article Noand (16), “the Concession Cont No n/a Yes In accordance No with the n/a article 12 of No n/athe contract the PPP Law, No balance in the case of hardsh No n/a Yes Yes Article 18 of PPP Law establishes Article 15 of that Yes PPP Law risks provides Article arising from50 for force the No of majeure the mitigation PPP Regulations must of the assessed provide be risks in sh thattha No n/a Yes No According to n/a Article 11.7(C)(8e) of the Yes PPP Policy, According projectto NoArticle 11.7(C)(8e) agreement draft must the PPP ofinclude P me No n/a Yes Yes The DBFM Standard Agreement Under Schedule details Yes the the Under DBFM 1 ofsituationsSchedule that Standard Yes are qualified of the DBFM as a force 1 Agreement, Standard majeure multiple Agr types No n/a Yes Yes According to the Standard According PPP Contract, to Yes the Standard The Section 1, PPP Standard “extension Contract, YesPPP Section Contract, event means 8.2(a), Section any: <…> 48 deals (c) Fo “anything th Yes No According to of the PPP Regulations, Article 54 n/a Yes Article the procuring Yes 27 of authority the PPP Law Article iscontemplates entitled 27 of to No request the PPP a possibility Law one orfor more themodifica contemplates a po private Yes Article 11 of Pursuant toYes the PPP Article 50:Law The No :partnership The PPPn/a contract shall No contract mayexplicitly provide n/a grounds include No for the following termination, clauses related to: in particular (..- for: No n/a Yes Noof the National Paragraph 4.5 Yes n/a Policy on Public Private Paragraph Partnerships 2.6 No of thestates that National some Policy events on Publi No n/a Yes No Article 41 of the PPP Law: n/athe annex Yes Article contract may be41 concluded of Yes upon the PPP Lawthe states: initiative Annex the of to thg No n/a Yes Yes The Standard Bidding Form According for BOT, Yes to Part the Standard 1 "General According Bidding Conditions No Form to for the Standard of Concession BOT, Part Bidding 1 Contract", "General Co Form for B Se Yes Yes Article 45 of Article 3.7 the PPP Regulation establishes: of Yes the PPP General Article conditions 46 of Regulations, under Nothe PPP applicable definitions, Law n/a toprovides: contract provides for modification No "Force modifications. Majeure. of contracts The The followi PPP for cont No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Article 97 of Decree 4183/20: Article 99 "Unilateral of Nodecree 4183/20: modification n/a "Fortuitous of the No contract. n/a events or force Before themajeure, No decisionduly verified, modificati of unilateral in accorda No n/a Yes Yes of the PPP The article 38.3 Article Regulations 38.3Yes of the PPP Regulations Article establishes that 37the of No also existence the establishes PPP Regulations of force that the requires PPPeve majeure to con No n/a Yes Yes The BOT Law IRR addresses Section force IV majeure Yes of in several the Policy Circular Changeinstances: in No.Yes 06-2015 the Section law on risks are Termination 4.3 - Draft Contract: Paymen apprehended by No n/a Yes According to No n/a Section 1.2 of the PPPYes GuidelinesAccording (“PPP management�) to Yes Section 2.13 ofthe <...>, Guidelines thePPP I contract Yes Yesauthority The procuring Pursuant may unilaterally toYes Article 7 (1) modifyPursuant (d) a PPP contract toPPP of the Article No if 314 Law, the risk n/a public (1) sharingof between the No (a) interest so demands the Public Contracts public it and or Code case 18, the inprivate p c par Yes Yes Article 17 of the PPP Law This provides: "The be agreed should No Partnership upon n/a in the PPP Yes shall Contract include, Contract pursuant in Article 22 particular, to No of Article the PPP 17 the law following: of authorizes the PPP Law. ...7- Organis In ad amendin Yes Article 35(1) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toNo Article GEO, in exceptional n/a(e) of the 105(1) Yes implementing circumstances According related norms to to of the Clause Yesthe public Concession 48.8 interest, of Government theapproved Law pa publicDec No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes The PPP Handbook No n/a in the Yes section regarding Supervening The PPP Handbook No provides Events that types in the section of supe regarding S Yes of the PSP Law Article 21.1 Yes Article states 22.1 Yes of the that PSP "The Contracting law Article 21 Authority allows of the Yes the extension PSP Law may, Chapter of within andthe Article 11 the PPPNo ofcontract 130 the of terms Privatization agreed the in case upon Implementing of Manual force in the majeur Regul provi Contra Yes that the PPP ConsideringYes Article is an 47 administrative Yes of the PPP Law contract, Article provides 93 of pursuant Yes that the the Code topartnership of Article Article Obligations 106 115 ofof No contract the of thethe Code can Administrative Administration be ofterminated Code Obligations provides of at ofthe thei Oblig No n/a Yes the PPP Law, Acording toYes According Chaper IV, to YesArticle the Law, PPP46(19), Acording Article "in determining to 55, Yes the "aPPP private thepartner Law, Chaper terms and may IV, Article unilater conditio4 No n/a Yes the PPP Act Section 4 ofNo provides that n/a Yes the PPPPursuant Agreement toNo Section shall provide for such 14 of the matters PPP Act, as chang No n/a Yes No The glossary of the PPPn/a handbook defines No n/a Force Noacts of God and other specified Majeure as No n/a Yes Yes According to the PublicThe Procurement Procedure Yes for Preparation Act, §18(1)(c), Situations "aand contract, ofImplementation No a framework Change in Law are of agreement PPPs, discussed section o in Yes Yes unilateral Generally, such According changesto are No not the allowed n/a with Concessions Act, the Article Noexception n/a where 57(1), "a grantor theyYes are andmade in a public interest. a concessionaire Thu shall estab No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Manual, Yes SectionAccording 11.4.6(4), to Yes the Concessions "Managing not provided changesManual, Sectio No n/a Yes Yes Section 48 of the PPP Standardized Section 49 of Yes Provisions According indicates how the PPP Standardizedto Yes Provisions the parties sectionprovides 49 of should the act guidance inPPP case Standa ofin Yes Yes of public For concessions This is explicitly works, article Yes mentioned 203 and For 261in of the case the No articleof LCSP 239, concessions (complemented 254 n/a and 270 of No the with of public LCSP works, articles "Article article 255270 andof 239. Force theregula 262) maje LCSP, No n/a Yes No According to the Contract n/aManagement No Guide, Section 9.3, n/a No "a Contract may not be termina No n/a Yes Force Majeure No shall be n/a regulated and No mentioned No n/ain a Partnership Contract. Article 34 of th No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Article 42 of Yes Pursuant the PPP Law to sets out cases No Article which in 37 a contract of the PPP Law,can the be t Ag No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No Section 35 of the PPP Act n/a the draft PPP requires No contract to n/a Nocontain the standard contract No n/a Yes No is not explicitly Force majeure n/a regulated, No n/aminimum but the Norequirements of the PPP agreem Yes Article 44 of Pursuant toYes the PPP Article 43 Law, of No "when the the n/a PPP Law provides contracting No that the public-private n/a authority unilaterally No partnership modifies an administrative contract cont shall include No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes The template Article 17 of a PPP contract the YesArticle inparagraph 2IX. of Thethe template 1.5 PPP law Yes provides No. PPP for contract unilateral 49-2015 Article on provides modification the IGPPP Yes VIII.2.3 "Taxation-accounting" website that, as ( http://www.igppp.tn/sit a general includes in rule, of section the PPP the t No n/a Yes No Article 26 of the BOT Law n/a Implementation No n/a requires Decree that the force majeure events m Yes No n/a Yes No According to Section 26(5)(f) n/a of the No n/a PPP Act, the Yes must address "the allocati PPP agreement No n/a No n/a Yes Article 20 (5) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toYes Article Law: "In (4) of 20 the case the of decisions PPP ta Law, the No n/a Yes No Article 26 of PPP Law provides the Dubai n/a Yes components The Draft ofContract No PPP contract the thatPPP in the Dubai Manual shall include No n/a Yes Yes The Standardisation PF2 Contracts of Section 15 Standardization Yes(https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/u Section of PF2 Standardization Yes 16 contracts of PF2 treats the Contracts Authority bre No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Article 47 of the PPP Law Article regulates Yes 49 of the the possibility PPP Law indicates Article of including 49 of No that PPP the thein the parties Law PPP n/aindicates ContractNo that the the may request right to parties renegotiate of themay Procuring the PPP Autho request Con to r No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to Article 34 of the PPP Law, <...> No n/a Yes No The Standard Works RfT n/a provides (p. No Force Majeure 44):5.15. n/a No 5.15.1. No Breach of Contract No n/a Yes Yes is mentioned Force Majeure Article several 50 of the Yes PPP times on the Law, Article regarding PPP50 of Law, the modification No PPP Law, specifically inregarding or article revision (a) of PPP rega 18modifica No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Act, According Section to 60,the Yes PPP Act, "either party According Section has the toNo right the and 59(a) PPP to terminate (c), Act,"a concessionaire an 53, Section "an agr agreemen sh No n/a Yes No According to the PPA, Section n/a 89(c), No n/a stated in "the grounds a procurement contract as justif No No n/a Yes Section 48(h) Yes The Foreign of the Tender the Rules: NoInvestment department n/a Lawor organisation No a guarantee provides in charge of overseeing in favor of busine No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Law, According art. 13(3), toYes "a public the According partner PPP Law, art. 13(3), must toNo consider "a public the a PPP Law, partner proposal art. 15(5), must of "if conside a durin privat Boolean Boolean Boolean Q41_E Q41_4_TEXT Q42 Q41_5_TEXT Q42_1_TEXT Q42.1_A Q42.1_B Q42.1_1_TEXT Q42.1_2_TEXT 41.5. If yes, please Subcontracting provide the If yes, relevant please and 42. provide legal/regulatory/standard replacement Does the the If regulatory relevant of please yes, the subcontractors. legal/regulatory/standard 42.1. framework specify contractual If yes, and is If(including yes, provide arbitration provisions: please the Domestic standard available relevant provide contractual contractual arbitration the If legal/regulatory/standard asyes, an relevant provisions: option? please and clauses) provide international Domestic allow legal/regulatory/stand the arbitratio for relevan contra arbitr altern n/a Yes rules in Article The generalYes The 36 PPP of the LawNoPublic Procurement provides under n/a "Dispute Law Yes Resolution" provideThe that: PPP in Article (1) Law The contractor provides 45 that:Disputes may sub- under be "Dis n/a Yes Article 34 (1) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the PPP toNo Article 46(3) Law, the n/a contracting of the PPP authority Yes Law, any disputes Pursuant may: A) require between to Article the concessionaire the of the PPPt 46contracting n/a Yes Yes As a general Art. 7 principle, Art. 70ofof the the Concession No n/a Decree Concession Decree states provides Yes that that holder in the event thePursuant the ofto article of public a dispute service 153 in the conc of Presidep n/a No n/a Yes No According to article 20.1 n/a of the PPP Yes According Law, the disputes to article arising the relations from20(1) of the P n/a Yes of PPP Law Article Article 9.u) Yes regulates 9.w of No the PPP Law, faculty ofn/a states concessionaires Yesspecifications the bid to subcontract. Article shall 9.w include the proceeding of PPP Law states the n/a Yes Section 33 PPPs Pursuant toYes may embody No of Resolution No. 526-N: Arbitration n/a contracting 1) theas means of a Yes party dispute Armenia bears responsibility is a Member settlement. of for Pursuant the theNew to Ar fail of Volume 3 Sections 32 Yes and 31 28 Sections of Yes Volume of Volume 3 In 7 of the and Sections National 27 of 31 Volume No PPP of Volume Guidelines 7 of n/a the 3 and National and 30Section Yes of PPP Volume 7.4.1 7 In Guidelines of Sections the provide National NSW31PPP of that Volume Guidelines allGuidelines, PPP 3 and prov 30 sub-contra n/a Yes Yes According to the Law on According Concessions, to Nothe Law on n/a §106(1), “after Concessions, the contract Yes Annex V, According has Part beenAawarded, (13), to information the the Public concessiona to be in Procurem n/a No n/a Yes No concluded The Agreement n/a between Yes investor and Thethe competent Agreement authority concluded (Min betwe n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a the PPP Act, Yes art. 30(1), “if any dispute According to arises relation inthe to the PPP Act, 30( art.app n/a Yes Article 43 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the Regulation toNo Article of39 the n/a of the PPP Tender, the Law: Yes tender 1. Disputes Pursuant between proposal to Article of the public selected 39 andofprivate the PPP bidder muspa n/a No n/a Yes No of the judicial Article 1676.2 n/a Code provides: Yes Article 1676.2 Whosoever capacity has of or power the judicial Code n/a Yes Yes Art. 47 pf the Pursuant that PPP Law provides toNo Art. the PPP 75 the n/aPPP Law: of contract Yes mustbefore include any Pursuant contentious provisions to the on Art. action, conditions 75 of the parties the under PPP Lato n/a No n/a Yes Article 32 of Pursuant toNo n/a the Sarajevo YesPPP Law: Pursuant event (1) In theto of 32 Article of the Sara a dispute betw Yes Annexure The PPP Policy, The2, PPP Section Policy, Yes establishes 33AnnexureThe2, PPP a Section Policy, No clause 35 in Annexure aestablishes Summary n/a 2, of a Section Standardized Yes clause36 in a establishes Summary Contract The Arbitration a ofclause Provisions Standardized in a Act Summary Chapter for Publicof Priva 06:01 Contract Pro Sta Yes Article 5, IX, Law provides of the PPP Article 25 of Yes the Concession that the PPP The contract PPP Law regulates Yes contracts must may contemplate with Article have a parties third 11, clause the "III" Nopossibility ofa of PPP activities private Law n/a of refinancing that makes dispute are a inherent, reference resolution and, inaccessory mechanism that to the use case,at n/a Yes Article 133 Pursuant Pursuant toYes of the Concession toNo Article Law: (1) of the 154 n/a With Concession the Yes subcontracting (1) The contract, Law:Pursuantprovisions to Article the concessionaire of 154the ofComme the Con n/a Yes Yes Article 37 of the PPP Law Article provides No that 37 of the PPP Law n/a allows subcontracting Yes provided Pursuant tothat Article the110 private partn of the PP article 36.15 Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toYes article Law, the contract Pursuant 36.12 and 36.13 shall toNo article include of PPP the 36.22 clauses n/a Law, of the related thePPP contract Yes Law, to renegotiation shall the contract Pursuant include shall clauses to article according include related to 36.22 a set to clauses of schedu condit the rela P n/a Yes Yes Article 37 of The the PPP Law provides: PPP Law "The No private designates Chapter partner XI n/a may Yes to implement Article a PPP 45project of It dispute resolutions. the states PPP by itself Law in or article thro its provide n/a Yes Section 4 of Pursuant toYes According Law No. 2006/012: to No Without Section 5 n/a of the Law prejudice No. Yes2006/012,According the partnership of provisions of the to Section present agreement 5law, of the as PPP em wel n/a No n/a Yes No Policy regulates The Contracting n/a resort Yes to ADRPursuant to Section for PPP Contract of the under disputes Federa n/a Yes Yes Article 32 of Article 47 the PPP Ordinance provides of Nothe PPP ordinance that the n/a contract provides: Yes shall contain Article provisions Disputes between 47 of the on thesubcontracting. parties PPP arisingpf ordinance n/a Yes Yes Article 22 of Articles the Concession Law35, establishes 36 and 36in No n/a this bis of the respect Concessions Yes that the State Articles Law. will35, The not36 beand regulatory liable 36 framework bisany for con es of the C No Circularn/a Article 1 of the YesMatters The on Regulating relating Notice to Asset Nothe of Ministry Securitization n/a of Finance of Public-private Yeson The Guidelines Article Partnership of The 12 for PPP Projects Administrative Operations, provides th artL n/a Yes Yes Article 2.2.1.2.3.1.1 According and seq. of Decree to No 1082/2015 Article of Law 68 n/a 80 of includes Yes 1993, in guarantee's parties coverage to this the According type to Article authorized of 68 of Law subco 80 contracts w n/a Yes Yes Article 12 of Pursuant the PPP Law provides: toNo the without prejudice n/a PPP Law, contest to specific and Yes disputes provisions, relating Article 110 to the private of public-private the PPP partner Lawpartne provid shall g n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a Article 144 of the Procurement Yes According Code: to Public Article 142 of procurement the P contrac n/a Yes Yes PPP Regulation Article 9 of the Article 219 regulates of Nothe subcontracting n/aPublic Procurement General for Yes PPPs, it states: Article Regulations 219 The of collaborating (Decree the General 33411) contracto stat Public n/a No n/a Yes No Article 33 of the PPP Decree n/a provides Yesthat: Any Article 33between dispute the of the PPP Contractin Decree prov of the PPP Act Article 4(4) Yes Articles states 68 and Yesthe that 69 of contract the Article Concession should regulate ofLaw 4 (4)Yes PPP refinancing, The Act lists the regulate subcontracting. PPP compulsory Act <...> No specifically Pursuant subject n/a allows PPP Contract shall tofor matter Article contain arbitration to be 68 regulated of least at the as a Concess the disput inpro th Yes According The Public Procurement Act is silent to Yes on this the Public matter. As Procurement theHowever, Public No Act, certain §180(8), guidance n/a Act Procurement for does concession is Yes provided not contain in As the contracts, any the PPP Public "§105 restrictions Manual Procurement shall and regarding apply the mutatis Act arbit Sampledo n/a Yes Yes According to the EU Concessions The Standard Directive, No art. PPP Model 42(1), n/a “observance Yes for Construction and of As the obligations Standard the Public Procurement PPP referred Modelto Act inRen for do Arti n/a Yes Yes Article 42 of Title the PPP Law requires 8 of the the No contract PPP n/a to include Law relates to dispute Yes clauses related Titleto resolution. 8 of Article subcontracting the56 PPP related is Law conditions to dispu relates to d n/a Yes Yes According to of Law28 article 32Article 340-06, of NoLaw 340-06 there n/a is aprovides 50% subcontracting that Yes in order cap. for the Subcontracting Articles 76 contract and 77to ofbe the considere Decree should also b n/a Yes Yes Article 71 of the PPP Regulations According (Executive to No Decree article 19 of the1190) n/a PPP Law: Yes makes In the event Article express of mention 20 international of the to subcontractors: PPP Law establis S arbitration n/a No n/a Yes No All options of complaint n/a mechanisms Yes Article in relation 35 of the PPP Law to implementation states: of the PPP c n/a Yes of the PPP Law Article 30.e Yes Article establishes 92 of No PPP thethe Law: n/a right Every of the private PPP Yes contract may Articles partner provide 92 and to subcontract national 93 inof the or internati order to deve PPP Law n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a n/a Yes Yes According to the PublicAs Procurement the Public No Act, Chapter n/a Act Procurement 2, Subchapter does Yes 5, §122(1), Asany not contain therestrictions Public "in theProcurement procurement regardingAct arbit do docu n/a Yes Yes Article 54 of the PPP Proclamation, Article 61 of Nothe PPP Proclamation, regarding n/a Assignment Yes of which addresses Article the Project Agreements, Disputes 61 of thebetween states: PPP Proclamatio Except 1)the Con n/a Yes Yes According to Section 77Under of theSection Public NoContracts 43 of the and Finnish n/a Arbitration Yes Act: Concessions Act In(967/1992, the case Under of as Sectionworks 43 amended), ofand the service a deci Finnish A c n/a Yes Yes According to The Public article L.2193-3 of the Acquisition Yes Public Acquisition According Code Code: to No providesArticle the for different L.2236-1, n/a holder a public Buyers ofdispute resolution contract may resort process: to may, arbit A under n/a Yes Article 54 of Pursuant toYes the PPP Articles 69-73 Ordinance Noof the PPP n/a the Ordinance operator Yes is are solely related Articles to dispute responsible of the 69-73resolution. of execution the PPP Ordinan of the More spec n/a Yes Article 25(4) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toNo Article Law, for of n/a 35the purposes the PPP Law: Yes of a 3. Disputes Pursuant public-private thatpartnership arise to Article out of agreement, a of 35 the PPPt public-priv Yes The Standard Contract According for Highways, to Yes the Concessions §43.6 The deals with Standard Ordinance, issue theNo of §33(1), sharing Contract n/a“in for Highways, by aa contracting Yes concession §56 describes notice authority Provisions orthe the in reconciliation tender of refinancing the Code profits of procedure Civil[if documentation, Proa n/a No n/a Yes No Section 72 of the PPP Act, n/a2020 (Act Yes Pursuant 1039) states todispute that ; A between Article 1 a co of the Dispu Yes Standard Contractual Provisions: Article 50 1.1 of YesNon-Qualifying the Concessions ArticleRefinancing Law 17(2)No regulates of theAny PPP subcontracting: consequences n/a Law provides Yes1. <...> whatever In the Content Article of every tenderof 31 Partnership of documents, Refinancing the PPP the Contract. not contracting Law being The under a " n/a Yes Yes Article 150 of the PPP Regulations Articles 94 to No provides the n/a 104 of for the PPPcontract Law establish Yes a specific Article to regulate dispute 94 to 104 the conditions resolution of onthe PPP which subco law. I mechan n/a No n/a Yes of the PPP n/a Article 25-1No Yes Law provides that the PPP Article 25-1 of Contract the contain must provi PPP Lawan am n/a Yes article 25 of Pursuant toYes Articles the PP95 Law, to No the private 95-1 of the n/a PP partner Law are No has to obtain related ton/a an dispute resolution, approval from the articles 22 as procuring n/a Yes Article 8.3.8 of Coalianza's Yes Article Operative 35 of No Manual the of n/a PPP Law establishes Yes Acquisitions the states conflicts Article that that 35 amongst ofthe arise the due tender to Law PPP documen establis requests of n/a Yes Yes According to According Article 138(3) of the to Public NoArticle 17(3) n/aof Act Procurement Act: CXCVI Yes (3) The of 2011Hungary on national contracting is a member assets, authority mayarbitration of not ICSID restric anm Yes As per NHAI Chapter Agreement, Model Concession Clause 1.4 12 Yes of refinancing The the Post-Award agreements Post No Contract Award (which n/a Contract Management Management are included Yes Manual ManualThe in the definition provides for the Highway that Post-Award of Financing Contract the Sector Concession Agreem Manage under a Pa n/a Yes Yes According to the Attachment According to the to Nothe Regulation LKPP n/a on Regulation 29/2018, PPPs, Yesart. 32 (2)(k), Chapter II, Ca(1)(d)(5)(b)(6), AccordingPPPtoagreement the Regulation during (contract) on a P one n/a Yes Yes Article The Roads Construction ByLaw 56 provides: No of Article the Roads n/a Construction 16- While Yes financing, ByLaw provides- Article the 56 For contractor of proper the company management Roads is allowed Construct n/a No n/a Yes No According to Article 8 of n/a the Government Yes According Contracts to Article instructions, 8 of thearisin disputes Gove Yes "Refinancing" Article 47.1-47.7 ofYes the Contract Article 50.1-50.11 Article "Subcontracting" Template 44 "Dispute No describe of the Resolution procedures n/a Template Contract inYes Procedure" casedescribe of of Refinancing. the Ireland procedures Contract is a signatory Template (E.g. Article in caseof 47.1: of contain subcont the Newpr "PPP n/a No n/a Yes No Law 5728-1968 The Arbitration n/a (asYes updated) regulates arbitration The Arbitration 5728-1968 Lawas (a a means to n/a Yes Yes Article 174 of the Public Articles Contracts 205No and 206 Code ofn/a regulates the subcontracting Code provides Yes in concessions for Articles an amicable 205-208 and settlement PPP of the (byPublic reference Con procedur n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a Section the PPP Policy, Yes 8.0, "<…> As the contract the should PPP Policy the Procurem or include mech n/a Yes Yes and 3-2 Provisions 2-2-5 Provision of the Contract 6-8 Noof the Contract Guideline n/a establish Guidelines Yes provides In accordance a framework that for subcontracting the parties with Article to the with 4-4 third of contra n/a Yes Yes Article 42(L) Regulation of the PPPArticle 15 of No states that: the PPP Law "The n/aprovides PPP Contract Yes that themust parties Article to 15 the include of the contract the following PPPcan Lawagree provide basic, to non n/a No n/a Yes Article 57 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Law: Yes1. Disputes Pursuant toto relating the execution paragraph 156 of the and n/a No n/a Yes No Section 70 of n/a the PPP Act provides Yes for the minimum contractual Section obligations 70 of the PPP tha Act provide Yes Guidelines on Article refinancing have 133 been Yes of prepared the PPP Basic Article in 2014 Plans byregulates 44-3No KDI. of the The Basic Entrustment PPP n/a Actplans provides provide Contracts, for the Yes some Establishment Subcontracts, information The Arbitration on etc. of Committee refinancing Act onof Designing, Koreain for arti Me of 20 Co n/a Yes Article 15 (1) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toNo Article Law, the 48 (2) n/aof the public PPP Yes authority Law, may the agreement Pursuant either: to shall 1.1. require Article specify the48 works the (2) conces of the P matte No The PPP Guidebook 130) provides: (p. n/a Article The Yes6.3 Refinancing 29 of Project Nothe PPP Law n/a provides, Company can refinance Yes "PPP Projects theArticle debt and 29 in accordance theof agreements the PPPwith Lawthereof provide the s term n/a No n/a Yes Article 19 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a Yes <...> disputes Pursuant arising between to Article the 19 of parties the PPP n/a No n/a Yes No Article 93 of the Investments n/a Law provides, Yes Article 93 of "Investment the Investments dispute Law resolution rela n/a Yes of the PPP Law Article 63.1 Yes Article regulates 62 of No subcontracting: the n/a PPP Law (1) A Yes provides that tenderer components selected Latvia of by is athe a member standard concession of PPP the contrac ICSID c contract n/a No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Law, n/a art. 10(15), Yes "<…> the Arbitration proceedings Partnership Agreement Lebano inshall in Yes Section IX of the Partnership ArticleAgreement 61 of Yes on "Payments," ArticleLaw the Concessions 60 of regulated precisely No the Concessions subcontracting: n/a 25, Article provides, Law Yes enumerates 1. The "25.1. awarding When compulsory a The Private authority foreign clauses partner investor shall inhas require thethe is conce righ the concer Yesof the PPP Article 29 (14) Decreeto Pursuant 2017-149 Yes article 29 (6) Article requires of Decree the 49 contract of No2017-149, the PPP include toLawthe states n/a clauses that contract Yes shall any related include to dispute Article termination arising clauses 49 directly of related the to PPP take or toin the into Law control states accoun connectiot Yes According to According the PPP Policy, Section to Yes 9.1.5, the PPP"the Manual, Section PPPC [PPP 35 of No Procedure Commission] the PPP #4.2: ActReviewing, n/aprovides: will provide Yes Approving “[…] advice (3) Every and Section & Signing support PPP 35 contract of ofin Final the the shall PPP PPP following Act provide Contract(s) provide areas for n/a No n/a Yes While the PPP No regulatory n/a Yes framework does notWhile provide any the specific PPP provisions, regulatory framew M n/a Yes Yes Article 37 of Articles the PPP Law is related 38 and No to subcontracts. 39 of the n/a PPP Law are Yesto Pursuant Art. 37 related to Article of dispute the PPP 39 resolution, III Law of the : I- PPP TheLaw private during proc p indic n/a No n/a Yes No Section 6 (4) of the PPPA n/a provides that Yes every agreement shall Section 6 (4) the PPPA of provide provide for dispu Yes Article 117.V Article of the PPP Law establish 101 of Yes the the PPP possibility Law Chapter establishes modifying of12 of the No thePPP following: then/a PPP Law indicates contract "Subcontracting Yesto reestablish the Article (…) dispute different the 138 mighteconomic be of resolution the Law only done balance establishes mechanism under of the th n/a Yes Yes is regulated Subcontracting under Pursuant toSection No Article 34 paragraph n/a 36 of (1) Yes the Concessions and 36 Law.Pursuant Domestic paragraph to (2) and Article of international the PPP 34 of Law: thearbitr Conc In ca Yes According to According the Model Agreement, to Yes Section the 1.13.6, Concessions According "a Law, Concessionaire toart. the No 26.6, Concessions "specific n/a may notworks Law, transfer Yes art. and services any 34.2, "any of According dispute related its obligations to to between the theunder Concessions thethis parties agree Law implementationt n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/aArticle 80, the PPP Law, YesDisputes According arising on to the basis the PPP Law, of Article a PPP cont n/a Yes Yes Article 20 of the PPP Law According provides No for to Article sub-contracting 27 n/a of the PPP of the YesPPP Law, a PPP contracts contract The law 05.08 provides arbitration on for and mechanism n/a No n/a Yes No 39 of the Articles 36 and n/a PPP Law (n.º Yes 15/2011), Article 39 of the and Article of PPP 72 PPP Law states t Regulatio n/a No n/a Yes Noof the PPP Section 11.12 n/a Policy provides: Yes (...) (2) disputesto According interpretation inSection of th 11.7(C)(8e) Article 3.4 (Refinancing) Pursuant toYes Yes Article 16 of of the the DBFM DBFM Pursuant Standard Standard to Agreement Article No 4.26 discusses Agreement: of (a) n/a the The Public Contractor theYes issue Procurement of subcontractors. may Pursuant not Act: enter If toarbitration into a new Article has 4.26 of been the Pu Financinga Yes The Standard The Standard PPP Contract, Yes Sections PPP 51 to Contract, 53 deal The Standard Section with No the 16 issue PPP deals Contract, of Refinancing. n/a the with issue Part 21 "Dispute Yes of the Sub-contractors. Resolution", According to the Standard Sections PPP 87 to 89 Co dea n/a Yes Article 25 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Law No Article 31 of (second paragraph), the PPP Law, n/a Yes thethe private PPPArticle partner 31 contract shall of the may subcontract have PPPaLaw indicate third clause p of al n/a Yes Yes Article 18 of Article the PPP Law provides: 11 of Nothe PPP The Law n/a provides partnership contract Yes that theauthorize, may Article PPP 52 contract on of an must theinclude PPP Law accessory provision provide basis, the n/a Yes Yes of the Paragraph 50.3(h) Section Procurement 16 (26) No of the Procurement n/a Manual Procedures Yes provides Act provides Section thatthat the "all bidding 16 (26) procurement of the Procureme document should contrac Yes According to Article Article 3 of the PPP 118 Content of Yesthe PP Law Decree, Pursuant states, in theto case No the "the bidder when Annexmay to n/a the private the award PPPpartner Content a part of Yes assumes Decree the Pursuant public that obligations procurement contains to the for Annex the thecontent to design, contract the PPP to of cos a n/a Yes Yes According to the Standard TheBidding Standard No Form for BOT, Bidding Form n/aPart for 1 BOT, Yes Part 1Conditions "General "General According Conditions of Concession to the Standard of Concession Biddin Contract",C n/a Yes Yes Article 62 and PPP Law 63 of theArticle 78 deal of No with the PPP Law n/a subcontracting: specifically Yes "Article address arbitration. 62. Construction Article 78 of It the provides: and PPP Law risk. The specific contr “Disputes n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 12 of Pursuant toNoArticle the Arbitration Act: 12 of n/a (1) the By leave Arbitration Act:(1)an of the Court, leave Byaward n/a Yes Yes Article 29 of Article the PPP Law: 41 "(...) The of Nothe PPPparticipant private n/a Law: may "Dispute Yes settlement. also subcontract For In the activities settlement general, articleunder 41 of of its therespon PPP a disputes L n/a No n/a Yes No Article 56 of n/a the PPP Law and articles Yes119 to 133 Article 56PPP of the Regulations of the establis PPP Law and art Yes National Annex 8 of the Government Section 1.3 Yes (g)Agency of the BOT Section PPP law Manual IRR 12.22 No standard of the define contractors, BOT contractual n/a which Law IRR provision - Yes Resolution includes provides Section those of Disputes for that 12.22 Refinancing may between of not the BOT the be gains. part Contrac Lawof Addit IRR the Yes According to Subcontracting Section 4.3 of the PPPYes Guidelines Pursuant IV (“PPP is regulated by Article management�), toNo Article 48 of22 then/a of the PPP Concession Concession projects' Yes Law (...) Law, mechanisms 1. the Code In the of concession that concession Civil provide Procedure contract for profit detailing shallshar documents, th con n/a Yes to 323 of Public Articles 316Yes According Contracts to No Code article 18 476 n/a (1) contain of Public Yes rules on the assignment/subcontracting ContractsAccording Code 18, the to article use of476 (1)of ofpub Pu arbitration o n/a Yes Yes Article 24 of Article the PPP Law: 28 of "In addition No the the Law: toPPP n/a"The Partnership obligations Yes stipulated in Contract this Article is Law,28the of the subject decisions to PPP Law: the provisions "The issued im in P Article 32 of Pursuant toYes the PPPto Pursuant Yes Article GEO, the 32 public-private of Pursuant the PPPtopartnership No GEO, Article the 43(2) public-private contract n/aof the PPP regulates partnership Yes GEO, at disputes contract Pursuant least the arising following regulates to out Article of aspects: the at 2 of implement Law s) least the mech No. 1 fol n/a No n/a Yes article 11 of Pursuant toNo n/a ministerial Yes instructions no 612/08.11 Pursuant of 16/04/2014 to article se 11 of minister n/a No n/a Yes No While no provisions regarding n/a Yes arisingAccording disputes to article 3 of the from the implementation PPP ofArbit n/a Yes of the PSP law Article 25.2 Yes allows Article 34 of subcontracting. Nothe PSP Law n/aPursuant allows for Yes to alternative Article 44dispute of the Article PSP 34resolution of the LawPSP NCP's LawBoard allows mechanismsoff n/a Yes Yes Article 40 of Article the PPP Law allows52subcontracting. of Nothe PPP Law n/aprovides Article 116 Yes that of PPP Decree Article disputes provides 52from arising of the the theconditions execution PPP and of p Law provide Yes According to According the PPP Law, Chaperto IV, Yes the PPP Law, Article 49, Thus, "with Chapter according theNo prior II, to Partconsent the 5, Section n/aof PPP a Law, 5.2, public Chaper Article Yes IV, 16,art. partner,"aaAccording 46(25), formation private“in to partner of determining the a consortium PPP will be empowe the Law, for term art. pa 46 n/a No n/a Yes dispute resolution Alternative No n/a is allowed Yes pursuant This to Section 61under is regulated of the PPP Act: Section 61 n/a Yes Yes Section 1.4.2 Pursuant of the PPP Handbook toNo Section addresses the n/a 2.1.7 issue (f) of the of Yes subcontracting. PPP Handbook, Singapore usually, The 1.4.2 there In general, Arbitration is the alsoroles Act a pro and bindin n/a Yes Yes According The Public Procurement to Act, Art. I,No Part Procedure the II, n/a I, Chapter for §41 Preparation "The Yes Use of According Subcontractors," and to Act № Implementation isof devoted 244/2002 PPPs, Partiss toCoA Yes According to According the PPP Act, Article 40(2), to Yes thea decision Concessions According about Act,a to No PPP, the PPP Articleif59(1), not Act, already "a n/aArticle concessionaire regulated 140(1), Yes "the inmay a decision parties According subcontract in made ato PPP the part by relationship a of public PPP a Act, concessio party Article may a n/a No n/a Yes No According to n/a the Procurement Instructions, Yes In regards Section “the 33.1,of domestic arbitra thePermanent Secre Yes According to the Concessions According Manual, to Yes the Section Concessions According 11.4.6(3), Manual, "changes No to Section the permitted n/a Concessions 8.2.1, Table Manual, under Yes 6: the Section concessions "Sample 11.5.2, Contents According "the contract of to mechanisms a the Concession are Concessions oftenavailab compl Ma Biddin to 81 of the Sections 76 Yes PPP Standardized According Yes to Provisions the PPPFAAccording Regulation, contain to Nosection the the standard 12 n/a section 16.8.1 (1), aclauses person of the Yes regarding awarded TreasuryFor refinancing, a contract the domestic may Regulation, which the only accounting arbitration, enter into include offic key apr accos n/a Yes Yes Article 215 of the LCSP-First The additional contractor No provision n/a LCSP (Procurement may conclude withYes third parties abroad): First the partial additional In theimplementation contracts provisionwith LCSP un (P fore n/a No n/a Yes The Guidelines No on PPPsn/a do not contain Yes any restrictions regarding The Arbitration № 11 of 1995 Actarbitration cla n/a No n/a Yes No Article 39 of the PPP Act n/a provides that Yes in case According the of dispute to Partnership the Contra Investment Act, n/a Yes Yes According to As the Act, the Concessions Concessions Chapter No 5, §8, Law does n/a“if anot planned contain Yes construction As theorConcessions a service any restrictions regarding contract Law arbitration may does m notc n/a No n/a Yes There are no No n/a Swiss public rules barring Yes entities Art. from 1676 of the settling judicialby disputes ADR code an pro n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 46 of n/a No 1. The bidder, the PPP Law: n/a with damage to property, t is regulated RefinancingYes under Section Subcontracting Yes is 100 addressed Section of the PPP throughout 22 Regulations: of Yesthe the PPP Public Act Section provides Procurement “100.-(1) Any 22 proposed of No that: PPP the"22. Regulations, refinancing Any Act n/arefersmost to disputeof arising domestic debt notably extended during under theby Secti cour len arbitration o n/a No n/a Yes No Section 35 of n/a the PPP Act requires Yes the draft PPP Ascontract to contain prescribed the in Clause standar 4 of the S n/a Yes Yes Article 23 of the Public Annex Contracts II inLegal Point No Regime n/a provides, (y) of the PPP Law"1. Yes provides The contractors Annex that II may amongstin Point subcontract the minimum (y) of the PPP contra the La good n/a Yes Yes The PPP Law regulates subcontracting Pursuant toNo Article but not n/a the 43 of the replacement PPP Law, Yes the ofcontract Pursuant mustto subcontractors include Article in Article provisions 4342. Indeed, of the reg PPP n/a No n/a Yes No While no provisions n/a exist in the applicable Yes While Public no provisions Procurement exist in the Regulations a in co n/a No n/a Yes explicit or separate There is no No n/a section Yes in the PPP-related regulations The Arbitration Act № 5 [Chapter devoted t Yes The template PPP contract Article on 22 the IGPPP Yes of Law No. website 2015-49 Article foundabout 30 of NoLaw includes the No. procedures at Chapter 49-2015 n/a established on public-private Yes VIII.4. by the The with provisions partnership partnership Article on Refinancing 30contracts contract, of PPP and lawrequires the No. gain 49- provides: Yes According to Article 56(1) According of Law No. to Yes6428, 13 Article payments The of Law PPPare legislation No. made No it 6428, within generally is stated n/a the in framework allowstender arbitration the Yes theThe contract forPPP ofdocument resolving that legislation provisions. whether disputes subcontracto Thearising update generally fro alloo No According to n/a of theYes Section 26(5)(l) PPP Act, the Section PPP agreement 26 (5) No(r), the must n/a agreement address "where should Yes necessary, contain According the the method procedure to Section for of allocating 49 of the dis resolving PP be Article 20 (3) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toYes Article Law: If28(2) Pursuant the prices of On(tariffs) Concession toNo Article for 19 Law, the n/a private of "the the PPP concessionaire partner's Law Yesand Article goodshas Pursuant (works, 45 the services) the ofright to Article Concession to engage are 19 subject of Law, the PPP third the to s part n/a Yes Yes Article 32 of the PPP Law Article provides No the 35 of theobligations Dubai n/a PPP of Law provides, the Yes partner private "b. A Partnership shall include, 0 Contract may "8 . Not not st contrac Yes Section Section 28 Standardization 7.26 of PF2 Yes Contracts of Standardization titled Section "Refinancing" of Standardization 34 No Contracts PF2 n/a regulatedeals Refinancing of PF2 with Contracts Yes of the PF2 (https://www.gov.uk/government/u projects According replacement of that subcontractors. to is Section one way 34 in of which Standa It inclu n/a No n/a Yes Both international No domestic arbitration and n/a Yes are Both international allowed under the Virginia and Unif domestic n/a Yes Article 50 of Yes the PPP Law Article 54 of No and Article the 75 PPP Law of the PPP establishes n/a Yes Regulatorythat Decree Article states for the 54 that ofthe settlement the ofPPP disputes PPP Law establis arising Contractor m n/a Yes Yes According to Article 13 According of the PPPto Law, No <...> article 40 n/a private a of the PPP partner Law, Yes may disputes According <...> delegate his rights arising to chapter in the andfield obligations 42 of PPPs ofthe u Ci n/a Yes Yes The Standard Works RfT The provides StandardNoWorks (pp. RfT 33-34): 5.3. n/a provides (p. No Obligations of 5.14. 43): the Contractor n/a Disputes and Settlement 5.3.1. 5.14.1. N General Obligatio n/a Yes Yes Article 50 of the PPP Law, Article regarding 97 of No modification the n/a PPP Law states: or revision Dispute Yesof PPP contracts, Article 1. settlement: 97states: Disputes of the "1. PPP Modification Law states: between comp n/a Yes According to the Procurement Yes AccordingRegulation, to No the PPP Act, n/aSection Section 86 (4)(d), 64, Yes "any "a disputes According Procurement between Unit toshall, the the PPP[Department] in Act, Section determining n/a Yes According to the PPA, Section Yes The Zimbabwe 83(1), No Investment "unless n/a the procurement and Development Yes contract Provisions provides Agency of Act otherwise, №the 10/2019 Arbitration contracto Act 1 a[Chapter [ n/a No n/a Yes No Regulations The Tendering n/a (Directive Yes The Tendering 1/2013) specify that any dispute arising Regulations fro (Direc n/a No n/a Yes No does not As the PPP Law n/a contain anyYes According restrictions regarding Federalarbitratio to the private Law № 3 Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q42.1_C Q42.2 Q42.3 Q42.2_1_TEXT Q42.3_1_TEXT Q43 Q43.1_A Q43_1_TEXT Q43.1_1_TEXT No If yes, please 42.2. If applicable, are arbitration 42.3. elaborate Are other If and yes, awards Alternative provide please enforceable 43. the elaborate Does Dispute relevant the by If and Resolution regulatory yes, locallegal/regulatory/standard courts? provide please 43.1. framework the provide (ADR)relevant If options yes, the which If yes, (including relevant legal/regulatory/standard available contractual please of the legal/regulatory/stand standard (including specify following contractual andoptions mediation provide provisions: b con No Yes Yes Article 56 of the Commercial The PPP LawNoprovides Arbitration Law of under n/a 2007 "Dispute No Resolution" provides, "1) An Arbitral n/a in Article Award, 45 the option for irrespective t ofth No Yes Article 419Pursuant Pursuant toYes toNo of the Civil Procedure Article 46 of Code, n/a the PPP Law: No 1. may the parties designate n/a the place wherepartner The concession/public-private the arb No Yes According to Yes article 1031 Pursuant toNo articleCivil of the Algerian 153and n/a of Presidential Administrative No Decree nº n/a Procedure 15-247, Lawthe N. 08-09, the authorit procuring arbitral No Yes Yes of 25 July Law no. 16/03, According 2003, which to Noarticle 20.1 enacted n/a the of the Arbitration PPPNo Law, Law, theintroduced disputes n/a an amendment arising to the c from the relations No Yes Yes Article 26 of Article the PPP Law establish 9.w of Yes that PPP Law the states According arbitral the bid awardto No will Article specifications 9.rn/a be final with of shall the PPP Lawexception include the PPP the contract of the appea mu proceeding No Yes Article 36 of Pursuant toNo n/a the Law on Yes Article Commercial 21 of Arbitration: No PPP Law award 1. The n/a of an provides <...> arbitral Step-in rights. made tribunal Substi No Yes Yes Arbitration NSW Commercial Act 2010 In Sections Yes 31 of No. Volume This 61 in Section 3 would and 3035 be of No Volume detailed under 7n/a in of "Recognition the the National PPP agreement, and PPP Guidelines, but it wou enforcement" (cf M No Yes Yes and enforcement The recognition According to of No arbitral the Law on n/a awards Concessions, is governed No Annex V, n/a by the Part Austrian A (13), Enforcement to be informationAct in (Exe No Yes Azerbaijan has Republic of Yes The ratified Agreement No United Nations concluded n/a between Convention Notheon the n/a Recognition investor and Enforcement and the competent of authority ( No Yes Yes According to According the Arbitration Act № to No of 2001, 1the art. n/a PPP Act, art. 44,30(1), No“if any in respect the of dispute n/a domestic arises arbitration, “where in relation to th the app No Yes Yes According to Pursuant Article 245 of the Code toYes Article of the Republic 39 of Pursuant the PPP of Belarus Law: toNo Article 1. of Disputes 15.12.1998 37 n/a of between the No. PPP Law: 219-Z public A public and partner, private "Economic pa a Pro No Yes Yes Articles 1719-1721 Article of the Judicial 1724 No of the Code. judicial Articlen/a 1719 Code provides No that states Any n/a that:the President dispute of ofa proprietary the nature Court of First In No Yes Yes Article 30 of Pursuant the OHADA Uniformto Act Yes Art. on Arbitration 75 Art.71 of the PPP of dated Law: the No before PPP Law March any provides: 11, 1999: n/a contentious The the contracting action, the arbitration parties authorit judgment it No Yes Article 32 of Pursuant toNo n/a the Sarajevo YesPPP Law: Pursuant event (1) In theto Article Yes of 23 a dispute of Pursuant the Sarajevo to Article between the 23 Concession Parties of the Law: concer (1 Sara No Yes Yes According to the Arbitration According Act, Section No to the PPA 20, Section for n/a domestic No arbitration, 104(2), "A contractor n/a “an award who ison a submission aggrieved may, by a breach No Yes awards are The Arbitration Yes enforceable PPP Law by - Art Yes the11, local III, Article makes5,pursuant courts a§2, reference Yes I, of the to to Section PPP Article the Law use 515, authorizes of 5, "VII", private §2, of I, of the the dispute thePPP procuring Brazilian resolu Law aua C No Yes Article 41(3) Pursuant toYes of the International Pursuant Article 141 toNo Commercial n/a of the Concession No Arbitration Act (1) Modification Law:n/a of the (ICAA), the award concessio signed by t No Yes Yes according It is enforceable to theto Pursuant Yes article Article 30 of the 110 Pursuant of the OHADA PPP Decree, Uniform toNo Article 86 any Actn/a of on theArbitration PPP dispute arising Decree, from dated the March public the 11, au executi No Yes is regulatedPursuant Arbitration Yes by articles toNo 337 article and sq.n/a ofof 36.22 the the civil PPP No procedure Law, the contract Code. n/a Arbitration shall include clausesare on awards e rela No Yes Yes Article 353 of Article 45 of the Civil Procedure Code Yes the of PPP Law According provides: Cambodia to No provides "In article that the case an n/a 29 execution athe of PPPPPP Contract ruling Law: "Both of a court or parties must to Concession No Yes Yes Article 30 of the OHADA According Uniform to Act No on Arbitration Section n/a 5 of the dated Law No. March No 11, 1999: n/a 2006/012, theThe partnership arbitration judgment agreement emis No Yes Yes Federal Commercial Arbitration PursuantAct toNo Section of Canada n/a "(2) 12.8 of the The Federal Code No applies only n/a inPolicy, Contracting relation negotiation to matters where and meda No Yes ArbitrationArticle The OHADAYes No Act 47 of the PPP ordinance n/a No provides: n/a between the parties arising f Disputes No Yes Yes Article 36 bis of the Concessions Articles 35, Law36 and Yesand Article 36 bis According 635 of the ofConcessions the to Yes Chilean Article 21 Code Law According of the of Civil Concession to establish aArticle Procedure Technical Law 21that and of Panel regula specif the to Con No Yes article 62 of Pursuant toYes Chapter 6 InArbitration Yes of Law, the parties Pursuant Measures shall for theto Administration No perform The Notice theof arbitration n/a the of Ministry Concession award. of for If Infrastructur a party Finance The on fail No Yes Yes Law 1563 of 2012, Colombian According Arbitration Yes to Law Article 68 PPP that of Law regulates Law80inof its Yes 1993, among the Article 30 other PPP parties says: Law things "In to inthis its the case Article type of enforceability of30 contracts default of the says: ofc "Inw No Yes Yes As a member Conciliation of OHADA, DRC localYes courts by an independent enforce Article domestic authority 57 No of the arbitration PPP is possible Law n/a sentences, provides that Article Pursuant in Article to 310 the event of 109of of the C a No Yes Yes Article 145 of the Public According Procurement No to Code 142 Article provides: n/a of theAny No dispute Public Procurement which n/ahas Law: 1- A Dispute previously the subje beenSettlemen No Yes No awards n/a The arbitration are enforceable No by the n/a local courts, No to article 43 of the Political Const according n/a No Yes Yes Article 30 of Article the OHADA Uniform 26 (s) Act No on of Arbitration the PPP n/a Decree which dated March No provides 11, n/a 1999: that PPP The contracts shall arbitration contain judgment i No Yes Yes Article 39, paragraph of the Arbitration 1 Pursuant ArticleAct: toYes 31 of The Pursuant the court PPPto Act, Yes Article shall enforce mediation 67 of Pursuant a domestic the mayConcession betoaward Article used toLaw, resolve unless 67 of lender the it PPP Con step co establ No Yes Yes According to The Sample the Arbitration Act, §28(2), Yes Concession The Contract Publicaward, "an arbitration provides Procurement No which for an n/a cannot existence Act be reviewed is silent on of athis mediation pursuant matter. Howto proce No Yes Yes According to section 38Chapter of the Arbitration 27 No of the Danish"An Administration Act, n/a arbitration No award of Justice in n/a this country Act sets out or rules abroad court onshall m hav No Yes Yes Article 28 of Title the Law on international 8 of the Yesarbitration PPP Pursuant (no to Law relates 79/AN/84/1) dispute toNo article resolution. provides 47 n/a of the PPP Article for Law, executing 56The is related ordinances. to dispu Contracting AM No Yes of Law 498-08 Chapter VIIIYes Article on 76 awards No of the enforcement. Decree n/a No. 434-20, Nothe PPP Law 489-08 regulates Regulations, n/a domestic and allow international and regulate m No Yes Yes Article 363 of of Procedure the CodeArticle Yes 20 of the (Codigo PPP Law Article establishes: Orgánigo 38 of No General the (iv) PPP de Procesos) Regulations 20.2 Mediation n/a states (Executive is athat possibility judges Decreewill to 1190 int solve No Yes Yes According to of the Egyptian Article 55 Article Yes 35 of theArbitration PPP Law Article Law38 states: The of No (Law the PPP No. 27/1994 contract PPP n/a Law shall states Promulgating "The be subject thetoLaw the admin contracting provis Conce No Yes Yes Article 101 of Article the PPP Law that92 establishes of Yes the PPPthat Article. Law:the Every arbitral 73 PPP of Nothe award contract PPP Law: hasn/a the may "in provide same accordance force national a court or the as with ruling term internati No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No According to the Civil Code, n/a Part XIV, NoChapter 77, for domestic n/a§753(1),No n/aarbitration, "a decision of the a No Yes Yes Chapter 4 of the Civil Procedure Article 61Code ofNo the ofPPP Ethiopia Proclamation, n/a deal with Noarbitration. which n/aAccording addresses Disputes to article between the 319 of s (2)Con No Yes No 43 of the Under Section n/a Finnish Arbitration No n/a Act No (967/1992, n/a a decision on enforcement of as amended), No Yes Yes According to Article 1479 The Public of Acquisition No Code of the French Code n/a Civil Procedure Nofor (Decree provides n/a differentndispute 81-500 resolution 1981, Offi of 12 May process: A No Yes Yes Article 30 of Art. the OHADA Uniform 69 pf the Act Yeson Arbitration PPP Pursuant ordinance dated provides: toNo Article March (…) 62 11,of Th e1999: contract the PPP n/a Themay Ordinance, arbitration providejudgment forprocuri the an ami No Yes and enforcement RecognitionYes ofto Pursuant the Yes Article award rendered 35 Pursuant of in to the PPP Georgia Law: No Article 3. Disputes 26 regulated are n/a of that the PPParise by Law: Articles 1. A out a 44public-priva and 45 of ofpublic-private No Yes Yes According to The the Code of Civil Standard Procedure, Yes Contract According for 1060(1), Section to Highways, No in the respect The §56 Standard of n/a describes a domestic the Contract arbitration, for Highways, reconciliation "compu §5 procedur No Yes Yes 57(1) Mediation Pursuant section is Yes of the Alternative explicitly Dispute regulated PPP Act byNo the provides TheResolution Act, Alternative 2010 in its (Act n/a Dispute 798) Third Schedule, anResolution awardSection madeAct byunde 58 (1 an No Yes Yes Article 31(2) of the PPPUnder Law provides Article Yes <...> 17, "Rules Standard paragraphs of Arbitration" 2t and Contractual No 2y of <...> theProvisions: n/a in deviation PPP Law, the Direct from partnership the provisions agreeme Agreement II of No Yes Yes Article 94 to PPP law. 104 of theArticle 94 In to Yes particular 104 of the According PPP law. article In to 95 of No the particular article Law PPP 65 n/a ofstates the PPP according that toLaw: article both"Contracts 95 of the theshall PPP c arbitration No Yes Yes Article 30 of Article the OHADA 25-1 Uniform Act Yes of on the PPP Article Law provides Arbitration 23 of datedNoMarch the that PPP11, Law the n/a PPP 1999. provides Contract for a direct must agreemen contain an am No No n/a Yes No Articles 95 to 95-1 of the n/a No PP Law are n/a related to dispute resolution, as articles 22 No Yes Yes Article 71 of the Law ofArticle Conciliation 35 of NoandPPP the Lawn/a Arbitration establishes statesNo that conflicts thethe n/a that arbitral awards arise will duebe requests to a of final decisi No Yes Yes According to of LX 2017to Article 53 According Yes onAct Arbitration: No. LVAccording of(1) An on 2002 to No arbitral mediation, Article award of parties shall 27 n/a Concessions to a thehave the civil same Act: effect legal 1. The as win af relationshi No Yes Arbitration The Section 36, Yes Conciliation Yes Contract and Post-Award Act, 1996 The Management provides step-in Yes thatManual rights of a the The domestic lenders forstep-in the arbitral Highway are provided award, rights of Sector the unless for lenders under challe under Pt a No Yes Yes According to the Law № 30 of 1999 According to Yes "About the Regulation According on PPPs, Arbitration to No and the Alternative art. Regulation n/aDispute 32 (2)(k), on PPPs, Resolution", mediationart. is one 32 (2)(n), of art. the 59a (1) PP stag No Yes No Article 35 of the Law on n/a International No Arbitration No n/a n/aunder "Enforcement" provides:1. Excluding the cases No Yes Yes According to Article 251 According of Code of No to Article Civil Procedures 8 of n/a No. 83 Noof 1969, the Government Contracts arbitration n/a instructions, disputes awards should enfo bearisin No Yes Yes Article 23 of AA 2010: "An Article award 44.3 Yes "Adjudication" (...) an arbitral made byFootnote of the82 Contract tribunal Noof the Schedule Template: n/aan 17 under arbitration Dispute of the Contract Resolution agreementofshal the Templat No Yes No Law 5728-1968 The Arbitration n/a (asNo updated) provides n/a No that: Court may, on the application of 23. (a) Then/a No Yes Yes The enforceability Articles arbitration of domestic 205-208 Yes of awards the Article Public is provided 176 of Yesthe Contracts Code forPublic in art. provides Article Contracts 209, 176 for (8) Code paras. 12-13 of the Mediation provides of Public and the Code ADR. Contr that le No Yes Yes According to the Arbitration As theAct, PPP2017, No section Policy or the n/a Procurement 56(1), "anNo arbitral award, Handbookn/adon't irrespective contain any of the country in restrictions r No Yes Yes are enforceable Arbitral awards by Yes local In accordance with courts Article pursuant 4-4 of Section the to No 5-1-5 Articles of Law relating the 45n/a and to46 Guideline the relating ofPrevention the Japanese of Delayed Arbitrati to Contracts prov No Yes and (51) of Article Article (50) Yes the Jordanian 15 of No Arbitration the PPP Lawn/aprovides Law No. (16) No that for parties thethe yearto n/a (2018) the contract provides foragree can to the enfo No Yes No According to Article 54 n/a of the Law "On Yes Arbitration" dated Pursuant 8 toNo Article April 2016 47(3) n/aof the the PPP Law, arbitration award in a case shall ma ofbe re No Yes Yes Section 36 (1) Section and (2) of the Arbitration 70 of Yes PPP theAct Act Paragraph (No.4 of 1999) 2 provides No for of (the Arbitration the minimum n/a Third Act) Schedule contractual states to thethat obligations PPP Act provid local tha arbitra No Yes Article 35 (Effect Pursuant toYes Articleof 44-3 Arbitral of the No Award) PPP n/a Act ofprovides the Arbitration for the Act, No n/a Establishment "The arbitral of Committee award shall for have t Me No Yes Article 38 of Pursuant toYes Law no.to Pursuant 02/L-75 Yes Article"On 48 (2) Pursuant of the PPP toNo Arbitration": 38.1. Article Law, An the 48arbitral (2) agreement n/aof the PPP shall award Law, madespecify the by anthe PPP agreem matte arbitral No Yes Yes Article 185 of Article Law No. 38 of 1980 29 of issuing Yes the PPP Civil Article theLaw and49 provides, Commercial of Nothe PPP "PPP Procedures Executive n/aand the Projects Regulations Law agreements provides, provides, thereof "The "Th judgs No Yes Article 40 of Pursuant toYes Pursuant the Arbitration toNo Law Article of n/a 25No.the 135: Mediation Nodecision 1. The n/a of the Law, the parties arbitral maytribunal for abe provide shall ex med No Yes Yes Article 38 of the Economic Article DisputesNo 93 of the LawInvestments provides, n/a "The Law provides, No have parties "Investment the n/aobligation dispute resolutionthe to implement r rela No Yes Yes Section 58 of the Arbitration Article 62 of Law Yes prescribes: the PPP Law (2) Article provides If a judgment 79 of Yes that theof PPP components anLaw arbitration Article of 79 provides of standard for the acourt lender is PPP be Law step-in to PPP contract express righ enforced No Yes Yes Article 795 of the CCP provides According to for the the No enforcement PPP Law, n/a art. of arbitration No "<…>awards 10(15), the n/a Partnership and criteria for doingshall Agreement so byinr No Yes Yes Article 22(2) Procedures of the CivilWhen a foreign Yes Code investor Article is concerned, provides 602. <...> ofNo Courts the Article also6n/a hear of the Concession Law cases Investments lists in accordance compulsory with clause Law will ex app No Yes articles 451 Pursuant toYes and 451-1 Article 49 of Yes of the the Law PPP According nostates Law 98-019 to that of NoDecember any dispute article of 2nd, 46 n/athe arising 1998 PPPdirectly Law, related the or PPP to connectio contract inarbitration No Yes According to Yes the Arbitration Section 35 Act №of Yes 26 ofPPP the Act 1967, Section According provides: 27, to Noin the “[…] respect PPP (3) Every Manual, n/a of the PPPdomestic Procedure contractarbitration, #5.4: shall How“an provide for to a m No Yes No regulatory While the PPP n/aframework Nodoes notn/a provide any No n/a specific provisions, Malaysia is a party to th No Yes Yes Article 30 of Article the OHADA Uniform 39 III Act Yes ofon Arbitration the Law indicates dated PPP Pursuant article March toYesthat,31 11, when of1999. the thePPP conciliation Pursuant to Law: article Before 31 of thethe deadlin procedure fail PPP No Yes Yesof the Code Article 1026-8 Dispute of Civil Resolution procedure Yes provides Section 8.5.27 is regulated for by section No exequatur of the 8.5.30 of n/a PPP Guide: arbitral of the PPP Financiers' decisions. Manual. A dispute Security: Th No Yes and 139 ofArticle Articles 138Yes the PPP Law 138 of Yes and the Articles Article 143 92 through Law establishes the of the No possibility 145 PPP Law of n/a the requires Regulation of mediation to include of by the the in PPP Public the Law.Fun Al PPP No Yes Yes Domestic arbitration awards Pursuant are to recognized Article 36and No n/a paragraph enforced (1) No in Moldova and n/a 36 paragraph as well as (2)foreign of the PPP Law:in awards, ca Inacc No Yes Yes According to According the Law on Arbitration to Yes the of 26 January According 2017, Concessions Law,art. to No art. the34.2, Concessions 48.1, "any n/adispute Law, "regardless of between the art. country "an 28.2,the parties of origin, Authorit No Yes Yes According to ThereLaw, the Arbitration is a dispute Part Yes V, Article resolution According mechanism 27, "a to Yes Article provisional with measure 72 the According paragraph determined to 2 of Article Concession the Commissions by PPP 72, anLaw: arbitral "In bein paragrap c t No Yes Yes Law 05.08 on According arbitration to and conventional Yes Article mediation, 27 According of the PPPto Law, Yes Article a PPP published in21 the contract Article ofOfficial 21 provides the PPP paragraph law, the Gazette for No. public 4 mechanism 5584 of the ofPPP Th entity No Yes Yes According to the articleArticle 43 of the 39 of Law No n.PPP the Law 11/99, n/a 8states of July (Law No that Tothe 2.of allow Arbitration, n/a for speedier dispute resolution Conciliation and Med No Yes Yes Section 11.12 of the PPP According Policy provides: to NoSection (2) n/a (...)11.7(C)(8e) disputes ofNo the in interpretation PPP Policy, n/a project of the project agreement agreement or draft mu No Yes Yes Enforcement of domestic Article Arbitral 21 of Yes the DBFMO Awards A Standard is regulated direct under agreement Agreement NoArticles is part n/a discusses 1062 and of the1063 the contract issue of the ofDutch Dispute Code Re documentatio No Yes Yes According to The Standard the Arbitration Act 1996, Yes PPP Contract, art. According 35(1), Section “an arbitral to Nothe award, 87.4 describes irrespective n/a PPP Standard theContract, Accelerated of the Section country 73.1, in whic Dispute Res"t No Yes Pursuant toYes Article 63 of Article the Law 540 Yes 31 of the "Mediation PPP Law Article and29 arbitration of indicates mediation the PPP Yes Law", Law as According the provides an first to arbitral that option article award, when forirrespective 29 the of the dispute res PPP private No Yes Yes Article 30 of Article the OHADA Uniform 11 of Act No onPPP the Lawn/a Arbitration provides datedNoMarch that the PPP 11, 1999: n/a contract must include The arbitration provision judgment is No Yes Yes Section 31(1) Section 55 of the Arbitration and of Yesthe Arbitration Clause Conciliation Cap Act and 4.4 Conciliation A18, ICRC No LFN 2004 Nationaln/a PPP Actprovides provides: Policythat provides "Notwithstanding that "There an arbitral th award No Yes Yes of arbitral The enforceability rewards Yes In particular, according is guaranteed Article to Article by Article 42 2No of the of the 456 PPPof Law PPP n/a Content thestates Law on Decree, the Civil following: "The agreement The(1) Procedure: The contr No Yes Yes According to According the Arbitration Act, 1940, to Yes theSectionAccording 14(2), Standard in respect Bidding No to Form the Standard for of the BOT, n/aPart Bidding 1 "General domestic arbitration, Form for Conditions BOT, "the Partof 1C arbitr No Yes Law 131 of 2013 Yes regulating Article commercial Yes 77 of the PPP arbitration Law Article (domestic 4.6 of provides: "Technical the Yes PPP and international) Law Article panel. A 4.6 states: "Right of and the technical Law of PPP panel 5/1983 Lawis states: create appro substitution. No Yes Article 12 of Pursuant toNo n/a the Arbitration No Act:(1) n/a No By leave of an award on a submission may b the Court, n/a No Yes Article 45 of Yes Law 1879/02 In general, article Yes 41 of the Republic ofof Paraguay the PPP38 Articles Law on Yes "Arbitration and and 39Chapter of the Articles PPP VIMediation" and Law of the 39 regulate of Decree the regarding this PPP Law situation 4183/20 recog furt regula No Yes Yes Article 132.1 of the PPP Regulations Articles 56 and Yes regulates 130 of the arbitral PPP113 Article clauses LawNo of and the and PPP refers Regulations Section II of n/a to the Articles PPP regulates 67 (arbitration the rights Regulations enf dealt w o No Yes Yes Section 40 of " Confirmation RA 9285: Section Yes 12.22 of of Award. the BOT Pursuant Law - The confirmation IRRto - Yes Resolution Section 12.21 ofSection of a Disputes (a), second 12.21 domestic arbitral of between paragraph, the award BOT the Contrac of shall Law IRR the b No Yes Article 1212 Pursuant toYes of the Code Mediation Yes is one of Civil of the Pursuant dispute resolution Procedure toNo of Article 17 November 10a methods of 1964 n/athe PPP (unified available Act,under (1) text: theJournal public the ent of C Polish L No Yes Yes Article 47 of Article the Voluntary Arbitration 476 of Yes Law, Contracts Public Pursuant Law Code 63/2011todated No Article 18 states: 14th n/a (1) "1 -of The Public 322December, useregarding Contracts of arbitration Codeor18, oth enforcemen No Yes Yes Article 34 of the Arbitration Article Law 16 of of Qatar the Investment No provides, n/a "1. Law provides, An arbitral "With No award n/athe shall exception status have theof dispute laborof res ju No Yes Article 57 of Pursuant toYes Law No to Pursuant 101/2016, Yes Article 2 theLaw parties No. may ofPursuant toNo 101/2016: Article agree39 (1) of Any that disputes the n/a person PPP GEO, concerning whoif the private the interpr considers part himsel No Yes Yes Article 50 of the Law N Pursuant 005/2008 No article toof 14/02/2008 11 of n/a ministerial Noinstructions on arbitration and conciliation n/a no 612/08.11 in commercial matter of 16/04/2014 se No Yes No Act states The Arbitration n/ain section Yes 21.1 that a According to Yes the foreign award shall, PPP subject Handbook Accordinginto to this the Part, the section be enforceabl PPP regrading Handbook No Yes Yes Article 34 of the PSP Law Pursuant recognizes Article toNo 34 of arbitration n/a in the PSP PPP Law, contracts No alternative and the n/adispute agreementmechanism parties' resolution on the app No Yes Yes to the Treaty Senegal is party Articleon 52 the of Yes the PPP Law Article provides Harmonization of42 Business of No lists themediation LawLaw PPP n/a in provides as part Africa (OHADA), of that: the which dispute resolution sets out operator ofm No Yes No According to the Law on n/a Arbitration, Yes According art. 64 ("Official to No Gazette the PPP of Law, RS", No. n/aChaper 46/2006), IV, art. 46(25), "in "a domestic dete arbitra No Yes Pursuant toYes Chapter 25, Pursuant Section 13 Section of Act (CAP toYes 61 Lender of 25 of PPP the step-in Laws Yes of Sierra Act, rights the parties and Leone Lender have 1960), step-in private partner the"An right rights award substitution to choose on a and submi betw are private No Yes Yes Section 46.1 10 of the of ChapterPursuant to Arbitration Yes Section 4.3.14 Pursuant Act: Anthe of to award Handbook, No Section by disputes n/a the arbitral made 2.3.16 of the should PPP tribunal try Handbook be resolved if the topursuant a to p No Yes Yes According to According Act № 244/2002 to Coll.Yes "On the Arbitration" According Procedure of Preparation for April No 3 to the Procedure and 2002, n/a Implementation Part for II, Chapter Preparation IV, §44PPPs, (2),Impleme ofand Part "a domA No Yes No According to the Arbitration n/a Act, Article No 41(1), n/a award issued "an arbitralNo n/aby a domestic arbitration may No Yes Yes Section 14 of the Arbitration According Act of No to 1987 the Procurement provides, n/a “an Instructions, No on a Section award n/a 33.1, submission may, "the Permanent by Secre leave of the Co No Yes Yesyet to sign, Somalia is still According ratify, enact to Yes orConcessions the According perform an Manual, accession to No Section the Concessions of 11.5.2, anyn/a of the Manual, UNCITRAL "the mechanisms Conventions Section availab an 11.6.1(b) No Yes Yes Domestic arbitration is According dealt with to under Yes the PPP Standardized Part O of the the Arbitration No Act Provisions, PPP 42 of 1965. n/a section According Standardized 86.1.6, Provisions to a the contains section disput fast-track the s 31(1) No Yes Yes provision First additional accordance In LCSP Yeswith . Articles 7, 8, Annex 40-43, Articleof 274.2 theYes III Spanish of LCSP, Arbitration the the LCSP Article (Work Law (Ley 274.2 possibility of60/2003, mediation Concessions): of the LCSP de When 23 (Work for de res the C dic No Yes Yes According to the Arbitration According Act № to11 No ofArbitration the 1995,n/a Section Act 31(1), № 11 “a No party of 1995, n/a to Section 14(1), "itagreement an arbitration pur shall not be in No Yes Yes According to Article the Arbitration Act, 39 art. of Nothe PPP 41, Act "withn/a prejudice provides to Noarticles that in case n/a (38), of dispute (39) and the Partnership (40), Contra the award of th No Yes No According to the Arbitration n/a Act (1999:116), No n/a "a foreign §53, n/a Noarbitration based on an arbitration agreem No Yes article 387 Article Pursuant toYes of the Code 189 CCP No of civil now expressly n/a procedure, provides an arbitral No that parties n/a has decision the may agree same effects that as a certain jud disp No No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toYes Article 40 of Pursuant the PPPto Article Law, contracting the 40 au of the PPP No Yes Yes Section 68 of the Arbitration Section Act, 22Act No of No.PPP the 2 ofAct 2020, n/aprovides No that provides: "68.-(1) any dispute n/a An award from an arisingmade the arbitra by agreement No Yes Arbitration Yes Act B.E. 2545, Mediation Section 41: No is allowed An arbitral by general n/a irrespective No award,civil and commercial of n/athe country law. in which it was ma No Yes Yes Article 671 of Annex II the Timor-Leste Civil in Point Procedures No n/a Code (y) of the PPP provides, LawNo provides that n/aof Feasibility amongst disputes the and arbitration minimum aw contra No Yes Pursuant toYes article 30 of Pursuant the OHADA Article Uniform toYes 43 of Act Article onPPP the 43 of Law, No the Arbitration the PPPcontract Law dated March PPPs n/a must stipulates 11, 1999: that include provisions The arbitration the reg public- No Yes No Section 66(1) n/a of the applicable Uk Arbitration No n/a 1996 provides, Act No An award made by the tribunal p "(1) n/a No Yes According to Yes the Arbitration ThereAct №No is no explicit 5 [Chapter or separate n/a 5:01] ofsection No Section 1939, 20, n/a for the domestic in the PPP-related arbitration, regulations devoted t" No Yes Yes Article 33 of Article the Tunisian 30 of arbitration Yes the code PPP law According No.that provides the to Yes 49-2015 Article arbitral ( the Law 36 According of n.the award may 2015-49 PPPto be law dated Article enforced 27 36November spontaneo of thethe No. 49-2015, PPP No Yes Yes Article 436(3) According of the Civil to Procedure Yes Article Law No. 6100 According 18(2) of states the BOT to that Article Yes Implementation the arbitral 62(1) Pursuant of Law Decree, to award No. shall Article the 6428, be 44 notified following In ofthe theto New poi the event No Yes Yes According to Section 49 of the PPP According toYes Act Section 49Section of the on dispute PPP 26(5) No settlements Act, (n)in "1. ofPPP Any the agreements PPP dispute n/a Act provides between and in areference contracting that to the PPP t a ag No Yes Yes Domestic arbitration According awards to are enforceable Yes Article 45 in(2) Ukraine of theunder According Concession Yes to theArticle Procedure Law, According 56 ofof the the parties Domestic to the substitution to Resolution the Arbitration of concession a privateLa p of CM No Yes Yes The UAE Arbitration Law Article (repealingNo 35 of the Dubai UAE Civil Procedure n/a PPP Law provides, No Federal Code, "b. An/a Law Partnership No. (11)Contract Chapter of 1992 may st not Th No Yes Act 1996. Arbitration Arbitration Yes to According awards Yes Section are34 Section of Standardization 26 of enforceable No by the thestandardization local of PF2 n/a courts Contracts, according parties of PF2 to Contracts the should Rules recom of t aim No Yes Yes Enforceability of arbitral ADR awards is regulated methods Noother than under n/a arbitration the Federal No explicitly n/a allowed areArbitration Act (FAA) under andthe theCode of Vi Virginia U No Yes Nothe General Article 472 of n/aCode of Yes Procedure acknowledges Article 80 of the Yes PPP and accepts Law Article establishes arbitral 80 of the the resolutions PPP Guarantees Lawof establis the arb to No Yes Yes According to According Article 364 of the Civil to Yes Code, the Economicdecisions Procedural <...>According of No to Article foreign Code,courts Part 35 of the n/a §2, PPP I,and foreign Chapter Law, <...> 16, creditors Articlecourt arbitration an 131, Yes No n/a Yes No The Standard Works RfT n/a No provides (p. Disputes and Settlement5.14.1. N 43):5.14. n/a No Yes Article 97 of Yes the PPP Law states: Article of 97 Dispute Yes the PPP LawArticle states: settlement: 53 Dispute [...] 5. of Yes the Disputes PPP settlement: settled Article Law, through 53 1. Disputes regardingof the Lender’s arbitration PPP between Law, rights, prescr comp state regardi No Yes According to the Arbitration Yes Act, 2000, According to Yes theSection PPP Act,16(1), Section According 15, for to Yes the the "notwithstanding domestic PPP Act, arbitral Section According section to 56(1), awards, the PPP sixty "the " anAct, award four, Section the [DepartmeonCoa No Yes According toNo the Arbitration n/a Act [Chapter No (No. 6 of 1996), 7:5] n/a No Section 35(1), "an arbitral award, irresp n/a No Yes Yes Section 40(a), Arbitration The Tendering Law: No Regulations Enforcement ofn/a Domestic (Directive No1/2013) specify Arbitration: the domestic n/a that anyaward dispute arising shall be enfo fro No Yes According toYes the Federal Law № 382-FZ According Yes to the About FederalArbitration, Law № 382-FZ According to art. the 41(1), Yes PPP About Law, According for art. the 13(13), domestic Arbitration, the to art. “a49(1), PPP arbitration, transfer Law, "using art. of "an the 13 the Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q43.1_B Q43.1_C Q43.1_2_TEXT Q43.1_3_TEXT Q43.1_D Q44 Q43.1_4_TEXT Q44.1 Q44_1_TEXT If yes, The regulatory please The framework specify prescribes regulatory and If yes, that provide framework please a direct the Other specify relevant prescribes and agreement please legal/regulatory/standard provide that should specify: the 44. be the lender relevant signed Does the with If step-in legal/regulatory/standard regulatory yes, rights contractual theplease lenders. 44.1. should framework specify provisions: be If yes, anddoes regulated (including provide contractual the in the regulatory thecontract relevan provis standard fc No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 43 of the PPP Law provides that:(1) Th No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 36 of the PPP Law, unless Pursuant toYes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes 65 of the Concession Decree Articles 64 and No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to of PPP Law Yes article 9.r n/a the PPP contract Articlemust 9.p of Yes specify the the PPP requirements Law andAgr states the PPP con Yes No Article 21 of n/a PPP Law, provides <...> No n/a Substitution Step-in rights. n/a to PPP contract: No of parties No 1. A PPP contract may pr Yes Nodetailed n/a This would be No in the PPP agreement, n/a it would but Yes find ground The based on Sections grounds are: 1. Termination Yes for Contract 25.1.1 of Volume 3 and No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the Law on Concessions, §109, No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 3.1.20 of the BOT Rules th Pursuant toNo No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Article 37 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a partner, a private No A public n/a Yes partner, Pursuant creditors toNoof a private Article the PPP Law: 30 of partner, 1. An and (or) a oth No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Art.71 of the n/a PPP Law provides: the No n/a contracting may agree with authority Yes Art.72 the oflenders Yes the PPPor Law with provides : thecontract the private public-p No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 26 (1) of the Sarajevo Con Pursuant toYes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Annexure 2, Sections 25 and The PPP Policy, No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 35 of the Concession Law (that applie No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes the Concession Law is related to Section V ofYes No n/a Yes Article 86 of Pursuant toNo n/a Yes the PPP Decree, the Articles public authority 96 to Yes 99 of the agree, may with project PPP Decree fu set forth No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes article 36.15 of the PPP Law, the Pursuant toYes No n/a Yes According to No of the PPP Law: article 29 n/a According Yes "Both parties to the to Yes Article PPP Contract may 42 of the agree PPP "the Law on P the No n/a No n/a No Yes No comments Yes contract can be cancelled: - The partnership No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Contract termination grounds are addressed No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes 43 to 46 of the PPP ordinan Chapter II Article No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 27 of the Concessions Law establishes Yes No Article 24 of The Notice of the Ministry n/a n/a on The Yes No of Finance Guidelines for Material PPP Operations Yes force breach, majeure, provides Lender and thatagreement a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes 18 of Law 80 of 1993 establis Articles 17 and No n/a Yes Article 57 of No n/a the PPP Law that in the event provides Yes Articleof 58 serious Yes a of the PPP breach Law by provides that PPP the private partc No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to Article 140 of the Public Procur No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 13 of the PPP Regulations establishes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 31 of the PPP Decree provides: the te No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 67 of the Concession Law Pursuant toYes Yes No The Public Procurement n/a Act is silent No n/a However, on this matter. Yes certain guidance Accordingis toprovided the Public Yes in the Procurement PPP Manual.Thus Act, §1 No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to the EU Concessions Directive, a Yes article 47 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law, n/a n/a No the Contracting Authority Yes may Pursuant agree with toentities article 46 Yes of the PPP providing Law for funding a Pr provide No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 72 of Law 47-20, the PPP Law, establi No n/a Yes Article 38 of No n/a the PPP Regulations Yes (Executive Decree Pursuant 1190) article provides toNo 15"The of The contracts will dete Public Private P Yes No Article 38 of the PPP Law n/a states "The Nocontracting Yes authority n/aadministrative Article shall 34 of bethe entitled Yes PPP Law to conclude providesdirect agre that the P No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article. 73 of the PPP Law: Articles "in accordance 70, Yes 71, 72 and 73 with of terms the stipulated the PPP Law set No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the Public Procurement Act, §1 No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 58 of the PPP Proclamation provides t No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 137 of the Public Contra Pursuant toNo No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes In all administrative contracts, the administra Yes Article 62 of Pursuant toNo n/a the PPP Ordinance, No n/a the Yes procuring authority can Default agree the Yesprocuring ofwith the financing entity; entities financial unb or the h No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 26 of n/a Yes1. A public-private the PPP Law: Pursuant to partnership No Article 22(3) of the PPP agreement Law, may a pu includ Yes No According to n/a the The Standard Contract No for Highways, n/a Yes §58, "as far as the According inclusion Yes to the of an Standard outside Contract planned capital isfor Highw No n/a Yes provides in The PPP ActNo its Third Schedule, n/a Yes Section The PPP 58 (11),provides regarding ActYes its Third Schedule, inminimum Se contractua Yes No Standard Contractual n/a Provisions: Direct No Agreement Yes n/a II of the ContractsArticle provides 17(2) for Yes the of the following: PPP Law1 NOTICE <...> provides "C OF TER No n/a Yes No Article 65 of n/a"Contracts the PPP Law: Yes shall contain According the requirements Yes to of the Article 73and PPP Lawunder conditions the te Yes No Article 23 of the PPP Law n/a provides No n/a Agreement that the Direct Yes and theArticle PPP Contract 21 of Yes the PPP may Law set out provides the terms unilate forand con No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 88 of the PP Law indicates circumstan No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes According to No n/a Article 139 YesProcurement of the Public According Act:(1) to YesSection The 143 oftenderer successful orProcu the Public tende No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 37 of the Model Concession Agreeme No n/a Yes No According to n/a on PPPs, the Regulation Yesart. 32 (2)(n), According a PPPto agreement No (contract) the Regulation shallart. on PPPs, 32 conta No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The Roads Construction ByLaw provides:Artic No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 11 of the Public Contracts Law provid No n/a Yes NDFA's Contract No Template n/a has a provision Yes a funder on Articles 33 right 38 -Yes "Termination" of of Contract step-in, without Te being speci No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yesof the Public Contracts Code p Article 180 (7) No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the PPP Policy, Section 8.0, "<… Yes No Section 5-1-5 of the Guideline n/a No to Contracts relating Yesfor Step-in n/a provides Section by the 5 lenders the Guideline ofYes and refers relating to that the to lende Contrac No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 41 of the PPP Regulation states that : Yes Article 47(3) Pursuant toNo n/aof the PPP No n/a of material Law, in a case Yes breach of According the PPP to contract Yes 49the Articleby private of the Law: (1) th PPP partner, th No n/a Yes Paragraph 2No of the Third Schedule to n/a Yesthe PPP Act Paragraph providesYes 16that of the theThird minimum requirements Schedule to the PP No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes ; Buyout: According to article End of duration No n/a Yes Article 48 (2) Pursuant toNo n/a Yes of the PPP Law, the PPP Pursuant agreement Article toNo contain: shall49 PPP conditions of the2.22 Law, the ea Yes No Article 49 of the PPP Executive n/a No Regulations n/a "TheYes provides, substitution Article of the Contracting 19 of Yes the PPPInvestor Law provides, "The High with another In No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 16 of the PPP Law, the PP Pursuant toYes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 87 of the Investments Law broadly pr No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 65 of the PPP Law regulates the early No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Law, art. 10(12), "<…> t Yes No Article No 32 of the standard n/a Partnership No n/a Agreement Yes <...> 32.1. provides Article The60 Lender Yes of theshall Concessions be entitled Law use compu tolists a step Yes No According to article 46 n/a of the PPP Law, No the PPP contract and n/a Yesthe Direct Grounds Agreement are, Yesmay provide pursuant the terms to article thecon 47 ofand PP No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to the PPP Manual, According Procedure to Yes the PPP Manual, #5.4: Procedure How to #5. manage requ No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 31 indicates the circumstances allowi No n/a Yes No 8.5.27 of the PPP Guide: n/a Yes may include The contract Section provisions 48(a) Yes the ofon the PPA Financiers' provides that a publ Security: T No n/a Yes Article 92 section No IX of PPP n/a Law Yes Yes a set termination causes bu The law specifies No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The grounds for the PPP contract's terminati Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Law,No art. 28.2, "an n/a Yes Authorized Entity, a Concessionaire According to Yes the Concessions and Law, art. 24.1, the concessionaire's lend No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 77 of the PPP Law prescribes the case No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to Article 26 of the PPP Law, the g No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 26 of PPP Law provides that: The cont No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to Article 11.7(C)(8e) of the PPP Po Yes No A direct agreement is part n/a of the contract No n/a documentation Yes concluded to The DBFM reach Standard financial Yes close Agreement of the project (article provides for Yes No According to the Standard n/a PPP Contract, No Section n/a Yes 73.1, "this Part 19 is The subject StandardYes to the terms PPP of the Financier Contract, Direct D Part 19 "Termina No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 28 of the PPP Law provides that the c No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 50 of the PPP Law: The partnership co Yes No Clause 4.4 of the PPP Policy n/a provides Nothat "There n/awill normally n/a Agreement No be a Direct No between the lenders and th No n/a Yes No Article 42 of the PPP Law n/a Yes states the following:Article The contract 43 of YesforPP the concession Law states for the following: goods of gen No n/a Yes The expressNo provision for n/a Yesto step in the lenders The is provided Standard YesBidding for in theForm Standard for BOT, Part Form Bidding 1 "G No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 67 of the PPP Law establishes: "Cause No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Section 11 of the PPP Policy, con Pursuant toNo No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Articles 36 of the PPP Law regulates this mat No n/a Yes No Article 113.1 of the PPP Regulations n/a expressly Article Yes mentions58 of the Yespossibility the PPP Lawof establishing establishes the act right No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Section 12.21 of the BOT Law IRR: Contract T Yes Nowith Article In accordance n/a10a of the NoPPP Act: n/a 1. The public Yes Article entity may conclude 47 of a Yes contract the with a third Concession party finan Law regulates si No n/a Yes Article 322n/a Pursuant toNo Yes (1) of Public Contracts A. Code Termination 18, and Yes by the public provided party:are that there contra Article 33 No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Article 17 of the PPP Law provides:"The Part No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Article 32 of n/a Yes the public-private the PPP GEO, Pursuant to partnership Yes Article 32 of the PPP contract GEO, theat regulates pul No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 12 of the PPP Law, The PP Pursuant toNo No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The PPP Handbook provides a segment titled No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 28 of the PSP Law and Article 132 of t No n/a Yes Article 42 of No n/a the PPP Law that: The operator provides Yes Article 47 of of the Yes PPP the project PPP may not transfer Law provides: The PPP tc Yes No According to the PPP Law, n/aChaper IV, Noart. 49, "At n/a Yesof a financier the request The PPP andLaw, a private Yes partner, Chapter a53 V, art. of provides public m partner fo No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The grounds for contract termination are pro No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo Section 2.1.22 n/a of the Handbook, Yes Section debt providers 2.1.18 Yes(c) of hold the PPP step-in Handbook rights over to take make Yes No According to n/a for Preparation the Procedure No n/a and Implementation Yes of PPPs, The Part A, section Yes for Preparation Procedure andof 5.2. "Signature the Pro Implemen No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to the Concessions Act, Article 61, No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Manual, No Sectionn/a Yes According 11.6.1(b), "contingency planning to is Yes the an important Concessions element Manual, Sectio of the co Yes No Section 73 of n/a the PPP Standardized Provisions n/a No concerns step-in Yes rights According by the institution to Yes the section lenders and by 60 thorugh of the the PPP Stand No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The grounds for the termination of the contr No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The Contract Management Guide, Part 9 dea No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 35.1 of PPP Act, the term Pursuant toYes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No Act, Chapter 14, §17 is devo The Concessions No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 42 of the PPP Law: A cont Pursuant toYes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Contract termination is regulated under Sect No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Clause 4(11) of the Standard Provisions Anno No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Article 43 of No n/a the PPP Law Yes that the PPPs stipulates Article public-private 45 of Yes the PPP Law provides partnership for the contract coi shall No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The PPP Law No. 2015-49 provides: (1) in its No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes According to Article 28 of BOT Implementatio No n/a Yes No According to Section 26(5)(z) n/a of the PPP Act, the Yes ThePPP specificYes grounds agreement for address must "direct agre the termination of t No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Article 17(4) of the PPP Law, the Pursuant toYes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 26 of the Dubai PPP Law provides tha Yes No Section 26 of n/a the standardization No of PF2 Contracts n/a recommends Yes direct Under theYes I. agreements to be used, and Standardization PF2 Contracts ofsection 26.6 se No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes § 33.2-1813 (A) of the Code of V Pursuant toYes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The PPP Law, in its article 51, establish sever No n/a Yes No According to Article 35 n/a of the PPP Law, According Yes <...> creditors and to No aArticle partner public 29 of thehave PPP the Law, <...>to right t No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes The Standard Works RfT provides (pp. 42-43) No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 52 of the PPP Law states on PPP contr No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Grounds forYestermination of agreement by co No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According toYesthe PPA, Section 89, "the groun No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Rules state in section 48 (i) that i The Tender Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes According toYesthe PPP Law, art. 13(8), "a [PPP Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q45 Q44.1_1_TEXT Q46_A Q46_B Q46_C Q46_D Q46.1 Q47 Q47_1_TEXT 45. If yes, please Please specify provide 46. and provide Are any unsolicited the Explicitly additional relevantallowed information Not proposals legal/regulatory/standard regulated by in [Field-Country] Not or the comments by regulated legalthe framework? legal If(PPP): on by framework, contractual the legal the the(choose answers legal framework 47. framework, provisions: but only Does do to the one) explicitly happen If procuring question(s) yes, Explicitly and in do please prohibits practice? not authority prohibited specify above happen orand allows conduct andin by indicate provide practic the unso an leg n/a n/a No Yes No No Yes Article 35 of the PPP Law Article provides the (1) 35 ofthat: PPP Law The provide Proponen Article 38 (3) Pursuant toComments Yesof the PPP No No the termination Law, following No of Starting the contract, from NoOctober 1st, n/a 2019, the government the concessionaire/private shall partnerwill acb n/a 65 of the Articles 64 and No No Concession No Decree provides different Yes grounds n/a No for termination n/a provide for compensation in and may n/a Comments No Yes No No Allowed by Yes article 7-A (procedure Article 7-A of private by the Regulations PPP initiative) o Comments Article 9.p of No states the the PPP Law Yes PPP Agreement No include a provision shall No on the Decree 966/2005 Yes grounds (Annex Articles I) establishes for termination 4 and 5,the Annex of the Private contract, I Initia of Decre n/a Comments No Yes No No Article 10(5) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of PPP Law, to Article 10(7) a legal of the person P (priv n/a According to Sections 25.6 No of Volume Yes3 and 24.3 Noof Volume No The National 7 of the National PPPYes Guidelines, PPP Guidelines This (a)Upondetailed isprovide termination, that in Section unsolicited the4private the of pro n/a Comments No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a Comments No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a n/a No Yes No No According to Yes the PPP Act, According to the art. 20(1), USP "any Guidelines, private organiz n/a Comments No Yes No No Article 15(2) Yes of the PPPChapter Law states, the Regulation 6 of "Any on Pr Legal entities, f n/a n/a No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a Art.72 of the No PPP Law provides: Yes (...) the termination No for serious No misconduct, fait Art.14 of du Yes the PPP prince Lawand Article of general provides: of the 21projects interest PPP likely Law: is to be a priva exe pronounc Article 21 of Pursuant toComments No YesConcession the Sarajevo No No Law, a concession contract Pursuant toYes shall specify: Article 20 20) of Pursuant the Sarajevo toand sanctions Article Concession fees20 for of failure Law, a the Sarat Comment The PPP Policy, No2, Sections Annexure Yes27 to 30 establish No No the a Summary clauses in According to Yes of the Standardized According PPP Policy, Section Contract to 6.13, the Provisions PPP "although Policy, Sect the for Publ Comments Article 35 of No Law (that the Concession Yes applies No to PPPs when Nothe matter Pursuant toYes Section is not regulated in3the of USP theEvaluation PPP Law) PPP Lawestablishes and procedurethat is outli thebt as regulated Comments No Section VI, "Concession Yes of termination" Contract: Effects No No of the Concessions Pursuant toYes Law, Article 55 Articles 150 of Pursuant -the 154, Concession to Article provides Law the57 consequence of <...> the Con The aw n/a Article 101 of No the PPP Decree Yes states that the contract No No the calculation specifies of Yes Unsolicited proposals the compensation are Article regulated due 62 to by PPP either Decree articles party states and 26 in the 33 that article 36.21 Pursuant ton/a No Yes of the PPP No Law, the contract shall No Articles include clauses 37 to Yes related to 50the consequences of the PPP Decreeproposals Unsolicited are of early relatedare toonly unsoli va termination, Comments According to of the PPP Law Article 42 No Yes "the PPP No No specifyPursuant Contract shall toYes Article 17 the circumstances for of contract Pursuant the PPPto Law, Article the 23 termination selection prior of the of its P to Law e Section 5 of Pursuant ton/a No Yes the Law 2006/012, No the contract must No includePursuant provisions toNo Section 5 consequences regarding n/a (2) of termination, of the Decree anti No. 2008/0115/P n/a Comments No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a Article 46 of No the PPP Ordinance provides: Yes No Nopartnership The public-private contract Article 25 and Yes shall 24 also determine of theArticle PPP Ordinance 26 the of the indemnities PPP Law unsolici regulate due in provide Comments Article 28, 28 No bis and 28 Concessions ter of the Yes NoLaw regulate No the effects of the Article termination 2 andYes Articles 4in According to 12 of the several to of the Concessions article cases and 4.2 Law of the(Tit Co manda 39 and 40 of Articles 38, Comments No for the Administration MeasuresYes No No of Concession Notice Thefor of Yes Infrastructure the Ministry and The of Notice Finance Public Utilities of the on -The Ministry in the concess of Fina Guidelines Comments Article 32 of No Termination PPP Law: Early No Yes Agreement. In PPP Nocontracts, Title III of it will included Yes be the PPP Law a clause is Title in section theIII which of PPPof the Law theindicates law that aspe allow mathematical f n/a Article 58 of No provides: the PPP Law Yes In the event Noof termination Article No of the contract 25 at provides: Yes the initiative public-private of the theArticle 45Contracting of the partnership PPP Law Authority, provide contra 0 No According to Article 140 No Procurement of the Public Yes Code, No except in cases n/a where termination No is decided at the initiative of the n/a Comments According to article 13 No of the PPP Regulations No if the procuring No Private Yes authority is responsible initiative No is not for the regulated n/a early termination, specifically in the the PPP r procuring the PPP Decree Art.26(o) ofn/a Yes No provides No that - PPP contracts No are drawn up in accordance Pursuant Art.22 toYes with of the the Art. regulations 22 Decree PPP in provides: : The force. (…) contracting unsolicited They conta p of the PPP Act Article 4(4) Comments compulsory YescontainsNo Nocontract subject No Article matter, including 9(1) No PPP the Act proscribes n/a consequences that of early only public bodyof termination e is th Comments No The Public Procurement No Act is silent on this matter. No However, Accordingis Yes certain guidance toNo provided the Public in n/a Procurement the PPP Manual. Act, Thus, §180(1), "a co the PPP M the Standard Section 4 ofn/a Nofor Construction NoPPP Model No states: Yes "If the contracting n/a No authority n/a terminates the contract, a financial article 46 of Pursuant ton/a No Yes The PPPNo the PPP Law, No determines the compensation Pursuantreceived Art 33.1. toYes ofArticle by eachthe party PPP in 23 of each Law: An the of PPP economic Decree the prov of te casesoper n/a Comments No Yes No No Law 47-20, the Yes PPP Law, Article 40 of Law establishes public-private that47-20, the PPP L n/a Comments No Yes No No According to Yes article 11 Article of the PPP Law, 21 of PPPPPP the the project c Regulations n/a Article 34 of Noprovides Yes the PPP Law No that the PPP contract must No include: Article "j. PPP contract 20 Yes of the PPP duration, Law The provides PPP Law cases of for early provides exceptional or partial in Article termi procu2 71, 72 and 73 Articles 70, Comments Yes Noof the PPP Law set procedures, No No conditions Theconsequences and PPP Law Yes has aof section Articles "Regimen 49 and termination. of50 Private of PPP Law est Initiative n/a n/a No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a Comments No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a Comments No Yes No No Chapter Nine Yes of the PPP Chapter Nine ofdeals Proclamation specifically the PPP Proclam n/a Comments No No No Yes authoritiesn/a ContractingNo shall not accept unsolicited prop n/a of the Public Article L.2235-1 No No Procurement Code No: In case of Yes n/a by a judge, termination n/a No the Partnership Contractor is entitled to c n/a Articles 64 of No the PPP Ordinance requires Yes No the procuring No to pay Sub-Section entity damages orYes financial 4 of the PPP compensations Ordinance Article 40 of the establish forPPP the Ordinance expenses a regulator r ex n/a Comments No Yes No No Yes Article 15 of the PPP Law Pursuant on "Initiative Proposals": to Article the 15 (3) of1. ApP Comments The Standard for Highways, Contract No No No§54 deals with the issue Yes of the legal No n/a consequences contract termination. of an/a provides in The PPP ActComments its Third Schedule, No Yes Section No 58 (11), No minimum regarding Section contractual Yes 55(1) of the PPP obligations Section Act, 2020 55 required (Act (6) theto of1039) PPP states beAct, specifie 202 that Comments Article 17(2) No of the PPP Law provides Yes <...> "Content No of Partnership No Article 1 The Contract." of Law Yes Partnership 4903/2022 Article defines Contracts 8 of Law and the 4903/2022 submission Ancillary Agreem of sta outlin Comments Article 143 of No the PPP Regulations,No indicates that No the contract Yes must establish n/a consequences. theNo n/a article 21 on Pursuant ton/a No Yes contract terminationNo for generalNo Art. interest, the holder 16 ofis the entitled NoPPP Law provides n/a to compensation that a covering the share Private Person ha article 88-2 Pursuant tocomments of the PP Law, No Yes shall indicate No the contract No the No cases, provisions conditions Noregarding n/a unsolicited and calculation damages depending of proposals are includ n/a Comments No Yes No No Yes The title II, Chapter IV of The the PPP Regulatory PPP Decree Regulatory inesta Decree its Article 2(8)No Pursuant toComment NoPublic Procurement of the Public No Act, Yes the provisions n/a No of Act on the Civil Code (the "Civil Cod V of 2013n/a n/a Article 37 of ConcessionNo the ModelYes Agreement No No refers to termination Ruleprovides and 162 (ii), No for consequences, General n/a Financial Rules, such as 2017 termination theprovides that n/a Comments No Yes No No Yes According to the art. 14According (2) of theto the art. 14 Regulation on PPPs, (3) a of the 0 No The Roads Construction No Article ByLaw provides: No51- After full Yesdepreciation or project expenses, n/a of planNo n/a subject of participation Public Contracts Law0 No No Yes No Although unsolicited No n/a proposals are not regulated by the Comments Articles 33.4(d), No 36.1(f),No 34.3, 35.4, No 37 to Yes 36.2(b), 36.3(b), TheTemplate 40 of Contract contributors No indicated n/a that the list consequences for termination NDFA follows the ofEU PP pro n/a Comments No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a According to No article 176 (4) of the Public Yes Contracts No Code, if No Article the concession is 183(15) terminated Yes of the forPublic Economic breachContracts of contract operators Code bymay the submit procurin provides th n/a Comments No Yes No No No Section n/a The PPP Policy, 9.0 is devoted to regulating the i aforementioned, Besides then/a Yes No the Standard No Agreement contains No the following provisions. Article 6, Yes 1 of Clause Article the Paragraph 60 Act PFI explicitly 1, Article (Termination allows Effects 6 of the prior PFI tA unsolic n/a Article 41 of No the PPP Regulation provides Yes that : No No "The PPP Contract must Article 12 of include Yes the basic the PPP terms Projects Article that 12 govern Law provides of the the PPP PPP that Projects “[a]ny Law Project, o e Article 16 (1) Pursuant toComments Yes Noof the PPP Law, a private No partner No to: 2) upon is entitledArticle Yes 44 of early the PPP termination Law Pursuant providesthe of to for Article public-private the possibility 44 (2) of partn the s to P Comments Paragraph 16 No Schedule of the Third to the PPPNo Yes No Act provides that the minimum Section 40 (1) Yesand (2) of requirements of Section the the PPP 40 Act (2) contract provides of the that shall PPP Act include A priva (1) stat The consequences of0 Notermination the Yesof the PPP Nocontract No are regulated The regulatory under Article Yes framework 37 of the A review for Basic PPP unsolicited of unsolicited PlansArticle proposals proposal is se 37 (Dete n/a Comments No No No Yes of the issue No mentionNo either in the PPP Law or Public n/a n/a Article 19 of Noprovides,Yes the PPP Law No "The Higher Committee No Article may approve termination the20 Yes of the PPPof Law the Article agreement 20 of "A provides, theat Concept PPP theLawproposer provide request of t Comments According to of the PPP Law, Article 17 No Yes in the event No of termination No the PPP agreement, of Pursuant Article 18 toYes the of According private the PPP Law: to Article partner 1.and/or In order 18 of the toproje the PPP test n/a Comments No Yes No No Yes Article 22 of the PPP Decree Article provides that 25 of the PPP Decree "[…] prov An unsol Comments Article 67 of NoregulatesNo the PPP Law compensation No in casesYes of early termination n/a the PPP agreement: ofNo n/a (1) The parties in a publ Law, According to the PPP0 No "<…> the Yesart. 10(12), NoPartnership No The Agreement PPP shall include LawNo the following: explicitly n/a in states <…> the(12) art.the procedure 4 that of PPP proje Article 60 of Pursuant toComments No Yes Law, No the Concessions the concession No agreement Article 13(10) must Yes include of the provisions Investment Article 4(1) Law regarding of allows the its PPP termination the submiss an Resolution article 47 of Pursuant ton/a No Yes in case of the PPP Law, No termination No for public Article 12 of interest, Yes the the procuring PPP Law Article 2015-039 entity must 12 the pay of and PPP article theLaw 28 require of Dec operator's Comments Without prejudice No to the Yes Parties to rights of the Noagree such Noterms and conditions According toof the Yesthe PPP PPP Act, According Section Contract as54 to they the (1), may "any PPP deem unsolicite Act, neces Section n/a Comments No No Yes No specific regulation There is no No n/a as to unsolicited proposal Law Article 34 of the PPP 0 Yes Nodescribes No the consequences of termination No for the8 Article andYes 14partner. private of the PPP Article Article Law, 24 25 II. asrequires aof derogatory the PPP thoseprocedu conseq Decree re n/a Section 48(b) No of the PPA provides that Yes upon such No a termination, No the contractor will Yes Section 3C(1) of bethe entitled PPPATheprovides toStep reimbursement by that step any process of expenses indicate person may, and 124 PPP Articles 123Comments No Yes Law complemented by NoArticles 124 No to 125 of the PPP PPPArticles Law Law YesRegulation. 26 to 37 Article and This27 regulation PPP Law and article Regulation include 28 of the Articl the PP rei Article 31 paragraph Pursuant toComments No No (2) of the PPP Yes Law, if theNo PPP contract n/a Noupon expiration has ceased n/a of its term, the private pa Comments According to No the Concessions Law, Yes art. 24.4, "an No No agreement Thehow shall specify Concessions theNo parties will Law, n/a art. be18 compensated is devoted to the for issue of u termination Comment Article 78 of No prescribes the PPP Law Yesthat In case No of expiration No or termination of to According Yes the the contract PPP Lawin Article accordance According 29, to the the with Concessions public contracti Law the provision n/a According to No of the PPP Article 26(4) YesLaw, the No contract determines No Article solely the of the Yes PPP Law 9indemnities in cases According provides of Force that to Majeure, the public Articles 9 of the the entity PPP distum Comments Article 44 of No the PPP Regulations Yes establishes that No if a PPP No is terminated, the private Article Yes 13 (5) party of PPP loses Law provides any 13 Article (5) that guarantee of Proposals PPP providedof to Law, and Art en PPP of the Public Section 127Comments No Procurement Yes Rules regards No No to be made payment while Article 11.8 Yes terminating of the PPP Policy procurement Article"Unsolicited 11.8 of contract the PPP Proposals" Policy by conven ide "Un Article 10.8 Pursuant ton/a of the DBFM No NoStandardYes Agreement: No In The Parties must the Netherlands determine Yes the compensation In the Netherlands unsolicited proposals referred are unsolicited not to in govern thispr A 0 No Part 19 The Standard PPP Contract, "Termination", Yes No No Section 78 "Consequences According of Yes Termination" to the Procurement According to Section Rules, to the Rule 79 Guide "Payment 15(j), to valid of Com aUSP, e “a n/a Comments No Yes No No Article 14 of Yes the PPP Law Pursuant to Article refers to 14 of unsolicited the PPP proposals n/a Article 50 of No The partnership the PPP Law: Yes contract No may provide No Art. for grounds termination, 40 of the Yes PPP Law in provides Art. 42 ofthat particular for:- the a PPP serious private Law breaches partner ca provides: T b n/a Comments No Yes No No Yes The Infrastructure Concession According to Paragraph Regulatory 3.2 of the Commission G Comments Applicable laws address thisNo do not No issue directly, No however, Yes n/a Article 2 of No the PPP Content n/aprovides that the contract wh Decree No for BOT, The Standard Bidding0Form Part 1 "General Yes No Conditions No of Concession According to Yes the PPP Contract", Section Regulations, According 27.1 provides Section to the PPP for 6 (1) Regulations the "Projec - compen Comments Article 74 of No the PPP Regulations No addresses economic No Yes applicable regime PPP Theto the Law termination does not of No n/athe PPP explicitly allow contract for reasons for unsolicited at pro n/a Comments No Yes No No the PPP Policy: Pursuant toYes According 13.1 The section toPPP 13.1 Policy of the P envisages Comments Article 104 of No Decree 4183/20: YesTermination "Early No of the contract No PPP due Law (articles to Public Yes 48-51) Interest. (...)Article In and Decree the case 49 PPP of of 4183/20 early Law: "Stages (articles terminationof1 Comments The Guidelines No for the design of PPP Yes contracts, No NoDirectorial approved by Unsolicited Resolution Yes proposals 001-2019-EF/68.01, The process ("Iniciativas provides Privadas") for evaluating further are regulat detai USPs i Comments Section 12.21 BOT Law IRR: (a) of theNo No events that Yes[…] For such No may lead Section to contract 10.1 of Yes the BOTSection Law termination, the IRR: contract Any 10.7 Agency/LGU of the shall BOT Lawmay IRR, provide a rem Article 10 of Pursuant toComments No No immediately the PPP Law, No after termination Yes of the public-private n/a No n/a partnership contract, the contracti Comments Articles 333, No of Public 334, and 335 NoContracts Code No 18 setYes out the consequences n/a for the termination No n/a of the contract. These ar n/a n/a No Yes No No No PPP Law: Article 4 of the "Each of the Government Agen n/a Article 38 of Pursuant toComments Nothe PPP GEO: No (1) At the No Yesof any public-private termination No It is not explicitly partnership regulated. contract n/a for any According Article 18(1) to reason, o the righ n/a Comments No Yes No No Chapter V of Yes the PPP Law Pursuant to article is related to PPP27 of the PPP procurement Comments The PPP Handbook No a segment provides Yes titled Contracting No Agreement The No PPP Handbook Guidelines, Yes which includes provides The ina1. PPP entire Handbook Key Commercial segment provides Terms, a en dedicated n/a Article 132.3 No of the Implementing Yes Regulations No specifically No "[t]he PPP states that Article Contract Yes 41 of the PSPshall Law, Article and 41.2 Articles define of the termination 134-140 PSP Law, of The andIm proceduresA Article 47 of Pursuant ton/a No Yes the PPP No the PPP Law, contract may Nobe terminated Article in Senegal 35 Yes of PPPif Law anyprovides Article of 104 for the the following of PPP possibility circumstances Decree for the oc provide Comments According to No Chapter Yes the PPP Law, No V, art. 54, "in the eventNo of a unilateral According to Yes theof termination PPP a public Law, According contract toII, Chapter the dueSection PPP to a Law, 6, art. fault of 19, a pu Chapte n/a Section 22 of NoregulatesYes the PPP Act No the consequences of PPP No Contract termination: Unsolicited Proposals Yes22. A PPP are Pursuant Agreementto Section regulated under shall stipulate Section 25 of the 60PPP how c of Comments Section 2.1.18 No (c) of the PPP Handbook No makesNo provision for Yes PPPs termination the incontract Singapore No due toinitiated are n/a private sector exclusively default. In these by the cir govern Comments No The Public Procurement No Act is not explicit about Nothe consequences Yes termination. ofn/a No the Procedure for Preparation an However,n/a n/a Comments No Yes No No According to Yes the PPP Act, According to the"a Article 34(1), public PPP Article Act, partner n/a n/a No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a According to No the Concessions Manual, Yes SectionNo 11.7.1(b), "the No concession contract Article Yes 80 of the shall Regulation Article include detailed explicitly 81.2 provisions of regulates the Regulation dealing pro wi unsolicite Comments According to No the PPP StandardizedYes Provisions,No section 61, No when either Party The has exercised NationalYes Treasuryits Practice According right to terminate to the Note № 11Practice of the 2008/2009 Note PPP on Agre Comments Article 280 of regulating the the LCSP No No YesEffects of termination No works 247.5 for publicArticle Yes concessions LCSP allows states: Article the 1. In247.5 the event presentation of LCSP. of of The private private init termination n/a According to No Management the Contract Yes Guide, No "a contract According Section 9, No to Yes may be terminated the Guidelines under According two ondistinct to the PPPs, Section situations Guidelines 237(a), namely on PP "Lin Article 35.1 Pursuant ton/a No of PPP Act,Yes the term of No No Contract the Partnership Unsolicited shall be No proposals agreed between n/a are allowed the Contracting under the Party PPP Act and th wh n/a n/a No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a n/a No No No Yes No The majority n/a of our contributors confirm that USP are ne Article 43 of Pursuant toComments No Yes an Agreement the PPP Law, No shallNo stipulate how Pursuant toYes Articledue compensation to 28 of Pursuant the either PPPto Law, party Article shall a contracting 28 be(2) calculated of the authP Comments Contract termination No Yes consequences are regulated No under Section No Section 101 of 16 Regulations: the PPP Yes of the PPP Act 101.-(1) Section as lastThe amended 16 parties of the PPP in shall Act 2019 astackle have a ra last Comments Clause 4(11) No of the "Standard No Provisions" Announcement No provides Causes Yes No termination, n/a of contract n/a method for contract term n/a Comments No Yes No No According to Yes Article 13 According of the PPPto Article Law, 13 of the Unsolicited PPP propo n/a Article 45 of Noprovides Yes the PPP Law for the conditions No No of termination Article of a PPP25 contract:"The of Yes public-private According the PPP Law states unsolicited to Article partnership 12 proposals the PPP as ofcontrac n/a Comments No No No Yes n/a No n/a n/a Comments No No Yes No n/a No n/a n/a The PPP Law No provides: No. 2015-49 Yes (1) in its Article No 34, that Nothe PPP contract is normally Article 55 Yes of the decree terminated According No 2016-772 byto the end of june Articleof 7 of the 20, Law 2016 No.p contrac Comments Article 28 of No the BOT Implementation No Decree, No and Article 61 Yesof the Highway Regulation provide n/a PPP No n/a that the consequences of Comments According to No of the Section 26(5)(z) PPP Act, the Yes NoPPP agreement No Section must 34(1) address Yes "theof grounds the PPP for Act termination provides, According to Section "A of contracting 34(5) the of the agreemen au Comments Article 17(5) Law contains of the PPPNo Yesa generalNo provision stating No that the legal Under consequences Yes Article 10 of the The of PPP assessment Law private terminating ais PPP partners a mandatory agreementre may su n/a Article 26 of PPP Law provides the Dubai No Yes that PPP No contracts Noshall include, "13. Article of 12The Yes the rules and Unsolicited Dubai procedures PPP Law provides, proposals for recovering "A Partnership fall un shall the Pr Comments Sections 23-25 No of Standardization No of PF2 Contracts No - (https://www.gov.uk/government/uploads/system/uploads/attachment_ Yes n/a No n/a § 33.2-1817 Pursuant toComments No Yes Code, the of the Virginia No responsible No public entity Pursuant shall to Yes § 33.2-1820 terminate the Pursuant (A) private to entity's (1.) of Section the Virginia authority 2.3.1 Code,the ofand is it dP Comments The PPP Law No establishes Yes certain situations, but No exhaust allThe it does notNo possibilities. the PPP LawYesin itsThe Chapter one Article that VII 36 it refers of PPP (articles to 34 Law to are: 38) stipulates establis Article t 52 n/a Comments No Yes No No Yes According to Article 15 According of the PPPto Law, <...>17 Article of the a PPP PPP projec n/a The Standard No Works RfT No provides (p. 42):5.10. No Payments on Yes n/a Termination termination (1) UponNo of the Contract, the Contractor n/a Comments Article 52 of the PPP Law PPP contract Nostates onYes Notermination: No "[...] 3. The contracting Section theauthority 2 ofYes PPP LawArticle expressly must report 27 the ofallowstoPPP the for LawUSPsonand competent Proc c According to the PPP Act, Comments Yes"an agreement NoSection 61, No shallNo stipulate how compensation According Yes to the PPP dueAct, to According either Section to 42(1), party the shall PPP "abe contracting calculated Act, Section a According to the Zimbabwe Comments No Investment Yes and Development No Agency ActThe No Zimbabwe [Chapter 14:37] Yes Investment section The 6 (2) Zimbabwe and Development "every joint Investment venture Agencyagree and AcD Rules state No The Tender Comments No in section 48 (i) that if the Yes winner fails No to supply goods or According to No provide services n/a within our contributors, specific unsolicited period ofare proposals tim According to the PPP Law, Comments Yes and (10), No art. 12(2)(8) No“a [PPP] agreement No According shall include Yes tothe thefollowing PPP Law, According essential art. 8(2), “a the toterms: PPP person <...> Law, who, a in proc (8)art. ac 8(5 Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q47.1 Q48_A Q47.1_1_TEXT Q48_1_TEXT Q48_B Q48_C Q48_2_TEXT Q49 Q48_4_TEXT isyes, 47.1. If yes, If please there any48. vetting provide Which the of Ifthe yes, relevant procedurefollowing please and/or legal/regulatory Thespecify options pre-feasibility regulatory and If best yes, framework provisions: describes please analysis provide The theprovide relevant before requires how procuring the the fully If legal/regulatory procuring yes, relevant unsolicited authority assessing please legal/regulatory authority 49. proposals does the Does provisions: unsolicited not elaborate the ensures evaluate and toprocuring beprovisions: provide among proposal? that unsolicited authority the example exist pr unsolicited Yes No Article 35 of the PPP Law n/a provides Yes that:(2) Unsolicited Law Noprovides The PPP Proposal is registered in n/a Article as Concept 35 Yes that:(1)of The Partnership Proponent shall subm Project afte No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Article 7-A of the PPP Regulations, n/a as amended No by Presidential n/a Yes Decree The 111/21 of No 29 April regulatory 2021: (Private framework does not state anp initiative Yes No I of Decree Article 2, Annex n/a 966/2005 No requiresn/a that to be considered No n/a the Private under Yes Initiative Regime, proposa Yes Article 10(6) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant Article No Law10(7) <....> of n/a The proposal the No PPP Lawof <...> Evaluation n/a PPP unsolicited of project the Yes shall be subject compliance proposal of the to wi evaluatio Yes Yes in Section This is detailed The4 NSW of the Unsolicited NSW No Unsolicited n/a Proposals Proposals Guide No Section Guide. It n/a 2.3 would an involves Yes initiala provide assessment basis. As such, proposal of the bid, an No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No According to the USP Guidelines, n/a Yes art. According 4(a), "the Original Proponent to No Guidelines, n/a the USPshall submit art. the Yes 4(c), "theNote Concept to the Contracti Contracting Authorit Yes Yes According to paragraphAccording 13 of the Regulation to No on paragraph 13 n/a Preparation of the Regulation Noof the PPP n/a on project, the Preparation Noof concerned the PPP project, procuring authority the concern No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Article 22 of n/a the PPP Law provides:Yes When the contracting Any unsolicited authority No decides n/a offer has to be to line Yes ingive awith favorable the Government action response to p the sp No n/a Yes Article 20 (8) Pursuant toNo n/aof the Sarajevo No n/a Concession The Cantonal Government may Law,Yes No Yes According to the PPP Policy, According Section to No5.2,PPP the “Government Policy, n/a Section Sponsoring No Institutions n/a 5.2, “Government Sponsoring have Yes the primary Institutions have thefor responsibility pri No n/a No n/a Yes Any ProjectNo must be approved n/a YesCPPI, that has to evaluate the by the Yes Article 56 of Pursuant toYes the Concession Pursuant toNo Article Law: 57 (1) n/a of TheConcession the proposal No referred Law:(1) n/aThe to Article Yes in grantor 55 shall herein for that ensure preparatory a concession awa Yes No Decree states Article 62 PPP n/a that where No the contracting n/a No authority n/a to examine decides Yes an unsolicited proposal, it m Yes article 33 of Pursuant toNo n/a the 2015 PPP No Law which Yesbe repealed n/a should not Pursuant ( onlyto the Yes article 33 of contrary the 2015 PPP provisions Law, not the 20a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No The PPP regulatory framework does not spec No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes No provision requires unsolicited proposals t No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No Article 25 of the PPP Ordinance n/a No that “an provides Yes proposal n/a unsolicited Article is an offer 26 of made the PPP No by Ordinance a natural or only specifie legal person Yes Yes According to Article 4 of Article the Regulation 2 of the No Concessions n/a for the Concessions Law provides NoLaw, that the n/a the assessment Ministry Public of Yes ofWorks unsolicited evaluate the must proposals p to b No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes framework does not state tha The regulatory Yes No Article 15 of the PPP Law n/a sets forth Yes Article that the public entity 15 and has No16 of the three n/a PPP Law months to review establishes Yes the prefeasibility study and the pre feasibility f subm Yes No Article 19 of n/aprovides: the PPP Law Nothat the Public n/a agency No n/a ( PPP unit) Yes in charge of advising, the coordination of ac No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No According to our contributors, the procuring No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes No provision requires unsolicited proposals t No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes article 22 of Pursuant toYes the PPP to Pursuant Decree: No articleIn accordance n/a 33.4. of the PPP with No Law, the provisions the n/a of decision ofarticle the No 33 of the PPP Contracting Law, the Authority Spont to pursue Yes No The PPP Law in its articles n/a34-38 establishes No n/aconditions solid Yesto present Although PPPs by private Yes the law does initiative, not evaluate then, the regula the cons Yes No Article 21 of n/a the PPP Regulations (Executive Yes Article Decree 21 of 1190) No provides: the PPP Regulations n/a the presentation "For Yes (Executive of Decree a private initiative, 1190) provides:th No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Noregulate n/a Articles 49-50 No of the private the obligation n/a party Yes to present a Nothing prefeasibility Yesframework in the that, if the study. Afterappears autho to regulat No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Chapter Nine of the PPP Chapter Proclamation Nine Noofdeals the PPP specifically n/a Proclamation with No Unsolicited n/aProposals. deals specifically Yes with It Unsolicited states:42/ Proposals. Unsolicited state ItPropo No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No proposaln/a An unsolicited is only valid No n/a is not inYes if the project Anof any program unsolicited the government Yesproposal is only (article 39 of the valid Ordin if the pr Yes Article 26 (2) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of Resolution toNo Article No. 426, n/a 26(3) the of Resolution initiative No proposal No. 426, shall uponbe n/a formulated Yes acceptance ofto the allow for Initial a prelimin Proposal an No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Section 55 (6) Section of the PPP Act, 2020 55 (3) No (Act the PPP of 1039) requires Act, 2020 n/a a Preliminary No (Act 1039) Review requires n/a of the Yes that the unsolicited unsolicited proposal proposal to be in the forc Yes Yes According to According Article 7(3) of Law 4903/2022, to No of n/a Article 9the Law unsolicited 4903/2022, Noproposal must n/a contain, the Committee Yes for among the Assessment of following others, the el Unsolicited No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Pursuant toNo article 16 of the PPP Law n/a Yes- A Private Person has the pos No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a Yes Article 20 of No n/a the PPP Law Yes states that "the presentation, evaluation, No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No According to the art. 14n/a (4) of the Regulation Yes According on to No PPPs, a business the art. entity 14n/a that (3) of the submits Regulation Yes an unsolicited on PPPs, infrastructure proposal shall No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No provided that in practice th Our contributors No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes According to According Article 183(15) of the to Noarticle Public 183 n/a Contracts (15) Code, of theNo the Public Contracts n/aauthority procuring Code:Yes "The mustfeasibility evaluate the feasibility project, of possibly No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes No n/a Yes No Paragraph 1, Article 6 requires n/a private business the No Yesto submit a proposal of the pr n/a operator Yes No Article 12 of n/a Law provides the PPP Projects Yes that Article “[a]ny entity 12 No of the from PPPthe Lawprivate provides n/a Yes sector thatshall “[a]ny have thefrom entity to submit right the privat Yes No According to the 725 Rules Item 15 ofn/a of the development No in cases n/a Yes of There a business is no plan direct Yes requirements for to evaluate the PPP projects a by a priv Yes Yes (2) of the Rule 53(1) and Section PPP Regulations: 25(2) No "(1)The of the PPP Act n/a Unit applies shall No review to all PPP a privately n/a projects,initiated whether No investment proposal made procured competitively or No n/a No n/a Yes No under n/a This is regulated of the PPP Decree, "where the c Article 7 (3)Yes No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes Article 1(3) No of the PPP Law n/a defines No n/a" a concept "Concept" as, Yesfor a PPP Project comprising a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes framework does not contain The regulatory Yes No Article 25 of the PPP Decree n/a provides: Yes “The Submission ofNo Article 22 andthe Consideration PPP Decree n/a of Unsolicited Yesthat "[…] provides An unsolicited Proposals propo for Partnership No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to Article 4(1) n/a of the PPP No n/a Resolution, Yes unsolicited proposals are implemented in a Yes article 28.3Pursuant Pursuant toYes of PPP Decree toNo article 2017-149,of if 28.1n/a PPPtheDecree public No 2017-149,decides person n/awhen to within continue Yes the framework of the article with the unsolicited pro Yes Yes According to According the PPP Act, Section to 54 No (2),PPP the Act, n/a "once the Section Commission No 54 receives (3), “if the n/a assessment the Unsolicited Yes Bid, it shall consult and consultation with t in subsection No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No PPP Law Article 9 of the in particular n/a 0 Yesto be prepared Norequiring an evaluation Unsolicited before Yes proposals procuring a PPP cannot is part be of the i consequent Yes No Sections 3C(3)-(4) of the n/a PPPA provide Yes that on The step receipt by of aNo step project, process n/a the contracting indicates:Yes The authority contracting within 15 will shall, authority workiex Yes No According to Anyone interested article 26 n/a Yes in carrying Article 29 a No outof the public-private PPP Law establishes n/a Yesthat partnership project "The may evaluation submit their of pro unsolic No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a Yes No According to the Concessions n/a Law, No art. 18.3, "in case of a locally-owned n/a Yes concession item, th No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yes Article 29 of the PPP Law devoted to regulati Yes No According to Article 37 n/a of the PPP Decree, No n/a unsolicited Yes offers must notThe consist PPPof aYes law is silent. project which Unsolicited was previously pre proposals a No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes Yesauthority does not evaluate un The procuring Yes No Section 28 of the PPP Act: n/aUnsolicited Yes Proposal: Article 11.8No of the PPP Notwithstanding anything Policy n/a contained Yes in the "Unsolicited Proposals": prevailing (3) law, a propo In case Pro No n/a No n/a Yes It is the Ministry No of Finance's n/a policy to consider PPP projects for gov Yes Yes Yes According to the Guide According to USP, “agencies to No haven/a the Guide considerable to No USP, “agencies flexibility haven/aconsiderable and Yes discretion flexibility to design their and own processes discretion to des Yes No Article 10 of the PPP Regulations n/a Yes establishes Article all the technical 9 of the No and PPPeconomic n/a information Regulation Yes the outlines atprocedures pre-feasibility which must level tha Yes No Art. 42 of the n/a PPP Law provides : that Yesif the unsolicited the Art. 42 ofbidNo isPPP accepted, Law provides: n/a The No the contracting Public-Private authority shall Partnership Supp refer the m No n/a Yes No According to Paragraphn/a 3.2 of the Infrastructure No n/a Yes Concession Regulatory Commission Guidel No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No According to the PPP Policy, n/a Section Yes L, the third to fifth steps According No to the in PPP the process n/a Section Policy, Yes for unsolicited L, the sixth proposals step in include:� 3. P the process f No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a Yes not currently exists an explicit re There does Yes Yes No Article 48 of the PPP Law n/a provides No n/a that the Public-Private Yes PartnershipWhile Project the regulatory Yes Unit entitled to receive, shall be framework does not inc inst Yes Yes Article 77 of the PPP Regulations For both self-financed establishes No and n/a the co-financed minimum No content USPs,of articles the USP. n/a and Yes 79 This 80 is the of the PPP Regulations admissibility esta stage ("adm Yes section 10.1 Pursuant toNo n/a of the BOT No n/aAgency/LGU Law IRR, any Yes may accept Pursuant Unsolicited toYes Section 10.3 ofon Proposals a BOT the Law IRR negotiated b No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes article 27 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a Yes In case of Pursuant an unsolicited article toNo 25 of proposal n/a the forPPPs Law, a PPP project, No unsolicited the partner, proposals are on its ac own Yes No The PPP Handbook provides n/a a entire Yes dedicated segment The to No PPP Handbook this, titled provides n/a UnsolicitedYes a entireProposals segment Guidelines, dedicated to and provid this, title Yes of the PSP Law, Article 41.2Yes and Article 139 Articles of Nothe137-140n/aof TheRegulations Implementing No Implementingof n/a PSP Regulations Yes Law sets out set out thethe areas basis verification of for by the Contra Yes Article 21 of Pursuant toNo n/a PPP Law, before Yes the UNAPPP Pursuant toNo Article delivers its 21 advisory of n/a PPPopinion Yes on the Law, before the prior UNAPPP assessment, its deliversit ad sho No n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/a art. 19, "within the PPP Law, Yes 90 days of the receipt of Yes Section 60 n/a Pursuant toNo No a feasibility of the PPP Act, required for n/a study isYes There all USPs: are no 60. Yes A contracting provisions authority for the may of evaluation re No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No According to n/a the PPP Act, Article 34(3), Yes "an application According to for an Nothe interest PPP Act, in Article n/a 34(3), Yes "anof implementation application a PPP must be for conside an intere No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes of the Regulation Article 81.2No No that "[i]f n/a provides n/a Yes of the the acceptance Article Unsolicited 80.1 Yes Proposal of is approved the Regulation by the provides IM that"I Yes No According to n/a the Practice Note on Unsolicited No n/a Proposals, section Yes 2.1 (a), The PracticeYes Note institutions are on not obliged to consider Unsolicited an Proposals, s No n/a No n/a Yes Based on the No n/a evaluation Yesof Article 247.5 of the LCSP requirement Yes No According to the Guidelines n/a on PPPs, Yes According Section 237(a), to "LineNo Ministries, the Guidelines na Agencies and Yes on PPPs, NAPPP Sectionreceiving 237(a), "Line Ministrie unsolicited pr No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Article 28 (2) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant toNo Section Law, after 7 of n/a Resolution preparing No a No. feasibility 81, whenstudy n/a for an selecting Yes unsolicited PPP projects, the project proposal provid and receivi Yes No Section 16 of n/a the PPP Act as last amended Yes Regulations in 2019 unsolicited tackles No 62 (3) (d) of n/a proposals: the PPP Regulations, Yes Unsolicited "16. 2020 bids require (1) The the cont privat No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes No According to Article 13(d) n/aof the PPP NoLaw, unsolicited n/a Yes can only proposals There be has considered No no been and evidence assessed that they are (d if nsolicted p Yes No According to Article 12 n/a of the PPP Law No and Article n/a 14 of the PPP Decree Yes TheofPPP 2022.More lawYes is silent. precisely, Unsolicited 12 of the P Articleproposals a No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes of Government Article 55.3 Yes Decree Article 57 of NoDecree No. No.n/a 2016-772 2016-772 of June 20, No provides on n/a 2016, thatthe "Inconditions the event Yes that the unsolicited and procedures proposa for awarding No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Section 34(4) Section of the PPP Act provides 34(4)(a) No where the of the n/a project PPP Act provides satisfies No that objectives n/a thean of unsolicited Yes the proposal shall National only be consider Development Plan Yes section 13 (of Pursuant toNo n/athe procedure Yes for conducting According an to No Article 11 analysis of n/a of the effectiveness the Law, unsolicited PPP Yes proposals, of public-private the sa partnersh Yes No Dubai PPP Manual provides n/a on p. 86 Yes under "2.Aforementioned No Proposal by the Private Articlen/a 6 Sector Dubai No PPP and of theCompany", Law in and accordance Dubai PPP Man with A No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Section 2.3.1 Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the PPTA toNo Section Implementation of the PPTA 2.1n/a No Manual Manual and Guidelines, and n/a Guidelines, Yes all90 within projects: calendar solicited days of receiving and unso Yes No According to of the PPP Law, Article 36 n/a n/a No the proponent of the Yes private initiative While the regulatory Yes shall along withdoes provideframework not inc the initiate Yes No defining Without formally n/ait as a vetting Yes procedure There is a or nopre-feasibility No specific requirement n/a analysis, orYes PPP Law contains obligation aPPP-related in the req preliminary reg No n/a No n/a No n/a No n/a No Yes Yes Article 27 of Article the PPP Law on Procedures 26 of the PPP No Law n/a for preparation provides: of Noinvestor-proposed n/a of anPPP Requirements investor-proposed Yes projects provides: PPP project “1. 1. An Procedure Yes According toNo n/a the PPP Act, Section 42(2), Yes "a contracting authority According No to the PPP shall, Act, n/aSection within days Yes after 14 42(1)(b), "a receiving an unsolicited contracting authority Yes The Zimbabwe Zimbabwe Yes Investment and Development Investment No and n/a Development Agency Act № No10/2019 Agency n/a [Chapter 14:37] No 14:37] Act [Chapter provides section in section 5: Unsoli 2 states: (3)Th n/a n/a No n/a No n/a No No regulatoryNobasis No n/a No n/a Yes According to No n/aart. 8(7)(3), the PPP Law, Yes "a decision of a public partne Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Boolean Q50 Q49_1_TEXT Q50_3_TEXT Q50_4_TEXT Q51_A Q51_B Q51_C Q51_D Q51_E 50. If yes, please Does the provide the If procuring yes, relevant legal/regulatory and please provide authority the time the grant 51. in relevant calendar a Does provisions: minimum the51.2. procuring days: period legal/regulatory Developer’s 51.3. authority of time provisions: Bidto fee use Bonus. (reimbursing additional 51.4. any of the Swiss challenge 51.5. the prospective following original Other(If bidders proponent incentive unsuccessful, (besides mechanism forthe the the pr p or Yes Article 35 of The the PPP Law provides same rules that: that Unsolicited apply (2) 30 Proposal No to solicited No proposals is registered No applyas unsolicited No toConcept of Partnership ones No in thisProject regard.after the Hence, appro Article n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No Yes No No No Yes Article 6 of Decree 966/2005 No. Section 8, Article establishes 12, 60 that Yes the Annex competent Yes I Decree 118, states authority Yesthe must No call for tender last publication No of the within call for days ofshould 60 tender be at the approva No 10(5) of Pursuant Article the PPP Law n/a n/a<...> TheNo regulationsYes envisaged No shall be applicable by this Law No No to an unsolicited PPP proj and Part 2 of Section 1.3 No n/a n/a the NSW Unsolicited No Proposal Guide No provides No No Government that the NSW No may subject unsolicited pro n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes According to The rules applicable the USP Guidelines, art. 42 11(a)(i), to "based No the regular No solicited on the outcomeproposals Yes of the further apply alsoNo to the preparatory Yes unsolicited works carried out during proposals. the Thus, acc n/a No n/a n/a No Yes No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes Art. 22 of the Art.24 of the PPP Law provides: 63 When PPPthe Law provides No that contracting authority No unsolicited decides Yes to give No proposals a favorable are subject Yes to response competition spontaneous to theunder off the condit Article 20 (8) Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the Sarajevo to45 ArticleConcession 40 (1) Noof the Public Law:No if the Procurement Cantonal No Government the contracting Law, No No the renders authority unsolicited shallproposal be under obli justif Yes According to According the PPP Policy, to the Section 6.13, PPA "<...> 42 Nothe PPP Policy Regulations, No does Section 28(6), not No“the pre-qualification exclude No unsolicited proposals No period shall but rather requires be no less 14 d than that Yes framework Brazil's regulatory 21 of the Law Sectionestablishes 45on that No once Public Procurement Yes as unsolicited proposal provides No is filed, No that theminimum the procuring No term authority until has receipt the the of the obligation Article 56(6) Pursuant toYes of the Concession Pursuant to Article 93 30 Law, of Nothe Concession the Yes under proposal Law:paragraph (2) NoThe time 1 shall limit not No give for the receipt Norise to of any other an rights or application a com in privil Yes Art.65 PPP Decree: contracting The Pursuant to authority Article 66 45initiates of Yes the PPP Decree, No a procedure where for No selecting the Noprivate the contracting authority partner Yes in accordance intends with to seek the pro comparativ Yes Article 49 of Article the PPP Decree mentions 8 of the PPP the Agency Decree 90 No is requires free to Yeschoose at the least 90Yes days procedure between No adopt. No to sending the tender notice and the limit d n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Section 5 and Pursuant toYes 17 (2) to Pursuant of20 Section the Decree 5 and No. No (2) ofNo the Decree 172008/0115/PM, the Yes No. procedure No targeted 2008/0115/PM, in No the procedure Sections 12 and 15 of targeted Sections in the prese n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No of the Concession Article 9(6) No n/a n/a Regulations states Nothat "within Yes one year Yes No from the approval No Proposal, the DGC will call a p of the Yes The Notice of PPPof the Ministry Procurement Finance 21 on The 2014,No article 6:for Guidelines No time PPP between Operations, No article the notice and No 6 and submitting 13 No - All proposals not be lessby bids shall submitted the1 than 17, 19 and 20 Articles 16, Yes of PPP Article and 19 17 Law andof 180 articles PPPNoLaw and Articles Yes and 2.2.2.1.5.9. 2.2.2.1.5.9. 2.2.2.1.5.12. Yes and 2.2.2.1.5.11 Yes of the PPP Regulations No of the PPP (Decree 1082/2015) Regulations es (Decree 1 Yes Article 45 of Article45 the PPP Law provides: of45 the PPP candidate No Law may submit provides: Yes the candidate an unsolicited No mayofferNo to an submit theunsolicited Contracting No Authority offer Contracting to the for A the implem n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes According to Article Art. 22: PPP contracting 79 of the based Public onNo 45 an unsolicited Procurement NoCode proposal refers No to Articles gives No in, in 63 and 64 principle, a Nocall for and tenders sets or a competitive a minimum deadline of n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No Yes Yes Articles 40-44 The unsolicited of Law 47-20, the PPP Law, proposal establish 45 Noshall be there that Yes would taken as the be basis Yesa competitive No for the process selection No of the for bids in accordance unsolicited with the proposals. Yes Article 24 of Article 25 of the PPP Regulations (Executive the PPP 90Decree No 1190) Regulations (Executive Yes provides:Decree "The Yes procedure provides: 1190)No selection for the"The No delegating and contracting entity shall of the p ensure n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes Article 50 of According to PPP Law: "statements of 60Article interest 50 shall No of the PPP be Law, Yes the published one PPP-Unit single No time in Yes two (PROESA) and national the No newspapers, Procuring as well Authority as in the promote th n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes Chapter Nine General of the PPP Proclamation Procurement 45 deals specifically No Directive with provisions No Unsolicited apply, Yes Proposals. NoAnnex specifically It states: 3, No 1.1(e) 43. Procedure depending Unsolicited foron Prp the type of n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No No Article 40 of n/a the PPP Ordinance n/a that the states No author of the No proposal No No in the bidding can participate Yes process. Article 15(4) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant to Article Law, the 19(4) 30selection No of a Yes private of Resolution No. 426, partner, Nothe application making after No for a the decision No on the intention the concessionaire of implementation of n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes of the PPP Section 55 (17) Act, 53(1)(b) Section 2020 (Actof1039) the 42 No states Public that; Yes Procurement Where Act the NoCommittee provides Yes approves that the procurement No the feasibility entity shall the study, contract allow tende Yes This legal framework As per a initiates the competitive provisions 100laid PPPYesprocurement out in Article Yes procedure 12, paragraphs 4, 5, No in which Nointerested and 6 of Law No parties 4903/2022, it is mandatory are required fo to submit an n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No article 17 of Pursuant toNo the PPP Law: n/a n/a the stages No of the procedure No the submission forNo No No and negotiation of the Spontaneous Off n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes The following According articles of the PPP Regulatory to the PPP 30Regulations, No regulates Decree Yes the Article 44, competitive g), No procedure the term for the submission Yes No to required of procure a PPPof expressions interest originated n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No No Provisions of n/a the LKPP Regulation n/a 19/2015 continue No to be No applicable to Yes Yes PPP proposals the unsolicited Yes as explained in Q2. Acco n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes Article 183 (paragraph Articles 15) 79Public of the and 183(15) Contracts 30 No of the Public Code Yes provides Contracts for a Code basis provides No Yes for the competitive rules on No procedure the period minimumwhen for additio proceeding w Yes According to According the PPP Policy, to 90 Section 9.0, the PPP Policy, No "in the event that Section No the 9.0.1, theNo Challenge proposal Process Yes meets the PPP criteria consists Noand the following of Cabinet stages "<...> has approved the No authority The procuring sets a certain n/a n/a period for Noadditional No submit their bidders toNo No in accordance with the Procurem proposalsNo No Article 12 of n/a the PPP Law provides n/a that “[a]ny entity Yes from Yes sector shallNo the private Yes No to submit a PPP Project conce have the right Article 44 (3) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant Law, if to Article 138 60 the Nonumber of of No Order No.offers 725, in from the Noabsence of potential No private alternative partners Yes proposals exceeds the need received for goods, from potent n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes under Pursuant This is regulated to90 Article 9 of Article the PPP7Act (8) No (3) :of When the the Decree, PPPNo competent this Yes authority time tohas is setNo decided at least 30 No days; to promote however, the project this propo period is e n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes Article 56 of The general the PPP Executive Regulations 90 provisions provides, Noper Article as Authority "TheYes23(2) of the shall YesPPP Executive No Regulations in collaboration Yes with the Public apply, Entity(is) stated in which provides, th ""Th Yes According to of the PPP Article 18 Pursuant Article toLaw, in the 12(2) 30 event No that of the the PPPNo Law, Cabinet <...> of the No tender commission MinistersNo of the Kyrgyz No carries Republic makes out the an appropriat collection of appl No Article 25 of n/a provides: the PPP Decree Yes n/a “The Submission and Yes Consideration No Yes of Unsolicited No Proposals for Partnership Projects[... n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No of the PPP Resolution Article 4(1) Yes The general rulesto refers on30 the procuring application No PPPsNo of would the general No according apply rules on PPP Noto Article procurement No 4-1 of Resolution with Nounsolicite regards to 1480 on Yes According to of the PPPto article 12 According article Law, if the 40 12 No of the PPP procuring Law, entity Yes decides if the procuring No to accept an Nounsolicited entity to decidesNo proposal, accept an unsolicited PPP proposa bidding process i No According to n/a the PPP Act, n/a Section 55 (1), “where Noa feasibility No study is conducted Yes No following No the approval obtained under section n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Of the PPPPursuant Article 25 II.Yes to45 article Decree requires unsolicited 12 II. No proposal Of the No PPP Decree, to be procured bidders No shall as projects Nogranted be at No initiated least by 30 the public days authority. from the notice r Section 3C Pursuant Pursuant toYes PPPA, (8) of the to Section the30 3C contracting (8) of the No PPPA, Yes the authority shall contracting Yes follow the No procedures authority No shall relating follow the to the invitation procedures for requ relating t Yes31 establish Article 30 and that Article 31 the 28 if of the procuring Noentity PPP which considers stating Yes that that thetime project Yesperiods will No it suitable will be applied proceed No as if to was a regular ithold bid link public tender it app n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes According to According the Concessions to Law, 60 art. the18.4, "if No Concessions the Government, Law, No art. 18.4, the No Citizens' "if Representatives No the Government, the Citizens' YesKhurals of aimags or the Representatives capita Khurals Yes According to If the decision the Concessions is IV, Law, Part made Section 30 that No 5, Article the Yes unsolicited 41(3), proposal "if No the Competent Noproceeded shall be Nowith, Authority estimates the same that the initiative rules apply to ist Yes According to According Article 9(4) to Law of the PPP and Article40 12(4) No of 40(3) the of PPP the PPP Yes Decree, Decree,No the the procuring general No entity may procurement Norules resort to the apply, competitive the dialo deadlines are a Paragraph 5 of article 13 No of the PPP n/a n/a Law and paragraphs No and 3 of article 2No No PPP Regulation Yes 14 of the No provide for a competitive No 11.8(7) Pursuant Article "Unsolicited n/a Proposals" n/a Yesof the PPP Yes No Policy, after appraisal of suitabilityYes Noan unsolicited proposal done by Yes Assuming the Pursuant procuring authority towill 30 Article be considered 2.71 of theaProcurement No No 'contracting authority' Act: No 1) For (aanbestedende No procedures, public Nodienst) the period as defined for the submissio in article 1.1 No According to to USP, the n/a the Guiden/a unsolicited No unique proposals No No tree, the decision No No demonstrate that an unsoli following steps Yes Article 14 of Article 30 of the PPP Regulations 120 the PPP indicates that Regulations after the sets No Yesa minimum unsolicited proposal Yes period has No been of days (after No the 120 accepted, theproject request for will offers) be to p procured n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes Paragraph 2.2 Section of the ICRC Guidelines 25 (2) on of the Unsolicited 42 No Procurement Public Proposals No provides Act provides No for Yes that "The overarching publication "not No principle less than is that weeks six all before p unsolicited t n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No No of the n/a Section 14(A)(4) n/a PPP act as amended provides No "a private party that:No No a proposal No may submit Yes for a project on an unsolicit n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No No According to n/a section 13.2 n/a of the PPP Policy, the No No process for No of an unsolicited consideration No Nowill be defined in due course. H bid Yes Art. 49 of PPP Article Law: "Article 4949 - Stages of PPP Law: of 90 private the No "Stages initiative of the Yes process. private YesThe processing initiative No The process. of private processing No initiatives include of private the followi initiatives incl Yes According to of the PPPto article 88 According article 90 Regulations, 88 No of interested Yes third parties the PPP Regulations, interested Nohave a period Yes third of ninety No parties have (90) calendar a period of days from ninety thecale (90) da Yes Section 10.13 Pursuant of the BOT Law IRR: toInvitation Section84 for No 10.13 of the BOT No Law Comparative Proposals IRR:No […] Within seven it shall Yes (7) calendar indicate time, theNo days which from the receipt should earlie not beof the n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes The PPP Handbook The PPP provides a entire Handbook 45segment provides: dedicated No to Yes Proposal this, is accepted titledNo In case the No Unsolicited proposal Proposals No Guidelines. meets a priority need It states: and procu 1. Objective Yes Article 140 of The Implementing the Implementing Regulations Regulations 84 Yes that privides Yes : "1. of PSP Law The provide No in Article Contracting Authority No79 forshall bidders No tocompleting upon the Business be given sufficient time tC Nothe PPP Decree Article 105 of n/a that: "[t[he n/a provides No contracting No authority Yes may, pursuant No No to the provisions of Article 28 of Law Yes According to According the PPP Law, toII, Chapter the Section PPP60 6, No Law, Chapter Article 19, Yes II, "if an unsolicited Section No 6, proposal Article 19,No "if an is unsolicited considered No to be in aispublic proposal interest considered b to a Yes Article 60 of Section the PPP Act requires 24 implementing of the Public 42 No USPS in accordance Procurement No Law establishes with No good governance Yes that and "the procuring No general entity shall public procurement set the deadliner n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes According to If aArticle the PPP Act, public 35(1), authority "a person decides 30 No who to carry hasNo submitted No an application out a competitive procurement No for an interest procedure Yes in implementing a PPPpart to select a private sha n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No of the Regulation Article 81.3No n/a that "[…a]n n/a provides No Unsolicited No Proposal Noshall be awarded No No pursuant to the same processes and Yes According to According the Practice Note onto Unsolicited the Treasury 21 Proposals, YesRegulation, Yes section section 16 the 5, if No A.6.3(c), unsolicited the proposal No No agreement accounting officer oris an accounting concluded, auth then t paragraph of The second Yes Article There is not 247.5 30 a specific LCSP states No that In procedure Yes the for private eventinitiatives. that No the feasibility No study However, No culminates general rules for in the granting concession public of of the Yes According to According the Guidelines to 90 on PPPs,the Section 237, No in Guidelines respect on PPPs, NoSection of the unsolicited 237(a), No "LineNo Ministries, proposals, No “once Agencies the need andis determined NAPPP the un receiving re n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Article 28 (2) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant Section to28Law, after 80 No of preparing of Yes Annex 1 a Resolution feasibility No study 81, an No. for No theunsolicited procurement No noticeand proposal to be published hasreceiving recomm n Yes Regulation 62 (1) of the PPP The Regulations minimum period 2020: 90of62.-(1) No Pursuant time for additional Yes to section bidders Yes 15 submit toof Yes the their Act, all proposals unsolicited No is public private provided partnersh in the Public P n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No No Article 14 paragraph of the PPP n/a 14n/a Decree provides No that "[…]If No the contracting No No authority No to proceed with the unsolicit decides n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Yes paragraph Article 11 sixth of Law Article No. 10 of Decree 2015-49 20 No. of No November 2016-772 No (Decree 27, 2015, No.Yes 2016-772 on of No 20 June public private partnership 2016, No about the conditions contracts and th provides that pr n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No No According to n/a of the PPP Section 34(6) n/aAct, "where No the contracting No No authority No an unsolicited accepts Yes proposal, the proposal sha Article 14(1) Pursuant toYes of the PPP Pursuant to60 Procedure Law, the PPP No procurement 384, Yes partner the public procedure No mustis publish No the announcement competitive (except No for certain of the competition cases inby specified t n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No Section 4.13 Pursuant toYes Pursuant of the PPTA to120 Section Manual and No 4.13 of Guidelines, the PPTA NoManual the procuring No Guidelines, and No alaunches authority Noa deadline of competitive procurement 120-day period pro for submiss Yes According to of the Article 36 The PPPPPP Regulatory Law 45 and Decree No 51 Article of the Yes indicates PPP in its Regulatory article Yes56 that the No once Decree, the public request No Procuring for proposals will Entity has be publi received th Yes According to of the PPPto Article 17 According Article Law, <...> 45 17 in No the of event the Law, Yes the PPPthat <...> private 45 Nocalendar days initiator passes No are the given No initial for the potential in qualification accordance bidders to exp n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No No Article 26 (2) n/a of the PPP LawProjectsn/a proposedNo Yes shall be by the investor No No open No procured under bidding or competitive negotiatio According to No n/a the PPP Act, n/a "a contracting Section 42(6), Yes authority No No shall, Yes proposal if an unsolicited No complies with subsection (1), n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No n/a No n/a n/a No No No No No According to the PPP Law, Yes art. 10(8), According “if a to the PPP decision 45 Law, No art. the No implementation on 10(10), No of "in the event that, a project within No is made 45 Yes days from on thethe basis date a proposal of of posting a dec on t Q51_6_TEXT Q51_5_TEXT Q52 Country QREFORM_1_TEXT QREFORM_1 QREFORM_2_TEXT QREFORM_2 Are you Descripti Are Descripti aware of on ongoing on Please provide please specify: 52. Please the relevant provide Country legal/regulatory information or comments on the answers to the question(s) above a any additionalprovisions: any and/or n/a n/a n/a AfghanistanNo n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Albania Yes The No n/a n/a n/a n/a Algeria No Parliamen n/a Yes A new PPP law is being drafted n/a Comments Article 7-B of Angola the PPP Regulations, as amended Yes Presidential by Presidential No Decree Decree No. 316/19 n/a 111/21 (Regulation of 29 April 2021: of the Law on Public-Pri (Reimbursement f n/a Article 8, 9 and Comments 10, Annex of Decree Argentina Yes No. 966/2005 Provision 2/2019 refers Nothe of to terms n/a and conditions ofof the Undersecretariat Public-Private a Bid Participa Bonus, access to the Pursuant toPursuant Article 10(12) of the Article toComments Armenia 10(11) PPP of the Law <...>Yes PPPIf only Law <...> The Thelaw a business on Public-Private Yes is attached Government case to July In Decree Partnership on thethe unsolicited wasPPP ofin adopted project implementation Armenia proposal, the on Ju the PPP project n/a n/a n/a Australia Yes Equator No 2022 n/a the n/a n/a Comments Austria No Principles n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Azerbaijan No n/a Yes Currently, According to According n/a the USP Guidelines, to art. BangladeshNo the USP Guidelines, 13(a), "where n/a aggregating the "when art. 17(b), Bidding Process Noinvolves the n/a draft score for pre-qualification the evaluation the and Proposal orthe shortlisting, submi BidUnsolic n/a Comments According to Belarus No n/a Yes On Article 15 (2) of the PPP Law, the winner of the Tender shall reimburse the legal entity, the foreign o n/a n/a n/a Belgium No n/a No January n/a Art.24 of who When the candidate n/a the PPP submitted Law provides: Benin the unsolicited No the tender holder of the n/a does unsolicited No bid not come participates first inn/a the ranking, in thehe invitation to tender or she shall under the may exercise th n/a n/a No Comments Bosnia and Herzegovina n/a Yes The n/a n/a Comments Botswana Yes No The Public Procurement Sarajevo Act entered into force on April 14, 2021, La n/a n/a proponentBrazil The originalComments shall be reimbursed Yes Law for theon Public Yes projects Bill No. Tenders and development 7.063-B, Administrative cost of 2017, by the winner ofwhich Contracts intends the(Law competitiveto am No. 14.13P n/a Pursuant toComments Bulgaria Yes Concession Article 56(5) of the Concession Law, where "- Law Yes Law SG No. Public 17 amended February 2021, Rules of Proced No.the grantor has used all or part of the development propo Art.65 The initiator of thePPP Decree: n/a may proposal The Burkina an incentive have contracting FasoY 032-2021 es or aninitiates authority advantagea procedure in No for Procurem accordance selecting n/awith thethe terms private andpartner in accordance conditions specified byw n/a comments Articles 44 to 46 of the Burundi PPP DecreeNo detail the developer's n/a fee mechanism. No n/a n/a n/a Comments Cambodia Yes Law on Public-Private Yes To Partnership ("PPP Law"), NS/RKM/1121/018, n/a n/a n/a Cameroon No n/a No support n/a n/a n/a Comments Canada No n/a -Decree No n/a n/a n/a Comments Chad Yes No. No n/a n/a Articles 8 and Comments Concessions 10 of theChile Yes Regulations Decree No. No establish 956/1997 n/afeeby issued a developer's the and bid bonus a Ministry Public Works (Conce ofrespectively. n/a n/a Comments China Yes 1. Yes The Draft n/a Article 2.2.2.1.5.10 Comments Colombia establishes the Yes Detailed reward for Decree unsolicited 438 No proposals Amendme n/a require public resources disbursement, a of 2021 that n/a the PPP Law Article45 ofn/a Congo, provides: Dem. The Rep. Yes Decree candidate, who n° 21/04 No has submitted of 2 octobre n/a an unsolicited 2021 on offer to whichOrganization the Creation, an the Contractin n/a n/a n/a No Congo, Rep. n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Costa Rica No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a Yes Côte d'Ivoire No No. 2019-679 The Ordinance n/a of July 24, 2019 on the Public Procurem n/a n/a Comments Croatia Yes Act (OG 69/2017) Concession Yes Public amended by (OG 107/2020), dated Oc n/a n/a No Comments Czech Republic n/a No Procurem n/a n/a n/a n/a Denmark Yes No No. 1080 Executive Order n/aof 29 June 2022, which specifies contract According According to to n/a Art.33.7 of Art.33.7 the PPP Law, of Djibouti the where PPP Law, Yes the where the The Contracting Contracting Authority Decree No No. Authority 2021-192/PR/MEFI intends ton/a respond intends favorably respond to approving to an theunsolicited Public-Private favorably unsolic Par to an proposa n/a Article 58 of Comments Decree 434-20, the PPP Dominican YesRegulations, (i) Law Republic No. 47-20 Yes provides: "AdvantageAfter on Public the implementation ofPrivate-Partnership the private originator. ofIn the ("PPPLaw No. Law"), case47-20 dated o F of init n/a Comments Article 24 of the PPP Regulations Ecuador (Executive Yes The Regulations Decree states 1190) Yes for inPublic-Private itsFurther second PPPPartnerships, regulations paragraph that "the are enacted expected. private Executiv bybidder w n/a n/a n/a Rep. Egypt, ArabYes Law no. 153Yes for the year Prime 2021Minister amending Law no Decree 67 of 2010 number for the 3217 regulati n/a ofEl Literal b of Article 51 0 Salvador the PPP LawNo n/a establishes Nothe proponent the right of n/a to be reimbursed for their expenses.Lit n/a n/a n/a Eritrea No n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Estonia Yes Guidelines Yes for conducting PPP projects effective 19 December 2019 Public n/a Comments Chapter Nine Ethiopia of the PPP No deals specifically Proclamation n/a No Unsolicited with Procurem n/a Proposals. It states: 43. Procedure for Un n/a n/a Comments Finland No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a France No n/a No n/a Article Art. 38 of the 40 of n/a the PPP PPP ordinance provides Ordinance. Gabon : the communication No of an innovative n/a No that would be followed by a procurement pr idea n/a n/a Pursuant toComments Georgia No n/a No n/a Article 15(6) of the PPP Law, if a participant of a selection process that is not a private initiator or a re n/a n/a Comments Germany No n/a No n/a n/a Section 55 (19) Comments Ghana of the PPP Act, 2020 Yes Public (Act 1039) deals withYes the Developers WorkFees is on going while Section on the 55(18) Public Private Partne states that wh n/a According toComments Greece Article 13(1) Yes (2) of Law Private Law 4903/2022, awardGazette n/a No (Government in3389/2005 procedures for the A 232/22.09.2005) of a concession on Partne or PPP contract, if, af n/a n/a Comments Guatemala No n/a Two No n/a n/a n/a n/a Guinea Yes implemen No n/a n/a n/a n/a Haiti No n/a No n/a n/a Comments The PPP Regulatory Decree Honduras indicates Yes In December in its Article 49 the Expense No through n/a as 2019, Refund, Presidential follows: In Decree case the award of the cont PCM-064-2019, the n/a n/a Comment Hungary Yes There have Yes Guidelines been changes Hungary to the Public Procurement Act. The chang n/a n/a n/a India Yes for No has n/a made According According to to the art. 14 (5)(c) the art. Comments of 14 the Indonesia (5) Regulation of the Regulation on PPPs, on Yes a business PPPs, aof Minister business entity No National that entity initiates n/athat a Development PPP Planning project initiates a PPPas Regulation project an alternative may be2given No. of 202 form o th n/a n/a n/a Iran, IslamicNo Rep. n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a Iraq No n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Ireland No n/a No n/a n/a n/a Comments Israel No n/a No n/a n/a n/a The Swiss challenge Italy falls within in Italy Yes the definition Law no. "diritto Yes di Law of120/2020, Guidelines no. 108/2021, prelazione", according no. 9Law have to been Article no. updated 233/2021, 183 (15) Law by the no. of A 2 the n/a Comments According to Jamaica the PPP Policy, No Section 9.0, "in the n/a No event that n/a the proposal meets the PPP criteria and Cabinet has ap n/a n/a n/a Japan No n/a 1/ The No n/a n/a Article 7 of the n/a PPP Regulation Yes that“A. Jordan provides Public- NoProposaln/a If the Direct is listed in the Registry, the Public Authority Article 103 Pursuant toPursuant toComments Order Article of No. 103 KazakhstanYes Order of725, consideration Amendments No. 725, consideration and selection Yes and to the PPP ofselection Amendme ofLaw competitive applicationsapplications competitive are carried are carried out out b by the Comm n/a No further relevant Comment Kenya was information Yes provided.A No new PPP legislation nts (ie, n/a on the Public Public Private Partnerships Act, Presidenti n/a According to n/a Article 7 (11) Korea, Rep.Yes of the al Decree PPP Decree, the No authority competent may grant preferential treatment to the ini n/a n/a n/a Comments Kosovo No n/a No n/a Article The allocation percentage of a 20 n/a of the PPP determined Law Kuwait and 57 ofNo by theHigher the PPP Executive Committee n/a Regulations of the shares No n/aof the provide, "The Public approval Stock Joint by Higher Committe theCompany not exce n/a n/a Comments Kyrgyz Republic Yes The new Yes Regulatio n/a Article 25 of the PPP Decree Comments Lao PDR provides: Law of the Yes “The Submission The Decree on No and n on the Public Private n/a Consideration of Partnership Unsolicited No. 624/GoL Proposals dated for 21 Dec Partnership n/a n/a Comments Latvia Yes Public-Private The Law on Yes Partnership, adopted in 2009 with subse Amendme n/a n/a n/a Lebanon Yes No Public Procurement Lawnts n/a Noto244 theadopted on July 19, 2021. Pursuant n/a n/a Comments Lithuania Yes Yes Law, was The Concessions last amended on May 30, 2019. Public n/a Pursuant ton/a article 12 of Madagascar No the procuring the PPP Law, n/a authority Procurem n/a for reimbursement to private initiator No must provide n/a provides in The PPP ActComments Malawi section 56: Yes "56.__(1) The Commission NoPartnership Public-Private may award n/a Act an No. extra 23 of 20 score to May, a Private 2022,Party which repea who init n/a n/a Comments Malaysia No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a Mali No n/a No n/a n/a section 3C (7) Pursuant ton/a Mauritius of the PPP NoAct, the contracting n/a No authority n/aspecify in the request for proposal referre shall n/a Comments Article 31: Section I establishes Mexico theNo developer's n/a No fee (the proponent n/a inform of the incurred cost and this wil should n/a n/a Comments Moldova No n/a No n/a Given a tender Comments n/a launched Mongolia on the basis No of an unsolicited n/a received proposal Yes attractsThe new other bidders, an original initiator will be giv Law, Y Montenegro In es IV, SectionDecember PPP law is n/a According to the Concessions Comments Part Law 5, No 46- No Article 2019, 41(3),a new "if thePublic-Private n/a Competent Partnership Authority Law (no. estimates that73 “P the n/a According to comments Article 9(6) Morocco of the PPP Yes 18 Law and 41 of the PPP Decree, the No unsolicited offeror may receive a lump-sum n/a n/a Comments Paragraph 5 Mozambique of article 13 of the PPP No n/a Law and paragraph of article 14 3 No of the PPP Regulation establish that the init n/a n/a Comments Pursuant Article Nepal 11.8(7) "Unsolicited Yes Proposals" of the Public PPP Private No Partnership Policy: PIAand (a) n/a shall Investment invite proposal after developing Regulations stru 2077 (2020) n/a n/a n/a Netherlands No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a No New Zealand n/a Yes The Article 15 of Article the PPP of 15Regulations the PPP Regulations Comments outlines Nicaragua states two No incentive n/a the proponent mechanisms: has No (1) a right a bidto environm the n/a reimbursement bonus: of Participate as a bidder costs associated with in the bidding t pr n/a n/a n/a Niger No n/a No n/a n/a Comments Paragraph 2.2 Nigeria of the ICRC Noprovides n/a Guidelines that: the Swiss Yes Challenge Public System will be Private applied such Partnership that the Regulatory origin Comm n/a n/a Comments Republic of North Yes Law Macedonia on No n/a A possibilityAccording for somehow to taking n/a the Pakistan the interests PPP Policy, SectionYesan ofL, "in some Public The initiating Public private cases, the No Private party n/a Partnership GOP into may require account Authority if a tenderAct competitive of 2017 is bidding launched was that amended will take into is provided for n/a n/a Comments Panama Yes Panama No n/a n/a n/a Comments Papua New No Guinea had n/a major No n/a n/a Comments Article 50 of the PPP Law Paraguay further developed Yes Decree by 4183/2020 the Decree Legislative 4183/20: No n/a proponent "Regulation The 5102/2013 of Lawof (PPP Law)." a private initiative shall hav n/a The PPP Regulations Comments (Supreme Peru Decree Decreeregulate Yes 240-2018-EF) Yes both the right Supreme A to Decree Revised No. 211-2022-EF a developer's 93) and fee (articlefrom Septth n/a Pursuant toComments Section 10.19 Philippines YesLaw IRR:March of the BOT in the event 2022Yes Revised of refusal,Septembe inability or failure Implementing of the Rules and winning comparati Regulations of R.A. No n/a n/a Comments Poland Yes Public Procurement No Law of n/a 11 September 2019 entered into force o n/a n/a Comments Portugal No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a Qatar Yes No Regulating Law no. 12/2020 n/a Public Private Partnerships n/a n/a Comments Romania No n/a Yes Law no. n/a n/a Comments Rwanda No n/a No 98 n/aof n/a Comments The PPP Handbook Samoa provides underNosection 2. Requirements n/a Private No n/a for an Unsolicited Proposal:Proposal is accepted: In ca n/a Article 140.2.b n/a of The Implementing Saudi Arabia Regulations Yes Sector No states that n/a of a public tender, the RFQ shall state th “[i]n the case n/a Article 105Senegal Pursuant ton/a Yes the holder of PPP Decree, Lawof the private n°2021-23 No of initiative Marchn/a 2021 must 2, offer take part in the on public-private tender proce partnership cont n/a Comments According to Serbia ChapterNo the PPP Law, n/a II, Section 6, No Article 19, n/a "a proposer, when submitting an unsolicited proposal, n/a 0 Sierra Section 1 of the PPP Act aNo Leone provides n/a definition of the Swiss No n/a is addressed under section 25(4)(e) of Challenge, which n/a n/a Comments Singapore No n/a No n/a n/a n/a Yes Comments Slovak Republic NoPublic Procurement Decree of the n/a Office № 493/2021 Coll. of 13 on According If, on the basis of an application to the PPPby Comments Slovenia anArticle Act, interested Yesperson, 35(3), Public "If, on a the Procurement public basis ofYes partner doesActAct an application notwith onthe by an interested initiate effective date person, a preliminary of April procedure1, 2016 a public ("Of reach a or partner n/a n/a n/a No Solomon Islands n/a No Amendme n/a Public n/a n/a n/a Somalia Yes Procurem No n/a n/a Comments According to South the Practice Note Africa on Unsolicited No n/a Proposals, No section (e), the process to be followed when procur 5.1.1n/a n/a Comments Article 247 of the LCSP Spain states that in No n/a case the proponent No not win the did n/a awarded concession (after a tendering pr n/a n/a n/a Sri Lanka No n/a 1/ the No n/a n/a n/a n/a Sudan Yes Public No n/a n/a n/a n/a Sweden No n/a No n/a n/a n/a n/a SwitzerlandNo n/a No n/a n/a Pursuant toComments Tajikistan No n/a No n/a the PPP project does not become the w Section 16 of Resolution No. 81, if the private partner initiating n/a Comments Under Part VII Tanzania - Procurement Procedures Yes For Unsolicited The Public Private Yes Partnership Proposal, Public64 Section Private Act, (3) Cap and Partnership (4) ofAct 103, theNo. PPP (Amendment) 18 Regulations of 2010 ado p Act n/a n/a Comments Thailand No The Public Private No n/a Partnership Regulations of 2020, G.N. No 37 of 20 n/a n/a Comment Timor-LesteYes 28/2019, the Decree-LawYes Organic Law Decree-Law N.º of 22the /2022, of 11of Ministry Finance, May s 2022,as n/a n/a n/a Togo Yes 1) Law No. No n/a n/a n/a Comments Tonga No 2021-034 n/a No n/a n/a n/a No Comments Trinidad and Tobago n/a Presidenti No n/a n/a Article 11 aln/a 6 of the PPP Tunisia law No. 49-2015 Yes al Decree provides No that the procuring authority initiates a competitive PPP procur n/a n/a n/a Comments Turkey Yes The Amendment The implements the changes made to the H Yes Regulation The tender According documents toComments prepared shall Section 34(7) indicate Unitedof the ArabYes PPPEmirates theAct, method "the to beDoF Dubai tender documents usedPPP No Omnibus compensate prepared n/aand to Guidelines shall forPPP thepolicy indicate propriety interests the method to propone the be used n/a Comments According to Article 14 Uganda of the Law on NoPPP, if the n/a the tender n/a winner ofNo is a person other than the initiator of the PPP n/a n/a n/a Ukraine Yes Law of Yes The Plan Draft n/a n/a Comments United Kingdom No Ukraine n/a Yes for the Concessio n/a n/a No Comments United States n/a No n/a n/a The PPP Law in its article Comments 37 establishes Uruguay Decree No. Yes the unsolicited proponent No 261/019 rights. (9 n/a September 2019) established The unsolicited shallprior proponentthat, enjoyto t th n/a According to Article 17 Uzbekistan Comments Yes <...> if The of the PPP Law, law the private Yes Several initiator does not become the winner of the tender, the n/a n/a n/a Vanuatu No “On n/a Public- No new n/a n/a of the PPP Law Article 27.6Comments on Procedures Vietnam Yes for preparation Law No. 64/2020/QH14 of investor-proposed Yes of (i) Circular the Government No. PPP09/2022/TT-BGTVT dated projects 18 June provides: “6. dated 2020 Costson 22 oJ n/a According toComments Zambia the PPP Act, Section 42(12)(b), Yes Act № 22 Yes an unsolicited "after evaluating The Public-Private proposal and any competing Partnership proposal Bill, as well as n/a n/a Comments Zimbabwe Yes of 23rd The Yes Investment Zimbabwe PPP and Guidelines Development are under review Agency by the (ZIDA) Gove Act, Ch n/a n/a Comments Myanmar No n/a No n/a days fromto If, within 45According the thedate PPPof Comments Law, Russian posting art. 10(9), Federation a No"in the decision on PPP event the n/a that, within No 45of implementation daysproject an/a on date from the of posting the official website of the on a decision the Russian 63-B, of 2017, which intends to amend the current law of PPPs to reduce the minimum value of public-private partnership contracts ente mplementation of Law No. 47-20 on Public-Private Partnership there have been no relevant reforms in the regulatory framework that may ster Decree number 3217 for the year 2022 amending the PPP Executive Regulations of Law no. 67 of 2010 issued by virtue of Prime Min Myanmar No n/a No n/a ate Partnership Regulatory Commission Bill, 2022, is underway. ecree No. 211-2022-EF from September 2022: Approves the Regulations of Legislative Decree No. 1543 w N.º 22 /2022, of 11 May 2022, setting forth the Legal Framework on Procurement, Public Contracts and respective Offences, only becom No. 09/2022/TT-BGTVT dated 22 June 2022 of the MOT providing guidance on bid evaluation methods and criteria for selection of investo e regulatory framework that may affect PPP2 projects in Dominican Republic. Nevertheless, there have been some initiatives that sought nd criteria for selection of investors implementing PPP projects and template of BOT contract in the transport sector;(ii) Circular No. 10/2 been some initiatives that sought to modify/complement some aspects of Law 47-20, but these have not been implemented up to this da nsport sector;(ii) Circular No. 10/2022/TT-BKHDT dated 15 June 2022 of the MPI guiding the provision and publishing of information and se t been implemented up to this date:1. Bill that introduces special measures applicable to infrastructure projects undertaken by public-priv d publishing of information and selection of investors on Vietnam National E-Procurement System;(iii) Circular No. 22/2022/TT-BGTVT dat projects undertaken by public-private partnerships and amends Law 47-20 on Private-Public Partnerships. (Proyecto de ley que introduce m rcular No. 22/2022/TT-BGTVT dated 31 August 2022 of the MOT providing guidelines on some contents of pre-feasibility study reports an s. (Proyecto de ley que introduce medidas especiales aplicables a proyectos de infraestructura pública y alianzas público-privadas y modific of pre-feasibility study reports and feasibility study reports of investment projects in the PPP form and BOT contracts in the transport sect alianzas público-privadas y modifica la Ley No.47-20 del 20 de febrero de 2020, de Alianzas Público-Privadas). This bill seeks to establish sp OT contracts in the transport sector; and(iv) Circular No. 50/2022/TT-BGTVT dated 30 December 2022 of the MOT on the performance of das). This bill seeks to establish special provisions for infrastructure projects executed in the Dominican Republic through PPP projects. It w f the MOT on the performance of the functions and tasks of State bodies having the authority to sign and implement the PPP contracts un Republic through PPP projects. It was approved in the Senate but is currently being reviewed by the Finance Commission of the Chamber nce Commission of the Chamber of Deputies.2. Draft Ruling for Non-for-Profit Publ